What??? - The Gospel According to Judas?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by dawgit
by hal 9000
[i]You have the bitterness of a broken faith.[/i]
But totally incorrect as I do follow a path just not a Christian Path I was taught from a very early age to follow a different path by one of the 47 Sholin Priests who where given the job of making sure that the Dali Lama made a successful escape from Chinese controlled Tibet. Even then I don't fully agree with the Dali Lama who is a complete Pacifist as I was taught to fight to protect the people who couldn't protect themselves and the Dali Lama just tells people not to resist and accept what happens. That is something that I can not accept but such is life and I'm not one to complain.
Being who I am I used to be called in to be a Body Guard for the Dali Lama whenever he visited AU which he found funny as he could never understand that he was in danger and was willing to accept whatever happened to him, where I was given the job of protecting him and making sure that nothing did happen to him.
But my Master did insist that we study the different religions around the world and understand them as they really all are the same thing expressed in a different way as different people express the same happenings in different ways according to their society and their previous experience. So from that prospective I don't see any real difference between the basics of Christianity, Hinduism, Muslim, Buddhist or any other faith.
Rather my view is a matter of an outsider looking in and seeing the differences and laughing at them for what they are rather than [b]having any bitterness over a Broken Faith.[/b] The ones that scare me are the fundamentalist of any faith as they distort their so called religion to suit their own ends and claim that the ends justify the means which I do find unacceptable. That can range from some Muslim Extremists flying commercial aircraft into buildings to a group of Fundamentalists Christians Declaring war on all of the Muslim faith because some Fundamentalists fools hurt them or scared them so everyone of that faith has to be [b]Put to the Sword![/b]
I can see wrong on all sides in the current conflict between religious beliefs and while I don't disagree with hunting down the Fundalmenalists responsible for the events of 9-11-2001 I do see a major problem with attempting to force your ideals onto every one of that religion and attempting to force them to change as this will only make the enemy stronger to fight against you. Currently there is a [b]MESS[/b] that has no solution in the Middle East and it has been brewing since before WW11 and there are some fools who think that they will be able to fix it in a few weeks/months/years when actually it will require decades to put right and I personally don't think that the people involved will have the stomach to follow through to the finial product where it is possible to have peace.
All I currently see is the supposedly [b]Good Guy's[/b] descending to the level of those they are supposed to free and by doing so are only making the opposition to their presence stronger and the fight more bitter and longer than it should or needs to be.
Currently Afghanistan is a Mess and Iraq is no better and if anything worse and there is talk of moving on from Iraq to green pastures to bring freedom before the job is finished, to me this smacks of [b]Hypocrisy[/b] as there is currently [b]No Plan[/b] to withdraw from Iraq and leave a stable situation in place just mess things up and walk away saying [b]Look How much Good we Have Done![/b]
Currently I still fail to see why Iraq was invaded in the supposed [b]War on Terror[/b] as there has been no proven connection between that country and the events of 9-11-2001. The only similarities are that both countries where Muslim and at one time got assistance from the US to fight against the supposed enemies of the US.
What is missed here is that we are now facing a new situation that no country is currently prepared to admit to instead of fighting over land and resources the enemy has neither just an idea and they are independent of any country so they are effectively invisible and have nothing to strike back against except the people themselves. Invading countries will not cure the current problem but it will exacerbate it and possibly push us over the edge into a World War which we will be on the wrong side of as previously we have never been responsible for a [b]First Strike[/b] we have only reacted to an attack against us and our property meaning land a couple of buildings just doesn't count in the bigger picture no matter how wronged we feel at the time.
Col
by hal 9000
But I'll admit to playing [b]Black Sabbaths[/b] War Pigs. ;\
Or on one particularly less than understanding group that wouldn't take [b]NO[/b] for an answer I did offer to attend one of their religious meetings if they would attend one of mine. Of course I made out I was a Satan Worshipper and intended to perform a human sacrifice of one of them at the meeting. :^0
It's so hard to get your hands on people willing to be scarified these days. :_|
I haven't seen any JW's since then and I'm not complaining either. :p
Col ]:)
by deepsand
Please see
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=193152&messageID=1993993 .
