Discussion Locked

UH OH! Canada has done it now!

0 helpful
30 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Today I was watching the Queens visit to Alberta for it's Centennial celebration, renaming of the Alberta Provincial Musem to Ablerta's Royal Museum etc. A nice 'walkabout', spectators line the gardens and surrounding area, very few visible police or security and no 12' high steel fences lining the way as she strolled around, shook hands, spoke with MANY children and took flowers from them with her usual grace and courtesy.

At one point I found myself reflecting on a past discussion about the Pledge of Allegiance being said in different languages in the US and how outspoken SOME people were about how disgraceful it was, and one young mans father removing him from classes during that period.

In Alberta they stood to sing Oh Canada and it was introduced as :
Please all rise for the singing of our national anthem, feel free to sing in the [b]language of your choice.[/b]"

So I can only say, this will be turmoil! How can they possibly sing Oh Canada in German, French, Japanese, Hindi etc.? Remeber this isn't Ottawa or Quebec, but Alberta.

Haven't heard anyone complain YET, but I am waiting with baited breath. ;)

30 replies

by jdclyde

(spoken in my best Dana Carvy/little church lady voice)

Glad this went off so nicely.

Question, why weren't they singing "god save the queen" or something? Or was that on a different day? Sorry, not up on my royalty protocols.

by oz_media

When she first arrived at the Museum, they had the mounties, bands, choirs etc. all playing God Save The Queen.

But this IS Canada and the Crown sing the national anthem, in front of a 20' high portrait of the queen of course.

But it was a really cool celebration actually, you really get an idea of what dignity and grace does for a representative, instead of the mudslinging and a few baby-kissing poses for the cameras that we see from our politicians.

For an old lady she sure has done a lot of work and has a natural civility surrounding everything she does.

by eteller

Nice to see some authority figure respected for a change.

Sorry to hear the "choose your language" deal.

Who said; "A house, divided against itself, cannot stand."?

There must be some core components that everyone adheres to or anarchy results.

by itgirli

...in exactly how many languages is that song known? And how would it sound in that clicking tongue language?

by oz_media

The option is yours and nobody has even raised an eyebrow over it. Canada is very multicultural and that's what has given Canadians their strength. We thrive on ethnic diversity, rather than shun it.

by guggs

I would be insulted, but not the least bit surprised if other language versions of the Canadian national anthem officially existed.

I was born & raised in Canada, but moved to the US about 13 years ago. There was an official french version when I left, & that's because french is the "official" second language there.

Over the years, Canada's values have become watered down. So much so that the RCMP had created a second set of uniforms for their siek officers.

I don't really care to go into detail, so I'll just say what I've been saying for many years...when you move to a country, you MUST assimilate to their way of life, not force them to do things your way. It's ok to keep your history, culture, beliefs, etc... but when in rome, do as the romans (within reason).

by oz_media

British commonwealth and America are two different places, with your mindset, you have definitely made the best choice for your needs and expectations.

Our country is what it is today BECAUSE of the diversity we embrace.

I agree with you to some extent, IF you come here form YOUR country and expect to carry an illeagle knife because in YOUR country it is legal, then too bad.

If you want to come here and become Canadian that's your choice, BECOME canadian then.

But what language your country is respected in is irrelevant. It's not the words nor the language it's the belief in a common goal.

Does it matter what language someone says they love and adore you in? It shouldn't, as it is the intent of the words and not the words themselves that count.

As for the Sikhs, the RCMP had to create a NEW uniform? They just accepted the wearing or the turban into the ranks.

Should they now discriminate religion and language? These men and women want to serve and protect the people of Canada and uphold its laws, which may be more than you did as a Canadian anyway. Are you now a US citizen? Do you now have a US flag on your lawn? Do you speak with a drawl and sing the US national Anthem in a US accent too? Have you assimilated and become one with the Borg?

They are not knocking doors and preaching their religion hoping that OTHER mounties will start wearing a turban too.

Like I said, you picked the right move.

by guggs

...I'm not trying to bash any race, religion, etc... I'm simply disgusted that the country changed it's standards & laws for a group of people. I'm sure that there are other examples of this, but this is the only one that comes to mind at the moment.

And yes:
They created a new uniform just for them including the turban.

They changed the laws so that ANY sikh can legally carry their "cerimonial" dagger anywhere.

I speak another language in addition to english (no, it's not french). When my parents emmigrated to Canada, they were held to certain standards and were expected to become Canadian (which they did), but things have changed alot since then.

It's not right to leave one country because of a war or hate, and move to another country bringing with you that same war & hate.

As for the language thing, I strongly believe that one should retain their language, heritage, customs, religion, beliefs, history, and in short, everything to do with who they are, but don't try to change the new country into the old country by bringing your "baggage" with you.

