Discussion Locked

What is the solution to the Social Security crisis?

0 helpful
28 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Already this is a critical issue in America, but will no doubt eventually become critical in other countries as modern medical techniques extend the lifespan of people.

In Australia, in the lead-up to the October 2004 election, Treasurer Peter Costello had a huge budget surplus which he suggested should be kept aside to meet future social security needs.

But Prime Minister John Howard blew the lot in order to buy his way to re-election.

However the issue is one of which the Australian Government is aware, and very concerned.

The episode of "West Wing" that was screened in Sydney this week was dedicated to the Social Security crisis.

Now I know a lot of you have strong feelings about welfare bludgers, but a restatement of those feelings is not what I am looking for.

I am looking for feasible suggestions. This may well include cracking down on welfare bludgers, but the real problem of course is with the ever increasing proportion of the population that is living longer and longer after normal retiring age.

One suggestion presented in West Wing was to extend the age for retirement, but this was dismissed as politically too unpopular.

28 replies

by hal 9000

And they die younger. As well as contributing a massive amount to Consolidated Revenue in Tobacco Taxes.

Col :D

by salamander

Any system in which people at the top of the pyramid get more out of a system than what they've paid in, absent any mechanism for interest-gathering, is in danger of collapse.

And for some back-of-the-envelope chicken scratchings to illustrate, assume that the average worker earns about $1,000,000 over his/her lifetime. Assume that a worker retires at age 65, and that he/she has had 10.3% of each check removed by the government for Social Security purposes. Assume the average (American) life span of approximately 77.2 years. Though the actual Social Security formula is more complex, this works out to a figure of about $703 per month in benefits. However, the U.S. average in 2002 for monthly benefits to retirees is about $874.

It appears to me that even people who work consistently throughout their lifetimes are getting a good deal more out of "the system" than they put into it...to say nothing of people who have contributed little or nothing to "the system."

In my opinion, anyone under the age of 30 who is having Social Security taken out of their checks will never see that money again...it should be considered "lost income," for all intents and purposes.

No pyramid can last forever. In most schemes, at the third tier, it falls apart. It's my belief that Generation X will have the task of dismantling the system, once it comes of age to weild a sufficient degree of political power in the U.S.

by protiusx

I concur. I am a generation X'er albeit an older one. I am on the back side of thirty and growing old fast. when I was taking economics in school back in the 80's my instructor said that we should not even consider social security as a part of our retirement. So I have not. I have made all my retirement decisions based on my own means of supporting myself and my family when I get to be an old codger like Col.
Now I now the question is what are some ideas to save or redo social security. I think we need to look at what the fund is being used for and what it's purpose is. We have completely changed the original purpose of Social Security and that needs to be addressed. We need to ask our selves whether this is a national retirement plan like it was intended or is it a benefits program for welfare programs. It shouldn't be for both.
Now here's a suggestion that will knock your socks off. The intent of social security was to take care of old people who can't work or who have reached retirement age. If that's the case then I think we should make a cap on income that would say if you have sufficient money to support yourself when you retire you really don't need the 800 bucks a month so we'll give it to someone who does. What I am saying is set a standard that says if a person has over a certain amount of money in their own retirement fund then they should be exempt from receiving social security payments. I am sure there are a lot of folks out there who have a decent retirement plan and still receive social security checks. Now don't get me wrong - I am not a communist or anything near it. I am suggesting that those who are able to take care of themselves do and collectively we all take care of those who can't. I think that is called charity not communism.

by salamander

I concur with your assessments regarding planning for the future. I personally do not figure Social Security into my plans for the future...people in Generation X or thereabouts cannot afford to do so.

Unfortunately, I think that basing benefits on how successfully a person saves creates a disincentive to do so, and would create huge problems down the line. Generation X is a smaller generation than the baby boomers. Social Security was built on the premise that each generation would produce a larger one after it. Unless taxes are increased dramatically, I cannot see how Generation X will be able to contribute enough to support the extended life expectancies of their parents' generation.

I think that a good start, albeit an unpopular one, is to begin cutting benefits across the board, though I think that's only a temporary solution. There is the matter of benefit creep...each politician promises more concessions than the politician before him/her in order to get elected...and we wind up sliding down a slippery slope into a quagmire. No politician in his/her right mind will suggest cutting benefits. Though it hasn't anything to do with Social Security, I was quite annoyed to hear yesterday that Medicare will now be covering lifestyle drugs like Viagra...I mean, really, people!

