Discussion Locked

Which job would you choose? (and why)

0 helpful
23 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Many of you know I've been looking for a job and I have several opportunities I'm considering and would like some opinions;

1. SVP of engineering at a fairly large transaction processor in Atlanta
2. CIO of a software startup, just received 2nd round funding ($5M), but doesn't have any revenue yet
3. Consulting to the same startup, with the option of taking the CIO position at a later time.
4. GS-16/ES2 position in Hawaii (where I used to work in the late '80s)

Pros

#1. close to family, stable co., good pay
#2. huge $$s possible, great salary
#3. not as much long term $$s as #2, but more $$s now
#4. Hawaii ('nuff said), 8 hour days, no travel, Hawaii

Cons
#1. slow moving company, VERY political, should pay better
#2. ridiculous hours, lots of travel, could fold over night (been there)
#3. could miss the equity of #2, same hours, lots of travel
#4. low pay (<25% of #2, <50% of #1)

What do you think?

23 replies

by jdmercha

1. Most likely one I'd choose.
2. Been there, done that, never again
3. If I were closer to retirement, this would be appealing.
4. I like Hawaii but, it takes like what, three days to see the entire island. Then your stuck. It costs $$$ to get off the island. Of course if you have your own boat that changes things.

5. Need someone to fill your current position?

by m_a_r_k

Actually, I can't answer. Hell, surfer, we can't offer much advice on this one. Those are three vey different jobs. Whenever I've interviewed someone, I've always tried to determine if they know what they want. If the interviewee says he/she would like to do any of 1) develop C# software, 2) be a DBA, 3) do IT support or 4) train race horses, I give them the boot PDQ. What do YOU want to do with the next 5-10 years of your life? Consult? Civil service? CIO? SVP? Having decided on that first of all, I'd then definitely need more parameters than job title, location and pay. What about coworkers? Size of company? Day-to-responsibilities? Your direct reports? Your direct manager? Health benefits? Bonus? Profit sharing? Office with a window? :D Pretty secretary? :D Age of secretary? :D Marital status of secretary? :D Oh... and you better find out the gender of your secretary before you go snooping around to find out her/his marital status, looks and age. haha

by surflover

The SVP position is in a very stable, VERY political company which I had done some consulting for a few years ago... decent pay (~200), good package... but would most likely be difficult to get much accomplished (when I was at Delta, we used to say "it takes a long time to turn a battleship")

The startup is throwing out big $$s and equity (~500/10%)... but the $$s wont last long if the 10% is 10% of nothing :^O (been there more than once)...

The civil service job is the director of an organization I worked at as a software engineer in the mid '80s (in Honolulu), I'd be over the IT organization (my bos would be in Cal), 6-8 hour days, no weekends, and a lot of people I knew are still there... but I'm afraid I'd get bored... there is another upside though... I have 16 yrs govt. svcs... 4 more and I qualify for retirement

by m_a_r_k

How the bejeezus could a wild young playboy surfer dude such as you get bored in HAWAII?? :^O

by jck

but if you find an open position for an IT guy at the American Embassy in Dublin Ireland, you better let me know.

I need real Guinness!!!! ]:)

by amcol

If it were me, I'd opt for door number 3 and hope it leads to door number 2. But that's because of where I am in my life, my career, and a wide variety of other issues.

You can't possibly expect anyone in this community to offer you an informed opinion on this. We know nothing about you, and what's good for anyone of us is not necessarily good for you. I wouldn't even presume to offer you an opinion if I did know you, unless I had a multi-year relationship with you.

You might want to think about why you're having trouble deciding, to the point where you've solicited a bunch of anonymous strangers to offer opinions. You've laid out the options pretty well, articulating the pros and cons. It all makes sense to me. Why doesn't it make sense to you?

by surflover

I've found some very insightful posts here... not that I'd take someone's recommendation and run with it... just looking for other's opinions (maybe something I haven't thought of)...

by ldyosng

You put in 4 more years, and then you can retire and do whatever the heck you want with the rest of your life with a nice pension? As opposed to putting in how many years with #s 2/3 for what known result? And #1 just sounds like more malarky than you really want to put up with. It looks like you threw that one in just to have a comparison. From what I've read about you, the 4 year working vacation in Hawaii sounds like the better personality fit. You have a pre-set exit date if you get island feaver, and you already have a good idea how long it will take to set in. The risk of a startup is for someone who is willing to work 60+ hours a week for a coin toss. Nice gig for a 20something with no life outside of work who can start over if it craps out. Do you really need that new Rolex?
Or - I could be totaly wrong!

by platformrogue

I'd go for #4. The money might not be good, but if you're that close to the 20 year mark, I'd go for it now.

