Vista, is it really worth it?
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Windows Forum
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by comp1systems
It appears that alot of companies are finding that they
cannot keep up with the speed of Microsoft. For reasons
being they cannot afford to keep upgrading their systems
everytime a new OS is released. Or new application
upgrades are put on the market. Therefore, they are
finding that until their budget can actually allow them to
upgrade, they have to stay where they are. Linux has
become a top subject. For one reason that I am hearing is
that they don't have to worry about keeping up. Or the
cost that comes with purchasing new Microsoft OS and OS
upgrades. It is no wonder why new businesses that start
will start off using older applications until they can afford
to upgrade.
And with vendors that they use with regard to purchasing
new systems, will often suggest upgrading inspite of
budget restrictions. It's tough on MIS departments who
find that they have to flip flop in their work. It's like a
major rollercoaster ride. Learn one thing then discover
they have to learn something else just to avoid being
caught with their pants down. Is Microsoft making it
difficult for some businesses and consumers who cannot
keep up? I would say they are, but they are not going to
slow down anytime soon just because one person cries
about being left behind to use older applications and OS.
It's not their character.
by golf24_7
Sorry about the line breaks.
Linux does not function better then Windows across the board. I will admit it does do some thing?s better but I can only do a subset of what I do on Windows in Linux. I do use both Windows and Linux at both home and work and I do not believe either are all that secure out of the box.
By the way you can get Linux for free yes but if everyone does that then who pays the developers. If you use the software you should support the developers by paying for their add-on support or using the donation feature on their site. Those people need to eat to.
You are right that some games will run on Linux but again you must settle for a subset of available titles.
By the way I guess every time you work on someone?s computer it is fixed completely without error the first time if not you are being paid to go fix deficiencies in your work, same concept.
By the way apotheon your initial comment was unnecessary in the future act like an adult if that is possible
by markdmac
by apotheon
I don't own a thesaurus. I find thesauri in general to be objectionable, in fact. They promote lazy and inaccurate use of the language.
What does a thesaurus have to do with anything I said? I suppose this must be your way of dodging actually responding to salient points.
by nighthawk808
by nz_justice
by jmgarvin
I need to purchase a new home machine pretty soon. I was going to build it myself, but I wonder....
We have a program at my job with Smell...Dude, I might get a Smell with Vista...
Na, screw that...I'm not buying a Smell and I've little faith Vista will be out THAT soon.
by nighthawk808
After seeing that same tired argument a few bazillion times, I created a list to copy and paste. A few months ago, I polished it up, expanded it, and put it on the Web at http://www.geocities.com/lmc2124/no_ms.html.
Thanks for saving me the trouble of Ctrl-C and Ctrl-V. I'll have to add FlashDevelop and NVU to the list, though. I can't stand Flash, and I hand-code my HTML, but apparently some people would find those apps handy.
by apotheon
Thanks for the list. I'll be using it, I'm sure.
As for web dev tools . . .
I do all my web development with three aterms open on one workspace (for vim and sftp) and Firefox open on another.
by jmgarvin
A) He didn't get the "joke"
B) He's never heard of mono
by nighthawk808
by nighthawk808
Certainly you aren't suggesting that M$ would pay people to say good things about them, are you?
Oh, that's right, Microsoft has paid over 100 companies to write positive news about them. Call me cynical, but it seems odd that EVERY study that compares Windoesn't to Linux and declares M$ the victor has been funded by--guess who?--Microsoft.
They've even started foundations to pose as independent, "unbiased" sources. Here's an excerpt from a breakdown of them at http://timlambert.org/2004/06/tanks/
"Why are all these think tanks so down on Open Source? Well, the Small Business Survival Committee is concerned that using open source will expose small business to the risk of lawsuits. Citizens Against Government Waste is concerned that the Government might waste money on Open Source. Defenders of Property Rights is concerned that Open Source might be a threat to intellectual property rights. However, I was able to detect a common theme to all their criticism. They all seem to be funded by Microsoft."
by jmgarvin
"Linux does not function better then Windows across the board. I will admit it does do some thing?s better but I can only do a subset of what I do on Windows in Linux. I do use both Windows and Linux at both home and work and I do not believe either are all that secure out of the box."
What can you NOT do on a Linux box? I'll list off the substitutes and/or complements to the tools you need.
Out of the box Linux is more secure for a number of reasons (that I've iterated over and over...and again...you'll see them)
A) MS OSes mudge kernel space and user space. Linux has strict kernel space and user space. With SELinux this is even more apparent.
B) The registry can be edited by anyone, even remotely! Linux doesn't use a registry. In fact, the way Linux works is via libs and shared libs so that even in the event that a user land lib is used in some way for a malicious purpose, the kernel land lib is untouched.
C) Run As... is crippled. For a proper implementation check out sudo in Linux.
D) Integrating a browser into an OS is STUPID.
E) Linux implements users, groups, and permissions properly. The problem is that Windows doesn't. File permissions are ghettoed out in Windows and the 3 basic rules of security are thrown out the window (Confidentiality, Integrity, and Availability). Hell, even authentication is mudged in with various kludges.
F) Windows allows default actions that shouldn't happen (out of the box). e.g. Hiding known file extentions, executing withing asking (ala Outlook), and forcing your to log in as Administrator for the first log in.
"By the way you can get Linux for free yes but if everyone does that then who pays the developers."
This is a tired argument that doesn't have a leg to stand on. If this were true, then why is Red Hat profitable? Why is Novell Suse predicted to be profitable soon?
Free in the context of free software doesn't mean free beer, it means free intellectually!
"If you use the software you should support the developers by paying for their add-on support or using the donation feature on their site. Those people need to eat to."
Normally this would be true, but a miriad of *FREE* FLOSS applications have proved your wrong. I give you Apache as a prime example.
"You are right that some games will run on Linux but again you must settle for a subset of available titles."
I have to settle for a subset with Windows too. Hell, you do realize that games made for Windows might not even run on your system? Elder Scrolls: Oblivion is a prime example. It requires Pixel Shader 2.0, but by default Windows doesn't support this. You have to get a specific driver (if your hardware supports it) to run it.
