Discussion Locked

Which company has had the best impact on IT?

0 helpful
108 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The TechRepublic poll question for the week of 9/26/2005 is "Which company do think has had the best impact on the use of information technology over the past two decades?
Apple
Microsoft
Google
Cisco Systems
IBM"

Let us know which company you chose and why. Or, if there's a different company that you would choose, name that company and explain why you think they had the best impact.

108 replies

by bfilmfan

Cause they create all the packaging boxes with logos that the computers come in.

A close second is Inland-Temple Paper cause they make the paper that we print reams of in the "paperless offices."

by seahawkblue

Next time we look at a "tree" We should thank Microsoft, Every E-Mail, all White papers save a tree . Hats off to microsoft!

by tony hopkinson

get printed out for discussion, or they are from the unfit bloke two cubicles down. In fact they are why we have a rep for being anti-social propeller heads, who carnt splel.

by jdmercha

Assuming we really mean "Best". Bell labs is the winner, hands-down.

But if we really mean "biggest" then Microsoft edges out IBM.

by surflover

After all, the icon based interface that we ALL use to drive our workstations, Windows, mac, Xwindows, etc. (and having begun my career with punch cards I am very greatful for :-)... was invented by Xerox... (they just couldn't figure out how to sell it)

by hal 9000

They let the others in to see what they had invented on a Unix system with 1,000 workstations sharing everything including CPU usage which is still something that we have yet to reach.

Xerox single handedly managed to snatch defeat out of imeniate world domination by not proceeding with the Lida project.

Col ]:)

by absolutely

And if everybody didn't already have their own PC at home, a lot of sysadmins would have very different typical days. I'm not sure that making these things affordable for everybody has been responsible for a single improvement in quality of life for anybody.

by robroynj

Absolutely, I couldn't agree more.

When I started, IT was MIS but that's beside the point. My work was very contained, challenging, but I could go home at a decent hour, and I worked with a limited group of well trained end users.

The difference was that most of the company had no use for the systems and those that did have a use, knew how to use them!

While I can't point to a single company, the internet has changed work more significantly than any single company. When I think about what we used to do to get any data from our business partners it floors me to look at the systems we now have in place.

The good news, I can monitor my systems from almost anywhere. The bad news, I monitor my systems from almost anywhere.

by surflover

So far no one has opted for the short list you provided... And there is a long list of innovative companies (many gone by the wayside) that could be mentioned as well...
Univac, Burroughs, GE -> Honeywell, DEC, EMC, etc.

I'm not sure any company had the "best" impact on IT... But as one of the posts eludes to, having PCs as ubiquitous as they are, has certainly had a profound (and not always positive) impact on society.

by apotheon

Out of the options provided, Microsoft is so far winning by a landslide in poll percentages. I'm thinking that most of the people answering either don't know anything about the IT industry or don't know what the word "best" means.

I agree with many of the posters to this thread, that it was places like PARC, Bell Labs, and others that [b]have had[/b] the "best" impact on the IT industry, but the phrasing of the question is only [b]has[/b]. This implies that the influence in question still exists and is still ongoing. I guess you need to pick something a little more current to satisfy the phrasing of the question. On the other hand, Microsoft surely shouldn't be it, for any definition of "best" that I've ever seen.

How about the Wikimedia Foundation, the Open Source Initiative, or even Novell? Nobody crucify me for this one before you stop to think about all the ramifications: What about SCO?

Yes, SCO. Nothing in the last few years has done as much to legitimize open source software than for SCO to take an ill-advised run at stealing from users of open source software, prompting several IT industry giants to slap SCO back down and demonstrate once and for all that OSS is relevant and important to the IT industry. I guess SCO's bloody sacrifice was a good thing, all things considered.

by apotheon

No other company has done as much to reduce the practice of security in IT. We're all aware of it, and very few of us are practicing it.

by charliespencer

Perhaps if the word "Most" had been substituted, this question would make more sense. In that case, I'd have to go with IBM for their sheer longevity in the field and their history of successfully marketing a variety of hardware platforms.

by apotheon

I would tend to think that "best" would indicate a positive impact:

broadening our options rather than restricting them

advancing innovation rather than oppressing it

increasing options rather than decreasing them

improving technologies rather than corrupting them

contributing to success rather than stealing it

encouraging knowledge rather than obscuring it

diversifying capabilities rather than monopolizing them

enabling educators rather than straightjacketing them

symbiosis with our industry rather than parasitizing it

and, finally, making our profession enjoyable, rather than sucking the life out of it.

by charliespencer

I don't know where you're seeing these poll percentages. Is there vote page or graphic I don't know how to find? In the posted comments, only one person favorably mentions MS.

by apotheon

There is indeed a voting page: the main page of the site. Click the TechRepublic banner/log at the top of the page, then scroll down until you find the "Question of the week". If you vote there, it takes you to the poll results so far.

