Discussion Locked

US Soldier Murders Injured and Unarmed

0 helpful
78 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Did y'all see the video of that US soldier murdering an unarmed, injured freedom fighter?

Knowing that he was most likely NOT al Quaeda, and knowing that he definitely didn't have any nuclear missiles - can ya really keep supporting the US war against the people of Iraq?

I mean, it's just not right to have US kids getting their minds so shattered, and their morality so compromised that they're murdering unarmed, injured people.

What did he do to deserve being shot? According to the soldier who shot him, his crime was "playing dead".

What choice do we leave these people, if playing dead is a capital crime, but to become suicide bombers, and to band together with Americas enemies like al Quaeda?

Is this really the way to spread Democracy - American style?

----
"If you wanna leave, take good care.
I hope you find a lot of nice friends out there.
Just remember there's a lot of bad and beware"
- Cat Stevens (banned from the US as a terrorist)

78 replies

by john.a.wills

The soldier in question is being brought to justice. It is not U.S. policy to kill harmless people, however many soldiers do it, and we know it is not policy because of the process against this traitor. In SVN things were somewhat different: most of the traitors were not prosecuted, so we can say that there was a murderous policy quite high up, despite the basically good intentions of the U.S. participation in the war.

by wordworker

...unavoidable. In times of war, people are stressed, and they do things they wouldn't ordinarily do. Doubtless that Marine thought he was acting appropriately for the circumstance. Until you've walked in a soldier's shoes, you can't really be a fair judge of how you would react under similar circumstances.

The worst thing that can happen is to vilify this poor Marine and blow the incident out of proportion. Sad and tragic as the event was, it is less gruesome - to my senses anyway - than a 16 yo kid strapping on explosives and blowing himself and 20 other people up. At least the soldier is a trained professional who has standards against which his behavior will be judged. That stupid 16 yo will be a martyr, tho no one will remember his name in six months...

What we need to do is END THIS WAR as soon as possible and get U.S. out of Iraq.

by jardinier

"What we need to do is END THIS WAR as soon as possible and get U.S. out of Iraq."

Assuming that you are an American, woodworker, I must say I never expected to hear this from an American at this website.

What America should have done was to cut its losses and leave Iraq 6 - 9 months ago. The longer the war continues, the more the violence escalates, and the longer America will be obliged to keep a large number of troops in Iraq to maintain some semblance of law and order.

In the present climate, the likelihood of fair elections in January is nothing but a pipe dream.

by protiusx

If the US were to do as you say and pick up and leave there would be a power vacuum in the region that would result in the deaths of a whole lot more innocent people.
Whether you agree or disagree with the starting of the Iraqi war you must understand that there needs to be a viable governing authority in place before we leave.

by garion11

This war isn't going to END tomorrow. It won't next year. This is a war for a lifetime. A whole generetion of that middle eastern hatred has to be moderated by a western influence. Iraq is a only a small picture...don't lose sight of the main goal. After Iraq is up and running...Iran and Syria are next. Reason for going to Iran and Syria...US shouldn't have to give any reasons to some pissant countries that are selfish in their own way. You don't like our actions...try to stop us. Russia is going to be with us...so is India, so is Israel. 9/11 started this...America will finish this.

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
After Iraq is up and running...Iran and Syria are next.
---- ---- ---- ----

While there are indeed a lot of Bush Loyalists who would *like* for the US to go to war with more countries, I think it's unlikely they'll get their way.

Bush got his nut in Iraq. He's overextended. There are not enough soldiers free up to invade Tijuana.

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
I know that 2 wrongs don't make a right but did you also see ( almost every week ) videos shown on TV of the inoccent civilians, journalists, Care workers who are executed / be-headed and broadcast around the world!
----- ----- ----- ----- -----

What else would you expect from people defending their homeland?

by garion11

You are defending terrorists, the same people who are beheading civlians (not the US military personnel) in a cowardly way behind masks and kidnaps. That soldier was defending himself and you are passing judgement when you are not even there? Did you know his platoon had one soldier killed because an insurgent's body was booby trapped? He won't be a smart soldier if he didn't do that, he will be a dead soldier.

Hehe there is a saying about war. War doesn't care who is right or wrong, only who is left.

by black panther

How is be-heading an innocent civilian Aid Worker defending your homeland???

