Discussion Locked

What should we call this new way to browse Hot Discussions?

0 helpful
33 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Here's another new feature for our members to try and critique. We've developed a new way to browse Hot Discussions. Here's the link:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11189-0.html

That new blue bar at the top of the page allows you to browse Hot Discussions. You may use the Previous and Next buttons, or pull the drop-down menu to choose your next discussion.

Internally, we've been calling this feature "the Hat" because of the way it sits atop the page.

We have two questions for you:

Do you like this method of browsing? (Why? or Why not?)

What would you call this feature? ("The Hat" isn't very self-explanatory, right?)

Please give us honest feedback, as always. We value your opinions!

33 replies

by old guy

I've only been active in these discussions for a couple of months. I've been using the heck out of the Search feature. I didn't know it was new. I just thought it was always there. It has been a tremendous help for me because I'm still looking at some of the posts that goes beyond the 10 pages listed.

I do a search and then open in a new window on what I want. Then I go back to the first window and just hit the back button to stay with the main lists. That way I have the primary discussions available to refresh for new ones and have the ones I'm active in opened in a separate window.

I like it.

by rexworld

For a name, what about "The Hot Bar"? I was thinking "Blue Bar" but that's perhaps too suggestive.

One request--I know you can also get the hot discussions as an RSS feed, what about adding a link to that RSS feed somewhere in the Hat?

by apotheon

Let's not call it "Hot Bar". There's an awful IE toolbar application that is a pretty heinous bit of spyware, known as "Hotbar". I recommend against naming a new navigation feature on this site after it.

by bp7226

Is a good short name for a bar with links to hot discussions and I like the bar!

by charliespencer

Jaqui won't like it because it's blue :-) I don't like it because it's just more lost screen space.

I don't read every discussion, so going directly from one to the next doesn't interest me. I would not like having to skip through the unwanted ones to get to those I'm interested in. The Previous and Next links wouldn't do me any good.

The center pulldown duplicates the "Hot Discussions" box to the right of the posting. I actually prefer the pulldown IF it means the "Hot Discussions" box will go away AND free up screen space for more content. However, I suspect if the HD box was dropped, the advertiser content currently below it would just move up. Nothing wrong with that; somebody's got to pay the bills. But since something is going to occupy that space, it might as well be the HD box, since the links on it are bigger targets that the pulldown.

If you decide to keep it, how about "NavBar" as a name?

by neil higgins

Like the pull-down screen,but the "next",and "previous" buttons I dont like.Why not Hot Search,in red,having tha avatar glowing flames...er,but maybe not.Sorry,it is Friday evening here in the UK :)

by jaqui

it's not because it's blue that I have an issue with it. :P
that would be Oz that has a problem with blue. ;)

it doesn't work. :(

I can see it but it does nothing to shift discussions at all.

so it's a complete waste of real-estate.

by beth blakely

If you can see it, what exactly is happening? Can you not pull down the menu? Do the previous and next buttons not work? Please try again and let us know what issue you're having and what browser you're using.
Thanks!

by m_a_r_k

But the Previous and Next buttons aren't necessary because you can see all the discussions in the drop-down box.

As far as lost screen space, why not just stick it in the empty gray area right above the "Welcome|Log Out|..." line without any additional space between the two?

How about adding an option to open or close the bar? Right now there's an option to close it. Once it's closed, it's gone for good. That would also eliminate wasted screen space because the Hot Discussion browser will only be needed once in a while. No need to have it sitting up there not being used.

Just call it "Hot Discussion Browser".

by stargazerr

I like it, but as M_a_r_k says, the prev and next buttons arent really necessary ...

I wouldnt really remember what the last discussion was anyway ... or what the next one is, for that matter ..

How about the name The little elf ... naah, I hate that myself ... I am getting carried away by christmas :D

by stargazerr

I like it, but as M_a_r_k says, the prev and next buttons arent really necessary ...

I wouldnt really remember what the last discussion was anyway ... or what the next one is, for that matter ..

How about the name The little elf ... naah, I hate that myself ... I am getting carried away by christmas :D

]:)

by m_a_r_k

Removing the Previous and Next buttons will give more horizontal space. How about adding a drop-down box for "My Discussions" as well? I know, I know... you give us an inch, and we'll ask for a mile. :)

by stargazerr

I was going to ask for a mountain ... :D

Can we put the next and previous buttons for navigating between posts there as well??

