Discussion Locked

Today is the day Democrats in America have Dreaded

0 helpful
91 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This morning, Justice Sandra Day O'Connor has announced that she will be retiring from the Supreme Court.

President George W. Bush will now be the person to fill this vacancy, to the utter horror of the alledged "progressive liberal movement".

Some have said President Bush will use this to try to get Roe v Wade overturned and was one of the big rallying points for trying to get Senator John Kerry elected instead.

Will this be the end of crazy decisions that grant the city councels the right to legally steal your land?
[b]
Will the fillibuster come out? Most likely.
Will the rule to change rules come out to slap the fillibuster down? Most likely.
Will the Constitution survive this? Most likely.
Will it be ugly? Most likely.
Will we go on? Most likely.
[/b][i]
NOTE: Most "most likely"'s can be substituted with the word "definately". I was just on a roll is all.

91 replies

by jck

The constitution's intent has been raped for decades by our legal system and general lack of understanding of how to work together for the common good. The legal system (both legislative and judicial) has made a mockery out of the premises this country was built on.

Sure, we can come together (like after 9/11) when we need to. However, most Americans live in a self-absorbed universe only thinkin of how they can save money for a new toy or how they can get those fancy things that impress others.

jmgarvin, I'll do what I can to help you find something in County Cork...my friend lives just miles from there. I'll probably be in Tipp or Clare.

Just glad my house is gonna be almost double in value when I go to sell. I will have money enough to live for a year or better there.

by jdclyde

did you have one?

And for the record, it is ONLY the Conservative judges that try to maintain original intent.

For more details about that you would have to go see Max's new post. An EXCELLENT adventure dude! I mean he does a great job of identifying the whos/whens/wheres and whys.

Side note: what is wrong with working hard to get something you want? "pursuit of happyness" remember? What is wrong with someone building up equity in their house so they can retire in Ireland? Nothing wrong with it.

Oh yeah, about your note about "popularity" of REAL beer, to that all I have to say is "bud light" and "miller". Just like your poll comment. The vast masses are a bunch of a$$es.... :^O

by jck

you point out in your bold type whether or not the constitution will survive.

Physically...I say maybe.
In intent...it didn't last past about 1970s.

As for only conservative judges wanting to uphold original intent: that's like saying only guys from Michigan have beards. Conservative judges vote liberally sometimes...liberal judges vote to uphold traditions sometimes. That was an extremist view you took there...that must be what only conservatives do too...since you're a conservative after all...right?

About Max's post: yes...very thorough...of course, I did as good (and more brief) of a job mapping out that Bush has out extended the Authorizations in H.R. 114 that lined-out what he could do in Iraq. Thanks for noticing that. You're probably doubting that the Senate website I gave is real? Maybe I hacked them and put that there?

BTW, there's nothing wrong with building equity in my home...it was a *good* thing...you misread that statement. (unless I mistyped something)
*EDIT*
I just noticed what you're referring to...most people in this country save their money and buy toys and stuff...and don't pay their bills, feed their kids, etc...trust me...I see it daily...women out at big lots buying patio decorations when their 5 year old is wearing ragged clothes.

Friggin unreal sh*t man. that's what I meant...people are saving to blow their money on insignificant crap all the time, when they have responsibilities to pay...not that it's wrong to buy equity property that is an investment in the future.

*END EDIT*

As for your real beer commentary: Just remember...Guinness is the most consumed beer worldwide...Ireland consumes more beer a year than the United states and has about 1% of the population.

So yeah...it is popularity...international...not just in areas of one country.

Budweiser...talk about me using a poor example...you're pointing out a beer that is popular with a minority of people...although, more than Killians.

You're just sore that I like a beer that's more widely accepted, loved and appreciated than one you like.

What do I say? If 3 million *real* Irish men and women (ones born and raised there...not psuedo-wanna-bes) love it, there's something good about it.

Make all the fun you want...Dubya is running his presidency in the ground by almost letting 2,000 troops die to rebuild Iraq...I drink a more full-flavored, more purchased, more consumed beer than you...and, I don't try poke at your opinions all the time.

Enough though. I am going home as soon as I get done running these reports and stuff.

Have a nice Independence Day...and I hope some developer doesn't kick you and your kids out of your house soon.

Welcome to America...give me your wallet...

by jmgarvin

This whole insanity is just killing me. It seems the American public just LOVES to get raped on a daily basis.

What happened to states rights? What happened to the federal government being the "guide on the side?" What happened to FOLLOWING THE CONSTITUTION!!??? Why do our judges keep ruling on what the feds can do, but forget that the feds are only there to take up the slack the states can't deal with.

Don't get me started on Social Security and the whole fiasco of that mess. Gads, us Gen Xers (and Gen Yers) will be paying for the baby boomers, the Iraq war, and for this insanity that keeps coming out of Washington.

Great, I just need a work visa and a job over there and I should be set. :-) I wonder if any of the universities are hiring??? I should be done with the piled higher and deeper in about 2 years (I hope). hmmmm....

by tomsal

Our SS check will be for $1.49 each week......and of course by then even a candy bar will cost $6.00. ;)

Oh great....I'm gonna be working until I'm dead.

Lovely!

!!Disclaimer for those without a sense of humor: Yes I know there likely won't be SS at all by then, and yes I realize you can't live on SS alone either! lol!!

by maxwell edison

Social Security was one of the worst government programs ever devised. It started Amerika on its road to the current socialist state in which we find ourselves.

The only ones to benefit from it are the people who've retired between 1945 and 1975. The ones who retired between 75 and 05 are probably at about a break-even. The baby-boomers (of which I am one) will get the short end of the stick, having been faced with paying social security taxes that were about 500 percent higher, as a percentage of income, than most of our predecessors paid, while our benefits will be reduced dramatically. And you're right, the next generation after me will be the ones to really get screwed. It's a silly system to expect one generation of workers to pay the previous generation, which is what it really amounts to.

But you know what? Even though it's painfully obvious how grossly inefficient and/or unfair, and/or unconstitutional it's been, how many people will come right out and espouse the eventual elimination of the Social Security system? I will. In fact, count me as leading the bandwagon. Want to jump on?

I propose we find a way to equitably get everybody OFF the social security system, gradually reducing both the benefits and the taxes over some given amount of time, eventually taking both the benefits AND the taxes to ZERO. My estimated timetable for the gradual reduction would be around 50 years.

It might go something like this:

The people just starting off in life, say 18 and under, will not have to pay ANY social security taxes. However, they will get absolutely NO social security benefits either. They will have to be warned that they MUST provide for their own retirement, and, of course, educated on how and why. But if they don't save on their own for their own, that's just too bad. (As it should be and always was before the SS debacle was created.)

The 18-25 crowd might just get a full refund of what they've already paid, perhaps put into mandatory personal retirement plan, and will also have to plan for their own retirement, but have a small amount upon which to build.

The 25-35 crowd might have their taxes and benefits cut by some percentage, maybe also see some kind of refund as described, and they will see a combination of Social Security benefits and a self-retirement plan. The reduced SS taxes could also be put into mandatory personal retirement plan.

The 35-45 crowd will be the same as the 25-35, but with different percentages.

And on it goes.....

The current old folks will see no changes, unless certain conditions exist. For example, did you know that Warren Buffet is collecting social security? Why? Sure, he paid into it, but he never paid SS taxes on his income that was over $85,000 a year, and that was most of his income (or most of his "net worth"). Maybe there should be some sort of sliding scale for reducing current benefits for people who have a certain net worth, especially if it's a result of having not paid taxes on that income that was over $85,000. No, it wouldn't be fair, but we gotta' start cutting benefits if we are going to start cutting SS taxes.

That's kind of simplistic, I know, and it would be much more detailed than that. But I think we all know what a gradual reduction in both benefits and taxes really means.

Work for the eventual elimination of ALL Social Security benefits AND taxes. Yes or no? I say yes. Who will say yes with me?

by jck

all the smaller universities outside of Dublin. I imagine getting a profesorship at Trinity is like trying to get Mother Teresa to have sex (sorry to you Catholics, but it's not an insult...it's a testament to her chastity and devotion to God).

Anyways...I'm still waiting for word. If all goes right and I get a good offer, I'll be in Ireland full-time by the end of 2006.

Anyone interested in a house less than 10 minutes from the gulf coast? ;)

by maxwell edison

You said, "The constitution's intent has been raped for decades by our legal system and general lack of understanding of how to work together for the common good."

I both agree and disagree.

I agree that "the Constitution's intent has been raped for decades by our legal system".......and, I might add, also by the socialist, I mean liberal (Democrat) party and the people who condone taking the personal property (money or otherwise) from the person who earned it so it can be given to a person who did not earn it.

Moreover, it's people who continually use the term "common good" (including you, since you just used it), who have been the impetus behind "raping the Constitution's intent", since its intent was to protect and guarantee INDIVIDUAL LIBERTY, not the "common good". The intent was that by protecting and guaranteeing INDIVIDUAL LIBERTY, the "common good" would be best satisfied. And it didn't start in the 70s, as you suggested, it started in the 1930s under Franklin Roosevelt and his socialist gang of collectivists. Moreover, a liberal's view of "common good" is my view of mutual destruction. And since "common good" is defined differently by different people, that's all the more reason to let INDIVIDUAL LIBERTY trump all else.

You said, "most Americans live in a self-absorbed universe only thinking of how they can save money for a new toy or how they can get those fancy things that impress others."

Another thing you collectivist "common good" folks continually do is somehow judge others on what their goals may or may not be and/or the things they strive to achieve and acquire. I try not to begrudge anyone for anything he may have acquired and achieved. Why do you feel a need to judge and begrudge? (And don't say that you don't, because you just did.) It must be that "common good" thing again.

by jck

1) I've never used "common good" in a socialist manner. Socialism is the set of beliefs which states that all people are equal and should share equally in the wealth of the country, or the political systems based on these beliefs
. I believe in the right for people to earn and keep what they've worked for. But, I do not believe in taking away just for the sake to give to others to level out income and possessions. It's one of the reasons I'm so viahemently opposed to the current form of our welfare system.

2) As for what the common good is, let's take a look at the Preamble of the Constitution of the United States of America:

"We the people of the United States, in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice, insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America."

"...promote the general welfare..."...hmmm...I guess the Constitution isn't about working toward a common good, huh?

Although I don't know why you can't see it, I understand that a government can be formed and run in an effort to provide for the common good of all people while allowing the prosperity of individuals to achieve all they are capable of.