The Gov't could change the rules and you're retirement options might disappear. I think opportunties like #1 and #3 will be available in the four years and the pension gives you the freedom to pursue #2s without having to worry so much about what happens if it goes south.

One of the reasons I took my current job was that it was in the same pension plan and I'm close to being vested.

Hope this helps.

by surflover

You're probably right about the startup... I've done 4 already in the last 10 years... don't know if I have that much left in me... but the HI gig just "qualifies" me for retirement... I couldn't collect anything till I'm 67-1/2 (22 years from now)...

the real advantage to that one is quality of life... wearing sandals, flowered shirts and shorts to the office... short days (nobody works past 4:30)... wind surfing, hiking, snorkelling etc. on the weekends... the swap meet, the weather, the bikinis :^O...

I think I'm talking myself into this :^O

by jamesrl

Ask yourself if this is really where you want to live. Do some house shopping. See if you can find one of those relocation calulators - they help you see what kind of money you need to have an "equivalent" lifestyle in another place - ie. $55k in Dallas =$90K in NYC.

I do agree with Max, we can't really help you make the decision as we don't know you well enough. What might make sense for you migt make no sense to us and vice versa.

Best advice - do what you love doing. If you have lost your taste for startups, don't do another one just for money - you will regret it.

James

by itgirli

#1 sounds good because you'd be near family, you know the company is stable and it's good pay. You said it should pay better, have you discussed that with the company? Let them know you would like to work there if you could get some more money ot of them. You can always try to avoid their politics.
#3 with the later option of #2 sounds pretty good, but you seem adverse to travel.
#4 is a bad idea. But that's my personal opinion. I have no desire to be out on a volcano surrounded by hundreds of miles of water. Oh sure, they're inactive. one word for you, "Pompeii".
I say, if you would not feel happy at any of them, look for an option #5.

by welshbilly

You still got 20 odd years ahead of you. You mentioned that the 4 years qualifies you for retirment but I'm assuming you still have to work for the next 20 odd years at the Civil Service?

So do you want to be tied to that job for that amount of time? You previously said that you have worked in Hawaii before and you got bored. Your going into that option with your eyes open.

I think your not entirley sure and none of these options really "floats your boat". I agree with girlIT and you should look for option 5.

Also, I think it's good you put this post on as you have had some cool advice, also it's nioce to be presented with all those options. Usually I just have an either or situation, not a list of options.

Good Luck - would be interested in what you decide.

by sleepin'dawg

The number 1 goal for me was to become financially independant and I would take on any job to achieve that goal. Along the way I and a few pals built a company of our own. We were successful enough that we have each achieved that. To top it off we invested in the markets and while I'm not 100% sure of my partners, I know I could live off my investments alone; I don't really need the salary anymore. There is a catch to this though; we built something and it's still growing. We're having fun facing the challenges of making it grow and are in the process of a large scale expansion right at this moment. However, we are no longer slaves to our jobs. None of us puts in more than 4-6 hours a day unless we want to, not because we have to. I have never taken any job where I wasn't prepared to tell the boss to shove it and then walk. There might have been times when it would have been tight but I always retained that option.

My priorities in your scenario would be:
(A): Which job will permit me to achieve financial independence the fastest.
(B): Which job will provide the greatest incentive to achieving (A).
(C): Which job will give me the greatest freedom to achieving (A)
(D): Once I've achieved (A) what do I want to do from there.

At this point you should be asking yourself why you want to be working for anyone else except yourself. Actually you do work for yourself; you just do it at somebody else's company; building their operation. Why not get off your butt and start your own??? It isn't all that hard and it's the most fun you are going to have with all your clothes on.;\ Just remember the primary goal is to achieve financial independence. You'll know you are there when you have the guts to tell your boss to shove it. How much financial security do you need to have, to feel financially independent??? ?:| How much money is enough??? ]:)

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by lansche

However, I'm not sure if this is the best advice to give anyone, because only a few lucky people can achieve what you have. Don't get me wrong you made the best decision for you, and if I ever met you I would shake your hand, and would even think about becoming friends with you. I'm 55 years old and for the most part my life has been a struggle until recently when I found a job that has been my hobby for most of my life. That is working for computers and teaching young people computer skills. Now, of course, I will never get rich but I will most likely never have a job that fits me so perfectly. No Stress! I can quit tomorrow with a smile on my face.

