Discussion Locked

To what extent does religion influence foreign policy?

0 helpful
34 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I found this interesting item in a Christian e-newsletter.

[b]A former secretary of state argues that we dare not ignore religion's role in foreign policy.[/b]

?THE MIGHTY AND THE ALMIGHTY
Reflections on America, God, and World Affairs?
By Madeleine Albright
HarperCollins. 339 pp. $25.95

[Reviewed by Noah Feldman]

In his introduction to Madeleine Albright's surprising new book on religion and foreign policy, Bill Clinton writes that his former secretary of state chose her subject "against the advice of friends." Those friends are left unnamed, but they surely include colleagues who helped Albright craft U.S. foreign policy in the Clinton years -- and maybe even President Clinton himself. The cause of their trepidation must have related to the most important -- and bravest -- point that Albright makes here: that on her watch, U.S. foreign policy made every effort to ignore religion.

To a new generation of foreign policy thinkers who must now deal with jihadist terrorism, it seems absurd that America's leaders self-consciously pretended that religion was not an important world force. But according to Albright -- and it is hard to see why she would overstate the case -- the Clinton team insisted privately, not just publicly, that the Balkan crises, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and, yes, al-Qaeda's August 1998 bombing of two U.S. embassies in East Africa were "not about religion."

Given that the participants in all these events said that their conflicts were precisely about religion, it is worth wondering how our best and brightest could have remained so obstinately in denial. The cause, according to Albright, was the legacy of foreign policy "realism" -- the view that nations' actions could be predicted by assuming that they would rationally pursue their own interests. This theory, which is "almost exclusively secular," taught diplomats to ignore religious rhetoric and zeal and to look instead for familiar, interest-based motives. Albright, with the help of her longtime speechwriter Bill Woodward, argues that the realist approach must be amended by inserting an awareness of the increasingly significant role that religion plays in the making of individual and national decisions, not just abroad but here in the United States as well. The result is a book that makes an important contribution to the question of how our foreign policy should adjust to the rise of religion worldwide.

Albright's reckoning with her own policy legacy amounts to a particularly candid first draft of history. She's right that foreign policy realism did, in a certain sense, downplay the religious interests of nations, but she does not acknowledge the main reason that realism let her down in confronting the principal diplomatic crises of the 1990s. Put simply, realism is a theory about the behavior of states . Yet the most important foreign policy challenges of the Clinton years came not from states but from nonstate actors such as Osama bin Laden's terrorist network and the militias in failed or failing states such as Somalia. Even Yasser Arafat, whose intransigence at the summer 2000 Israeli-Palestinian summit at Camp David cost Albright and Clinton a permanent place in diplomatic history, was not the head of a proper state.

This matters a lot. Leaders without states have very different incentives than do presidents and kings. Although dictators and democrats do not always behave the same way, any government -- admirable or nasty -- needs to deliver basic security and services in order to maintain its authority. That is why the behavior of presidents (for life or otherwise) can often be predicted by asking what actions would best serve the interests of the state in question.

The same is not true of guerrillas, freedom fighters or terrorists, who may be chasing dreams of world-transformation. Without a body of citizens for whose well-being they are in some way responsible, nonstate leaders are free to act according to ideals that may well clash with practical reality -- and some of those ideals will be religious ones. Albright is therefore right to call for enhancing religious expertise in the State Department, but we also need to pay much more attention to the ways that U.S. foreign policy engages not just governments but groups and movements made up of ordinary people who are moved by the full range of human beliefs and emotions.

Of course, religion's role in foreign policy does not stop at the water's edge. In our own democracy, citizens' religious commitments often play a major role in shaping their preferences about how the United States should engage the world. It would be hard to explain, for example, America's close relationship to Israel without at least some reference to the strong connection to the Holy Land felt by many Christians and Jews.

When it comes to the effect of religion on U.S. policies, Albright takes a somewhat complicated stand. She is eager to make common cause with evangelicals who care deeply about humanitarian issues in order to create an international genocide-prevention force under U.N. auspices. (How many evangelicals would agree to this plan is left unexamined.) She studiously avoids criticizing the Bush administration's foreign policy as religiously inspired, though she quotes others who accuse the White House of being "theologically presumptuous" and "dangerously messianic." And she accepts that "religion must be taken into account" by leaders who, like the rest of us, are inevitably influenced by their faith when they choose a course of action.

