Discussion Locked

This is (one reason) why I'm opposed to the Koyoto Treaty

0 helpful
21 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

China is exempt. Why?

http://www.breitbart.com/news/2006/05/16/060516132400.eml4a2y7.html

India is exempt. Why?

http://www.ieta.org/ieta/www/pages/index.php?IdSitePage=955

And the selling of "credits" defeats the purpose. The aim is to either reduce emissions or not. It obviously is not, and it can not, and it will not -- regardless of how the USA replies. So what's the point?

How many of the people in the USA who cry about "American jobs" going to India and China, are the same people who cry about the USA's refusal to agree to the Koyoto Blackmail Scheme ..... I mean the Koyoto Treaty? Don't these people realize, since India and China are exempt from restrictive manufacturing processes, that manufactures will flock to those countries, and be accepted with open arms by those countries, thereby actually encouraging those jobs to leave American shores, and will actually ADD to the problem of air pollution? (Or "global warming", if you buy into that myth?)

Even the Democrats in Congress refused to buy into the scheme.

For the record. I'm in favor of reducing air pollution. In fact, I'm even in favor of working to eliminate air pollution entirely. But don't use the Koyoto scam or global warming scare to do it.

If these nations are exempt because they are "developing countries" (Yea, right!), and if developing new and clean alternative energy sources is so easy and is being prevented only because of will and desire, then what better way for a "developing nation" to become a significant nation than to do it with new alternative energy sources? If a nation, in theory, has to build an industrial society from the ground-up, why do it in a way that will only have to later be drastically changed or torn down? If it's going to be done the "first time", it might as well be done right. Right?

21 replies

by dr dij

even many 'eco-nuts' don't think China and India should be exempted from air pollution rules via Kyoto treaty.

They have been filling their streets with cars that spew out vast quantities of pollution due to missing emission controls, which after years, here in US, we've minimized the cost to add them to cars.

It probably costs them more in dead people & increased health costs (asthma, pneumonia, etc) who breath in noxious fumes from 2 cycle engines and un-regulated diesel, gas cars.

Credits may be useful if not overdone. Many eco-nuts don't like them but they do spotlight emissions control and keep it in corporate mind.

Some things such as the mercury and chlorine emissions (paper plants, etc) should not have credits. If they were kept at levels or reduced then the involved plants would make the investments necessary to reduce emissions.

Anyway, china is paying: sunlight has been reduced 10% in many areas, reducing crop output, besides scarring the lungs of many with sulfur forming sulphuric acids, and other acids from pollution. As in Greece, air pollution eats away at historical structures such as great wall, tombs, etc.

by Member 25348569

I'll have to explain the difference between pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. I think that Maxwell does it on purpose just to get more knuckle-marks on my screen.

Anyway, (again) all the catalytic converters and exhaust emission rules in the US don't really reduce your CO2 production. Efficient engines reduce your gas consumption, obviously, but otherwise, it's made the problem worse because you/we don't have any visible pollution to tell us how much oil we're burning. All that has happened in the last twenty years of engine efficiency improvement has been negated by the fact that people buy cars with exactly the same size (or bigger) engine than before and just use up the extra horsepower by smoking their tyres.

Back to the plot. The reason that India and China are exempt is that, when measured on CO2 emissions per capita - [b]which is what it's all about[/b] - they are way, way better than you.

The idea is to leave them some headroom to develop their economies and improve the living conditions of the billions of their citizens who currently live as they did a couple of ceturies ago. If we help and encourage them, we can help guide that economy to be non-polluting, sustainable and - dare I say it - friendly! God alone knows, wouldn't you like a friend or two?

Our per capita emissions are half of yours and I don't feel short-changed in my lifestyle.

Edited for a quick rant.

What the Chinese and Indians want to do is grow, transport, refrigerate and cook food safely so that no-one starves. What you want to do is warm your hot tubs and keep your Hummers going.

by sleepin'dawg

are you complaining about the hot tubs in our Hummers??? This does reqire some clarification on your part otherwise Maxwell might think you are a Sneaf!!!

