Discussion Locked

What's good for the goose isn't necessarily good for the gander

0 helpful
22 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

While Westerners said that Muslims were overreacting about cartoon depictions of Muhammud, Australia's PM John Howard and Foreign Minister Alexander Downer have taken great offence at a cartoon in an Indonesian Newspaper depicting them as fornicating dingoes.

Do I detect a double standard here?

http://www.news.com.au/story/0,10117,18653255-2,00.html

22 replies

by dawgit

They could have made them cute cuddly Kolas 'making love' :-) But a dingo? tsk-tsk, Who wouldn't be insulted.!.?.

by maxwell edison

...if Australia's PM John Howard and Foreign Minister Alexander Downer riot in the streets, burn buildings, and kill people to show that they're offended.

Are they doing that?

To compare simply being offended to riots in the streets, burning buildings, and killing people is silly.

by rob mekel

civilisation.
Or, if you like, reason vs emotion.

But otherwise then Mohammed, John Howard and Alexander Downer can express themselfs if they are offended by these cartoons.
Not that I don't agree upon you but just spelling out what the difference is!

Rob

by bfilmfan

Wasn't that a Captain and Tenil song?

Dingo Love?

And are dingos that wrinkley? Looked more to me like a couple of hippos in a romantic interlude to me...

by jdclyde

only if they go out and riot, start killing people and destroying property world wide.

There is NOTHING wrong with being outraged over something as intentionally offensive as any of the cartoons.

The difference is HOW you show that outrage.

Your way off on this to even compare the two. (or have they put a million dollar bounty on the head of the cartoonist that I missed in the article?)

by jdclyde

Didn't have time to read the postings that were already there because I only had a few minutes free to get my fix.

Came back later and saw that I had telepathicly plagerized your post.... :0

I still stood behind it, so I let it stand.

The way I look at it, this is like a basic programming class project. If logic is followed, the programs SHOULD all look almost exactly the same because they have been given the same information as to what the proposed question is and how to resolve it.

I am actually more surprised that EVERYONE didn't post the exact same thing? But then I forget, some people are just nuts! :D

by maxwell edison

Is what's good for the goose
Really good for the gander?
Or is this an attempt
At political slander?

Is what's good for the goose
Really good for the gander?
Or a prophet or clergy,
Or nation's commander?

If what's good for the goose
Is good for the gander,
Then this would be met
With the usual pander.

For what's good for the goose
And not for the gander,
Is often approached
With the utmost of candor.

What's good for the goose
And also the gander,
Has all been said,
So it's time to meander.

(I know that it's bland,
but it could have been blander.)

by tonythetiger

If, six months after the fact, Austrailians start rioting, pillaging, etc., then there may be a case for stating a similarity. We'll just have to wait and see.

by jdclyde

if you don't agree with everything the EXTREME liberals say, they will next accuse YOU of being just like Hitler too!

Facts? Details? History? Thought? Check them at the door. You won't need them here.....

by rob mekel

Riods starts first and afterwards the insult is expressed. :D ;)

Was looking for the link myself but you beat me to it. :D

Rob

edited for emoticons

by jardinier

But it IS stupid, given that Muhammad, for obvious reasons, did not instigate or participate in the rioting and pillaging.

Your suggested headline becomes even more absurd when you take into account that while John Howard is in control of both houses of parliament, he is in fact playing God, which puts him higher on the spiritual hierarchy even than the Prophet.

by jardinier

or perhaps you could say: "overreacted."

[jardinier retreats, dingo fashion, tail between legs] :(

by jardinier

by the cartoon which portrays bestiality.

I was about to say that it is extremely unlikely that an Australian newspaper would publish a cartoon of this nature, but the Australian has killed my theory by publishing a t1t-for-tat cartoon. I cannot locate the cartoon online, but here is Alexander Downer's response:

[i]" FOREIGN Minister Alexander Downer has slammed a cartoon published in The Weekend Australian as tasteless and offensive, declaring the government did not condone it in any way.

The cartoon depicts the Indonesian president as a dog sexually dominating a Papuan and is an apparent t1t-for-tat response to a cartoon in an Indonesian newspaper this week depicting Mr Downer and Prime Minister John Howard as copulating dingoes.

In the Australian cartoon, by prominent artist and cartoonist Bill Leak, President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono appears as a dominant dog, tail wagging as he mounts a Papuan with bone in nose, saying: "Don't take this the wrong way..."

The caption reads: "No Offence Intended".[/i]

It is interesting that the country which contains one of the largest Muslim populations in the world -- maybe 170,000,000 (figures vary according to different sources, which list Indonesia as having either the first or second highest Muslim population) should publish such a cartoon.

This would suggest that in some ways at least, Muslim Indonesia is at least as liberal as Australia.

[i] [Post edited because of stupid TR bowdlerization tool.][/i]

by maxwell edison

First of all, I made no such comparison; you're the one who made the comparison in your original message. Is this another one of your over-reactions, Julian?

But yes, my suggested headline was intended to be absurd. In fact, it was intended to be VERY absurd. So you are calling my intentionally absurd headline, absurd? Okay, I guess I can't disagree with that.

Absurdity, however, seems to find its way into real SMH headlines from time to time, doesn't it, Julian? And that might make mine funny to some people, in a satirical sense, that is. If not to you, I don't really care. Some people appreciate certain satire, others don't. Just like you probably appreciated the satirical depiction of John Howard.

by absolutely

What article did you read? When I clicked your link, (http://www.news.com.au/story/0,10117,18653255-2,00.html) I read about Australians acting very rationally. Where do you believe you have detected a double standard?

Excerpted from the article:

[Mr Howard was unmoved by a popular Indonesian newspaper's front page drawing depicting Mr Howard and Mr Downer as two dingoes having sex under a palm tree on an otherwise barren island signposted "Papua".

"I have been in this game a long time. If I got offended about cartoons, golly. Give us a break," Mr Howard said.

Mr Downer said the cartoon was a tasteless act by a tacky publication, but said newspapers were free to publish such things.]

by ahsun83

Creating and Publishing offensive cartoons
about the most respected personality of Islam
was the worst thing those cartoonists and
newspaper editor could have done to them
selves. I hope the worst for them.

The Australian PM has clearly shown double
standards by taking 'great offense' about his
own cartoons.

This discussion is closed to new replies.