I can't play The Simpson's Hit and Run in Windows either...Copy protection doesn't recognize the CD in the drive.
Check out www.transgaming.org/gamesdb for the large number of games that ARE supported on a platform they were NEVER meant to run on.
By the way I guess every time you work on someone?s computer it is fixed completely without error the first time if not you are being paid to go fix deficiencies in your work, same concept.
By the way apotheon your initial comment was unnecessary in the future act like an adult if that is possible
by apotheon
by amberhaze
I am reminded of kids playing in a play ground....
I want it now
I want it for free
I want it to be faster
I want it to include everything I need
I want it to be secure
I want
I want
I want...
oh wait a minute... guess I was describing where Linux was years ago... hehehe sorry I return you to your regularly scheduled windows programming....
by apotheon
I agree that there's a definite conflict of interest issue there, but that doesn't mean what they're saying isn't strictly true. I prefer to take a middle road: I'm of the considered opinion that while the article about sixty percent of Windows being rewritten in less than a year is highly suspect, there is almost certainly a substantial grain of truth in it.
For more details about my opinion, you might have a look at a piece I wrote in a weblog titled "Sixty Percent of Windows":
http://sob.apotheon.org/?p=31
I'd explain more here, but it's pretty lengthy.
by nighthawk808
Kind of gives a whole new meaning to "one-banana problem", doesn't it?
And, an extra special bonus joke:
It has been hypothesized that if an infinite amount of monkeys had an infinite amount of time, one of them would eventually finish WinFS.
See RFC2795 at http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2795.txt
by nighthawk808
"Additionally, I don?t care what OS you are running exposing it directly to the internet without proper patching and monitoring is absurd yet most people I know do this. They get high-speed internet plug their PC in to the modem and leave it on all the time not to mention they don?t run an Anti-Virus and if they do rarely keep it up to date nor do they deploy patches when they are released."
See http://www.honeynet.org/papers/trends/life-linux.pdf for the details. The results in short: unpatched, unsecured Linux boxen lasted an average of three MONTHS. Any guesses on how the Windows boxen did? Four MINUTES. It doesn't get any more black-and-white than that.
Since M$ likes to pay companies to write positive reviews, I'll tell you who the major backers were for this project: Indiana University and the National Intelligence Council (a government agency).
Windows boxen are compromised so fast that reinstalling the OS is somewhat dangerous. In the time it takes to download and reinstall all the patches, there is a substantial risk of system compromise. I didn't make this idea up. I can't remember where I first read it, but I'm pretty sure it was a mainstream (read pro-M$) tech magazine not too long ago (a year or so).
by apotheon
by apotheon
by apotheon
by nighthawk808
I've had to type this so often my fingers are starting to do it on their own now, but here goes anyway.
Let's switch places and give Linux a 90% share on the desktop and give Microsoft 10%, but let's leave everything else equal. Microsoft boxen would still exploited be in greater numbers. For example, if there are 900,000 Linux boxen in this hypothetical world and 100,000 on Windoesn't, there would be approximately 60,000 compromised Linux machines and over 80,000 pwned Windows computers! (Recent studies show that over 80% of home Windows machines have been the victim of a security exploit at some time or another.)
More than half of web servers run Apache, yet somehow an overwhelming majority of defaced web sites were on Microsoft IIS servers. Are you getting the picture yet? If not, how about this: when was the last time a major worm/virus/etc. that caused major disruption on the Internet transmitted via *nix machines? 1988, Morris worm.
Now, when was the last time the same thing happened on Windows machines? Let me count the ways: 2001, Code Red; a few months later in 2001, Nimda; 2003, Slammer. And these are just the ones off the top of my head. I'm going to use the words "Microsoft" and "quality" in the same sentence without also including the word "not" for the first time. Here goes: Microsoft's exploits are of very high quality.
People don't attack Windows machines just because they're more popular, they also attack them because they're so easy any script kiddie can do it. In fact, they're so easy to break, they've bred an entirely new genre of kiddie: the "click kiddie"--someone who doesn't even have the knowledge to write a simple script, and just clicks a box to scan your computer.
Why try to break into a bank when you can just knock over a liquor store? Why try to hammer a crack into a Linux castle when you can walk through the garage door Windows left wide open?
Tastes vary, but I'll take KDE over XP's GUI any day. Much more customizable, way way faster, and in almost two years I've had KDE crash on me exactly zero times (I counted them). Heck, I had Windows Explorer crash twice on me last night and all I was trying to do was the only thing Windows is good for: playing a video game.
Don't take this post personally. This isn't an attack on you; it's an attack on a bunch of old, worn out arguments that never held water.
by dogknees
I read a lot of posts here, and it sounds like a discussion I had today.
If you're not going to go to Vista, and I assume by extension any other new MS operating system, what are you going to be running on your new PCs in 10 years time?
It's not if, it's when. In the real world, particularly the business world, most people don't really have a choice.
So, what are you all going to be running on your next PC when you can't buy XP any more, or on the one after that? I don't see IBM reviving OS/2 any time soon. An linux won't vut it for a lot of users. So, what are your choices.
Never say Never!
There's a difference you know. The users at a business get what they are given. I look forward to the day when MS is not the automatic choice. If nothing else it will mean Redmond will have to start creating something we want to buy instead of something they want to sell.
So indeed never say never.
by amberhaze
As an example, I give you the K12LTSP project.
It is a LINUX based project which gives a low cost integrated solutions for schools. It takes care of both servers and workstations. And best yet.. allows the recycling of old hardware by turning it into thin clients.
While the first couple of cases were a hard sell, we now have local schools excited about this project as we have enabled them to move forward within thier budget constraints. And as One school board official put it, Microsoft has not even come to the table with any kind of comperable single package solution.
While this particular example is very niche oriented, it is a good example of where 3rd party competition will hopefully generate a "kick in the butt" for venders like MS.