P.S. Several of us have noted Gret's apparent long absence from these proceedings, and are hoping that she is well. Can you advise?
by jellimonsta
That is pretty funny what you did to the Jehova's Witness. Reminds me of the Seinfeld episode when Jerry asks for the telemarketers home number so he could call him back! :D
I believe in sharing the 'good news' with people, but I do not believe in ramming it down their throat. I guess it is a very delicate balance, and I have not really seen many able to balance it.
by sleepin'dawg
http://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/geos/is.html
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
by sleepin'dawg
Here we go again on another exercise in futility. Why Dan??? What's the point??? It is all speculative!!! Do you expect any real intelligent information will be learned or will it be the usual group of religious whackos dispensing their born again mumbo-jumbo???
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
by faradhi
I a may be Wacko. But Don't blame religion for it.
I am wacko by Divine Grace :D
by hal 9000
Involved in that Green horrible festering EL Thread?
If the answer is no then you are not completely Wacko just slightly Wacko. :p
Col ]:)
by x-marcap
All testing that is even moderately accurate usually involves destructive testing. Why give history to be destroyed? At some place faith is beyond proof. See Thomas those are holes in his hands, and his sides.
Blessed are they who have not seen, and yet believe.
Happy Easter All...
by hal 9000
Did you realise that I caught Maxwell Feeding that [b]Horrible Festering Monster recently?[/b] Not even the Great and the Mighty Maxwell could not keep away from that nightmare of a Disgusting discussion. :_|
Max being such a nice Pro Lifer just has to sneak off and feed that deformed monster every so often so it remains alive to haunt the rest of us. :_|
[b]There is NO JUSTICE in this world.[/b] :)
Col ]:)
by deepsand
...scratch behind the ears...
You just lie there and I will pray you into dawgie heaven, OK? :D I had an Irish Catholic mother (that's like having a Jewish mother, but with beer opted over wine) and an atheist father and they both made it. The one thing they agreed upon was to let a sleepin' dawg lie.
...picking off a flea...
What do you say we start an ET thread and discuss what life might be like on another planet?
:X (Boy I hope I got this emoticon right. I'm as tired of typing reasons for edit as you are of religious discussions!)
Edit: Argh! try again! : x
Edit again: to say "Help, dawg! I'm never gonna get this thing right! :x
by jellimonsta
Check with link, it shows you how to get them right! :D
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5100-22_11-5269527.html?tag=search
by dmambo
I did worry about the ravings, but I also thought it would have interesting points. I'm a merciful dude, and the idea that one of the most reviled individuals in human history could possibly be thought of in a sympathetic light is very interesting to me.
I don't expect the same for Hitler, Saddam, Brutus, Benedict Arnold or GWB though!! :)
BTW - don't you think that "SOB" is a little harsh???
Edit - Anyway, I generally just stick to the top level posts in a topic like this. I takes a few responses and replies to get to the real crazy stuff.
by jardinier
At any given time there seems to invariably be a new member of TR who is an arrogant, offensive a$$hole.
Currenly you are fulfilling that role.
I suggest you change your attitude if you want people to treat you seriously.
While Colin has spoken for himself, after knowing him for more than three years I can say that he is always polite, has a vast general knowledge, and most certainly is not bitter.
[Edited because of auto-censor]
by jardinier
Once upon a time there was a very attractive young JW woman who invited me to sunbathe nude on her balcony, which was out of the line of sight of any neighbours or passers by.
I thought this was a friendly gesture, although I never took up the offer.
by jardinier
by dawgit
by jardinier
I am not telling you how to practise YOUR faith.
Perhaps you can extend the same courtesy to me.
This is something that really bugs me about so many Christians. They presume to KNOW what is my relationship with God. I also have a totally different concept of God to that held by most Christians, as most of you well know.
I fail to comprehend the apparently subtle distinction between "talking to God" and "thinking to God."
I have actually had far greater blessings heaped on me than I would ever have thought to "pray" for.
I will stand beside Colin who, in the way he leads his life, would put most Christians to shame.
[Edited to add afterthought]
by jellimonsta
telling you how to do anything. I was just merely expressing my opinion on prayer. Just as you expressed yours.
