Discussion Locked

What do atheists believe?

0 helpful
121 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

121 replies

by coachcs

It is easier to believe that we created god than that god created us.

Of the first I have proof - we carry on this discussion of god and have so amny different opinions. We created god simply by the act of speaking about god.

Another theory is that of creation. Maybe. But if god is a creator, she is now busy creating yet another universe and has no time for a personal relationship with me or 7 billion other humans on earth.

by coachcs

Developers are not too keen on maintenance. They'd rather have someone else handle it. A systems admin is not the person who wrote the kernel. A creator - and we have yet to prove that she exists - is not likely to be a caretaker. Yet most believe that she is. Our concepts of god, all major religions included, are too full of contradiction.

by john.a.wills

Creation is not an act in time but an act outside time which causes the existence of something in time. The idea that God is busy now creating elsewhere is thus nonsense, but vwi may well inject vwiself into time and interact with any creature in time.

by jardinier

Hello John. The idea of this thread was to let atheists state and explain their viewpoints. It was not intended to be a discussion AGAINST atheism.

And who are you that you are such an expert on who God is and where or what He is doing? From whence did you learn the definition of creation which you have described?

by jardinier

I absolutely agree. While many Christians believe they have a personal relationship with God -- as Jesus or the Holy Spirit -- what about the millions (more likely billions) of people in Third World countries especially who live and die in horrendous circumstances?

I am in email contact with various people in African countries who are devout Christians. I guess they have to believe in something to compensate for the aweful reality of life including and especially AIDS orphans.

No amount of prayer or faith stops young children from being orphaned by AIDS and in many/most cases subsequently dying of it themselves.

I will have to say that the Christian religion especially is a curious phenomenon. While I accept that many people feel that their lives are enriched by their faith, only a minute portion of people in Third World countries actually benefit in some tangible way from their faith.

Maybe I will start a thread: "What is Christianity?" because to my knowledge that question has never been asked during the more than five years that I have participated in TR discussions.

by tonythetiger

does not make it so.

If you require evidence, you cannot have faith, and I doubt that it can be explained in terms that one who does not have it can truly understand.

by jardinier

As you live in a country, Bahrain, which is predominantly Muslim, were you raised in a religious household? If so, at what age did you dissociate yourself from this religion?

by tabish

I am a muslim expat working in Bahrain and am of Indian origin. We are Sufis by ancestry. It?s not Islam which I have dis associated from. Any organized social system which claims to be a voice of God on earth is my problem.

I am currently exploring reincarnation as a possible explanation to the maturity of the soul. As far as your age question goes, I knew something was not right from say the age of 10- 12. By the time I turned 25 I had no interest in faith.

Are you researching faith? You would find better answers at philosophy forums rather than tech forums.

by jardinier

Hi Tabish

I joined techreplublic in November 2002, just before the invasion of Iraq. It has been interesting to interact with Americans during this period.

As I have had a strong interest in religion and related subjects all my life, I am known for starting religious discussions here at TR.

However there is a handful of members who are atheists and who do not miss an opportunity to remind us "lesser mortals" who believe in some kind of religion or other, that they (the atheists) are supposedly more insightful or intelligent.

And so I decided to start this discussion specifically so that these members can explain their viewpoints.

I have done all the research that I am likely to need, but I do enjoy participating in online discussions. Currently I am posting regularly to an American website: meetchristians.com

While I am not, nor ever have considered myself to be a Christian in any normal understanding of the term, I do know quite a bit about this religion and its Scripture.

So for the most part I play devil's advocate -- challenging the Christians to re-examine their beliefs. The website features members from extreme fundamentalists to quite scholarly people. It is awesome to see to what lengths the fundamentalists will go in order to "prove" that the Bible (preferaby KJV) is literally true in every way.

by john.a.wills

1. The atheists do not seem to be doing a very good job of defending their beliefs, and I may as well point out a few flaws.
2. I learnt my definition of creation in primary school.

by nicknielsen

I don't see a need to defend my beliefs to anybody. You can believe that I'm an atheist and going to hell all you like, but what you believe isn't important to me. Even if I'm a Christian/Muslim/Hindu/Buddhist, [i]my beliefs are none of your dang business[/i] if you're not my preacher/priest/mullah/swami/whatever.

I believe ( ;\ ) that if you have to defend your beliefs, it's an indication that you don't believe in what you say you believe.

Edit: spurious d

by jdclyde

is still a belief. ;\

I think there are people that try to justify themselves and what they do to others, for some validation. This goes for religious beliefs as well as any other aspect of our lives.

You can try to share things that are important to you without it being a "defense".

to some that will be religion.
to some that will be politics.
to some that will be a video game.

doesn't matter what it is, you talk about what is important to you, or you find interest in.

On the other hand, if I find it noneyabusiness if I play strippoker on the computer vs cartoon girls, then I won't tell you about it. simple. does get chilly though.... :p especially when you lose.... :D

by john.a.wills

Perhaps we should try to expose our beliefs, because (I here quote Merton) the truth exposed can defend itself.

by Member 25348569

you've annoyed me a little bit now.