Of course, I didn't bookmark the page with the results, so I'd have to vote again to find it at this point and see if the results have changed any.

by jaqui

about accpac? for thier infamous accounting package.
autodesk, for thier industry standard Drafting app?

break it into industry, and you can pick a software company that has had a major effect on how the industry does business.

get google out of the list, it's only been around for 7 years so doesn't meet the 20 year requirement.
( 7th birthday today. )

by apotheon

I don't think the question was meant to specify that the impact in question had to last more than 20 years, but rather that it had to occur within the last 20 years.

by robroynj

Thinking about this more I must vote for IBM

1. It is the granddaddy of all IT companies.
2. It was instrumental in supporting Linux
3. It introduced the corporate PC and legitimized its use in business settings
4. It supports multiple OSes - OS390, Unix (AIX), Windows, linux, AS400, etc.
5. It plays in hardware, software, and services spaces.
6. It has an amazingly good R&D group
7. For most, but not all, of its life as a company it has been a leader in the industry.

You may not like them, you may not use them, but I have a hard time denying them their place at the top.

by waldon

All of the other players have certainly added on, but maybe most IT people are too young to know the history. We are also a society that likes the latest hot new thing.

by surflover

Eniac was the first electronic computer (1945)...

the US ARMY and the University of Pennsylvania began it's creation on June 5, 1943, and it was placed in operation at the Moore School, beginning with the cycling unit and an accumulator in June 1944... followed by the initiating unit and function tables in September 1945 and the divider and square-root unit in October 1945. Final assembly took place during the fall of 1945... IBM, while founded in 1911, didn't get into the computer business until 1950 (although some claim they began R&D in 1946), and Univac built the first mass produced computer (the Univac I) in 1951... IBM Joined them a few years later.

by tony hopkinson

were well before IBM. The first practical application of IT was probably the Jacquard loom. Pop over to the Smithsonian they used to have one.

by jaqui

the abacus.
the first adding machine.
since a computer is nothing but a fancy adding machine. ( works really really fast, but it only adds and subtracts numbers. )

by dc guy

Apple recognizes a fact that is heresy for us in IT: Most of the people on earth are NOT like us. We design computer hardware and software for other computer geeks: people who have the time, interest, aptitude, and resources to learn how the stuff works and to become their own help desk.

Regular people don't want to think about their computers. They expect to turn it on, accomplish whatever they had in mind while not having to think too terribly hard about it, turn it off, and go away. Maybe two or three times a year it needs professional maintenance, and an occasional repair.

Sort of what they expect from their family car.

Can you imagine what it would be like driving to work if the people you designed and built your car thought you were one of THEM? If you were expected to be able to fiddle with your fuel injector or adjust your own brakes? That's what computers are like to the six billion people on Earth who are not "one of us."

Apple knows that eventually those six billion people will be able to buy computers, and they will not want to have anything to do with the Windows/PC architecture.

Frankly I'm a little concerned with their attitude about the internet itself. It too appears to have been built by programmers for programmers. It might be up for a major rearchitecture once it reaches places like Ingushetia.

by maxwell edison

.
It's your choice of the word "best" that makes me think you are baiting people.

Considering that the impact made by the Internet can be best illustrated by considering the mere numbers of people using it, one might conclude that Microsoft has been the impetus behind those people using their computers, thereby using the Internet. (And if it wasn't Microsoft, it surely would have been another company; but Microsoft, for better or worse, was the company with the right product at the right time with the right plan.) And Microsoft has the pure numbers to put it clearly at the top of the list. I'd like to know of another company that went from nothing to a market value of 300 billion in only 20 years, an Internet company or otherwise. Cisco, for example, has a value that's less than half that of Microsoft.

And then you go and use a word like "best" around a bunch of computer geeks.

Okay, out of your list, I'd say Microsoft is the clear winner, as it's allowed the "average" person to easily use their computers and the Internet; and without those numbers of people, the Internet wouldn't be what it is today. And I'd say Cisco for their initial impact on the hardware development that made the Internet infrastructure possible in the first place.

