Discussion Locked

US government asks Canada to become their Australia.

0 helpful
79 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

In his year to close Guantanamo, President Obama has been looking for places to 'stick' the released detainees. Canada among many other European countries have been asked to accept these released, suspected terrorists.

The Canadian government has, so far,declined the warm hearted offering, however there is the Canadian Council for Refugees (CCR), whoe are looking to use unique Canadian refugee adoptio laws to sponsor released detainees who have chosen Canada as their desired destination. (and there I have been boasting about Vancouver being the most desired city in the world. :O )

[u][b]Refugee release to Canada denied[/u][/b]
http://www.cbc.ca/canada/story/2009/06/04/uighurs-canada.html

[b][u]Canada a desired location for Guantanamo Bay [/b][/u]detainees
http://www.cbc.ca/canada/story/2009/02/03/guantanamo-detainees-canada.html

EDIT: Ironically, I was just watching Chasers The War on Everything, a hilarious Aussie political bashfest (similar to Penn & Teller's Bulls**t) and they were talking aout how Oama has asked Australia to take suspected terrorist prisoners too. They did a funny piece on a secret CIA prison in Poland that the CIA apparently says doesn't exist...(while standing right in front of it)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bHy0HyG8Yus

:D

79 replies

by santeewelding

To your bosom take them. Retrain them in Computer Science. Teach them not to gnaw through cables to crash your systems.

by oz_media

Its funny how all the old time British Columbians have all headed out of town and built up tiny towns into small cities now. Everyone's heading for the hills, which is the only way to get away and enjoy what BC is really all about

P.S. I added a YouTube clip from a great Aussie show, just happened to be watching it tonight and they hit on the same subject. Funny enough that clip is already on youtube and it just aired.

by deadly ernest

to close Guantanamo got asked to take the people they wanted released. If they weren't prepared to take them, they should never have spoken about closing the facility.

Of course, it would be interesting to see how the people feel if told they have to go back to the country they came from or their country of origin.

As to the CIA and a prison in Poland, it's more likely a Polish Intelligence operation than a CIA one.

by Member 25348569

My message to the US : "Prosecute them or send them back to where you caught them. And if you send them back to where you caught them don't be surprised if next time they really ARE terrorists.

If you invade somewhere, people have every right to be pissed off with you. Why can't you accept that even people who aren't from where you've invaded might be pissed off with you and might join in just so, next time, you might think twice before you invade THEIR country. I'm pissed off because you invaded Iraq - just not to the extent that I'm willing to kill anyone about it."

To answer your question, Ernest: I say that Guantanamo should be closed but, other than that, why should it be my problem? US paranoia crated it and it's a blot on the honour of the US. They have to fix it. Hell, the US shouldn't even be there. It's Cuba! Give it back! They are there under a completely weasel treaty.

And, before you ask, I'd give Gibraltar back to the Spanish and make the Spanish give Spanish Morocco back to the Moroccans (just so Spain doesn't occupy both sides of the Straits - not that I don't trust them).

:)

by deadly ernest

my issue is with the people who pushed to have it closed and the people released aren't interested in having them released in their backyard - I hat hypocrites.

Another issue is the expectation some have that having been in GB they're now entitled to be released in the USA, or Australia or anywhere except their home country or where they were caught. I'd ship them back to the very place they were caught and release them.

by oz_media

You incarecerated people in a dead end legal loop during a war which you started against the wishes of allies and while saying FU to them at the same time.

Apprently you feel it is only other nations who have said you should not have gone to war, should not have detained many of these suspects and should not be toruting then.

As a result, when your president decides to close the 'concentration camp' named Guantanamo Bay, you feel it is purley someone else's fault and that they should carry the burden of your mistakes?

get bent, mate!

by deadly ernest

at me as I'm and Australian. I just take the line that the other countries who's governments or senior politicians complained about the existence of GB and the keeping of prisoners and advocated they be released, should now also take responsibility for providing a place for said prisoners that heir actions are getting released.

Kind of like - don't bitch about the food unless you want to cook.

by oz_media

Do you have a relevant comment to add or are you a a grammar rant today?

Canada, among many other countries.

Canada and many other countries in Europe.

Canada, and many European countries.

Canada, and many countries in Europe.

Whatever, take your pick, make one up of your own, change the whole text if you like.

Whatever floats your paper boat.

by maxwell edison

Guantanamo was no more than a symbolic and contrived issue to trash Bush. It had (and still has) a necessary and legitimate function.

When Obama campaigned to close Guantanamo, I predicted that he'd do no such thing. At best, it'll move to another piece of Real Estate and be called something else, but Guantanamo's mission will continue - and, of course, without the trashing in the press.

by jaqui

I get to play evil empire torturer with them. ]:)

I want to see if I can get them to admit guilt. ]:)

by the 'g-man.'

I hear they have some Plans.

They are also traitors and part of the rebel alliance.

EDIT: lost a Y and had bad grammar but its fixed now.

by jaqui

perfect.

one of my neighbors calls me Darth. ]:)
seems he can't handle me being a goth. :D

so I'm the evil empire's chief torturer. :)

by oz_media

First of all, when others want the Us to do something it doesn't want to, they are told to F-O. America is just and right and will do as she pleases to whomever she pleases and disguise it as security ad safety for the citizens of America (that always gets the people to back them, scare them and save them from doom).

SO when you make such mistakes, and recognize the errors in your ways, it is the others who opposed it in teh first place that should take up the slack and clean up your mess.

Without them (your so called Allies), you'd be happy to imprison, torture, and wrongly detain many suspects at will and are right in doing so.

What a joke, it doesn't work that way and shouldn't either. Always ready and keen to point the finger at someone else for your own mistakes, it's just too obvious these days for others to buy into the BS. There's no way America could be wrong afterall, it MUST be the other guys.

by puppybreath

I especially liked the signs he put up. I was waiting for something along the line of the old Burma Shave signs. But he'd have to be an old American to remember those. :-)

by oz_media

At least somebody has a sense of humour. We always see such things from Canadian political satire shows, so it's nice to see our Aussie mates have a giggle too. (ooops, Pink FLoyd's a bit too loud, don't want to rile my neighbours}.