At the same time, Albright espouses a skeptical theology according to which we should tolerate other people's religious views because they might turn out to be right, after all. As a proof text for this approach, she quotes Clinton himself: "It is OK to say you believe your religion is true, even truer than other faiths, but not that you are in possession in this life of a hundred percent of the truth." This cautious doctrine is appealing -- even characteristically American. But it is by no means shared by all people of faith, many of whom believe the Bible or the Koran contains the whole truth. In a democracy, the votes of the true believers weigh just as heavily as the votes of the skeptics. To welcome religion into the making of our foreign policy is to acknowledge that certainties, not just well-meant aspirations, are going to play their part.

The painful truth about democracy is that the policies we make will generally be the product of compromise, not reasoned judgment. Realism sought to solve this problem by teaching diplomats to ignore ideals and focus on long-term interests. Today, our moral compass tells us that realism without values is not enough. But once we open the door to values, we cannot be sure that our policies will be coherent enough to succeed. ?

[I]Noah Feldman, a professor of law at New York University and a fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, is the author of "Divided by God: America's Church-State Problem -- and What We Should Do About It" and "What We Owe Iraq: War and the Ethics of Nation Building."[/I]

34 replies

by rknrlkid

When I read this, I have to consider the source (no jardinier, but Albright).

In a nutshell, Albright's worldview ignores the influence of religion in the world of global politics (which will affect us, because other countries do not have the same viewpoint).

The idea that religion must be removed from the world of politics or everyday life is absurd. If a person's religion is true, then it is inseparable from their self. It is who they are.

When I was in the Army, I was once challenged by a superior about the effect that my religious beliefs would have on my duty performance. He wasn't too pleased when I informed him that yes, it did influence my duty performance, because my beliefs made me conscientious and ethical (two traits that were sadly lacking in my unit).

The comments in a book like this, of course, are aimed at evangelical and fundamentalist Christians, and at Christianity in general. Christianity is a convenient "straw man" for those who do not want to face actual reality. Unfortunately, Albright and those who think like her miss an important point. To paraphrase Ann Coulter, it wasn't Christians who flew planes into buildings, and its not Christians who keep blowing up car bombs in shopping centers.

The only real religion in the US is "selfishness." Albright's use of Bill Clinton as an example of what a religious believer should be is an example of this. Do what is expedient and convenient, and its ok to lie when it is personally beneficial. Its the same old story of the ends justifies the means. Which is an athiestic/communist idea, not a religious one (unless you consider those to be religions, which some do).

I'm still waiting for someone of her generation to come up with some original thinking, rather than a rehash of leftist student revolutionary ideas. They were wrong then, and they are still wrong now.

by john.a.wills

RknRlKid seems to think that only Rabbinical Jews and Muslims practise terrorism, but some Palestinian terrorists are Christian (George Habash, for example). Furthermore, a large proportion of Israelis, the terrorist citizenry, do not practise their religion. Going further afield, India has experienced a lot of terrorism, some of it Hindu against Hindu, so one might guess that that terrorism does not derive from religion.

by rknrlkid

What I was saying was that the fanatical religous groups we really have to worry about are not the ones in mainstream US Christianity. I agree with you 100% that there is terrorism in the name of misplaced religious ideas everywhere. But that isn't the premise of the book review. Its always seems that in books like this its those nasty Christians like George Bush who are the problem, NOT everyone else's religious fanatics.

Terrorism is terrorism, period. In my experience and research, the "relgion wars" are usually political wars that are given a religious smokescreen. And like you, I have concluded that those who wage war in the name of religion are not orthodox practioners of their own religion, but have twisted it in order to further a personal or political end.

by jellimonsta

Neil, (I am not sure why I am even posting this as you are bound to know more about it than myself), but here goes.
The term 'The end justifies the means' was credited to Nicolo Machiavelli in his book 'The Prince'.
As you no doubt know Machiavelli was considered a 'humanist'. Although he supposedly never actually coined the term (I am not sure who did).
Maybe it should have been stated that the phrase is a capitalist/ humanistic viewpoint? But it is obviosly not a Religious viewpoint as the 'Golden Rule' principles (that are evident in most Religious) would be opposed. IMHO. :D

by rknrlkid

Quote from Leon Trosky, Russian Communist leader and theorist, in "Dialectic Interdependence of Means and Ends:"

?A means can be justified only by its end. But the end in turn needs to be justified. From the Marxian point of view, which expresses the historic interests of the proletariat, the end is justified if it leads to increasing the power of man over nature and to the abolition of the power of man over man.?

This is the thinking that allows for lying, breaking the law, murder or whatever, as long as its in the best interest of the state (which is really those in power). This principle was used by Lenin, Stalin, Mao, Kim, and scores of other communistic leaders. Its justified genocide and alot of other atrocities.