3) I didn't say it "started in the 1970s", I said "In intent...it didn't last past about 1970s."

4) As for letting INDIVIDUAL LIBERTY trump everything else, that is the perfect example of what is wrong with this country. You need to put one HUGE caveat on that...which is to add "...,unless it infringes on another's INDIVIDUAL LIBERTY."

5) You see, it's that attitude (along with all the convenient legal loopholes the bureaucracy has created) that allows individuals to take advantage and rape the system, i.e.- that INDIVIDUAL LIBERTY you so cherish gets turned into INDIVIDUAL PROFITEERING by those who have the "if it's there, it's my right" attitude. And again as I've said before, too many Americans don't care if it goes on until it affects them. They'll even screw their neighbor to get ahead.

Again...I have NOTHING against anyone earning their keep. However...when someone abuses a system, takes advantage of the law, takes advantage of others, and most of all takes away from others via the legal system...that INDIVIDUAL LIBERTY banner you so proudly wave becomes the symbolism for CAPITALIST LIBERTY.

I also have a beef with a system that for years (and still even after legal reform, still allows some) has let people go out and with reckless abandon run up bills, then skip out on them and place the burden of repayment to the others within the system...whether that's credit cards, government loans, etc. If you incur a debt, you should be responsible for it until the day you die. No one made you spend that money....no one else should have to pay for it.

6) I want to make clear your twisting of my use of the term "common good", since you seem so intent to bastardize what I mean and cast me as some kind of Marxist radical.

When I refer to a "common good", I am stating a belief that our government has been established to serve all its citizens. Programs are setup to help the needy, build roads, build libraries, etc. Another part of our government is the establishment of the legislative and judicial branches to create and interpret law which is supposed to protect all citizens rights (hence why there is a motto on the outside of the Supreme Court: "EQUAL JUSTICE UNDER LAW").

It is this common good that not only should perform that task, but also protect the rights of citizens to "life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness" as declared as unalienable rights in the Declaration of Independence.

BUT...these rights should never EVER be held up for any individual or organization when they become infringing on the rights of others, i.e.- when someone takes advantage of the welfare system and double dips and it takes away from someone else in need, when government agrees to allow the right of private enterprise to take holdings of people to benefit private enterprise under the guise of "benefitting the public", etc.

You seem to be holding no faith in the ability of the American system to grow itself into a system which can not only function, but also meter itself in its activities and procedures.

You seemingly want to lock things down and only go by only letter of the law. But at the same time, that letter of the law which you seem to hold so dear has become the prime means by which those who would do abuse this system you hold so dear and abuse the INDIVIDUAL LIBERTY of others.

Until someone can figure out how to get politicians (from both sides) to write law that prevents all foreseeable abuse, and then gives for room to deal with contingent abuse thereafter, I don't see how your way will work either.

Just remember...before you can patch the tire...you have to find the leak.

BTW, I don't begrudge anyone who has earned what they have. However, most people in this country didn't earn what they got. They've inherited it. Examples of people like Sam Walton are fewer and farther between because the free-market economy here isn't so free.

It's almost impossible to go and build up and become a competitor in today's market, because eventually you'll endanger some goliath's business and the big boy will go buy out your supplier or intimidate a carrier so they don't ship your cargo...but they'll do anything other than work harder to make sure they keep the lion's share. That is, "dirty pool" is now an accepted business *and* personal practice in this country.

Anyways, I'm sure you'll have a lot to say. But, I've spent way too much time on this topic simply because you seem to think that anyone who believes a government can provide for everyone an equal playing field is actually pushing for a socialist government enterprise.

That is not the case with me, I assure you. I have (what I call) the "Jamestown" belief system. If you're able to work, you work or you don't get. If you're unable to work, those around you provide for you. If they need some help, those around them help them.

It's not that hard of a concept, I assure you. And, it isn't the paramount sign of me being a socialist. It means I think our government is more capable of working and self-regulation than you would give it credit.

Anyways...must run...have fun with it...I'm going back to talking about beer now.

by jdclyde

The part about the Constitution surviving was in regards to all the shrill screaming about the "constitutional crisis" at hand when the Reps proposed doing away with the super majority vote in order to get a vote.

I DID say it was good to save the money! I just used that as an example to put it in your ballpark so you could relate that there is NOTHING wrong with making a profit.

HMMM, you slipped in an edit from the time I read your post and the time I hit reply. Sneaky! I also used to see things that would make me sick. Used to work in a gas station and scumbags would come in and get a pop and pack of smokes for themselves but would tell their kids "no" if they asked for a 50 cent candybar. How pathetic.

Bud is VERY "popular" in this land we live in. Thus making my point that popular is not always a sign of something being good.

As for your hr114 post, I haven't gotten back to that discussion to see it yet. SOME of us have the "w" word to do today...... ;\

But I DID hear a lot about this during the election, which was the point of this post. NOT to poke at you, it was just timing that I had heard about her retiring so I had to get this up.

And a grand fourth of july weekend to you. See you on TUESDAY!

by jck

You have wal-mart to do? ;)

Actually, I've already created an interface for my boss (when he gets back) to be able to pull up pre-made Crystal Reports, I've configured a local FTP service and got an FTP file transfer/format conversion utility written, and started specifying the app I'll be writing next month to synchronize all 3 solid waste stations onto one real-time DB.

I do a little work too, ya know ;)

by tonythetiger

a mother put Beer, Cigarettes, and Diapers up on the counter, then when the total is more than the money she has, puts the diapers back.

by jmgarvin

I'd rather KEEP my money and not have it going into a general fund that is going to be raped and pillaged!

My 401k is huring, the IRA is killing me, and I still will never have enough to retire. (I'm guessing that I'll need at least $1 million in the bank to retire AND pay for doctors AND medicine AND housing AND car repair AND food AND etc etc. Think about it...with anything less than that you can't afford to live...you won't have SS, you won't have medicaid/medicare, you won't have medical/dental insurance for a resonable amount, etc)

SS needs to just die. We (Gen X and Gen Y) can't support a generation that is twice our size!!

by av .

He is likely to pick an ultra-conservative that would alter the makeup of the Supreme Court. Maybe someone from under the same rock that they got John Bolton from.

It is going to be a real interesting show. It could all be avoided if GWB would appoint a more moderate person. But we all know that GWB is far from moderate.

I hope they go nuclear. I want to see Bill Frist exercise the nuclear option to trump the filibuster.

Oh yes - the eminent domain law. If that doesn't get Americans to rise up, I don't know what will. It just shows even more how corrupt our whole government is.

by jdclyde

You say that like it is in question.

The thing that really winds my crank about this whole thing in the press it the dumba$$s who are saying that Bush should use this chance to give the minorities a voice.

That isn't what the majority AND electoral vote put him there for and he knows it and so does everyone else. The vote that put him there was to further like ideas, not to give a voice to the losing party.

Then as for REAL majorities it AMAZES me how there aren't more women that are Concervatives than there are. Who gave them the right to vote? Who has put more minorities in high offices? (minorites includes blacks, hispanics and women as all were denied basic rights for too long)

Bottom line of every newscast I have heard today from the left AND right is that this will all be about abortion. WHEN the judge is anti-abortion, the fillibuster will come out and all bets will be off.

by maxwell edison

You said, "....if GWB would appoint a more moderate person......."

GWB was elected president by a majority of voters, a conservative majority, I might add. They knew what his principles were when they voted for him. They knew what kind of people he would appoint. Why in the would he violate his own principles just to pacify the people who disagree with, and didn't vote for him to begin with? Just like John Kerry would have appointed a flaming liberal, if GWB appoints a flaming conservative, that's the way the game is played. If you don't like it, too bad. I absolutely cringed when President Clinton appointed Ruth Bader Ginsburg to the court, an extreme flaming liberal, to say the least. And if GWB appoints someone to counter-balance her, that's just fine in my book.

by av .

Isn't everyone somewhat happy with moderate when it comes to our government? That way we both get something.

Bush would never do what I want. He hasn't even thought the thought. He should be trying to unite the country.

Maybe you might like his conservative appointee. I probably wouldn't. Somewhere there is a more moderate approach that we desperately need to find. Regardless of what has happened in the past, you have to agree that Bush had no landslide victory in the past election. Almost half of the voters voted for Kerry. Why is this president representing only half of the country? What about the rest of us?

The Supreme Court needs to have balance. Bush should recommend a more moderate individual to maintain the balance. We don't need a John Bolton-type candidate for the Supreme Court.

by montgomery gator

AmericanVoter wrote: "He is likely to pick an ultra-conservative that would alter the makeup of the Supreme Court. Maybe someone from under the same rock that they got John Bolton from."
...
I surely hope he does find an "ultra-conservative" if that means someone who believes in the plain language of the Constitution and the original intent of the Founding Fathers, if that means someone who believes in State Sovereignty, that the Federal Government has interfered in the internal affairs of the individual states in violation of the 10th Amendment. Someone who looks at American law, not at what other countries did, unlike what the majority of justices did when they interfered with the states in death penalty cases.

However, I fear he will pick someone like Souter, who seemed like a judicial conservative, but ended up being one of the lefties that has voted to allow the Federal Government to expand and voted in favor of that decision that allowed the taking of private property for private use if it had some nebulous "public benefit".

by sleepin'dawg

[b] The Faith-Based Attack on Rational Government

As "people of faith" step up their crusade to inject religion into judicial decision-making, people of reason must understand why America should be a wholly secular state.[/b]

By Thomas A. Bowden

They call themselves "people of faith," and they are waging war against a basic principle of American government: the separation of church and state. Complaining that our secular culture has improperly banished God from government, religious conservatives are working tirelessly to inject faith-based decision-making into America's legal system.

This conservative onslaught requires a bold defense of the secular state--by people of reason.

Although that defense must encompass all branches of government, today's battleground is the courtroom, where judges find themselves under relentless pressure to legitimize religious dogmas such as the sanctity of the God-given soul (the Terri Schiavo case, anti-abortion laws, stem cell research), the literal truth of holy scripture (laws against homosexuality, displays of the Ten Commandments in courthouses), and the recognition of God as master of the universe (creationism, prayer in public schools). The First Amendment, conservatives declare, guarantees only freedom "of" religion, not freedom "from" religion.

To their credit, secular judges have valiantly resisted the religious right's persistent advances. In response, frustrated conservatives are leveraging their newfound dominance over Congress and the presidency in a crusade to emasculate the judiciary. Whether it's senators limiting filibusters, or Congress threatening to reorganize the court system, or President Bush decrying "judicial activism" while nominating compliant federal judges, conservatives are targeting secular judges as enemies.

