Discussion Locked

Value of ethics in medical informatics

0 helpful
1 reply
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Has your organization determined ethical guidelines for medical informatics? What do you think about creating an ethics officer position in your organization? Share your comments about determining ethics for medical informatics, as discussed in the Sept. 30 e-newsletter.

If you haven't subscribed to our free Healthcare IT e-newsletter, sign up today!
http://nl.com.com/acct_mgmt.jsp?brand=techrepublic

1 reply

by drbwaugh

Being a retired physician currently an IT manager for a small medical billing company, I felt compelled to comment on this issue.
Personally, I beleive that Ethics, whether those of a physician or someone providing medical information, cannot be defined by company policy, legislation, or managers. Monitored, yes, and the idea of providing information and guidance is great. But the idea of regulating or even closely defining ethical behaviour is very shaky ground indeed.
As IT personnel and managers we work daily with systems that respond to precisely defined logic and operate with parameters that we set. This type of thinking is necessary to our jobs. The problem here is that the ultimate source of the information in this case comes not from the systems, but the "loose nut behind the keyboard" namely the personnel. Unfortunately (or perhaps fortunately) ethics at it's source cannot and, I believe, should not be regulated from outside the individual.
Yes, it is a serious problem and yes it needs to be addressed, but great care must be taken as to how it is addressed.
My reasons for retiring as a health care provider have everything to do with ethics. Without getting into a tedious personal rant, I felt that with the current cycle of provider, insurance and patient, along with input from attorneys and courts, it was becoming impossible to provide the care that my ethics dictated I provide for my patients.
Information, by itself, cannot be either ethical or unethical. The more information that a patient can gather about his condition, the better. It is the context, format and delivery that give it definition. It can be wrong, biased, misleading, subjective or objective, based on fact or fiction. Many physicians have found in recent years that their patients, because of sources like the internet, actually ask questions and expect answers, rather than blindly following assigned protocols. Some physicians and others feel threatened by this; others welcome it. And it then becomes the physician's job to answer those questions and educate their patients.
(the origin of the word "doctor" is "teacher")This can be inconvenient, uncomfortable, or even embarrassing, for sometimes the questions and answers can lead an open minded provider to change either diagnosis or treatment.
This topic edges on subjects like censorship and free speech, as well as patients rights and responsibilities, along with responsibilities of providers and insurers. The trend in the last 50 years is to try and quantify and group patients and their diagnoses and treatments. This is fine and necessary, but can only be taken so far. Patients with the same condition can require very different types of treatment and diagnosis. Just like ethical behaviour, it ultimately comes down to the individual.

This discussion is closed to new replies.