Defending means defending against an attack does it not???

by montgomery gator

Al-Zarqawi (from Jordan) and the other terrorists are not defending their homeland, they are trying to restore Saddam Hussein to power. The ones defending their homeland are the Iraqi soldiers fighting alongside the US and other coalition soldiers to bring the terrorists to justice. Many brave Iraqis have fought alongside our troops to liberate Fallujah from the terrorist grip to bring them freedom. Those who oppose Saddam and the terrorists in Iraq are the ones fighting for their homeland.

by cortech

You are a worthless POS!!! Those ****** are defending their homeland against peaceful, volunteer CARE workers???!!! FU They are worthless thugs and bullies and have absolutely no compassion for life. How many of their own "innocent" people have they killed with car bombs???!!!

I am not trying to justfy the US soldiers actions in the above case, but we do not know what led up to his (in my opinion, stupid) actions, and makes ALL Americans look barbaric to the rest of the world.

And before you start up again Buckster, I DIDN'T vote for Bush!!! Can you read that??? Earth to Bucky!!! You are soooooo lucky we live in a country of free speech. If you lived in Iraq and talked about the government the way you do you (and probably your whole family) would have already been beheaded a looooong time ago. But, that would have been humane and justifiable I suppose, because they would have been defending their homeland against a possible terrorist.

by thechas

With the style and type of combat that the Muslim Extremists have been practicing, I find it difficult to blame the soldier until we have all of the facts.

From what I heard on NPR and BBC today, after the first group of Marines had cleared the building, snipper fire continued to come from that specific mosque.

As i see it at this point in time, the soldier was just using his best judgment to protect himself and the unit.

Like it or not, (and I don't) the US started this war, and we need to stay in Iraq until the Iraqi government is ready to defend itself.

Clearing the extremists out of Iraq is part and parcel to having fair and free elections in January.

Chas

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
With the style and type of combat that the Muslim Extremists have been practicing, I find it difficult to blame the soldier until we have all of the facts.
---- ---- ---- ---- ----

He was injured and unarmed. What more do you need to know - his faith?

re:
As i see it at this point in time, the soldier was just using his best judgment to protect himself and the unit.
-----

From an injured, unarmed man - slumped against the wall, groaning in pain?

The soldier was, unquestonably, using poor judgement - as are those who defend him.

by garion11

Were you there? I hope you get drafted and be forced to go. I bet you are the asshole that protested the Vietnam war and all wars by calling soldiers (who are under direct orders whether they agree with the political administration or not) baby killers aren't you? And I bet you think you are noble at the same time?

by trockii

I just fulfilled my enlistment in the Air Force. I was deployed from Nov 2003- March 2004 to Qatar. While I wasn't on the front lines, everyone that was going to or coming from went through my base. I heard stories about everything going on over there. The news does it's best to get ratings. It doesn't report ALL the facts. As for this story about the marine shooting an "unarmed" civilian. That's all the news reports. How would the story change if this "civilian" was playing dead with a RPG laying next to him and that marine passed by then the "civilian" jumped up and fired upon him? Would everyone still making a big deal about the Marine shooting him? I think not. Until you know ALL the details, which including myself don't know we can't make judgements on him. If I was in his same situation I couldn't tell you right that second what I would have done at that very second. Do you know what it takes to shoot and kill someone? It might not seem like a big deal, but I KNOW from talking to friends that HAVE killed, that it reeks havic on their minds and souls. They are doing what they HAVE to do to survive. They are not just shooting innocent bystanders like the news reports. If that was the case alot more people would be dieing. I am still in the Air Force Reserves and my unit is talking about deploying in March 05. I don't like the idea of going into war, but put in the situation I will kill to live. That's the same decision that Marine had to make and live with for the rest of his life. Hopefully I can go there and remain safe and make it back home without having to face the decision to kill or not to kill.

May GOD bless and be with all MY brothers and sisters over there. Come back home soon.

Rocky

by silvioandpauly

Why not shoot 'em all and let Allah sort them out. Isn't that what Radical ISlam is all about?

It's war - just like the bombs we dropped in Japan that killed almost everyone.

by jardinier

For a start, it is not a war. It was a pre-emptive strike on Iraq.

It has been argued at this website that it "is a war" because it is merely a continuation of "Desert Storm."

Now that the original stated reasons for the invasion have been proven false (No WMDs, no link between Hussein and bin Laden) and Hussein has been captured and his two sons killed, why IS America still in Iraq?

