If management policies are to be truly fair to all employees, then you can't set a single rule by which to judge all employees' situations.
All circumstances are different. All people are different. All HR Departments are different. All managers are different.
Each situation must be evaluated and be given due consideration to be totally fair.
After all, you don't know if zlito had been there 2 months...or 2 decades. Perhaps he had not built up a level of trust in his manager?
But, to say a single rule fits every possible situation is, in my opinion, quite obtuse.
Again, zlito might not have directly taken an aggressive approach to putting a stop to the situation.
However if zlito goes up to a woman who has been "very friendly" to him and says...
[i]'Hey...I'm really not interested in your amourous advances toward me.'[/i]
that makes him vulnerable to a charge of sexual harassment himself. After all if you imply to someone that they are making sexual or amourous advances toward you and they want to get back at you for turning them down, she simply need to go HR and say...
[i]'He said that I was making sexual advances toward him. I am offended and would never do that. I never act in an unprofessional manner.' [/i]
and his arse would end up being, in the corporate's eyes, in the wrong when he really wasn't.
Plus if he goes to HR with [b]no[/b] proof whatsoever with an allegation...and somewhat revealing clothing such as loose blouses and slightly above the knee skirts would not be proof of sexual advancement...any HR department in a company would take no action other than maybe to speak to her manager and have him/her address the clothing issue...and at most might consider amending or modify their code of conduct concerning dress code to cover themself legally if they felt it was that much of a liability risk on their part.
And with that said, you can't possibly think that the feel good you should get from reporting harassment would end up a feel good if they deny your allegation...or even worse...turn the table on you.
And, I see zlito's case as one of those where he had no proof and a "Fatal Attraction" type woman who was going to extreme measures (including professional coercement) to get him in vulnerable situations.
It's not the reporting that gives relief...it's solving the problem. Hence, that is why I suggested in my last post removing the "cancer" from the workplace rather than firing an employee for being too passive.
And to let you know, I'm not green to the management arena either. After working 6 years professionally in programming IT, I moved up to a supervisory/management position and did budgeting, employee evaluations, staff meetings, technical analysis and implementation design, project estimations, etc. Plus, I also filled the roles of maintaining systems and software as well at the same time.
So, I'm not just talking out of my arse either. I've been in the management arena. The only reason I didn't stay where I was at because of where I was living, and because I was going to be sitting in the position I was in with no possibility of promotion until one of two people retired for me to move up. I was upwardly mobile and wanted more of a challenge than managing a $4M budget. So, I started over in Florida as a software engineer with a multi-billion dollar corporation to begin working my way up again. Of course, that flopped when they lied to me about "promoting from within" and "a very upwardly mobile work environment".
I worked over 2 years there...not once considered for promotion...only got cost-of-living increases and one salary adjustment which was corporate wide.
Hence, I don't promote being totally trusting of anyone in the workplace...or the workplace itself.
Nonetheless, I don't see drawing the hard-line being necessarily the best management technique.
And, being fair to all employees doesn't mean setting the same rule to them all. It means being [b]fair[/b] to each of them, and giving each of them equal consideration and understanding.
Of course where I live, we have a larger embodiment which does this called the legal system. Everyone is given consideration under law, because their are extenuating circumstances.
And, the workplace is no different. Extenuating circumstances exist [b]everywhere[/b].
BTW, the everybody taking a 3-week unannounced leave...happens. It's called a walk-out.
I also do have to point out...you said:
[b][i]"If someone has a crisis, all I need is a phone call. If you can't make a call in the day, leave a message at midnight when I will not be there. But some information is required, you can't just not show up. If you can't face the boss on the phone, then have someone else call about the situation."[/i][/b]
zlito (or OP as you've called him) did say:
[i]"...I called in and said I was a car accident and would be out for awhile."[/i]
So, he did make the call.
Again, I won't condone what he did. As I said, it was a very bad decision he made. However, I would not just say in a "cut and dry" manner 'Oh he's fired because he lied about the issues he's having.'
If I found out, I'd call him in and tell him I knew and ask him why he lied. If he told me about the situation with the woman, I'd then tell him 'Listen...you should have come to me. I would have helped you. I'm not gonna bite your head off for you being a victim. OK? Now, let's solve this thing so you can be you at work.' and dealt with it from there and helped him pursue and investigate it myself and with HR.
It might not be a manager's job to do HR functions, but it is your job to work in your employees' best interest...whether professional or personal.
Now on the other hand if I found out he was in the Bahamas for 3 weeks, I'd have gathered proof and said 'Listen...I know the truth. And, there was no underlying cause for you to take sick leave for an infirmity of any kind...mental or physical. I regret I have to do this, but I am going to have to notify HR of the situation and suggest dismissal.'
As I understand, you take a much harder line to the management philosophy than I do and hold steadfastly to the written rule. And as I said before, I wish you all the luck in the world with it and hope that it works for you and your employer...and I mean that sincerely.
Good luck.