I do not pray out loud most of the time anyway, so I am inasmuch 'thinking to God' also. In fact, I think I am going to go do some 'thinking' right now! :p
by hal 9000
Grett has had computer problems and has been messed around by the supposed professionals down where she lives. About a year ago they rebuilt her computer and sold her new MS Software but didn't change the Video Card which has been giving problems but from my understanding the people who did it have not accepted the problem and have had the computer for ages attempting to make it work by changing the M'Board CPU & RAM.
I got an E-Mail from Grett about a week ago and she's madly fighting her way through the backlog of E-Mail in an attempt to get on top of things [b]As if that's ever possible[/b] :^0
But with a bit of luck she'll be back in the near future as her usual self. I just hope that she doesn't have Reams of Translations to do as that will slow her down considerably, but she insisted that she fine last time I was in contact with her and very [b]Peeved OFF[/b] with the people who repaired her computer.
I was down there just after the repair and if I had of known I could have done it for her properly.
Col ]:)
Well just to finish off the week properly after upsetting at least 2 of the TR Staff I'll post this and see if they throw me off all together. :^0
Jay look and [b]Suffer!!!!!!!!![/b] :p
Remember I have my eye on you!
by hal 9000
If you needed something nasty done to you and at your own planning who better to trust than one of your closest friends who is willing to lay down their life for you or worse?
Col ]:)
Well just to finish off the week properly after upsetting at least 2 of the TR Staff I'll post this and see if they throw me off all together.
[b]Jay look and Suffer!!!!!!!!![/b] :p
Remember I have my eye on you all!
by jardinier
I have actually had quite a lot of contact with these people over the years.
I have found mediums in general to be a very unreliable source of factual information.
by deepsand
Unlike mediums, Reverends are the clergy of the Spiritualist Church. It is important to not equate the latter with the former.
As an agnostic, I make no claims re. the legitimacy of the beliefs of said church, but simply offer my personal observations of several of their members.
I can say that there are several who are repeatedly sought out by law enforcement to aid in their investigations.
I can also say that the particular Reverend noted is amazingly accurate in predicting the outcome of sporting events; in fact, accurate enough to "make book" on. This from a woman who knows nothing of sports!
by x-marcap
by x-marcap
They also have text consistant illustrated manuscripts from circa 175.
You might want to investigat before claiming none by the hands of the disciples. They do have writings by Appollo, also mentioned by Paul. They also have peices of Christ's cross.
by hal 9000
Chocolate Investigation Agency insists I will not argue but I find it very hard to believe that there is such a small number of members of the Jewish Faith in Israel. Particular when you consider that the entire population isn't Jewish it just seems way too small for belief. B-)
I suppose that people are trying to tell me that Hitler did a much better job that I was lead to believe in ridding the world of Jews. I know that he killed far more Russians and even that vast number killed had very little impact on the entire population of the USSR but he must have done a better job of killing off the Jewish Faith Right? ?:|
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
It was a present from one of the Peers and since I've upset a few people this week I couldn't help myself from using it. :^0
As far as my understand of Basic Maths is concerned aren't you now Glad that I wasn't put in charge of the Cyclotron that was proposed to be built at Lucas Heights? I could have taken out all of Sydney in a Fission Reaction by accident. :D
NAAH I wouldn't have done it [b]Accidentally[/b] It would have been on [b]Purpose![/b] B-)
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
That's such a great job and one that I wouldn't mind doing if I wasn't mentally deficient and working IT. :8}
Just keep the Wine and Beer out of the Job Description and I'd be as happy as a Pig in Mud. :p
Col ]:)
by deepsand
You're right; fall behind here and you'll never catch up. The best one can do is try to forget what may have been missed and start anew. I know, from experience.
You may recall that I vanished from sight here in July of last year. Owing to the needs of a client, who is also my closest friend (the Spiritualist Reverend that I've referenced elsewhere believes that we were brothers in a prior incartion), along with my efforts to re-hab my house, preparatory to selling it and moving back to the Penn State area, have left me with precious little time for other than the absolute necessities.
At the moment, I've a short period during which to re-visit TR. I very quickly gave up on trying to read all of the posts, noted in several hundreds of e-mails, that I'd missed during my absence. It was either that, or continually subject myself to playing Sisyphus.
