Discussion Locked

What I would change or add to TPG...

0 helpful
28 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
TPG features in-depth articles, downloads, and online fully searchable books on IT Topics. Are we missing anything? What features would you add to TPG to make it a more valuable and useful product? Online training? Blogs? Interactive Chat? Reorganize the TPG Tracks?

28 replies

by zlitocook

That might be cool but alot of are still dialup and that could be a problem. If TPG did offer training how would it be done? Free for paining members, pay by course and if a course is passed would the person get any thing? Like a cert. or a icon next to thier alias? Just asking because I am taking online training and paying out the uh ear:).

by j sheesley

I'm not sure how it would work. I just put it out there. :) What would work best? There are companies that do CBT training that works over the Web. But that might not be the best course of action.

We would probably have to partner with someone like we do with TechBooks. The key would be to find the company that does that, and would do so without charging US too much.

What kind of training would work?

by zlitocook

I have used this at one place and it seemed to work great. But some thing like that has alot of overhead. Cost to buy, to install and user to use the software. It may cost less to out sourse it to a company here in the US for training and testing.

by blackcurrant

I am currently trying to provide remote access via VPN to our network. I have been extremely frustrated by the lack of information about how to set up a VPN. Could TPG compile an article about how to do this?

There are zillions of articles about how to set up Cisco routers and that's great if you have a Cisco router, but although these articles are fine, none of them talk about how to make the leap from the router to the network. They are all rather clinical, as if they have been written for a lab environment.

Also, many of the VPN + Windows 2000 networks articles seem to assume that everyone wants to use their server for the connection to the outside world. This is not the case for many people.

VPN goes beyond the router!

by wowjr1

(If this feature already exists, my apologies.) One problem I have with TPG is its large volume of content. I would like to see the ability of members to complete a fairly granular profile of "things" relevant to them. Then, I would like to see TPG categorize its content using the same things. (A particular piece of content would probably be categorized into multiple areas.) Finally - and the payoff - I would like to see e-mail notifications of the relevant new or changed content. (This is a more sophisticated version of what's available in Windows Sharepoint Services.) Seems to me this would help busy IT professionals realize more value from TPG since the availability of content on topics they have said they are interested in is being pushed. I realize the e-newsletters do this to some extent, but - IMO - they are not granular enough.

by j sheesley

I guess you're suggesting something different than a TPG specific RSS feed. Something more like, you pick the topics and get emails specificially when something posts that fits that topic?

We might have that... Im not sure.

by wowjr1

Yes, that's what I'm suggesting. RSS feeds are OK, but getting a message in Outlook (or another mail client) enables the recipient to keep it around, flag it for future investigation, etc.

by Greg Shultz

Along these same lines something like the My News feature on the MSNBC site might be a really cool feature.

If you've not seen/used it, check it out... Go to MSNBC.com home page and look about midway down on your right. Once you provide your zip code and click submit, you can then go back and pick and choose news stories from a big list of categories. Now, just imagine being able to pick certain tech topic areas from TechProGuild/TechRepublic/CNET and having a customized section appear each time you connect.

by j sheesley

The Web pages you see on TPG - the Home page, Download Center, TPG Tour, TPG Preview - are hand coded HTML now, just like the good old days of the 90's.

Article and search pages are dynamically driven through the common backgound engine that CNET uses. The Discussion Center is driven by Jive.

That's a great idea, but I wouldnt even know where to begin to implement customization like that... any idea how MSNBC does it?

by zlitocook

Just thought about how Yahoo customizes your login. We could let each user select what loads at login. Like favorite downloads, discssions ect.

by j sheesley

Naturally if we partner with a third party, they're going to want a cut of the pie. That's one of the bad things about the TechBooks service - naturally Books24x7 eats into the subscription fee for TPG.

Therefore, if we also tried to add a CBT service on top of TBs, the margin on TPG would be even slimmer. The CBT feature would have to be wildly popular and in demand to make it worth the while of adding it to the site. Unless we found a cheaper replacement for TechBooks or eliminated that feature altogether..

If it came down to that, what would you rather see... CBTs or online books?

by zlitocook

Hum I think CBT's are getting old, I can read online but there are a hundred other things that I also need to do online. Is it possible to have a SAN for just looking up answers? Not typing in a question and having to go through hundereds of non related returns? A search engine that only returns things related to the qusetion? Microsoft is getting close but still can not get it right. I spend more time looking up answers then I do finding them. I still like books over CBTs.

by j sheesley

So for you, a CBT has less value than the online books.

In that case, some type of online knowledgebase or technical support fits better with TPG?

by mclbcpj

Hello !

In The TPG Donwload Center, when you click on "All TPG Donwload", the list of all donwloads appear without description.

Perhaps, add a brief description in this list ?

by mclbcpj

Hello !