But the BEST Internet company, without a doubt, is .......... TechRepublic.

(Do I get those cookies now?)

by apotheon

In terms of Internet connectivity, Microsoft was very late to the game. The initial Internet infrastructure was the fault of DARPA and a couple of university research groups. The continuing Internet infrastructure was (and is) largely the fault of companies like ICANN and technologies like POSIX-compliant unices. The explosion of Internet activity amongst the hoi polloi is pretty much all the fault of the World Wide Web, invented by Tim Berners-Lee at CERN, implemented using software development technologies found on the now-defunct NEXTstep operating system (which was created under the direction of Steve Jobs), and brought to the United States by particle physicist Paul Kunz. The fact that Microsoft has made a (moral equivalent of) killing off the whole thing doesn't in any way indicate that Gates' racketeering organization is in any way responsible for the technologies' widespread implementation and advancement.

In fact, the only Web browser Microsoft has ever had, Internet Explorer, is built on the codebase of the Spyglass Mosaic browser, which Microsoft didn't even license for use until 1995. By then, there was already a thriving commercial web browser market (in which Spyglass Mosaic was an almost entirely unknown bit player). Microsoft didn't promote Web usage: it just ate up the market share of others, then squatted on its market dominance share and collected the Web userbase that naturally accumulated over time. I even remember in early '97 that Netscape was still the best browser available, and pretty much every PC or Mac available had Netscape on it by the time anyone bothered to use it.

Maybe we should add the Wikimedia Foundation to the list instead of Microsoft, for making the main body of human knowledge accessible to everyone with a Web browser and an Internet connection.

by jaqui

but it was billy and his minions that, with thier marketing behemouth, were able to push the drive for widespread internet usage.
if it hadn't been for them, the internet would still be very much for it pros only.

~sigh~
wouldn't that be nice? no spam, no virus threats, no phishing...

by maxwell edison

You didn't really understand my message, at least I don't think you did. Moreover, I think you are too emotionally involved to offer a rational observation. There are SO many people, and I presume you are one of them, who are so anti-Microsoft, that they're actually swayed by their opposition to the company.

Anyway, I've always avoided pro-Microsoft versus anti-Microsoft discussions, just like I avoid the religious discussions, and this one will be no exception.

by absolutely

I disagree with the premise "that the impact made by the Internet can be best illustrated by considering the mere numbers of people using it, one might conclude that Microsoft has been the impetus behind those people using their computers, thereby using the Internet." End users without a clue of the vulnerabilities of the technology they use have made identity theft, child pornography, and anonymous acts of vandalism far easier to commit than they were when the Internet was the province of military commnunications specialists, IT professionals with large businesses, and technically skilled academic researchers. Those were not what confidence men would call suckers. The bulk of today's web surfers probably are easy targets to even amateur troublemakers. By popularizing the Web before securing it, Microsoft has enabled criminals to violate more citizens' privacy, enticed honest people to mingle with the worst the world has to offer, and obscured productive tools like Lexis-Nexis by making fluff entertainment even MORE available than it already was, Microsoft has secured its place as the company that has performed the widest act of destruction with IT. And in case anybody thinks I'm an anti-Microsoft "zealot", I support their right to sell crap to everybody who will buy it, and even to offer discounts to resellers who will install their crap and not Netscape.

Caveat Emptor.

by maxwell edison

And McDonalds has defined "fast-food", for better or worse, and regardless of how stupid fat people are because they eat at McDonalds six times a day.

The fact remains that Microsoft is to Information Technology as McDonalds is to fast-food ..... and as Starbucks is to la-de-da coffee shops ..... and as Wal*Mart is to discount shopping ..... and so on. And just because you may not like it doesn't make it any less of a fact.

by surflover

I worked a bit on the DARPA project Arpanet in the late 70's writing communications drivers for TCP/IP... There was frequent debates about the 4 class address scheme in those days... the "grey hairs" told us "pups" that the world would never have a need for more computers that that... we felt otherwise :-)...

by apotheon

I disagree quite a lot. If it wasn't for Gates and Co., the Internet would be no less the force it is now, but it wouldn't all be seen through the narrow apertures of IE and OE. I suspect we'd see more embedded Internet-enabled technologies, more networking tech that you don't really notice, instead of some of this very self-consciously conspicuous "New Technology" we're seeing now. It's true that the average individual wouldn't be as [b]aware of[/b] the Internet in his or her life, I think, but would probably actually be making at least unconscious use of it more often. I think Tivo-like technology would be about three years older than it is, for instance, and things like Internet radio would probably be far more prevalent. These things would simply not likely be as commonly implemented by way of the PC on your desk.

