Discussion Locked

when IT people deserve to be dead

0 helpful
42 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

general question folks - i have recently been between jobs and took a project management/admin job to pay the rent. The IT guy came around, waited until all the people were in a meeting, and deleted all the software off all machines (including licensed machines) he said he would re-install when he worked out what was going on) that didn't comply with company standards. People lost 3 years work on the project without warning and cursed all IT folks generally... (i can't blame them)

I asked him to set me up a personal profile (out of courtesy - I could have done it with my hands behind my back and blindfolded) in Win NT and he told me this was not possible!!! (I was sick of mapping my drives every day)

I got a real good insight into why people hate IT people at that moment and I am interested in what y'all have to say (given the amount of times we all complain about the general public and how they relate to IT people)

Cheers Mary

42 replies

by nick l

Like everywhere else in life, there are the good and the bad. Using the individual you mention is the same as Dr Shipman (serial killer in UK) as a reason for hating doctors, or child molestors as a death sentence on all priests.
As long as IT staff keep out of an "Ivory Tower" mentality and COMMUNICATE with their customers (NOTE: not "users") there should not be a problem.
People can be frightened of computers and IT staff need to "evangelise" the possibilities and not act as the cultish priests of some dark overlord - we all do sometimes!

by pallan

You have given an excellent description of why people hate working with morons, but it has little to do with IT people in general.

by feymary

I take your point but unfortunately - before i was an IT person (although I always was one before i even knew it) I got frustrated a lot by people condescendly telling me i wouldn't unserstand or it was too hard - I have done help desk (is it plugged in and is the power point turned on???) type work but am wondering if some sort of ethics standard would help to defer the kind abuse that is routine on a help desk with frustrated clients/people)

While I would give at least a day or 2 warning so people could make arrangements in the above scenario - its not the first time I have seen things happen this way - if IT people want to call themselves professionals - what standards should be set?

Should a code of ethics apply similar to other professions (which would allow the kind of people referred to in my original query)to be blasted elsewhere in the grand scheme of things?

M

by sparent

I think everyone should be given the benefit of the doubt.

I have worked in many capacities, including those illustrated in your messages.

A LAN administrator is typically a "lightning rod": every problem is imputed to the network, so it is therefore up to him/her to fix it! Because the nature of the work, requires them to be at various workstations, they are accosted during their travels with everyone's requests and complaints.

A tech support/help desk employee has to face a diversity of skill depths, as well as various emotional states, from the problem reporters. Effectively dealing with such an amalgam for extended periods is, at the very least, taxing.

These situational problems are not particular to any professional category: you can find examples in most of them.

What we need is not codes of ethics but a little bit of empathy and understanding!

Regards,
St?phane Parent

by ernie1aka

well i may agree with you on this but i think that IT guys need machines to break down so that they get jobs to do.... sounds dumb but true.

by ken selfridge

I have been on both sides of this particular fence. Some mandate is handed down from upper management to enact some change on their users' systems without consulting with or warning said users. The mandate, of course, is effective immediately. The technician tasked with the change is immediate stoned by the users as being "the cause of all the problems"...

Conversely, if the technical person operates in a management vacuum (i.e. he made this particular call), then I would agree that he/she has some communication and customer service issues.

::throwing his 2 cents on the pile::

Ken

by bklein

and every where in between.

Your IT person made *drastic* changes to your workstations without warning the users. This is stupid. He should be shot.

But...

People "lost" three years work on the project? I highly recommend you retreive the work you "lost" from the server on which it was stored. Or the tape backup. Or the server which replicated the server to which the tapedrive was attached. There - I gave you three posibilities which should always exist when it comes to missioncritical data. Not there? This is stupid. Everybody should be shot.

by andreas.blom

Well if people really are so stupid as to havin 3 year projects without saving their work on at least two different disks they actually should blame themselves.

Always save your work on a networkdrive that is regularily backed up!

Fire the bastard who deleted everything for gross negligence and for all in all being an ass!

by feymary

And he physically took the back-up server with him - I have never seen anything like it - he said he wanted no evidence of any file created with an unlisenced copy and ignored the hastily raised purchase orders etc

The only thing in his favour Ican say is that he was very thorough....