Have a good weekend, OM

by hal 9000

The Elephant Diet was much better for instance and when they got Americans to say nice things about eating Hay or asking for seconds I was rolling around the floor.

The Secret CIA Prison in Poland just wasn't as funny to me as the other skits run that night. The best one so far this year was then flying the Blimp in Rome with the rope hanging from it so that the good Christan's could pull it to get to the Naked Boys Inside. ;)

But then again maybe it was aimed at a different type of person and I didn't appreciate it.

But when they got into OPEC last year with the Pass that allowed them into any [b]Ice Cream Pallor[/b] and Osama was a passenger that was something to really get you laughing even though quite a few politician's did make formal complaints and wanted the show stopped.

Col

by deadly ernest

if they'd gotten to the third security level the lead would've been flying and they wouldn't have seemed so funny when some of their people got shot. They got past the outer security cordon, well duh, almost anyone with the guts to act like they belong can do that, it's the deeper layers where they actually check Ids properly etc. But I bet they never mentioned that. And I bet they didn't mention the last line shoot first and ask questions later.

Years ago I was working at RAAF Fairbairn when Pres Bush came to visit. Air Force One was still, sitting out on the tarmac after the Pres had left when I went over to that part of the base on a routine business activity. Believe me, I was very much aware of the various snipers keeping an eye on my movements as I need the last line of buildings before AF1 - and was very happy to reach the one I was headed for about eighty metres short of the tarmac itself. I was NOT on their pre issued photo list so they took a great deal of notice of me. I even got a special visit after I left, security wanting to know what I was doing over there and why.

It's very scary once you get through the outer layers of such a security shield.

by oz_media

We have shows that constantly interview Americans and make them look like idiots, it's just not much of a stratch and we see it all the time. 30 minutes from my front door I can see it in real life action, actually there was a guy at 7-11 today and was so typically rude and arrogant I asked if he was American. He said, yes, why? I just smiled and said it was his accent. He nodded and left.

Peple behnid me were all giggling to themselves as they know exactky what it was, "Hi can I help you?"
I WANT.....and I WANT....and I WANT....and I WANT.... No kidding that's exactly what he said to the clerk, while asking for lottery tickets.

I did the same thing just a moth or so ago with ANOTHER American pulling the I WANT and I WANT in a store, I explained to him though that in Canada we usually say please and thank you when we ASK for something.

'kin rude baystards, go home, stay home the worlds a better place that way. Kinda how the Iraqi's think of Americans too.
'Thanks but no thanks, can you go home now?'

Americans are like bullies in school. Bullies are weak, they are insecure, they are unsure and yet want to portray themselves as smart, self confident, and tough. So they waltz in like they pown the place, leave their manners up their arse and feel they should be served. Get bent.

by blondlot

It chafes me that no state will take these prisoners. We arrested them; what's the problem with detaining them on native soil? Are we afraid of terrorist attack? And if we are, why would we assume any other country would be stupid enough to take them off our hands? Are we morally outraged that someone who may have done something deliberately aggressive against the American people will be staying in our country? If that's so, why do we pay billions a year to detain mafia bosses, murderers and child molesters in American prisons? I don't get it.

I have an idea. Build an undersea dome. Put them in the undersea dome. Problem solved for at least a few generations, after which the world will be terrorized by technologically advanced mer-terrorists.

But I'll be dead by then, so who cares?

by oz_media

Nice to see you view reality as reality and not a mistake that is now someone else's problem to sort out for you.

The undersea dome idea, I am thinking expand that to include the White House! Hey I'm not too particular either you can have our politicians too, but we have some pretty nice looking Parliment Buildings that are still nice to have around town.

http://pixelpat.com/images/The%20Parliament%20Buildings%20Victoria%20BC.JPG

http://farm1.static.flickr.com/56/152906054_29396f9838.jpg

I know, sorry, BC is a pretty ugly place but we do what we can. ;)

Here you go! The same harbour in the foreground of the pics has a tourist trap called Undersea Gardens. It is an underwater aquarium that looks out into the natural sealife in the harbour.
http://s3.images.com/huge.67.336664.JPG

We could put the oval office in there,and people could look in on the White House. Of course with a sign saying don't feed the animals or "please don't tap on glass, politicians are easily spooked and distracted".

Right next door is the wax museum, (http://www.scotdancecanada.ca/SDCCS2008/images/tourist/Wax_0597.jpg) we could have life sized replicas of our politicians in the stockade (they have chamber of horrors) where passers by could buy stones and whips. Have your picture taken flogging Bush! Have your picture taken stoning Steven Harper, it would draw well, especially as there is a direct ferry to and from Seattle.

With the Olympics coming up, who knows, it may even steal their thunder too.

Oh, the joy!

by deadly ernest

by another state. However, I believe there's an odd thing in the US laws about if they drag you to their shores they can't kick you out again. I do remember reading the biographies of a couple of organised crime leaders who got kicked out trying to organise having the US government drag them back for questioning and charges on other matters which would then fall through but allow them to stay in the US.

by oz_media

They WOULD release them back to where they came form, however when they face greater prosecution/death when they return, the nation freeing them is responsible to see that they are let go to a safe place.
I don't have an issue really with sharing the burden, in most cases; however when they are incarcerated, some with allied approval and many as a result of the war in Iraq which was not suported to begin with, it's a matter of sleeping in the bed you made for yourself.

by oz_media

Of course you are Australian, sorry for not recognizing that in my previous post, I really didn't mean to call you American, that's not very nice of me.

I see what yoru point is, but as these are nations that NEVER supoprted the action to begin with, why would they be expected to help clean up the mess?

If we had all been gung-ho about taking them in and sending them to Gitmo, that would be different and rather hypocritical to say, 'not in my backyard.'

In the case if Afgan refugees, we have many in Canada already, and I would accept Canada taking these people in and INCARCERATING them and following through with legal trials in speedy time etc.

