Here is the full text of the interview, below is an extract.
http://www.abc.net.au/lateline/content/2004/s1245842.htm
Now, millions of TV viewers have seen yesterday's horrifying video of a US marine evidently killing a wounded man in cold blood.
Is that evidence of murder, is it evidence of a war crime or is there another category of justice for soldiers who kill enemy wounded after a battle?
GEOFFREY ROBERTSON, UN JUDGE AND HUMAN RIGHTS LAWYER: Well, it's evidence, yes, what lawyers would say is prima facie evidence, which means there is other evidence to be heard, particularly the marine's story.
But, look, it's been a war crime for 500 years.
Back in the English Civil War in Cromwell's time, armies were never permitted, and soldiers were prosecuted, if they killed enemy who had surrendered or who, what is termed horde a combat, which is a French term meaning, in effect, "out of action because of serious injury".
So, on the face of it, this is a breach of the Geneva Conventions.
On the other hand, you've got to consider the pressures that the soldier was under, what was going through his mind at the time.
There is evidence that mujahideen had been booby-trapping themselves, strapping compression mines, and a number of marines have been killed by dead bodies that have exploded.
So you've got to factor all of that in to deciding whether there's the moral culpability in the case of that individual marine.
But there are wider issues, I think.
This isn't as serious as Abu Ghraib which indicated systematic torture.
It is serious, though, because there is the possibility that the rules of engagement which provide for what is termed "clearing ground" may permit rather more permissively than international law does, the pumping of a couple of bullets into a seemingly dead body or a body that twitches and that's something that I'm sure the American investigation, and you've got to understand that the American military are very good at investigating and they do court martial people where there is clear evidence of war crimes.
That will bring that to light.
TONY JONES: You could argue - we'll come back to that in a moment - but you could argue that soldiers who've been killing in heated and brutal close combat are not in their right minds, in fact.
Could that be a mitigating circumstance?
GEOFFREY ROBERTSON: Well, there is some suggestion that this particular soldier may have been put back into action too quickly after he had been himself wounded in a previous engagement and that has to be factored in to a fair consideration of his state of mind and, I mean, you've got also to protect the Geneva Convention principle that those who have surrendered or who are out of action through serious injury have to be treated humanely.
I mean, that's been the case ever since Breaker Morant was prosecuted for that.
There were problems about the fairness of his trial and Kitchener's complicity.
But killing prisoners, killing those who have surrendered and are in no state to fight back is a serious matter.
But then the camera doesn't tell the whole story and it's the whole story that needs to be considered, particularly the pressure on the individual marine and what he assumed from a movement of a body, a twitch or a reach perhaps for a gun or, indeed, to detonate the compression mine that has in some cases been used by the mujahideen in precisely these circumstances.