My temporary "solution" would be to cap benefits so that they would not exceed the amount contributed by each individual to Social Security. I also agree with your comment regarding returning Social Security to the purpose for which it was designed, and move individuals who are not workers to a separate public assistance program. I don't know much about the rules concerning the transferability of Social Security benefits, say between spouses, for example, but I would think that they would need to be re-examined, as well, for the future.

My preference, though, would be to have the system dismantled entirely, and I believe that this will happen within the next thirty years.

I do think that this problem will be one of the big dragons to be slain by Generation X...and I see this creating a huge generational schism in our society. The politicians currently in power will do everything they can to preserve the spoils of this system for their own generation. I only hope that the X'ers will have the will to take it on unflinchingly in the coming years.

by thechas

Protius,

I never thought I would see any topic that the 2 of us had any basic agreement on.

I also believe that Social Security needs to change from a universal benefit to a needs based plan.

One side note:

While Social Security was sold as and has become a retirement program, it's initial purpose was jobs creation to help end the Great Depression.

Prior to Social Security, it was not uncommon for people to work until they died. Pensions were meager at best, and the stock market crash wiped out many peoples savings.

Social Security was created to provide a means of support so that older workers could retire and open up jobs for younger workers.

Chas

by jardinier

and has been for as long as I remember.

ALL types of pension (old age, disability, widow's etc) have asset and income tests to determine if the individual is entitled to full pension, part pension or no pension.

"Assets" include all your material possessions except the house that you own. There are different ceilings for single and married persons.

"Income" includes all income whether from part time work or investments. I think the figures have changed recently, but it used to be: for every dollar you earn more than a set amount (used to $AU 50 per week, but may have increased) Social Security subtracts 50 cents from your pension.

For the assets test (quite separate from the income test) if your assets (not including the house that you own) exceed a certain figure, your pension is reduced accordingly.

There is an example in my own family. My sister, aged 69, is receiving a full Old Age Pension. When my mother, now aged 94, passes on, my sister will inherit a considerable sum of money, which will make her no longer eligible to receive any pension payment.

[I will make enquires today, and edit the figures if they have changed].

by levannah44

No, Protius, it's called means testing, at least here in Australia.

No-one likes it, but it may be the only way to go in the future -- here and in the US.

Levannah (aka Gret)

by apotheon

Social Security was never sustainable. As TheChas has pointed out, the original aim of SS wasn't to provide for those who are too old to provide for themselves; it was to get older workers out of the market with government handouts. This served two very useful political purposes.

1. Seniors felt like the government was doing good things for them, so they would be likely to vote again for all relevant incumbent candidates next time around.

2. Younger people felt like the government was doing good things for them, so they would be likely to vote as the seniors did.

Of course, it was a short-term "fix" for some of the effects of the Depression at best. The Depression briefly faltered, then worsened, as a result of the economic effects of taxing the hell out of everyone still working to push others out of work and pay their way. The only way to turn around an economic depression is to increase production of wealth, but policies that increase production of wealth don't look as much like handouts to the general public, so they don't tend to garner as many votes.

Rather than increase wealth production, SS only took wealth from the hands of those who could ill afford to use it and put it in the hands of others so that they would cease producing wealth. I trust you can recognize the long-term folly of that way of thinking (in this case, long-term being anything longer than only a couple of years or so). Ultimately, what saved the US economy was the production demands of war.

In any case, the encroaching collapse of SS is simply the long-delayed inevitable coming home to roost. Welfare programs, when they're calculated out and measured and judged "good", are judged based on foreseen expenses and projected growth. Such growth projections don't take into account the effect the welfare program will have on economic growth (I haven't met a government handout yet that motivated people to produce more: they demotivate those who have to pay and remove any incentive to find work for those on the dole). They also assume a static system, where a snapshot of a given time-span is assumed to be a reliable judge of future trends. The baby boom (as a result of celebratory fun after the war) and subsequent low birth-rate amongst the baby-boomers themselves threw a huge monkey wrench into the whole "money grows on trees" theory of Social Security.

Add into that the fact that politicians, whether Left-wing or Right, plan in five-year increments (give or take: adjust for actual term lengths of various offices) to maximize electability over a four-year (or adjusted number, natch) span. As a result, SS got plundered any time there was a "surplus" (meaning "for once, we're getting more in SS taxes than we're paying out in benefits", without any concern for the fact that this would need to continue for a while just to get back out of the red). This, of course, is just evidence of what I've known all along: you can't trust government with your money. We're now looking at the inevitable collapse of the SS system, here at last.