When in school (many, many, years ago), I'm sure I could've sang "Oh Canada" in my "Mother" tongue if I wanted to. I was fluent enough to do so, but I didn't. And if I wanted to, I'd have done it quietly to myself. Out of respect to those around you and to your country, you speak (or sing) in the language that everybody understands. When you're in a group of "your people", then it's perfectly acceptable to communicate in your own language since you will not be showing any disrespect by doing so.

by Member 25348569

if you sing their national anthem in it. You can sing "God save the Queen" as well. I don't mind.

You might even get a grant from Lambeth Council! (English joke, don't worry)

Neil :D

by oz_media

Gog maboth ack Canada!

Ouse hamint ingh naruh libe!

Nobody would even bat an eye. The words mean nothing when the end result is the same, praise the nation. People don't care who you are or where you are from, nobody cares what language you speak, who you sleep with, what color you are, what foods you eat, what you wear etc. If you are a citizen of Canada, you are Canadian.

Somethng you would have to experience to understand I suppose, it's the same thing in ANY country I've been in, and at one time there were many, except America where (for the most part) you are expected to be an English speaking Christian.

by eteller

now that hits the nail perfectly on the head. Respect for the country YOU have chosen to move to.

by oz_media

You speak but one language, you are an immigrant who is trying to learn a very hard language and customs of a new land.

In order for you to show your support for the country and your pride in the country you must first of all learn English? Otherwise you should stay home and study the language?

Now you MUST be American!

by eteller

and am sick of my money, my time and my life being taken away by illegals such as what is happening in LA hospitals, they are turning away American citizens to treat the illegals who freely admit they are here illegally. Now, I'm not a jerk, a sick kid is a sick kid anywhere and a medical emergency is a medical emergency anywhere. however, these people take hours long bus rides and sit in the ER's of the US and refuse to pay. A quote from one woman there in the waitign room: You have so much money here in America, we have nothing". Oh sure, so come "steal" our services. This is terrible in the southwestern states. How would you feel if your kid had a fever but had to wait in line while some illegal alien got her sore throat looked at, for free, well wait, not free, because you will have to pay for it in some way. Your insurance cost will go up again. And again. I don't say you have to speak English before you can come here, but TRY to learn it and TRY to get employment.

by jdclyde

they could chose french if they so desire.

That is what national language is for, to allow people to comunicate.

That is why after a corporate take-over, all software is standardized so you can share information. Exactly the same idea.

To encourage people to not even try to standardize just means more people won't. If they can't communicate with people in public, then who is getting hurt? You are sabatoging them right of the bat by this misguided attempt to be understanding. It is NOT in their best interests to not learn the national language.

When in groups that speak alternative languages, yes they should be free to speak in any language they please.

If they go in for medical treatment, how do they let the doctor know what is wrong? Does the doctor have to be able to speak 20 languages?

If they go to renew their drivers license, or want to buy a house.

I understand what you are saying about welcoming and accepting people as they are, but that may not always be in the best interest of the people or the country.

Just my humble opinion.

by oz_media

They allowed the Turban to be wornby the RCMP, which is an international police force made up of members of many commonwealth members.

THey do NOT allow Sikhs to carry the Kirpan ANYWHERE, in fact it is VERY tightly regulated that they can be worn at religious ceremonies, but even carrying one TO the temple on your belt is illegal if it is over legal length for a knife. A very good friend of mine is Sikh and he has a kirpan, he has also been arrested for waiting for the bus while coming home from his temple.

We DO ebcourage people to learn English, yet for a country that has many people that are new residents and are in the process of learning English are we wrong to allow them to participate until they learn English?

Your ideas on assimilation are in tune with my own. People leave thier lands for a better life in ours and I expect them to live to OUR laws. Ex. BEcause an East Indian man can beat his wife without repercussion in India, it doesn't mean they should get away with it here, and they no longer have such leniency as they did a few years back.

As for singin gthe amthem, anyone who wishes to sing tribute to Canada is free to do so, no matter how they do it. It's got nothing to do with bringing YOUR ideals into a new land, it's a language barrier, Canada doesn't have an English speakign requirement in order to immirate here, however they DO provide more than enough government assistance in education and language skills once you aer here. So should we ask these people to NOT participate in national tributes of any sort until they are full fledged Canadians?

I'm not Canadian, English IS my native tongue though. But I am still accepted as a Canadian because I admire the country ad it's people, I work and pay taxes, I involve myself in the community etc. I am a good neighbour, THAT is being Canadian, not learning to speak English.

by jamesrl

The RCMP did accomodate the Turban, with appropriate badging on it, but then again, we borrowed the Sam Browne hat from the US, and prior to that we used a British Engineer's hat from the mid 19th century. The Sam Browne depicted in Hollywood movies was a turn of the century thing.