I use as much MS product as I do LINUX based, and have no problem with using it when it is appropriate. I like the idea of options and so do my clients. I am very hopeful that with examples like the above, MS and maybe even some others will also look into catering more to specific needs and perhaps the competition will help us move forward into a much batter place.
by nighthawk808
Windows and Linux are treated differently in how they are listed. The Windows vulnerabilities are ones that affect mainly the core of Windows, which is a small subset of what Linux offers. OTOH, a huge number of applications that run on Linux are included in the list. Not the kernel itself, which is kind of the only thing Windows is judged on, but the kernel AND everything surrounding it. To be a real comparison, you'd have to hold a flaw in WinZip against Microsoft, for example. Also, there's not just Linux in that section, there's also BSD. Would you include a Xenix flaw in with the Microsoft results? No, but that's kind of what's going on here. Furthermore, the same vulnerability is often reported multiple times. For example, if there is a bug in the kernel, there may be separate advisories posted for SuSE, Red Hat, Debian, etc., even though it's the same thing.
So, basically, Linux is fighting Microsoft with one hand tied behind its back, and it's still winning. I'm not saying that US-CERT is up to something, because they're not. It's just a side effect of how they group things.
As for the "risk" of letting people see the code, that argument was beaten down more ways than Rodney King years ago. But I'll toss a few sentences out anyway.
1 - This is true if you are talking about Microsoft. When you base your whole design process on keeping the code secret, it has to stay secret afterward. Otherwise, if the code does make it out into the wild, there is a good chance that someone will find something in it. Why? Because it hasn't had the benefit of hundreds or thousands of eyeballs reviewing it like open source code has.
2 - For every one malicious person poring through the code looking for exploits, there are 100 good people looking for those same holes so that they can be patched immediately. This is another reason Linux's security is much better than it may appear if you only look at the CERT statistics by volume. Look at the number of days between a vulnerability being found and when it is patched. It is MUCH lower for Linux. Also, most vulnerabilities in Linux are found by the programmers themselves. Many of Windows's vulnerabilities are discovered once there is an exploit in the wild. Why? Again because no one could look at the code to find it before all hell broke loose. And, finally, many Windows vulnerabilities are much more serious than the Linux ones. Numbers aren't the whole story.
I'll stop here, because Eric Raymond showed years ago why open source design works so well in _The Cathedral and the Bazaar_ ( http://www.catb.org/~esr/writings/cathedral-bazaar ), so there's not much I can say that he hasn't. But, Microsoft diehard or Linux geek, I highly recommend reading this. And it's free, too.
by dumblogic
Every body in this forum knows of microsoft track record,how the bean counter and corporate bigwig are designing the software forget it.
It is a feable atempt on microsoft part to disway the customer into thinking that they have a better or more secure product hog wash.
Have you seen how long it take for microsoft to respond to a bug report and put a patch fix for it and sometime the cure is not worth it.
Have you ever take a look at a antivirus sight and look at all the operating system that are effected by a certain virus, microsoft top the list you don't hear about mac or linux being effect that much but microsoft is and it like a running joke around the computer tech field. What crap bill gate is going to feed us this time.
Vista is just another feable atempt to prove that they are on top of thing.
by the_fixer
Those are really good points. I will check out that site as well. I have big a big fan of the open source movement and have been using Desktop LX for my home laptop for several years and have never run into a crash or any other security issue. I use XP at work and see the benifits of the Windows systems as well.
Thanks for the link, Nighthawk.
by nighthawk808
MS is going to find out the hard way that Vista is a big flop. A - No reason to upgrade from XP. The only reason I went to XP was because it got away from the kernal32.dll problem which made it much more stable than 98. B - 98% of potential buyers will have to go through a major hardware upgrade to run it well.
Good Luck Bill - Your going to need it.
John
by markdmac
I can respect the fact that apotheon has mastered the English language. I don't post much in these forums so you guys don't really know who I am either. Check out the Tek-Tips forums http://www.tek-tips.com and you will find I am the number 1 MVP for Windows 2000 Server, Windows 2003, Exchange 2003, I am second top MVP for vbscript and third ranked MVP for Windows XP Pro. I've posted 5203 replies, and written 14 Faqs, some are the most highly rated. I was recently voted Tipmaster of the Week by the members of that site for the fourth time now. My Enterprise Login Scripts are in use in several hundred companies.
I was a Microsoft employee 4 years ago. During my employment I received recognition for my work and am proud of the fact that I was one of many MS employees who volunteered time to help rebuild Wall Street after September 11th. I left MS after that when a relocation fell through, the result of the depressed market. I was already building a new house in AZ otherwise I would not have quit.
After leaving MS, while employed for a Microsoft Certified Partner I had the privilege to work on Deployment Guides for Small & Medium IT. Some of my works are published on Microsoft.com for deploying Windows 2003. Three roll outs I did for that Partner are documented on Microsoft.com as case studies.
I am aware of internal discussions regarding Vista and because of this believe I have a better take on this. I am willing to site Microsoft's faults when they are accurate and find the constant MS bashing to be annoying.
And here is the little bomb shell for you...I AM CURRENTLY A MICROSOFT EMPLOYEE as of November of last year.
So, I can respect the fact that apotheon is active in these forums and commend such efforts. Anyone can have a blog, so that fails to impress me. I am exposed to truly brilliant people every day at work, so perhaps I set the bar a little higher.
Apotheon points out that he is MS certified. I'm MCSE certified and have been for over ten years. I am also a Novell CNE and Comptia certified. Novell is no longer the player they used to be, so I don't get any value from my CNE anymore but my Microsoft certification has given me a great career. I love this industry which we have Microsoft to thank for and I am grateful to them for pushing technology and innovation as they have.
Thus far I have only observed negativity and distrust toward Microsoft from apotheon. As such it is hard for me to take him seriously.
Disclaimer: The above opinion is my own and not necessarily that of my employer who I did not contact for comment.
I have been beta testing Vista for some time now and the only thing everyone is hitting on target with is the Eye Candy. Yep it is pretty cool and that is where I am going to stop. I say leave the Eyecandy to Graphics programs and Games. Give me a lame Windows 98 looking interface again and I am happy. If you must have eye candy put on Window Blinds. Much cooler skins for the OS.
Working as a Systems Admin for a Engineering Firm that like to stay "CUTTING EDGE" we are going to deploy Vista as soon as it rolls out. What do I know I only have to support this stuff. Corporate makes the decisions ultimately. I have not seen much speed performace in Vista over XP with SP2, I will also give it the fact that it does boot quicker. Personally I like my morning stroll to get a cup of coffee and relieve myself of the presures of morning traffic. So that does not bother me.