But to just grab hoards of Iraqi's from a war that few supported and then expect us to help take the burden of your actions, actions which are seen as war crimes wordlwide, is a bit much.

Don't bitch about the food, unless you said you weren't hungry to begin with and didn't want to eat there anyway.

by deadly ernest

those who put pressure on to have them released do bear a responsibility for creating the environment for them being released and thus are responsible for the release. That's the point I'm making. They wanted the situation changed, then they have a responsibility for the new situation.

by hal 9000

GB is just plain wrong and a Blot on America.

If the Yanks don't understand this simple fact it is up to others to point it out to them in the sternest manner possible.

The Yanks created this mess and they are responsible for fixing it up, [b]Plain & Simple.[/b]

The only thing against this is that because of the Abuse that the Yanks have dished out they have created a bigger problem than what they began with and this is what they don't like and are unwilling to deal with.

Col

by oz_media

Half of America wanted them release, the rest of teh world wante dthem released. They were incercerated against the wills of others, just because they dshouldn't have been incarcerated in the first place, it doesn' tmean those who thought they were wrongly detained should be responsible.

I completely iunderstand your view and it applies in many cases, but that same expectation doesn't even come close in this case.

Lets say I tell you not to rape someone, you go ahead and tie a girl up in your basement and rape her anyway. If I continue to urge you to release her and you eventually do, is it MY responsibility to take care of her? Hell no, you shouldn't have taken her to begin with.

Let's say America decides they need world support to lock down Alabama and arrest everyone that they think is affiliated with the KKK.

The rest of the world says there's no need to lock down Alabama, they do not represent the KKK and others want nothing to do with it, but America goes ahead and locks down Alabama and arrests everyone anyway.

The rest of the world cries foul and expects you to release these people you have wrongly taken from their homes and arrested. YOu eventually decide they need ot be released, why shoul the countries opposed to your initial actions be responsible?

That theory of yours has SOME merits in SOME conditions, certainly not here though.

by hal 9000

The Chaser has been taken off air for 2 weeks after last weeks show.

Apparently quite a few people from the Make a Wish Foundation didn't like the Skit that they did on the Greedy Undeserving Dying kids. :0

Personally I liked the bit about renting cheap rooms in London. The Bobby who moved them on was so much better than the Police in Rome who took their Blimp and wouldn't give it back. :D

Col

by deadly ernest

The morning after the show aired all the media people around here were up in arms about it, even the local ABC radio people. They hit the wrong target and now have to wear the response.

There's many media people calling for them being taken off permanently.

by hal 9000

When they bad mouthed Mr P Brock.

The only problem with that one was that everything that they said was true and even then it was Chanel 7 A Current Affair who started the Uproar. But no one wanted to pay attention that The Chaser was putting ACA and it's presenter down at every opportunity and there where plenty of opportunities. I watched the show and I laughed at that skit. Granted I can see some not thinking it was funny but then again they take things [b]Too Seriously[/b] The Chaser isn't on that same league and if you are likely to take it seriously [b]Don't Watch[/b] it.

It's really that easy and I despise people who watch something so that they can make complaints about the content. Hell I can complain about the ABC broadcasting Parliament and the Bad Language used and the conduct of the people show and be so Uprighteous not to be funny. But as I know what is likely to happen with that I just decline to watch it and let those who blindly follow all things Political hand on the Low Life's every work as if it was an uttering from God. Neither the Politician's or those that believe then will be changed so why bother trying?

As for Comedy Programs you watch things like that to laugh not to take them seriously and until the place is populated by people like Mary Whitehouse who found fault with everything broadcast those who may be offended shouldn't watch the show. I notice here that The Chaser is one of the ABC's top rating shows I just have to wonder how many Non ABC watchers watch it so that they can make complaints about it. :D

Col

by oz_media

The show usually gets picked up by another network and is more famous and gets better funding than before.

The BBC shunned off The Benny Hill Show after just a couple of seasons, it had become huge everywhere else though and Thames TV picked it up and cashed in.

by oz_media

I thought that skit was absolutely 'kin hilarious! My neighbour's kid almost wet his diaper when I showed him, he a 14 year old quadrapalegic. He wanted a Sony Playstation 3 ut got an XBox 360 for Christmas, I got a Sony year or so ago so I let him come and play games as he likes (he's got a key so he can come and go after school).

Anyway, what I mean is we are good friends and he's got a great sense of humour but he also said it is other people who make a fuss about being PC around him and he really REALLY doesn't get bothered by it at all, as long as it is jkoking and fun and not just hurtful insults.

But the Make REALISTIC Wish Foundation was side splitting.

Here's the YOUTUBE: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mZw2Z7LJqxw

Comments echo the same views of people who just don't get it and think they are laughing at sick kids.

It isn't a shot at sick kids, it's not even a real shot at the foundation, it's just sh*ts and giggles.

by puppybreath

if you listen to their Animals album. The neighbors will just think you have a lot of barking dogs.

;-)

by oz_media

Actually I have been on a vinyl binge. I have lots of collectible albums in mint shape, so I throw them on the turntable and remember how good music USED to sound before the world of digital 'almost' music.

by puppybreath

What model turntable are you using? I have ton of vinyl but my turntable died years ago. I never bothered looking for a replacement then but it might not be a bad idea since I still have the LPs.

by deadly ernest

wanted it closed have to accept some of the responsibility for what happens to the people affected by the closure.

by deadly ernest

from the local free to air radio announcers all day. I simply said the Make a Wish people weren't the only ones to have a problem with the show.

by deadly ernest

really love, when they were on, The Mavis Bramston Show, Rowan and Martins Laugh In, The Two Ronnies, Are You Being Served, Monty Python, One Foot in the Grave, Waiting for God, and other similar comedy that involves puns and actual humour instead of pie's in the face and banana peels.

by oz_media

To release ANYONE back into a land where they were part of a terrorist group is sending them to die. Terrorists don't care if you are founf guilty, you were captured and lived. First of all, for a Muslim that is purely disgraceful that you did not die for Allah, you did not sacrifice yourself before of after you were caught.