I'm glad to hear that Gret's absence is not owing to some greater tragedy than that of a loss of communications.
Should you have the opportunity, please tell her that I wish her well, and look forward to her return.
May the future be kind.
by deepsand
by hal 9000
Jesus was a direct descendant of the House of David and hence the Rightful Ruler of the Jewish People.
Judea at the time was an invaded land controlled by the Roman Empire.
All through their History the Jews had a history of being subservient to overseers or even to be seen as nothing more than slaves. This predates the time in Egypt even according to the Old Testament.
Now if that part of the New Testament is correct that Jesus was a direct descendant of the House of David I would look at the movement that he started as a Political Movement and an attempt to rid his Land of the Invaders, Oppressors or however you like to view them. If that is correct he would have needed 2 distinct circles of inner advisers those with a Military insight on how to throw out the Romans and those who where True Believers in his supposed powers Paul fell into the latter group and not the former group while Judas was in the former group and a Loyal Servant of Jesus so much so that he would do anything necessary to allow Jesus to rise to his rightful place in Judea and over through the Invading Romans.
Paul on the other hand would have been necessary to stir up the People and get them to do his bidding we have seen something similar to this recently when the population rose up against the Shar of Iran and threw him out. Judea at the time could not hope to win a Military Victory against Rome so it had to sustain a Popular Uprising and rely on People Power to throw out the Romans and make it distasteful for them to return.
There are several references to Jesus heritage the most obvious one being the title bestowed on him as [b]King of the Jews[/b] at his crucification. There is also an obvious time problem in the time taken for Jesus to die as it happened too quickly as with any form of crucification the cause of death was suffocation because a person can not breath while being suspended by the arms and have all their weight hung off them in that fashion. The Vinegar told in the story of the Crucification is misunderstood as at the time it was used as a sedative not some form of cruel punishment as alluded to by the latter writers of that passage of the bible. They simply [b]Didn't understand the consequences of using one chemical in conjunction with another and what it would do.[/b]
Then there is the story of Lazarus and the way that the Magdalen approached Jesus and spoke to him at the time no woman could have spoke to a male like that unless she was close family example a sister or wife could get away with it but not as supposed by the people who currently interpret the Bible a complete stranger.
The story of Barabbas is another furphy as well as the Romans never let a convicted prisoner go for any reason and the idea of pacifying the Jews would have been so foreign to their way of thinking as to be unbelievable. If they wanted to pacify the Jews they would have used one of their Legions not let a prisoner go. While it sounds good now at the time it was not only unthinkable it was impossible to comprehend the Romans held their Empire with the [b]Might Makes Right Idea.[/b]
Anyway I've said enough to upset the Rabid Christians and I'll be expecting a solid wall of flame to descend upon me for having the audacity to post the above so I'm about to climb into my fireproof clothing. :^0
Col ]:)
Well just to finish off the week properly after upsetting at least 2 of the TR Staff I'll post this and see if they throw me off all together. :^0
[b]Jay look and Suffer!!!!!!!!!
Remember I have my eye on you ALL![/b]
by jellimonsta
by deepsand
She is presented with a list of blind questions, identified to her as simply, for example, Question No. 1, Question No. 2, etc..
For each question, she is asked to select from a list of blind answers, identified to her as simply Answer A, Answer B, etc..
In short, she does not know the actual content of either the questions or the answers.
I had the link, but need to write this particular one down on a piece of paper and leave it on my desk!
:x I tend to use a capital X or leave a space between the : and x. :p There's little hope for me Jelli, unless I hire a typist!
by jardinier
is a clairvoyant who charges $150 per private session, and is booked up six months ahead. :)
I am not aware of there being spiritualist churches in Sydney which have ordained persons. In fact I cannot imagine how any spiritualist could legitimately carry the title of "Reverend." However in American I guess anything is possible in the area of religious sects.
More than 20 years ago I was given readings by two amateurs. One attended one of the most respected Spiritualist Churches in Sydney, and the other was a Charismatic Christian who was afraid to reveal her gift.
Everything these two girls predicted has come true, with the exception of publishing a book. I have written the book, but not attempted to publish it so even that might come true.
