Discussion Locked

"This may be just a game to them now, but a war will not be a game for them

0 helpful
45 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

"This may be just a game to them now, but a war will not be a game for them later. In war, they will only face miserable defeat and gruesome deaths" These are the words of the Korean Press as written in Stars and Stripes, America's military news, pep-rally paper.

Full story:

"According to Stars and Stripes Pacific's translation of a North Korean government newspaper article, UbiSoft's forthcoming Ghost Recon 2 videogame, which envisions a near-future North Korea/China conflict with US involvement, has already attracted the reclusive country's attention. In a curt review, a North Korean government-run newspaper called the game proof of U.S. warmongering. 'Through propaganda, entertainment and movies,' read a recent online commentary in the Tongil Newspaper. Americans 'have shown everyone their hatred for us. This may be just a game to them now, but a war will not be a game for them later. In war, they will only face miserable defeat and gruesome deaths.' Given the steep learning curve of previous incarnations of Ghost Recon, it's conceivable many may face miserable defeat and gruesome deaths anyhow."

So the US in turn felt it neccessary to add this little comment to Stars and Stripes, MANY GR players are military as well as several bases will use Ghost Recon to simulate war for strategic planning and troop movement practice. I platy it with a licent over his network LAN almost daily if I am at home and it is truly entertaining as well as beautifully modded and rescripted by fans.

Now in a long term view, is this perhaps America's way of inviting dislike toward North Korea from the US troops (published in Stars and Stripes?). Are they now possibly feulling conflict with NK by showing this as hatred toward America?

Well if you leave Iraq say by next winter (positive thinking), that COULD be year 2 for GWB's second term (heaven help us all), perhaps that would then give him 2 years to fuel the NK issue and create another war before his term is completed.

Judging this purely on the Iraq actuins, it really isn't a far fetched assumption at all, in fact it would be damnwell mirroring Iraq. Fuel the fear and act upon it.

This guys is just plain scary, at least Hitler was clear that he wanted to take over the world and we all knew where he stood, or where he now rests.

45 replies

by skipperusn

Who cares - about a war between China and Korea - unless they use Nukes.. then it would be an interesting test site.

I don't think the US would get involved - now the UN may - they are stupid enough to get into it again ... like in the 1950's -

I think the USA would just let them have at it - neither country is of strategic importance to the US ... It would be interesting a country that can muster a 100 million million men - and a little tiny country called Korea..

I think China would win that one in 1 month or less...

by jamesrl

Given the fact that China is a major trading partner of the US, I'm not sure that the US could or would sit it out. It would be challenging to try and intervene in such a way that makes a nuclear exchange less likely - and that is an imperative not only for the conflict itself but for the whole region. A nuclear exchange, even a small one, would have an impact on South Korea.

It will also raise tensions on the border between North and South Korea to an alarming level - take an already paranoid leader in North Korea, and make him even more paranoid.

As for over in a month? Well the terrain is more like Bosnia than Iraq - lots of hills and caves, not good tank country. China's troops have not been tested in some time - last time was Vietnam, and frankly they lost. North Korea spends an incredible amount on its armed forces. I'm not saying the outcome is in doubt, but it would take a long time to achieve ultimate victory. And you can't underestimate what a desparate North Korea would do when it looks like they are going to lose. Its a no win scenario.

James

by stress junkie

I know when I read the original post I wasn't sure what the setting was. I finally decided that the only thing that came close to making sense would be a Korean and Chinese alliance against the United States. I don't believe that the story was about China going to war with Korea. I may be wrong. The story was absolutely not clear on this point.

by oz_media

I was wondering, obviously by your alias you are either an active or inactive (retired) member/skipper of the US Navy.

Are you still active in the USN or are you just expecting someone else's kids to go to war if the need arises?

As for your high expectations of the war in one month, well I suppose you would have said the same about Iraq at one time too. A bunch of sand-n*****s who are ill equipped and untrained to fight like the Iranians were. Hmmm, I guess you are right, Iraq was only short engagement before it was declared that it was no longer in a state of war and wartime pay was removed, thus saving the government money while allowing the constant attacks on military personnelle to go ignored as SOME resistance.

However, your reply in itself diminishes the fact that your are being criticized by these governments for the exact same reason as you had posted. You sem to think it's a walk in the park, if need be you will be in and out and they will suffer, a very common opinion in the USA.

Others may have thoughts like, "Why would we go to war with North Korea?" or "I wouldn't WELCOME a war with a country that will inflict major casualties on our forces." or "Why would hate speech from a foreign country be aired in our military magazine?" That would certainly cause a rise to arms and a blanket dislike toward NK from American soldiers, thus stoking hatred for yet another country's people.

Watching recaps of US soldiers in Iraq over the weekend was haunting. Some were laughing at the devastation their arms had just caused to "suspected" insurgents. Others were BLATANTLY opposed and said they wished they had voted for a Democratic government and would never have voted Republican had they seen this coming.
They were hapily listening to the OzzFest CD (Manson, HateBreed, System of a Down etc.) via tank mounted radio systems that they can hear through their helmets and say it's like playing a video game with a cool soundtrack. One guy said the screams heard from direct hits were "gettnig me stoked" while another said it truly sickened him that his friends had died while fighting such a un-justified war to begin with.