The RCMP is not an international body. It is Canadian (Royal Canadian Mounted Police). It was originally formed as the North West Mounted Police. It has served overseas - fighting in the Boer War, training police officers in new democracies like Haiti etc.

There was a tussle over turbans in legion halls, and legions do "admit" commonwealth and other "allies" as guests. Our Legion Halls allow no hats as in the British traditions no "covers" are worn indoors. In the end, turbans were allowed, but not without some fierce opposition.

As for immigration, there is a language component for the "non" family class immigration, but the language can be English or French. In Quebec they hold a bias towards french speaking immigrants. Family class has no language issues.

I don't care what language someone sings the anthem in, participation is the key. I've been known to sing it in French when I am out west just to live on the edge.

Canada does have 2 official languages, both with equal weight in theory. But that doesn't mean you can go to a federal government office anywhere in the country and get service in both languages. We are practical that way. It is generally easier to get help in English in Quebec than to get help in French in Alberta.

As far as laws, there have been some experiments with things like aboriginal (native) sentancing circles, and alternate non-court dispute mechanisms. There was a controversial study that recommended Ontario allow a voluntary dispute resolution mechanism using the Muslim Sharia as a basis, but it was a recommendation, and frankly there is so much opposition, I doubt it will ever happen - and I am one of those who would oppose it.

James

by oz_media

I was referring more in general terms of the RCMP's international cooperation, when compared to a local police force. The original model being based on the Irish Police Force and the US mounted military and always having a very close relationship to the British Army and Scotland Yard.

But singing the national anthem ?

I can see some people's point with accepting a countries laws and social ways but I don't care what language you speak.

by guggs

Oz.. I respectfully appologize. I've made an error. I started second guessing my facts & therefore decided I should refresh my memory by doing a bit of research.

It wasn't the RCMP, it was the Metro Toronto Police that created the additional special uniform.

It's been a while since I've been there & I confused the two agencies.

That said, you're right, it's got nothing to do with bringing old ideals to the new land, and it is a language barrier, but IF you know the official version (meaning the english or french), and everybody around you is singing it one way, then it's disrespectful (at least to those around you) to go a different route.

Look at it this way... I invite you to come to my house. You accept the invitation. You show up at my door and I happily invite you in, but all the while that you're there, my wife and I only speak english when the conversation is directed at you. We know that you don't understand us, but we understand every single word you say and are obviously capable of communicating in a language you understand.

I myself would feel very uncomfortable in that kind of situation & therefore should RESPECT you by not making YOU feel uncomfortable.

This is a bad analagy, but then again, I'm not usually good with analagies.

I guess the bottom line is that we're living in the free part of the world for the time being, therefore, you're free to see things your way as I'm free to see things my way.

by oz_media

But you did add [i]"but IF you know the official version (meaning the english or french), and everybody around you is singing it one way, then it's disrespectful (at least to those around you) to go a different route."[/i]

This is most definitely true but not the case at hand. And I hate that too, believe me. When I lived in Vancouver it is SO mixed and people talk about you practically right in your face in a native language when they are plotting and scheming, I agree it's VERY inconsiderate and rude. It's realy bad in stores I find too, but that's also a derivative of their culture that does change, sometimes after just the second generation.

Although this irks me to no end sometimes, I have to remind myself I need patience, they are ALL plotting and talking about me...I hope...well maybe...now you're giving me a complex.....ahhhhhHHHH! :D

by oz_media

"In 1990, RCMP Regulations standardized the current Review Order as the Force's "Significant Uniform" for all male and female members. Furthermore, a new regulation authorized the Commissioner to exempt any member from wearing any item of the "Significant Uniform" on the basis of religious beliefs (for example, allowing turbans for Sikh members), and allowing First Nations peoples to wear braids."

From the RCMP website.

