Discussion Locked

What motivates a terrorist?

0 helpful
160 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

160 replies

by monkeybutter

I am in no way condoning the acts mentioned above, but how do you think they should express their problems with the issues they are so violently against?

by oz_media

I wish that mad cow did wear a mask.
Hows this for taking a discussion off topic.
Damn, this thread's been going on forever!
May it be laid to rest in peace.
( I think I'll still be checking it tomorrow tho.)

by jimhm

What happened - do you believe in the actions taken by Anti-Abortion groups - by the green whinies - Anti-Technologies - and the other groups.

In the US they can Lobby - Advertise - Attempt to sway public to their side.. If that fails well guesswhat - it fails ... People want technology, people want the option of abortion, people want wood to build homes - so these things are going to change ... I don't believe in abortion - and I don't support it - but its not my job to tell someone else - they can't have one... That is between her and her maker...

So if they can get things changed - Live With It .. There is no justification for Terrorist actions - whether it is Domestic or National or Internation - If you can't change it - because the majority doesn't want to change it ... then tuff - accept it - live with it - or kill yourself without hurting anyone else ...

by monkeybutter

Just re-read your "how many good Brits" post.

Someone *did* take on Germany when it invaded Poland. Both France and Great Britain declared war on Germany just two days after the Polish invasion commenced.

Took the US another two years, and the most stupendously foolish act on the part of Japan in the history of warfere, to get involved.

*shrug*

by zlitocook

For people who would kill them selfs. There are hundredes of cults, clubs and religist groups who will die for thier religion. I bet the first people here did not have this problem. The people who deside to die with a bomer vest are told that they will get what they want in the after life.

by jimhm

If I remember my history correctly ? when Hitler invade Poland, he promised the British and French governments that was all he was going to take. Then he invaded another country ? then Britain (I forget the name of the foriegn minister that worked the deals with Hitler attempting to appease him) only imposed economic sanctions. And The French were invaded they didn't defend Poland, and surrender months after being attacked. Britain must have a different history book.

As to America entering the war ? the delay was caused by the liberals (they were called isolationists) in the government at the time that said it was a European conflict and didn?t involve the interests of the United States. And blocked any measure to support the war except for selling arm?s to the British government.

As I said there were over 50 Million deaths in WW-II which included British, Irish, Scott?s, American?s, French, German?s, Italians, Chec?s, Pol?s, Russian, Chinese, Japanese, Aussie?s, Dutch, SouthAfrican, Egyptian shall I go on ? I don?t think there was one race of people that didn?t lose during that time.

And it is all speculation and conjecture on if taking Hitler out early would of changed the course of historical events. And there isno evidence one way or the other -

by jimhm

Sorry my mistake - it was not Poland it was Czechoslovakia that he started with ... Ooops - my fupa -

Change Poland to Czechoslovakia in previous post..

by generalist

I seem to recall hearing rumors that some of the 9-11 hijackers were suckered into participating, thinking that they were involved in a hijacking, rather than a suicide crash. The rumors hinted that some of the hijackers fit a more criminal profilerather than the religious profile of the cell leaders.

They would have been the ones keeping the passengers at bay. They wouldn't have known they were being suckered until the planes hit their targets, given the timing.

by monkeybutter

In the late '30s, Britain was still recovering from the effect of harshly interest-loaded war loans from the US, the origins of which were the Great War. For over 15 years, approximately 13% of the exchequer's revenue was going to the US, at a timeof depression. It should be noted that only the UK was obliged to pay back at these rates. France's war loan repayment was much more lenient, and they weren't even paying it anyway. The move to a war economy for Britain was a long-term effort which took nearly two years. War was simply unfeasible at the time.

Neville Chamberlain is often viewed as a sell-out for trying to "buy off" Hitler (and to a lesser extent, Mussolini) with the Italo-Germanic peace accord, and whilst he may have been a prime example of a bad war-time prime minister, his piece of paper, and "peace in our times" allowed the UK time to shift to more of a war-related footing.

The US may have had decisions regarding entering the war, but for a long time those decisions would have been which side to enter upon. Hitler had a lot of popularity amongst many prominent American citizens, the most notable of which was Henry Ford. Henry Ford's written work "The Universal Jew" went through six print runs in Germany, and Hitler praises him in Mein Kamph. Ford actually *financed* the Nazi party, affording them over a hundred thousand dollars towards party funds via numerous front organisations. He was not alone amongst some of America?s finest. In fact, upon the invasion of Russia by Germany, President Roosevelt publicly advocated entering the war *on Germany?s side* ?to kill as many [Russians] as possible?. As previously mentioned, it was the raw Russian numbers and Stalin?s disregard for the welfare of his troops that ended up defeating Germany. Hitler?s support in the US lead him (quite rightly, in all honesty) to believe that they would remain out of any war actions.

by monkeybutter

Numerous primary sources, including German defectors, recovered dossiers, intercepted communiqu?s and the like, demonstrated that Hitler had no intention of ever going to war with the US or the UK. Hitler?s aristocratic support in both these nations led him to believe that he could develop peace accords with these nations, and at the time their ideals were not entirely alien to his own. Hitler?s primary target, the country he wanted most, was Russia, at the time his most powerful enemy. The conquest east was his main goal, and the ultimate intention of what was to become the Second World War.