So Skipper, will YOU be going to this simply little skirmish in North Korea (only 30 days shouldn't be a problem), or do you simply support those that will?

by admin

We really do need an outlet for those humans that want to go human hunting. Maybe we should legalize it by consent somewhere out in the desert like Las Vegas originally was and let all those people who enjoy this to pick teams and hunt each other to the end.

This would create a lot of associated jobs and solve a lot of social problems.

Personally, I get my stuff out by playing in a simulation much like Ghost Recon. I get the thrill of hunting the most intelligent game on Earth and no-one gets hurt. I like that. It's not a simulation leading to violence or war at all. In fact, I think there is LESS aggression amoung my clan-mates than the average Joe in real life. I don't get this- this "War Simulation" stuff. Is everybody 6 years old or less in developmental years and can't distinguish reality from fantasy? I don't think so.

by skipperusn

Lets see - Enlisted in 1970 - commissioned in 1975, (at that time by the posts you have put out - your dad was still wacking off and you were but a dream in his eye) - now retired after 30 years of service - :-)

Lets see - son and daughter are now commissioned officers - 1 USMC - 1 USN ... and serving in different parts of the world - Yes they both have children - and yes I worry about them - but they are willing to risk their lifes to keep freedom alive - :-)

Now Oz - your turn - And from your post I know this will never be answered by you. (Kind of how you can tell a red) How about you - have you or any of your family servered in the Royal Canadian armed services? Let me take a stab at it - NOPE - You let others fight and die for the freedoms you and your family enjoy - :-(

I know you are don't like guns or war - you think everything can be settled with talking and deplomacy - Wrong. Get into the real world mate - before someone comes around and takes what freedom you have away. Talking appeased Hilter - and it kept Saddam in check right...

So now - you're going to call me a war monger - a baby killer - or someother B.S. that you don't have a clue about - So keep posting your redic and everyone will come to know you for what and who you are... a fool.

Confuses say - let a fool speak and he proves himself the fool.

by tomsal

The fact is North Korea does have nukes. The fact is China *IS* very much important to the US, no matter if we Americans want to admit it or not -- its an economic FACT.

The fact is China has nukes.

The fact is China has the largest army on the planet, the fact is China is one country that could serious give the US a whopping -- ALL BY ITSELF.

North Korea is a comparatively smaller nation of course, however to write them off as if they are some hodge podge army is indicative of one who does little research into the military forces of the world.

North Korea is a formidable military force and should not be under-rated.

by tomsal

Just laughing at myself, don't mind me...

My original subject should of read "Too bad your scenario isn't on fact.."

One of these days I'll slow down my type speed for the purpose of more accurate spelling and improved grammar.....

hmmmm...

nah..screw it.

;)

by generalist

My biggest worry about North Korea is that we'll learn that they have nukes when they set one off near one of our bases in South Korea.

My next biggest worry is that they set one off in their own country in a way that could be blamed on the US.

The people in charge of that country are unpredictably nuts and shouldn't be trusted with anything more lethal than styrofoam rocks.

by oz_media

"On Oct. 16, 2002, the administration of U.S. President George W. Bush disclosed that North Korea had admitted to having a program to enrich uranium for use in nuclear weapons. With its admission, North Korea, also known as the Democratic People's Republic of Korea or DPRK, abrogated the Agreed Framework signed in 1994 with United States, under which the North Koreans agreed to freeze their nuclear weapons program.

On Dec. 10, 2002, North Korea announced it would restart plutonium production and eject the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) inspectors who monitored North Korea's compliance with the Agreed Framework. On Jan. 10, North Korea withdrew from the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT), an international accord prohibiting the acquisition and proliferation of nuclear weapons. "

"...The ability to deter a U.S. led invasion and blunt U.S. coercive power is the primary objective of North Korea's nuclear weapons program. North Korea also likely sees its nuclear weapons program as a means to get leverage to extract economic concessions in negotiations with the United States and even its nuclear-armed neighbors, Russia and China."

Sounds VEY similar to Saddams WMD issues with GWB.

http://www.cdi.org/nuclear/nk-fact-sheet.cfm

by jamesrl

They have nuclear weapons and the intermediate range missles to carry them, and they are working on long range delivery vehicles. Currently they could hit US bases in Japan.

The estimates in terms of numbers is small - perhaps fewer than a dozen. But one hit on crowded Tokyo could kill millions and send world stock markets into panic....

James

James

by stress junkie

First, North Korea is like a high school delinquent standing on a sidewalk charging people a 'toll' to pass. The United States is like Hulk Hogan who could kick the punk's ass but doesn't want to fight so he pays the 'toll'. The relationship between the United States and North Korea has been one of the United States shipping billions of dollars to North Korea on a regular basis to shut them up. This has been true for several presidential administrations. The North Koreans keep making a lot of noise in order to keep the money rolling in to their pitifully wretched country.

The question of Chinese support for North Korea in a military situation is not clear. Period. Nobody knows.

Comparing any American president to Hitler is just stew ped.

by oz_media

I am sure the Nazis would have said the same as most were in full support of saving Germany from these inferiors.

or as Maxwell would say, "if it walks like a duck...."

by jamesrl

BTW Skipper, there are no "Royal" Canadian forces since the forces unification in the 60s. The Mounties are still Royal, but not military.

I'm not from a purely military family, but members of my family died in WWI, and others fought in WWII. My wife's lost her grandfather in Korea. My uncle served in the RCAF(pre unification) and the Canadian armed forces, spending most of his time in Germany during the cold war. My father in law had a distinguished career. He commanded an Armoured Recon Battalion, worked at NATO headquarters(where he worked with Al Haig, and once briefed Donald Rumsfeld) and went onto to work with Vickers Marine(torpedo systems for 688s and other NATO boats) and a German armoured vehicle manufacturer.