The Web, on the other hand, probably [b]would[/b] be mostly reserved for the IT pro and enthusiast.

by charliespencer

I know, it's a government agency, not a company. apotheon reminded me of our use of taxpayer dollars. But without it, no Internet, no WWW, no Google, no Amazon, no E-Bay, no e-commerce, no e-mail, no IM, no VOIP, etc.

Of course, we all know Al Gore invented the Internet.

by apotheon

Let's say it's Al Gore! He's sorta like a company unto himself anyway.

DARPA doesn't qualify by the "last two decades" standard, unfortunately. They haven't had a helluva lot to do with Internet development lately, in comparison to private enterprise.

by maxwell edison

Some companies helped make the Internet what it is today; and I think Cisco, for example, is one of them. Other companies became what they are today because of the Internet; and I would put google into that category. And I believe the distinction should be made.(I know, DARPA is not a "company.)

Besides, the original question asked about IT, Information Technology, not just the Internet.

by apotheon

"[i]I think you are too emotionally involved to offer a rational observation.[/i]"
. . . the last defense of someone that doesn't have a real argument is to attack the psychological underpinnings of someone else's decision to disagree.

by maxwell edison

.
I'm defending nothing.

I'm defending nothing; I'm not arguing; I'm not attacking; and I'm not suggesting that you can't disagree.

I've merely observed that arguing with an anti-Microsoft zealot is just as futile as arguing with an anti-God zealot or pro-God zealot or whatever. And if a person in such an analogy is either pro-God or anti-God, he/she is just too emotionally involved in that particular position to even try to understand the other.

Arguing, and/or disagreeing, and/or trying to convince, and/or whatever is no more than an exercise in futility. So why even try? You think what you want to think, and I'll think what I want to think; and at best, all we can possibly agree on is the fact that we disagree.

And that's why I had to ask the Jason, the discussion originator, if this was a "Bait" question to get the pro-Microsoft and anti-Microsoft people arguing again.

But I suppose I just shouldn't have replied to your message. Okay, I retract my reply. (I don't retract my thoughts and or opinion, just the fact that I posted it for you to see.)

by hal 9000

You should have voted for IBM as they where the company who made MS what it is today.

How far do you think MS would have got if they had not have teamed up with IBM and sold software on all new IBM PC's?

Prior to that MS was just a second rate Bit player in the market attempting to sell second rate software that just couldn't compete with the then industry standards like Word Perfect, Lotus 123 and so on. Really at that point in time Apple was a far better prospect.

Actually come to think of it, it wasn't until Windows 95 hit the market that MS made any attempt to be Internet ready do you remember setting up an Internet connection on Windows 3.11? I do and I'm glad those days are long gone.

Col ]:)

by maxwell edison

.
Asking which is the BEST company is like asking what ice cream is the BEST, vanilla or chocolate -- or, the correct answer, Cherry Garcia.

"BEST" is almost always a matter of opinion, and can rarely be quantified with a supporting argument. And if all you want is blanket opinions, I think I'd have more fun with the ice cream question. At least then I might get an idea for a new flavor to try.

by maxwell edison

.
Instead of, "Which company has had the BEST impact on Information Technology".....

Which company has had the greatest impact.....

Which company has had the most significant impact.....

Which company has had the most important impact.....

Which company has had the most influential impact.....

Which company has had the longest-lasting impact.....

And stuff like that.

And don't forget to award a TechRepublic coffee mug for the BEST answer.

by hal 9000

You've got to get into the Rum & Raisin it's delicious and highly addictive. :^O

Col ]:)

by dibo

It was IBM that brought computing at a very large scale to companies all over the world. I don't mean the IBM PC but the good old 1402, 1410, 360, 370, etc. Those large mammoth computers shaped the computer industry for centuries to come.

by frank.marten

I interpreted that the question was refering to the "best" impact on IT, not necessarily the biggest impact. I felt that Apple have been influential in shaping innovation for the better whilst Microsoft has obviously been the most successful with their penetration of products into the market place.

by beoweolf

The company we all love to hate has, for better or for worse, standardized the market, the industry. You can't ignore the presence of the 800 lb. Gorilla, among the cute monkeys.