For more information about Albright having 60s radical ideas, I recommend the book "DESTRUCTIVE GENERATION: Second Thoughts About the '60s" by Peter Collier and David Horowitz. In this book it is clearly shown that many of the ideas of modern American liberalism are actually leftovers from 1960s radicialism, but few people are aware of that.

by x-marcap

That was, the selfishness of Bill Clinton wasn't that of the Christian faith. Nor, is it the pattern of most believers. I expect that I will be lambasted by Julian about the fundamentalists that he perceives as a problem.

Actually, that isn't too surprising. Eventually a pragmatist will realize they were wrong. After a great deal of soul searching she probably was unable to come to any other conclusion.

I realize this will be hard for many to understand,or believe, but I applaud Albright finally seeing the light. It may be late, but if she ever is in position to influence another administration, she is now better equipped.

by jardinier

No tjsanko. I think I have expressed my views sufficiently to not need reiterating.

Yesterday I had a long and friendly chat with a woman (60 year-old widow) who lives in my building and attends one of Sydney's largest Charismatic churches.

I respect the woman's views, and some personal experiences she described -- especially in regard to living for 5 years in a strong Muslim area of Sydney. I did not challenge her views, but merely asked questions and temperately stated a few of my own views and observations.

She is a fine woman, but I will know not to broach the subjects of religion and politics with her again because I do not wish to offend her in any way.

Her church is sponsoring a visit by Benny Hinn in the near future.

by stephanisat

For years, I have been saying that American foreign policy has taken the role of religion in the world too lightly. Madeline Albright finally listened! If you look back through the past few millenia, the two causes of major change in the world have been economic and religious policy, with just a few exceptions. It's not just terrorists who are influenced by religion. Whether the agnostics out there like it or not, the U.S. is a mostly Christian state. (Only 8-10% of Americans claim to be agnostic). Foreign and domestic policy, as well as social mores in almost every country are now and will be influenced by religion. BTW -if you do not believe in any type of supreme being, you are an agnostic not an atheist.

by tonythetiger

I think terrorists simply cannot deal with a world that does not match their (possibly but not necessarily religious) views. I suspect that religion is just the excuse they use to try to validate and justify their actions, as well as for recruitment.

by john.a.wills

Some people cannot get what they want by peaceful means, notably democracy, either because they are not in a democracy or because they are liable to lose elections. The IRA and ETA turned to terrorism because the majorities of the relevant electorates were against them. The Zionists use terrorism because within the rule of law they cannot dispossess the Palestinians. The PLO turned to terrorism because there seemed to be no other way of making the Israelis let the exiles home and restore their property to them. The justice of a cause and the morality of terrorism are connected but distinct: if the cause is unjust the terrorism is immoral; if the cause is just terrorism may be moral, depending on circumstances.

by jardinier

I ask this because her name is mentioned at these three websites which I have stumbled across (well actually they arrived as spam, or because they are affiliated with some other website to which I belong).

http://www.conservativebookclub.com

http://www.conservativebookservice.com/

http://www.conservativedvds.com/

Every title offered at these websites is extreme to an extreme degree.

I would offer a description of "mega, ultra, far right-wing, fundamentalist" etc. etc.

Whatever your personal political and/or religious stand might be, I think you would have to agree that there is a totally one-side view presented on each of the topics covered.

by rknrlkid

Yeah, Ann Coulter is a far right ding-dong (as opposed to a far left ding-dong ::laffs::). She's a smart cookie tho, and gets a few things right. Unfortunately, she is obnoxious and too sarcastic for most people's tastes. (Which is why I've read her stuff, I think its funny.)

And you are absolutely right...there is always a one-sided view presented. That irks me to no end. A long time ago I discovered that very few things in life are either/or. Because of the over-simplistic polarizations we keep getting fed by the media, politicians and others, its almost impossible to get real solutions to world problems anymore.

by Member 25348569

I merely wanted to see if he could back up his statement.

I usually go off on one, though, when I - as an atheist - get lumped in with some radical political ideology such as in the sentence that I quoted. It's not always justified! Communism - as paractised in the USSR and China was surely a religion in every sense of the word. Especially in their belief that they were right and therefore justified in suppressing any opposing religions.

We atheists, on the other hand, just have no belief in any god or gods. After that, our political beliefs are as varied as any other mans.

As for the phrase in question not being a Christian trait. "The ends justifies the means" was superbly exemplified by the Iraq War - which was certainly perpetrated by a Christian state.

by rknrlkid

My statement was not meant to denegrate anyone one in particular who claims to be an atheist. It was meant to illustrate that communism, which is an atheistic philosophy, is opposed to Christianity, which is deistic. It was not meant to be personal.