My father in law, and many of his military historian friends, retired general friends, from Germany, Britain and other NATO countries all opposed the war for a number of reasons. They believed that there were no weapons of mass destruction. They believed it was a dangerous precident. Most of them supported the Afghanistan invasion, because the linkage was clear.

Your own general Zinni didn't support the invasion.

Its not so black and white as you would like to paint it.

I'm not defending some of the anti-American rhetoric or the baiting thats gone on here. But to equate support of the war for support of basic freedoms is a bti of a stretch.

James

by skipperusn

Oz tried pulling a Mike Moore trick - when and how long were you in - and any of your family in..

I answered his childish question in the respectfull way he posed his...

I was not trying to insult anyone in Canada that has not served - except for him. If I did offend you - you have my appologies and appologies to your family for some excellent service during those wars and conflicts... All are hero's..

by jamesrl

I wasn't insulted. I simply meant to point out that not all military support the war automatically. But those who serve don't denigrate service in others.

Personally I always wanted to be a fighter pilot. Sadly, I was born without all of my fingers on my left hand. My eyesight isn't perfect either. I did try to sign up for the militia - no one seemed to notice my hand, I wrote the tests, the unit commander was very impressed, until the physician did the physical. He said I might be able to join a non-combat unit in Toronto like communications, but in my town, the unit was an artillery unit, and there was no way to take me. I was dissapointed to say the least.

What kind of ship did you serve on? I've played many thousands of hours of Harpoon....I've visted quite a few ships - all the Canadian ships I could - the WWII Tribal destroyer that was in Toronto's harbour, the liberty ship and sub docked by Fisherman's warf in San Fran, the OHP and Canadian City Class which visited Toronto. I'm no naval expert, but an enthusiast none the less.

James

by oz_media

My post had nothign to do with baiting you like Michael Moore, for some reason you feel that I am defending him, which I am not, nor will I. I am not a staunch Bush supporter therefore I am automatically labelled as 'the other side' or Democratic or MM fan or Anti-America. I am not pro-democrat nor am I ppro-Michael Moore, I just believe in listening to alternate views behind something and arriving at my own conslusions based on what is presented.

That aside, my question was sincere. I know you are pro-war as you have been trained to be pro-war, if you weren't you wouldn't be much of a naval skipper would you?! This is an honest and upfront approach by the US forces that they admittedly have lightened up on the drill sergeant form of screaming men into submisison and taken to understading each man individually, the main goal is still to make the man fight without question.

THerefore one can surmise that if you have served in the military for any length of time (including basic) you have been trained to favour war and fight without question.

Therefore your comments are typical of a former naval member. NO offense intended, I am not trying to INSULT you as you admittedly have done in your post but am just making a simple and unquestioned point, you are trained to favour war andfight without question, your opiinion is extremely biased in that respect. This is further mittored in your proud alias that claims you are a former naval member and people ought to know who they are talking to, YOUR are USN material. This is neither good nor bad, just a fact.

by oz_media

as I was born in 69 (I ghave a much older brother and sister by 8 and 10 years respectively) long before you were comissioned.

Military history of MY family? My grandfather fought in WWII, My father was an engineer and aircraft mechanic in Singapore, my uncle flew fro RAF, my briother flew for RAF and I was in ATC before coming to Canada.

Since living in Canada, no I gaven't served on any peace keeping or humanitarian missions with Canadian forces, but I am not Canadian so that's out of the question anyway. The British won't train me in Canada either so poor old unhappy me doesn't get to kill people for a living. :-(

That plus I am now too phuqued up phsyically since a couple of near fatal accidents. IF I was 'needed' to go fight for England OR Canada, I would though, if the cause is justified properly and not just a whim provided by a questionable source with war and regime change as a motivator.

This wasn't SAVING your country from anyone, you were NOT threatened by Iraq or Saddam. There was NOT sufficient evidence that you were at risk of attack from WMD, however Great Britain was in a much more 'RISKY' position than yourselves, they were under FAR greater threat of attack than the US as Saddam neither had the technology or arms to launch an attack on the USA.
There is no need to have your sons and daughters placed in harms way for the reasons provided, which were, weak, doubted and uncomfirmed to begin with.

At least Tony Blair admitted to receiving false in formation and he had also said from teh ONSET that the British were needed to Liberate Iraq, he had received a petition from 3500 exiled Iraqi's living in England that Englands help was needed to help stop the repression in Iraq, this is what the British people were sold, this was why they supported the UK's war efforts.

This was clear and concise reasoning, not the fear tactics that GWB used to get Americans to support the war three weaks prematurely and wiothout the allies who wished to let the UN finish what was proven to be successfully inpecting for WMD.

by oz_media

Sorry I hadn't fully responded to your post.

You said:
"I know you are don't like guns or war - you think everything can be settled with talking and deplomacy - Wrong"

Correction: You THINK I don't like guns or war, correct, what sane person does? Anyone with even 1% of a brain doesn't LIKE guns or war, are you telling me that there are those that LIKE guns or war? I can believe it but I didn't realize someone (especially ex-military) would think that guns and war are FAVORED resolutions.

So I will give you the fact that I don't think you LIKE guns or war, and that it was merely a wording error in your post.