Because the US Administration has this totally unrealistic agenda of establishing a democracy in the Middle East, allegedly for the benefit of the ignorant "sand-niggers" (an extremely objectionable term) but actually of course to facilitate access to Middle East oil.

As Bush has surrounded himself with "friends" in the reshuffle of the administration, the attitude of the US will become even more hawkish than it has been up to date.

As for the soldier shooting the unarmed, wounded Iraqi, it was stated on the Australian news last night that an American serviceman had been killed by a booby-trapped body. Well if I was in the situation of the American soldier, I am pretty sure that my emotions would at least for the moment override any reservations I might have about correct military procedure.

I would hope that, when the soldier faces a court-martial, the specifics of the situation would be taken into consideration when choosing an appropriate punishment.

by garion11

Based on the previous situation faced by the soldier(s) these people were booby trapping the dead bodies or faking that they are dead (which the soldier actually uttered here)...so based on that scenario if any soldier would be a fool not to do what he did. They are not out there to play nice, they are there to win a war.

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
Isn't that what Radical ISlam is all about?
----- ----- ----- ----- -----

The Iraqi people are not Radical Islamists. They're left-wing liberals. Religious nuts hate them for their moderate stance.

Saddam's Vice President was a Christian for God's sake.

by jamesrl

Its just too easy and simple to call the Iraqi people one thing or another.

Saddam's regime was "liberal" in no way I understand the term. They were not religious - not radical Islamic - but most of them belonged to one religious faction - the Sunnis. They were more tribal than religious. But, the regime did not represent the majority of Iraqi citizens, the majority of whom were Shia. It was only through brutal repression that Saddam and his regime kept power.

James

by rayeni

Bucky, I am not trying to be contentious, but is this an IT forum or a political forum?

by garion11

Learn the difference. Fuck em. They don't follow any geneva convention rules, they are not soldiers and certainly do not fall in that category. The rules of Geneve convention do not apply here. In your blind hatred of the Bush administration and Republicans you are defending anything and everything. Be careful how far you follow that road.

Solders are more noble than these barbarians. I have more respect for Red Army, Nazis and Vietcong then these barbarians. Murdering civlians behind masks is not freedom fighting.

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
they are not soldiers
----- ----- ----- ----- -----

Yes, they are.

re:
Solders are more noble than these barbarians.
----- ----- ----- -----

The soldier who murdered that injured, unarmed man is noble, but his victim is a barbarian?

That's a very barbaric (and *Republican*) idea of nobility.

--
"Clearly the fault lies with the troops in the field, and NOT with the president" - Giuliani

by garion11

You call the American troops murderers and the "injured, anarmed man" a "victim" (who a moment ago had a gun shooting at these soldiers). You place the interests of America second to the interests of anyone else. You are a communist asshole who has to clearly stop smoking crack. Keep up this rehtoric and I can't wait to see how far the Democrats fall in 2006 and 2008. Bring it on Bucky!!!

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
They are not out there to play nice, they are there to win a war.
----- ----- ----- ----- -----

The war was won over a year ago. By continuing to slaughter injured, unarmed Iraqi freedom fighters indicates that *winning the war* is not the goal here. Killing Iraqis is the goal.

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
You are defending terrorists, the same people who are beheading civlians (not the US military personnel) in a cowardly way behind masks and kidnaps.
--- --- --- --- ---

What makes naplaming civillians any less terroristic than a simple, quick beheading.

by garion11

they do it on purpose, we (most countries) do our best to avoid them. Thats the difference. When Abu Gharib broke out, look how we court martialed our own soldiers, did you see "their" community put on trial any terrorists?? Of course not!!!

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
When Abu Gharib broke out, look how we court martialed our own soldiers, did you see "their" community put on trial any terrorists??
----- ----- ----- ----- -----

The real shame in that is that their authority to torture prisoners came from the Republican Leadership - and they have NOT been put on trial for their crimes.

----
"Clearly the fault lies with the troops in the field, and NOT with the President" - Giuliani

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
Were you there?
---- ---- ---- ---- ----

No, but I saw it on TV. You should watch the video before you defend the murderer.

It's not like it's a unique situation. LOTS of US soldiers have been charged with murder, torture, rape and other Crimes against Humanity.

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
You place the interests of America second to the interests of anyone else.
---- ---- ---- ---- ----

You think a soldier murdering an unarmed and injured man is in America's interests? How is that in America's interest?

by cortech

Since you obviously feel so stringly about it, I'm sure we could take up a collection here to send you over there so you can stand up and fight with the poor opressed "freedom fighters". I'll even send you a ski mask.