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by Member 25348569

It doesn't have to make sense!!

Bloody hell!!! A man can't come onto this site and type a simple comment about the US raping the world for its resources and trampling rough-shod on the backs of the oppressed Third World billions to destroy the planet without having the damn comment dissected by the resident Libertarian Goon Squad!!!!

Just as well that I'm so even-tempered else I could easily lose it. :)

by maxwell edison

First of all, of course I know the difference between air pollution and "CO2 emissions". And of course I do it "on purpose". I also challenge the notion that "CO2 emissions" are causing "global warming", but you know that as well. But as Oz points out, POLLUTION KILLS THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE, and that fact alone is enough to encourage compliance, or so he says, so therefore what?

However, I'm glad you are FINALLY admitting that those nations are using Koyoto as a ploy to simply catch up with the USA. And that's precisely why I'm against it. It's a wolf in sheep's clothing. It's intended to produce results that are different than their claim. It's dishonest. It's bogus. It's a lie. I hate it when people get on their moral soapbox and spout-off about how BAD someone is for one thing, but they give others a free pass to do that very thing. It's either wrong, or it's not. It's either bad, or it's not. It's either harmful, or it's not. And the same answer should apply EQUALLY for everyone across the board.

(Beginning of rant)

And on your one-sided rant about the USA being the biggest producer of your dreaded CO2 emissions, put that in proper context and show what is produced as a result. The USA is also the biggest producer of world-wide food donations. Perhaps we should reduce the number of diesel burning farm vehicles that produces that food; and perhaps we should reduce the number of diesel burning locomotives that transport that food to the docks, and perhaps we should just quit producing that food. The United States is also the biggest producer in medical advancements, which results in world-wide benefits. The United States is also the biggest producer in aerospace technology, which results in world-wide benefits. The United States is also the biggest producer of .......... Put it ALL in context, Neil, or just STFU about it.

(End of rant)

See, I can do it too.

by rogjr

Kyoto and most "global" treaties have been conceived to redistribute money. Kyoto's plan is fine (sell credits) the utilities whenever the socialists need more money, which will result in higher rates on Americans. If the socialists start running out of cash to redistribute, they'll raise the fake standards to get more cash. It'll continue until we have blown world socialism in place. Follow the socialists and we will self destruct.

by da philster

Thank you all for some rather thought provoking comments.
Still, the idea of buying and selling pollution credits seems to defy the concept of lowering pollution......something like someone charging others for the right to pee in his pool.
b.t.w., a "hummer" is someone who forgot the words to the song.
Regards

by Member 25348569

I won't be posting much longer today as it's the Champions League final with Arsenal vs Barcelona - [b]proper[/b] football - and I have a date with several beers, a curry and a large plasma screen with a gang of Arsenal supporters.

Of course pollution should be reduced. But it's not so simple. You have to weigh it up against the extended lifespan of those elsewhere in developing countries who benefit from those factories. A simple example; if a refrigerator factory, for example, pollutes and shortens the life of a thousand but saves many more by preserving them from food poisoning is it a good or a bad thing?

However, as for food exports, I won't take the easy track and mention McDonalds, BK and others as they are franchises and merely the idea has been exported and the money returned to the US. I'll have to get some real figures and get back to you.

More later...

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]"Of course pollution should be reduced. But it's not so simple. You have to weigh it up against the extended lifespan of those elsewhere in developing countries who benefit from those factories. A simple example; if a refrigerator factory, for example, pollutes and shortens the life of a thousand but saves many more by preserving them from food poisoning is it a good or a bad thing?"[/i]

I used that very same argument when Oz made that comment. You used the refrigerator factory, however, while I used ambulances and hospitals as my example.

And to answer your question, on balance, I fall on the side of suggesting it's a good thing.

by maxwell edison

I was talking about the donation of wheat and grain, dairy products, beef and poultry, etc. Of course, you knew that.

How much of your dreaded CO2 is generated by harvesting and transporting the 1 million (plus) metric tons of wheat we provide (free of charge, by the way) to the world food bank each year? And how about.......

by brillgene

Mr. Edison (what a fitting last name)
Having heard the two rants, I'll keep this brief and simple for everyone else.

