Discussion Locked

Vigilantes Mutilate Phishing Sites

0 helpful
41 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

May 19, 2005

Vigilantes Mutilate Phishing Sites

Courtesy of TechWeb News
Online vigilantes are taking matters into their own hands, and defacing some phishing sites to warn off the naive, a U.K. Web monitoring firm said Thursday.
According to Netcraft, a phishing site that posed as PayPal.com was recently defaced with a page created using the open-source OpenOffice application suite. The page read "WARNING -- THIS WAS A SCAM SITE" and "site killed courtesy of sickophish."

Another phishing site that imitated NatWest Bank, was also recently defaced. This site's home page was replaced by one attributed to The Lad Wrecking Crew, a group that Netcraft said had been involved in earlier defacements. The group even maintains a Web site with 11 Windows wallpaper designs that can be slapped over hijacked phishing sites. The wallpapers have titles such as "Scammer Terminated" and "Fake Bank Down."

"Phishing sites are commonly hosted on compromised Web servers, where lack of security allows fraudsters to access machines and upload phishing content," Netcraft noted in a statement. "If a fraudster exploits these security weaknesses without securing the machine, then online vigilantes are just as likely to exploit the weaknesses to replace the fraudulent content."

Although Netcraft noted that defacing a site, even a phishing site, is at best, "questionable," it went on to say "so far it's reasonable to assume that only the fraudsters themselves have been disadvantaged."

41 replies

by dr dij

started discussions I already started a thread on.
YOu seem to get a alot more posts than me, possibly because I act too PO'd at the stupid people. Well, doesn't matter, I don't have an ego in the regular sense.

I bow to your mellowness, wisdom and popularity :)

by deepsand

Did you start a Discussion on this, or were you referring to a post in a related Discussion?

by dr dij

No need to aplogize. If they go by in new discussions, and not many posts, will never see them again. Just shows we both read relevant stuff and may thingk alike on some topics

by choppit

Part of me applauds these people for taking a stand on behalf of the public whilst part of me suspects that these individuals are also behind less honourable deeds. When I receive phishing mails relating to services I use, I report them to the spoofed site owners in the (naive?) hope that they can actually do something to stop it. I then submit bogus details to the phisher in the hope that it will make them work that little bit harder.

by deepsand

1) Those that are both capable & willing to do so also have the requisite resources to seek ill gotten gain.

In fact, I should not be surprised to learn that such might be the equivalent of a gang fight over turf. Remember that we've already seen such break out between the creators of viruses.

2) As for reporting incidents of phishing, I've quit. To date, I've yet to receive so much as a mere acknowledgement of a single one.

I seem to recall another Discussion where a regular postor reported that he had actually been rebuffed on one such occasion!

by jmgarvin

I've gotten a ton of email from "pay-pal," "e-bay," and "gmail" telling the hapless user their account is suspended until they change their passwords.

With the current DNS cache poisioning, I see some security nightmares brewing. I think we are quickly reaching a boiling point where it will be like Mad Max on the internet.

by roger99a

This is another reason we need public lists like the DNSBL's for blocking web sites, too. Then we could block all kinds of stuff like spyware, phishing sites, porn (if you want to), gambling sites. I would like to see it tied to a Linux firewall with automatic daily updates so we could block hackers and junk mail and all the nasty stuff we get from the internet. That would definitly be worth paying for.

by dr dij

if they did this instant they got a phishing email then they're helping STOP the phishing!

by jerry~beans&bytes

as one might expect of a member of the online (vs. brick and mortar) community, PayPal not only responded to my recent phishing report, but they actually included info in the response that indicated that they were acting on MY input.

by bfilmfan

I like to go to the phishing sites and have the following fun items:

Submit Richard Nixon's Social Security Number for mine.

Input the address of the Justice Department in Washington, DC as my home address.

And in the field where it asks for passwords, I make scatalogical comments about their momma.

by jdclyde

I like that!

Kind of like when telemarketers call I sound real interested for a minute then ask them to please hold.

I then set the phone down and walk away.

BWAAHAAAHAAAAHAAAAAAAAAA!

by eteller

is that people will scream for their "freedom" to view these sites and take their own action or inaction however they darn well please and you better not try and "protect" them... yadda yadda... you can't win for losing sometimes.

by roger99a

I'm talking about a corporate environment and I have blocked lots of sites. The only ones I've gotten complaints about is Yahoo mail, and it's still blocked in the name of virus protection.

by dr dij

they're usually hacked sites
and the orig owners don't want you to see hacked site

by dr dij

says m$ has setup dozens of 'webmonkeys', pcs that randomly browse major site after being re-imaged. They are using this to detect if certain configs get hacked or pick up trojans, spyware.

And some anti-adware companies (at least one) have lists of bad sites they block (with paid vsn I believe). Probably not terribly comprehensive. Would be good to have realtime list that people could contribute to.

Contributed sites, if not already in the list, would be verified by triggering a 'clean' PC to browse them to verify driveby installs.

by husp1

But instead of just putting it down you MUST think of a nice location to place the phone. My personal favorite location is the bare top of the toilet tank face down after a few of my flush and fills they're gone!!

by jdclyde

It isn't to chase them away, but to waste their time in return for wasting My time.