What really bugs me is the Login to the network. I do not feel it necessary that everytime I login I have to either type my whole freaking e-mail address/ passwor or Domain Name\Username / password to log in. Bring back the old style there.
I was able to run all of the visual effects with a 128 PCIE card and 512MB RAM so I am not sure where you are getting you need a gig and 512MB but as of now in this current beta I can max out on eye candy and it is not taking much of a toll on the OS as if it was off.
The only thing I think Microsoft should focus on is Cool effects for the home users and a stripped down interface for business.
There is my 2 cents on this discussion...
He distrusts your company therefore he's negative towards it so therefore he can't be taken seriously?
So none of the issues he raises , merit even a response, never mind redress.
Can you get your programmmers to check the return value when they call a function.
Please.
Oh yes and can I have memory back when you've done with it. I need it to run an application. I know it's an non-ms one and I foolishly thought I'd bought an operating system to do what I wanted to do, but it was an honest mistake. I was misled by an advert.
We often gets trolls FUDing us on a regular basis, some may have confused you with one. Easy mistake to make I'm afraid, when the response to a technical issue is an advert, or a the chorus of a company song.
by flylta
PALease is there anything in Vista I need?
I would not buy it
And 7 versions?
What the heck for?
So I need to learn all the nuances of another defective M$ product!
The only time I will see Vista is when I am fixing it for someone else!
Ron
by lds_sailor
I am a Network Administrator and have a few thoughts on Vista.
1) I agree with the majority of you that eye candy alone is not sufficient cause to upgrade. I mean if all youre going to get is a newer interface, I can spend far less on a Windows XP skin program and make it look however the heck I want it to.
2) If indeed the windows Vista source is just another evolution / refformation of the XP source code, Then its not going to take long to have someone exploit it. However in Microsoft's defense, If someone wants to exploit something there is always a way. I would suggest if Microsoft is going to release a "new" OS, then it needs to be new.
Scrap the original source code and use the past 5 years to make something truely new. Something that addresses the issues of today and not just patches them but deals with them head on.
3) I can understand the need for a home and a business version of Windows, but come on 9 versons! I mean how the heck is anyone supposed to know what to buy or what they need.
Now with that said, I am an MCP an soon to be MCSE. I am also very interested in Linux. Not because I think Microsoft is a big evil giant, rather becuase I dont think that anyone has all the answers. Linux has flaws to. As does MAC. The thing is, if we can't learn from others mistakes then it's our own dang fault that things break. Linux learned from Microsoft's follies and created a good platform, is it perfect, NO but it gives another point of view.
I will not be upgrading to Vista until I see a value to upgrading. In the mean time, like many of you I am getting more involved with Linux and Apple. I dont think there is a silver bullet but in order for Microsoft's Vista to work, they need to think outside the box and make something truely NEW. Give me a reason to drop $300+ on a new Os and I'll consider it, but dont pass off fancy visuals as a reason. Just my 2 cents worth guys.
by apotheon
Look, son, you seem to have missed many of the points of recent discussion.
1. Go back and reread the part where nighthawk808 said I wasn't trying to impress you. It's true: I'm not. I don't care if you're unimpressed. I think the point nighthawk808 was trying to make is that I have a long history here and, based on that, people know me better than to assume I'm thumbing through a thesaurus looking for three-dollar words. In fact, the thesaurus argumentum ad ridiculum fallacy directed at me might be one of the key identifiers of someone as a big-mouthed newbie to TR, since only big-mouthed newbies tend to make that mistake. In other words, it's probably in your best interest to get the lay of the land before you start mouthing off, as looking before you leap can help you avoid looking like a fool.
2. The mention of me having a blog was pretty clearly not intended to impress you with its existence. Reading comprehension seems to be lacking. What nighthawk808 was suggesting was that you should perhaps read through some of my blog posts to get an idea of who I am before you start making lame assumptions and petty accusations regarding thesauri and the like. Research your subject before getting noisy about it. Of course, your apparent eagerness to start making up implied insults about people before you've done even minimal research into the characters of the people you attack certainly doesn't incline the more thoughtful of us to assume you research any other subject before sounding off. As a result, your commentary about Windows and Linux is more suspect than it might otherwise be.
3. Taking my mention of MS certification as some sort of assumption of authority on the subject, once again, betrays a lack of reading comprehension. I admit that in this case it might in part be due to the fact that I wasn't as clear about the purpose of that mention as I could have been, but some of the blame is yours as well -- you didn't notice that the context of the statement clearly indicated I was refuting your implication that I am just an anti-Microsoft zealot who doesn't know anything about, or consider, the technical issues of the matter. Instead of noticing and acknowledging that, you just assumed it was an assumption of authority, then started waving your dick around in response with all your talk of working for Microsoft and a string of certification letters after your name. In addition, to compound the problem, you continue to respond to me as though I've never used Windows for more than office receptionist tasks or World of Warcraft.
4. I'd ask for some links to those case studies and other corroborating evidence about your stated experience, except that [b]I don't care[/b]. If you can't make your points sans appeals to authority, you can't make points that are worth consideration anyway.
5. Without comparable experience with Linux-based operating system (or other free unices for that matter), your truckful of claimed MS software experience means just about nothing for comparative analysis. That's especially true when your arguments against Linux thus far are largely based on easily, and often, refuted fallacies, and on MS-centric marketing FUD. Security through obscurity and obviously false statements about software and/or hardware incompatibility won't fly with this group. You'll need to do more than repeat what you read on some discussion forum full of people raised on Microsoft and only Microsoft.
6. The reason you've seen a lot of distrust toward Microsoft is simple: I don't trust anyone that regularly lies to me and does everything in his or her power to obfuscate facts. I trust verifiable truths. I trust transparency, in government, in business, and in software. Microsoft is the opposite of transparency in every way, for most purposes. There are occasions when Microsoft manages to be transparent, but they're few and far between. That doesn't mean I won't give a fair and accurate assessment of the technical merits of something offered by Microsoft, but it does mean that I won't take marketing FUD at face value. On the other hand, I won't just automatically assume everything that comes from MS is a lie, either. You should have a look at a recent ramble I've composed about the whole Vista delay for an example of the sort of middle road I often take on analyses of Microsoft policy, PR, and technical matters:
http://sob.apotheon.org/?p=31
by jdclyde
If you go back and look, not once did I tell you to switch to linux. Not once did I complain about price.