Even the players in the *nix market have to give Microsoft a debt of gratitude, without the influence of Microsoft as the driving force, we would still have (and actually still do) this "elitist" bent to computers. For all the beauty, elegance, compact code of "C"/*nix based system...they are difficult for neophytes to install, setup use. The numerous versions and current push to establish hegemony over a "free", open product serves to only further illuminate the stabilizing effect of having Microsoft as a loom giant that drives the rest of the market to improve.

As I said, the company we all love to hate...has allowed the entire industry to mature and develop to be the global influence it is today.

by beoweolf

I guess all children start talking one word at a time? It's unfortunate yours was a description of the value of your comment.

by tony hopkinson

very correct if the question had been more specific
Which company has had the biggest deleterious or commercial impact on IT.
Definitley hands down winners there.

Some might make the distinction between IT itself and it's more commercial aspects.

Company was very loaded concept anyway.
Which Person, perhaps Bill would have got in there along side.
Turing, Von Neuman, Babbage, Jacquard, Boole, Dodgson, Berners-Lee, Mandelbrot et al.

Well maybe not, they all brought us something new.

by beoweolf

...and Hell. For all its brashness int he early days, outright theft in some cases and Monopolist bent; Still Microsoft has been an overwhelming force in IT since it branched out to threaten and eclipse Mainframes in the popular workplace.

Just as there are some people that long for structure, the presence of MS is like Mousselini..."He kept the trains on time". some people are willing to forgive the excesses to reap the benefits.

I am no great fan of MS, a quick review of the bodies strewn in its wake ... Netscape, Sun, Apple, Novelle ... is a reflection of "Paradise Lost". Progress is built on the results acheived by predators, not grazers. The trick is to recognise the excesses, learn from the mistakes and build a better solution. sooner or later, we will find another villian to admire and hate.

Just to be a little pendantic. Monoculture, in agriculture (and IT) is great for standardization, over the last centries, farmers have perfected Wheat, Corn, rice, potatos to the near exculusion of other food crops. The result has been more effencent food production...the down side, a blight, diease or virus could destry the bulk of the worlds food production in short order.

That is the same case we are faced with in our dependence on MS and its products. The issue (of security, privacy, piracy...etc) isn't really an issue to be laid at the door of MS. Rather it is a problem of bad choices, lazy implementation and of course, the bad guys doing bad things. I'm not apologizing for MS, just facing the facts...no hackers = no security breaches. No virus writers = no need for AV. Heres a novel idea, if we really want security, just establish AV on all the Backbone node servers. But that would be like asking for road signs, stop lights and traffic control on streets and highways...who would tolerate something like that, it's much better to just blame MS. It's to much work to hunt down the real killer (Go OJ, GO)!

by jaqui

Bill never brought anything new, only managed to market better what he stole from others.

by tony hopkinson

Besides the justification for picking IBM was they were there at the start in his history of IT, in mine they were jump on the bandwagon Johnny-come-latelys

So There

by apotheon

Your comparison of MS to Mussolini might be more relevant if MS could keep the trains running on time.

Progress is [b]not[/b] built on the results achieved by predators: it's built on the results achieved by innovators. Predators in the marketplace are predators because they feed on others' successes, not because they produce anything of value themselves. Microsoft hasn't contributed to progress, only to its own commercial success. The reason others haven't succeeded where Microsoft has isn't that Microsoft did it first, but rather that Microsoft made concerted efforts to prevent them from succeeding.

"Heres a novel idea, if we really want security, just establish AV on all the Backbone node servers."

Clearly, you've bought into the common misconception that security is about antivirus technology. The reason unices are relatively virus-free is not obscurity or excellent antivirus software: it's that the underlying vulnerabilities that make virus-writing in any way effective get solved, while the Windows approach is to leave the vulnerabilities and try to attack the individual virus. This means that each new virus gets its own virus definition, but the underlying vulnerability that made that virus effective can still be exploited to produce another virus (or six, or six hundred) that is just different enough for the virus definition to fail to detect it and protect against it.

by apotheon

You want me to enumerate the problems with your earlier post, in all its absurdity? Okay. I'll take a whack at it. I was simply far too tired of the mountain of misconceptions I encounter every day to try to address them all [b]again[/b], especially since your previous post was so full of misconceptions that it was difficult to figure out where to start.

