Discussion Locked

When is it proper to put that old hat back on?

0 helpful
19 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'm certain many of the more senior techs out there have run into the situation where they are called upon to perform duties they were once responsible for but have since moved on to other positions where it is no longer in their job description. I'm not talking about the casual can you help me with this as you're walking by someone's desk or when you see a co-worker is having difficulty with something you know is an easy fix, I'm talking about when you are asked if you can take on extra duties for an extended period of time to help out in a time of need; usually without extra compensation.

There are certain situations where it would be expected of you to help during a crisis and I personally would expect that of my employees; for instance, during our recent close encounter with a hurricane, I wouldn't have thought twice about getting right in there and doing whatever was necessary to get all the workstations and network back up, But what about when someone leaves a position with little or no notice? How about if a critical employee has a medical issue that requires them to be away from the office for a month or two?

In my case, I really liked my previous position (not that I don't like my current position) so it's more a matter of keeping me away from it rather than asking me to help out. Our Network Administrator will be unable to come to the office for a few weeks but she can do most of her job via VPN or remote connections but we all know, sometimes you just have to be there to push the buttons. So it goes through the chain of command, her boss goes to their superior, that person goes to my superior and he expresses his concerns about me taking too much time away from my duties to help out and is concerned about co-workers calling me more than they should when they could wait for the Network Administrator to deal with their issue remotely. I know the Network Admin is very capable of handling things remotely; that was my former position, I am currently manager of a different department with heavy IT requirements.

How do you deal with being asked to take on duties from your former position?

Edited because PurpleSkys said my grammar sucks :)

19 replies

by tink!

Working for small companies I tend to not have an official department or position. So I help out everywhere my skills could make me useful.

When I started my previous job everyone was trained through Reception no matter what position you were hired for. This was so anyone could back up Reception when necessary. In my later years there it seemed to become the norm that everyone new hired on went straight to their position and I trained new Receptionists. I also backed up Reception. Guess they were used to me being there every day.

Nowadays in my current job I hold whatever title fits the project I'm working on. Everything from Office Manager, Network Admin, to IT Manager. I don't mind at all. I'm not tied down to one specific job description. :)

by darryl~

It's much better than doing the same thing day after day! I wouldn't do well in a factory job.....small companies are good to work for....if they're stable ;)

by tony hopkinson

Personally I'd suggest you procedure up and get someone trained up to do the day to day bumf. You should have at least one person there who wouldn't mind experience in a junior admin role, or may be get a college studemt in or some such.
If you've got that sorted out you are effectively on call, there's no real way to predict the imapct of that and your other duties will suffer if it happens a lot. All you can really do is get the two managers to agree to an ongoing review of the impact.
The only way it's going to work is everybody goes out and reduces the impact, or they second you to the other department and anything that gets done on your current job is a bonus ball.

Whatever you do don't get set up to do everything, you end up not doing anything particulary useful and end up judged on that basis.

by darryl~

It's never good to have yourself spread too thin when it comes time for a performance review!

My situation is a little different...I'll get into that in a minute....I guess my thoughts were more focused on how others are required to deal with this type of situation.

My current position, Property Information Manager (GIS/Database) for the Municipality, would require me to do whatever to keep the Municiality up & running anyway....I'm always on call. I used to be Network Admin for a couple years & know the system well, the current Network Admin knows the system better than I could ever hope to (she built it....I filled her spot while the MIS manager was on leave & she was filling the manager position)....in our structure, the MIS manager is under one director & I'm under another so to follow proper protocol, the directors had to agree to allow me to be available....not that it would ever be an issue if I was needed....more like okay Darryl, if someone needs your help, go ahead and do it....but just don't let it take away from your other duties.

As for getting someone traind & ready for such a situation....well...you have to be careful when spending public $$$, as much as people think the municipal governments spend money on a whim, we really are aware of our budgets & the fact that it is the tax payers $$$ we spend.

Your comment about how it would impact my duties & that other areas may suffer was EXACTLY my director's concern.

Good response Tony :)

by tony hopkinson

You stop doing it, or you spend money on doing it better.

Short term thimble brain bean counter ideas like lets ask Darryl to do two jobs, always cost more in the long run. Especially when you consider that IT is the home of the permanently temporary and the temporarily permanent fix.

by deadly ernest

refused, so I did too. It isn't what they're paying you for now, you shouldn't be doing it, for many reasons - one of the most important reason being legal liability for anything that goes wrong and may even be loosely related to you doing that work. If it's NOT part of your proper duties you rarely have liability cover by the insurance companies.

by darryl~

I didn't think of that....for me it wouldn't be so much an insurance issue as it would be public accountability or accountability to council.

Very good point.

by deadly ernest

can sometimes lead to charges and time inside. A lot depends on what it is and what happened.

One case I know of from many years back the organisational policy was 'Only the person designated as a First Aid Officer may open the First Aid Cabinet and provide first aid treatment from the contents.' A person was injured and the FAO couldn't be found so someone else with a First Aid Instructor's Certificate treated the person. The person ended up having to claim compensation and the insurance company tried to get out of it by suing the treating person as they had acted against company policy. It took a long court case to get them to cough up, and it led to a change in the policy too.