But yes, you are right, and I fully agree, that the idea of the end justifying the means is used by almost every political group to further themselves. I do have a problem with that. But I disagree that America is a Christian state. From my perspective, its far from it.

by Member 25348569

you explained yourself perfectly.

I also have a problem with "ends justifying means" when dealing with societies as it's never that simple and they never know when to stop.

From my perspective, certainly, the US is nominally Christian at the very least! So, what is it from yours?

by jardinier

Well that's debatable because Americans in general take their religion more seriously than in some other western countries, notably my own country of Australia.

However the initiator and instigator of the war in Iraq, George Bush, claims to be a born-again Christian, so I think you would have to say that there was a strong Christian component in the war.

by Member 25348569

though I admit I didn't make it in the slightest clear. :)

Simply put, my objection is to the inclusion of aetheists - of which I am one - in with radical political groups. I agree with you that these are religions in every way. I would suggest that their "atheism" is merely the replacement of a belief in God with a belief in their own god, a warped interpretation of Marxism, and not true atheism - a lack of belief in any gods.

See my reply to Jelli up a post or two though I've covered it here.

by john.a.wills

Rajiv Gandhi was murdered by a Tamil terrorist, presumably a Hindu. And there have been other killings in varous parts of India which seem to have nothing to do with religion.

by onbliss

LTTE which carried out the assasination is headed by V.Prabhakaran, who leans towards communism. LTTE has not known to project its cause based on religion, but based on ethinicity though the Sinhalese against whom it is fighting are Buddhists. There are many Christian Tamils in LTTE, and LTTE has been reciveing support from many Churches in America.

Few links:
http://www.christianaggression.org/item_display.php?id=1141381467&type=articles

http://www.epdpnews.com/news-Parthasarathy.html

http://www.larouchepub.com/other/1995/2241_south_india_groups.html

by john.a.wills

I was giving an example of terrorism where both perpetrator and victim are Hindu. The motive may have nothing to do with religion, or perhaps be peripheral in some way. The Naxalites might be a better example, but perhaps you would think them communist - or whatever it is they really are - rather than Hindu. Again, you might claim that many Naxalites belong to non-Hindu polytheisms.

by onbliss

..there are terrorists in both camps - theists and atheist. And terrorists come from all religions.
If the motive has nothing to do with religion, then you can not use it as being "Hindu on Hindu". That is my point.
The naxalites might be Hindus. But they are terrorising people not in the name of any religion.

But now I get your idea, though.

by jalefevre

If they had embraced civil disobedience over murder. The end never justifies the means (though those with power can often avoid accountability), but the means always define the end result.

by john.a.wills

except for 70 years of Zionist terrorism. But the Zionists cannot get what they want justly. And the Palestinians have tried peaceful methods without avail.

by jalefevre

It has been suggested that the difference between a terrorist and a freedom fighter is press coverage.

What I am trying to suggest that if someone is killed (as a part of the ?means?) the ?end?, along with any other achievement of that ?means? includes murder.

by jardinier

I have been blasted from one end of this website to the other for stating (based on available statistics) than an unusually high proportion of Americans, compared with other western nations, state that they are Christians.

You will probably get an argument with your usage of the terms "agnostic" and "atheist," but for practical purposes -- based on dictionary definitions -- they mean pretty much one and the same thing.

by onbliss

Agnostic is a person who considers that a lot of things are unknown in this world, and many a time these beliefs, faiths or claims are [b]irrelevant.[/b]

In the SQL/Database world, if the datatype of a column is Boolean, True could be theist, False could be Atheist, and NULL could be an agnostic.

Here is how Webster.com defines it:
Etymology: Greek [i]agnOstos[/i] unknown, unknowable, from a- + gnOstos known, from [i]gignOskein[/i] to know -- more at KNOW
: a person who holds the view that any ultimate reality (as God) is [b]unknown and prob. unknowable[/b]; broadly : one who is not committed to believing in either the existence or the nonexistence of God or a god

by onbliss

1. What is just and unjust?
2. Who decides it?
3. And, can justice to one be injustice to the other?

by tonythetiger

1. every action is just to the person who performs it.

2. The writers of history.

3. Yes, and in fact almost always [b]is[[/b].

by onbliss

..the Palestines could be feeling that injustice has been metted out to them. The Irsraelis could feel the same.
Compromise by both parties seems to be the sensible way to save further loss of lives and improve the welfare of the people living there.
But if the Palestines do not perceive the World (not the Arab world) to be a neutral player encouraging compromise, then they are just going to keep backing out. Then, the world chastises them saying we offered you a solution years ago, but you did not accept it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.