Loko at the innocents who are captured by terrorists, have cages locked to their bodies and are loaded with a remote bomb. THey are being forced to run to allies with please for their lives and then teh terrorists with the bomb control set them off, killing any allies trying to help them.

Anyone caputured and later release back into their hands would be killed, and that's why such laws are in place that we do not simply send them back home and instead we allow them to claim refugee status.

And MANY of these suspects still haven't been tried or found guilty of a crime, just suspected. In the case of a terrorist, they can hold them on that alone while they investigate further.

Many are innocent, many are guilty, many are guilty by asoociation.

Either way, it was America's war, it was America's arrest, America's prisoner, America can deal with them.

by oz_media

That civil/moral issue simply does not apply in this case.

Ever heard the saying, you make you rbed and you can sleep in it?

This wan't like Americans that were wrrested for just causes and the world said they should free all rapists, in which case those countries would be responsible.

THeir arrests were not supported to begin with, they should never have been at war so nobody else should be responsible for helping carry the burden on that war.

I had no part in it, I'm not helping clean it up.

I think Bush should be in Guantanamo, and tortured. If he was and then I requested his release, then fine it is for me to see ot him after that.

If Americans arrest someone they shouldn't and then public outcry has them released, it is AMERICA'S problem, nobody else's, they shouldnt have arrested them to begin with.

by oz_media

If there was anything left of you. We don't put up with rude people in public, and don't like it when hardworking people get crapped on at work by arrogant nobody's, a 'somebody' would have even more trouble.

There's absolutely no reason to not be cordial to someone offering to help you, common courtesy like please and thank you are part of life here, a pleasant one. We stop to let people merge in traffic, we stop to let people cross the street etc. Nothing that I see in the US too often.

by oz_media

The people who complain are ot the peopl ewho find anything like this humorous, they watch shows like New Kids on the Block just looking for something offensive they can rant about to get it removed and their own organizations/selves recognized instead.

Just cashing in by riding coattails, they all have an agenda and making news is a biggie.

by deadly ernest

and at no risk. If they were part of a terrorist group, well they get what they deserve from joining up with the terrorists.

If you regard them as America's problem, then you shouldn't be saying anything about what the US does with them, and shouldn't have argued for their release.

If they were solely a US problem then everyone else should have shut up and totally ignored the matter. The moment others speak up and abuse the US and scream they should be released, they are making themselves part of the issue and taking on themselves part of the responsibility for the people if the US chooses to do as you say they should and release them - thus they do become your problem as well.

If no other countries said anything and let the US take their time to try them and either release them or put them in prison after the court hearings, then they would have remained a solely US issue.

by deadly ernest

where no one interferes and the person in trouble comes seeking help - that is NOT the case here. What this relates to is a case where the US was lying in their bed and a bunch of others came around and complained about what the bed's made of and insists it's changed. That makes the complainers responsible for the bed as well.

You said "Their arrests were not supported to begin with..."

The one really publicised case of an Australian involved included public evidence of the guy admitting, in documents prior to his capture, to being involved with a terrorist organisation and a photo of him bearing arms for them overseas - then he confessed, which the validity of it is being disputed by some.

His diary and letters home, and the photos he sent home make him guilty of a crime under Australian law which prohibits the bearing of arms in another country except under specific conditions which he did not meet. - He was guilty of being a terrorist. Did he actually fire weapons at allied troops? Unproven. Did he bear arms for a terrorist organisation? Proven by his own words.

Who's to say the same is or isn't true of those still there? I haven't seen the evidence available so I don't know. However the guilt or innocence of the prisoners is NOT what I'm talking about. What I'm about is countries screaming at the US that GB is wrong and should be closed down, then doing a Pontious Pilot and refusing to get involved in the clean up of what they pushed to have happen. That's hypocrisy by them.

by seanferd

Either prove they are terrorists, and put them into prison, or clear and release them, with a f-ing sincere apology. Once cleared, they should be able to go home, or any country which will have them.

Of course, some of those who have done nothing wrong may desire to do America harm now that they have been sorely abused, but until they actually do something, they are not criminals or terrorists.

by deadly ernest

causing major delays in the process they would likely have been completed before now. But things are now so old and do messed, I doubt we'll ever know the truth. We'd have more luck going to have a look at a certain Grassy knoll in Dallas tomorrow.

by oz_media

If they are tried and innocent, let them go where they want, within the laws of immigration of course.

If they are guilty, 'their captors' should lock them up and treat them like any other criminal in their system.

However that has NOT been done. They were simply rounded up and locked up. It wasn't until after years of fighting that they finally started to sort through them and fin dout who was who, but that is still far from complete and yet the US government sits on their hands waiting for an answer.

They would not accept Iraq arresting Americans, not trying them in due time and not treating them as they would other prisoners.

However when it is them policing someone else, its a whole new set of rules.

Hypocrisy is the word.

by deadly ernest

military legislative system on martial law that applied, until people started interfering for political gain - nothing to do with the prisoners themselves. most of the interfering people were only out to try and make a few personal political points and started arguments about which legal jurisdiction should be applied - the whole thing was put on hold for a few years while some court cases on the suitability of which legal jurisdiction and which set of rules of evidence were to apply to the situation.

Civilian criminal law is different to civilian corporate law, different again to civilian general law, different to the military code of conduct, and different again to martial law. And each comes with it's own set of rules of evidence and procedures etc. As do the laws on arrest and treatment.

Many of the people in GB would be dead now if they hadn't been taken over by the US Military as they were originally captured by Afghanistani forces who wanted to execute them under Afghanistani law.

None of the cases are simple or straight forward and needed time to be investigated fully. But all the messing about has made it a moot point if any real evidence is now available as a lot of the original witnesses are now dead or can't separate the GB people from others.

Now the whole things is a major mess that no one can sort out in a short time frame.

by oz_media

The only issue I have is your last comment.
"until they actually do something, they are not criminals or terrorists."