I might seem somewhat anti-American here, but as mentioned before, the responsibility for the Second World War does not lie solely on the head of Hitler. It has its roots in the Great War, and one of the primary problems that made his surrounding nations such a walkover were Wilson?s 14 points, the obvious one being the insistence that Poland be made into an independent state with free access to the sea, and peripheral aspects of other points leading to the creation of several nations within Europe that did not priorly exist in that form.

Prior to the Great War, Europe existed in a stable state because of nations that formed effective buffer zones to prevent any one given country spilling via military conquest into its neighbours. The various countries spawned by Wilson?s 14 points (which he fronted to Germany without consulting *any* other European country) could not performthis buffer effect, and as such set up multiple areas of easily conquerable space for Hitler?s Germany to expand into. Poland in particular, which, thanks to its free access to the coastline afforded him easy launching platforms for his naval assaults. If the independent nation of Poland had never existed as a largely defenceless country bordering Germany, this couldn?t have happened as easily.

by monkeybutter

As previously mentioned, Hitler did not want the US or the UK. He was hoping to hack through Poland, followed by France, and then create a stronger peace accord with the UK.

As previously mentioned, what Hitler really wanted was Russia. If he?dhad a chance to focus the entirety of the German War Machine on this target, he may have overwhelmed their numbers with sufficient forces adopting his Blitzkrieg methodology. As such, if France and Great Britain had not declared war against Germanyat the time they did, it?s entirely possible that Germany could have routed the Russian forces, rendering them incapable of fulfilling their necessary role as the only nation on Earth who could destroy Germany.

Great Britain declaring war was notsomething Hitler had anticipated. He?d expected either compliance or the same indifference he?d pegged down for the US. At the time of Great Britain declaring war, Hitler had no plans whatsoever concerning an attack on Britain, let alone invasion, which was one of only two methods of bringing Britain to its knees (the other being the utter annihilation of supply lines).

The first and only plan Germany ever contrived in the direction of invading Britain was born in 1940, and its name was Operation Sealion. Operation Sealion was an extreme exercise in wishful thinking, and was so fanciful as to make the Narnia Chronicles look realistic. Britain, as I?m sure you?re aware, is an Island nation, and as such requires an amphibious assault. Such an assault requires air superiority (preferably total), secure supply lines (guarded by total air superiority), sufficient troop carriers (to get enough forces over to capture a major port for further landings) and enough troops trained in amphibious assaults to effectively lead an invasion. Hitler had none of these, couldn?t make them in time due to other resource commitments, and Operation Sealion would never have worked.

by monkeybutter

American Congress showed no signs of commitment either way in the war up until they were forced to enter in self defence, and for no other reason. The US had isolationist principles ingrained into its very core, abstention from any interaction or alliances were against long-running policy, and had no intention of being anything other than onlookers with regard to Europe.

Then the Japanese made the biggest mistake in military history.

It should be pointed out here that there was, since 1905, an Anglo-Japanese alliance, whereby mutual assistance would be provided by each signatory should the other be drawn into conflict by a third party. This was a very nice deal both ways, and had it persisted, it?s highly likely that Japan would not have allied with Germany and Italy come the Second World War, but instead be obliged to side with Great Britain and France. The British were pressured to dissolve this alliance by another nation, in the early 1920s, who threatened an unfriendly stance were the Anglo-Japanese alliance to persist. No commitment from this nation was forthcoming to replace this alliance.

Take a guess which nation that was.

Yup. Say it with me. The US.

Facing a choice between a hostile US and a disgruntled Japan, Britain chose the latter. This would prove to be one of the catalysts towards Japanese aggression. After the alliance was dissolved, the Pacific Dominions became viable targets for the Japanese navy, which was approximately 60% of the Royal Navy in size, but concentrated on the other side of the world, close to its own motherland.

In the late ?20s and early ?30s, the inevitability of war with Japan was far more important a concern for Britain than war in Europe. This is why they remained out of any conflict with Germany following the consumption of Czechoslovakia and the Baltic states, aware that they would be unable to wage war on both fronts at that time.

by monkeybutter

On the 27th of November, 1941, General Short of Hawaii and General McArthur of the Philippines sent word that a Japanese attack was likely. US failed to notify any nation of this information, including themselves.

Three days later, Prime Minister Churchill contacted President Roosevelt. ?Station X? had decrypted an Enigma-encoded German communiqu? strongly suggesting a Japanese attack was imminent. Churchill advised Roosevelt to state to Japan that in the event of Britain or Siam coming under Japanese attack, the US would declare war. Roosevelt said offering guarantees to anybody would be ?unconstitutional?, but advised that Britain contact Siam offering support in the event of it being attacked.

Four days later, British Admiral Phillips was reminded by US military officials that the UK would be obliged to assist the US were it to come under attack by Japan. The US was not mutually obliged to the UK in the same way. A sizeable portion of the British fleet is moved to Pacific waters to ?monitor? Japanese activity.

The day before the attack on Pearl Harbour, US Admiral Turner assured his peers that there was going to be no attack on the US from Japan, and observed Japanese buildup was taking place prior to an attack on Britain. Britain was not told of this ?intelligence?. Meanwhile, a Japanese invasion force was observed heading towards Siam, shadowed by RAF forces. RAAF vessel Catalina was shot down.