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
send you over there so you can stand up and fight
---- ---- ---- ---- ---- ----

That would be fine, except for the fact that I'm opposed to the war.

Since you support it, from waaay back in the rear, I'm sure there's work for *you* there, but certainly not for me.

by cortech

Since you obviously feel so strongly about it, I'm sure we could take up a collection here to send you over there so you can stand up and fight with the poor oppressed "freedom fighters". I'll even send you a ski mask.

by nd_it

You weren't there, but already passing judgement on someone. THe reporter that was there even said about the soldier has just watched his buddy die from a booby trapped body and he himself had been just returned to duty after being shot in the face! Good for him, I would have popped that SOB insurgent too. If you are so big into defending these freedom fighters that shoot aid workers in the head on camera behind closed doors and behead truck drivers and dump their bodies in the streets, by all means go and help them, I will let the Marines know you are coming.

by garion11

He wasn't "murdering" an unarmed guy, this guy was armed just a few minutes ago and even if he wasn't, these insurgents have been known to booby trap bodies and fake their own death. A soldier with your so called "righteous" attitude will get his/her platoon destroyed if he plays it like that. I can't believe we are even discussing this, but leave it up to a Liberal to blame America and her troops first, without considering all the facts and situations.

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
can't believe we are even discussing this, but leave it up to a Liberal to blame America and her troops first
---- ---- ---- ---- ----

I don't blame the soldier himself for being a murderer. I blame the people who put him there and made him a murderer.

We liberals don't blame the troops. It's the NeoCons (like Giuliani) who do that.

--
"Clearly the fault lies with the troops in the field, and NOT with the President" - Giuliani

by jamesrl

The Sunnis, the minority in Iraq, may long for Saddam's return, but the Shia majority would never allow it. If the US suddenly withdrew there would be a power vacuum, and these two groups would likely have a civil war(which could be bloodier than the current conflict). Opposition to the US is the only thing that unites these groups.

James

by jdclyde

After following the "discussion" I have noticed a few things.

1) Bucky isn't and won't listen to anything you have to say that doesn't agree with his/her preconceved point of view.

2) Buck is one of the extreamist that thinks America is evil and hates it.

3) Anyone who calls someone who beheads unarmed civilians a "freedom fighter" can not be engaged in an intellegent conversation.

Luckily a large part of the Democratic party feels differently than Buck along with the support of the Republican party. This puts poor buck in a small group of people listing to NPR, wringing their hands about how evil we all are and how nobel the terroists are.

After going back and following His prior discussions I can see that he is quick to through out words to justify the freedom fighters while condeming anything that he disagrees with. In another political post he started on this Tech board he goes off on a rant about people being anti-muslim because someone made the correct statement about problems with extremist islamist. Just like there is problems with extreme christians or any other religion or belief system.

Not all muslims are bad, just like not all Americans are bad.

But your poisonous socialist rambling have no place on a Tech board.

I am sure if you look you will find a lot of blogs where your views will be welcome. Here we would like to discuss the Tech industry.

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
I am sure if you look you will find a lot of blogs where your views will be welcome. Here we would like to discuss the Tech industry.
----- ----- ----- ----- -----

Nobody's stopping you. God's greatest gift to man is "free will". Use it.

by trockii

I just fulfilled my enlistment in the Air Force. I was deployed from Nov 2003- March 2004 to Qatar. While I wasn't on the front lines, everyone that was going to or coming from went through my base. I heard stories about everything going on over there. The news does it's best to get ratings. It doesn't report ALL the facts. As for this story about the marine shooting an "unarmed" civilian. That's all the news reports. How would the story change if this "civilian" was playing dead with a RPG laying next to him and that marine passed by then the "civilian" jumped up and fired upon him? Would everyone still making a big deal about the Marine shooting him? I think not. Until you know ALL the details, which including myself don't know we can't make judgements on him. If I was in his same situation I couldn't tell you right that second what I would have done at that very second. Do you know what it takes to shoot and kill someone? It might not seem like a big deal, but I KNOW from talking to friends that HAVE killed, that it reeks havic on their minds and souls. They are doing what they HAVE to do to survive. They are not just shooting innocent bystanders like the news reports. If that was the case alot more people would be dieing. I am still in the Air Force Reserves and my unit is talking about deploying in March 05. I don't like the idea of going into war, but put in the situation I will kill to live. That's the same decision that Marine had to make and live with for the rest of his life. Hopefully I can go there and remain safe and make it back home without having to face the decision to kill or not to kill.

