Discussion Locked

When to "copy and paste" and whento link

0 helpful
2 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi,

The TechRepublic guidelines dont mention plagarism in our answers.

My personal view is that its absolutely ok. We're trying to help people and that is what's important - but personally, I always try to provide the link to the original article it came from.

My question is... How much cutting and pasting is too much? At what point is it better to simply provide the link to the relevent article?

I've seen answers where the cut and paste extends over many comment sections...

Doesanyone have any thoughts on this?

Cheers,
Tim.

2 replies

by petemcc

I agree Tim, there is a lot of copy'n'paste going on- not just here but at any tech forum you may look in on, and it's usually pretty obvious.

When I include info lifted directly from another source I like to at least put it in quotes and name the source, if not provide a link.

I think to just paste line after line of text shows a certain lack of respect for both the source and for the questioner (who after all, must be tech savvy on some level or wouldn't be subscribing to a forum like this).

That doesn't mean I don't think it's OK within reason- after all, the information is there to see for anyone with the ability to do an informed search. I mentally roll my eyes when I see a big post that's obviously straight from a MS article.

by c1980

In most cases, if I found an answer in a Kb or something, then I will reference that link - unless I feel that the person who asked the question may have trouble understanding, or if the article is just too long - then I will not only ref. the link,but also cut and paste parts of the article or re-word the article.

Yes, one great value of TR is it's wealth of knowledge. When I do a search to find something, I enjoy being able to see right then and there a possible solution - like a knowledgebase and not just an INDEX to a Kb. And, instead of sending someone an e-mail with my solution, I prefer copying my code or text my answer.

Your right - there is a limit. If takes more than 4K to explain, and there isn't a link, then maybe someone should offer it via e-mail to anyone who asks - but maybe people don't want to do this.
I have at times pasted code of mine that took 2-3 comments to show everything. But it was code that I felt many could take advantage of.
But, that's one thing, and Copy/Paste from another source, is another thing - If it is short and can be done with-out a comment page, and the source gets credit, then, with-in reason why not?

This discussion is closed to new replies.