If they are sitting around waiting for me to come back, then they are not bugging anyone else.

Think of it as a community service that I am providing so selflessly.

by deepsand

Given that I've no time to regularly allot to the boards, it is my practice to look at the 1st page of New Discussions only; rarely do I have the time to scan more deeply.

No doubt I've missed a good number of discussions that might have been of interest.

by deepsand

leveling off.

The current problem is not with the volume of phishing and pharming attempts, but that they are becoming increasing sophisticated.

An increased probability of success, at the same or somewhat smaller number of attempts, will result in a greater yield for the purveyors of such.

by jmgarvin

Hmmmm...I see your point, but it got me to thinking about stopping the attempts (because they are getting pretty good at doing this). Is it ethical to hack their site (the point of the thread)?

I would say off hand no, but then I think about it...There is really no way to police the phishers, right? So stopping them by defacing or DDoS or more sophicicated attacks might be a viable answer.

How do you stop the bad guys? Do you put on your gray hat and squash them before they rob from someone?

Is there a better way to stop phishing?

by deepsand

The effective [i]public[/i] control of crime requires that the criminals be within the [i]jurisdiction[/i] of an [i]actively engaged[/i] law enforcement agency; absent such, there can be no control beyond that which private individuals seek to undertake.

Given that Internet activity is without borders, public efforts to thwart criminal activities requires an extraordinary degree of co-operation between sovereigns, which is not easily achieved; witness the case with enforcement here of the various states' Use taxes, which involves but the states of a single nation!

Until then, the Internet will truly remain today's Wild West, where individuals have only themselves to rely on for their own defense.

by dr dij

by phishers, so if it was a break in, they've effectively stopped it by putting up 'this is a scam' to replace the phishers data collection page.

and if it was not a valid biz site but one setup by phishers to begin with, then they've stopped it with harming a legitimate biz.

by deepsand

not whether or not the site in question was a legitimate one compromised by phishers.

I.e., the "vigilantes" may in fact be phishers attacking competing phishers.

by deepsand

Unless and until such are administered by a party generally accepted by all, one whose operation is both transparent & subject to public review, blocking lists will continue to be both subjective & Balkanized.

by roger99a

That's why I would want it open source and categorized. I would theorize (sp?) that it would be more effective than the spamlist RBL's because spyware depends on long term communications to count and track web usage. Spammers can hijack a PC, send out a million emails and move on. Spyware requires frequent communication. Spybot already does this with it's immunize function.

by deepsand

SpyBot, for example uses centralized definitons of threats, but deploys the defenses in a de-centralized manner.

But, as is the case with AV software as well, their definitions, and those of similar products, are not universally accepted.

Hence there is no single solution available.

To be effective, a single source centralized system seems to be in order.

by jdclyde

I had all kinds of problems when I ended up on a CBL list for "suspicious traffic" that they would not identify.

Just that my linux server had mydoom or some lame excuse.

My firewall was set to deny all outbound SMTP from everything but our mail server so it wasn't coming from an infected PC on the LAN.

And being a NAT addess, the outbound didn't match the inbound address.

Way too many places that people can make mistakes and not be accountable to anyone.

by dr dij

to forward the email tot hem

ebay is abuse@ebay.com,
paypal is spoof@paypal.com
(do I have these backwords?)

address is on their website

by dr dij

are vulnerable to
a) attacks, witness RBL being ddosed by spammers
b) legislative whims (supposed they declared that a gov't run RBL would be turned off due to campaign contribs e.g. from that horrid adware company, while NGO's are not as subject to either legislative or fiscal pressures of taxpayer funds)
c) it is good to have multiple sources for this to hash out slightly dift approaches

by dr dij

their act of destroying one phishing attempt is NOT phishing, and in fact doing good by stopping a phishing site. I don't see the problem.

They could be adware people, hacker groups, vigilantes, child pornographers but the act of taking down a phishing site is unrelated to what they do somewhere else, and is good.

Who's to say a burglar can't stop a person from being mugged?

by deepsand

In order to best avoid false positives, of the sort that now plaque those who find themselves falsely blocked, a centralized authoritative body is required.

The execution can, and should, be distributed, so as to provide for a more fail-safe system.

Consider the DNS system as a model.

by deepsand

So long as there's no collateral damage, if it's a turf war, it has my blessing.

However, one must always beware of the Law of Unintended Consequences.

In the turf wars between virus writers, such greatly escalated the number of innocent victims.

by dr dij

so some bureaucrat would quickly remove you from a banned list? Suppose instead they wrongly called the FBI to shut you down when it wasn't really from your server.

There's all sorts of problems with govt in this. With a private list you're not required to subscribe. Suppose ISPs were required to use a list containing your email server that had falsely been banned.

I searched for my domain, was curious. It turned up on one list banned for spam. This is really odd as my actual domain's email server has NEVER sent a SINGLE EMAIL out. However spammers like it as it is short.

I asked the guy how he knew it was really from my hosting site. He had no answer. He banned it as it was convenient to block actual spam faked from somewhere else. If I actually needed to send email out from it, this could be a problem. Gov't RBL systems would be worse.

by deepsand

The vast majority of standards are defined, implemented & maintained by industry itself.

There is no reason why this matter could not & should not be addressed in a similar fashion.

This discussion is closed to new replies.