So do I think talking resolves issues, no, not always. NOR do I think this war wasn't neccessary, eventually. Based on the FEAR tactics used by GWb to escalate this into an immediate and neccessary action, I do not support the premature and unwarranted attack on Iraq. Wepaons inspectors were successfully doing their jobs, I don't know what crap you heard but it is a fact that they had uncovered SOME dual purpose goods that are used globally by all countries. They also found SOME unused warheads, from missiles that were unable to be used against America.

Perhaps YOU can explain exactly why you were in such a hurry to save yourselves that waiting for allied support (again about three weeks) was not an option? Nobody else has had an answer, being former Navy perhaps you can justify it.

As for myself and war, yes, in a situation where my country is directly attacked I would support Canada AND her allies in stopping it.

NO I don't believe everything can be settled by mere words, as you suggest, although you started the statement with 'I KNOW" which you really don't nor are you correct in your assumption.

You seem to be liumping me in with lefties or anti-war demonstrators, which I am not, yet I do not see the justification to drop everything, go against your allies and invade Iraq. Only to return to the table and ask your allies for help again, after ignoring them.

The allied nations of the world are not a specialzed force that is available at America's request. It is a global alliance to prevent these countries from being attacked and support them when they are, not Americas backup system.

Yes, Saddam needed to be removed from power, yes the people of Iraq are repressed, no more than in many other countries you have ignored though, yes it is a good idea to liberate Iraq and if they CHOOSE, instill a democracy in Iraq.

Not by some fly of the handle, knee-jerk reaction to false intelligence though, a properly planned and allied invasion would have cost you less lives, less money and would have gained favour instead of dislike for the world's new leader, er... I mean your president.

by skipperusn

There are millions of americans and millions in the world that love and enjoy guns. (lets not even go to Iraqi or Middle East and the guns they have) - America won its freedom by the right to own and bare arms - If you want to control a country remore that right from the people - and you will look like Russa did - before its colaspe - Hum little red of you - sir

You are a prime example of Confuses saying - Keep speaking and prove the fool you are ... Its great to see you kill your own points..Great quote you came up with - "Correction: You THINK I don't like guns or war, correct, what sane person does? Anyone with even 1% of a brain doesn't LIKE guns" - And I didn't say War you added that tidbit.

What a fool you are - small brain or lack of thinking. You also just insulted millions world wide with that one... True no one likes War - but war and guns are multuly exclusive -

I love guns - I love shooting - I love hunting - Which has nothing to do with war... Sounds like you Global Warming B.S. ... Redic - When you make sense and can keep on a subject - then maybe you'll be worth another response...

But you are doing a great job proving the Fool you are...

by dbertsche

Couldn't agree with you more. Now he'll have some long-winded bs answer like he always does. He is totally obsessed with "trashing" Bush, it gets a little old. I haven't responded to posts for a long time because it's pretty much a waste of time but agree with you.

by oz_media

All your posts shows is that you can support what favours your own opinion, you have neither offered a response nor an opinion in any way, just a little slamming.

Glad to hear you're sick of the forums and don't want to waste your/my time.

by dbertsche

That's pretty much what your posts do too, support your own opinion.

Concerning slamming, it's skipper who slammed you, I only agreed with him.

Glad to see your capable of a short response Ha-Ha, I didn't think you had it in you. Being concise is not one of your virtures but you managed it this time.

by oz_media

In most cases a simple point is made effortlessly and everyone can see your view. On TR, it seems that a simple point is so easily lost on those who will stretch it out to mean somethng entirely different. Therefore i can never be too careful in making sure my veiws are expressed as they are so easily mistaken for leftie American comments, while I do not support teh american left OR right, I just have a view or america and how it has changed over the last 15 years or so, and it isn't a pretty veiw at all. It is nice to know that not everyone thinks as you guys do though, a get the same sentiment when In England, other parts of Canada and even from peer mail from US TR peers who have been discouraged from offering opinions here due to the right wing slant.

by oz_media

I read your post three times and still wondered how your title fit, "I must have missed something...was it sarcasm?"

Sorry to say it, but that's MY kind of mistake.

Oh well, I guess I am not the only imperfect human here after all! :-)

by stress junkie

I hate to think of the number of times that I made a
spelling error and didn't catch it before I pressed the
'Submit' button. I hate it even more when I rethought
something that I was writing and edited the words that
I had already written but left in a word that no longer
makes sense in the sentence. At least we don't see a
lot of that kiddie junk like "ur gr8". That stuff really
bugs me.

by oz_media

I am probably the TR star at making spelling mistakes/typos. In actuality, I write a LOT of advertising copy but with that I take time and effort to ensure it is concisely worded and the grammar is correct. On TR, I rarely put any time into checking my posts, it somehow just doesn't matter as much as getting my thoughts out sometimes. They could REALLY use an edit feature here of all places.

As you mentioned, I often change a sentence or even the tense of the statement while forgetting to remove a previous comment and it ends up not making any sense. Oh well, I guess I am not ALWAYS right afterall, as suggested by some peers.

My typing is horrendous to say the least, I still use all the fingers but with no format to keep them in the correct rows and such. Much like I play piano and keyboards, except the tune sounds the same while teachers cringe at the fingering.

When I was in school, is was not acceptable for a guy to take typing and keyboarding, not when automotive and machining trades were being taught, thanks to that I have a stable trade to supplement me as needed, or if IT gets much more boring.