7/11/41. Japanese forces land on the Malayan coast in the early hours of the morning. Japanese air-raid Singapore by 4am, and at 7.55, Pearl Harbour is attacked. The following day, Churchill requests a meeting with Roosevelt, who says he?s too busy to talk. Three days later, Italy declares war on theUS. A few hours later, Germany declares war on the US.

President Roosevelt requests an urgent meeting with Churchill.

by monkeybutter

History is an intriguing subject. Its study primarily revolves around the concept of cause and effect. People don?t just wake up one morning and decide to invade Poland. Comparisons of Saddam Hussein to Hitler are weak and sloppy at best. Both are unique situations that show little correlation. As you say, we can learn from history. What we learn depends on how deep we dig.

I find it amusing that most of America?s foreign policy concerning strong-arming other nations into the coalitionagainst Iraq consisted of ?we saved the world in two world wars?, which is the most amazing falsehood.

The US had a negligible effect on the First World War. Most of the weaponry heavier than sidearms being used by the 600,000 involved US troops, (only 25,000 of which were ever in the front lines) was supplied by France and Britain. To this day the American populace seems to think it suffered massive losses in the Great War saving Europe from the Hun, when really their casualties were fractional. The total US death toll in WWI is equal to the British Army death toll in three months and the French equivalent in two, less than four times the number of Americans who died in car accidents back across the pond over the same period. If France and Britain had enjoyed the same ratio, 500 Britains a day would have died in road accidents, 900 a day in France. This is contrasted by Vietnam, where far more Americans died on the roads than in war, but there were more cars then, so that?s neither here nor there.

As for WWII, the US actually helped *bring about* a lot of the problems that caused it, and whilst without their intervention Germany may have reaped (more) merry hell around Europe, (but not Britain, because Operation Sealion could never have worked), the Germans could still not have countered both the Western and Eastern fronts, and would *still* have been vanquished by Russia.

by thechas

Peace through justice WILL NOT be a quick solution.

It will however be more lasting than the present "bomb now ask questions later" philosophy.

I am not a card carrying pacifist.
Yes, there is a time, place, and need for a military solution.
What needs to happen in ADDITION to just military action is a movement toward the just treatment of other cultures and people.

Businesses MUST stop plundering 3rd world nations for a few cents extra profit.

Governments MUST have consistent policies that promote just treatment of all people on planet earth.

Governments MUST drop the policy of "the enemy of my enemy is my friend" when the 3rd party would not 'normally' qualify as a friend.

Individuals need to stay informed of world events. Then, think globally and act locally to build a better world for all.

Yes, there is a good chance that there will always be a few sociopaths that desire world domination at any cost.

With a true effort for world justice, these sociopaths will not have any events to use as rhetoric to stir others to join them in their battle.

A few terrorists acting alone are a lot easier to deal with than thousands acting in unison.

As far as the military solution, I see that has worked very well for Israel against the Palestinians!

Chas

by thechas

I am not suggesting that we NEVER use military action against SELECT terror targets.

What we need to do is consider the global consequences of our individual, corporate and government actions.

We need to stop providing megalomaniacs like Bin Laden the fuel for their speeches and rallies.

Once the US is seen (on a global basis) as working for justice in the world, not just what is best for our own short term interests, the terrorist leaders will no longer be able to recruit the large number of followers that they have now.

No, we will NEVER convince everyone that we are a just nation and people.
We do however need to make a few changes in how we deal with 3rd world countries and some 'allies' to re-establish ourselves as a just people and nation.

Chas

by youasked

Excellent Chas..I like your reasoning I think you have covered a good part of the solution. God be with you.

by hal 9000

I cna see that you have gone o a lot of trouble in listing all of these events but you have missed the major one and the was that all miletary planning between WW1 & WW11 from both Britian and Europe was an expected attack from the US as the US was building Battle Ships in bigger numbers and even bigger guns and these where considered as the uliterment weapon of the time as at that point in time the Aircraft had not proved itself.

This was somewhat setteled down by the Washington Treaty which limited the size and number of Battle Ships that and 1 country/Empire could have and this lead to many of the Battle Ships being scutled at sea particuarly by colonies of Britian like Ausatralia who had to forfeit their 1 and only battle ship to keep within the terms of this treaty. But Britian did sell quite a lot of naval equipment to the Japanese and to the Empire of Great Britian Japan was considered as nothing more than the dumping ground of any goods that they could not sell eleswhere but at the same time they refused to allow Japan to sell good in quantie to the Empire so the British Empire was starving Japan's economy to death. I do agree that Pearl Harbour was a miscalutation on the part of the Japanese Emperior as they already had a nice little war going on in China but as they required the resources they felt preasured into attacking the Pacific Fleet at Pearl Harbour just in case the US got involved as this fleet was a major threat to the aims of the Japanese Empire of the time.

I could go on and on here but it's all just a waste of time as I don't think that anyones actually listing and it would only be a waste of my time as well.

by monkeybutter

There was indeed the possibility of the US going to war with the UK. The US had three primary war strategies: "Orange" for Japan, "Black" for Germany and "Red" for the UK. Britain had no war plans for conflict with the US. In 1914 the Anglo-Japanese alliance was modified excluding US from the mutual defence strategy as an aggresive third party, at US insistence. Another nail in the coffin of Anglo-Japanese cooperation.