Of course you don't mean 'actually do something' unless you consider conspiracy to be doing something. I think they nust be PROPELY interrogated and investigated. Any ties to Taliban or other terror groups at all, and they should be watched or locked up pending investigation. You can't release them on their own if there is ANY question remaining at all, they are not your normal prisoner.

However, I do feel many have been wrongly incarcerated, they have not been treated with the same attention as normal criminals, they should be interrogated (not tortured) and processed in a timely fashion.

This is a repeat of exactly what got this mess going to begin with. Saddam kicked out inspectors repeatedly because the USA was holding imported goods and not inspecting shipments in a timely fasion.

When the final inspectors were sent in, the White House made a big deal about the dual purpose goods trading and how Saddam was not allowing inspections, so he must be hiding something. Of course completely ignoring the real reason WHY they kept getting kicked out. It is all detailed in the White House library for public download, though grossly edited form it's initial version, which they had posted for a while before 'cleaning it up'.

So then when the final inspectors were sent in, Saddam allowed them to get NEAR completion (finding nothing_ when GWB pulled the plug, removed inspectors himself and then invaded against prior plans to only use such force to complete inspections.

It's as if they think people can't remember more than a few months back in time or something. We just forget whay has gone down if they edit and rmove the facts from public documents.

PROCESS THEM, find the criminals and real suspected criminals, let the rest go.

by oz_media

To Broken Record!

As I said, I know EXACTLY the viewpoint you are taking, as I take it in most cases (where it applies)too, but this is nothing even CLOSE to the same thing.

First of all, they shouldn't be there to begin with.
Second of all, most of them are sitting there as suspects of association to a crime and haven't been processed as we would expect under due process as they are not subject to due process.

Some are innocent of the crimes they are accused of, some guilty. The USA locked them up, the USA shouldn't have, the USA can't send them home now because they locked them up, the USA should have to deal with them.

You talk about innocent people being locke dup as if it is so simply solved. How many people have been released from death row because they were wrongly sentenced to death?

They can't figure out who's who, they just coralled them like cattle and locked them up to play a little Saddam game themselves, but it failed, 'not my fault, shouldn't have done it to begin with, sort it out yourselves'.

You seem to feel that I wanted them released and Guantanamo closed. I am sure many Canadians did, many Iraqi's did, many Australians did, many Brits did, many Germans did, many French did and even more than ANY nation, many AMERCIANS did.

So, when America realises their horrific mistake and the situation they have created and the inefficiency of Guantanamo Bay to do as they thought it would, and the ineffectiveness of their incareration, THEY can bloody well deal with it.

'America' listens to nobody, never has and never will. They join in the game when THEY want to, yet they oppose those who don't jump to join them. They expect full apology from those who wrong them, but wrong any other without a second thought.

Why the hell should anyone bale them out of a mess they created, insisted on and then fail to see through?

The world's mightiest nation/super power? BS, they can sleep in the bed they made.

by oz_media

You've been hanging out with Tony or something.

By saying many arrest were not supprted, I am referring to those who were captured and arrested in Iraq, a war that was against the majority of allied nations wishes and one that is still seen as an illegal war where war crimes have been comitted.

Certainly some are wanted men, some are known criminals, some are unproven criminals that may be set free, some are completely innocent, the same goes for any prison in the world. HOwever we process our own as we must be due process, we decide who's a cirminal and lock them up, whether we were right or wrong. We decide who's innocent and send them home, sometimes regretably.

But just because other nations thought it should be closed and were outspoken about how wron git was, it doesn' tin ANY way makek them responsible if america see their fault.

Just because you open somebody's eyes, it doesn't make you responsible for their actions.

by deadly ernest

giving you the same response. You seem too hung up on the concept everyone at GB was innocent (despite evidence proving some of those tried were guilty) without fully examining the evidence available. That is a different issue to the one I'm making.

You want to play in a neighbour's yard and dictate the rules, you get to be involved in the clean up. If you didn't want to get involved in the clean up you should have stayed completely out of the game. Simple isn't it.

Many of these countries are now in the situation of a Chinese Obligation and are proving themselves to be hypocrites by refusing to accept responsibility for the outcomes of their actions.

by oz_media

I have stayed with, worked with, and been a neighour to many great Americans. I have run a business and had offices in Amercia and loved it. People aren't that bad, even the nicest Americans I've met have some god awful manners in punlic or when driving, but their innocence makes you ignore it, they simply don't know any better.

That's why I laugh at the American PC bandwagon. While they were 10 years late on that one, now they are all of a sudden the righteous ones who find everyone else not politically correct.

Meanwhile, everyone else played that game, realized it gets way out of hand and leaves people pu$$yfooting through life, then reverted to a happy medium.

But its still fun to watch Americans play the PC game as if they are above people now, just observations for sh*ts and giggles, kind like watching the monkey cage at the local zoo.

by oz_media

Well then it's goodnight from me, and it's good night from him. :D

You left out the goodies though, a little goofy but a roar too.

Fawlty Towers (or was it Watery Twots, Warty Towels ?) "lick O paint, lick O paint, let dry for 10 minutes, got time to 'ave a cup o tea."

by oz_media

If I keep saying the same thing and you still don't get it, I give up.

I have NOT said everyone at GB is innocent, I have said that many have not even been tried yet, as we must do with our own in due process, and therefore a lot of these assocaited terrorists in GB are simply there as suspects of association. THey locke dthem all up and couldn't/DIDN'T even process them.

It reminds me of teh games the US played with Saddam over the dual pupose goods inspections. They insisted they were in charge of inspecting all goods destined for Iraq, however they failed to do so in a timely fashion and many shipments NEEDED for medical reasons, health reasons, food etc. perished before ever gettign to Iraq. Saddam was pissed at that and kept kicking out weapons inspectors.

Of course all teh US government aired at the time was that he had kicked out inspectors again. no mention of how Iraq was protesting the lengthy delays of shpments that were needed. Sure some were dual purpose goods being traded for Russian oil, which REALLY PO's the US because Sadaam wouldn't trade oil with the US but had no problems with Russia.