One guy emailed his files home when he caught on - another paranoid guy dumps everything on CD-rom regularly and hides them off-site - and a lap-top was overlooked (after being stored in a most unusal location) The regional office ave now decided to outsource their IT requirements which means he will be limited somewhat in what damage he can do in future.

And we did find some stuff he missed...

Cheers

by kidops

You just told us what the IT guy did but not why he did it. For all i care he might have warned u all a number of times before and when he notices u are using ur negligence to delay his job. He fires back.
But if the warning didn't come kick the guy out for overzealousness

by bryanb

I was thinking the same thing, there is no way in any laws of Networking should you store important data on a workstation.. and not backing up those data.. rediculious. I maybe new in the field but im not dumb. You can borrow my shotgun if you want!

by packratt

When a supposed IT professional does not perform his or her job professionally or is incompetent he or she should be exiled by the IT community and/or fired to avoid giving all true IT professionals a bad name.

I bet this person will not be fired, and it is likely that this person works at this company as a cost saving measure because the professionals who really know their stuff and are professional and ethical are just too expensive for management's taste. So they hired some cocky wannabe right out of training class at Skippy's School of IT and paid him something below market value.

Please, don't let this person and others like him give you the wrong idea about IT professionals. I'm sorry that this happened to you and your co-workers and hope that you have better luck in the future.

BTW, some time ago I talked about an IT guild that would hold professionals to standards and also hold companies to standards in the treatment of professionals. This solution would have prevented a problem like this, a problem that happens every day all over the world. A problem that gives those of us who do our best to be professional a bad name.

by jeff dray

What a great idea. We could set it up, I could run the UK chapter you Packratt could run the US side of the operation. then we could give up this IT thing and become wealthy union bosses and have people kneecapped for not paying their dues!
Startwith the person who asllowed the situation to arise where three years work was done and nothing implemented in all that time. All my critical files (novels in progress, techrepublic articles, humourous plays for radio, short stories, text books, training courses etc.) get copied onto CD once a week and that copy held in a fireproof box, and that's just my home system! They say there's nothing worse than a reformed smoker, maybe there iss and that's someone who lost all his data because they didn't do a backup

by packratt

I never said a union, this would be something quite different that would not have a dictatorship feel like unions and would have more open controls that would give the members more power colectively to avoid the problems associated with corrupt union bosses.

Yes, losing vital data is the fault of the user if the user was educated by the IT department. It sounds like the individual in this case had other problems understanding the technology he worked with and had an attitude problem to boot.

Come on, we all know about the ones who are out there. The ones that make us ashamed that they use the title "IT professional". The ones that we wish to slap around and teach them what's what. The ones that we would kick in the butt because of their pompus attitudes even when you try to teach them something for their own good and they think they know more than you. Then they go and screw something up when you told them how to do it right three times. Don't you hate that there are people out there like that who are giving you a bad name?

With that many users not doing any backups, it makes me think that it's the IT department's fault for not informing and motivating users to use backups or not having backups available to users. Ultimately it's the IT department's responsibility to push policies for sound computer and network usage to the company they support.

But, that's just my two rusty pennies.

by jeff dray

The crunch is that no-one wantsto payfor end userrs to get a proper briefing from the IT dept, neither does any company that I have ever worked for allow time to formulate proper induction procedures and policy updates. In short no one is told whatthey should and shouldn't do until they do it, or not.
Rusty pennies are still legal tender here in the UK

by karl

Whatever this clown thought was right in the UK he could have committed Criminal Offences. Although he may have had a right to remove illegally held programs he had no right to destroy the data that was the product of the programs. He may have rendered himself amenable to the Criminal Damage Act and in addittion the Computer Mis-use Act. This one sounds like a real jobs worth. You know "Its more than my jobs worth!". One for the bums rush I think!

Karl

by dan walton

After only reading half of the messages posted for this discussion, it starts to all sound the same, so pardon if I repeat what someone may have stated in the other half.