Could I just point out something for you to chew over. I don't want an answer for reasons that will become obvious.

I'm an atheist. My platform is one of simply not believing in any gods. I don't feel the need to claim anything, deny anything or argue with anyone except for simple exercising of my logical and debating faculties. I'm not a theist, not a believer in your God or any other god, force, superstition or superior alien influences.

I don't CARE what you theists collectively or separately believe unless you cross my path. I don't CARE if you personally think this particular atheist isn't "doing a very good job of defending his beliefs" and THAT, my rather dim-witted chum, is because I don't HAVE any beliefs to defend. D'oh!

Do you somehow feel that by not agreeing with your beliefs in the existence of your god I am somehow claiming something in opposition to you? How insufferably arrogant of you! Like most smug theists, you make (erroneous) assumptions about the motivations of atheists and then attack those motivations. Under those circumstances, all I do is to stand off to one side scratching my head and wondering "what's bitten HIM?".

My atheism - the absence of a belief in any gods - puts the burden of proof solely with you, the theist. If you cannot show me that your belief is reasoned and justified, then my atheism is, of necessity, plausible and rational.

You cannot argue that I deny the existence of God because God cannot be defined by you in terms that I accept. Until you and other theists, and those who are Judaic/Christian/Islamic in particular, can accept that your eternal, omniscient, omnipotent Yahweh/God/Allah is just another member of the set of gods in which I don't believe, we have no common ground over which to argue.

If I cared.

Which I don't.

Neil :)

by Member 25348569

It's non-belief and that's very different but I don't seem to have ever been able to get that across. See my gentle prod of John wills, above, where I've tried to define what I don't think...

Personally, I only argue religion as a sport anyway, because religion, per se, is not important to me but debating is fun. I wouldn't argue religion against Tigger, for instance, to try to undermine her beliefs because she's nice but if someone else comes onto TR and tries to kick butt over religion, I'll do my best to poke their eyes out but I won't start it.

Neil :)

If you lose a hand, you don't HAVE to take your kit off - they aren't real, you know.

by nicknielsen

Your choice of expose says volumes. Too many believers would rather impose; I suspect that's where the "defense" of beliefs comes in.

by kevin

What you need to do is look at the question you have written.

Atheism is one response to one question, which could be written as "do i believe there is enough proof for there to be a specific god figure or deity that created us"?,this can apply to one who is written about in so called holy books, or in general, as you can imagine the answer is no.

To an athist the above question has not been proven within reasonable doubt, in fact it would be fair to say that most come to the conclusion that the wild claims of most religion have very little basis in reality itself.

Some even would say that books such as the bible prove the exact opposite of some sort of devine creator.

Regardless however, Atheists can beleive in the supernatural or not, they can believe in scientific process, alien creators or in witchcraft, or purely in science, these are really other opinions which have nothing to do with Atheism.

Some other comments, regarding issues such as morality are really irrelevant.
We all (christian, muslim, atheist) develop skills from our environment and culture, parents, friends, and from how we perceive the world, no one is morally superior.

You do NOT need religion to develop a sense of morality, compassion and other positive human emotions are that, human emotions.

by jardinier

No that is what YOU need to do. I have not challenged atheism. I have merely asked athiests to express and explain their beliefs.

Perhaps we are feeling a bit on the defensive?

by kevin

The burdon of proof is with you my friend, as you are making a claim about the existence of something, I am not.

I wasnt going to but i will respond to your post.

1) Quoting bible verses does not make something true.

2) The evidence is unfortunately not there, if there were it would have been on the front page of every paper and we wouldnt need these sorts of discussions.

3) My Atheism has enhanced my life, not because of me "being free of the shackles of religion", but because of how wonderful you see life as.
There are great mysteries and there is knowledge to be acquired, because i dont say its gods work as a default answer to everything i can explore and expand my mind.

4)RE Personal ethics, Hitler was a catholic, George Bush is a Christian, Ahmendinejad is Muslim, uk voodoo women performaing rituals on children, the great witch trials performed by religious prejudice, i could go on, but i hoppe this illustrates my point that religion does not make you morally superior, in fact i think time and time again if we look at it objectively religion causes more division and prejudiced against various people in society.

I guess source of ethics, would be other people (such as friends and family), education, my own free will to decide to be a decent person, the fact that I sincerely value life, I could go on.

"I did not intend to be disingenuous with my remark about disproving, but I stand by it. If you cannot disprove that there is a god, then you are not in a position to judge or assess the validity of religious faith."

I go back to my first comment, i have nothing to disprove, basically because it is your job to prove the existance of god, and you havent done that, no one has, and i suspect ever will.

by jardinier

The sole purpose of this thread was to give aheists an opportunity to state their beliefs (or disbeliefs) and give reasons.

There is no burden of proof on me because I am not challenging atheism. I am just asking for your beliefs which you have stated very clearly.

Thank you for your post but do not read into my initial post something that was not there.

This discussion is closed to new replies.