No, the "people of faith" are not calling for a Christian theocracy--yet. For now, they simply want to establish religious faith on an equal footing with reason as a legitimate method of governmental decision-making. But if they succeed in this, the eventual emergence of government by clergy is all but assured.

A proper defense of the secular state must penetrate to fundamentals. It is insufficient, for example, to criticize Christian evangelicals for imposing their own narrow creed on a diversely religious citizenry. Such superficial criticism implies that faith-based governmental action is permissible if representative of all beliefs, when in fact our Constitution forbids it.

America was established for a secular purpose: the protection of individual rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. The Constitution neither mentions God (except to forbid religious tests for public office) nor imbues government with any religious purposes.

Individual rights can be protected only by a secular state whose every action is grounded in objective fact and guided by reason, not blind faith. By way of illustration, consider the importance of rational methodology in the field of criminal justice.

To justify an arrest in a proper legal system, the police must have probable cause, and to win a conviction, a prosecutor must establish guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, based on objective evidence. If justice is to prevail, each governmental decision must be taken without regard to anyone's religious faith.

Any admixture of religious faith guarantees injustice. In the Dark Ages, a prosecutor would submerge the defendant's arms in boiling water, and if the scalded flesh became infected, that was taken as a sign of God's disfavor, mandating a guilty verdict. Adopting that benighted era's essential methodology, today's conservatives demand that judges accept "God's will" as a legitimate basis for punishing homosexuals, science teachers, stem cell researchers, and a host of others. This is the collapse of criminal justice, as surely as if Jewish judges were rejecting testimony from atheists, or Catholic jurors were relying on scripture to convict Protestants.

Centuries of history demonstrate that faith-based governments spawn persecution, torture, and endless bloody warfare. Today's religionists may insist that this time will be different, but their evasions cannot eradicate the inherent connection between faith and force. Since faith entails overriding reason in favor of emotion, religious disputes are necessarily unresolvable through rational persuasion, leaving force as the only weapon against heretics and infidels. No wonder religionists so often lust after government power.

If "people of faith" choose to act irrationally in their private lives, they are free to do so. But if there is one institution that must be held rationally accountable for every single action it takes, it is the agency that can lawfully use guns, prisons, and lethal injections against legally disarmed citizens.

Separating church from state does not guarantee victory for the rational protection of individual rights--secular irrationality is possible, indeed commonplace--but such separation is indispensable nonetheless. This is why issues like abortion, gay rights, and "Intelligent Design" creationism merit so much attention. Once judges begin accepting religious feelings as valid decisional factors, the secular principle cannot survive, and the disintegration of society into sectarian strife must soon follow.

"People of faith" began this war, and so people of reason must now end it--by zealously defending the secular state, and vowing never to allow faith and force to be united under the American flag.

[b]**************************************************[/b]

Thomas A. Bowden is an attorney and a writer for Ayn Rand Institute (www.AynRand.org) in Irvine, Calif. The Institute promotes the ideas of Ayn Rand--best-selling author of Atlas Shrugged and The Fountainhead and originator of the philosophy of Objectivism.

Copyright ? 2005 Ayn Rand? Institute. All rights reserved.

[b]**************************************************[/b]

I think, one conservative to another, you will have found the above interesting, to say the least.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jdclyde

is there is no such thing as "separation of church and state" in the constitution. All it says is the government will not sanction a religion providing for ALL religions to flurish, not be stamped down.

Remember the founding fathers wanted religious freedom, not freedom from religion.

(this isn't going to pull us into the morals without religion discussion is it?)

by sleepin'dawg

And if a lapsed black protestant may say so, Mea Culpa. [b][i]Illigitimi non carborundum[/b][/i]- don't let the barstards grind you down.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by house

The government in Canada will buy up your property at its appraised value for the sake of development - no questions asked.

There have been older highways around here that have been expanded or re-routed, only to leave some poor shmuck with a 150 year old home with a wad of cash and no place to go.

In my opinion, Bush can do whatever he wants. The world can only take so much. Besides, I'd be stupid to think that he is anything more than a representative. Did you ever notice how stunned he looks? Who works the levers?

chris

by jdclyde

What are all the media outlets talking about? Doesn't matter who it is or what their political slant, they are all talking about how Bush will appoint a judge that is in line with the Republican point of view and how that is such a bad thing for him to do. (bad if your not Republican that is)

Listing in the web and radio, from Hannety on the Right to Schultz on the left it is the same discussion.

Will it alway be legal to give an abortion to a minor that you could not give an asprin to?

Don't care WHAT your opinion on abortion is, so I will not even go into that direction. But this IS all we will hear for the next three months.

by maxwell edison

If their guy (a liberal) is elected and makes the appointments, it's okay for a flaming liberal to be appointed (Ginsburg). But if a conservative is elected, he's expected to appoint a "moderate" (whatever the heck that is).

When they win elections, the get things their way. When they lose elections, they still expect things to go their way. They don't understand what it means to LOSE.

THEY LOST! THEY DON'T GET TO DECIDE SUCH THINGS WHEN THEY LOSE!

It's no wonder fewer and fewer people identify themselves as liberals. They are a dying breed, indeed, perhaps because they're so ungrounded in principle and/or can't legitimately stand on principle.

by jck

And anyone who has to sit and coin people as "flaming" shouldn't sit and shoot flames himself.

BTW, when Justice Ginsburg was appointed he was supposed to be a "moderate conservative", but ended up being a "moderate liberal".

Wasn't that Orrin Hatch who was head of the Senate Judiciary Committee and Majority Leader of the Senate who saw that nomination through confirmation? ;)

by beads

The only thing getting ground into the ground is this nascant ultra-conservative rhetoric.

Since "conservatives" are so hell bent on things lets review a small scant of history shall we?

Back in the 1920s and 1930s "conservativism" ruled American politics only to be replaced with moderatism and finally liberalism in the 1970s. Or don't conservatives think that the pendulum is ever going to swing back again? If for some far fetched reason you do there is going to be yet another shock to the conservative movement.

Personally, I am waiting for another televangelist to come out of the closet or annouce that he's a complete hypocrit and had a number of affairs while stuffing money away into a foriegn bank account. Oooopppsss! There I go stating facts again. As we know facts are bad. Very bad. Lets let Carl ask the question for me. Taking the Republican view point: How does that make you feel about the subject?

For the record I am a flaming environmentalist. Hence I no longer feel any room for me or my kind at the Republican table.

- beads

by maxwell edison

Why would a person compromise his principles just to pacify someone with whom he disagrees? I wouldn't, and probably neither would you. Besides, I don't buy into the "moderate" label. Moderate is not a politically descriptive label except to suggest that person isn't grounded in principle.

And like I said, when a liberal gets to make the appointments, no one, especially fellow liberal constituents, are beating the "moderate" drum in the name of "uniting the country". Moreover, in my opinion, it's the liberals on the left who need to move in the name of unification. They're the ones splitting the country, so to speak. It's the liberals who constantly pit the rich against the poor, black against white, the have's against the have not's, women against men, the "little guy" against big-business, and so on.

Regardless of what President Bush does, he'll be criticized. That's just the way the left will play the game. And you don't know the first thing about John Bolton except what you've been spoon-fed to believe by the critical left. Why would you choose to believe what someone like Robert Byrd, for example, might say about John Bolton instead of believing someone like Bill Frist? Do you know something about the guy that those people, and others like them, don't? Do you have first-hand experience dealing with the guy? You know only what you hear and read; and you choose what you read and decide who you will believe.

You might suggest that the Supreme Court needs to have "balance", whatever that is. But I suggest that the Supreme Court should NEVER make law, it should NEVER attempt to push a political agenda, but rather ALWAYS rule based on the true intent of the Constitution. And if you think that the intent of the Constitution included the taking of a person's private property so as to give it to a hotel developer, you're nuts -- just like the other 5 extremist and activist judges who made such law from the bench.

by av .

Its not a matter of pacification, its a matter of nominating a candidate that would receive bipartisan support, which is in the best interest of the country. A moderate is someone that is not too far right or left in their thinking. Conservative or liberal, they are more open minded and fair minded. Someone too far right or left is not well suited for any public office because their mind is already made up and their views on any given subject are written in stone. They are extremists.

This country desperately needs unification and the President should make an effort to do that. He prefers to preach to the choir. Both extremes, liberal and conservative, need to become more moderate and make an effort to work together. There are 2 sides to everything and both sides are guilty of not working together, not just liberals. Our government is dysfunctional. It truly is a sight to see at this point.

President Bush will always be critized, you are absolutely right, and he deserves to be. He has polarized the country from the day he won the election in 2000 and hasn't been able to unite the nation since. John Kerry wasn't a good enough candidate to unseat Bush in 2004. Now, Democrats are refusing to work with this government, out of spite sometimes and also as a way to differentiate themselves and position themselves for the next election. I think I agree with them in some cases, but it isn't doing you and I any good. We're paying these people!

Bush's nomination of John Bolton is just a poor choice. From all accounts that I have read from all different sources, he is no diplomat, just an abrasive, obnoxious man. He looks disheveled, like he crawled out from under a rock. How would he ever work with other nations in a diplomatic position if he can't even work with his coworkers? He insulted the very institution he would be working with. Do we need an even worse face in the world? Do you really have to be abrasive to affect change in the UN?

You say, why would I believe what someone like Robert Byrd says over a Bill Frist? The truth is, I don't believe either one until I investigate what they say and check the facts with independent sources. I'm not as partisan as you are or you like to think I am. I'm in the middle and the jury is out until I see real facts. Not partisan politics.

Look where this country is at right now. We need people that can solve our many problems, not grandstanding, partisan politics and power plays. That takes a moderate.

For example, Bush's social security plan just HAS to have personal accounts. Democrats are opposed to personal accounts. Many people are opposed to them. The outcome is, NOTHING is being done with this very important problem. Neither side will budge. A moderate would consider other plans that didn't rely so much on personal accounts. A moderate point of view is more interested in team USA.

When I think of moderate, I think of a team environment. Republicans and Democrats working together for the good of the people.

by maxwell edison

And what makes you right and me wrong?

You said, "It's not a matter of pacification, its a matter of nominating a candidate that would receive bipartisan support, which is in the best interest of the country."