What amazed me especially was that both girls said I would do "a lot of writing." This baffled me at the time, because writing was not on my list of planned projects. But sure enough, eight years later I acquired my first computer and wrote a science fiction novel as well as other things.
by deepsand
Yes, the General Assembly of Spiritualists does has such title; a Reverend is the equivalent of a Pastor in other churches.
The Reverend in question too is given to hiding her light under a bushel.
For some time she has her own congregation, give instructions on Spiritualism to members and perspective members, and gave readings for members.
She relied on voluntary donations for her support; such ultimately proved to be insufficient for her basic needs.
Being unable to bring herself to charge for her services, she sought gainful employment elsewhere, and now give readings, still at no charge, only to close friends and those recommended by such. This she does infrequently, as she finds it quite emotionally draining.
by jardinier
Many years ago one of my best friends, who was a doctor, worked for a while in an American hospital.
He sent me a photo of all the doctors. What was very obvious was that almost all of the doctors exhibited distinctly Jewish facial characteristics.
And before someone jumps down my throat and calls me a racist, I can readily distinguish most Jewish people regardless of the prominence of their breathing apertures.
by x-marcap
The problem with carbon dating is consistency.
We took a leaf in amber and it tested 15,000 years old at OSU. To Cap Poly the same artifact was sent. It came back 14,750 years +- 250 years. We took a fresh leaf, dessicated it and encased it in sap pressurized it and cooked it for 8 months... OOPS... Carbon dating isn't ALWAYS accurrate.
The problem is that science is now a religion, but it is a religion with no power to save you from anything but ignorance. It can lead you into stupidity.
carbon dated and scientifically tested. It was proven to have come from the correct era and the writing on it was also consistant with the correct era - early 1st century AD.
Since they have allowed some items, like the cross and the Shroud of Turin, to be scientifically tested and examined by experts it makes it more than a bit odd that they refuse to have others checked the same way.
BTW The Shroud of Turin has been proven to be a medieval fake - many suspect it is one of da Vinci's greatest works.
As for taking their word on things - you are talking about an organisation that for centuries was a byword in lying for political gain. Take the crusades, Christians had no trouble visiting the sights of the holy land while it was under Muslim rule, they had less troubles than after the crusaders took over. But when a dispute arose between the Vatican and senior Muslim leaders about charges and taxes on goods coming in on the 'silk route' the Vatican decided that they needed to 'control the holy land to make it safe for pilgrims'. And the Borgias are great examples of papal conduct; ditto the pope (forget which) that decided the Knights Templar should give him most of their riches and had them declared heritics when they said no. You can sure trust the word of such people.
by deepsand
and set it to that time. However, regarding the item known as a piece of the True Cross that had been found by Helena - the wood dates from that period and place, it is a part of the identification name plate and the text is consistant with that period, method of writting etc changes towards the end of the first century AD.
It could very well be a 1st century AD fake relic, but the industry in relic fakes did not get really going until much later. Also Helena testified of finding that relic buried in the ground, some metres down. It is these last two points that cause many academics to think it may be an original. Others think it a bit interesting that the find occurs just when this very rich and influential widow is in town looking for Christian relics. And this was in a period when persecuting and killing Christians had been a major sport until a couple of years earlier. Very suspicious - no real evidence that it is or is not of the true cross.
I like the current status of the Shroud of Turin. To start with when Jesus was entombed shrouds were put in place by wrapping the cloth around the body and haveing a lot of overlay, thus only a small section of each inner wind is in actual contact. The Turin Shroud is as if he lay on it and they folded it over him. Also the holes in the hands and feet in the shroud are in the wrong place for a crucifixtion, the Romans actually nailed through the wrist and ankles. The hands and feet themselves would never take the weight and the accused would quickly fall of the cross.
Recent scientific investigations shows that the material is of a type and weave that was used in medieval Europe not 1st century Judea, and dating methods support this. The general concensus amongst the academics is that it is a medieval fake, probably one of da Vinci's greatest works as they think he is the most likely candidate.
desoite all this some of the church hierachy and many of the church members still believe that it is a true relic of Jesus.
