Discussion Locked

Unable to obtain IP address from DHCP

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi,

When broadband guy came he worked 5+ hours to get connected and failed. His solution was I needed to reinstall Win2k because he thought winsock was corrupted. I did, and it worked. A week later I lost connection and did everything I could think of. After reinstalling win2k again, it worked. It's 4 days later, and I am AGAIN unable to obtain an IP address from the DHCP server. I refuse to reinstall Windows again... what gives? I have been up and down the MS KB, nothing there. I have a packet sniffer installed and if I run ipconfig /renew it sends the packets but I get nothing back... if I reinstall though it works. Anyone got a solution to this tricky problem? (Formatting the hard drive and starting over doesn't count unless you can explain why that's necessary!) Thanks!!!

- Jason

8 replies

by beermonster

Hi,
This is a bit of a long shot (a hefty medium shot anyway). What might be happening is that the delay over a modem connection is causing win2k to autoconfig an Ip address. Ordinarily, win2k will continue to poll in the background for a dhcp address BUT I had a problem recently whereby some nics (yeah, I know that's different but the principle is the same) locked up with an auto address and didn't continue polling Turned out to be a driver issue. You could try disabling apipa and see if that helps any - Q244268. Other than that a worst case scenario would be that the problem is the remote network end, in which case you could be chasing your tail for hours. I can't help thinking that the reinstall is a red herring, as the dhcp requestis the same new build or not.

by syversen

I found out what the problem was... my software firewall (ZoneAlarm) was blocking the DHCP renew requests. That is why it was happening "randomly" every 3-4 days... my lease would run out and I couldn't renew it. It was partially my fault for not clicking the "remember this answer" button the first time it asked, but it was also ZoneAlarm's fault 'cause it stopped asking me and just denied the program access.

by pikikoko

Why don't try using a static IP address on this computer. I use this and I have no problems. Some times the anti virus software gets in the way of using the ping function. Turn off any anti-virus software if you have it and if it doesn't try a static IP address.
Good luck.
mike

by syversen

Sorry,I can't use a static IP 'cause that's the way the ISP has it set up, you have to use DHCP. Thanks though.

by techkid

So, one day you come in, turn on your computer and it doesn't get an IP? Some software can cause network problems. It may be that you're installing this one piece of software that's causing it. Try getting a static IP from your ISP just for testing purposes. Explain your situation to them. If it works for a month or two with a static IP then you know it's more likely a dhcp problem and not a networking problem. I work with DSL and Cable companies for my work and I know that most modems record your MAC address. If you are changing the connection between two computers the modem may block dhcp because it has detected more than one MAC address. ISP's do this to protect against multiple users using the same connection. Otherwise, try a new network card, make sure you have all service packs installed, try a new modem from your ISP... good luck on this one

by syversen

I found out what the problem was... my software firewall (ZoneAlarm) was blocking the DHCP renew requests. That is why it was happening "randomly" every 3-4 days... my lease would run out and I couldn't renew it. It was partially my fault for not clicking the "remember this answer" button the first time it asked, but it was also ZoneAlarm's fault 'cause it stopped asking me and just denied the program access.

by syversen

Comments for the two other responses:

I used to think it was a remote problem but the fact it gets fixed after a reinstall definitely points to something win2k is doing... the trick is to figure out what triggers the problem and how to prevent it! I'm pretty sure it's not a polling issue, because when it was working it worked fine, when it doesn't it goes down for good. (And then gets fixed on a reinstall.) Some file/driver somewhere is getting corrupted by some "normal" activity, but I'm not sure what!

Something along those lines, yeah. Good idea trying to get the static IP, I'll give that a shot. No other computers using it, that would be a good idea though. (Someone else forging it? No, because reinstall solves the problem). As I mentioned earlier, somehow a system data file or driver is getting screwed up, and reinstalling it must reset everything.

The only clue that I have is it seems to be related to checking mail in Outlook, it seems that when you switch profiles in Outlook (97), it has trouble checking the second account and Outlook will freeze/not shut down from there. It appears that my DHCP problems occured not too long afterwards... is Outlook doing something?

This discussion is closed to new replies.