"[i]The company we all love to hate has, for better or for worse, standardized the market, the industry.[/i]"
Wrong. It has done nothing of the kind. The only thing it has even approached standardizing is the sticker you get on the front of your computer when you buy it from Dell or Gateway. Not only has Microsoft simply ignored or intentionally violated industry standards at every turn, but there aren't even any standards maintained from one version of a piece of MS software to the next. New MS Office versions aren't backwards-compatible, new NTFS filesystems aren't backwards-compatible, and so on. OpenOffice.org is more MS filetype backwards-compatible than new MS Office versions. That's just inexcusable.

I guess there's one standard Microsoft has introduced to the industry, though: there's a low standard of performance expected from computers by the general mass of end users, because that low standard is all Microsoft has provided.

"[i]Even the players in the *nix market have to give Microsoft a debt of gratitude, without the influence of Microsoft as the driving force, we would still have (and actually still do) this 'elitist' bent to computers.[/i]"
1. How does that translate to a debt of gratitude?

2. If you think Microsoft is promoting egalitarianism and unices promote elitism, you probably haven't attended many LUG meetings and MS developer seminars. I assure you that, in all my experience in this industry and surrounding enthusiast communities, the opposite has by far tended to be true.

"[i]For all the beauty, elegance, compact code of "C"/*nix based system...they are difficult for neophytes to install, setup use.[/i]"
I'm going to make a wild guess here that you haven't used Linux much lately. That's the only reasonable explanation for this. You've probably been reading the Microsoft marketing propaganda intended to scare people away from some very user-friendly Linux distributions that are easier to install and use than any Windows version.

"[i]The numerous versions and current push to establish hegemony over a "free", open product serves to only further illuminate the stabilizing effect of having Microsoft as a loom giant that drives the rest of the market to improve.[/i]"
All I can really say to this is: What the heck are you talking about?

"[i]As I said, the company we all love to hate...has allowed the entire industry to mature and develop to be the global influence it is today.[/i]"
Thus . . . bullsh*t.

The only thing you've said that was based on any kind of fact was the one statement I cut out and to which I didn't directly reply: you said we can't ignore the 800lb. gorilla. That's especially the case when it's rabid.

by marxtevens

You have to build on something, "standing on the shoulders of giants," as it were. Microsoft has done this and one of the giants, still in existence, is IBM. Give IBM points for longevity.

Documentation. For the programmer creating code for the end user, there was an error number, like IEF001, for EVERY error. You could look it up. In a book. With an index. In the begining, answers were sometimes not very helpful, I remember many JCL and OS Utilities errors having "Correct and resubmit" as the fix, but they got better over time. EVERY OTHER operating system and language struggles to hit this target, to this day.

Marketing, IBM was number one for a long time, with salemen making promises that the hardware and the software couldn't meet, but that didn't stop the sales or wiping out the competition: Sperry/Rand/Univac/Unisys, General Electric, Control Data Corp, etc. Microsoft learned from IBM and learned well. Maybe better, since they beat the government rap for all intents and purposes and IBM didn't.

Hardware, say what you will, but IBM hardware was over-engineered and lasted a lot longer than it should have, including their PCs, XTs, and ATs. I knew of one site that at least through 1999 was running a 360/67 system for production, because it worked. We were running 4341's and then 4381's through 2000.

Software, first multi-tasking Operating System, (MFT) I believe. First Virtual Operating System CP/CMS aka VM aka CP-67, where you could run another OS on top of the base one, including a copy of the base. Compilers, and assemblers, and macros made use of libraries of commonly used routines touting reusability before it was fashionable. First language documented before it was written, REXX.

Yes, there are instances of all of the above today, from other companies, but unless one of the other now defunct companies did it first, IBM is still here.

Internet, first run on IBM hardware, I believe, or maybe this one belongs to DEC with UNIX and C on PDP-8's and -11's. The first educational network was on IBM hardware and VM in New York and eventually merged with DARPA-net. I'm having a problem remembering the name of that network. Anyone from Marist, or CUNY, remember?

by apotheon

Whether you like it or not, the question asked for the "best" impact on IT. Whether or not McDonald's is the Microsoft of fast food has little effect on the fact I wouldn't call its impact on the fast food industry the "best".

by maxwell edison

.
.....I asked Jason to qualify his use of the word "best".

Personally, I think he was either baiting or had a brain-fart. Using the word "best" in this context will not result in any definitive answer.

by apotheon

There's no definitive answer to the "best" in this case. At least, not without some clear definition of what constitutes "best" in this case.