I disagree. It's a matter of nominating a candidate who would strictly interpret the Constitution -- as it was intended to be -- and not "read into" it something that's not there. "Bipartisan support", in most cases, only means one side capitulated to the other. In the recent Supreme Court case that's been discussed in this forum, it's either acceptable or not for the government to seize a person's personal property under the guise of eminent domain so it can be given to a private developer. The only compromise possible is if someone compromised on his principle. "Bipartisan support" is merely the battle cry of the person or party who lost an election in an attempt to advance his agenda anyway.

On conservatives, liberals, and moderates (and I'll throw in libertarians for the heck of it). Instead of repeating the tired old catch-phrases, such as "a moderate is someone that is not too far right or left in their thinking", please define a "moderate's" position on specific current-day issues, with current examples that would illustrate such a position. For example, where would a "moderate" fall in the above eminent domain issue? Where would a "moderate" fall in the case of abortion? Where would a "moderate" fall in the case of deciding whether or not to privatize (or eventually eliminate) Social Security? Where would a "moderate" fall in the case of the death penalty? Where would a "moderate" fall on the basic issue of taking a dollar from the person who earned it, only to give it to a person who did not? (Would a "moderate" only take a half-dollar?) And please, be very, very specific. And please, base such stances on a set of core principles.

When you said, ".....which is in the best interest of the country.....", you mean "best interest" as defined by whom? Personally, I believe it would be in the best interest of the country to literally slash (over a given period of time) all government-forced transfer-of-wealth social programs by at least 80 to 90 percent. Others, however, would believe that the "best interest" would be better served by doubling or tripling such programs. I believe that you should define your best-interest, and I should define my best-interest, and as long as we don't infringe on each other, that will serve the country's best-interest -- AND remain consistent with the original intent of the Constitution.

And you, yourself, defined who is really "polarizing the country", when you pointed out that the Democrats lost the election, but they are still "refusing to work with this government, out of spite sometimes, and also as a way to differentiate themselves and position themselves for the next election". But yet you blame the winner of the election who is only fulfilling his campaign promises (such as private SS accounts). One could certainly surmise that the majority of Americans would prefer to have more personal control over their own retirement, or they wouldn't have voted for the guy who advocated such a position.

On the United Nations, I would suggest that it's a corrupt organization that will not advance the best-interests of the USA, will always criticize the USA, will always "blame" the USA, and if I had my way, we'd simply suspend our membership until the security council was reorganized to include ONLY nation-states that advocated free elections, and a free and open society for all its citizens. Moreover, I believe that someone, perhaps even an "abrasive, obnoxious" American, should publicly demand that the criminals who were involved in the recent oil-for-food scandal, and who bilked innocent victims out of billions of dollars in food and medical aid, should be publicly identified and tried for their crimes. Moreover, the United Nations has failed miserably in bringing about improvements to the impoverished and war-torn African continent, even though it's painfully obvious that it's the Africans themselves who are the cause, and it's the Africans themselves who have been stealing billions of dollars in aid money that has poured in over the years. The United Nations is the most corrupt and inefficient organization on the face of the earth, and it should be either dismantled or overhauled entirely.

You say that you're not as "partisan" as I am. I might suggest that you're not as principled as I am -- or, you won't clearly admit and identify your core principles.

You said, "Bush's social security plan just HAS to have personal accounts. Democrats are opposed to personal accounts. Many people are opposed to them." Like I said, President Bush is the winner of the election who is only fulfilling his campaign promises. One could certainly surmise that the majority of Americans would prefer to have more personal control over their own retirement, or they wouldn't have voted for the guy who advocated such a position. Just because the Democrats, who LOST the election when they put themselves on the record of opposing such accounts, still want their way. The MAJORITY of Americans have spoken on the issue; The MAJORITY of Americans want to control their own retirement destiny; but the Democrats who still insist on having their way are attempting to block it. And who is "polarizing" the country, you say? Give me a break.

And I'll ask you again, since you didn't answer me the first time I asked. On conservatives, liberals, and moderates (and I'll throw in libertarians for the heck of it). Instead of repeating the tired old catch-phrases, such as "A moderate is someone that is not too far right or left in their thinking", please define a "moderate's" position on specific current-day issues, with current examples that would illustrate a "moderate's" position. For example, where would a "moderate" fall in the above eminent domain issue? Where would a "moderate" fall in the case of abortion? Where would a "moderate" fall in the case of deciding whether or not to privatize (or eventually eliminate) Social Security? Where would a "moderate" fall in the case of the death penalty? And please, be very, very specific.

by jdclyde

[i]"For example, Bush's social security plan just HAS to have personal accounts. Democrats are opposed to personal accounts."[/i]

Personal accounts are not wanted by the Democrats because it makes the individual independant of the government. They WANT you coming to papa government for your daily bread to keep you in line. And would an OPTIONAL 7% out of what you pay in going into YOUR account that you can leave to your kids really break the bank any quicker than the decades of raiding the funds that has been going on? Do you really think putting your money into a non-interest bearing account will help anyone under 45?

What other reason is there to be so against the personal accounts? Bush is "pig headded" for insisting on this. What are the Dems for insisting just the opposite? Hmmmm.

by maxwell edison

Will you please define a "moderate"? And use specific issue examples to illustrate. Some issue examples might include, taxation, abortion, gay marriages, national defense, social security, the practice of taking personal property under the guise of exercising the power of eminent domain, and the general sentiment of taking a dollar from the person who earned it so as to give it to a person who did not. Where would a "moderate" stand on those and other such issues? And define the basic core values on which such a stand is grounded.

by beads

Maxwell;

Could you please enlighten those of us less politically intellectual as to what you consider a liberal or moderate? It might be a better starting point than accusing everyone who is not slightly right of Pat Buchannan (sp) of being a liberal.

As stated by Carl Rowe. Liberals have made the mistake of trying to start the debate with facts, while we (the Republicans) only ask how you "feel" about issues. Its brilliant, really is. I have to hand it to Carl and the boys in power right now.

- beads

by maxwell edison

I stated that, "I don't buy into the 'moderate' label. Moderate is not a politically descriptive label except to suggest that person isn't grounded in principle." And then you ask me to define a moderate. What gives?

What do I consider a liberal? Someone who espouses taking a dollar from the person who earned it, for the sole purpose of giving it to a person who did not earn it. Some wear the liberal label under the Republican Party flag, and just about everyone under the Democrat Party flag wears it.

A liberal believes in government solving personal problems instead of espousing individual responsibility for such problem solving. And a liberal believes in forced government mandates as the methods used to solve such problems.

A liberal believes in a stronger federal government instead of stronger state governments.

A liberal believes in capitulating to the United Nations instead of maintaining a stronger sovereign government.

A liberal is "pro-worker" at the expense of free enterprise. A liberal is in favor of a government mandated minimum wage, for example, instead of market driven forces to establish such wages.

All Democrats are liberals as shown by the programs they support. Most Republicans are liberals because they won't support the abolition of such programs, but instead only less of them. Most Republicans are no more than baby-Democrats.

Has the definition of a "liberal" changed over the years and decades? Absolutely. I describe today's liberal as opposed to an anti-liberal.

The Republican Party of today is ~equal to the Democrat Party of 1960. The Democrat Party of today is ~equal to the American Socialist Party of 1930.

I could go on, but I think you might get the idea.

Comments?

By the way, beads, welcome. I've not seen you hangin-round these parts before (said in my best "western-drawl").

by jck

Most Americans don't care until *they* stand to lose something.

And when they are getting something free, they usually don't care if it adversly affects others unless it has some gross misjustice or heinous effect.

I'm not worrying about retirement, btw...by the time I retire at 65 (if I make it that long), I'll have well over $1M in the bank.

Starting next year, I'll be putting $500 a month in investments and do that for some 29 years. Plus, I'll also have a fully paid pension from the state. I'll end up with $500k plus pension plus other savings, IRAs, etc.

Sad thing is, people our age will need that much to retire on.

Good thing is, I'll probably be retired in Ireland and only come back to the USA to check on my winter home and visit family and friends.

by maxwell edison

I'll admit that I'm a FLAMING Libertarian. I'm passionate in my Libertarian beliefs which are founded upon and based on a strong belief in individual liberty. Not only will I admit it, but I'll proudly proclaim it from the highest mountain-top. I am a FLAMING Libertarian.

And "flaming" isn't, in this context, the same as flaming somebody. A flaming ___________ is a passionate person.

Flaming: very intense; a fiery temper; flaming passions.

Why is it, by the way, that a flaming liberal doesn't like to admit it, but a flaming anything else will?

And Justice Ginsburg is a she, not a he. Ruth Bader Ginsburg isn't, nor has she ever been a conservative (or a man, at least I don't think so). She is as liberal as they come, and there's nothing moderate about her. She was appointed to the Supreme Court in 1993 by President Bill Clinton. The Senate, at the time, was controlled by the Democrat party, not the Republicans. And the minority party never gets to chair a committee. Joseph Biden (Democrat from Delaware) was the committee chairman in 1993. And South Dakota Democrat Tom Daschle was the Senate Majority Leader.

I don't think you could have been more wrong -- and with absolutely everything in your message.

by jdclyde

it is so inconvienent when facts get in the way of a good story.

The idea that the party that is elected should compromise themselves to try to appease people that won't feel "unified" no matter how much you give them is insane to even be thought of.

Yes Max, that is dead nuts it. You get elected by the people of the United States Of America to please the wishes of the like minded majority that voted for you.

The FACT that no other candidate has EVER recieved more votes that Bush did is always somehow forgotten in the playing with facts on elections.

Last time it was complaining about the Electoral College and the FACT that it is what maintains individual STATES voice in government instead of a pure population in one state running the whole country. Bush got both the electoral AND the majority. Had to switch to something else to cry about.

by jck

"Yes Max, that is dead nuts it. You get elected by the people of the United States Of America to please the wishes of the like minded majority that voted for you."

Bush is also the candidate to be elected by the smallest percentage in history, being it was below 50% (over 500,000 votes less than Al Gore) of the popular vote. If your statement were accurate, Bush wouldn't have been president.

So, I guess you're gonna say it's alright for Bush to be in there even if all those people didn't like him huh?

I smell a double-standard.

(BTW, I hated Al Gore. Voted Harry Browne myself.)

Oh yeah....Bush...lowest 2nd term presidential rating in history...45%.

Guess the majority of people now think he is doing a sucky job too.

Off I go...gotta fight Visio.

by jck

Sorry about that. I got the name wrong. I told you I've been extremely busy today. My head is still inside two dozen Visio diagrams.