If governmental officials really want to make things as smooth as possible, they'll go with a plan similar in principle to what George Bush is currently proposing (I loathe the guy, but nobody else in federal government is offering even mildly sane alternatives except Ron Paul, and nobody's listening to him). He's recommending allowing workers to divert part of their SS tax into an approved retirement account so that they can provide for themselves rather than simply paying into a black hole.

Personally, I don't think there's any need to bail out Social Security at all. The longer we keep it on life support, the more problems it sill cause. Government handout programs cause more economic hardship than they alleviate. For every dollar going into the hands of someone poorly-screened (and, thus, as likely to be some lazy parasites with six kids and a crack habit as they are to be a hard-working, needy individual fallen on hard times), there's something on the order of three dollars taken from the hands of those ill able to afford it.

Thus, the answer to Social Security is, to me, quite simple: Let it die. Better yet, cancel it TODAY, and start trying to figure out how to pay back the debt its current financial rat's-nest has created. If any money can be eked out of it upon cancellation, use it to retrain the bureaucrats currently working in Social Security offices nationwide to do a useful job.

We Gen-Xers aren't just going to have to deal with the lack of SS to fall back on if we are such poor planners that we decide to let government take care of us: we're going to have to keep paying money into that black hole because politicians aren't willing to take the heat from the voters for doing the right thing.

By the way, ProtiusX, if I give money voluntarily to help someone else, that's charity. If someone shows up at my door with a census form and a gun to steal my money, that's socialism. There's a distinct difference, and Social Security isn't on the good side of that.

by jessie

For Congress to STOP SPENDING IT!!! Congress "borrows" from social security all the time to fund their little pet projects. If they STOPPED doing that, and put BACK the money that they "borrowed"... problem SOLVED!!!!

Of course, if Bush had done what the democrats WANTED him to do with that budget surplus 4 years ago, and put it into social security, we wouldn't be having this conversation at all!

by jardinier

there has been a parallel in Australia.

Prime Minister Howard ("Liberal Party," equivalent to your Republican Party) blew the surplus to buy his way into re-election. That is to say, whatever the opposition ("Labor Party," equivalent to you Democrat Party) offered in the way of promises to put more money in peoples' pockets, Howard countered with a more generous offer.

by apotheon

There wasn't enough money in that budget "surplus" by far to bail out Social Security. In fact, it's mathematically impossible to indefinitely maintain the Social Security program without periodically turning off payments while still collecting taxes on it. That, of course, would be fairly counterproductive, though less so than continuing to attempt to keep SS going.

Unfortunately, this means that the problem would not have been "solved" if Bush had pushed to have that money earmarked for Social Security. Keep in mind, by the way, that though Bush suffers quite a few failings as a President, it's Congress that holds the purse strings. That means that it was Congress that voted to deal with the so-called surplus as they did.

by jdclyde

The Clinton recession if he had socked that money away instead of giving it back to the people that made that money, us.

The government is a non-profit organization. ANYTIME they have a "surplus", it means they OVER taxed us. Something that is illegal.

If you have more of your own money that YOU earned, then you are more likely to go out and get that SUV / Big screen TV / new X-box or whatever.

If you buy that new toy, someone else has a job SELLING that new toy. If someone has a job selling that toy, someone else has a job MAKING that new toy. All of these people are working, making a living and PAYING TAXES so the tax base goes up.

Just sitting around saying we should tax the "evil rich people" that make over $200 K to pay for OUR bills won't fix things.

The raiding of the SS fund has been going on for decades, and as apatheon pointed out it is CONGRESS that spends the money, NOT the Pres. The CONGRESS decide what bills get passed, what gets taxed, what "rights" we gain of lose. They do a lot of strutting around playing politics about it but it is a fact that when one party is in "power", the other party drags it's feet on everything because if anything good happens the other party will get the blame. What is bad for our country is good for the Democrats at this time and has been for the last four years.

Listen to Sent. Kennedy sometimes and look at what he is doing. First, is he concistant in his stance from administration to administration? Is he offering a solution or just running around saying that the other party is evil and out to fill their own pockets?

Remember, ALL Senators are millionairs, not just the Republicans. And the the Kennedy fortune came from bootlegging and shorting stocks at the start of the depression. How "in touch" is he with the common man?

by thechas

This has been a news and talk show subject since the President announced his desire to change the Social Security program.