Oh well, at least I'm not the only one.

by skipperusn

Lets see I like killing people in Cyberspace - but to defend my home, wife and children - they can have them... I wouldn't fight to protect my family or neighbors...

Interesting - wasn't it an old jewish saying - They came and took my Neighbor and I said nothing, then they came and took my Parents and I still said nothing - then they came to take me - and there was no one left to say anything... Something about going to the Camps during WWII ..

Oh thats right - Hilter didn't murder 6 million people and the Japaneese didn't murder 4 million Chineese - or behead hundreds of Allied military in POW camps ... Thats right Burma was a figment of British propaganda... Bombing of London never happened -

Remember War has to be part of life... and it has some rules that can't be changed...

Rule 1) Good men and women die
Rule 2) Doctors and lawyers can't change Rule 1

When you have someone like Hilter and Hirohito they have to be taken down - what would of happened if they won? A would full of Peace if you were German or Japaneese or Italian - right..

by oz_media

We cannot equate this incasion to previous wars as it was not based on he same underlying principles of saving your own land.

Saddam has NEVER threatened America nor had the ability to do so, we can just drop the whole saving your families routine, it's old and proven otherwise.

This is Liberating Iraq, not WMD, not mass graves but helping Iraqis.

hON the other hand, I sincerely doubt the last post had anything to do with killing people on cyberspace and not defending one's country, I don't think any man woud idly sit by while his family or country was attacked, again, this is not what's happening with Iraq, Iraq did not attack America.

by skipperusn

No - no mass graves - no Kurds were gased - no he didn't tourcher and murder his own people - na no wds - Saddam didn't want to attack america - na all lies from GWB - in the Eyes of the Fool - Oz Media.

I guess you have been following the news in some of the liberal american papers - WMD found - and shipped out of the country... Alcada working with Saddam for attack on America - Check the NYT - WP..

Oh continue to speak oh great fool

by admin

"ON the other hand, I sincerely doubt the last post had anything to do with killing people on cyberspace and not defending one's country,..."

Actually, I had intended to point out that North Korea was being silly in equating a video game to somehow being a pre-cursor to a war with them. Just because everyone loved playing Grand Theft Auto didn't mean that they were out stealing cars and running over people for points. It's a healthy way for us to get our primal urges out and be social IMO. It's just non-sense IMO, and I thought it needed pointed out.

by admin

You pre-supposed my logic, friend. I hate the bi-partisan liberal vs. conservative way that people try and choose sides by innapropriately fleshing out arguments that abounds. I am not saying here at all that you are stupid, you seem quite good at thinking. Just don't take thinking to the point where you build your pre-fab box all around someone you don't know and expect them to sit there so that you can keep an innacurate view.

I am all for killing in real life when it is necessary. I do not balk at this and support our military. I would kill people in many situations, but I do not enjoy it. Personally, I am glad that the military trys to psychologically screen people that only want to kill, harm and maim for the sake of doing this. These people should hunt each other by mutual consent IMO and it should be on TV. I would not advise endangering the other normal people who join the military by surrounding them with bloodthirsty people who get off on killing, torturing and bringing pain to people just to do it. It's dangerous to the rest of the soldiers around them and gets too many people injured and killed.

On the other hand, getting injured and killed is often part of a tactical objective. It is important to be clear about this then:

1: Intent.
2: Objective.

Personally, I will defend my family and country to the death. This is no problem.

I will not hunt humans for sport. Even though hunting humans for sport is in some ways the ultimate game, I would prefer to do this in a situation where you can re-spawn and play again. It's sort of a painless human "Catch and Release" and I am glad we have this today. I would be tempted to cut people in half if I drew my sword and they were handy without this outlet. I would also miss not tracking them down before I killed them or was ultimately killed myself. I am glad I didn't live in a time where real life was the only way to access these primal urges.

No where did I say or imply: "but to defend my home, wife and children - they can have them... I wouldn't fight to protect my family or neighbors...".

This is your premise, not mine, my friend.

I would do all of these gladly, and I would do them for you and your family as a fellow citizen.
On the other hand, any time you want to go at it with paint balls let me know. I would gladly hunt you for fun. :)

by Member 33346398

That kills me.....by the way, in case you left your history textbook closed during high school, Hitler was a socialist....can you repeat after me?
National Socialist Workers Party = NAZI

Hitler's social and economic beliefs were more more in line with the the Democrat mentality of state run health care, state controlling businesses, etc....Volkswagen ring a bell?
Last I checked, Hitler didn't liberate any country from a dictator and then turn the goverment over to the people and assist with free elections.

Oz, you're chump change when it comes to history and fact. Your best weapon is dropping propaganda bombs and explaining with far fetched facts or assumptions. Go back to school, study your history and then make comparisions to today.

by oz_media

Well I just finished answering a post fro a pro-war supporter who has also equated this wwar to WWII and Hitler.

So I guess we are either ALL out to lunch, which you have no right to suggest anyway, why can't people defend a point without the derogatory comments to the poster himself (NOW THAT'S CHILDISH at best)so don't point the finger until you have at least heard the same from those you favour, you may be offending those who agree with you.

BOTTOM line on this WHOLE discussion though, this NEVER gets addressed and simply eldedby the Pro-Bush crowd. GWB used FEAR and misinformation to call your country to arms and create this MASS hatred toward Saddam. He then USD WMD to urge you into a war a few weeks prematurely and against your former allies wishes (well current allies, we don't just turn our backs and slander each other when the call to arms goes unanswered).

