Discussion Locked

What's with all the political threads?

0 helpful
35 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

It's a poorly kept secret around here that several TechRepublic members are passionate about politics, as evidenced by the fact that there's always at least one politically themed thread to be found in the Hot Discussions list. That said, it is rare that any of these political threads ever generate a truly significant amount of traffic, despite the fact that they are usually record-holders for number of posts. In other words, a small group of people are very active on these threads, but they don't have a wide following.

So, my question is this: are IT pros in general a very politically motivated and interested group, or do we just have a few armchair pundits who can't resist a good flame war? Let me know what you think.

35 replies

by admin

Funny thing is, I bet if it was a political site there would be the occasional sidebar about IT issues. ~LoL~ Have you noticed recently that forays into religion are happening too?

I think one of the reasons these go here is that some time ago some people got mad about not getting Techpoints because people where answering tech questions here in discussions. If you go to most IT boards all the discussions are is mainly answering what is seen as Q&A material here. With the tech questions disallowed on the board, we are left with primarily discussing the philosophy of IT and related subjects.

A longtime interest of mine is that the philosophical discussions about IT seem to be decreasing in passion everywhere in IT. I have not seen the new "The Cathedral and The Bazaar" for instance. J. Random Hacker- not the misnomer for Cracker- and his true progeny are dying out IMO. This is across the board though, not just here, and I blame the move from general education to certs and in the "do-it-yourself" culture, the move from the soldering iron crowd to the IRC and script kid ranks to eventually develop a different meaning for the word, and with it a different focus. Of course those who grew up during the IRC days of the next meaning of "Hacking" are interested in security a lot, so the boards that focus on this draw them in like flies. :)

Of course I am not directly answering "Why Politics" with this last part, but I believe the vacuum this creates contributes to the off topic stuff here.

Well, for whats itsa worth ~LoL~ hope that itsa helpful :)

by Jay Garmon

There is a possibility that the next iteration of our Discussion Center may reintegrate Tech Q&A, so the separation you talk about will end and--if you're right--the off topic discussions will be crowded out.

As to the general decline in IT meta-theory, I'd wager that what has really broken down is the separation between technology and business theory. With "The Wisdom of Crowds" and other trendy management books openly admitting that their theories require IT simply to be implemented, it may simply be that the long-demanded IT/business alignment has already quietly taken place.

That, or it makes for better selling books. :)

by admin

I would agree to that as well, but personally I would not like to see my childs school materials written by corporations either.

Although I agree IT and Business need to align for work, I think we are really losing something by limiting education to only what the market needs at any given moment.

I have seen what happens when IT is simply implemented and it is neither cost-effective nor does it meet the end user employees work needs for more than 3 years- 5 years max. This will pull profits in the short term, but then you are left with big messes that are fixed by pouring lots more money in than would have been necessary with a long term sustainable plan. Of course, long term matters nil in some publically traded company these days, but luckily, those usually fall by the wayside or clean up eventually.

From IT worker burnout to end user frustration you can see the effects of management following this strategy long term IME. Of course, it will be old hat soon and a new "corrective" strategy will appear with new books and new windmills for the Quixote management culture to justify their golf discussions with.

I guess I am saying that we do need integration, but let's try and convince our CEO's to balance the pendulum a bit in the balancing process.

Actually, to me this would be a good long discussion! ~LoL~ It probably won't get a lot, although I hope I'm surprised.

Best of luck with this issue :) I enjoy your site.

by maxwell edison

.
Some time ago, there were a few "non-Americans" who felt it their duty to bash America for absolutely everything under the sun, hijacking the TechRepublic discussion forums as their vehicle, and a few defenders (myself included) chimed in to rebut their constant verbal attacks. From that contentious start, the content grew into what you see today, which is a wide-range of political topics.

And I, too, have noticed that the people who post in such threads are limited to a small number (small is relative, in this case), as I see hoards of other users in the technical discussions and Q&A that I never see in the political ones.

I've found, however, that while I love a good political debate as much as the next guy, the level of true political understanding is rather lacking among those who regularly participate. There are some politically savvy people, to be sure, but for the most part, there's a lot of political ignorance being thrown around as though it's some kind of informed expertise. (Imagine being a true baseball aficionado, and discussing - or debating - the finer points of the game with someone who's never seen a game or understands its rules.) Being disingenuous, relying on silly political platitudes, butchering the English language so as to stretch words into new meanings, and building arguments on a false premise which generally leads to a faulty conclusion, are all quite common. (Oh, but I forgot, those kinds of things are just a "difference of opinion".)