The Washington Accord afforded the UK a ration of 5:5:3 naval tonnagevis a vis Japan and the US. I could see how this could screw with the Japanese economy chronically, as well as accounting for the fluctuatons in Japanese naval strength over the next decade. It did, however, completely annihilate Britain's "two-navy" defence scheme, which required a lot of repair when WWII hit the fan.

Personally, I blame the US :-)

by maxwell edison

That Monkey Butter guy is a real nut case. He's either been dropped on his head too many times or he's dropped too many funny looking pills in his life. He's really got some problems.

by monkeybutter

Well, you may be right. Two questions:

1) What gives you this impression?

2) What makes you think I'm a guy?

by generalist

I suspect that if you took all of the historical facts and opinions provided by MonkeyButter, Colin, JimHM and others and looked at them carefully, you would find that the 'truth' is a combination of everything, minus a number of the opinions.

I'm quite impressed by MonkeyButter's WWII mini history. To provide that many hard facts involves sticking your neck out, especially when they can be easily verified. And from my own readings about WWII, I can say that many of the facts hold togetherand can be found in American history books. (I'm a Pearl Harbor history buff for example. I know about the early warnings the US had and the fact that Yamamoto knew that the attack on Pearl was not the brightest idea.)

On the other hand, a number of MonkeyButter's comments seem to be designed to incite as much flaming as possible. While I don't disagree with MonkeyButter's list of things in the "Moral High Ground?" I would like to point out that many of the comments apply to other nationsas well at various points of history. And some of those points of history are current history.

History is indeed an interesting creature. You can find parallels of different degrees all over the place.

by jimhm

Yes - history is interesting and the minor fact that history is recorded by man which alters the events to fit their own environment.

Example - How the US history books had Custer as a Indian war hero - but in actual event he mascared men-women-children.

Japanese still don't accept the historical fact of the chemical weapons testing they did on the chineese people they called cordwood -

Britian has some nasty history as well, along with France, German, Russian and all other countries.

So what does that tell us - we are all the same just different beliefs - knowledge - languages - hum interesting isn't it...

So now we are recording the events of 911 and terrorism - how will they be shown in history? What has the world had to say about the IRA and other previous terrorist groups? Will they be labeled as hero's or villans? Martars or Fools? Only history will tell - but as for me they are all Fools and Villians...

by monkeybutter

Thankyou for your honest critique.

The "Moral High Ground?" post wasn't intended to be a list of acts solely attributed to the US, merely pointing out that it couldn't really claim a particularly aloof stance on morality given these items.

Some of my comments may be a bit flame-magnetic, but against all reason, I was expecting a little more cut-and-thrust of lively debate, as opposed to "MonkeyButter smells of wee, doo-dah, doo-dah", and once you get through the first half-dozen comments that assault the credibility of your arguments based on your percieved political stance, percieved age, percieved education, percieved mental hygiene, etc., but leave your *actual arguments* unscathed, pushing the point as far as it'll go to demonstrate your opponents' lack of debate skills becomes more and more satisfying. Not particularly mature, I'll concede, but satisfying nontheless.

I can handled being called a "greenwinny liberal" ("liberal" has widely different political connotationsin my country, and I'm fairly sure I don't fall into either the UK or US versions; incidentally, is "greenwinny" even a word?), and I can cope with having my mental health slandered, but being called really pushes my buttons in the wrong way.

by jimhm

Is there a doctor in the house - MonkeyButter needs help - Very very RED - it appears that this young person has been feed a diet of RED MEAT and RED RICE - and is now Fat - Dumb and Stupid... or Dumb and Dumberer ...

A waste of good Bytes - Enjoy your dream land Monkeybutter

by monkeybutter

What a cunning and well-thought-out counter argument. You must've thought long and hard about that one.

Can I see your bibliography for it?

by generalist

If you're a fighter pilot in a plane that has been shot up and you have been injured enough that you know you won't survive very long, you may choose to take out an 'honor guard' by flying your plane into a ship or other target. To an outside observer it would look like a suicide attack. To the pilot, it is one last attempt at fighting the enemy.

In a slightly different vein, you may be in reasonable health in a damaged plane and not be able to bail out. Drowning is not a pleasant way to die so you may take the fast way out and try to be of use to your fellow pilots by hitting a target.

Then there is always the possibility that the pilot was distracted or unable to fully control the plane. Instead of being a suicide, the crash isan accident with favorable battle results.

The Japanese, on the other hand, had true suicide planes and pilots. They knew what they were getting into when their planes took off and headed for their targets.

by monkeybutter

Sorry...that should have read "being called 'uneducated' really pushes my buttons in the wrong way".

This correction was brought to you by me. Isn't it great?

Damn. Now I've started another post, I feel obliged to put something of substance and value in it. Ummmm...

How about some sort of comment on the original topic of this thread? Asking about what motivates terrorism, and then answers that actually answer the question in any detail greater than "they're all evil-doing monsters who hate America for no reason" having cheap pot-shots taken at them?

No?

I have logical beef with this entire thread, however I also have an overwhelming desire to see things through until they're finished (Ahhh, Atticus Finch, what wise things you can teach us...).

Anyone else got anything they want to say?

by generalist

I can agree that terrorists of all types should be considered fools and villains based on WHAT they do. Setting off bombs in public places and flying planes into buildings filled with common people is stupid at best and pure evil when done outside of the context of a declared war. And even in the context of a declared war, such actions should be considered war crimes, especially when the reason for the war is one of marginal ethics.