I have also been on both sides of the fence. Sometimes IT people (whether professionals or not) will get sick of explaining things to people. Sometimes people don't want technical details ("How does it work")- they only want to know "Can you fix it?". I like teaching my clients as much as I can about what is going on. I teach them how to setup an Outlook profile or how to configure their machines. I have found that in an environment like this, where the users are like little IT pros (I like to call them my mini me's), alot of the frustrations between administrator and end-user are quelched. Not only are there less problems because the clients are more informed, but they are more likely to be patient with whatever changes need to be made on the system. This establishes a solid relationship that makesthe image of IT Departments everywhere look much better. We don't have to be the cultish ogres of confusion and destruction like end-users sometimes see us. A little lamenology and alot of patience goes a long way folks.

As far as the gentleman who wiped everything goes, the only real explanation for this is that there had to be illegal activities going on at that company. Whether it be by the company, or by this "IT Professional". You said that he was very thourough, so he obviously knew what he was doing, right? Let's think about this; the guy didn't get fired. That must mean that the order came from somewhere higher in the chain of command. I think that says more about the company that you're working for than it says about the IT Department, don't you?

Dan

by robert defazio

People who work in IT are notorious for not caring what system users need. Too often they feel that users are stupid, uninformed, or negligent. Users, on the other hand feel that IT people are high-handed, suffering from a God complex, and socially ignorant.

The chemistry between the two is terrible, but it need not be so. If for no other reason that having a career path that leads up instead of down, everyone in a company should learn to articulate his position instead of shouting it. Persuasion through reason is a powerful tool in business. Customers buy from vendors that practice this technique, and the best companies REQUIRE it among their senior and mid-level staff.

Even the lowest ranking IT person should be able to stringtogether several sentences into one coherent paragraph that COMMUNICATES. When changes are to be made to systems, IT people should not only tell users that the changes will be made, but also what the users should do, why they should do those things, and what may happen if they don't do them. IT personnel should resist dictating when things will happen regardless of user preparedness. Remember, users (sales, engineering, customer service, and clerical) do all the things that lead to a paycheck for all.

User, however, should also remember that IT personnel are not fossilized remains of a feudal barony. They have good reasons for doing things the way they do them. Most users would throw their arms up in the air and run screaming from the building if they had to face for one single day the pressures that IT people have come to regard as normal job requirements. IT people bear heavy responsibility for the smooth operation of a business. This is not because IT people compelled business to use computers; it is because businesses chose to use computers, mostly without ever understanding just how temperamental they truly are.

by cscript

...is that we have ALL seen or heard of these types of things happening, anywhere you've worked. Thank goodness these are the exceptions, rather than the rule.
We all have horror stories (another topic?), we can look back on them and laugh, (or cry)
Chalk it up to being human and learning from your mistakes (to whatever level you want to take that)

by feymary

Yes folks the same guy - and the company has a strict policy about taking company data offsite which is fair enough given the line they are in - a leaked document could result int the loss of a contract/tender in excess of a billion.

oh well - can't win em all
cheers

by packratt

Sure, I could understand about the fear of data being put offsite, but what happens if a fire breaks out? Then all your data is lost forever with no hope of recovery. That is why companies put backups offsite in rotations, to keep data safe.

See,while it may be an IT department's duty to support the user, thereby inform the user, it is also the IT professional's responsibility to advise the management on good and sound policy and procedure in the delivery and protection of said data.

Yet, as always, it is ultimately the responsiblity of management at the highest level to ensure that the company has the best IT staff it can get and to heed the advice of the professional or take it into consideration and then to back the IT departmentas well once policy is made.

It seems to me that while your IT person may be a bad fit, it is ultimately the management's fault.

Good luck.

by paulin

Not that there aren't plenty of user-friendly, automatic back-up devices, servers, and software, and its not that there isn't plenty of security features to keep users from installing and using less-than-company-approved software, and its not that there are no procedures to prevent users from themselves or removing the temptation from IT-wanabees, but sometimes bad things have to happen in order to expose problems and lead to better actions in the future.

Thank you for playing...

by generalist

I've always assumed that it is possible to delete the software without deleting the data when you're running well designed packages. At the same time, too many software packages seem to save their data in subdirectories that are children of the software package's main directory. (Unless, of course, you override them.)

If the IT person didn't know this little tendency, then he is not fit for his job. (Could it be that he is supposed to be a 'hard nosed anti-software piracy policeman' in this case?)