However, at this level, we're all, as you suggested, "armchair pundits", and what we say here will affect the outcome of any political contest about as much as the temperature on Venus. And just like the temperature on Venus, the heat generated from the passion stirred by some of these debates can rise to some scorching levels indeed.

by sleepin'dawg

There are times when IS/IT can become excrutiatingly monotonous through repetition and the grey matter has to be turned loose to play. There is little harm meant or done beyond the revalations of lack of knowledge of history, political science or economics by a few.

by dc_guy

We're deep in the throes of the Paradigm Shift and that means that everything about politics is in a state of flux if not absolute chaos. Just the kind of milieu that the generally well-educated, opinionated, and articulate IT crowd enjoys jumping into.

I don't know whether you track read-only hits into these discussions. My employer would have a fit if I posted anything from this workstation but I occasionally glance in because it's wise to see what the IT community is thinking.

It's always interesting to see a discussion of politics that is not limited to my countrymen. Some of the foreigners are as misinformed about the US as some of us are about their countries, but others offer very insightful perspectives.

Freedom of speech being one of our most cherished traditions, it's heartening to see it popping up in the most unexpected places.

by oz_media

Political discussions are a complete waste of time, which I have much of through the day.

I find it amusing most of the time, just how politically defensive people can be, being English/Canadian this is ew to me. People actually defend politicians, which I find quite amusing.

There are many who are so politically defensive that they will discount anything other than what they've ben told to believe...get this...BY A POLITICIAN!! :D

Some of the people in the politcal threads could have had the president lie to their face and tell them that they are women and not men and they'd actually run out and buy a dress.

Even if you showed them grade 6 sex-ed movies showig the diferences between boys and irls, they would just say it's propaganda or Anti-presidential sentiments.

So all in all;

it's a great way to idly pee away time, when tired of the Q&A questions plastered all over discussion threads as if nobody knows how to navigate a website.

it's good for personal amusement.

it's fun to watch the blatant followers follow aling fathfully regardless of what they see, or choose to see.

but overall, politics in any country is all just a laugh and can't be taken seriously, yet some do as if it makes any difference.

by nicknielsen

Actually, I think it can be summed up as laziness on the part of Americans.

Too many people are too lazy or lack the skills to read, analyze, and think for ourselves. So they pick somebody who pretty much echoes wheat they think.

It's easy for conservatives: Rush is right! It's a bit more difficult for the liberals, because there's nobody left...

by oz_media

Sometimes it is vey had to decipher the intent of such a brief post, especially aroud such defensive people.

Thanks for clearing it up,
OM

by maxwell edison

.
Is about as far from accurate as it could possibly be. So much for your level of understanding.

Not thinking for ourselves?

Please, speak for yourself, but don't presume to speak for me.

I'm not a "conservative" because I can't think for myself. To the contrary, I'm a conservative because I can - and do - think (and accept personal responsibility) for myself

I guess you've been listening to too many "liberals". How many have made the same, tired-old characterizations about conservatives and Rush Limbaugh? Too many, I'm afraid.

by protiusx

I think that most people are bored and have nothing better to do with their time. I have stoped posting to the very article that I authored because I didn't have the time to reply to everyone.

by oz_media

As a relatively NEW poster on TR, you have managed to trump the most popular threads on TR by a long shot.

Whether it was timing or comments, users or arguments, you have become the King poster on TR.

I don't know of any othr time where a thread has hung on so long.

I opted out for a week after I thought it was a dead one and it STILL stayed at the top and the comments kept flowing.

I think the key part was the number of side bars.
Normally people are pushed back on track but in this case, it was all oer the place.

Bush, Kerry, War now, War then, Canada, Autralia, past residents, SEX, abortion, religion, racism you ame it, it was there, just like a whole handful of Bits and Bites, or more recently, like a box of chocolates, "you never know what you're gonna get."

So for all your success with your post, you get TR's gold star, a big wet kiss from GWB (maybe a little French action?!?)and a hip-hip-hooray from me (and you thought tounging the pres was the highlight!).