In The TPG Donwload Center, when you click on "All TPG Donwload", the list of all donwloads appear without description.

Perhaps, add a brief description in this list ?

by j sheesley

That's actually a simple canned search query... I think that they're working on the search engine to make the results make a little more sense.

That may go a long way to fixing this problem, but I havent seen the mockups of how download results look yet...

Good idea tho! Thanks!

by andeanderson

CBT's are OK. But, I spend most of my time in Tech Republic searching for and then sifting through all of non-related results for a specific item or question.

A knowledge base would be a welcome addition. However, most do not realize the time and effort it will take to compile a viable product. You may want to base it on having volunteer editors for specific topics or areas.

For example: Joe - Linux OS, Betty - Linux Drivers, Larry - Windows 3.11, etc...

Of course they would have to be chosen carefully so the topic would remain live and active and moderated to prevent unrelated information from being added.

Then have a search engine/spider which could perform exact match or Boolean searches.

by andeanderson

To start, contract with Microsoft to have a link to their Multi-Tetra Database which is linked with many news feeds;^)

You have the basics already in place. Based on the Unique User ID you would need to do a little Java-Scripting, or you might be able to get by with XML, to pull up the information links related to the User ID. MSNBC uses two cookies, one for their basic Home Page and one for the information associated with the unique user ID that is presented in a nested Table.

by j sheesley

Sounds like something I need to talk to Web Dev about. Lemme check into it. I think they're talking about doing more personalization on TR in general, which would also affect TPG. BUt that's an interesting thought.

by andeanderson

I would like to see a way to provide a Rating Feedback for the Downloads after I have had a chance to download and then either read or try them.

Right now you either have to provide an immediate rating or come back later to the download page to submit the rating. I do not know about the others who use these downloads, but it can be two or three weeks before I can get to actually trying to read or apply the download.

And, I do not try to go back into the download area to find that download and provide any rating. Sometimes the download is not even available anymore so no ratings could be submitted.

How about putting a HyperLink into the downloaded document or a rateme.txt file for programs for providing a feedback rating?

by mary.hoerr

Same thing happens to me. I usually download stuff to a folder for reading or using later. I haven't gone back to rate anything yet.

by j sheesley

As insiders, I can let you know that all TR downloads are going to be undergoing a change here very shortly. There will be more feedback, versioning, and requested features going to be added to the page as well as more ratings. It's looking good and I think they're going to be rolling it out very shortly.

by Scott Lowe

In the search results for the site, I would love to see a field added the lists the number of comments in the discussion for a particular article. It seems like it could also generate further discussion... maybe?

by andeanderson

I had forgotten this part.

I am searching for information on Apache 2 configuration on a Linux box.

I went to the Tech-Books and searched for Apache 2. I received 65 results with everything from Microsoft Networking to Solaris to Mastering Netware.

Out of them only 1 book dealt with Apache. And it was for Hardening the Security of Apache.

It would be nice if we could do another search within the results found. I could have done a second search for configuration and that would have weeded out a lot of the books.

by andeanderson

I have noticed there are similar discussion topics posted throughout the Discussion Areas that might be better served with a specific Discussion Topic.

There will always be new IT people and managers who are just running into problems and new situations that they need advice for or help with that are not Computer Centric.

One of the topics which keeps popping up is "How to say No to free advice."

I know you already have a Discussion called "Management". But, what about a Discussion Group for these New IT People/Managers? Call it "Help for New Situations" or maybe "Help for New ITs".

Or, set-up a Discussion Group called "IT Complaints"?

Something that would Help to attract these new people to a Discussion Area that is more applicable than "Network Administration" when they are trying to find out how to handle, or adjust, to a situation that is new to them, but a lot of us have already been through.

Apparently, most of them do not consider the "Management" discussion group as appropriate, since they are posting their questions in different Discussion Groups.

by andeanderson

I was searching the Server Discussion for information and when I didn't find what I needed I clicked on "Start Thread".

What I failed to notice was this link took me to a form which required me to select which Discussion Group to Post to. I thought I was still in the Server Discussion Group. So, instead of being posted to the Server Discussion my new thread was posted to the Network Administration Discussion.

You have the default group set as "Network Adminstration" and that's where my post went. I wonder how many others do the same thing?

Could there be a way for us to move or correct the discussion group our Post is in, when we are too quick on the submit button?

Or, you could change the form to require the selection of a Discussion Group and not have the form defaulted to any one specific Discussion such as Network Administration when starting a New Thread.

Just a thought from a busy, and sometimes lazy, IT Admin.

by j sheesley

Actually, I had the same thing happen when I first started this forum. Took me a couple of minutes to figure out what the problem was.

I'll have to check with Engineering to see if theres anything they can do about that.

This discussion is closed to new replies.