But then that is in a church where they teach people to ask various saints and Mary to intercede for them when Jesus himself said that he was the only intermediatory that you could call upon. So why do they tell people to pray and ask help of those that have no right to help? Darned if I know. But this is the same church whose leaders advocated celibacy except for married couples, celibacy for priests and nuns, yet had unmarried archbishops and popes who sired enough children to populate entire towns. Seemed they failled to practice what they preached.
by x-marcap
The issue became one of control. The Medici Pope was elected without the preceptor of the Templar's being allowed to vote in the election. (at the time a voiolation of church rules.) The Templar's tried to pull a Martin Luther and withdraw from the Catholic Church.
The pope said "Give us your lands, and your treasury collected in the name of the church" The templar's response "Go pound sand." At that time the Templar's believed that the church wouldn't begin a war to control the church and it's assets. They were wrong. They were rooted out and killed.
Follow the money. and Never insult a man's pride. The Borgias and the Medicis are the reason priests can't marry today...
by deepsand
Please, spare us from having to listen to that tired refrain again.
Such is naught but sophistry .
by deepsand
It seems that you [b]are[/b] willing to accept the word of those with an agenda, so long as such agrees with your beliefs.
This is a rational position?
by deepsand
He also claimed to have personally autographed pictures of Jesus Christ.
Both were available for a suitable donation to his radio ministry.
Does the Catholic Church know about this?
Are they the reason that he is no longer on the airwaves?
by deepsand
And, no matter how hard you may try, you cannot require that faith be accepted in lieu of proof.
In this instance, if one claims to have a piece of the cross in question, then the burden of proof rests with that person, and he must, if he expects his claim to be given credence, produce said artifact for examination.
Otherwise, his claim remains unsubstantiated.
by deepsand
has recently been demonstrated.
One of the criticisms of those who believe the Shroud to be authentic was the absence of an explanation of how to produce an image that seemed to contain 3-dimensional data.
The technique for accomplishing such turns out to be quite simple.
1) Paint an image on glass.
2) Place a piece of linen on the ground where it will be exposed to bright sun light.
3) Place the glass on the linen, with the side bearing the [b]image on the top[/b], so that it is separated from the linen by the glass.
4) Wait until several days of clear skies with bright sunshine have passed.
Voila; a miracle!
by deepsand
Please describe.
Thanks.
taking one brass or steel bust or statue of the required size and then heating it up until it is hot but not red hot. Tightly wrap one layer of light cloth around this to stop too much burning and then apply your intended 'relic' to the bust or statue, wearing protective pads push the 'relic' onto the bust or statue. Enough heat comes through to lightly scorch the 'relic' material but not actually burn it. The light scortch marks look like heavy stains but the material is not as deformed as if applied direct to the hot metal.
A few years back some people did this and got a finished product that look exactly like the shroud of Turin. The trick is getting the metal hot enough to scortch but not burn.
by deepsand
1. I like the concept of playing with a 'hot' bust.
2. It is simple and does not need any knowledge of chemicals or science.
3. It is emminently possible with the technological levels in use at the time the 'relic' was created.
4. I just can't get past the concept of playing with one hot, very hot bust - sorry.
by deepsand
by x-marcap
--- replace it with Science several places...---
Science is trusted by those who can't tell a beaker from a bunsen burner. If I start talking valences they are looking for the curtain rods...
It is believed even in the face of insurmountable evidence. The but what if we are right is just as plausible for the GA. baptist as for the global warming crowd and Greenhouse gase morons...
They don't want to be confused with measurements or any potential contradictory facts... For those who can quote, but cannot understand it, Science is a religion.
by x-marcap
Crucifixion was brutal.
Quite often, ropes were used to fasten the miscreant?s arms to the cross. The stand was there and to help the victim live longer. If he pushed up with his feet, he wouldn't die of pneumonia as fast. Those who were nailed through the hands and tied to the cross were known to have stolen from the temple, or from a taxe collector...