........

On the other side I've seen a person sacked because they were found liable for damage to company property when they were told to cover the forklift driver's job for three days as no one else knew how to use the forklift. Since it wasn't part of his duties and some gear got damaged while he was using the forklift and some idiot walked across in front of the fork, causing him to swerve to make sure he didn't hit him, instead of waiting for him to pass. The government body that investigated industrial accidents, Worksafe, did their thing and said the forklift driver did the right thing to swerve as he couldn't see the person when they walked out so close to the load; but they also gigged the company for having a person operating the forklift when it wasn't on that person's duty statement. Higher ups fired the guy who caused the accident, the driver, and the manager who asked him to work the forklift.

If they'd amended his duty statement to include something about being a back up forklift driver then he'd have been OK.

........

Don't you love bureaucrats.

by darryl~

Well said Tony.

And I see it in a lot of departments throughout the municipality...and not just our municipality....the ones next to us also....there's a lot of staff moving around between the various municipalities & it seems someone is always short staffed & looking to fill a couple positions. In our case we don't really have enough work to have an assistant for the Network Admin (we're too small a municipality) plus we're a Novell network and there aren't many trained in Novell in this area...plus the fact that's it's only for a few weeks....to me it's not a big deal. But I do see it being practiced regularly in other businesses to "save money"...just like you said....they put off replacing vacant positions for 5 or 6 months just to increase the bottom line....I think it hurts them in the long run & is hard on the person trying to do 2 jobs.

by darryl~

But I beleive most union environments would prevent that from happening (I've never worked in one, so I'm unsure)...doesn't most union contracts prevent workers from crossing into a temp position to cover for a job not in thieir description? I'm not a big union supporter but I could see that as one area where it would be a benefit to the employee.

by tony hopkinson

If you are capable of operating efficiently as Manager and network admin, there is no job.

Artificially creating jobs will damage profit and there by threaten them all. Artificially reducing jobs with damage productivity, reducing profitability and thereby threaen them all.

Go to be balance, closed shops don't have it.

by deadly ernest

the trade unions is the rate of union membership in Australia is now under twenty percent with the majority of that in the over forty-five age group. The younger people aren't interested in the trade unions. As the union membership has dropped so have industrial disputes, mainly due to their lack of effect, partly due to legislative changes in work conditions.

Back in the 1960s, 1970s, and early 1980s we had a very high union participation rate and some very militant unions (still do, but not as many) that called a strike at the drop of hat, many being demarcation disputes - which pissed most people off. Many people got fed up with the way the unions were pushing the country and the economy, to the detriment of everyone except a select few in that union. This has resulted in a much more generalised dislike of unions.

As union membership has dropped, so has the number of unions as many were forced to amalgamate, cutting down on demarcation disputes. One union that used to be very militant through the 1960s to 1980s called a few strikes in the 1990s on purely political grounds and had less than five percent support amongst the workers; in fact, many the members resigned from the union over their calls for strikes to support political agendas as against work issues as the union was concentrating on the political support of the union owned political party and ignoring many workplace issues. Over five years that union went from eighty percent membership of workers to twenty-five percent membership of industry workers. That tend has been reflected across most industries in Australia.

Anyway, back to your point, the workplace legislation is more likely to affect the situation than union rules. And they do, in most cases, allow such matters. There are rules about driving forklifts and needing operator's licenses but they didn't apply in the case I mentioned.

by purpleskys

they either cross trained others to do a different job, or they had it put on paper and called it a temporary transfer if they wanted you to fill in for someone else in a different position...removes most liablities

by darryl~

I am not in a union environment and it is common for someone from the planning dept to be helping out on let's say they website or something....quite often, if someone needs assistance with something & there is someone knowledgable or qualified but in a different dept, they are asked to assist...and usually people are happy to do so.

by mjd420nova

Just in the past month I have been asked to take over the training module of the corporate location when the supposed certified trainer they hired couldn't achieve any results. His classes were unorganized and no one was learning anything. The students were unable to move on to their next blocks as they didn't have any of the previous material firmly implanted in their skills. Luckily, I've done this before and just last week after three weeks of classes, the VP gave me a pat on the back and a merit raise for exceeding his expectations. He said he's also be reviewing HR's programs used for screening applicants for open positions as it appears they were unable to select people with the proper skills for position placement. It has also given me a chance to brush up on some of my own skills and develop some new approaches to some of the advancements in technology that I've missed out on. The newer generation that are coming along have some interesting views and refreshing excitement for the industry in the future.

by darryl~

You did get rewarded both morally and monetarily and additionally were able to brush up on your skills at the same time....that worked out very well for you.

As Tony pointed out above, many times a company will require employees to take on extra duties while another employee is on an extended absence or a position becomes vacant with the sole intention of getting more production from their employees while decreasing their expenses; I believe this is happening more often during the current economic situation.

This discussion is closed to new replies.