It was Stephen Breyer. He was considered a moderate who voted conservative on "critical issues" and had won brownie points when serving the Senate Judiciary committee. However after his supreme court confirmation, he's proved to be more of a "moderate liberal", although still balancing the court and often showing a "dry wit".

And yes, Hatch wasn't chair yet. He got that in 1995, not 1994. The Reps won it in 1994.

But, Hatch didn't contest Breyer's confirmation. He only stressed how he and Clinton didn't stand politically aligned.

You can go read Hatch's entire text here as he recommends Breyer:
http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/D?r103:2:./temp/~r103aWTI7h::

Now let's address flamingness, from the point of being "flaming" on a political issue...

You speak to liberalism as some flawed system, when the "conservative" system that a "conservative" president has implemented is running this country now into further deficit, putting forth a law enforcement mentality similar to McCarthyism (Patriot Act expansions proposed to implement the "if we think you're guilty, we just consider you guilty and search what we want" attitude), etc.

The "conservative" agenda isn't solving down the problems with this country. In fact, it's causing more than it solves.

So, how wrong can I be (even if I am such a liberal, as you say) in being against administrative and political ideologies that are running the deficit up, trying to take away rights provided by the Constitution against illegal search and seizure, and proposing to take even more money out of a Social Security system (through personal accounts implementation) that is already losing money at an alarming rate?

How can you validate an (conservative) ideology that is failing as bad as you suggest liberalism would if it were the controlling ideology?

Is it because it is what you want to believe? Hmmm?
you really a Libertarian?

***************************************

Now, let's take a look at where you're wrong:

you said:
"Ruth Bader Ginsburg isn't, nor has she ever been a conservative (or a man, at least I don't think so). She is as liberal as they come, and there's nothing moderate about her."

the BBC would disagree with you (about the neither having been nor being conservative):

"Despite originally joining the justices as a conservative, Ms O'Connor became a centrist who regularly voted for both liberal and conservative measures.

Her stance on critical issues such as abortion, which she views neither as unconstitutional nor as an unquestionable human right, has often guided the court.

The BBC's Justin Webb in Washington says a more reliable conservative could give the court a harder edge on social issues, which would affect the nature of American society for decades. "

So according to at least one major international news organization, you're wrong. She's a "centrist" who used to be a "conservative". I guess she got more moderate as a centrist, eh?

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/4642059.stm

yahoo news says she labelled herself as turned into a moderate conservative.

"Aware by her own account of the historical burden, she evolved into a moderate conservative, but more importantly, the consistent center of a fractured court."
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20050701/ap_on_go_su_co/scotus_o_connor

That's two. Guess we'll have to say they're both wrong in favor of you, right?

Looks like your "facts" are a little fractured there too, Max. You haven't been right either.

I suppose you're gonna say all news organizations are liberal socialists now so I can't use them as informative sources?

And btw...I voted for Harry Browne twice, so I guess this means you need to fear the Liberal bastards invading your party now? hahahahaha.

more research, man!!! more research!

by maxwell edison

First you say Ginsburg, but really meant Bryer. Then you correct yourself.......by talking about O'Conner? WHAT? And you suggest I don't have MY facts straight? Geesh, take the day off, dude.

But I'll say it again:

Ruth Bader Ginsburg isn't, nor has she ever been a conservative (or a man, at least I don't think so). She is as liberal as they come, and there's nothing moderate about her.

Do you want to try again? You have two down (O'Conner and Bryer), with seven more to go.

by maxwell edison

You've obviously not followed my messages over the months and years, but I've always maintained that today's Rupublicans are no more than baby-Democrats. Give me a Barry Goldwater conservative.

by maxwell edison

Will you please indulge me and define where you stand politically? Be specific, base your stances on principle, and use examples to illustrate. Don't be vague, but rather very precise so there's no misunderstanding. And how do you catagorize yourself?

by jck

1) I admitted my mistake in confusing Ginsburg for Breyer. I have been busy, since I'm doing my job and my boss' while he's on vacation and I'm in a rush when I type here. I have things to do and as I said had my head in a ton of Visio charts and a preliminary design document for a solid waste usage tracking system.

2) I then pointed out Breyer was a moderate with a conservative tilt before he went to the court, but has ended up becoming labelled as a "moderate liberal". That being said, it's ironic that he was pushed through by Reps and Dems so quickly without the Reps making sure he wasn't truly a liberal. If I remember right, only one Republican on the committee even questioned him on anything of more than a trivial nature.

3) I then pointed out how your view of Ginsburg neither being nor never having been a conservative is not only out of line with an American news report (from yahoo news), but those of the BBC reporting as well (A British agency not in the muck of the American press). So evidently, you do have the opinion that the press have no idea what they're talking about (one even stated that's what Ginsburg labelled herself) when it comes to conservativism and that you know everything about what defines a conservative.

I apologize...you are the authority on conservativism and the press has no idea of what they speak.

4) What have I been smoking? Nothing. If you've followed me for months and years, you'd realize that I've always said I drink Guinness. (Sorry, but I had to mock your rhetoric on your years of attendance here)

5) If you'd been attentive yourself for years, you'd have noticed...I haven't been here for years. So, don't expect me (having only been here 4 months) to know everything you've said for years.

6) Barry Goldwater...nice guy...talked to him on the ham radio several times years ago. I think his callsign was N7KUA.

7) Let me now answer your questions (kind of):

"Will you please indulge me and define where you stand politically? Be specific, base your stances on principle, and use examples to illustrate."

I vote based on capability, ideology, common sense and seeming to have some intelligence and leadership quality. I don't stand "politically", because political affiliation is another way of casting people into a mold of which most don't generally belong or fit.

In this country, we are all free-thinkers.

To call me a "conservative" would be out of line, because the party line in the current conservative view is that abortion should be illegal. Although I would not choose it for me and my other half (if I had one) unless I knew the pregnancy would kill her, I do not begin to dictate the morality, conscience or actions of others.

On the other hand, calling me a "liberal" is out of line because the liberal stance on affirmative action is that it is a tool that "levels the playing field". To me, that is a crock of sh*t. A level playing field (whether in the workplace, in attaining business/education loans, etc) is where people are evaluated on relevant criteria. If discrimination is happening, prosecute it to the full extent of the law. But, don't give a guy a job over another guy simply because of the color of his skin because it meets a "quota". Whether his skin is black or white...giving a job to someone because of their race is discrimination either way.

Plus in the primary system of voting, political affiliation limits voters as to whom they can vote for. For example, I thought in 1984 that Gary Hart was a much more capable candidate than either of the two major party candidates who won their party's primary (I didn't get to vote then). I've voted for Harry Browne in two elections because I thought he was far more articulate, had more valid points when it came to government reform, and held more principles in common with me than the other candidates. Unfortunately, he was not a Libertarian candidate in FL during the last election.

"And how do you catagorize yourself?"

I categorize myself as an American.

by maxwell edison

.
"Social Security will be saved or reformed only when it's taken completely away from the politicians, and you're allowed to keep the money yourself -- to do with as you think best.....proposing that you should be completely free from Social Security."

by maxwell edison

Your point number one: So you and I must agree that it's wrong for a government to take a dollar from the person who earned it, only to give it to a person who did not earn it? You and I agree that we should abolish all forms of welfare? You and I agree that we should abolish Social Security. You and I agree that we should never have a nationalized health care system?

Your point number two: Read what James Madison, the writer of those words, had to say about his term "general welfare":

"With respect to the two words ?general welfare,' I have always regarded them as qualified by the detail of powers connected with them. To take them in a literal and unlimited sense would be a metamorphosis of the Constitution into a character which there is a host of proofs was not contemplated by its creators."

"The powers delegated by the proposed Constitution to the Federal Government, are few and defined. Those which are to remain in the State Governments are numerous and indefinite. The former will be exercised principally on external objects, as war, peace, negotiation and foreign commerce; with which last the power of taxation will for the most part be connected. The powers reserved to the several States will extend to all the objects, which, in the ordinary course of affairs, concern the lives, liberties and properties of the people; and the internal order, improvement, and prosperity of the State."

- James Madison in Federalist Paper No. 45

Your point number three: Maybe I just missed the whole point since it spanned a couple of messages with someone else. Okay, I misunderstood what you intended.

Your point number four: I agree. One person, while exercising his individual liberty, may not infringe on the individual liberties of another. I thought that was implied. But if not, there ya' go. Your individual liberty stops at my nose -- or my bank account. I suppose we agree on this point as well -- in ALL cases.

But wait a minute. On one hand you espouse the "programs (that) are setup to help the needy". But on the other hand you say that you are, "vehemently opposed to the current form of our welfare system" I suppose it's the "current form" that gives you your wiggle room. Go back to point number one, and either agree or disagree with that basic statement: it's wrong for a government to take a dollar from the person who earned it, only to give it to a person who did not earn it.

And I, too, believe in what you called the "Jamestown belief system". What I'm opposed to, however, is a government that forces it. Do you agree or disagree?

by jck

to the point 1 reply:
the direction you're taking this is, again, extremist.

We should all pay to maintain the system. That's taxes. Taxes fund programs from roads to medical and what not. Do we eliminate them across the board? No.

But when the system is manipulated such that Halliburton *just happens* to be the only petroleum engineering firm staged to move into the Iraq, a BIG red flag goes up in my book since Vice-President Dick Cheney holds millions in shares still with them.

You can't tell me that Halliburton just "knew to be there" or "got lucky" that they put billions in equipment into a convenient place to be used nearest to Iraq.

As for welfare, that system has been morphed from a way to get you back onto your feet...to a way for people to never have to work again. You should never get a free-ride. Welfare, in my opinion, should become "workfare". There are enough menial labor jobs to be done at a federal, county, state and private level. Welfare people can be used to staff non-skill jobs to gain a job skill and make them productive again rather than live their days sittin around getting a free check.

As for the SS and NHS thing...no...I don't agree. Others have already paid into the system. The government owes all those people money. We have an obligation to pay them back. Then, we could eliminate it.

As for a national health service...in some aspects, it might be superior to what we have now if we do it right. But, how are you going to know if it never gets done? Just guesstimate it's not going to work? I know Australia's health system is pretty damn good from what all my friends down there tell me. At least, in Adelaide, Sydney and Perth it is.

your reply to point 2: So you're saying...the federal government is incapable of maintaining a guideline by which the general public can benefit?? I guess that means the Bill of Rights should be discarded?

your reply to "programs for the 'needy' ":
I oppose the abuse of those programs, i.e.- people I see collecting welfare in both the mainland and US territories because the government hasn't kept up with people, people who draw welfare from 2 different states in the mainland, etc.