Sure, linux is a good alternative, but that has nothing to do with what I have been trying to say to you.
MS puts out shoddy work, only because they can get away with it. They get away with it because people like you make excuses for them. The more people look to linux as an alternative, the better product MS will HAVE to come out with. That or increase the FUD to keep people like you from thinking linux CAN replace a windows box.
Again, if I have a video card go bad after two weeks, I expect it to be fixed. If the batch was sent out KNOWING they were flawed, then there will be class action suits.
Quit making excuses. MS is more concerned with securing lisenced copies than it is about securing the copies, that is why it is much easier to hack a windows system than it is to pirate one. Until the customers that WANT to use Windows stand up, this will not be a concern.
What incentive does MS have to improve their product to make someone like you happy? Your not going to look elsewhere anyways, so they don't have to worry about if your happy or not.
by jmgarvin
by jmgarvin
You've posted nothing to this discussion that would lead us to think you had anything to say. The ad hom. attacks on Apo were pointless and stupid. You provided nothing to the discussion and added to the FUD.
"I can respect the fact that apotheon has mastered the English language. I don't post much in these forums so you guys don't really know who I am either."
Why attack those that you have no idea about? Apo is a reasonable (yet sometimes cranky) guy.
"Check out the Tek-Tips forums http://www.tek-tips.com"
Let me start with:
That site makes my eyes bleed. If anything could someone PLEASE make it usable? Might I suggest a book called "The Design of Everyday Things?" It was hard to get a feel for what was going one, esp with the colors that blended together...dark text on a dark background are pretty tough to read.
The threading of the posts was nice though.
"I am aware of internal discussions regarding Vista and because of this believe I have a better take on this. I am willing to site Microsoft's faults when they are accurate and find the constant MS bashing to be annoying."
How is holding MS to a standard that we hold other software to bashing? FLOSS advocates will jump on Linux distros (or even the kernel folks) when something goes wrong. Why should MS be any different?
Check out what people are saying about Fedora Core 5:
http://lunapark6.com/?p=481
http://www.fedoraforum.org/forum/index.php
"And here is the little bomb shell for you...I AM CURRENTLY A MICROSOFT EMPLOYEE as of November of last year."
What a surprise considering you parrot all the talking points in Get the FUD.
"Thus far I have only observed negativity and distrust toward Microsoft from apotheon. As such it is hard for me to take him seriously."
Why is it so hard to see why many of us IT Pros distrust MS? Many of us have been at this a long time. Some of us are highly educated, some of us are educated in the school of hard knocks...but we all see the forest for the trees. When it comes to MS, the Emperor has no clothes. Security is not just an issue with being "popular," but a huge issue because the architecure is WRONG.
Further, after dealing with slow patch cycles (recently a f-secure employee released a patch faster than MS), bad patching (XP SP2), and a slew of misinformation (WMF flaw), we should trust MS and buy into the hype?
I'd rather discuss the issues that MS has and what solutions there are to them. I'd also like to stomp out the FUD about Linux and how FLOSS will kill us all (according to MS).
If you really wanted to start a civil discourse you should have brought up some valid points, not just ad hom attacks.
So try again...this time, bring up points that relate to WHY MS is better or what niche MS fills that Linux can't...and why.
by dasein42
The high end PC's that are currently shipping with XP Pro installed will likely be the first to switch to Vista. But if the requirements are even slightly higher than XP the machines aimed at the low budget home market will stick with XP Home until they can bring down the price of a Vista capable machine sufficiently.
My father just bought a "refurbished" Compaq laptop the other day - 1.8ghz 512mb. Of course it came with XP Home, but interestingly it also came with OpenOffice 2.02, not MS Office. Margins are tight at the low end of the market - the cost of Vista itself plus extra hardware will make it a slow introduction.
by nighthawk808
by abobble2
by abobble2
I looked at your referenced page and it appears that you are more than correct. Other operating systems are have just as much or more problems than MS with security. Its just that we hear less about these other operating systems than we do microsoft. I agree whole heartedly with the fact of where computing would be had it not been for microsoft. MS has made possible for most to afford in a home now than in the years past. I can still remember when it was out of the realm of of most middle income families to even consider buying a compute. But now most can afford it.
So irregardless of WHAT most people spout about ms i for one am glad to have experienced ms almost from the beginning and will continue to do so. As u state nothing is perfect when it comes to os's all are open to attack and will always be.
by jmgarvin
Cert usually lumped non-OS issues in with Linux because they just did. Sure it was a PHP problem, but will put it in the Linux catagory.
That normalizes the data set enough to see that:
A) The critical issues with Linux (the OS) are typically FAR smaller. The last REALLY critical issues was a fork() problem in the 2.6.9 kernel. There hasn't been a hugely critical issue in the recent kernels.
B) FLOSS issues are usually reported more quickly and responded to than MS issues. Re: the IE fiasco. Not only that but MS plays games with their reporting. The WMF flaw has been around forever, but MS counts it as reported and patched within a week.
C) Windows is built on an insecure architecture. I've gone over this time and time again. The architecture of the OS is less secure than *nix.
D) Application integration, esp with insecure apps like browsers, means more security issues
E) MS has made computing more accessable, now let's make it more secure. How about we start by talking about the flaws in the MS OSes and holding them accountable?
BTW irregardless is redundant. You are (in essence) saying regardless regardless.
by abobble2
You seem to be like the lady that bought hot coffee at McDonald's and burned herself with it. Hello----Coffee is supposed to be hot!!!
If know about securities breaches, and MS is sitting on it before a release patch is released. Hello---Then you should take measures to avoid the breach. Not burn yourself with it. Wake up. You want MS to do your thinking for you. Then you should become a robot and plug yourself into a computer and then you would surely have the right to complain about MS not fixing you properly.
by jmgarvin
Thanks, that's great...What a little gem you have there, since the onus *IS* on the community to write patches.