My suggestions would "fix" the funding problems, but would be rejected out of hand by the politicians.

1. Go ahead and start some form of partial investment accounts. Keep in mind that limiting the accounts to "safe" investments will NOT provide the kind of investment growth that some people expect.

2. Change the limit on contributions.
Cap employer match at the first $75,000
Remove the individual cap. Or, at least raise that cap to $200,000

3. Keep the present formula for adjusting payments.

4. Change the program from paying all retirees to a needs based system.
I don't have the statistics to define a formula for capping benefit payments.
The formula should take into account all other forms of income not just wages, and the value of investments with some exclusions.

Primary residence, family owned farms, and family businesses should NOT be part of the investment assets used to determine need.

5. Set up the funding system to have a nominal 5% or 10% fund surplus. Adjust the rate annually to maintain the surplus.

Chas

by jdclyde

If part of the money taken from us goes into this fund (only if we chose) it would have two major benefits that I can see right off the bat.

One, this is less money sitting around that can get raided to fund other projects. Forcing the Congress to keep their mitts off it. (a major reason I see for them apposing this type of change.)

Two, the money gets re-invested, which gets more capital in the work place. Leading to more growth?

Three, right now it doesn't get any interest on the money we are putting into this fund, so it doesn't even keep up with inflation. At the worst if it was in a savings account we would get between 1 and 3% on it.

Fact, lots in "power" would lose some of that power if they give up partial control of the stigma of running the social security fund and being the one's to hand the money out. When people go around lying to current seniors they will lose their benifits if there is privatization should be nothing short of illegal. (the same people that ran around screaming that Bush lied? Their turn now I guess.)

by onbliss

Parents took care of the kids, when the kids were young. When the kids grow up, they take care of the Parents.

by levannah44

As unpopular as it is, focus more on means testing, as well as raise the retiring age, say to at least 70.

People who continue to work longer should, by rights, enjoy better health in any case. Firstly, they're occupied, with, it's to be hoped, not too much stress in their lives to cause illness.

Secondly, medical progress is so phenomenal at the moment, I doubt anyone could stay too sick for long anyway!

That said, we've also got to face the fact that many of the younger generation will never work, that is, have paid employment. Call them the dole bludgers if you like -- although I doubt all of them would be classed as such, because many would love to work -- but many of them simply cannot qualify for the jobs they want or are qualified and there are just no jobs available.

The whole work ethic is changing, too, or rather, has changed drastically over the past two or three decades. It's continuing to do so.

The trend to work from home and not commute every day is a growing one, but while many people are finding their ease with this arrangement to be exactly to their taste, the niche business in the home market is (at present) unable to secure one vital fact -- control over the compulsory portion of a person's salary that formerly went towards their super, plus, of course, the employer's component.

How can these very necessary matters be monitored and controlled from the perspective of the home business? For that matter, can they be controlled?

Without this compulsory saving, the home business owner will either have to work forever, until they simply drop, or retire at whatever the new age for that becomes and live on the pension, having, of course, first been means tested.

This will unquestionably throw a great many people on the dust heap, something no-one wants to see happen and, for that matter, something which only makes the divide between the "haves" and the "have-nots" wider and deeper than ever.

People are not "things", so somehow a method will need to be found to monitor a person's income, especially that of a self-employed home-business based person in the same way PAYE employees are already monitored to ensure that part of their weekly income is compulsorily put aside for their superannuation, i.e. retirement.

The government simply can't afford to go on handing out money to those who are no longer in paid employment, AND for more and more years now after they retire. Right now, the so-called "baby-boomer" generation is slowly drizzling onto the retirement market, and they all have to be catered for.

Many will already be self-funded retirees, but just as many won't. Some may have had a patchy employment career and not have been in a position to save. Then again, the compulsory putting aside of a portion of one's salary perhaps wasn't around long enough for many of them to save either.

Eventually, we will all need to become responsible for funding our own retirements, whenever and however long they may turn out to be, but it'll be a rough ride over the next decade or so while we're getting there.

I don't know the ultimate answer. Other than the above, there appears to be no rapid, ready-made solution. I wish there were. But then, life wasn't meant to be easy, was it?

Levannah

by av .

There is no reason why some of our other federal taxes that we already pay can't be diverted into that fund now. They did borrow over a trillion dollars from it for general use over the years, now is the time to start paying it back. It was supposed to be money that the taxpayers paid in to be used for social security, in good faith - not part of the general fund.