THis war was NOT properly justified, even though it is inevitably neccessary, I am not AGAINST the war at all, just the fact that nobody cares that GWB BS'd you all, never apologized for reporting misinformation and simply changed the focus, as ALL of you do anytime it is brought up.

All of a sudden it is MM supporter, Democrat, Anti-American, non-patriot or whatever, whereas I DON'T support MM or Democrats, I am not Anti-America allthough you can say I am anti-Bush like more than half the world.

You have all been so inundaated with Pro-Democrat's and Anti-Republicans you seem to foget, people in other countries don't give a damn what party runs America, just that when they are in office, they don't mislead the country (even that is OK, until they bring the rest of the world into it). NOw it is MY issue as much as yours, and I for one would not stand for our PM, acting that way, why wouldn't America do the same? Well from what I understand MUCH of America does, except it is hidden under a cloud of democratic propaganda and simply ignored by Reoubicans.

If that doesn't make any sense, I can send it to you in braille.

by Member 33346398

I read your blather and listened to your opinion. I didn't change any subject, I simply took issue with your comparision of Bush to Hitler which any sane person knows is ridiculous. I pointed out some fairly major facts about Hitler that don't come close to the Bush comparision you assert. It seems you avoided answering my chief issue by accusing me of not addressing yours. There you go again :)Since the Hitler comparision is obviously foolish and you don't want to own up to it, I'll play your game:

You seem fixated on the "Bush mislead" theory...is it not true that Saddam funded terrorist families, gave safe haven to terrorists like Abu Nidal for years, defied UN sanction after sanction and brutually murdered thousands through torture and WMD use? Since that is all true, isn't it good he is gone and Iraqi's now have the power of self rule?
What part of Saddam being gone is a bad thing for you? Oh, that's right, forget about all of what Saddam did over the years....Bush freakin lied, that's more important isn't it? Ironically Europeans let Hitler lie to them for years and it took America to help liberate y'all. Can't you taste the irony?

Many intelligence agencies failed in their estimation of his weapons stockpiles....Bush looked at the evidence presented and made a decision. Right or wrong, the decision has been made and I for one believe the world is a better place with Saddam in a prison as opposed to a palace. To leave Iraq now would be a mistake, the job must be finished and if only the rest of the world would get fully behind the effort, we could have a model middle east democracy with which to spread further peace and liberty to a radical region of oppressed peoples. Quite honestly if the UN wasn't so tied up in the Oil for food scandal maybe they could have taken a tougher stance with Saddam and gotten his unconditional surrender of power without firing a shot.

by skipperusn

Enlisted days were a couple of PBR's - then during the climb - mostly small stuff missile / distroyer / tendor classes - some shore duty - didn't want the big ones - get lost in the crew. And never went to Sub-school (great duty but I would go nuts not seeing the sun for 3 to 6 months at a time..)..

by oz_media

You make the most prfound statements yourself.

If you had been here a while back you would have seen the discussion on Global Warming which I was not in favour of. I believe that reducing our KNOWN harmful emissions, mainly CO on our streets and in our day to day lives that is PROVEN to kil people slowly, is a great step.

IF in 40 50 years or whenever, they find that Global Warming is a fact, then at least we have helped reduce the effects of our pollutions in the meantime.

By turning a blind eye on the concept, we ignore the issues that ARE killing people and starving our land of oxygen, CO inhalation leads to carboxyhemoglobin, FACT.

Othe than that, the rest of your post is just an inwarranted rant with o substance or proof behind it anyway.

by jamesrl

Mass Graves: These bodies are from the Iran-Iraq war, a war that America supported(not with arms but with dual use items such as trucks). They are Iranian POWs, and dissidents from the Shia area of southern Iraq(who are of the same sect as the Iranians). I'm in no way supporting this kind of thing - it was a huge war crime, but it was pre Gulf War I.

Kurds Gassed: again during the end days of the Iran Iraq war, the Iraqis gassed a village, killing between 5000 and 7000 people - yes a huge war crime. But after this happened did the US withdraw its support for Iraq - the answer is no.

Torture yes - but Saudi Arabia still uses torture, even on Canadian and British subjects(William Sampson case - google it). And the US didn't hesitate to send a Canadian suspected of terrorism to Syria, knowing he would be tortured. As for murder, the US well knew that the Shah of Iran was as despotic and killed people just like Saddam, and yet they supplied him with arms and money.

WMDs. There is no doubt that in the 80s, Saddam had chemical weapons - he used them on Iran. They were delivered through artillery shells, and some leftovers remain. We also know that Iraq had a nuclear program, but from many accounts that program shut down after Gulf War I. Saddam also worked on biologics such as anthrax(got his stock from a US supplier), but never used them. I haven't seen anything about the rumoured WMDs in Syria.

Al Qaeda working with Saddam. I think it important to note that while Saddam was in power, the only Al Qaeda cell was in the kurdish area which Saddam had no military control over. Al Qaeda has in the past many times called for the end of Saddam - they wanted him dead because he was not a religious muslim and could not and would not be swayed by clerics. Al Qaeda wanted Saddam dead or at least out of power. This is not to say that now in the power vacuum in Iraq, Al Qaeda has not moved in.

And I am no fool.....but its not as simple as you argue with Oz...though at the risk of angering both of you, its not as simple as Oz would have it either.

James

by oz_media

In fact GR is probably one of my favs. GTA was fun but got boring and easy.