Ethnic cleansing, radical religious ideals and certain types of knee jerk national and regionalisms would qualify as marginally ethical reasons for war. Unfortunately they also represent the causes behind a lot of today's terrorist groups.

When you get down to it, true terrorists are folks who use violence outside of the context of a declared war to promote their marginally ethical agenda. They work outside the 'rules' of formal warfare and don't care if innocents die because they KNOW their cause is right and that violence is the ONLY way to fight for their cause.

In order to counter the true terrorists, you need to figure out why they think the way they do and how you can divert them to other lines of thought. If you don't get to the root of the problem when dealing with terrorists, you just spawn more terrorists. High profile attacks and martyrs are inspirations for those who are on the verge of becoming terrorists.

Now, what are the roots behind the better know terrorist organizations?

by monkeybutter

Firstly, the IRA:

Ultimately traceable back to the Norman invasion of Ireland in the 12th century, whereby it became a British colony, and later split into the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland. Several centuries later, Northern Ireland remains part of the British Isles, whereas the Republic of Ireland is a country in unto its own right.

Towards the beginning of the 20th Century, political and paramilitary organisations combined to form what is now known as the IRA, producing an organisation with the ultimate political goal of "freeing Northern Ireland from the British", coupled with the terrorist tactics from the original Irish Republican Brotherhood. The political party Sinn Fein ('Ourselves Alone'), still exists today, and whilst it's not *officially* synonymous with the IRA, their separatist philosophies do not seem to differ all that much.

Recent peace accords, most notably the Good Friday Agreement, have caused several splinter groups of the IRA to branch off, the most obvious being the Real IRA, the Continuity IRA and the INLA.

For all their vigour and zeal, the IRA or any of its illegitimate children are unlikely to see their goal visualised, owing to a combination of religious, political and resitendial issues that aren't likely to be resolved in any of our lifetimes.

This should be roughly correct. I haven't studied it properly since I was 12, and most of the current situation I pick up off the news, but it's a sufficient breakdown for these purposes.

by monkeybutter

Al-qaeda:

Back in the days of the Cold War, things weren't so cold in Afghanistan. The Soviet-Afghan conflicts of the late '70s and '80s saw a lot of funding and support go towards several groups of rebel Afghan fundamentalists, most notably fromthe US and Saudi Arabia. The idea was to disseminate local resistance to the Soviet presence in Afghanistan, and generally sort out Johnny Russkie without risking an all-out war between superpowers.

It wasn't just limited to funding, however. Documentary evidence came to light some time ago showing the presence of assorted fundamentalist operatives recieving training in espionage and associated illicit tactics at Virginian CIA training institutions with the ultimate intent of spreading these techniques and skills to the various underground resistance movements in the Muslim world, quite prominently including Afghanistan.

The exact accounts of how al-qaeda came into existence in its current incarnation are vague and conflicting, but what is generally agreed upon is that following the withdrawal of the Soviets from Afghanistan, an existing network of Afghan "freedom fighters" with strong international ties to their fellow Muslim countries, fell under the remit of Osama Bin Laden,the son of a wealthy Saudi family. Bin Laden's job in the Afghan/Soviet conflict, with the complicity of the US, was to fund and train mercenaries (see "terrorists") for the purpose of removing outside elements, such as communism, from Muslim soils.With the retreat of the Red Army, he's simply continued to do this job, extending it to all Muslim countries, and focussing his attentions on the new "threat" to Muslim fundamentalism, which is westernisation.

This is one of the reasons that genuine links between Al-qaeda and Hussein are ludicrous. Iraq was (is) a secular Muslim state, and would ultimately be just as much of a target for Al-qaeda as the US, if not more so.

by jardinier

I guess I was motived to start this discussion because, if you don't know what influences have caused a particular terrorist group to evolve, then you are in no position to develop a strategy to defuse its destructive actions.

I think Monkey Butter's suggested evolutions of two particular terrorist groups are good examples of what we should be looking at.

To declare a war on terrorism without understanding how each particular group has evolved, and what it's particular gripe is, is likecharging at windmills.

Unless we know where they are coming from (geographically and psychologically), then we might just as well declare war on ghosts or sea monsters.

by Former member

Here's my view on the evolution of a terrorist...

Once upon a time in the wayback god (or allah, or buddah, or gaea, or human consciousness... whatever you prefer, doesn't really matter), set out a few basic rules:
respect and take care of the world in which you live, and be nice to each other.
He/She/It also told us to make sure we teach our children to do likewise.

Well, we got distracted along the way, started obsessing over things, and the collection of them (particularly little green pieces of paper). And started competing with one another for said things. We decided it was more important to have a boat and 2 cars and a big-big-house, than it was for mom and dad to raise their kids. So kids learned their morals from hollywood.

As the focus moves away from the well-being of the family, the sociey, and the world, and moves toward the well-being of self, above all else, that is when the amoral, sociopathic tendencies develop.

How do you prevent terrorism? by each and every parent making their first priority in life be the teaching of their children to "love thy neighbor as thyself".

by Former member

Well there are a number of options availible...

1. Educate the "unwashed masses" to the validity of your cause. I have had my views changed many times by reasonable people using peaceful debate. Seek change through positive means, rather than destructive ones.