On the other hand, it might prompt some worthwhile dicussion.

by tony hopkinson

Monoculture gave you the dust bowl for instance.
It gave us BSE
It's depopulating fish stocks, making animals extinct ... Not Bill's fauly of course.
He gave us both a case of ActiveX. The principal argument against MS isn't ramapant commercialism, but the standards they've stuck us with to become a commercial success.

Stop signs etc on the roads haven't stopped road crime have they, they helped admitted. What has reduced problems is non-commercial regulation of safety specs of cars themselves. You can't market an unsafe car and you shouldn't be able to market an unsafe OS. Definitely you should not be in charge of the definition of safety when you can make a huge profit out of watering it down and use that power to marginalise your competitors.

by surflover

CPUs can only add... to subtract, they add -1... (I used to write the operating systems assembler code for honeywell mainframes in my (much) younger days)

by jaqui

are you trying to educate people or something like that?
don't you know that doing that will get you into trouble with the king geek.
and queen geekette for that matter, she's almost as perverted as I am. :)

adding the negative instead of actually subtracting is only a difference is detail, the end result is the same.

I'n my younger days ( aka junior high school and high school ) we all used to use hex code and program our user space apps in r/t.
( we are talking the ancient at / apple II time frame here. )

by surflover

I was talking an era of bootstrapping the machine with toggle switches from the "console"... there really was no console as we think of it today, it had an async tty printer that would give you feedback on the instructions you loaded, and error codes when you got one wrong... The smallest machine at that time was an RNP (basically the size of a modern day standard rack)... the osborns, and apples were just wishes in those days :-)

by fefrench9

I selected Cisco because they seem to be on top of the software crisis (security, etc), while Microsoft is a target both domestically and from foreign countries. I would also like to add that my experience with Microsoft has left a rather bitter taste in my mouth. Their patches only open the door for more spyware and viruses. While Microsoft has been a leader in the organization of the computer industry as a whole, they are falling from favor because of their attitude especially towards small fry like myself who are trying to eak out a living assisting small business become literate in the computer era.

by tony hopkinson

THEY brought something new.

Jeez the guy was trying to come up with a name for his new product and noticed the framed hole in his office wall.

Pity he didn't think someone could break into my office quite easily through there.

by hal 9000

Unix was by far the best thing that has so far come out of any company to help society today.

MS on the other hand has undone all the great work that was done by these people who developed Unix as you needed to know how to actually use a computer back then. Now there are trained chimps being paid with bananas using Windows boxes and complaining that they don't work right.

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

MS is left out in the cold isn't it?

That company hasn't done one of those things listed actually it has done the exact opposite.

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

But as I said it's addictive and I can't get enough of it. Maybe if I could get it more often you might stand a chance but it's so rare that when a shop gets some in it all goes in the first few hours. Even the bulk suppliers don't have a steady supply of the stuff if you happen to wonder in when they have stock you're in luck otherwise it's Hard Luck Mate Don't have any! :(

I don't give a rats what's in it even though it is likely to kill you it tastes nice. :^O

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

Most "Home Computers" are nothing more than glorified game consoles.

Just look at all the rubbish that they put in them lit case fans and everything else that is possible to squeeze an LED into has one or more.

Col ]:)

by absolutely

The fact that they are used for playing games, Googling trivia, etc., is exactly why I think they do not constitute an improvement, and why the company (Microsoft) that is synonymous with mass-produced computer/game consoles, has not had the "best" impact on IT.

I suspect that "IT" was meant to refer to the profession, but I took it literally, and World of Warcraft is an inane use of information technology.`

by apotheon

For offering wireless inside the coffee shops? They weren't first, and they charge (at least in most places) for the service.

by maxwell edison

And it was a joke.

IT people ..... all hours of the day ..... drinking coffee to stay alert and productive ..... Starbucks .....

by maxwell edison

.
Oh what could have been, and what might have been for IBM if they didn't agree to not only pay Gates for his operating system BUT ALSO agree to let him keep the licensing rights to a slightly different version of it (PC-DOS versus MS-DOS), how the technical landscape today might have been different.

And also what about IBM's decision to bundle their hardware and software together, not selling them separately, opening the door for Compaq and other like-minded fledgling computer companies that came along, companies like Dell and Gateway? I wonder if IBM regrets that particular business decision as much as they might regret their contractual agreement with Gates?

Life is full of "what ifs".