May GOD bless and be with all OUR brothers and sisters over there. Come back home soon.

Rocky

by jamesrl

You ask us to not make snap judgements about things that might reflect badly on US soldiers, but you yourself make a snap judgement about reported incidents not happening. Thats a double standard.

What I do know is that soldiers are people, and people are widely variable. Some great, some bad. Lots of room in between. I respect the sacrifice they make. I don't lionize them either. No one believed My Lai was possible either - there was lots of denial until the inquiry came out. I was suprised and horrified by what Canadian soldiers did in Somalia(caught an unarmed man sneaking into camp and tortured him till he died). My father in law, who was retired from the Canadian Army, was not so surprised.

I am not saying that the soldier was some kind of monster, or comparing what he did to My Lai, or Somalia. He was obviously under a lot of strain, and I assume that the inquiry will take that into account. He may indeed have had cause, or may have been in such an altered state that he didn't make a clear judgement.

We are all tempted to make snap judgements about such things - but it helps no one.

James

by protiusx

I had resolved not to respond to Bucky?s schizophrenic dribble again. However here I find myself putting thought to writing and wondering all the while why I continue to argue with this intellectually inane lump of who-pudding.
It is easy for one who has never served in the military and watches the news clips from Al-Jezerra or the ?Commissars News Network? while firmly ensconced in ones chair eating bon bon?s to pass judgment on the Marines who are fighting in this engagement. Bucky hasn?t had anyone shoot at him lately, or kill his best friend while pretending to be dead. Bucky hasn?t had to deal with the so-called-freedom-fighters who use women and children as human shields or raise a white flag in order to get close enough to the Marines and then open fire.
I was a Marine. I know the sacrifice these men and women are facing and the hardships they endure and my heart aches for them in this their hour of despair. All they have is each other. There is a camaraderie that comes from being in combat that no civilian will ever know, comprehend or understand. I along with millions of other Americans will stand by this Marine and we will not allow FOOLS like Bucky to down play his valiant sacrifice for any reason. I have said this before and Bucky if you?re listening ? YOU DISGUST ME!

Semper Fidelis = Forever Faithful

by montgomery gator

All I can say to you is to express my deepest heartfelt thanks for your service to our country. I have nothing but respect for the USMC and other branches of the US military. A classmate of mine from college was a USMC captain who was shot down and tortured by Saddam's thugs during Desert Storm. I thank God he survived, and he is now a full colonel in the USMC.

by packet spoofer

Bucky has been ABDUCTED BY ALIENS!!!!!
Check out this link....

http://setiathome2.ssl.berkeley.edu/fcgi-bin/fcgi?cmd=view_feedback&id=17364

I believe that judging from the out of this worldly nature of buckys recent rants, the only plausible explanation is that he has actually found aliens, and in doing so, was abducted by them, and he is actually now speaking on their behalf...
So fellow techrepublic members...now is the time to BREAK OUT THE TINFOIL HATS!!!!!!!!!
LOL

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
If the US were to do as you say and pick up and leave there would be a power vacuum in the region that would result in the deaths of a whole lot more innocent people.
----- ----- ----- ----- -----

That's what's happening with the US soldiers running Iraq. There's a power vaccuum that is resulting in the deaths of a whole lot of innocent people.

Since the before beginning of this nation, Militant Christians and White Supremists have been insisting, as you do, that without White Christian leadership, dark skineed and non-Christian people fall to barbarism.

It's revolting.

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
How is be-heading an innocent civilian Aid Worker defending your homeland???
----- ----- ----- ----- -----

The same way raping, beating and torturing prisoners to death "liberates" the Iraqis people.

Compared to what the US is doing to the Iraqi people - beheading is downright kind.

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
Al-Zarqawi (from Jordan) and the other terrorists are not defending their homeland, they are trying to restore Saddam Hussein to power.
---- ---- ---- ---- ----

That's just downright wrong. The Islamists hated Hussein because he's a liberal.

He let women go around uncovered, driving cars, holding jobs - even government posts. He hired Christians into his administration and encouraged his people to travel abroad for university education.