Well done sir, you broke the mold, and the boredom. :)

by oz_media

Have you considered resizing the tiny POST window?

It find on one workstation I use it is okay, but that station is just a PBX monitor and is set to 800X600. As much of my work involves graphics and press kits, i generally run at much higher resolution, the POST window becomes a POSTage stamp.

It seems you can only fit 8 lies ad about 7 words per line. This makes proof reading a post a pain in the butt, line by line scroll by scroll.

I noticed tha there was little or no mention of the new Discussion age layouts when you changed them, (I was trying to submit a post when the change was taking place and it kept timing out)but I noticed how much better the new layout was as soon as i reposted. I think the page layout offers a much better format for reading the posts. A little wider tha before. The POSTAGE stam sized POST window could use the same treatment, is this something you have considered or are already working at?

It would really make it easier for one like myself who can't type worth a damn.

Cheers,
OM

by av .

my husband's job was eliminated because of offshore outsourcing. Then, I became very interested in politics. Now, I want to know everything even if it makes me want to vomit. I think many IT workers that have been affected by outsourcing have become more politically motivated as well.

I find it interesting to hear views of US politics from other parts of the US and other countries on Techrepublic. I don't care if it is off-topic.

I like the diversion, too, of discussing topics that aren't specifically related to IT. Maybe its time wasting, but its a great release.

by thechas

I think like many people, we wish to extol our political views.

However, in the workplace, we need to maintain an air of professionalism, and avoid divisive topics.

Here at TR, we have relative "freedom" and anonymity.

This allows us to express our views much more freely than we can at work.

Chas

by sleepin'dawg

That you could make a mint on by selling tickets.
A safety valve to all the mindless drivel that is imposed by the outside world.
Stress is that feeling one gets when the mind overwhelms the body's basic urge to choke the living sh*t out of some as*hole who so desperately needs it.]:) ;) :D

by saphil9

Speak only on topics related to the job and make few friends among the non-IT people.. This has worked for me at some jobs. But among my IT co-workers, politics and sex and foreign policy were always discussed.

by itgirli

But mind you that I am agreeing after I thought about it myself. Even though I'm conservative I would like everyone to know that I thought about it. I didn't just go along with what skidoggeruk said because he said it, but because I thought the same thing, but it took me so long to get to the end of the postings that it was too late. Someone already said it and I agree, but that doesn't mean I'm a conservative that can't think for themselves. Or does it? what was a thinking? Oh that's right! a post was started asking why we have political discussions and along with answers we get more political mud-slinging. well, well, well..... We just can't get away from it, can we?

by mrafrohead

it's because you have a "room" full of some smart arsed mofo's (and then Oz ;p) that like to flex their noodles...

And we all have something to say about the current state of the world, that with some luck will just self implode and wipe our worthless asses away. As we can't all just get along, it's despicable.

Although, before that happens, I would really really really like a chance to box the people that released that last video of the 11 poor souls.

Neone that has seen it, knows what I'm talking about.

Sheer and absolute torture.

by sleepin'dawg

I agree. Pretty gruesome but can't find the link for it now and people should see it at least once (which is more than enough).:(

by mrafrohead

I can post it, but are you really sure that it should be here?

It in all honesty is probably one of the most disturbing video's I have EVER seen!

As in, I almost quit my job and walked to the recruiters office to sign up and leave, just to return the favor.

by mrafrohead

You know, I have a huge complaint.

It is regarding all of this "muslim" crap. And all of this "jihad" garbage, nonsense.

I have been collecting all of the released execution video's for my children when they are older(along with war footage). That way I can SHOW them exactly what was going on, before some schmuck in a PC office is deciding what to exclude from the history books.

I want my kids to have the opportunity for truth!

So I have been gathering these video's since Nick Berg.

I decided that maybe I should watch some of them, as if my kids (when they are older) decide that they are going to watch them, that I can have an honest discussion about it.

I have seen almost all of them.

The key thing that I have noticed in these beheading video's.

It is done slowly, usually the person cut appears to be drugged, they are tied up and there are at least three people helping to keep them from struggling.

The last one released with the 11 young people. This one as well as the last one, were quite different. The last one being the "suspected CIA agent".

In these, the CIA agent, the person stood next to him with a sword. This man was SO drugged that he could barely hold his head up. You would seriously have to see it to understand what I am talking about. I don't know what they gave him, but it was potent. The sword didn't appear to be sharp, as it took about twelve blows before his head was removed.