At the same time, the people who lost the data should consider setting up non-package dependent directories for their data. This makes things a heck of a lot easier to back up.

by uncle_alien

It would appear that this particular encounter with the species "IT-iredescedumb" was living in a vertically driven environment. Having been there I know I was correct in doing whatever I thought to be necessary because it could not possibly affectanyone adversly. And what I nice set of blinders I have on. (As the gun lies smoking in my right hand I draw upon my left handed cigarette and continue...). But living in a horizontally structured business you soon learn that what you do does have an effect on other peoples karma. And learning to think horizontally, vs vertically, is challenging. Especially in todays heterogenous enviroments. But a good challenge in my view. Perhaps even an opportunity. Mmmmm, think I'll roll another.

by bgjkl

I was an admin at one point, and now am on the development side. Some IT folks give me the same feeling you had, mainly because being an admin myself, I know when I'm being snowed. I am also currently on a project that has been stalled for weeks as admins make mountains out of molehills. I am not allowed security to the server I am supposed to be installing software on. (approved project and nothing else on it).
On the other side of the coin, when I was an admin, an incident occured where accountants were using 'illegal software' to perform accounting functions for the company. (as opposed to the official software stored on the mainframe).
When we were audited by an agency we all dread, on the mainframe files...the company got fined 20% of an entire years profit for the mainframe not tying out to reports officially filed.
After that, I was sent on the same mission that you are talking about, and to boot, everyone found with illegal software was called into the personnel office. (it was totally against company policy that you have to read and sign prior to being issued computer equipment).
If you were using software that at some point the IT dept of the company sanctioned, these people are nuts....but if it is something someone outside of IT put in on their own, the above is the reason IT departments do that. They do have to answer to someone when the example above occurs,when confidential info leaks becuase of inadequate security, or data is lost because it is not backed up.

by molecule man

What you imply is that some machines had licensed software installed and some did not! Apparently someone got a clue and realized that using questionable software is, at the least, unethical/sleazy and quite possibly illegal. We've all seen this -one user has a package that is shared with other staff, in violation of the licensing agreement or management is too cheap to acquire the product/licenses legally. So the IT person [probably one of these posters who feel that no education but 'computer savvy' is enough to function in the real world and should qualify for big money] is tasked to remove the offending software but without a clue or guidance as to how this should be done. Staff, who've been using the packages scream but refuse to accept any of the ample blame for the situation. So staff uses software they shouldn't, tech person removes the software without warning or explanation, and no one accepts any responsibilty.
How very American, blame evryone else for the situation. Oprah is waiting to tell your sad tale.

by dylan teo

Molecule, I believe the IT manager or security personnel should be informed of the violation without having the support person deleting everything on the PC.

I believe the IT manager could be informed or the IT personnel could send a warning email to the person, their erspective managers and cc the IT manager before taking such drastic action.

IF the follow-up found that the offending software is still there without a license then it justify the action of erasing it. Otherwise, this person has just created a problem of lost man-hours and the laborious task of replacing the 3 years of data.

Any IT personnel would have the common sense to recognise that business is their pay-master. If business fail, support personnel get the falling axe first.

by hotzmiller

This sounds as if Mr. IT had something personal to hide, perhaps he's been naughty himself and is going overboard to cover his tracks. He is really out of control. Doesn't he have a supervisor?

I'm not usually one for excessive hyperbole, but, if all is as you say, firing is too good for him - a beating may be warranted here.

Getting on topic, there is problem in the IT field of persons being hired who are underequipped in nearly every way other than ego, where they try to make up for the lack. These individuals are good at sales and self promotion, which impresses the non-technical dupes who hire them. Employers beware - the IT guy we are all appalled with will have his smashing good resume in your inbox soon.
---Skip

by kim2786

It is true that Some ITs Professional are very rude and they think they know everything. I am also an IT professional and make me sick to see how they treat people outside IT field. But there are also IT profession that are really professional.

by jennyred

Depending on what the company polcies are, what his position was, and what the exact circumstances were, he could either have been doing what he thought was right (if he had been told that there was going to be an audit of software licenses that day, for example, and was afraid of piracy) or could have been going off half cocked.