'kin US government, point the finger and shout loud enough at your enemy and maybe nobody will ask what YOU'VE been up to.

by deadly ernest

first person shooters as they let you get rid of the adrenalin, followed by tactical games.

Yeah, I know that's not what you meant but I've been p***ed of with political correctness for over twenty years of the bovine excreta.

by oz_media

I have two lawyers in my family, corporate and criminal, I have studied criminology and watched a million cases, I understand the proceedings, as I said before, they are not processed in due time and can just be held at will as suspects. As they are suspected terroists they have no rights to speedy trial, as do military criminals.

I don't know how you read dozens of posts and still didn't get that message when I said the same thing repeatedly.

by deadly ernest

enforcing many laws and been in the court rooms for cases involving civil cases, traffic offences, criminal offences (misdemeanours and felonies), immigration cases, planning cases, torts, and even on the edges of a couple under military law. And interestingly they're all different rules and only criminal cases demand a speedy trial, but even then they get regularly delayed while investigations continue.

On speedy criminal trials, if the media reports are anything to go by the average time between arrest to final court case in US Federal Criminal Cases is measured in years, the bigger the crime the longer it takes to get to court. Wasn't there a recent TR thread on the court decision in a case dating back to 2001 - and that didn't have everything put on hold and restarted twice due to political interference by Congress and the US Supreme Court.

As to your complaints about repeat messages, I heard what you had to say the first time - but since it's wrong, I keep correcting it.

by oz_media

Personally, and I mean it in the nicest way, I couldn't give a rats arse what you think happens in the court system based on what you've seen in the media. YOU started arguing because you think America is being pressured to release these people against America's wishes (which is incorrect) and that those urging them to correct their mistakes should be responsible for cleaning up (which is completely screwed up). When I said they face different laws as terrorist than criminals do, you started to explain how you know about the legal system and that terorists are treated differently than criminals (echo?). And now you are trying to argue that point as if I had said otherwise? You need your noggin checked, mate; something aint right up there.

Now you are trying to say that the delays in military crime processing of terrorist suspects are the same as the constantly delayed proceedings that defense lawyers create in civillian criminal justice system.

There is a MASSIVE difference between delayed due process because the defendant postpones and delays the inevitable for years, hoping witness memory and evidence fades to the point of incredibility, and delayed process because the prosecution doesn't have to address them and is encouraged to 'coax' informatyion from them. Once these people are tried, they are either innocent or guilty then must be set free or incarcerated. It is in the military's best interests to hold of that process as long as possible, because they feel using deprivation and breaking down their minds will lead to confession, which may not be so if tried in court. They don't HAVE to try their cases, so they DON'T plain and simple. It is nothing like our civil legal system.

There are a million reasons why people on trial purposely delay their own process, but the failure for a court to process a hearing in a reasonable time frame is usually not the problem, it's almost always the defense in such intstances.

What you are arguing at this time is irrelevant and a rather moot point; the fact is, people are not being processed and hearings are being held off by the US military because, when they arrest a suspected terrorist, they are not bound by the same laws as citizens.
I said that before too, before you tried correcting me by saying the same thing.

I have said that repeatedly AND you have said it too in your mroe recent posts, if you insist that we are both wrong in agreeing on that issue, you need to speak to your other personality and have it out.

When people draw me in these circular discussions where they initially disagree then agree but make it seem like they had that stand all along, I let them have the playground to themsleves.

Feel free to give yourself your 'righteous Australian' badge for thinking someone else's criminals should be absorbed by all those who didn't agree with their arrests to begin with.

Have a swell day

by oz_media

I have a few turtanles but I currently use a Harman Kardon T-60 floating suspension table with Mission cartidge. I had a Blutone but can't justify sitting on hardware that expesive. I loved it but find the heavy platter of the T-60 best for my room to reduce rumble and bass pockets in the corners.

For yourself, I would seriously consider looking for a used Dual, you can get a 1219 on craigslist pretty cheap ($100-$150.00) depending on condition.
Something like this: http://saltlakecity.craigslist.org/ele/1207171516.html

If you see one and want to hear about its quality or value, just Google it and you'll find audiophile forums discussing it and similar models. The 1237 above is a pretty entry level example but still better than anything new (last 20 years) under $400.00
Take it straight to a local shop and have it cleaned oiled and balanced ($80?US). Buy a decent cartidge/needle if you can too.

Another place to finnd old Dual turntables is in those all in one cabinet stereo systems thta were so popular in the 70's. Most of them used teh Dual 1210 and 1219 turntables, then just find a junked or near dead Dual turntable cheap and use the base.

A bit of digging gets you a killer turntable for less than $100.00

by deadly ernest

For some years the media have been carrying many reports of senior politicians from many countries pressuring the US to close GB - I didn't make that up.

The defence are not the only ones to delay a criminal case. Often delays are through the prosecutor wanting time to gather more evidence. However in this case the delays were due to political pressure having all cases put on hold while a case about the jurisdiction worked its way through the US Supreme Court, that took a long time to process. A stay was issued once the case was accepted by the Supreme Court. Another aspect was also taken through the Supreme Court after that one was done, causing more delays - I forget what they were arguing about at the time beyond all cases being stopped pending the outcome.

The situation is akin to the animal right people who lobbied to stop the use of exotic animals in circuses. In both cases, having pushed to get changes, once they got the changes they pushed for they were a responsibility for what follows from the change they wanted. With the animal rights people they didn't want to accept the care of the animals that no longer worked, and became horrified when most of the animals were put down because the circuses couldn't afford to feed and care for animals that that didn't perform. With regards the prisoners they have a responsibility towards the prisoners.

Should the US just ship the prisoners back to their home countries and some are killed by the governments of those countries, you'll here the screams longest and loudest from the people who wanted GB closed.

These people were taken into custody as being suspected of being involved with terrorist organisations, many have made it clear they don't like the US or its people, so only a fool would release them in the US. that leaves ship them to their native land, the country where they were taken into custody, or find another to accept them as migrants. Of the three the most humanitarian is to find another country, so the countries who pressured the US to free them should be stepping up to the plate with the numbers they'll take. Funny how they're very silent on the issue.

by oz_media

Scrolling through TR, Oh no, he's replied again. Sigh, deep breath, what now?! Oh, just more of the same misguided and delusional concept.