by sleepin'dawg

[b]BTW, for better or worse, I mostly agree with you.[/b]
The wearing of braids by First Nations peoples [b]does not[/b] preclude the wearing of the Smokey the Bear hat and I,ve actually seen members of the force wearing braids and pony tails with the hat.
The wearing of turbans was a different matter all together. When a bunch of despicable 'old sweats' wanted to bar Sikhs from wearing a turban into a legion hall, I was offended because so many Sikhs had performed admirable service in the past and I thought some sort of dispensation should be made for them. I also felt that they shouls be allowed to wear turbans in any branch of the armed services they chose to serve in.
When it came to the Mounties though I will admit I had a problem with that. Next to the maple leaf on the flag, the beaver on the nickel and the moose on the quarter can you think of anything more symbolic than the Mounties and their Smokey the Bear hats??? Somehow a turban doesn't cut it as being symbolic of Canada and while forced to accept it, I still don't like it. As it now stands the constable in question has had his duties so arranged that he seldom if ever is called upon to show up in the full dress uniform. That is hypocritical and shouldn't be what Canada is about. However, a choice was made and if the wearing of a turban is to be accepted policy they shouldn't be hiding him behind a desk.
Our national emblem is a leaf and the national animal is a beaver??? The whole thing smacks of comic opera. I don't know what they could have used in place of the leaf but you'd think they could have come up with something like the moose or grizzly for our national animal. Here's an image for you. Our national animal, the beaver, will gnaw down all your trees and cover you in leaves up to your ears. :^O

Dawg ]:)

by oz_media

You are talking about illegal immigrants abusing the system, more specifically East L.A.

I am referring to immigrants to our country (Canada) and being accepted for their differences while they work to establish a new life in a foreign land. People who went to Alberta's Centennial celebration and get a chance to see the Queen on a sunny afternoon.

It was a joyful occasion, Alberta is a phenominal province (it really is visually stunning) and a highly valud contributor to the country, with a budget surplus and all kinds of positive growth and sucess to be proud of, it was a really GOOD thing.

People, and I am not speaking general public but those representatives of the Crown in attendance in the court, were asked to stand with the queen and join the singin of the national anthem.

To bring you up to speed, in case you weren't around;
A thread a while back was regarding a certain US school who was recognizing Interational Language Week by saing the Pledge of Allegiance in English and then in another language (a different one each day for the week). One father had refused to allow his son to attend classes during that week.

This raised many people saying "So WHAT? Let them learn some cultural diversity here!" Others said it was near blasphemy.

by jamesrl

We had the same problem in Toronto, only it wasn't Mexicans crossing the border for US Health Care, it was uninsured Americans coming across the border for Canadian health care. So we tightended up the process - just try and get medical care without a photo ID health card. The older cards were easily forged, these ones with holograms, pictures etc are not so easy.

As for me, as long as there is a sane triage system where everyone was seen on the basis of their level of emergency, I don't care if they are illegal or not. They are human beings. I would prefer that they find a way to fix their problems in their own country, but at the end of the day I am not going to ask a sick person to leave a hospital because they aren't citizens. We are all human beings and citizens of the planet.

James

by oz_media

Are you referring to provincial medical cards?

I just got mine replaced and it's the same BC MEdical card, plastic card with a BC FLAG printed on it and a number stamped into it. (That reminds me, I gotta pay my medical, thx!)

They had charter coaches running from Bellingham/Seattle to Vancouver for a while during thta last flu break for people to get medicines, but up this way it just isn't gonna happen. I was in the horsebrutal a few weeks ago for a rib X-ray and they didn't even ask for my card, just my name and address, but they know me now. I'm kinda like Tim the Toolman Taylor but not clutzy and clumsy with tools, just always in there for something.

by jamesrl

You know, the centre of Canada.....

A decade ago, someone noted that we had about a million more Health Cards in use than citizens of the province, so it was decided that the old card, which was a very simple card with a name and number, needed to be replaced. While there may have been some illegal immigrants with cards, there was also a pattern of heavy usage at hospitals in border communities that pointed to US citizens getting cards.

James

by oz_media

THought it was actually pretty funny.

Just like when they found out there were more Social Insurance Numbers in use than working people in Canada, or something like that anyway.

Gotta love SYSTEMS, that's another reason why I take the gov at face value, these people are just humans with jobs and they f-up just like anyone does.

by oz_media

You can take a driving test in several languages, even the signs! I always thought that a bit odd, I'd rather people could read English before driving here, at least basic English.

There is a testing center in Richmond that has been investigated and many people fired and fined for selling licences to Asian testers. As you can have an Asian speaking tester they were simply working cash deals in a language nobody else in the office understood. Plus how do oyu know they aren't giving the guy all the answers? I don't understand that, much Mandarin or Japanese etc.

BUT, for the circumstances of this occasion, who the hell cares. The government here has placed excellent assistance programs for immigrants, sometimes too much assistance, but it's there. There are ESL schools EVEYWHERE and people DO learn ENglish rather quickly while here. In the case of the Queens visit to the Crown in Alberta, I am sure they were accepting the fact that French speaking people were in the house. Yet they didn't say English or French, they said language of your choice, and THAT's very Canadian. CHOICE.

While we are thought of by some as a very tightly controlled socialist country, we have a lot more CHOICE than most think.

This discussion is closed to new replies.