"Programs for the needy" doesn't mean "programs set up for people to stay on all their lives". It means "programs to help people get back on their feet".

Currently, our system isn't doing that. It's handout-fare. And, I don't like it one bit.

As for the Jamestown belief: I oppose the military or police enforcement of it, but I think the policy should be written, as in the case of our US welfare, that no person on welfare shall collect compensation without having been assigned at a minimum any available, non-skilled labor to earn their pay.

Trust me, man...I see signs at Big Lots, McDonalds, Dollar General, 7-11, Wal-Mart, etc. They all need unskilled labor and pay money. Most welfare folks just don't want to work. They want a free ride. I think policy should be written to prevent that free ride.

by maxwell edison

.
....you both contradict yourself and misrepresent my positions. For example, I didn't say to eliminate all taxes and all government functions (roads). EARNED is the key word, here.

And it's not extremist to suggest that the government should not take a dollar from the person who earned it, only to give it to a person who didn't. That describes what America was intended to be, and always was before, that is, FDR started to push his socialist agenda. Any other option is socialism, to some degree. I want socialism to NO degree. When you start to support "some" government transfer of wealth, then it only becomes a matter of degree.

If John has no money, and he has no intention of earning his own money, or even if he doesn't have the capicity to earn his own money, and I give him some of mine out of the goodness of my heart, it's charity. If he takes it from me against my will, it's theft. If the government takes it against my will so they can give it to John, it's socialism. Deny it all you want, but that's what it is. Socialism, to some degree. You have to either admit you want to live in a socialist and collectivist society, at least to some degree, or you don't.

The Bill of Rights discarded? What in the hell are you talking about. Where did you pull that one from? How about reinstating the Bill of rights and quit infringing on people's guaranteed rights. Transferring wealth from one person to another violates, in my opinion, the fourth amendment, "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable..........seizures, shall not be violated..........", and the fifth amendment, ".....nor shall private property (money) be taken for public use (social programs), without just compensation."

Your Jamestown thing - you don't want enforcement of it, but you want written policy. Yea, right.

Social Security:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=177209&messageID=1801858

by jdclyde

"Halliburton just "knew to be there".

You ARE aware that William Jefferson Clinton also gave Halliburton a "no-bid" contract? (this is before there WAS a Vice-President Dick Cheney) ?:|

This isn't just the latest scheme on the part of the Bush administration, or does blind Bush hate keep you from seeing that part of the story? It doesn't fit with the negative picture your painting so we will convenently leave that part out..... :_|

by maxwell edison

Regarding the Halliburton "no-bid" contract in question, Halliburton was the only company in the United States with a system in place to deliver what was being asked. No other company even attempted to place a bid on that contract.

?We are the only company in the United States that had the kind of systems in place, people in place, contracts in place, to do that kind of thing,? says Chuck Dominy, Halliburton?s vice president for government affairs.

Prove it, you might ask? Well, since a person can't prove a negative, it's up to you to prove the positive. Since I claim that no other company even placed a bid, it falls upon you to prove that another company DID place a bid. Show me just one company that placed a competing bid. Show me just one company that cried foul. You can't. The only ones crying foul are the divisive and partisan Democrats, who are hell-bent on discrediting the Bush administration and further dividing the country for their own self-gain. And they don't care if they have to mislead the public to do it.

(Maybe the contract should have been given to a French company. After all, the French did have experience providing war support to the Iraqis.)

by montgomery gator

She will make an excellent replacement for O'Connor. She is a pro-business strict constructionalist, who believes in the original intent of the Founding Fathers. She probably would have voted against that decision that took away property rights, since her judicial philosophy is similar to Justices Scalia and Thomas. Plus, the thought of her on the Supreme Court will make Ted Kennedy's bloated head turn even redder with anger and explode!!!

by jck

Man...you might have just converted me to a conservative!!!! Blow up Uncle Ted "Where's my drink?!?!??" Kennedy? That's a dream come true!

WEEEEEEEELL DOGGIES!!!!!

(so can I join and get my pitchfork and chew some grass and sing some hymns now?)

by jdclyde

but there is always room up on the porch!

Shoot dang, but anything that would have that affect on Kennedy can't be a bad thing! Him, Sharpton, and Rangle all have hijacked the whole process and perverted it so badly that it is a disgrace.

by montgomery gator

I am 41, and I would be in the middle group that would have reduced benefits and reduced taxes under your suggestion. We need to get it done as soon as possible, before I am in the plus-50 group (or whatever age is decided) that will have no change. I want lower taxes and lower SS benefits, so I can invest the money myself and control my own destiny, not be subservient to a socialist government plan.

by jdclyde

And how many people in the US VOTED for Bush? Was there more than 45% of the total population that voted against him?

The percentage of people that don't vote throws a lot of that talk right out the window.

The Anti-Bushers will say unsatitisfactory no matter what he does.

The poles mean nothing as 86% of all statistics are incorrect! :^O

by beads

Though interesting this board can't even agree on what constitutes:

A.) A Conservative.

B.) A Moderate - in America? Should be on Federal endangered species list by now.

C.) A Liberal

Though we have heard basically from the Libertarian side of the political argument. A third party would help Americans to some degree.

- beads

by jck

Where's that source? I want you to quote the GAO for the expenditure ;)

by jck

************************
Your elimination of "socialism" has a far more reaching effect that you must realize.

If you eliminate giving one man's dollar to another man, we'd have no consistent roads, buses, or law enforcement. Cause I guarantee you, your local police, roads, bus system, etc., are probably funded partially by people from NYC, LA, Chicago, Houston, Philadelphia and other large metros.

So I tell you what. Keep your dollars. I beg you. And keep your crime and bad roads there too. I'll gladly pay into a system and try to move for change to improve it, while you hoard your pennies.
******************************
As for John...you make John get off his arse and work or he gets no money and starves. If he commits a crime stealing money and goes to prison, he works in prison. If he doesn't work in prison, he starves.

Hunger is a big motivator. And if he steals in prison, he'll learn about real punishment.
**********************************
The Bill of Rights is a guideline. It does not set specific example. You seem to disavow the need for the federal government to delineate law at any specific level, and therefore I assume that your belief is that states should only delineate anything other than basic rights and that federal courts should not be the all-determining legal body when it comes to more than a basic right.
**********************
As for violations of the 4th Amendment, I love how you:

1) read "money" in there as property. Money was not considered property when that was written. That's an invalid assertion.

2) how you left "...search and..." out before "seizure". prohibiting "unreasonable search and seizure" was written in because of the British often entering homes without purpose, sacking them, and taking possessions in the process. It wasn't written as a financial control...it was written as a means to control law enforcement/military from making unwarranted entry into a home.
*************************
As for the Jamestown thing, it's not that I don't want it enforced...I specifically said "I oppose the military or police enforcement of it,...".

Simply put (for your sake), establishment of law, policy or regulation is first enforceable by within the appropriate court jurisdiction. At a time which the court deems the violator has not complied with court order, the court can *then* take action by use of pecuniary, other legal, and even physical means if necessary.

It would be silly to go and institute a policy then just send the police out any time someone sat on their ass and starved. If they robbed someone, that is a criminal matter to be dealt with by the police.

by jdclyde

Had you READ what I said, it was STATISTICS are full of sh!t. Statistics can be MADE to support or oppose just about anything you want and they don't mean crap.

That is why NO ONE should base their oppinion OR what they do or don't do around a cussed pole!

The only pole that is worth paying ANY attention to is the one up at the local pealer joint!

by jdclyde

Do you go to rallies? Where? (don't see much of that sort of thing here in Mi)

What kind of car do you drive? Or are you a public transit kind of guy? Or does commuting force the choice?

What do YOU do to make a difference?
What do you recommend REAL everyday people do to make a difference?

Not an attack, just real questions.

by jck

I would think the North Pole is valuable too ;)

Besides, I wouldn't wanna be near a peeler joint pole after some of those girls have been on it.

by maxwell edison

Gee, I replied to your Al Gore comment, who ran in the 2000 election, and I asked you who you voted for in the 2004 election. Get a clue, dude. But to "indulge you", pick an election, any election, and let us know who you voted for in 2004. Better yet, tell us about all of them, federal, state and local.

by maxwell edison

You know as well as I do that I separate necessary government infrastructure type of expenditures, such as roads, police and fire, the military, and so on, from the myriad of transfer-of-wealth social programs to which I was really referring.

But disingenuous, coy and evasive is thy name; and disingenuous, coy and evasive shall you be.

by maxwell edison

Here is what you said:

"...your (my) view of Ginsburg neither being nor never having been a conservative is not only out of line with an American news report (from yahoo news), but those of the BBC reporting as well (A British agency not in the muck of the American press). So evidently, you do have the opinion that the press have no idea what they're talking about (one even stated that's what Ginsburg labelled herself) when it comes to conservativism and that you know everything about what defines a conservative."

However, the "news reports" you cited were talking about Justice O'Conner, not Justice Ginsburg. THEY WERE TALKING ABOUT O'CONNER!

How plain can I make that?

Geesh, overworked indeed.

by jck

1) Al Sharpton - Camera hog, sensationalist, media darling, about as much of a man of God as Charles Manson. He feigns reverence to keep in the good graces of older blacks who innocently send him their food money so he can buy expensive watches and nice suits.

2) (Charles?) Rangle - Not as bad as Al Sharpton, but worse than Kwiesi Mfume (former congressman, now head of the NAACP).

3) Kweisi Mfume - The guy used to be quite a congressman. He had a level head. I guess taking over the NAACP would be like Laura Bush running the Neo-Nazis. If you don't do what your constituency wants, they'll ostracize you.

4) Ted Kennedy - This guy has done about as much for his constituency in Massachusetts as Captain Kangaroo has done to find a cure for AIDS. NOTHING. He's riding on the name of his dead relatives who were both womanizing spoiled rich boys too. Ted needs to retire to be the taste-tester for Tanqueray or Smirnoff so he can assure quality martinis and cosmopolitans.

5) Bill Clinton - A real arsehole for cheating on his wife, but more of a leader than we've seen in decades.

Who else can I dog on? Is Newt fair game now? :D

by jck

because I think you casting "liberalism" as "socialism" would be akin to me labelling "conservativism" to being "victorian" or a "police-state mentality". You're comparing an ideology to the extremist point of it's extent, not what its true incarnation in the system today.