2. Seek compromise. Often the two extreme views can meet at a more rational neutral, like managing resources, establishing lumber farms, and Natinal Parks...( "understanding is a 3 edged sword, your side, my side, and the truth" -J.M.S.)

3. Tolerance. You don't have to like it, but you can still respect it. You can even, to some degree isolate yourself from it (ie. Don't care for Canadians? Stick to the more southern states. Not fond of Mormons? Don't move to Utah. Can't stand people? Build a cabin in Antarctica). It's an imperfect world. Be patient with one another.

by generalist

One of the favorite books around my house is a British-American American-British Dictionary. Browsing through it provides a fascinating look at two great countries separated by a common language.

That's one of the reasons I mentally chuckle whenI see people arguing about definitions. The meanings of various words and phrases change over time, time and society. And even with the advent of computers, resources like Webster's and the Oxford English Dictionary are well behind the curve. After all, it takes time to find new words/phrases and new meanings for existing words/phrases.

But it can take but a minute for a new word/phrase to be heard around the world and make its way into common usage. But such a word/phrase needs both impact and context to make such a splash.

The term 'greenwinny' or perhaps 'green-whinny' doesn't appear to be one of those splashwords. Given the context, I'd guess it refers to ecologically minded people who actually speak up when issues impact them. Unfortunately, some of them do have whinny voices and their complaints may be considered whining by those who they oppose.

Ah, well. Such is life.

by jimhm

The Green-Wennies or Green-Winny or Green-winnies(or even if you perfer a Tree Huggers)are Environmental Terrorist groups. Here in the USA they have been Spiking (for you Brit's - that is putting a large nail into a tree) - so that when a logger cuts it down - the nail breaks the chainsaw chain and the logger gets cut up. Or when cutting the tree into lumber the nail breaks the saw blade and a miller may get killed.

Most terrorist are a minority group (idea/believe not race) that attempt to force the majority (that don't belief in there ideas)through violent means to comform to their ideas and beliefs.

by monkeybutter

Well, thankyou for your previous allusion that I was somehow involved in these activities. I dare not speculate what the surrounding comments involved; I might find myself being identified with muggers, rapists or murderers, and that could really put a bit of a crimp on my entire day.

As for your comments that terrorism is the province of the minority, can you back this up with statistics? I've played the We're-the-Majority-You're-The-Minority-Swapsies-You-Back-No-Returns game far too manytimes to not realise that raw numbers are the only way it gets solved.

by john_wills

People who kill abortionists can make a reasoned case that the abortionists have forfeited their human rights. Those who planned 9-11 knew that they were killing innocent people but thought that God would reward them for it. They thought that God would reward them for bad actions done with a good end. The chapter "Hangwite in context" in my book Albatross 0-595-19418-4 approaches this problem set from a different angle, which I am not goint to try to reproduce here. However, I have the impression that many abortionist-killers cannot articulate their case, and I am not entirely sure how the 9-11 events were hoped to lead to the Kingdom of God on Earth. The 9-11 actors had divorced morality and religion, perhaps.

by jardinier

As I am not aware that any of the 9/11 suicide pilots were interviewed before the event, it is rather presumptuous to state what they may or may not have expected to greet them at the portals of the afterlife.

It is however fairly obvious that they had a major gripe with the USA, or possibly the whole industrialised world, as they chose the World Trade Centre as their primary target.

Such a carefully planned attack indicates a particularly strong motivation. It is the motivation that we are seeking to establish in this discussion.

by monkeybutter

You're assuming such a thing as a universal morality and objective religious standpoint. Such ideas are generally rejected by psychologists involved in the field, and don't carry much weight with a lot of modern philosophers and theologians either,who tend to be a fairly self-inclined biased bunch at the best of times.

The people who carried out the September 11th attack were not raised in the same way as you or I. You'd have to look to the culture they were raised in (and not just the umbrella term of "Muslim Fundamentalism", but the specific upbringing they were subject to) in order to learn exactly what they expected from God and death, and what they deemed to be "right" and "wrong".

by john_wills

The September 11 attackers and I are both children of Abraham, so we have a great deal in common. Our common morality is based on natural law, which is why the children of Abraham claim that the law of God is "true": it corresponds to the nature of things. Natural law can in principle be worked out by anyone, but happens to coincide with divine law in the Tradition of Abraham, whereas a god outside that tradition might give an order contrary to natural law(actually, some of the orders given in the OT are a bit hard to explain under natural law). What sometimes happens is that someone imagines that God allows the end to justify the means. We are all tempted to believe this sometimes, but it is contrary to the nature of right-and-wrong discrimination. Ultimately all sin is irrational. In the Kingdom of God on earth, the September 11 people and I agree, the innocent will not suffer; it naturally follows that to build the Kingdom of God we should not make the innocent suffer, but the September 11 people overlooked that.

by monkeybutter

First of all, let me get this out of the way: I am an atheist. I would go so far as to describe myself as a "radical atheist", to distance myself from notions of agnosticism, so absolute is my belief that there is no divine presence. This is not something I just decided one day, but the result of many years of in-depth contemplation on the subject.

In spite of this, I have a lot of respect for religion, as specific entities in their own right and as a conceptual abstract, and as such, I am applying the utmost care to this response, as not to offend. This isn't easy.