I say give people the benefit of the doubt, until management has determined whether their actions are justified or not. If they back him up, it's really their faultfor not being more specific or sane about the licensing policy. If not, then they will hopefully fire the ignorant SOB! Either way, I wouldn't prejudge his actions until I knew the whole story.

by jennyred

IT will now be outsourced? How will that solve the problem if policies are not established to deal with this sort of thing? It could just make things worse, actually, because they may be even more ill-informed. The company needs to secure its data, and make sure that site licenses are put into place. It sounds like this dude was probably totally off his rocker if he thought that data generated from unlicensed products needed to be destroyed. However, who is is boss, and what did this boss say about what he did? If he was following orders, then the person who gave the orders has some explaining to do. If he made these decisions unilaterally, he should be fired. End of story.

by dylan teo

Outsourcing is not a solution here. This is very obviously a personnel attitude problem. If there is a security branch then these policemenn should educate emplouees about license violation.

IT managers almost always think of security as prevention of hackers and stolen information. BUt in my view, license violation is also a security problem which management should get actively involved.

The IT person in this case has over-stepped his/her jurisdiction by deleting the files. This person may have crippled a vital part of the business cycle.

The IT procedure needs a review of such actions. Hopefully they can make amends and prevent actins from recurring.

by larry rutherford

Where's the Change Management process? Where?s notification and approval from the customer at least 48 hours in advance? These are fundamental Departmental (if not Company) wide processes that must be adhered to. The IT dude might have just been following orders but, sounds like he does need some Internal Customer Service training.
Here?s a good one:
We were getting ready for Y2K and found that about 100 of our desktops needed a BIOS upgrade. We used someone from our IT Foundations Group (college kids hired in to train in future IT positions). Simple job: go to the person?s desk, insert this floppy and reboot. Soon after he took off we started getting calls to the helpdesk. ?I went to lunch and now my machine won?t boot?. ?Some strange guy was at my desk and now the computer is broke?. ?I?ve got some strange looking guy at my desk right now and he is telling me he needs to work on my computer. I told him to get lost because I heard what he already did to another computer!?
I took off running and stopped him. ?What are you doing man? When the first computer broke why didn?t you tell someone?? ?I told the customer to call the helpdesk and went on to the next one.? GEEEZZZ?
I took a bad butt cutting on that one as it was my project! Next time I did it right with notification and approval from the customer prior to sending someone out to the desk. Plus, got someone with the common sense enough to handle the job?.

by uncle_alien

leads me to believe a hoax is afoot. Is this a psychological study of pavlovian proportions or was I born yesterday?

by cjb3

IT people have been walking all over the "stupid users" for as long as IT has been able to think they don't work for a boring old (retail/service/etc.) company. As long as their goals are allowed to diverge from and supercede the business goals, we'll hate IT. Fire them - computers are not that complicated. My kid uses them.

by dylan teo

It is the "stupid users" that helps pay our salaries and keeps our job. Take note that their incompetenece helps create the demand of the IT industries.

by generalist

Personally I am fully aware that IT is a service function whose purpose in the universe is to help their users/clients do the best job possible. That's why I try to avoid the 'stupid' user mindset.

In many instances 'stupid' users are often untrained, improperly trained or simply forgetful. Complex programs, infrequent program use and lack of detailed knowledge can make anybody look dumb.

Then you have the quality of training. Ideally the user should be so comfortable with a program that they can teach others how to use it. Unfortunately, a lot of IT training doesn't get a user to that comfort level. As a result, little things go wrong and some IT people consider this to be an indication of 'stupidity'. (Imagine if a 'stupid' lawyer were to try to teach an IT person how to write a case brief using a similar degree of training. In that case, the IT person would be the 'stupid' user.)

Of course there are the people who are either malicious or unable to do anything that involves computers or complex actions. These people have other problems and should just be kept away from computers, unless those computers use bullet proof software and hardware.

by gomes

Like all lucrative professions, IT industry has attacted alot of non-IT talented people into the field. Its getting hard to find natural IT people - who are damn good at what they do because they have a true interest in it. Its just like the medicaldoctors. Its so hard to find one that really knows what they're doing. After all like in IT, many people become doctors for the money not because they are interested in the field. If they are, they become damn good doctors.