You know that MS isn't releasing the patches for IE until the 11th...That's ok, the community has taken up the slack and released patches.
Don't blame the manufacturer, blame the stupid user for being a unable to write their own patches....wait I thought that was the whole stance against Linux...It's hard to use! If I have to write my own patches, doesn't that make MS OSs hard to use?
by nighthawk808
Coffee was designed to be drunk, not chucked in your lap.
If I relied on MS to my security thinking for me, I'd be diagnosed as brain dead !
by j.a.leo
The 1 % solution to Microsofts, and therefore 90% of all users is simple.
Take the top 1% of product developers across the board and have them perform the activites of a RED TEAM that agressively and very intellegently searches out every possible flaw immaginable in all product designs and force the other 99% in the development teams to incorporate their finds into the product designs before any coding begins.
before they've become familiar with clicking on the big blue e, good plan.
Do they have concerns about them being developmently challenged by not being familiar with windows though.
Enquiring minds want to know.
LOL
I'm one of the tech beta testers of Vista. I already know what is required to run Vista. In fact I'm running Vista as I write this on 3 computers one is
MSI K8M4M-V
AMD Athlon XP 1700+
512 meg ddr PC 2100
WD 40 gig harddrive
Toshiba CD RW/DVD drive
On board Video/sound
Gateway 17" monitor
Runs pretty good just no eye candy.
point
1 IE is isolated from the OS just like FireFox(in other words it's isolated from the os)
2 Increased security built in(for one no program will install with out asking if you want it installed first-2 Vista will also iinform users about securtiy and privacy issues
3 Nearly instant search for files on pc(The search function is much faster and better than all previous versions-WinFs will just make it more powerful)
4 Improved tcp/ip for faster internet(is the part that gets you on the internet and allows d/l of progrmas-Vista improves on this also when ip 6v is available-Vista already has it)
This is just a few of the added value of Vista
by jmgarvin
*Since you edited your post, I'll edit mine...
1) IE is still integrated into the OS it just runs in "protected mode."
2) What increased security specifically? Their anti-spyware tool? As for programs not installing without user interaction: I'll believe it when I see it. It is too easy to quietly run code without user interaction.
3) Nope, WinFS ain't coming out with Vista. How is the search going to be made faster? Indexing the HDD? Magic?
4) WTF? Ok, please for the love of god explain what this means. You claim that IPV6 somehow "makes the internet go faster." Please go on. I'm interested how IPV6 will make everything so much faster.
Rather than taking a few MS talking points, what technical merits does Vista give us?
by jmgarvin
When I was a kid we had to write patches, in the snow, up hill both ways, with a stone tablet, eating only what we could catch...
Wait, that doesn't make any sense at all ;-)
by apotheon
by thestorys
I agree with many comments here.
The bottom line is. Microsoft needs to make more money...so we all get another unneeded upgrade shoved down our throats. It is the same old story. Looks like eventually we would get tired of it.
I have grown tired of it and looked at Linux and we are starting to use it for some things. It does still have a way to go.
Let's face it, Microsoft makes things easier to get going and more user friendly than their competitors and that is why they are where they are. I am hoping that the Linux community will learn a few lessons from what Microsoft is doing right and continue to take a really great product and improve it more and more such that it will be a really great alternative.
I still use Office 97 at home. It does everything I need to do, but eventually I'll be forced to upgrade to a bloated newer version that I don't like as well and for no reason other than to $end more money to M$.
Open Office looks nice but who wants to take the time to relearn everything. Let's face it, most of us are MS addicts and kicking the habit is hard.
I too wish MS would support older things longer and not just create a new OS, just to be doing it, and not force it upon everyone.
My 2 cents.
by mlansing
by yinbig
People, alot of people spend 300-400 on a graphics cards for your games, just to get the latest release / effects. So why then when an OS decides to do the same you are up in arms?
Plus this high end will enable all entry level PC's that run Vista being shipped with decent graphic options, no?
by jmgarvin
Wait...lemme get this straight:
You are saying that since the OS required more resources that it will make games better?
You are also saying that better graphics cards will be shipped with new computers...for free...just to run Vista?
by nighthawk808
A Hummer H2 is a huge vehicle, so that means it's a better car, doesn't it? Ergo, Vista will be better because it has more code and has insane hardware recommendations. And who wouldn't want to drop $500 on a video card so they can run Microsoft Word with decent frame rates? Have you ever tried fragging typos with a mere GeForce 6800GS? It's not for the timid, let me tell you.
But don't discourage him, jmgarvin. I've already got my road to riches already laid out, and if people start waking up to this, it won't work. Here goes: the day before Vista finally ships, I'm buying as much stock in ATI and nVidia as I can. I figure that if I start saving now, by Vista's 2018 ship date I should be able to afford a few thousand shares of each.
by rgeiken9
by nighthawk808
We didn't have punch cards that controlled looms--we had looms that made punch cards. And here's why we called them patches: if we wanted to write a program, we had to knit it ourself. Black thread meant a 1, white thread meant a zero. And if there was a bug, we'd have to sew a patch onto the code to cover the original thread.
Compiling got its name from when we used to stack all our programs on top of each other. When we were ready to run the program we'd spent weeks weaving, someone would yell, "Come pile!"
We used washing machines as bulk erasers back then.
CodeWeavers were really code weavers back in my day.
by nighthawk808
http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/SearchTools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=697013&CatId=694
And I have full areo experiance.
by jmgarvin
I have to say not only does that card stink on ice, but its performance is questionable.
While I do play WoW, I sometimes do get funky graphical hickups...I also sometime get freaky artifacts in X.
Sure it's a video card, but it's a Pinto...Areo might catch it on fire.
by rewand1
but then the only game I play is Chess or watch TV/DVD movies and it works very good for me. It also works great with Aero Glass in Vista. Also if you check with Windows Catalog, you would have learned that
EVGA e-GeForce FX 5200 Light - graphics adapter - GF FX 5200 - 128 MB
has the designed for Windows XP logo from MS.
As I ssaid it works very good for me.
by jmgarvin
Look at the amount of critical security issues Windows has. Look at the mess Windows is making of the desktop market.