The terrorists are not there to restore Saddam, but simply to repel the antagonsitic US Death Squads and torture brigades.

by montgomery gator

Bucky-Ball said:
"The terrorists are not there to restore Saddam, but simply to repel the antagonsitic US Death Squads and torture brigades."
....
You must be talking about the situation in the Bizarro World you live in. There are no US Death Squads and Torture Brigades. The US Forces, along with their Iraqi and coalition allies, are there to stop the terrorist death squads and torture brigades, for example, like the Al-Zarqawi torture rooms they discoverd in Fallujah. Al-Zarqawi and his minions are using the same tactics as your beloved Saddam Hussein. In your Bizarro World, it sounds like Saddam Hussein was a saint. Saddam, Al-Zarqawi, and Osama Bin Laden are Birds of a Feather, who are united by their hatred of the USA and our free, multicultural, capitalist, society. At least you admitted this time that Al-Zarqawi et al are terrorists instead of calling them freedom fighters. You refer to Saddam as a liberal. Well, Saddam Hussein hates America, so he has that in common with most other liberals, like Michael Moore and yourself.

by protiusx

Ha! Beat Bucky to the punch. Oh wait 100,000 innocent Iraqi dead, Bush worshiping death squads, NEOCON Nazis, red-neck Militant Christians, blah, blah, blah. Did I miss anything? Oh yeah, Protius is stupid! ;o)

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
There are no US Death Squads and Torture Brigades.
----- ----- ----- ----- ----- -----

That would be SO much easier to believe - if innocent Iraqis weren't being trotured and killed by them.

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
Those ****** are defending their homeland against peaceful, volunteer CARE workers?
---- ---- ---- ---- ----

The unarmed, injured man was not attacking anyone when he was murdered. Not even volunteer CARE workers.

It's a disorganized, chaotic bloody war - and you seem to support it. If ya wanna stop getting what you're getting, stop doing what you're doing.

It's interesting how you defend the murder of defenseless people - as a way of opposing the murder of defenseless people. It just don't make no sense.

Clearly, you have no problem with the murder of innocent people - so what's your *real* agenda here?

by black panther

Defending Terrorists be-heading inoccent civilians and aid workers who are their helping the iraqi people??

Are you saying there is no difference between good and bad, a terrorist and a civilian.

There is good and bad in every country - is their not??

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
Defending Terrorists be-heading inoccent civilians and aid workers who are their helping the iraqi people??
---- ---- ---- ---- ----

Speaking out against Bush's state sponsorship of terrorism is not "defending terrorists".

by black panther

I supposed we all have to take this thread as a non-serious comedy as I would say by Bucky's comments he would not be serious and is trying to get a 'reaction' - which he has done a good job at!

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
They are not just shooting innocent bystanders like the news reports.
----- ----- ----- -----

Actually, many Iraqis have died when US soldiers have fired into crowds of civillian. It's been confirmed by their commanders.

re:
Hopefully I can go there and remain safe and make it back home without having to face the decision to kill or not to kill.
----- ----- ----- ----- -----

Once you choose to go to war, you've chosen to kill. To think otherwise is just insane.

by protiusx

Because according to you anyone who disagrees with you is a stupid, hate-filled, mindless, NEO-CON, militant Christian, 100,000 dead people lovin?, fool who should be thrown in jail with the rest of the extremists. You?re the only rational one right Bucky?

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

re:
You?re the only rational one right Bucky?
----- ----- ----- ----- -----

Between you and me, yeah.

But if you think I'm the only one disgusted by Militant Christians such as yourself - YOU MIGHT BE A REDNECK!

by jardinier

Here is the full text of the interview, below is an extract.

http://www.abc.net.au/lateline/content/2004/s1245842.htm

Now, millions of TV viewers have seen yesterday's horrifying video of a US marine evidently killing a wounded man in cold blood.

Is that evidence of murder, is it evidence of a war crime or is there another category of justice for soldiers who kill enemy wounded after a battle?

GEOFFREY ROBERTSON, UN JUDGE AND HUMAN RIGHTS LAWYER: Well, it's evidence, yes, what lawyers would say is prima facie evidence, which means there is other evidence to be heard, particularly the marine's story.

But, look, it's been a war crime for 500 years.

Back in the English Civil War in Cromwell's time, armies were never permitted, and soldiers were prosecuted, if they killed enemy who had surrendered or who, what is termed horde a combat, which is a French term meaning, in effect, "out of action because of serious injury".