Nope, haven't shot any eritrean soldiers nor hijacked any casr and run over hookers, but I had fun all the same.

Sometimes comments are taken so literally and out of context that it takes and hour to even figure out what the response was based on.

by oz_media

It was simplistic. I agree to offering a very simplistic answer but it was an 'in a nutshell' reply and very vague.

Your knowledge of the actual politics behind the graves and WMD is always welcomed and interesting to read.

My point is that WMD were sold as the reason for invasion. BRITISH troops uncovered mass graves AFTER the invasion was underway, not before.
Liberation ws something ALL the Allies supported, they were under great threat from saddam, unfortunately people were mislead into thinking it was all to save themselves from harm, not to save others from harm until it was sold that way. As you have mentioned, the US has ignored this repression for many years now ad even supported it to someextent. Why all of a sudden the change of heart? Why all of a sudden do they want to save America from someone who has not threatened the US with WMD?

thi is why my only dispute is that the US acted prematurely and without support that was waiting in the wings for the UN to do their job before declaring war with Iraq.

yet many Ameircans will still say they have SAVED themselves from something and this I cannot disagree with more as there was no immediate threat upon the USA from saddam.

That and the constant reference to 9/11 just tells me nobody knows who to blame or where to look next, which is scary when waging wars (who's next?) I would start at the top and work my way down, GWB stand up and be counted you have some questions to answer...truthfully.

by oz_media

For some reason, the fact that I don't buy a word Bush says, I am automatically said to be Pro-Saddam, which is ludicrous, how many times do I have to repeat myself here before the americans will actually understand that I do NOT dislike America, I do NOT think Saddam should be in power, I do NOT think that the war was unneccessary, I have NOT forgotten what an evil dictator has done to his people, and even mroeso I do NOT think yuo should leave Iraq. STOP LUMPING ME IN WITH THE WAR HATERS AND AMERICAN DEMOCRATIC LEFT WING, I AM NIETHER!

GWB also did NOT state any of this as a reason for the premature invasion of Iraq. My point ALL along is HOW can American's stand by and support someone who they ALL know has provided misinformation to the people and used it to justify sending their kids to a war prematurely and without support of America's allies? It make absolutely NO sense.

If OUR P.M. had done that, he would be sitting in skid row now wondering where he went wrong.

When the focus was changed from Saddam's imminent attack upon th eUS with his horrible WMD, nobody raied an eyebrow?! What you weren't under attack and nobody cares that you went to war because you were told you would be attacked?

how can nobody care about this? It truly boggles the mind that you would support someone who has already mislead (whether knowingly or not) Ameria which IMO has most likely resulted in a far greater number of US casualties than if you were attacked or at least more than if you had allied support, proper recon, more troops etc.

Your sins and daughters died bravely as heros but WHY? after the UK uncovered the mass graves, the Us defense for backing th ewar was immediately, LOOK AT THE MASS GRAVES!!! He has WMD and would have used them upon us if we hadn't gone in when we did, BULLSH*T!

When it was reported that these were graves from former war crimes, the focus was Operation Iraqi Liberation, the latest justification.

From what I read before the invasion, the other 'jerks' who used to be considered Allies wanted to wait until the UN had completed it's inspections, which is WAS successfully completing and had found nothing relevant other than some old unused warheads. After this time, they were prepared to discuss further actions against Iraq.

For SOME reason, probably due to this this 'curveball' guy and said Iraqi informant, the US Givernment was given th impression Saddam was stockpiling WMD for use against the USA, even though the UN had confirmed that Saddam was living up to his promises o destroying KNOWN WMD.

GWB had a knee-jerk reaction and called the country to arms despite allied requests, he then convinced americans of the same and the invasion began.

Several tanks were hit on recon duties that they were not equipped for and would have been much more effective if conducted by Canadian high speed Coyotes (as usual)and US soldiers dies as a result. Who knows HOW many similar incidents have occured since then that MAY have been avoided if numbers were greater and arms were more diverse?

Based on this, I support removing Saddam, I support soldiers, I support America and I support the people of america, I DO NOT support GWB.

This then makes me a liar, anti-American, Anti-Bush, an american HATER, Pro-Saddam, unprtriotic for allowing my family to die, Democratic, Socialist, Communist and god only knows what else.

is it THAT hard to see why I say American's are too quick to the punch? I've been labelled INSTANTLY so many times and eachtime with a diferent label to echo my feelings, which are also said to be everything but what they really are.

No wonder I think Americans see what they CHOOSE to see and not what's actually in front of them. :-)

by garion11

Ok here is my view on this and why I feel it was justified, whether he had WMD or not.

Ok first of all, this wasn't some war that Bush dreamed up one night and decided the next day to go and invade Iraq. Saddam did defy 12 UN resolutions leading up to the war. He did fire on British planes and American planes throughout the 90s. He kicked UN inspectors out during 1998 I believe.

Then 9/11 happened. After that, the administration came to the conclusion, that America will take a much more pro-active approach when its safety and interests are concerned. Saddam with his virtually unlimited resources, it would be best for American safety and security, to be taken out of power. Did he have WMD?? I think he did and they are somewhere in Syria. Was he pursing nuclear and other chemical agents?...I believe he was. Was Bush wrong in saying he was pursuing or had WMD weapons?? No, because, based on the intelligence reports he received (which is more than what you and I receive) he made the best decision he could in PROTECTING American interests and to prevent any possible future attacks on America.