That is why ENTIRE CITIES (ala Munich) are jumping ship...MS OSes are not reliable nor are they usable.
Sure, bells and whistles are fine...so is the geewiz factor, but honestly, what does Vista give us that isn't just a new interface*?
* The answer is nothing. The only thing that made Vista worth while was WinFS, without it, there is no point. IE is STILL integrated into the OS (it runs in "protected mode") and there in NOTHING in terms of real architectural change. It's XP with a new skin.
Windows dosen't work-I think there maybe a few million people that may disagree with you there.
As far as Munich that decision was made in 2003 and they still have not done the job yet. I have also read that so far it's costing them $12million more than if they stayed with Windows plus on some systems they will be running Windows in VM and they are not even started yet.
Vista is more than Xp with a new skin-actually its based on the Server2003 SP1 - With added security features and other features.
Tell you what Jim-when Vista goes Beta 2 and you can get/use it. Then tell us how wrong Vista is.
As far as stability goes my Windows XP pc's run 24/7 with no problems and I've done this since Windows XP went Gold(released to manufacturers).
by jmgarvin
I've named the technical issues with Windows and you didn't respond, so I'm not about to go down the same road again.
Please post a link where it is going to be $12 million more and they are running Windows via VMWare (or whatever).
Ok, what is the difference between Win2k3 and XP? What are the security features? What are the other features?
Please screen shot your uptime...I just don't believe you have never rebooted. As far as XP being stable, while it isn't awful, it isn't great either. I've noticed you've given up on secure...
Before we discuss anything any more, please read:
Threats:
http://isc.sans.org/diary.php?storyid=1250&isc=688d0d82db90a070162de16c731384f5
http://isc.sans.org/diary.php?storyid=1251&isc=688d0d82db90a070162de16c731384f5
Stability:
http://www.seattleweekly.com/news/0422/040602_news_microsoft.php
by apotheon
by nighthawk808
several times a week-esp when I'm checking out the Vista 32/64 bit versions-when not beta testing-I usually re boot 2 x a month but only for updates to windows or drivers only.
You may want to read these
http://www.geek.com/news/geeknews/2004Feb/gee20040217023885.htm
http://businessweek.com/magazine/content/04_45/b3907083_mz054.htm
http://www.silicon.com/research/specialreports/opensource/0,3800004943,39152061,00.htm
by nighthawk808
Surely you can't take that seriously! I'd read the National Inquirer for IT news before I'd read their pulp. They are the Art Bell of technology coverage. No, wait, I take that back--I wouldn't want to insult Mr. Bell like that. At least some of the things he had on his show made sense occasionally.
From the first story: "It has also been revealed that the Open Source software bid was actually 51% more expensive than the proposal made by Microsoft, as Microsoft had heavily discounted its proposal in an attempt to keep the German customer." That's like a heroin dealer on a street corner complaining that the methadone clinic is more expensive, so obviously staying hooked on heroin is a more attractive proposition. And, of course, he would never jack up the price after you got your first hit in your system. No, that would be unethical, and Microsoft is a fine, upstanding corporate citizen. If you don't believe me, just ask Steve "As-laid-back-as-John-Lennon-on-Valium" Ballmer.
Also from the first story: LiMux project manager Peter Hofman says, "Right now we are proceeding as planned, and we have no hints ... that the city council is regretting ... their decision to move to Linux." Did I miss something, or did that mean that they're NOT unhappy about the transition?
As for the second story, I have a hard time taking it seriously when there is a Microsoft ad running down the right side of the webpage. Call me crazy.
by apotheon
http://toolbar.netcraft.com/site_report?url=http://www.microsoft.com
Microsoft's website. As of today, last rebooted sixteen days ago. OS: Windows Server 2003 with IIS 6.0, of course.
http://toolbar.netcraft.com/site_report?url=http://www.linux.com
"The Enterprise Linux Resource". As of today, last rebooted thirty days ago. OS: Linux with Apache 1.3.x, of course.
That thirty days doesn't sound too impressive, but then you have a look at the graph:
http://uptime.netcraft.com/up/graph?site=www.linux.com
Thirty days ago, Linux.com hit 497 days of uptime. The uptime counter in Linux (unlike the one for Windows) rolls over to zero every 497 days. Hmm. So, the total is actually 527 days of uptime. Before that, there was a break in uptime that was at less than 497 days: it was, in fact, about 400 days, greater than the highest uptime figure on the Microsoft.com graph by a factor of about 3.5 (that's 3.5 times the uptime, for the lowest peak on Linux.com's graph, as for the highest on the Microsoft.com graph). That was in late 2004. I suspect they upgraded the kernels on their servers or replaced hardware. They certainly aren't rebooting every two weeks, like you do.
Well. Yeah. The legendary stability of Windows.
by nighthawk808
An eVGA? And I thought I was slumming it when I bought a PNY. I don't feel so bad now.
jmgarvin, I'm surprised you bought an FX anything. IIRC (and correct me if I don't), isn't the FX, like the MX series before them, just a regular GeForce GPU minus all the whiz-bang things that make them actually nice processors? Kind of like the graphics equivalent of the Intel Celeron: rip out all the useful stuff since it's expensive to manufacture and then sell a dirt-cheap skeleton of a chip.
Anyway, on to the thing that led me to post: Mr. Hereid mentioned the "Designed for Windows XP" logo on the box of his card. Next to me, I just happened to have the box for a PNY GeForce 6200 I got a couple of weeks ago (I've been too lazy to take it down to the basement and throw it on the heap of old, dusty boxes). I picked it up and searched all over it for the logo, but it's nowhere to be found. I could care less since the card is in a Linux machine, but I find that kind of odd. Adding to the mystery, it is obviously designed to be used in Windows, as there are two screenshots from The Sims 2 on the back.
by nighthawk808
by apotheon
I restart Linux machines under the following conditions:
1. it's a laptop
2. there's a hardware/power problem
3. it has to be moved and isn't plugged into a UPS that'll sustain it that long
That pretty much sums it up. My main server got restarted once earlier this year because of a hardware issue, but otherwise has been chugging along since August (when I first moved to this state) without interruption.