So, on the face of it, this is a breach of the Geneva Conventions.

On the other hand, you've got to consider the pressures that the soldier was under, what was going through his mind at the time.

There is evidence that mujahideen had been booby-trapping themselves, strapping compression mines, and a number of marines have been killed by dead bodies that have exploded.

So you've got to factor all of that in to deciding whether there's the moral culpability in the case of that individual marine.

But there are wider issues, I think.

This isn't as serious as Abu Ghraib which indicated systematic torture.

It is serious, though, because there is the possibility that the rules of engagement which provide for what is termed "clearing ground" may permit rather more permissively than international law does, the pumping of a couple of bullets into a seemingly dead body or a body that twitches and that's something that I'm sure the American investigation, and you've got to understand that the American military are very good at investigating and they do court martial people where there is clear evidence of war crimes.

That will bring that to light.

TONY JONES: You could argue - we'll come back to that in a moment - but you could argue that soldiers who've been killing in heated and brutal close combat are not in their right minds, in fact.

Could that be a mitigating circumstance?

GEOFFREY ROBERTSON: Well, there is some suggestion that this particular soldier may have been put back into action too quickly after he had been himself wounded in a previous engagement and that has to be factored in to a fair consideration of his state of mind and, I mean, you've got also to protect the Geneva Convention principle that those who have surrendered or who are out of action through serious injury have to be treated humanely.

I mean, that's been the case ever since Breaker Morant was prosecuted for that.

There were problems about the fairness of his trial and Kitchener's complicity.

But killing prisoners, killing those who have surrendered and are in no state to fight back is a serious matter.

But then the camera doesn't tell the whole story and it's the whole story that needs to be considered, particularly the pressure on the individual marine and what he assumed from a movement of a body, a twitch or a reach perhaps for a gun or, indeed, to detonate the compression mine that has in some cases been used by the mujahideen in precisely these circumstances.

by trockii

Re: Once you choose to go to war, you've chosen to kill. To think otherwise is just insane.

I don't choose to go to war. I choose to serve MY country. If I am ordered to war I go, by no means is it choice to leave my family and friends.

Rocky

by garion11

Understand that clearly. Giuliani is more liberal than John Kerry is in his support for Gay rights, gun control, and other social issues. It is possible Giuliani is Republican in fiscal issues...but your perception is so warped (for whatever reason) that anyone that supports "conservative" issues you label them as NeoCons, lol. Shows an incredible lack of depth and intelligence. I am neither Christian nor Jewish, and I voted for Bush...*GASP* how am I a NeoCon dude?

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

It's a real failure of the Bush Regime that so MANY people throughout the world have joined up with al Quaeda. Not just radicals islamists, but more moderate folks as well.

Bush Republicans have been very successful to INCREASE the threat from terrorism - too bad the goal was to decrease it.

by packet spoofer

over the past thirty years dude. Wake up and smell the car bomb! You just do not have the stomach to face what must be done, because you are a spineless weasel and I pity you!

by bucky kaufman (mcsd)

True - it has been on the rise. Unfortunately, under Bush, it thrives. Probably because he pumped $200M into promoting the terrorism industry.

Since Bush took office, Americans have been killed by terrorists every single day, day after day, month after month.

It would be nice to get back to the point where terrorism is just a nuisance, eh?

by aldanatech

The global managing editor of British news agency Reuters said today the US military was entirely to blame for the deaths of three of its employees in Iraq since the start of the war there in March 2003, an allegation disputed by the Pentagon.

"All of them were killed by the American army," Reuters chief David Schlesinger told reporters on the sidelines of a media conference in the southern Portuguese resort of Vilamoura, Portuguese national news agency Lusa reported.

"There is no understanding on the part of the US military regarding the exercise of journalism," he said, according to the agency.

"We can't run the risk that journalists will become targets (in Iraq). We must learn the lessons from these tragic cases."

Two Reuters photographers and a cameraman are among the more than 60 war-related deaths of media workers recorded in Iraq.

The most recent death occurred in the Iraqi city of Ramadi on November 1.

The US military said a cameraman killed there while on assignment for Reuters died in a gunbattle between marines and insurgents, but the Iraqi man's colleagues and family have said they believe he was shot by a US sniper.

Another Reuters cameraman, a Ukrainian citizen, was killed in April 2003 when a US army tank fired on the Palestine Hotel in Baghdad.