Doing so called "good" things like research, food donation, does not compensate for the wars, CO2 emissions.

All nations have a right to their citizens developing a good quality of life.

Since the per capita CO2 in the DEVELOPING, yes they are developing and probably scaring the pants off whiners like you, consumption is low they are being incentivized to use more eco friendly methods.

And just because they are exempt does not mean that we in the developed world hide away from the responsibility to redute our emissions.

It is still one planet.

Netizen/Earth Citizen

by deadly ernest

never about real envirnomental fixes. The trick is in the definition of a 'developed' as against 'developing' country. If you use an economic measure, you get a different answer to if you use a population density measure, or a technological measure. Most of the countries that support the Kyoto protocol are 'developed out' and have no room for any further technological expansion and limited for population expansion.

It is interesting that the countries that would be hardest hit, economically, by adhering to the KP are USA, Canada and Australia all of which have a total population denisty of less than 10% of that of Europe, where the most KP supporters are. These countries have a high per capita emission rate as they all have a bloody long way to go between town and cities etc. In Australia you can drive 500 kms between major cities, in Europe you've left the bloody country after driving through a dozen.

The most interesting aspect of KP is that it does NOT allow for the reward of planting more trees or retaining the existing trees. Why? Because Europe and Japan need to cut down trees to make housing space, USA, Aust and Canada have space to plant the suckers and can get around having to pay penalties and subsidise Europe by doing so.

by steve-nyeoka

The main reason for Kyoto was to allow near-socialist European countries to keep up with the US economically.

Funny thing though... after Kyoto American businessmen discovered the "slave labor" of China and pretty much all of the goals were inadvertently met anyway...

by richard kirk

and I drive to the recycling depot in my hummer (on the other side of town) after every meal, to dispose of a few cans while heavily polluting the area I live in. Doh!

by juleslt

As a sometime smoker, I'm well aware of the scare tactics used by the anti-smoking lobby - exageration of passive smoking stats, attributing death by cancer to cigarettes rather than other factors, etc.

I'm also well aware how much the tobacco companies tried to prevent evidence of the cancer risk of their products becoming public, and spent large sums of money on making it seem like there was a debate to be had - that the evidence was questionable, etc. I see the same tactics going on with global warming - a tiny minority of dissenting voices being used to suggest that the jury is still out and that this is some sort of 50/50 issue. You can still find people who are willing to go on TV and insist the Earth is flat, but only a moron would suggest this was something up for debate.

Like it or not, global warming is sound science. Sound enough to impress Margaret Thatcher - an Oxford chemistry graduate, and certainly NOT someone you would associate with the political Left.

Other than that - you're about right on the stupidity of exempting China and India.

by afleader

First off, China's "no car day" is kinda like the US' Great American Smokeout. It's voluntary. The article doesn't say how successful it was nor does it address the much larger polition caused by their heavy industries.
The article about India only states that they are making money by selling their emmissions credits to industries that generate more pollution than others, steel being only one example.
In the end, it doesn't matter. The whole idea of "international law" is bogus in the first place. Every nation is soverign meaning they can choose to comply or not to comply. In fact there was an Economist article about two months ago which reported that not one signatour to the Kyoto treaty had kept it's promise to reduce their greenhouse gas emmissions. All of these nations have cited economic reasons for not cutting their emissions...job exportation is likely the biggest fear behind this.
The fact of it is this: The West HAS cut their greenhouse gas emissions greatly since the 1950s. Some of it through cleaning up industries, but most of it though job losses in manufacturing. The biggest problems we face in the US are twofold: cars that need a tune-up and citzens blocking the replacement of older power plants with newer, more efficient ones. None of this makes any sense, but we have the economy, the government, and the enviornment that we asked for. Maybe if we took responsiblity and maybe were willing to give in on things like power plants and car maintenance we wouldn't need to fret over a silly treaty like Kyoto.

This discussion is closed to new replies.