Scrolling through TR, Oh no, he's replied again. Sigh, deep breath, what now?! Oh, just more of the same misguided and delusional concept.
[i]"For some years the media have been carrying many reports of senior politicians from many countries pressuring the US to close GB - I didn't make that up."[/i]
And a simpler analogy, perhaps even you can follow without too much trouble.
Mary is a babysitter, she is one of three who babysit the Henderson's kids. The baby sitters always tell the Henderson's that they are messy and should clean up more, because it's not safe for the kids to play in, but Mrs. Henderson couldn't care less and lets the kids play in a dangerous home.
Mr.Henderson divorces Mrs. Henderson and finds a new girlfriend. That new girlfriend sees the messy house and makes the kids clean up because it's dangerous to play in a messy house.
Why should Mary and the other babysitters have to help clean up just because they noted the mess and it was ignored before?
According to your 'moral standards', these three baby sitters should be responsible for cleaning the Henderson's house, now that the new girlfriend has decided it should be cleaner, because THEY said it first, even though it fell upon deaf ears.
And like I've said before, more than once, since WHEN did America's government start LISTENING to the media (other than to prepare rebuttal)or caring what others think? A simple example would be nice but the fact is, America's government listens to nobody, nor should they, their own people and the new president made it so, not anyone else. GWB would still have the place running and would be selling tix to live tortures.
Just because a new president takes office that agree with the general American public, you see that as the world forcing America to shut a prison and therefore is responsible? Get real.
[i]"The defence are not the only ones to delay a criminal case. Often delays are through the prosecutor wanting time to gather more evidence...."(and the rest but too much to quote).[/i]
You are really missing the point here. The prosecution DOES SOMETIMES delay a case, I didn't say otherwise. I said it is USUALLY, which it is, the defense who delays cases.
Either way there is a due process and it is followed, they don't just sit in jail wondering when they'll get to put forth their case and be heard, as they ARE in Gitmo. Even the military does not hide this fact it is used to break them down to confession and hopefully a trial is no needed.
Then you go on about animals rights and how they faced a similar action, again completely missing the point. THAT is part of the process of many cases, it's not unique to Gitmo but that IS processing the case, however that is ONE excuse for ONE set of delays, which was dragged through the bureaucratic red tape and used as an endless excuse for indeterminate holding without due process, while the broke confessions from them, or tried to anyway.
That form of interrogation is not legal in normal prison systems, why not? Because it is proven that it leads to false admissions of guilt, but that still keeps Joe public happy and the prison/torture system in place.
[i]"Should the US just ship the prisoners back to their home countries and some are killed by the governments of those countries, you'll here the screams longest and loudest from the people who wanted GB closed." [/i]
Americans scream and shout the loudest already, they are the ones you were referring to right? Seeing as millions Americans opposed Gitmo too and most of the noise came from America.
If you take the number of Americans who wanted Gitmo closed and compared that to Canada's population, you'd find more Americans were opposed than the entire population of Canada!
You seem to have this delusion that Americans were all happy with the war and Gitmo, and that under pressure and pleas of others they decided to appease their allies and release the suspects? Give your head a shake, it just doesn't/DIDN't work that way.
Obama stood on the same side as all those millions of Americans who wanted it closed, it has f-all to do with anyone else's wishes, for the last time and hopefully you finally get it, AMERICANS LISTEN TO NOBODY BUT AMERICANS.
Get it through your skull, they are doing it because [b]THEY WANT TO CLOSE IT, NOT BECAUSE CANADA, AUSTRALIA, GERMANY or any others want it closed.[/b]
What bizarre stroke of your imagination thought that, after over 200 years, America's government was listening to what the rest of their allies wanted them to do?
If it was Bush it would still be in full swing and open for business as usual.
[i]"These people were taken into custody as being suspected of being involved with terrorist organisations, many have made it clear they don't like the US or its people, so only a fool would release them in the US."
[/i]
And only a fool would accept them anywhere else. They are wanted men, they will bring trouble to any nation that houses them, until they are dead of course and cannot tell tales. but we didn't capture them, we didn't arrest them, we didn't lock them up.
[i]"that leaves ship them to their native land, the country where they were taken into custody, or find another to accept them as migrants"[/i]
Of course completely missing the fact that if they are PROVEN to be criminals in America that America has countless facilities to lock up and process their prisoners, besides Gitmo.
I can't believe that you see this as anyone's fault, problem or responsibility besides America's.
[b]THEY ARE [u]NOT[/u] BEING CLOSED DOWN BY OTHERS. AMERICA IS CLOSING THIS PRISON BASED ON THE POLITICAL STAND OF THEIR NEW PRESIDENT WHO LISTENED TO THE PEOPLE WHO VOTED FOR HIM, [u]THEY WANTED GITMO CLOSED.[/u][/b] JUST BECAUSE OTHERS FEEL THE SAME WAY, IT DOES NOT MEAN THAT THEY ARE BEING LISTENED TO NOR SHOULD THEY BEAR THE RESPONSIBILITY FOR [i]AMERICA'S SELF INFLICTED BURDEN.[/i]
What a lot of rot you've gushed forth here and yet you will again go on to repeat your same old stand as if you have a point...a point fit for a pointy hat.