That said, that was torture. The first cut didn't go very deep, and this person had to sit there through it all.

The last video of the 11 men. They show a man that falls to the ground. He appears to have been knocked down there, as he is acting out of breath.

Someone climbs on top of him and cuts half way through. Then leaves him there. ALIVE choking on his own blood. The worse part is I can't get the image or the sound that he makes out of my head. It's been this way for two days. They LEFT him that way for about fifteen second before they finished.

Then they show a man, that is shot in the back, and just left there to die. Looking around, but they won't finish him off.

This is absolute blatant torture. There is NO point being made here, other than what appears to be some men trying to get their rocks off by hurting others.

NOW to my point!!!

I have read posts here about the heritage and history of these people that are committing these heinous crimes. So I decided to do a little research.

The other day, I started to watch execution video's from before the war started. Also some punishment video's.

I will tell you this much, one of them was a beheading of a man that committed some crime, I don't know what, but I will tell you how it all went down.

His body was put on a block, with his head slightly off of it. His knees were on the ground, and a man sat behind him with his back against the victims butt to keep him in place. The victim was blindfolded. The person who did the beheading, did it with a SWORD (not a freakin glorified steak knife) and it was over with in ONE swipe, kind of like the Guiatine (spelling?).

Then there were shots of people that had their fingers and hands cut off for stealing. ONE swipe, done.

Tongues cut out, ONE swipe, sometimes two if there was a miss, done.

If you notice the pattern here. The discipline, though sounding harsh, IMO was done civilly. Not to torture, but just carried out quickly and not dragged on.

So, if there is anyone out there that can explain to me, why these people are performing these "executions" in such a torturous manner that they are trying to justify as it's their way, I would like to know.

I absolutely CAN NOT understand this one. It is totally out of my comprehension.

by rdbennett

First, let me say I share your revulsion, and I applaud you for it. It shows you're civilized enough to believe in the rule of laws other than those of the jungle.

The martyrs you're watching die a slow, hero's death were the victims of butchery. The others you've seen were being punished under the law. Albeit somewhat draconian by Western standards, nonetheless it was a judgement rendered by a court established under the laws of the country. There are those who would make arguments about the deterrent effect of such punishments, and others who would argue just as vociferously that the deterrent effect is chimerical. Regardless of which side is ultimately correct, the punishment was meted out by the court with the goal of protecting society from the lawless. For more in this vein, check out Rousseau's "Social Contract".

The butchers you saw slaughtering the martyrs demonstrably are not interested in the rule of law, depsite their claims to the contrary. Further, they might say they've achieved the desired result: your revulsion. It would appear from your posting, however, that their belief in success is misplaced. Rather than your revulsion generating fear in your heart, or moving you to sympathy with their cause, it appears you are moved to anger. If that's the case, I again applaud you.

They are also demonstrating to their sympathizers their resolve and willingness to drive the infidel from their holy lands. I presume they believe this will increase their support base, particularly among the downtrodden. I'm afraid they may be right, but I'm equally convinced they must be eradicated or at the very least beaten down to the point where they pose no threat to civilization.

One of the reasons you, like most of us, can't fathom their motivation is because you know that the U.S. has a history of taking the first punch or two, then giving boxing lessons to the intellectually challenged ones who believed we were "too soft" to do anything about their misbehavior. There haven't been many of them that came back for a refresher course. The folks who took down the WTC, who bombed the USS Cole, who tried to take down the WTC in the '90s, who blew up the barracks in Saudi Arabia, the embassies in Africa, and the Marine barracks in Beirut, who rolled a wheel chair-bound man off the back end of a cruise liner at sea, are getting their lesson now. Because they're such slow learners, I don't believe there will be many of them left when school's finally out.

BTW, have you noticed they're starting to let hostages go now that several other countries have refused to play patty-cake with them?

-- Randy

by skidoggeruk

they enjoy it.

You have been watching snuff films. Nothing more nothing less. These people enjoy it. They can play it up anyway that they want to. They are just murderers.

I keep waiting for somebody to jump up and down to say that these people do not represent their theology. Looks like the French Muslims have finally stood their own ground. Will the rest of the Muslim community around the world?

This discussion is closed to new replies.