What's the difference between PC-DOS and MS-DOS, someone once asked me back in the mid 80s? I forgot the exact answer I gave them, but today the answer is about 300 billion dollars and a seat at the top of the computing world.

by apotheon

I'll be more impressed when someone opens a halfway decent coffee shop with free wireless that's open 24/7.

by apotheon

I don't enjoy working in a job involving "the public". I'm happy where I am, with an office that doubles as the datacenter, supporting reasonably intelligent "end users" that are smart enough to use Linux of their own free will.

by jaqui

even a dream, cause they hadn't even gotten past the gleam in thier inventors eyes stage yet.

but linux won't run on anything older than a 386.

by hal 9000

Took the Easy Option with it's Open Archetype and allowed anyone else to jump on the bandwagon which eventually caused their downfall if you can call it that but at least it made computers Standard across the board. I would hate to think of what things would be like if we had a Closed Shop Apple, a closed Shop IBM, and closed shop HP. Compaq and everyone else all with different systems doing more or less the same thing.

Actually I don't think IBM regret that decision and they certainly don't show any signs of wanting to change as they are pushing Open Source quite hard today as well. Of course it is aimed directly at their Big End Server market which is one area of the business that MS doesn't compete in.

Just for fun think about Windows 2003 ES attempting to run a a 2,000 CPU blade array. While these are not every day machines they also are by no means the biggest that IBM sell either but they are one of the more common units that they sell and even if you only want a 500 CPU machine you'll get a 1000 CPU unit and only start paying for the extra processing power when you start using it.

From past experience I don't think that Windows would like that system too much. :)

The answer to the PC DOS and MS DOS is easy one worked and the other sort of worked so it had to be replaced with a more system hungry OS to make life easier for the end user. In MS DOS you couldn't perform an XCOPY between different size floppies it was just so restrictive that I dropped it after about 3 days and never went back to it. The surprising thing is that MS still sell about 50 copies a month here in AU. If I was developing hardware for applications that ran with DOS I would be using PC DOS, DR DOS anything at all except MS DOS. These are mostly big machine tools like lathes and the like that are computer controlled and will be there for years to come. :)

Col ]:)

by apotheon

Linux will run on hardware older than a 386, just not on Intel hardware older than that.

Actually, you can even get a highly modified Linux kernel OS to run on a 286, if you really, really want to. I'm not sure there's a good reason to do so, but you could. It has been done.

by richmondofori2000

well i think i will go for micrsoft,google,cisco system.i think microsoft being the world greatest software manufacture has made a great impact on our world today.i say so because almost every pc in the world has windows or a product of microsoft installed on it.their software is quiet flexible and easy to use.i would say its environmental friendly and more over solves the most of the problems of the day which gives more credit to microsoft.google is aslo making a great impact on the world today because it produces a wide,fast and convinent search engine for various people in the world.i would say 80m percent of people in the world today use google as their search engine.well when it comes to networking stuff,i will recomend cisco cos is best u can have in your environment today.thank you.richmond

by hal 9000

You're welcome to this dual processor high end workstation that shat itself after a power outage. The UPS shut it down normally and on the restart it ran Chkdsk and trashed the OS to such a point that while it would load up it wouldn't keep running. You couldn't repair it, roll it back or anything else.

Currently I have it reduced to just one HDD to load Windows and the drivers for the hardware and then I'll reconnect all the HDD's and see if it still works.

Of course when I ran diagnostics on it everything worked perfectly and even a Live Linux had it running perfectly so much in fact that I got all the data on the boot drive saved to one of the SCSI's without a problem. But try and install Windows XP Pro and it wouldn't have a bar of it even though it has been working perfectly for well over 1 year now since I fitted a much bigger Power Supply into it. You need at least 500 Watts when you have 16 HDD's and 5 CD/DVD drives.

Now if MS Software was so good why have I spent the last 20 hours with this thing and still haven't got Windows fully loaded?

What's far worse is that I'm stuck in a clean room and can not leave for a smoke or even have a packet of my peppermints in here I'm close to climbing the walls and if I'm not finished before the user gets here latter today I'll most likely kill him out of frustration. ;)

Col ]:)

by oisleach9

I vote for Borland because they have provided solid alternative products that I have used in the past. These products IMHO have always been ahead of the curve.

Lunis Torvalds also gets my vote simply because he has brought the non-reboot experience to the masses. With Linux, and all of it's variations us work a day schmoes can actually experience 24/7 computer up time. Plus with Linux, and it's variations I am actually empowered by people I have never met, never will meet, and yet they have changed my life.