Morality is not an objective concept. This can be shown in terms of moral ambiguity, and demonstrated by the radically different systems of morality across the world. There is no act humanity is capable of commiting that has not been condoned by some civilization or other arcing back through human history. Morality can be observed to be instilled upon us by our culture, influenced by personal and environmentalfactors.

The only way this can be wrong is in the presence of an objective absolute definition of what is right or wrong, independent of sentient life, as the backdrop to an imperfect humanity. As there is no observable autonomous universal "rightness" or "wrongness" present in the universe, this must, if it does exist, be held by what we would refer to as God.

Ergo, in the absence of an absolute God being known and proven to exist (and by the very nature of the concept, God's existence cannot be proven or disproven), the human origin of morality rises as the chief baseline outside of a theistic debating context.

I think...

by monkeybutter

Whilst Islam does share a common origin with the Judeo-Christian faiths, to say that all acts considered a sin in all branches and sects of Islam are also considered a sin in all branches and sects of Judaism and Christianity is patently untrue, as is making the same claim between all currently existing religions that fall under the above categories and their common source.

Religions fall under a memetic model, and therefore memetic selection and variation gives rise to claddish groups of different religions with their own systems of morality, which, in turn, change over time based on their environment. This is why a catholics can now happily eat pork on fridays, why protestants always could, and jews stuck to something kosher throughout the week.

Those responsible for the September 11th attack could quite easily not have considered what they were doing a sin. Their minor commonality with your own religion does not guarantee them holding the same system of morality.

by jardinier

"(actually, some of the orders given in the OT are a bit hard to explain under natural law)"

You should surely be aware, John, that in the Old Testament "God" commanded his people to commit all kinds of atrocities, including genocide, gathering of foreskins et al.

And just think of poor Onan who, because he made a moral decision not to impregnate his brother's wife, not only was slain by God who was "displeased," but became the sole building stone for the Church to create it's "moral basis" for condemning both masturbation and coitus interruptus.

There may be a Natural Law, but God himself wasn't too concerned with following it.

by jardinier

Hello MonkeyButter. I would like to publish material from some of your postings on my website www.thinking-seriously.com, as they are most relevant to the general theme of the website.
However, I would prefer that you email me your real name, and possibly place of residence, to give as authorship of the statements.

There is also the option of submitting comments on any of the articles on the website, or actual articles, by clicking on "email" at the bottom of the contents menu.

I have found your thoughts most stimulating and refreshing.

by monkeybutter

Sure. Had a look at your site a couple of days ago, and it seems an interesting sort of place.

I'm currently away from home (and email) but when I get back to my own box I'd be happy to send you what you want to know.

I wouldn't mind having alook at exactly what you're planning to put up in my name before it goes up, just as a matter of general principle, but I've not to my knowledge said anything here I'd mind my name being tagged onto, so I'm unlikely to object.

by generalist

When people of the Islamic faith defend their faith in light of the terrorist attacks, they emphasize that Islam reveres women and condemns attacking innocents. They also emphasize that the word Islam means both 'Submission' and 'Peace'.

These people also mention that there is a strict set of rules in the Qur'an that defines when warlike behavior is appropriate and how it should be waged.

From a religious ideal, Islam has a lot of good points going for it.

Unfortunately, people practice Islam in different ways. Some groups appear to consider bystanders to be infidels and thus not innocent. They also appear to consider winning to be subordinate to obeying the formal rules of warfare.

Those groups are the ones that are the true problem. While they claim to be defending Islam, they could easily be the death of it.

by monkeybutter

Jesus preached tolerance, love and forgiveness. Look at what's been carried out in his name.

Religion often end up being a means of control over its practitioners, in spite of the whatever good intentions may have been possessed by their founding figures and the more benevolent of their followers. The successful religions promote themselves as the embodiment of what is "good" and the paragon of what is "true", which aids in their propogation, and which causes their followers to adhere to them all the more ferverently. It does not become difficult for a charismatic and manipulative individual to take advantage of this.

That said, religion does fulfil a very important role in a lot of peoples' lives, and there's a lot of evidence tosuggest that as a species, we've been hardwired to be succeptible to a need for faith and spirituality in our lives, as a coping mechanism, instilled through selective pressures over the duration of the existence of our cognisant race.

Memetics is a fascinating subject.

by jardinier

Full marks from me, MonkeyButter. Whilst having declared your own position as an unmitigated atheist, you have politely acknowledged that many humans have an innate need to believe in a higher power.

Just for the record, I describe myself as an agnostic relativist. Agnostic, because I don't know, and relativist because I accept the possibility or even likelihood that a number of belief systems may be equally valid.

by monkeybutter

It says a lot that often the people who explore to the limits the boundaries of theological philosophy and the connotations of religious belief systems tend to be those who refute classification into an organised religion themselves.

Robert Winston once commented that whilst biologists were more often than not devout atheists, because of their perspective on the world being limited to finite observable objects such as cells and base-pair sequences, physicists tended to be substantially more spiritual than their organically-inclined brethren, on account of their having to address concepts that exposed them to their own insignificance on a cosmological scale.