This would be better known except for tons of disinformation that is out there... Ropes or long cloths were started under the armpits while the victim was still alive. If they were flogged or beaten cloths were used because a rope wouldn?t sick to the wounds as painfully as would the cloths. If someone was flailed raw, then it really didn?t matter, everything hurt.
by x-marcap
since the papal edicts of the 7th century which well and truely predates the medieval Borgias and Medicis. Even then it is based on older papers by Augustine. Celibacy by priests has NO scriptual support what so ever - as a matter of fact the Old Testament supports priests being married and having families. Which is why I wonder the RC ever got into this concept.
BTW Don't you just hate that 'Maximum message depth notation'
by deepsand
Quoting "science" means nothing.
Labeling something as "science" does not perforce make it so.
Science and Religion are distinctly different. The attempt to label Science a religion is naught but an attempt by those who put beliefs before facts to hold out their beliefs as worthy of acceptance without having to be subject to empirical proofs.
In short, the claim that Science is a religion is sheer intellectual dishonesty.
by x-marcap
In particular I am targeting the so-called environmentalists, and green house gas gang. For many science is their religion.
Science is trusted, even though, when proved inaccurate, the progressive revelation of "new data" allows the ignorant to continue to believe that which they want to believe.
Valences and electron rotation are beyond the ken of the average environmentalist. Most of those characters top out at grade school geometry. Schroedinger's wave equation, and Uncertainty anyone?
What is the mathermatical relationship between speed and accelleration. If you don't know what it is, then your faith in science is a religion for you not a science. What is the mathematical relationship between distance and time.
For those of you who wonder if I know what I am talking about:
d=1/2(a*t); this is the 1st derivative of
s=a*t
For those of you without a calculus background, and physics, to you science is religion. You may use technology, and the fruit of others labors, but you don't understand them...
If it can't be measured it is opinion. If the facts aren't consistant, don't bother telling the facts as their minds are made up.
Sandy, I hope I answered your response. You sound like an old Lieut. Cmdr on the Enterprise in 1977. I told him he has the right to be wrong...
by deepsand
The discussion at hand is about "Religion," as in definition 1b), below shown, not "religion".
In your remarks re. Science, you are using "religion," per definition 3) and/or 4).
Therefore, within the context of this discussion, equating "Religion" with Science is incorrect.
Give close attention to the etymology.
==================================================
Main Entry: re?li?gion
Pronunciation: ri-'li-j&n
Function: noun
Etymology: Middle English [i]religioun[/i], from Latin [i]religion-[/i], [i]religio[/i] supernatural constraint, sanction, religious practice, perhaps from [i]religare[/i] to restrain, tie back -- more at RELY
1 a : the state of a religious
b (1) : the service and worship of God or the supernatural (2) : commitment or devotion to religious faith or observance
2 : a personal set or institutionalized system of religious attitudes, beliefs, and practices
3 [i]archaic[/i] : scrupulous conformity : CONSCIENTIOUSNESS
4 : a cause, principle, or system of beliefs held to with ardor and faith
by x-marcap
Most environmentalists with no understanding want to restrain our activity. Look at the etymology yourself...
The answer is in the etymology as well as 3 and 4 definitions.
The discussion at hand is about "Religion," as in definition 1b), below shown, not "religion". In your remarks re. Science, you are using "religion," per definition 3) and/or 4). Therefore, within the context of this discussion, equating "Religion" with Science is incorrect. Give close attention to the etymology. ================================================== Main Entry: re?li?gion Pronunciation: ri-'li-j&n Function: noun Etymology: Middle English religioun, from Latin religion-, religio supernatural constraint, sanction, religious practice, perhaps from religare to restrain, tie back...
This is the Kyoto treaty and Carbon gas concern in a nutshell.
by deepsand
To repeat,
"The [b]discussion at hand is about[/b] "Religion," as in [b]definition 1b)[/b], below shown, not "religion".
In [b]your remarks re. Science[/b], you [b]are using[/b] "religion," per [b]definition 3) and/or 4)[/b].
Therefore, within the context of this discussion, equating "Religion" with Science is incorrect.
Give close attention to the [b]etymology[/b]."
==================================================
Main Entry: re?li?gion
Pronunciation: ri-'li-j&n Function: noun
[b]Etymology[/b]: Middle English religioun, from Latin religion-, religio [b]supernatural[/b] constraint, sanction, religious practice, perhaps from religare to restrain, tie back...
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending