Discussion Locked

What is the point of TR Insiders?

0 helpful
20 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The PTB ask for our opinions. We offer our opinions and indulge in a little light banter along the way. Our opinions are ignored and the PTB proceed to do what they were going to do anyway.

Can anyone recall an instance or instances in which a suggestion from a TRI was actually implemented?

20 replies

by maxwell edison

....all of them, in fact, in which suggestions from TRI were considered by the PTB. I would never be presumptuous enough to believe that just because I suggest something, it should be automatically implemented.

by maxwell edison

The Web designers at TR (the PTB) at one time decided to take out the View All Open Questions link. I requested that it be put back. Quite a number of TR members (TRI or otherwise) agreed. It was put back.

by jardinier

Thanks for the feedback Max.

Of course I am a relative newbie to TRI. I guess it could be less than 12 months ago that Jay invited me to join the team.

But when you give those examples, possibly my voice has been heard also.

by jardinier

Perhaps instead of asking for opinions which THEY HAVE NO INTENTION OF IMPLEMENTING, the PTB could set up a direct marketing system so that we can all get RICH selling T-shirts with TOTALLY DUMB designs invented by the PTB.

by Jay Garmon

First, the teaser is out of date. Our Blog plans don't exactly match the supplied images.

Second, we're not merging the Discussions & Tech Q&A, we're merging the *hot & new lists* for each feature. Tech Q&A is changing rather significantly--based very much on TRI feedback--but not like that.

We'e also totally redesigning the purpose and function of blogs on the site--based partly on TRI feedback.

We're *FIXING SEARCH* based partly on TRI feedback.

We're modifying our tagging system so that there is more structure, based partly on TRI feedback.

We're combining Tech Q&A and Discussion posting forms--so the distinction is clear and the choice can be easily made--based partly on TRI feedback. We're also simplifying and merging the category lists of the two features--and allowing you to place a post in MULTIPLE categories--based partly on TRI feedback.

Oh, and after the revamp, we're making preliminary plans for a flat, chronological discussion view that places all the posts on ONE PAGE, based partly on overwhelming TRI feedback.

But, there is one catch--after revamp, the private TRI forum is going away. We'll be having these conversations out in the open. And we're working on a beta version of the site that might--MIGHT--be accessible to external beta testers. Because some TRIs asked for it.

Sorry if we weren't listening to you all. ;)

by hal 9000

But that has been there for ages and it's just a teaser they don't want us to have a play yet so we can break it. :(

Col ]:)

by tig2

So here is another question- When is the site launch planned for?

Beta????? Me too please!

by Jay Garmon

We don't have a firm date yet. We're more committed to getting the redesign as right as we can than hitting an arbitrary date.

by gadgetgirl

I [b] [i] [u] LIKE [/b] [/i] [/u] being a member of the Secret Squirrel Club!

How else can we tease people??

Come on, Jay, leave us [i] something [/i] to work with, here.

suited the fluffy tail,too

GG

by jardinier

Now I feel important again.

One question though. Do you think TR will ever evolve to a point that it actually works ALL the time?

by maxwell edison

You asked, [i]"Do you think TR will ever evolve to a point that it actually works ALL the time?"[/i]

I sure hope not. If there's one thing we've learned (or should have learned), is that in the realm of IT, change is not only inevitable, but it's almost a constant.

You may not know this, but in my job, I really have two functions (Well, three counting my training function.). I actually use IT to assist in producing the company's product, and I also maintain the IT infrastructure -- which is designed (by me), to specifically produce our product. When faced with an IT task, I approach it as trying to work myself out of the job, so to speak. But the tasks just keep coming and coming. As soon as I finish one, another pops up, whether it be because of software upgrades, hardware improvements, or new procedural methods because of people learning new and different ways to do things.

I've actually been trying to work my way out of this job for years, but change won't let me!

by Jay Garmon

We're going nuts trying to improve performance around here, but I don't think we'll ever completely win this war. For one, TR is a pretty feature-rich site, far moreso than your typical flat-content magazine-style article site. With so many moving parts, something always needs tuning. (Yes, we're working on simplifying stuff as part of the redesign.)

Second, we're part of corporate network of sites. For the most part, that has some serious advanatages in available technology and content. There is a price to be paid, however, in that our user authentication system, our ad-serve system, and big chunks of our hardware are controlled by people who radically outrank us and have far larger and different concerns than us. If somebody up the chain redesigns our login system (as has happened), we have to redesign to fit, and anybody who has ever worked in a big corporation can tell you how "smooth" such processes can be. Same for shared hardware (most of which has been eliminated)--back in the day, if News.com had a big traffic day, TR would slow down because we shared some app servers.

All of which is to say, we're going crazy trying to make our site function like a well oiled machine, but I don't think we'll ever hit five nines of perfect performance.

by hal 9000

You've just reminded me of my first days at IBM where the Sales Team made outrageous Promises about what our hardware was capable of doing generally when they where selling something way to cheap for the good of anyone but they kept coming back with [b]Look How Much Money We Have Saved You![/b] Actually that meant that the Technical Side was constantly driven crazy attempting to make a system perform in a way it was never designed to mainly because the more expensive hardware did the job better and right without all the mucking around because the Sales team where instructed to move Model XYZ this week because the Store Room had too many of them.

Anyway don't you now have some laws in place about using [b]Terror as a Tool?[/b] :D

Col

by jardinier

When did you implement this one Jay?

The website just prevented me from making a duplicate post, and from the tone of the message, I think I was chastised for inadvertently attempting to do so.

This discussion is closed to new replies.