Discussion Locked

What to do about user porn?

0 helpful
118 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

118 replies

by abelnguyen

I agree that you have the obligation to report if you stumble across any evidence of illegal activity. However, you don't have to report it as a PC repair shop and take all the risk on yourself. Why can't ladytech report it anonymously? (I guess youmisunderstood me because of the title "Don't report" that I used)

About our society, yeah, we are in bad shape :(
Just go to google.com and type in "preteen", :( .

by hal 9000

How do the Ploice investigater? Will you be taken seriously? Surely the police or whoever need to see exactly whats on the computer so they can make up their own minds if it is actually CHILD PORN after all it just might not be and even if it is there could be a perfectly resonable reason why its there in the first place { I don't know but maybe the person trains others to reconise abused children or something like that} but YOU MUST REPORT IT SO IT CAN BE LOOKED INTO!

by sobek

Jim says "It's not your call as to what's ok for someone to have on the PC." (In relation to child porn)
Does this extend to everything else
It is'nt your call to decide whats okay, thats why you report it to the authorities. Invasion of Privacy??Do you allow privacy for crimes?? The rape and sexual abuse of young children??
Jim says "you report someone and invade the owner?s privacy and you may as well lock up your store and look for a job."
or do you let whoever it is go on on to potentially sexually abuse, rape and kill young children
Your call Jim !!!!

by abelnguyen

?How would this person feel if they where held up at gun point in a busy street and robbed and when the Police asked, no one came forward to help the Police??
If the robber held me at gun point (which mean they have guns), it is unlikely that anyone would came forward to help as there?s a big risk of being killed. And even if they want to, the police won?t let them as they might make the robber become violent (i.e. I get robbed with no help, but I might get killed if I am helped the wrong way).
Anyway, I am glad that there are people like you around. The society need more people like you to make it better.
About pirate software, one reason that MS is not so interested in the End User is because there?re too many cases like that for MS to handle. Believe it or not, the US software pirate rate is more than 20%. And US software pirate rate is one of the lowest compare to other countries (China = 96%; Bulgaria = 93% ...)

by hal 9000

I was trying to make. I did not mean to intervien at the actual robbery but to help the police after the event. Once upon a time {in a galaxy far away} anyway I think thats how it goes but I used to pick up payrols for my staff as I could not expectany of my staff to do something that I was not prepared to do and Yes I did have a firearm licence and I did carry a pistol but it was all unnecessary as I was instructed if ever stopped and confronted to simply hand over the money and let whoever get on their way without causing any potential trouble like shotting people. After all the money was insured and it wasn't worth getting yourself or anybody else hurt/killed over and I agree with this. But I was told to observe as much as possible so I could latter help the police as much as possible. It is this situation I was refering to as the more wittness that come forward the easier it is to clear yourself and at the same time help the police if there is only you to report this type of robbery the police may think you staged the whole event but if several people come forward with similar stories you are in the clear and actually no 2 people will ever see the same thing the same way as everybody brings their own prediguces and believes to what ever they see. I guess its the same in business we all see what we want to and act acordingly.

by sobek

Duck says "Trust me when I say you always need the facts before you go into anything like this".

So you going to ask this guy if it's his kiddie porn ??
Let me guess, he'll say NO WAY!!
Let the authorities find out the facts
Your not a detective
Let them sort it

by abelnguyen

1) I guess there's a different in where you live and where I live. Here, if the customer is prosecuted, you don't need to seek for media attention. They will knock on your door, and you can't control what they will say about you.
2) Risk of being sued - this is depend on what kind of customer you are dealing with (which might be hard to tell). If the customer wants to sue, there?re several things they can sue you about. For example, if the shop doesn't stay clear in the contract/work order that the customer give the shop permission to access the content of files on the hard drive, it's a risk of being sued for invading the customer?s privacy.
Well, we live in a law suits culture. I hate this fact, and I hate the fact that you can easily be sued for no reason just as McDonald is sued for selling bugger. And the point here is not wining or losing a case but lawyer fee and lengthy law suit.
3) My point here is the result of reporting. What if the customer has no ideal about that picture? A report might lead to that?s customer?s computer being taken by the police for evident, or worse, he might be arrested. If he has nothing to do with the picture, it?s likely that the judge / jury would find him innocent. However, who will pay the bail if he is arrested? Who will pay for his lawyer?

chappieaj@yahoo.com.au , I don't know about your country, but at mine, you have to pay to talk with a lawyer, and it's quite expensive. It probably cost more than what you get for reparing that PC. In my opinion, the best course of action would be report it anonymously and let the police do their job.

by oldefar

I still don't see evidence supporting your concerns. Maybe I have been searching on the wrong keywords.