This is just another example of wasteful government spending. You don't hear the government talking about how they raided the piggy bank and it was wrong, instead they want to dismantle the system and start anew. I am tired of the flim flam games. I want my government to start working for me.

I don't think they should change Social Security's structure at all. It has worked for years and will continue to do so. I don't think there is one government program ever that has been so successful. Our government should identify cuts in spending so we don't have to pay any more taxes. Like how about if we don't take on new wars? That would same tons of money.

I see Australia is in much the same place as America. It's time to hold governments accountable and demand fiscal responsibility.

Privatizing Social Security sounds like you can get more for your money by investing it your way, but what if you're wrong? What if the stock market fails? I have a 401K, it took a big hit - like 25% during the dotcom failure without being invested in aggressive funds. What if that happened to your social security? It might be the last thing you had left (worst case scenario). Then you would be old, maybe sick and penniless. Maybe you think this could never happen to you, but its possible. Social Security is there so you at least have something.

I definitely do not want to see them raise the retirement age. By 65 years old, its hard to keep up with the routine. Thats enough. You've already put a great deal of your life into working and its time to enjoy things that you never had time for over your working years. Then you get to go from work to live to live to work. The Golden Years. Time to do that certain thing you've always wanted to do.

I think everyone should be entitled to that. For myself, I would never totally retire, just work less.

by apotheon

If Social Security, in present form, isn't dismantled or phased out in the next [b]fifteen[/b] years, it will either collapse under its own weight to produce a catastrophic economic crisis that affects far more than just baby boomers, or it will become such a tremendous cash sink for this government that conversion to what is effectively a soviet system will be unavoidable. Thirty years is far too optimistic, I think. Look for the emergency to come to a head in half that time.

by salamander

...is that in fifteen to thirty years, when Gen X'ers have the political power to impact major policy, this generation will have more of a vested interest in preserving the system, due to the contributions they will have made up to that point. It will be interesting to see how that shakes out.

by apotheon

There was a comment in [i]Breakfast Club[/i] to the effect that when you "grow up", your soul dies. While I'm not sure that's strictly accurate, it does tie in nicely with the idea that as people get older, they get politically moronic.

by hal 9000

What about the programs by the US Federal Government that pays farmers to produce crops that go unused or are so under priced as to no longer be even remotely funny?

Maybe it's just me but wouldn't it be far more useful to stop these idiot programs and save money there?

Col

by apotheon

That's a good point, and something I've discussed with others before. Government subsidies constitute an interference with market forces, which in turn causes economic crises to arise on a regular basis. For every farmer kept in business in the US by subsidies, producing crops that are burned or letting fields lie fallow, there are probably a dozen farmers in other countries that suffer from US surpluses and a thousand US citizens that can't afford to pay their bills this month due to tax withholdings.

by tomsal

I think its a joke for the most part. Hey all I'm saying is I'm preparing my mindset that it doesn't exist for me. And being that if I retire at age 65 I still have 35 years left in the work force...I strongly *STRONGLY* doubt in 35 years SS will be there for me.

But I like the idea of the money being privately invested instead of the goverment's mitts all over it (we've seen how well they managed it so far).

It's pretty sad when I think my nephew who is 16 and is probably the WORST person I know when it comes to saving money...yet I put more confidence in him saving his own SS money than the government.

by apotheon

Social Security can't really be taken seriously by any rational being. It's a joke. Even the name is an oxymoron: "Social Security". It's self-contradictory by nature.

by dwdino

1) Quit living so long, die when your young and healthy.

2) Put all elected official back on SS. They have private health care for the rest of their lives and we allow them to manage our retirement care... hmmmm

3) Stop taxing for SS and well runs dry, adios.

4) Teach the American people to quit being lazy ass' and work hard without handouts. Expect nothing, earn everything. My grandparents are 70 and still working (granted, at what they enjoy), but income none-the-less.

5) Personal savings accounts, maybe. CD style with 2-5% standard return annually for 30 years.

If falls back to an old chinese proverb:

Hand outs bad, Hard work good, get busy you lazy poo.

by apotheon

It works for me.

(Note: I'm a "lazy ass" American that doesn't use government handouts.)

by salamander

Hmm. Don't think that I'm in a rush to grow up, then. I'm rather attached to my soul as it is.

This discussion is closed to new replies.