]:)

by m_a_r_k

Give us a mole hill and we'll ask for a mountain. I hope the mole hill they're giving us really isn't an ant hill. Have you ever been attacked by a thundering herd of pissed off fire ants?

by apotheon

I like "the hat" as a name for it, but maybe you should jazz it up a bit. Call it "Blue Hat". Kind of a self-conscious ripoff of White Hat, Black Hat, Gray Hat, and Red Hat, that way -- or maybe go with something like Sombrero, or Stetson, or something like that. Yeah, that's it.

Okay, I got nothin'. I like the look of it, though. What's wrong with just leaving it "Hot Discussions"?

by unclerob

but seriously I don't mind this new feature at all, but naming it seems to be the difficult task,
how about TR QuickLinks or TR Hotlinks

Since you were on a Seinfeld trip how about Kramer's Quicklinks or Costanza's Buffer zone.

- just kidding ;-)

by m_a_r_k

Ants are small. And they like cozy warm places. They can worm their way between crossed fingers and crossed toes.

by stargazerr

That I will also be hanging in the middle of no where, so the miniscule things cannot even think about getting to me ...

]:)

by m_a_r_k

the ants will simply build a bigger ant hill. And if ants don't get you, then a swarm of ravenous man-eating killer bees will. You can't beat Mother Nature...

by jaqui

I looked at the frame source, and it's the fact that it is javascript that is killing the link functions.
I gan get the drop down to show the options, even pick an option, but it won't navigate.
the previous and next do absolutely nothing.

by apotheon

It's designed using Javascript, and you have Javascript turned off: thus, it's not broken, it's just not designed for maximum accessibility.

by jaqui

won't help.
the little beggars can climb the support for the hanging apparatus and then down to you. ~evil grin~

( and yes, they can do that. )

and probably will after we spray you with warm jam so it makes you all sticky sweet.

by m_a_r_k

I think she implied that she's hanging from thin air. Therefore, the ants have to call in the air force, i.e., killer bees.

by oz_media

While that is probably the expected answer from me, it really is just real estate, may as well have a banner ad too (but you've already got those I suppose).

This site has become TOO functional I think. While many of the recent layout changes are okay, there has always been redundancy on TR, too many links to the same content, too many different ways to do the same thing or get the same info.

I used to get Word users who could spend DAYS formatting a single document, the endless list of options can keep you going for ages. In the end though, they had the same page they started with but they had wasted so much time reformatting it and making it look different while the text and message was the same.

Just as you can overformat a word document, I feel that there comes a time when you just ave to say,'okay, this works well' and leave it be.

Does C-Net have you guys doing other stuff or are you all just looking for ways to recode the site all the time? No offense intended toward yourself of course, but it just needs to be left as is, it works and works well, why continue to play with it?

How about spending some time resolving the endless Tech Q&A problems? People mispoting to discussions and people not being pushed to close questions or respond to answers? Perhaps even a timeout system, you can't ASK a question until you've been registered X amt of days or have answered X number of questions or something?

Another HOTBAR for searching discussions? Redundant and not needed.

On anoter note, too blue a gradient would help ( :D ) and too much wasted real estate but kinda cool if it was needed.

But if you must...Hot Discussions works doesn't it?

by stargazerr

why i hadnt replied to this thread for 3 days ... now that i read the above posts, I know why..

Ants?? Killer Bees?? I am going to the North Pole and hibernate in some cave ... then the dad dratted things cant get to me ...

]:)

P.S .. Yeah Jacqui, I did mean thin air

by oz_media

Ants, Killer bees, you forgot Polar bears, nasty buggers at best, and VERY big too, I mean VEEEEEEERY big!

ooooh, trivia, did you know a polar bears fur isn't REALLY white?
It's actually a transparent, hollow, quill like fur that reflects light and appears white. If it didn't reflect light, it would look black, because a polar bear has black skin.

Oh and your alias, yes it's just fine, but you might wanna be careful people may think you mean US (as in USA) geeks rule. :)

by m_a_r_k

But I'm under the impression that [b]american_geeks_rule[/b] will be spending all her time at the North Pole hibernating in a cave. Do polar bears hibernate in caves like real bears? I don't think so. Polar bears are a confused lot. They love snow and ice and all that winter crap. So your polar bear trivia, though interesting, will be of no use to her unless she hibernates in the same cave as a schizophrenic polar bear. On the other hand, if you know some trivia about bats...

by jaqui

naturally they are large, they are the largest bears on the planet. they are the biggest of the Grizzly family of bears.

M_A_R_K,

naw, a polar bear will hunt down any animal in winter, they are starving because mankind has killed off a lot of the food chain on them.

by stargazerr

How about if I go to Mars?? No polar bears or ants or killer bees there?? I can hitch a ride with the next NASA mission ...

Then I will change my alias to Martian_geeks_rule

]:)

This discussion is closed to new replies.