In a month and a half, your uptime is going to show one day, though. The Linux uptime counter only goes up to 497, y'know. I wonder if/when they're going to fix that.
by nighthawk808
I didn't know it only went up to 497. If I would have known that, I would have waited another six weeks to upgrade to Sarge. I guess I'll never see what happens, because the UPS this box was on is now in the big hardware graveyard in the sky and some bad midsummer thunderstorms inevitably knock out our power here at least a few times a year.
Have you tried setting your clock to 03:14:00 on January 19, 2038 and waiting eight seconds to see what happens? My SuSE box won't let me set a date later than the year 2031.
Post edited to correct 03:18 to 03:14
Why or how did this happen
http://news.netcraft.com/archives/web_server_survey.html
or this
by nighthawk808
The big blue line that shows Apache dominating the stats?
Or are you referring to GoDaddy's decision to put all its parked websites on IIS? After Slashdot got done with that one, it looked like it went through a food processor:
http://linux.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=06/03/23/008229
BTW, GoDaddy is also the company that is so technically incompetent it can't even tell when it is broken, so while you're there, you might find this interesting:
http://apple.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=05/12/08/236246&tid=177
Have you been out of the loop for the last few years? The study you cited in the second story has long been known to have been bought-and-paid-for by Microsoft and intentionally put the Linux box at a disadvantage.
by apotheon
by apotheon
I thought we were talking about uptime and stability. What does that have to do with market share and performance?
Regardless, you obviously aren't checking your own source material:
1. As the news item at Netcraft indicates, the relative increase in market share for Windows and relative decrease in market share for Linux is entirely accounted for by the fact that a single business made some kind of mass licensing deal with Windows and chose to migrate 4.4 million servers. One company switching platforms isn't exactly a ringing endorsement so much as a fluke of the business world. You might also have bothered to scroll down a little bit and notice the graphs, which show that the market share drop for Apache and jump for IIS, due to GoDaddy's business deal, isn't much of a measure of market success. As I'm known to say over and over again, market share (relative numbers) isn't as important a measure of success as absolute numbers. The absolute numbers for Apache have been climing at an incredible rate -- so much so that GoDaddy's migration of millions of systems from Linux to Windows doesn't even show in the absolute numbers graph. Hint: the blue line is Apache.
2. I just lost all my bookmarks yesterday, so I'm afraid I don't have the articles handy, but nighthawk808 is right: industry and tech analysts tore that "Windows Wins" crap, sponsored by Microsoft, a new bunghole. Also, it's out of date, to say nothing of the fact that SMB isn't a standard protocol for Linux. If you want a network filesystem for Linux, you should be looking at protocols designed for Unix, rather than the protocol that is primarily in the Windows bailiwick these days. Frankly, I'm disinclined to put much faith in any study that isn't performed entirely independently.
Comparing the two for fileserver performance and forcing RedHat Linux servers to use CIFS rather than letting it use something better suited to unix is a bit like checking to see whether a right-handed person or a left-handed person is a faster writer with his right hand. If you'd let the left-handed person use his left hand, he'd do a heck of a lot better.
"What kind of support is your Office 97 getting these days?"
Great support. Not from Microsoft, of course, but then again, I never relied on Microsoft for that. In fact, I don't remember ever calling or emailing Microsoft.
However, because there are/were so many users, it's pretty easy to find an answer.
Remember, most of the user's problems do not come from computer bugs, but a lack of knowledge on the part of the user.
Similarly, when you contact the hotline of a software manufacturer, they seldom solve your problem by sending you a new version. Most of the time, they tell you how it's done and it works.
So the real question, when you talk about support, is "how can I find the data I need".
Ask some random people if they know how to display hidden characters in Ms Word 97. How many people do you have to ask before you find one that knows? 2 or 3 at most.
Take OOo. Do the same test, same question. Out of 10 random people, you will be lucky to even find one that knows what OOo is, let alone knows how to use it.
Bottom line is, if there are more users, chances are the "support" (access to data) is better.
by chas_2
by rgeiken9
I had windows 3.1 on my computer, and got a chance to be a Window 95 beta tester. The beta had it's share of problems, and sometimes I would get a little discouraged since I was doing the beta test on my only computer. After it was finally released, I was glad that I could participate. Being able to go from a file name that was 8.3 to a 128 character file name was precious to me. I could finally name a file something that I could recognize when I saw it. Unfortunately it was still locked in to the same old external interfaces.
When I upgraded to Windows 98 SE, I got access to both USB and IEEE1394 buses. By the time I bought a new HP computer, it had Windows XP installed, and this was better than Windows 98 SE. Everyone of the Operating Systems that I have had on my computer have had some pesky problems, but each has been better than the former.
I now have Windows XP Pro installed on a "rehabbed" HP computer. With a Hyperthreading 3 gig processor and 2 gig of DDR2 ram, it works great. Disabling the Page file setting really speeds things up. I occasionally have a crash, but it recovers nicely, which is about all that I can ask.
I'm sure that Windows Vista will prove to be an improvement over Windows XP. By using Zone Alarm Firewall, AVG free anti virus, and using an ISP, Cox communication that removes viruses that are contained in e-mail, I have not had any disruptions on my computer due to all the malware that seems to be floating around on the Internet.
Like a lot of other people, I will wait until Vista has been out for 6 to 9 months, and then look for a powerful computer that will be able use it properly.
by jmgarvin
I figured for $25, how can you go wrong, right? I'm an idiot.
Normally I pick REAL hardware, but in this case the price tag suckered me. It was a $50 card with a $25 rebate...I just couldn't say no. So I picked it up and it was the WORST choice I could ever make.
The FX cards have most of the wizbang things, but it depends on the card and depends on the numbers in front of it.
So the moral of the story is: You get what you pay for...and sometimes less. I'd say this card is worth maybe $10, I over paid by $15!
by jmgarvin
A) Sponsored by MS
B) Untrue, just check out sans.org and/or cert.org for clarification
C) Just look at the mess of IE, IIS, and their ilk...
Security IS NOT what MS does. While they have improved, they sure haven't produced a secure product.
They are just turd polishing.
by jchapple
Sort by Trending