Can you point to some specific cases where media publicity occurred, and where a lawsuit against a shop owner was initiated so that I can reconsider my position?

by hal 9000

Because if they actually exist it might make me change my mind on how I do business. But unless you can give proof that this has occured I will continue to go on doing the right thing. And I don't expect to be sued for writting the legal report on the destruction of the server & network but I do expect to be called as a wittness buy who ever built the server in the first place against the importer of the power supply and while I want no part of any of this it just comes with the job and if you don't like it then get out and find something else to do where you will never have any possibility of running into this type of thing and being required to give evidence. By the way whan you find this job PLEASE LET ME KNOW WHAT IT IS SO I CAN WORK IN THAT INDUSTRY!

by hereinoz

A valid point, but the fact remains that you still think that it is worth reporting - anonomously or not, it still gets followed up and is dealt with. If the person is innocent, perhaps they will get a good lesson in boosting computer security, andthat is not a bad thing in any case.

by hal 9000

I personally agree with you and I wouldn't have a bar of it and I work for a Bank so I know exactly what happens however most people go for the quick and easy fix and Internet banking suits them as they already have a computer of some sourts so theydon't have to go out and buy one. The same thing happened when ATM's where introduced it was convenient and easy and you did not have to go to the bank durring bank hours either. Actually it made it cheeper for the bank to do business and they couldcut back on staff and branches well the same applies to Internet banking only it is better as the bank doesn't have to go to the expence of placing a ATM and constantly filling and clearing it. Its the banks ultimate aim to have everybody use Internet banking as they could close up almost everything, sack most of their staff and only need data processing assets there by reducing their overheads to virtually nothing and then they will continue to increase the charges for this service as they will claim that it costs them money to opperate the service just like ATM's they very quickly forget about how much they are saving but continually want to push up their proffits.

by jardinier

Yes the banks sure have the customers by the short and curlies. How many times have you walked into a bank and noted four staff and only two customers, but nobody actually being served?

I am so often tempted to call out in a loud voice for all tohear: "How do you people pass the time now than you no longer have customers?"

by hal 9000

Have it all their own way and worse still they have the ear of th eGovernments who make the laws which they work under so if something happens that they don't like they simply get the laws changed. The banks in any country are just too powerfull andthier one goal in life is to make as bigger profit as possible. Really customers are nothing more than a necessary nuciance who must be tolerated because they want their money but unless you are going to give them massive amounts of money you will not get any form of service. I actually work as a consulant for a bank and because theor head office pays me which is interstate it takes 10 days to clear my payments and at the time I was banking with that bank. They insisted that interstate cheques took longer to clear but I pointed out if their head office didn't have the money to pay me then the staff could not be sure of their own pay either. It gets even better as one night when I was doing some routine work I stumbled across 1 of my pay cheques that I had deposited that day and it had been cleared but I had no access to the money, the bank was investing it on the short term money market and making money with my money. They certianly see you comming and make every effort to ring as much out of you as possible. But thats my Bitch for the night.

by hal 9000

Somewhere here someone claimed that the media would be crawling all over the business in question if they where to report this to the authorities. Thats probably true if the matter was ever to come to a court but how would the media become aware of the report prior to this occuring? I'm quite sure the authorities wouldn't go out telling everybody as it would interfere with their investigation. The business would naturally keep quite as they would have been instructed by the authorities not to comment as it could hinder the investigation. And if/when the case was brought to court would media coverage be such a bad thing? Surely it would only promote the business in the eyes of the public as being a place of prinicipals and then there is thesaying that no publicity is bad publicity.

I'm sorry that this isn't in the right place but I've had one of those days where I'd gladly cut my wrists if only my keepers would allow me to use other impelments than the plastic knives and forks thatthey issue to me. I was asked today by MS was I a Certified MS Partner to which I replied I don't know but at the moment I'm certianly Certifable.

by admin

Children everywhere need the safety, compassion and love that responsible adults can provide in these areas. If the person has a legitimate reason for this then they will be glad to share their motives with the clergy and appreciative that others are responsible in these issues. At any rate, I think it commendable as it seperates the tech from trying to be law enforcement, judge and jury and just deal with the straight up facts.

Good Job. :)

by admin

I get asked a lot about where a good reputable, principled shop is. My favorite shop, one that I work quite closely with is owned and operated by an ex-cop who still does private investigation and evidence work for both local attournies and law enforcement. Sometimes in the course of PI work he uncovers things that have to be reported. Does anyone usually make a big deal about this? Picket his shop etc.? No, quite the reverse actually. He has MORE business due to his stance. People seek him outfor his principles and values.

I think the fear of less work is not at all justified, in fact if I take a box to a tech and I'm pretty sure they may compromise values, I'm going to be pretty concerned about what they may steal, hardware or software or misuse while they have it there.

The computer business isn't just based on ability, it's heavily based on reputation as well IMO.

:)

by support#netropole.com

I don?t see why it?s so difficult to see if the person has been downloading and collecting porn, warez, or even baseball cards on his computer. Files are dated and probably organized. Even in the temp internet files they are all dated. Yes it?s possible that they persons son/daughter is downloading stuff on his computer without their knowledge but if it?s a case of tons child porn blatantly sitting in my docs then that?s bad. If it?s a few questionable pix in the temp files then its possible some popup windows put them there. People aren?t stupid, they can be dumb and not think about what they are doing but most dumb pervs won?t even think of it when they ask you to fix the drive.

On another note why was the tech looking at files. When I fix a drive I ghost it or rebuild and copy files. I don?t look at temp files or any other files for that matter. I mostly look at extensions and folders.

Ghost and go. It?s safe easy and really fast.

This discussion is closed to new replies.