Not to mention, "socialism" ties to 2 things in the modern era:
1) the old Soviet Union
2) France, who a lot of Americans have a dislike for at the current time.

That makes for a great scare tactic.

Your radical taxonomy seems very disingenuous to me. Hence, why I take most of your allegories to be quiet daft and reply in kind.

by maxwell edison

.
....trying to nail Jell-O to the wall.

I asked about your voting preference and political categorization to show your inconsistencies. You claim to have voted for the Libertarian candidate, Harry Browne, not once, but twice. (That must have been in 2000 and 1996.) However, you totally dismiss my position concerning transfer-of-wealth social programs as unrealistic and extreme. But Harry Browne espoused THE VERY SAME THING - except more of it. Where I would cut all such social programs by only 80 to 90 percent, and do it gradually, over time, Harry Brown espoused cutting them 100 percent and immediately.

And Harry Browne wasn't on the ballot in Florida -- or anywhere -- in 2004, because he wasn't the Libertarian candidate in 2004. Michael Badnarik was.

So if you voted for Harry Browne, not once, but twice, because, as you said, "he had more valid points when it came to government reform, and held more principles in common with (you) than the other candidates", then you must have voted for Michael Badnarik, who is very consistent in his views with Harry Browne -- AND AGREE WITH ME. But you dismiss my views as extreme and unrealistic. Go figure.

And go have some Jell-O

by jck

Again...I've said it many times before, so I guess you haven't been watching what I say either.

I voted for John Kerry for US President.

As for the other elections I remember, since it's been almost a year.

I voted for Ginny Brown-Waite for my local rep.

I voted for Bill Nelson

I won't go into what county elections because I don't want people to know where I live, other than north of Tampa.

As for answering the Al Gore comment...I stated I hated Al Gore and that I voted Libertarian...what warrants a reply in the first place?

by jck

I can't think straight...oh well.

Sorry man...my bad...my brain is mush.

I'll be back later this week or something when I am coherent. Like I said...I fly through these posts...and I don't have time...gotta have this entire design by Monday along with a FTP file transfer interface.

sucks being senior programmer and backup to the IS department head.

by jck

Whomever the Libertarian candidate was...I saw *nothing* of him on any outlet available. Hence, I'm not going to vote for a candidate who was totally unknown to me.

I saw a LOT of Harry Browne on C-SPAN and heard him talk. I never saw him say "I will do away with all socialist programs immediately."

I did see him say he'd eliminate the IRS immediately. That made sense to me, since the IRS needs to be abolished and all tax accounting should be handled anyways by the GAO. The IRS is an unnecessary institution.

Anyways...I'm going to get back to work...again...I got tons to do and 3 days to get it done.

I'll be back when I can read English again...and not just Visual Basic .NET.

by maxwell edison

.
No, his call-sign was not N7KUA, but rather K7UGA. And he died in 1998, was pretty much out of contact since the late 80s because of a stroke he suffered, so you must have talked to him a couple of decades ago, not a few years ago.(Unless there was some sort of Divine intervention.)

But regardless, what do you think about his views and his version of conservative politics?

His 1964 presidential platform would suit me just fine if applied today.

by jck

I got my ham license when I was...17 I think. So, it was about 20 years ago.

by jck

The Russians? The Martians?

Seriously, man. I know who said it. It's the same guy who said:
***************************************
"In fact, there's very little difference between them (supreme court nominees) -- just as there's very little difference between Republican judges Anthony Kennedy and David Souter on the one hand, and Democrats Stephen Breyer and Ruth Ginsberg on the other.

Mr. Bush, for example, says he'll appoint "strict constructionists" to the bench. But in Texas he has appointed a number of activist judges -- the very kind Republicans claim to oppose.

All we want from a Supreme Court justice is the ability to read and understand the plain words of the Constitution. When the First Amendment says "Congress shall make no law ... abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press" that's what it means -- and thus it is unconstitutional to censor the Internet, prohibit tobacco advertising, or limit political advocacy. When the Second Amendment says, "the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed," that's what it means -- and thus all the gun-control laws on the books are unconstitutional.

You will get Supreme Court justices who will honor the Constitution and restore your liberty only when you get a president who believes more in your liberty than he does in big government. So we'd better get started now doing whatever is necessary to elect such a President -- no matter how long you think it might take."
***************************************
See...that makes a lot of sense there. Especially the part about abridging 1st and 2nd Amendment rights.

I gotta go.

by av .

Nothing makes me right and you wrong or vice-versa except your opinion that there has to be a right or wrong position. I agree that a supreme court justice should interpret the constitution and not read into it something that is not there. Bipartisan support to me means that both parties are comfortable working with a given candidate and that their ideas will be represented by that candidate. No one is giving in. The candidate's views are acceptable to both sides.

You truly have a very black and white way of looking at things. The eminent domain ruling was a victory for big money. It isn't fair to someone of modest means. A moderate lawmaker would try to be fair to both sides by defining the ruling to apply only in certain instances. For a road maybe where all benefit, not a strip mall so one developer gets rich. Other lawmakers have recently introduced legislation to curtail the ruling by eliminating federal tax dollars from funding such projects. Pro-choice is a moderate position on abortion. The right would ban abortion altogether and the left would have abortion on demand with no restrictions. A moderate would try to fix the current SS system without throwing the current system out the window. Privatization will not make SS solvent. The core principles for a moderate are to represent mainstream America and create a win-win situation.

The best interest of the country is to have a government that doesn't waste its time fighting because of partisan politics. You say you want to slash 80-90% of the social programs, (Im with you here) but say, maybe I don't. The only way to keep us both happy is in the middle of those two opinions. You would get some of what you want, I would get some of what I want.

Bush is a polarizing figure. He is arrogant, rigid and undiplomatic. Even before the 2004 election, he didn't make very many friends around the world. We are stuck in Iraq. Fiscally, he is a horror. Maybe he didnt create all of the problems, but he hasn't done anything right to fix them. The majority of Americans want to fix SS, but don't want their SS revamped as he suggests. He is still stumping to sell his idea anyway. The Democrats say they are willing to work with him on SS without the private accounts. Its true, Democrats have polarized our government in response to Bushs policies. They are all responsible for the dog and pony show that is going on now.

As for the UN, I have to agree it is just a hotbed for corruption. Its an ineffective institution and has done little to solve Africas problems. I think rather than dissolve it though, it needs new leadership and a total overhaul. John Bolton doesnt have the diplomatic skills necessary to bring about that change.

I have my principles, Maxwell, but Im not partisan because I dont believe that most of our government officials have any honesty or integrity, Democrats or Republicans. I would like to think that they are doing the work of the people, but every day I read about them enriching themselves and personal interests instead. I vote for the person who is the lesser of two evils and it doesnt matter what party they are affiliated with.

by maxwell edison

First of all, the last national election suggested that the majority of people want some sort of self-control over their own retirement, regardless of your claims to the contrary. Moreover, the results of a most recent Zogby poll found similar sentiment. The bush plan was supported by 52 percent, while opposed by only 40 percent. Your claims that most Americans don't favor some sort of privatization simply won't hold up under the slightest bit of scrutiny.

More from the poll results (cut and pasted):

The thing that is compelling in this poll is that this is the response you get when you use a positive approach on Social Security reform," Mr. Zogby said. "If you use the 'Chicken Little, sky-is-falling' approach, then voters understand that something has to be done, but don't see the connection between personal accounts and fundamental reform of Social Security.

There are a large number of voters, especially those under 50, who don't think they are getting the best possible deal from Social Security," he said.

As in past surveys on the president's personal-accounts proposal, strongest support comes from younger voters under age 30, who embrace the idea by a margin of 66 percent to 23 percent.

Support declines somewhat among voters between 30 and 50, with 58 percent in favor versus 37 percent who oppose it.

Voters over 65 oppose personal accounts 52 percent to 40 percent and those over 70 oppose them by 55 percent to 38 percent.

The survey also contained a warning for the Democrats about how their opposition to any reform of the Social Security system is playing with the electorate.

By an overwhelming 70-22 percent margin, voters believe that opponents of President Bush's proposals for Social Security reform have an obligation to put out their own plan for reforming the program," including 55 percent of Democratic voters, Mr. Zogby said in a report of his findings.

Among supporters, the most popular reason for supporting private accounts was, "It's my money; I should control it," Mr. Zogby said. "This was true for every group except African-Americans, who chose inheritability as their biggest reason for supporting accounts.

The poll's results suggested that Mr. Bush's proposal would be much more popular if he focused "on the points in this poll," Mr. Zogby said in an interview.

Nobody can understand or relate to the system's insolvency in 2043. But it wins a majority when the issue is raised as a matter of choice and as a positive opportunity," he said. "If it's pitted as just Social Security reform because it is becoming insolvent, that's not enough.

Among the poll's other findings:

?Support was strongest (57 percent to 36 percent) in the "red states" that Mr. Bush carried in his 2004 re-election. Support split more evenly (48 percent to 44 percent) in the Democratic "blue states" that Sen. John Kerry won.

?Voters by 62 percent to 30 percent remained deeply skeptical about Social Security's promise to pay future benefits. Skepticism was highest among younger voters, with more than 70 percent saying they doubted that the system would be able to pay their benefits when they reached retirement age.

The poll of 1,006 likely voters was conducted May 23-25 and has a margin of error of 3.2 percentage points.

http://washingtontimes.com/national/20050530-094706-3415r.htm

Why do you continue to post something that's not true? It's a common ploy to put forth false truths, but people are starting to get wise to such tactics. And you claim to be based on principle? Please, spare me.

by maxwell edison

Sure, I'll admit it. However, I see it as firmly based on principle. I am absolutely convinced, for example, that transfer-of-wealth programs are not only dead wrong, but harmful to a nation. Why would I want to compromise those principles just to appease someone else who disagrees? It's like being a little bit pregnant as a compromise. It's like stealing only a little bit as a "moderate" compromise.

On abortion, if a person views this as taking a life, how can that be moderated? It's black and white; no in-between. On the death penalty, it's black and white, no in-between. (I oppose both abortion and the death penalty, by the way. Both are taking a life.)

I'm a firm believer in letting each and every person set his own standards for living, as long as they don't infringe on others. You live up to your standards, and I will not infringe on you; and I'll live up to mine, and expect the same in return. When your "moderate" views infringe on the liberties of others, they're anything but moderate.

And your conditional moderate position for taking a person's personal property is abhorrent to me. Are you suggesting it's okay to take a millionaire's house, but not the average guys? To even suggest that a government can take anyone's house for private developing is beyond my ability to comprehend. And we're not talking about for a road, and you know it.

You are not consistent in your views. You have different principles for different people. And that's just wrong in my eyes. And you try to force your "right" on me. Well go away. Don't infringe on me.

by maxwell edison

I'm sick of people who attempt to impose their will on others, infringing on their right to self-responsibility and self-determination. Yea, it's as black and white as that. Infringing a little bit or only under certain circumstances in the name of moderation just doesn't cut it.

by tomsal

As I largely agree with everything you said about SS.

It's bunk, its a scam, its a con.

by oz_media

There is no way you can offer a rational or open minded comment here.

As you said very recently, "I will believe President Bush over any and all middle-east leaders, the Russians, the French, the Germans, and the entire American Democrat Party; you don't."

So how can you converse rationally over something when you refuse to believe the other side and won't offer it your attention?

"I'm an American who will admit that I prefer to put American interests over and above those of any other nation; you're not."

So you also admit that you only prefer to place GWB's (not America's) interests above all others. You obviously don't believe what half of American's feel their best interests are either, just those that follow your own cause.

by oz_media

Those were your recent words.

So by discussing YOUR views compared to democratic ones, you simply cannot be rational or informed in your comments, according to those quotes.

Plus, nobody would be able to offer an opinion you could logically counter, as you don't believe Democratic veiws.

Or you could just as easily run through the discussion and just post 'BS' to every post here that you don't favour.

Just some light hearted pokes, When you post to TR, "Anything you post can and will be used against you in a post of another's choice."
:D

by oz_media

I edited the last sentence of the last post as it was broken from edits and didn't make sense.

by av .

I've seen the polls, but I just don't see people beating their chests asking for SS reform. People know SS will one day run out of money, but I think other issues are more at the forefront - like heathcare and jobs and of course terrorism again now that London was bombed. Bush's plan is a non-starter at this point. Otherwise, we would see lots of media coverage that would say differently.

I don't like transfer of wealth programs either. Some of it is necessary for the needy. For that we should all give. No pork barrel stuff though. Abortion can be moderated. If the mother's life is at stake, rape, birth defects. Whose life is more important? Mother or child? I think a woman should have a choice whether she wants to give birth or not. Its a personal decision a woman has to make and shouldn't be a matter for the government to decide. The death penalty? Considered on a case by case basis just like it is.

You said "I'm a firm believer in letting each and every person set his own standards for living, as long as they don't infringe on others." Are you kidding! Are you saying live and let live? Thats a very liberal, moderate statement for you.

Do you actually think I think its ok to take anyone's house? My one exception is if it is for public good. A road or train that absolutely has to be built over your property. I think they should pay for pain and suffering as well as top dollar for your property in that case. Definitely not for a strip mall or private investor. I'm not saying its ok to take anyone's house, rich or poor. I'm saying a millionaire developer shouldn't be able to take your house if he wants to build a strip mall that will generate more tax dollars than you, the poor person, are currently paying to the local government. Its urban renewal under the guise of eminent domain.

I don't like people that impose their will on others either; thats why I don't like the government. I know you well enough from this forum to know that no one will ever impose their will on you. There is only one way with you, and thats your way.

by oz_media

So your bold and clear statements, are quoted out of context now?

Perhapse the rest of the post would clear up how you really feel about Democrats and their opinions compared to your faith in Bush?

"I believe President Bush; you don't.

I trust President Bush; you don't.

I give President Bush the benefit of the doubt; you don't.

I believe that President Bush has acted, and is still acting on the best interest of the United States; you don't.

I will believe President Bush over any and all middle-east leaders, the Russians, the French, the Germans, and the entire American Democrat Party; you don't.

I'm an American who will admit that I prefer to put American interests over and above those of any other nation; you're not.

You believe that the whole world could live together as one big happy family; I don't.

We'll never agree or find common ground in this regard. So what else is new?"

But I suppose where you say, [b]'"I will believe President Bush over[/b] any and all middle-east leaders, the Russians, the French, the Germans, and [b]the entire American Democrat Party;[/b] you don't.

[b]I'm an American who will admit that I prefer to put American interests over and above those of any other nation;[/b] you're not."

You constantly make false assertions (a nice way of saying you lie continually) of what I believe and don't believe in, and you KNOW very well how off base you are.

Your comments clearly state, quite hipocritically, that you DON'T believe a word democrats say, you believe in BUSH all the way, but you THINK you place Americas interests before your own. This is impossible if you are merely paying attention to half of America's views or comments.

I agree, it is completely out of context...if we were talking about men's swim shorts in Brazil of course. but we aren't.

This is a discussion about democratic views, you have offered many strong assertions and even disagreed with several democratic views, expecting others to at least consider your point, yet you openly do NOT do the same with their views at all.

In fact you VERY clearly say that you DON'T believe "the entire democratic party." In case tyou are new to TR, this would mean you also don't believe any democrats opinion when compared to Bush's.

So why would someone expressing their support of Democratic views even THINK that you would consider their view or offer a nonbiased or slightly reasoned/rational reply if you don't believe a word they say? Any comment you offer is only a view from your side with no consideration for the pack of lies you are replying to.

If nearly half of your country's citizens (even if it was only only 15%) believe in democratic solutions and feel democratic resolutions are in the best interest of America, how can you claim you take America's best interests into mind, when you refuse to listen to your fellowman's wishes?

You merely believe what a portion of your population agrees is best for America. The rest are all not worth your consideration.

In order to determine what's best for AMERICA not just your ideals of America, you would need to listen to all views of America's people. Your president even claims to do this and seems to do a much more open minded job of it than you.

Hypocrisy:

1. The practice of professing beliefs, feelings, or virtues that one does not hold or possess; falseness.
2. An act or instance of such falseness.

And yet you still continue to sidle out by claiming you are misquoted, misunderstood and taken out of context all the time.

At least you do when it's convenient, a lot like the Republican administration that you bow to faithfully I suppose.

You want to be seen as this all caring American who only has everyone's best interests in mind and the good of America unbiasedly considered before forming your ever so carefully researched political opinions. But how can you deem it knowledge if half of what you read goes without any consderation

Then you want to be seen as someone who is staunchly right wing suportive and that doesn't buy anything the rest of the country has to say unless it agrees with your own views, or else you will take Bush's word over ANY comment or beliefs of the Democratic party, thus uncluding Democrats, or a large portion of your population.

No matter how you spin it, it has the same result. You only believe Republican views as stated by your president and all else is unbelievable BS.

You can't jump over the fence then sit in he middle, then jump back on your side again before jumping back into the middle.

You are either a heartless, uncaring, single visioned repulbican supporter that has no consideration for anything unrepublican, or you do extend your attention to hearing and considering democratic views. This would make your comments quoted above, complete lies too.

Perhaps for once you could make yourself clear and help us believe in your solid 'core values' once and for all. You either believ in Democratic viewpoints or simply look and listen to your own or those which support your own.

Otherwise, why should anyone consider a single comment you make without just tossing it out as Republican righty BS that isn't worth believing in? Or simply another one of Max's one-sided disingenious viewpoints.

Ws that a long enough explanation, or will you stil continue to make false asssertions about my beliefs and claim that's not what you said, when quoted in full context.

Or perhaps you simply don't know how to make a point without being misunderstood because only a republican would understand, as anyone else is full of lies?

by maxwell edison

Sure, I want things to go "my way" -- as it pertains to my life, my future, etc. I freely admit it. But I admit it with a distinct qualification. I want things to go my way for me; but I don't presume to force "my way" on others. If you don't include the very important "for me" qualifier, then you're grossly misrepresenting my position.

Moreover, I give absolutely everyone else the same consideration. I don't presume to force "my way" on you or anyone else. In the case of transfer of wealth programs, which is primarily what we're talking about here, a proponent of such programs must force "their way" on me, and that's when they have gone too far.

I'm absolutely amazed at the number of discussions I've had in this regard, but people continually misrepresent my position by eliminating that very simple, but very important, distinction. And you just did it again.

I can only surmise that people do it because they can't present a reasonable argument against it.

Another misrepresentation I'm often met with is when people won't make the very important distinction between taxes that pay for the transfer of wealth programs versus the taxes that pay for the necessary infrastructures, such as roads, police, national defense, etc. And again, I suppose people can't present a reasonable argument against my position, so they must misrepresent it.

Would you like to try again to persent a vaild and reasonable argument against my position without misrepresenting it, and by also providing the basis on which the argument is built? By what authority, for example, do you presume to force your way on me and/or prevent me from living my life my way if I don't infringe on you?

If you can present such an argument, you would be the first to do it.

by oz_media

"Moreover, I give absolutely everyone else the same consideration. I don't presume to force "my way" on you or anyone else. In the case of transfer of wealth programs, which is primarily what we're talking about here, a proponent of such programs must force "their way" on me, and that's when they have gone too far."

"I will believe President Bush over any and all middle-east leaders, the Russians, the French, the Germans, and the entire American Democrat Party"

Which is it, Maxwell? You either consider them is discount them as Democrats an dtherefore unbelievable. Is THAT what yout thinj consideration is? Do you listen but dismiss with out consideration, or do you consider the views and deem them possibly viable points regardless of what Bush says?

by av .

I want things to go "my way" too, but I realize that I'm not always going to get "my way." I also realize that there are many ways to look at any issue. It depends on what side of the issue you sit.

The truth is, in my opinion, we have very little control over how our tax dollars are spent. Very little is spent on infrastructure and alot is spent on entitlement programs. Aside from calling or writing your representatives, a regular person has very little control over how their tax dollars are spent. A pet peeve of mine is that the government will pass a humongous bill that is supposed to be for one purpose and then all of our legislators will throw in their special pork barrel projects, like a museum to honor the wild turkey for $2mil and it isn't even questioned.

"I'm absolutely amazed at the number of discussions I've had in this regard, but people continually misrepresent my position by eliminating that very simple, but very important, distinction. And you just did it again. I can only surmise that people do it because they can't present a reasonable argument against it."

I'm not trying to force my opinion on you. I'm just expressing a different point of view that maybe doesn't coincide with what you think is right. You shouldn't be amazed at the number of times this has happened, you have very strong views on just about everything. The truth is, there is no argument that will ever change your mind. Thats ok. I have my opinions too, but I'm a bit more flexible than you.

This discussion is closed to new replies.