A cameraman from Spain's Telecinco television network was also killed in the strike, which injured three other reporters.

In October 2003 a Palestinian cameraman for Reuters was killed near Abu Ghraib prison during a shootout.

The US military has denied direct responsibility for those deaths as well.

Pentagon spokesman Bryan Whitman told the media conference via satellite from Washington that those incidents were inevitable in a war.

"Media coverage in places of conflict is always dangerous," Lusa quoted him as saying.

He put the blame for the two deaths at the Palestine Hotel on Iraqi troops resisting the US invasion, whom he accused of using civilian structures for military purposes, leading to confusion about what is a legitimate target.

Journalists at the Palestine Hotel, including many working for US-based organisations, had informed US military authorities that they were using the hotel as a base.

Source:

http://www.heraldsun.news.com.au/common/story_page/0,5478,11433640%255E1702,00.html

by packet spoofer

planet buuyaaah, but on earth where the rest of us live, it has been a huge problem for 30 years and the Bush "regime" is finally fighting back....your strategy didn't work....so again I say wake up and smell the car bomb....

by aldanatech

I just found out on Reuters that senior U.S. Army generals in Iraq were told in December 2003 that special operations troops and CIA personnel were suspected of abusing Iraqi prisoners -- four months before the scale of prisoner abuse became public in television photos that shocked the world.

The December 2003 report on suspected prisoner abuse, confirmed by U.S. officials on Wednesday, also showed the U.S. leadership in Iraq had clues about prisoner treatment before photographs of detainees being abused at Abu Ghraib jail emerged within the military in the middle of January. But officials disputed the notion that the warning had been ignored.

"It's indicative that there were some troubling signs, and actions were taken early on. It got overcome by other investigations (after the Abu Ghraib abuse became known). But it was not ignored," an Army official said.

When the abuse photographs, including ones showing a U.S. female soldier holding a naked prisoner on a leash, were shown on U.S. television, they prompted calls by political opponents and human rights activists for Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld to resign. The Pentagon said it was investigating but the existence of the 2003 report was not revealed.

The report by retired Col. Stuart Herrington, requested by the senior U.S. military intelligence officer in Iraq, found that some prisoners turned over to the U.S. military by members of an elite task force had injuries suggesting they may have been beaten while in custody, said the defense officials, who asked not to be named. The suspected abuse detailed in the Herrington report did not take place in Abu Ghraib.

The report also provided an early warning about the practice by some U.S. forces of keeping "ghost detainees" -- prisoners kept off the books and hidden from the International Committee of the Red Cross.

Herrington found that the task force, a mixture of Army and Navy special operations troops and CIA personnel searching for high-ranking Iraqi fugitives and weapons of mass destruction, had taken prisoners to an undisclosed interrogation facility in order to keep their actions secret, officials said.

The report also found some of the detention activities at the time may have been "technically" unlawful, officials said.

A defense official said Maj. Gen. Barbara Fast, intelligence chief for the U.S. military command in Iraq, asked Herrington, already retired from the military, to examine the situation at Abu Ghraib, which at the time was crowded with prisoners and facing attacks from insurgents.

The official said that while looking into Abu Ghraib in December, Herrington learned that U.S. medical personnel were seeing prisoners arriving with injuries that suggested they had been beaten. The official said neither Herrington nor witnesses he interviewed personally had seen task force members beating a prisoner.

'TROUBLING SIGNS'

Another official said Fast notified Army Lt. Gen. Ricardo Sanchez, the top commander in Iraq, who asked U.S. Central Command, responsible for military operations in the region, to investigate. The official said an investigation was done, but was unable to provide the findings.

The Navy said in September the military had charged members of an elite Navy SEAL unit with abusing prisoners in Iraq, including a man who died in November 2003 at Abu Ghraib after arriving with severe head injuries.

Additional official reports on U.S. military detention operations were expected soon.

One examining detainee treatment by elite U.S. special forces in Iraq conducted by Army Brig. Gen. Richard Formica could be released sometime after Jan. 1, an official said.

A preliminary draft of a broad assessment of U.S. military detention and interrogation practices conducted by Vice Adm. Tom Church, the Navy's inspector general, is being reviewed, and could be finalized within weeks, the official said.

Source:

http://reuters.com/newsArticle.jhtml;jsessionid=YDJIQHR4ZHHT0CRBAELCFFA?type=topNews&storyID=6970806

This discussion is closed to new replies.