[i]"For some years the media have been carrying many reports of senior politicians from many countries pressuring the US to close GB - I didn't make that up."[/i]

And a simpler analogy, perhaps even you can follow without too much trouble.

Mary is a babysitter, she is one of three who babysit the Henderson's kids. The baby sitters always tell the Henderson's that they are messy and should clean up more, because it's not safe for the kids to play in, but Mrs. Henderson couldn't care less and lets the kids play in a dangerous home.

Mr.Henderson divorces Mrs. Henderson and finds a new girlfriend. That new girlfriend sees the messy house and makes the kids clean up because it's dangerous to play in a messy house.

Why should Mary and the other babysitters have to help clean up just because they noted the mess and it was ignored before?

According to your 'moral standards', these three baby sitters should be responsible for cleaning the Henderson's house, now that the new girlfriend has decided it should be cleaner, because THEY said it first, even though it fell upon deaf ears.

And like I've said before, more than once, since WHEN did America's government start LISTENING to the media (other than to prepare rebuttal)or caring what others think? A simple example would be nice but the fact is, America's government listens to nobody, nor should they, their own people and the new president made it so, not anyone else. GWB would still have the place running and would be selling tix to live tortures.

Just because a new president takes office that agree with the general American public, you see that as the world forcing America to shut a prison and therefore is responsible? Get real.

[i]"The defence are not the only ones to delay a criminal case. Often delays are through the prosecutor wanting time to gather more evidence...."(and the rest but too much to quote).[/i]

You are really missing the point here. The prosecution DOES SOMETIMES delay a case, I didn't say otherwise. I said it is USUALLY, which it is, the defense who delays cases.

Either way there is a due process and it is followed, they don't just sit in jail wondering when they'll get to put forth their case and be heard, as they ARE in Gitmo. Even the military does not hide this fact it is used to break them down to confession and hopefully a trial is no needed.

Then you go on about animals rights and how they faced a similar action, again completely missing the point. THAT is part of the process of many cases, it's not unique to Gitmo but that IS processing the case, however that is ONE excuse for ONE set of delays, which was dragged through the bureaucratic red tape and used as an endless excuse for indeterminate holding without due process, while the broke confessions from them, or tried to anyway.

That form of interrogation is not legal in normal prison systems, why not? Because it is proven that it leads to false admissions of guilt, but that still keeps Joe public happy and the prison/torture system in place.

[i]"Should the US just ship the prisoners back to their home countries and some are killed by the governments of those countries, you'll here the screams longest and loudest from the people who wanted GB closed." [/i]

Americans scream and shout the loudest already, they are the ones you were referring to right? Seeing as millions Americans opposed Gitmo too and most of the noise came from America.

If you take the number of Americans who wanted Gitmo closed and compared that to Canada's population, you'd find more Americans were opposed than the entire population of Canada!

You seem to have this delusion that Americans were all happy with the war and Gitmo, and that under pressure and pleas of others they decided to appease their allies and release the suspects? Give your head a shake, it just doesn't/DIDN't work that way.

Obama stood on the same side as all those millions of Americans who wanted it closed, it has f-all to do with anyone else's wishes, for the last time and hopefully you finally get it, AMERICANS LISTEN TO NOBODY BUT AMERICANS.

Get it through your skull, they are doing it because [b]THEY WANT TO CLOSE IT, NOT BECAUSE CANADA, AUSTRALIA, GERMANY or any others want it closed.[/b]

What bizarre stroke of your imagination thought that, after over 200 years, America's government was listening to what the rest of their allies wanted them to do?

If it was Bush it would still be in full swing and open for business as usual.

[i]"These people were taken into custody as being suspected of being involved with terrorist organisations, many have made it clear they don't like the US or its people, so only a fool would release them in the US."
[/i]

And only a fool would accept them anywhere else. They are wanted men, they will bring trouble to any nation that houses them, until they are dead of course and cannot tell tales. but we didn't capture them, we didn't arrest them, we didn't lock them up.

[i]"that leaves ship them to their native land, the country where they were taken into custody, or find another to accept them as migrants"[/i]

Of course completely missing the fact that if they are PROVEN to be criminals in America that America has countless facilities to lock up and process their prisoners, besides Gitmo.

I can't believe that you see this as anyone's fault, problem or responsibility besides America's.

[b]THEY ARE [u]NOT[/u] BEING CLOSED DOWN BY OTHERS. AMERICA IS CLOSING THIS PRISON BASED ON THE POLITICAL STAND OF THEIR NEW PRESIDENT WHO LISTENED TO THE PEOPLE WHO VOTED FOR HIM, [u]THEY WANTED GITMO CLOSED.[/u][/b] JUST BECAUSE OTHERS FEEL THE SAME WAY, IT DOES NOT MEAN THAT THEY ARE BEING LISTENED TO NOR SHOULD THEY BEAR THE RESPONSIBILITY FOR [i]AMERICA'S SELF INFLICTED BURDEN.[/i]

What a lot of rot you've gushed forth here and yet you will again go on to repeat your same old stand as if you have a point...a point fit for a pointy hat.

by deadly ernest

1. In the baby sitter situation the baby sitters have been invited in to take on the role, temporarily and with limitations, of the parents. Not the same as a person from the next block over standing in the street and yelling abuse; which would be a more appropriate analogy to the situation.

2. The only reason the US is taking action is because other governments kept putting the thing in the news and screaming about until the media attention created some responses within the US. If the other governments had not kept raising the issue in the international forum, it's unlikely much would have been done.

3. So if the US ship all these people back to the very place they were taken into custody and released them and they did something or something happened to them, you will hold the US totally blameless for those events.

4. To follow your comment to proven them guilty means to keep GB open while they finish the investigations and hearings. But that's not what the other governments have been saying, they wanted immediate closure of GB and release of the prisoners; and that's what Obama is offering. Nothing about completing the cases, just closure and release, as requested.