Personally, I feel the need to believe in a higher being myself. Rationally,I've deduced to my own satisfaction that no such entity exists, and in terms of psychology and various elements of sociobiology I can understand where the need comes from, in the same way I know where the need to have children and to stay alive comes from, but this doesn't make it go away.

by jimhm

I will answer your questions as soon as you answer mine -

Why do you can what I belief in? What right do you feel you have to question my beliefs? What right do you feel you have Questioning my belief in a God - superior being or whatever someone class it? What rights do you feel you have to questions other peoples beliefs in their religion? What right do you feel you have to force your beliefs on others?

And lastly What makes you think or Why do you feel that you are superior to those that belief in a superior being?

Answer those MonkeyButt and then I will reply to your questions - Until such time you don't rate the bit space ...

by jimhm

Red BS Flag (Red Card in your case) tossed on the field ... what you say in these posts don't compare to your other post against religion... And we are discussing "What Motivates a Terrorist" not religion.. Which neither has a place in the Tech forum...

by monkeybutter

Very well. I'll go along with your avoidance tactic.

The answers to your questions:

- I have not "canned" what you believe in.

- I'm not questioning your beliefs, in any sense of the word "questioning".

- I'm not questioning your beliefin God; I could not care less what you believe in.

- I'm not questioning anyones' beliefs in their religion. I'm only stating my opinions about religion, and I challenge you to demonstrate at any point in this discussion a deliberately and patently inflammatory comment at the specific expense of someones' religion made by myself.

- I'm not forcing my beliefs on anyone. Again, I challenge you to find a point in this discussion where I have done so.

- Nowhere have I claimed superiorityover anyone based on their religious persuasions. The above challenge stands for this as well.

And since we're here, I'll drag up the "BS Flag - Red Card pulled" comment from above, since it's easier to keep track of all these if they're in the same place.

I have not made any posts against religion. In fact, I have made specific mention of religion holding an important and meaningful place in the lives of a lot of people.

"They're windmills, Quixote...windmills!"

by hal 9000

Geing God actually allows you to set the natural Laws it is then up to man to interpurate what God wanted.

Of course this whole argument fails if you don't believe in a God. But then again if this was your own belief there would be no need to give quotes from the Bible would there?

by monkeybutter

One of the best sources to yield arguments against any given religion is the inconsistencies in that religion's own texts. If a religious text contains two irreconcilable points, then the text cannot be completely true, and if it is not completely true, then a cornerstone of the religion it serves is taken away.

But God's omnipotent, and can therefore make it true.

Such is the problem of the Omnipotence Paradox. It goes by many names, but it basically runs "Can God make a rock so heavy that not even he can lift it?" Any answer results in a logical inconsistency.

I'm sure we've all played with infinity as a thought experiment at one point or another. This is what happens. This does not deter the Theist, however, since God, in his omnipotence, can *make it work*

This is one of the pivotal points that makes the idea of God such a pervasive success; it's completely self-protecting. You can't prove or disprove the existence of God any more than you can prove or disprove the existence of an invisible, insubstantial 2000 mile long banana orbiting Jupiter that no person or equipment can detect. The infinity clause and the omnipotence getaround is a win-all-ties concept that can reconcile any logical fallacy one might encounter with the religion in question.

That said, people versed in logical debate might call it an argumentative fallacy in unto itself.

by john_wills

The September 11 people were not atheists. They believed the story in Gn 22. HaElohim, the hallucinatory gods of the subconscious and visceral, were over-ruled by Yahweh, the God of the conscious mind. This is the basic distinguisher of the Tradition of Abraham from the religions which exalt the subconscious and the visceral; there is a similar paragraph in the Mahaparinirvanasutra. Gn 22 also teaches us to ignore immoral commands coming from false gods, that the real God will not give an immoral command and that the end does not justify the means. The September 11 people must have had this lesson, but somehow failed to slot it into their internal logic. After Abraham's time it took millennia for his tradition to consistently avoid the false gods of mindless urges; the September 11 people have regressed, while retaining the trappings of the Tradition of Abraham.

by jardinier

I describe myself as an agnostic because "I don't know." This does not preclude my "belief" that there is in fact an innate intelligence in the natural universe.

I also answer to the label of "pantheist" in that, if such an intelligence exists, then it is integral with the physical universe and not apart from it.

I feel quite justified in quoting from the Bible in response to any statement made by someone who is using the Bible as the basis of their argument.

by jardinier

Hi MonkeyButter. I am actually flattered that you like my site, and it is your postings about the deeper and more profound aspects of religion/philosophy that interest me most.

No doubt you have found as I have that it is very rare to find someone who has thought deeply and broadly without getting attached to a particular belief system along the way.

As you would know, most people who become disillusioned with their native religion either make a blind commitment to some other religion, orjust give up thinking altogether.

by youasked

It's could be form of singlemindedness of the individual(s) who firmly believe that they are just and right. Someone once said (I'm trying to think who it was I heard it again the other night)" If you can't find anything to die for, you have nothing to live for" in some respects it is an accurate statment.
As far as the Japaness zeros that that kind of suicide comes out in the form of zealots,(not unlike religous zealots of many) that they get caught up in ferver of the moment, they see one doing it and the others follow.
Or can it be that they feels that they have nothing to live for?. Or perhaps this will make them a hero to their people, and their life's will be significant and justifiable?
In Osaman case however he should have been an only child and not one of 57..he would have gotten all the attention that he needed.
We are dealing with very complex personalities in any event..well beyond my comprehension.

This discussion is closed to new replies.