Discussion Locked

What's Up with Firefox and Phoning Home?

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://blogs.zdnet.com/hardware/?p=2143&tag=nl.e539

Looks innocent enough, but given that most users probably changed from IE to Firefox because they didn't like how Microsoft does things, Mozilla sure is acting a lot like Microsoft in that regard.

You'd think for perception reasons alone, Mozilla would make all phone home features an opt in only option and not on by default.

4 replies

by rkuhn040172

Phoning home can have legitmate reasons.

However, you'd think Mozilla would be a little more forthcoming about it.

I wouldn't call what they are doing "stealthy" but I would expect more openness from Mozilla.

by michael kassner

I'm not sure what you're seeing as "phone home" traffic, but it could be due to auto-update. Which you can opt out of. If that is not enabled on the system you are referring to, I apologize.

This sort of stuff totally intrigues me and I feel it's very important to be aware of any "phone home" traffic. As far as I can see this is the information that is being relayed:

1. Live Bookmarks updating
2. Auto-update checking
3. Anti-phishing list updating
4. Anti-malware list updating
5. Extension blocklist updating

FireFox being open source allows anyone to research exactly what's going on. On the other hand, IE being closed requires a great deal of guess work and packet capture to get the same results. Hence, my appreciation of FireFox

by rkuhn040172

If you read the article, rumor has it (I wish it wasn't a rumor...when I have more time I'll do some packet captures) that they collect the following information:

- IP address
- What time you were using the product
- What exact version number you were using
- If you are using any of the plugins or addons sent in the disabled list
- Total number of active users of their software

If that's true, that's out of line for an organization like Mozilla...we expect it from Microsoft.

Your list is straight from the Mozilla website. That'd be like asking Microsoft what they collect, I'm not sure you'd get a straight answer.

This discussion is closed to new replies.