If you had, and if you had the "intellectual integrity" you accuse neilb of lacking, you wouldn't describe her style as "soulless intellect". The closest thing to a soul that any of us can be sure that we have is a personality, or a "sense of life", which is clearly in evidence in all of Rand's books that I have read. Now, I'll take a few minutes to de-bunk your claim that religion gave to the world the values you claim it has given.
[i]"Classical music had as its roots religious madrigals from which evolved the most complex symphonic creations."[/i]
If those religious madrigals really [i]contributed[/i] to classical music, why does classical music survive as entertainment, and classical madrigals only as subjects of academic study, of interest to none outside the academy, and so few in it? Rather than making a contribution of substance or style to classical music, it's more accurate that religious madrigals served mainly as impetus -- to make something BETTER! Thus, we have classical [i]music[/i], not classical [i]madrigals[/i], and NOBODY listens to madrigals for enjoyment.
[i]Jazz had its roots in negro spirituals -- Christianity once again.[/i]
The roots of jazz include Christianity, one could argue, but one must also admit that African musical styles also contributed to "negro spirituals", and that the blending of the two styles (African and Christian) would not have occurred (at least not when and where it did) without slavery. So, if you claim that Christianity deserves credit (and I'll allow only partial credit at most), then to be consistent with the facts of history, you must also concede that slavery was [b]the[/b] indispensable element in the process that brought those musical styles together, at that period of history, resulting, eventually, in jazz. Therefore, any credit Christianity has for jazz, it owes directly to slavery, aka evil. You're free to claim that all you meant is that "some good came of it" via Christianity, but I won't call that the primary conclusion to draw from slavery and Christianity's role in it, which was mainly passive acceptance. Ignoring the fact of slavery is exactly the type of evasion of the most important facts of reality that makes beliefs based primarily on otherworldly myths inherently evil: religion tends to make it more convenient to ignore or dismiss, than to oppose, real suffering in the real world, caused by real evil people. Systematically perpetuating evil in the name of That Which All Of Us Know To Be Unreal, is evil in the extreme. And Christianity does tell us to "pick up our crosses" and to passively accept suffering rather than to recognize that suffering is only one of many possible scenarios, and that we have it within our power to choose among those possible scenarios, or at least to influence which one we experience.
[i]Perhaps you have some explanation as to why so many of the greatest minds and most creative people have found room for religion in their lives...Religion did not prevent some of the greatest scientists from developing their theories which eventually were turned into applied science.[/i]
Because it has been prevented, we have no way of knowing [b]what[/b] has been prevented. We can only know a subset of what has not been prevented -- that which is, or has been. It is true that many of the greatest scientists have admitted to a religious affiliation. But my personal experience tells me that the prevalence of religion among scientists is more the result of unofficial, undocumentable censure of all, in any profession, who do not join a mystical collective of some sort.
[i]Take away from Western -- or any other culture -- everything that has been created from a religious motivation, and the world would be a bland place indeed.[/i]
Take away from Western -- or any other culture -- everything that has [b]evolved beyond[/b] a religious motivation, and the world would be a bland place indeed.
[i]The most beautiful example of architecture in the world ? the Taj Mahal ? a product of Islam. The many beautiful and ornately carved structures in the world ? all products of one religion or another. [/i]
I haven't seen either in person, but I preferred the lines of the World Trade Center to the Taj Mahal. The styles of both are well-suited to their respective purposes, I suppose. I simply prefer the purpose of life on Earth and its accompanying architecture to worship of the unreal.
What I see in the examples you cited is not religion bestowing blessings on the real world. I see reason providing superior alternatives to every drab, uninspired attempt of religion to secure a monopoly on the meaning of life, which in fact is: the pursuit of happiness. Show me a religion that has done more to advance the individual pursuit of happiness than to obstruct it, please!
PS Alter is a verb, meaning "to change". If neilb has a sacred space in his home dedicated to Ayn Rand, it would be correctly spelled "altar" or perhaps shrine, but not "alter".
:^O