Oz you seem to be missing a very fundamental attitude of what happened to the American government and her people after 9/11. I am not critcizing you on that, but you have to understand that at this point (I can't speak for the Democrats, god only knows where they stand), the Republicans and conservatives have reached a conclusion that America can't REACT anymore to what our enemies are doing, we have to be PRO-ACTIVE (meaning we have to take the first step), in eliminating any perceived threats to this country and her intersts. I for one agree to that philosophy. Not being pro active cost America 3000 lives, and we can't take that chance anymore. When our Allies refused to join and follow us, thats when certain perceptions here changed about France and Germany. Will we go after other threats to us (North Korea, Iran etc)? possibly. Again diplomatic channels, UN, etc will be tried and in fact they already have been.

So I really hope you understand why America was pro-active in removing the Saddam threat. Even though he never fired at us, even though he didn't have weapons that he could use to launch to our cities (according to you), what HE DID have were resources (aka $$$), he COULD and WOULD have used the first chance he had to attack America. After 9/11 the Bush administration isn't going to take that chance. EXACTLY like what a President of a country is supposed to do, protect his/her citizens first (just like the Filopino and Spainish governments did).

Its not misinformation and he didn't mislead the American people (where you get this I don't know), he had whatever information he was given by CIA, MI6 intel. He didn't make up intelligence to justify anything, what he did do was use the intelligence that was given to him to come to the conclusion that Saddam needs to be taken out (again an exile was offered). Should he NOT have used it to make the best decision possible?? Again after 9/11 he wasn't going to take that chance to REACT. I hope you understand.

by oz_media

The informant, code named cureveball was known to be inaccurate and was interested in having the USA topple Saddam, that was HIS motive (or on eof them). Even when this information was aquired and presented to the President, it was done so with caution that the source was not too reliable. GWB acted upon what is a questionable source, fair enough he is protecting Americas interests. So when the inspectors were proven to be successfully inspecting and turning up nothing other than unused and antiquated warheads, GWB went to the WORLD ALLIES AGAINST TERRORISM and asked for them to support the US invasion of Iraq due to suspected WMD and the fact that the UN was taking too long.

From what I ynderstand, the general consencus was to wait for inspections to be completed as others felt they WERE being successfully handled now. UN inspectors were said to need about three or four weeks to complete inspecting suspected sites. After the UN had completed it's inspections, it would be safe to decide whether to declare WAR on the basis of WMD or an invasion based on Liberating Iraq's people, as requested of Tony Bliar by 3500 exiled Iraqi's living in England.

GWB returned to america and decided to invade anyway. His justification; WMD that saddam HAS, and is planning on using against the USA.

Well this was misinformation provided to GWB, BUT it ws also suspected misinformation at the time it was shown. This was ignored becuase who is going to support a war for SUSPECTED WMD, when their sons and daughter may die saving their cuontry from an uneccessary threat.

THIS is exactly why I as a Canadian would scream bloody blue murder at the P.M. and hold him accountable for every single death created due to a premature and improperly justified invasion.

How many times, Garion, have you or others said here that you are saving yourselves from attack from WMD? The general feeling is STILL there, nothing found, information doubted to begin with, yet you still justify GWB's invasion with every last thing you can think of. WMD, mass graves, Kurds, Liberation, schools it goes on and on, but THAT's not why you all supported the invasion to begin with.

You were mislead by the ONE voice that speaks volumes to America and NOBODY holds him acocuntable for his actions. If being president of the US is as easy as this, I will gladly send you all down the wrong path as i would have nothig to answer for, you would still support my every move.

Why?

by Member 33346398

OZ, your all over the map with this. I humored your Bush conspiracy fantasies briefly, but now it is done. You're convinced I labeled you somehow as a liar a socialist or whatever....actually I didn't label you once. I think it's quite interesting how you assumed something once again that isn't true. Don't take this so personal OZ or assume people like myself care about labeling you. I don't need a label for you.

I'm glad you support America, we'll be there if your country ever needs us to defend it.

Since you state your a supporter of American troops and removing Saddam, I would encourage you to send a care package to a soldier overseas at:
http://www.anysoldier.us
It would be a show of honor and credibility to fellow posters I think if you sent a package to those you support that are over there doing a job you think is right (removing Saddam). Or don't, it's up to you. YOU live in a relatively free country to choose. Remember though, actions always speak louder than words.

My post started with calling you out for comparing Bush to Hitler and why that is a nonsensical and offensive statement. Offensive to Bush supporters because what does that make us, his SS? What's ironic is that there are still Jews out there who know the horror of Hitler and have lived very near the threats of Saddam to the point of firing missles at them during the first gulf war. They understand the similarities. They can't understand why someone would claim the same of Bush.
I questioned your knowledge of history and fact in making that claim. It's not a statement that can be justified and you know you should retract it. If not, it's impossible to have a discussion with you.

Thanks for shining a light on how Bush haters make their case...I've enjoyed the dialogue and sent it to many friends as a reference for voting decisions this year.

by oz_media

That's a good suggestion, perhaps I will send aomething to the british soldiers who defended England against a much more likely attack though ( I am British afterall, not American or Canadian).

But I will not do anything for the purpose of gaining credibility from yourself or others, I am credible and have credibility given to me from the many who peer mail me in support of my defense here. Those hat are on the right or don't agree with me, have no reason to give me any credibility, if so you would all be followers.

This discussion is closed to new replies.