.
Would Colorado's proposed amendment 36 help John Kerry or George Bush? The answer is yes - and no. (I know, that answer doesn't make sense.)
Who's behind Colorado's proposed amendment 36? We all know the old saying "follow the money", and following this money is interesting. Are the Republicans behind it? Absolutely not. Are the Democrats behind it? Well, yes and no. Is the Democrat Party behind it? No. Is a Democrat activist acting outside the party behind it? Yes. Do the Republicans support it? No. Do the Democrats support it? Well, yes and no. Some Democrat leaning activist groups are in favor of it, but the Democrat candidate for the U.S. Senate, Ken Salazar, is opposed to it, as is his Republican opponent, Pete Coors.
Well then who's behind Colorado's proposed amendment 36? It was extremely interesting several months ago when no one could answer that question? The state Democrat Party and Republican Party offices couldn't answer it, and it was a mystery for some time. It was literally a "stealth" proposal, and no one would "own up to it".
We've now learned that the funding for the effort to get this proposed amendment on the ballot comes from one person by the name of Jorge Klor de Alva, a California resident (from Brazil) and a business executive who heads a firm called Apollo International, which is linked to Apollo Group, parent company of the University of Phoenix. The founder of the Apollo group is Dr. John Sperling, who has been a major Democratic donor, giving thousands of dollars to candidates from John Kerry to Howard Dean. Klor de Alva has contributed to the campaigns of two Democratic congressional candidates.
Why Colorado, and why did this "outsider" spend millions of dollars to get this proposed amendment on the ballot? Well, the answer to the question "why this ballot measure" is obvious if you consider that in 2000, had Colorado's 8 (at the time) electoral votes been split, then 5 would have gone to Bush (instead of all 8), while 3 would have gone to Gore - and the election, with those 3 votes, as a result, would have gone to Gore. Okay, there's the motive. And at the time, it was probably assumed that Colorado would go to Bush in 2004.
However, Colorado is a rather independent thinking state, it has elected both Democrat and Republican governors in recent years, and has gone to both the Democrat and Republican candidates. So if John Kerry, for example, wins Colorado, which is certainly within the realm of possibility, and the amendment were to pass, then Colorado's current 9 electoral votes would be split 5-4, with 4 going to Bush - which could hurt Kerry. And even though Colorado goes to the Republican candidate more times than not, it could go either way in 2004. No party has consistently won Colorado by huge margins; and Colorado did, after all, go to Bill Clinton in 1992, being supported by the state's Democrat Governor, Roy Romer, at the time.
The answer to the question, "why Colorado" is not so obvious to people living outside the state, but as clear as a bell to most of the state's residents (and other politically aware individuals). Two states in the union, California and Colorado, have election laws such that it's very easy to get just about any measure on the ballot. If enough signatures are gathered on enough petitions, and in Colorado it only takes about a hundred thousand, there could be a ballot measure to place a tax on people who own certain kinds of dogs; there could be a ballot measure to close Wal-Marts on Sunday; or there could be a ballot measure to target a tax increase to a particular group of people, smokers, for example (yes, there is).
That's why the nation has heard so much about those California ballot measures, referendums, proposed amendments, and so on. Colorado is in the same ballot boat as California. Personally, I don't care for it, as it makes for a more direct democracy, which can be extremely dangerous, instead of a representative democracy. But why did this California resident pick Colorado instead of his home state of California? Because California's 55 electoral votes are all but guaranteed to go to the Democrat, and he wouldn't want those to be divided lest ~20 more electoral votes would go to the Republican presidential candidate.
This proposed amendment just doesn't pass the stink test. There's even a political commercial running in the state that shows both the Democrat AND the Republican Senatorial candidates, Ken Salazar and Pete Coors, voicing their opposition to it. And all the state's major newspapers have voiced opposition to it. Especially this year, when Colorado is an "in-play" state, and it could go to either Bush or Kerry, neither party wants to risk losing, what could be, 4 very valuable electoral votes, and ones that could determine the winner. Right now it looks as though the proposed amendment will fail by a pretty big margin. The latest polls show that it is failing by about a 65 to 35 percent margin.
But if it does pass, by some fluke of miracles, you can be sure to see the party effected, whether that be Democrat or Republican, file a court challenge - especially if the electoral vote tally is like it was in 2000 where those 4 votes would determine the winner. (Oh no, not again.) What are the grounds for a court challenge (by either party)? First of all, both the state and federal constitutions specifically provide that the manner in which the state's electoral votes are assigned will be up to the state legislators. Moreover, this proposed amendment, if passed, would be applied retroactively to the 2004 election, and not just for future elections.
So, like I said, this proposed amendment just doesn't pass the stink test, and leaders of both major parties know it. I predict it will fail 70-30 percent.