In IT, its even easierto jump into the band wagon. One can double their salary within six months by just doing an IT course that costs < $3000. No wonder there are so many "lousy" IT people out there. So, I agree if you get frustrated as users because you are being serviced by these non-IT people whos in it for the bucks.

Ivan Gomes.
IT consultant - for interest sake not money's sake.

by dylan teo

Ivan is right about the situation. Especially in SIngapore, asian view IT a lucrative market that is easy to tap. Many IT people here tout a Computer degree and expected to be well paid without putting in much effort.

To make matters worst, certification has been made into a money spinner for many companies. I do not think certification is not necessary. But quality control is required. Many MCSE or CNE are either students or people without IT experience but would like to join the band wagon.

The shortest, easiest way is certification, these people I term as "paper sharks". Intimidating to look at but sharks without teeth (So they can't bite).

Certification should review the situation and place certain limiting criteria before allowing non-IT personnel to be certified

by hotzmiller

I entered IT as a total career change. I'd like to be characterized as one of those people who doubled their salary in six months, but I'm not. I started out in an entry level position, which I held for 18 months. My salary was 30k. When my company began to fold I left and got a slightly higher level responsibility position - my salary moved up to 36k.
I've been at job #2 for about 15 months. I've now achieved my CCNA, and feel I am truly competent in the requirement for that certification (ie - I learned stuff, not just crammed for the test). My friends tell me I'm going to double my salary now. Where?? My current employ has little room for advancement. Every IT job I see that pays well has a list of requirements longer than my arm. I might meet a third to a half of them. It seems to me I need to master at least two NOS's, SQL, MS Exchange admin, every desktop application, be a adequate programmer, network designer, troubleshooter, hardware setup and more just to be considered competent. My assessment is I'm more likely to get a $45 - $50k job now if I jump ship.

I don't particularly mind being resented by a few coworkers if I double my salary to 75 or 80K. Please advise. I am well behind the six months doubling rate - perhaps I ought to be earning about $150k by now. Where are all the pricey jobs for people with little experience?

by dylan teo

Mary,

I believe the IT person you worked with has an attitude problem.In many cases, there are specific guidelines in which IT support personnel are to inform and gice time to users of any changes.

If the PCs do not comform to corporate standards, due notice has to be given and a schedule set to delete the files. Thus work will not be lost.

In your case, management has to be informed as IT personnel is to support the business not destroy it. It this instance, the lost of information and time and labour is too costly to the organsization.

This person puts all professional IT personnel in a bad light but rest assured. He do not represent all IT people, most IT people I know are great people and some come with a sense of humour which makes working with them enjoyable.

by feymary

Thanks to all who chipped in and please bear in mind I was not in the best of moods when I initially posted (try incoherent rage) - hence the (er) rather provocative title...

To update/clarify.
1. there was no warning ever.....
2. He deleted the offending software (I have no problem with this) but also did a search on all files with an extension that matched the software and deleted those too.
3. He controls the back-ups - alot of them went.
4. He deleted all the manager's files as well (suicidal or egalitarian - you be the judge)
5. He didn't read the lisence first which allowed for multiple copies of the email programme associated with the software even with one lisence.
6. As a consequence everybody's address books vanished overnight.
7. It was a genuine oversight and the money was paid to the vendor within 48 hours. At the end of the day over half the copies had full lisences and he deleted them all as well as the files they created - (let God sort it out)
8. he is theIT manager - he has a degree but
not a lot of experience and was following a checklist.
9. He has received a written warning and 'counselling'
10. I got to be a hero by restoring address books via back-ups he had missed and some files he had also missed as well as re-setting up profiles for all - they want me back in a month or so - we are still talking money. Jack of all trades (general fixer) job - my speciality.....

So there you go - every cloud has a silver lining and its up to Mr IT Manager if he heeds the warnings or not. Part of the function has been outsourced (ostensibly) due to geographical difficulties (he got off a plane and wreaked his havoc) - up to him what he makes of it.

Again thanks for the comments - some useful stuff i am pitching to management about how they can prevent this in the future etc - really thanks!!

Cheers feyM

This discussion is closed to new replies.