Your position presents as 'it's happening outside my country and my citizens aren't actually doing anything (media and political pressure doesn't count as doing anything) then it's nothing to do with my country.' That being the case, as soon as the US drop them back where they found them, they no longer have any involvement or responsibility towards them.
........

On another aspect, I love your comment

"And only a fool would accept them anywhere else. They are wanted men, they will bring trouble to any nation that houses them, until they are dead of course and cannot tell tales. But we didn't capture them, we didn't arrest them, we didn't lock them up."

So you now claim they're guilty after saying they're innocent for so long. Why the change? Oh, doesn't matter.

Let's make this simple and have the US just execute them then.

.......

But back to the original subject.

Many countries agitate to have GB closed. In response to the international media and the political pressure a political decision is made with a total disregard for the legal aspects occurring. Obama says close GB, he naturally turns to the countries that screamed for it's closure and asks if they want any of these people they want freed. A natural question, as they wanted them freed.

Those governments show their hypocrisy by saying "Oh no, we want them freed, but not here." And thus refuse to accept any responsibility for the results of their earlier actions. If they said, "Give us their files and we'll see if they meet our usual immigration standards and make a decision on individuals." That would be showing they accept some responsibility for their actions but are still prepared to operate within their normal rules. Sadly, that is NOT what happened, just a blanket refusal.

By jumping up and down and putting pressure on the US, all those governments have accepted a partial responsibility for the people affected. It's that simple.

You disagree, and you're allowed to do that. It doesn't make your attitude on it right.

.........

Since there seems to be no new material or points being made in the last few posts. I'll call it a day here and stop checking this thread now. That way you can get in the last comment if you want.

by oz_media

" Not the same as a person from the next block over standing in the street and yelling abuse; which would be a more appropriate analogy to the situation."

Okay, so someone down the street whines and bitches about the state or your yard. YOu ignore her as awlays and then your new girlfriend looks at it and says, we have to clean this up.

Why the hell should the mouthy neighbour have to help? it's your 'kin yard, YOUR girlfriend that decided to clean it up. Just because you have a neighbour who agree with you and feels you should clean it up, that doesn't make it HER problem, it's YOUR mess YOU created it YOU clean the crap up.

Your second point is pure hogwash, complete and utter rot. It is speculative and assumes something that would be complewtely out of character for the US.

once again, the US listens to NOBODY. There was just as much if not much mroe pressure (by population) from teh US to close it down as form anywhere else in the world. If you REALLY for a second think that the US would heed allied wishes at th is late stage in the game, perhaps you can show me examples of how they have done this, against their own wishes before.

THEY HAVEN'T, THEY DON'T, THEY WON'T, THEY DIDN'T.

If you REALLY expect anyone to believe that Obama acted on the wishes of allies and against the wishes of the US people to shut down Gitmo, you don't have the vaguest clue what you are on aout.

It's nice that your analogies suit your story, but a story/dream is all it is, so far beyond reality it can see unicorns and faries.

As for them being innocent or guilty, you are WRONG, just plain WRONG. I have NOT said they were either guilty OR innocent.

I have explained in detail that many COULD be innocent, i am sure many ARE innocent, but again many are rightly incarcerated for trrorist activity. Therefore they are wanted men, those who are not offenders, I have no probblem with, let em go where they want. After all these years and a failure to even find out who's who and who should e set free vs who should e tried, it's noody's problem to cleam up except the USA.

THEY feel these are all dangerous criminals, peopl ewho are a threat to modern society, then show them due process and get to the bottom of it. THEN you can ask allies to take the innocent in as refugees.

THe issues is not that they were locke dup, it's not that they are innocent or guilty, it's not even that they were captured as suspects, its that THEY HAVEN'T BEEN SORTED OUT AS THEY ARE SUPPOSED TO HAVE BEEN.

"Many countries agitate to have GB closed. In response to the international media and the political pressure a political decision is made with a total disregard for the legal aspects occurring. Obama says close GB, he naturally turns to the countries that screamed for it's closure and asks if they want any of these people they want freed. A natural question, as they wanted them freed."

Bullsh1t completely fabricated garbage that you have dreamed up for teh sake of support. PLEASE post links to these facts you share that read Obama's mind and intentions.

He'd be the first president to do so in world history and he'd never see a second term if he went against Americans to appease allies, just the concept itself is simply ludacris.

"And thus refuse to accept any responsibility for the results of their earlier actions"

Where do yo come up with this? If it was the norm for America to follow alied wishes, to listen to others and act AGAINST their own wishes in order to appease others your poast would have SOME shred of validity to it. As that has never been and never will be tah casem your post is complete horsesh1t. You REALLY think America was heeding the wishes of others by closing GB and that the people of America wanted it left open?

"putting pressure on the US"

YOU are surely making it up, putting PRESSURE on the USA? Give me a break! Did you just wake up after a 60 year nap or something? This is the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA we are talking about, not France of Sweden.

YOU are backing out now simply because you don't have a limp leg to stand on. Your last post was rife with false assumptions, character generalizations that do NOT fit teh character at all, and just dream filled BS. Utter garbage and you know it.

So lets see the facts on WHO wants GB closed:

Those FOR closure:
Kofi Annan Former U.N. Secretary General
Barack Obama United States President
John McCain U.S. Senator, Republican
Hillary Clinton US Secretary of State
Colin Powell Former U.S. Secretary of State

Those AGAINST closure:
Dick Cheney U.S. Vice President 2001-2009
George W. Bush US President 2001-2009
Mitt Romney Former Governor of Massachusetts
Rudy Giuliani Former Mayor of New York City

http://www.takeonit.com/question/110.aspx

To dispell your mythology, if the main cainet menbers of THIS administration all feel it should be closed for their own reasons, which are also cited here: http://www.takeonit.com/question/110.aspx
And teh former administration is against it.

Why do YOU really think they are closing GB, because of pressure from Allies???? Give me a break, you aren't fooling anyone.

This discussion is closed to new replies.