I'm sure I don't have to tell you this but unless your Donald Trump you business could fail anyday, anytime. Like you said it would matter to you because your financially set for life, but what about those that work for you, how would you feel if some poor sucker lost his job because your company just went in the tank. I would certainly hope the stress of this situation could change your life for ever. "My life depends on others no matter what my situation is, I could be on top of the world when the big earthquake hits." Quote by Bill Lansche, a small person in the eyes of my closest competitor.

by sleepin'dawg

Me and my buddies were all laid off from the same company in Mar/88. We were and are all skilled professionals and when we considered our skills jointly we recognized a symbiosis that gave us the incentive to take a plunge into a venture together. I was 47 at the time; my partners about 10 years younger. Our first rule was we were never ever going to refuse any kind of work. The second rule was we were going to make money on every job we took on. We struggled a lot in the first two years until we identified certain niches in the business that were not being adequately filled. Those became our focus and we determined to fill those niches better and cheaper than anybody else would or could. You refer to luck??? Luck is what happens when hard work and planning coincides with opportunity. It just requires the knowledge to identify an opportunity when it presents itself and the balls to jump on it and run with it when it does. I've heard your song before. "You guys are crazy to be taking all that risk." or "There's a lot of competition in that field. How can you possibly compete with that???" or the best one yet, "You're going to need a lot of luck to succeed." Oh I just love you nay sayers. You people provide the pool of talent which we draw on when we need to hire someone. Understand we only hire from the top of the pool we do not go dumpster diving. We get good people pay them better than scale and provide profit sharing. As a consequence we hang on to the vast majority of our people, to the point we will carry them through slow times but so far we haven't seen too many of those. As regards risk; there is risk attached to everything in life, even crossing the street. The thing with risk is you take calculated risks and the bigger the risks the bigger the payoff. If you never cross the street you'll never get anywhere and will be left sitting at the curb with the garbage. Competition??? Let me say this about competition; if there is competition that's only because there is money to be made there.

How am I going to feel if my company tanks and somebody loses his job. Well that would suck, big time. I would have lost my company and that would piss me off, royally. It would mean I'd have to scramble around to start another company, wouldn't it??? As for the guy who loses his job, it would be sad but those are the breaks of the game. Hell he loses a job; I've lost a company. I'll feel worse for myself based strictly on the comparitive scale of loss. For what it's worth remember Mar/88??? Me and my pals were all downsized together. We weren't expecting it and we were all in debt with kids, child support payments, car payments and mortgages. Hell even my wife was out of work. The only good thing was I had no credit card debt. Did we sit in a corner sucking our thumbs and bemoaning fate. No way would any of us have done that. We sucked it up and struck out on our own. We aren't so special. Anybody could do what we've done. It isn't rocket science. The one major item you need are the guts to be a leader rather than a follower but leadership isn't for everyone. Right now we have almost 700 employees divided between Montreal, Boston and Boulder and we are building a new expansion facility in Nevada which will probably add another 250 or so to the payroll. We haven't had a losing quarter since 1993 when we had two. We still ended the year in the black. Now tell me again about luck!!!!

I loved the reference to the Donald. You do realize that at one point he had 3 of his casinos in receivership. He didn't get out from under Chapter 11 for about 2 1/2 years and had to divest himself of quite a few of his properties.
You obviously don't have the leadership mentality and if you're content as a follower then be happy but don't try to lay any of your phoney moralizing guilt crap on me because I don't and won't accept it. You call yourself a small person in the eyes of your closest competitor. You do realize that neither of you make it onto the radar screen of life.

Oh yes you mentioned your age being 55. Is that meant as an excuse??? Colonel Harland Sanders was 67 years old when he opened his first Kentucky Fried Chicken. When he died several years later there were more than 4500 of his restaurants around the world. I bet he would have loved to have started out earlier, say around 55.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by surflover

I told my last boss to shove it... (My CEO demanded I submit a false report to VISA for an audit, and I refused and quit)...

... and I have started 5 corporations in the last ten years, beware of telling anyone it's not that hard... it's the hardest (and I grant you, the most fun) thing you'll ever do...

by sleepin'dawg

I said take the job that leads to you being finacially independent the quickest and I should have added the easiest and fun way possible. For what it's worth I've always considered three years salary in the bank and your mortgage paid off as being a decent start on being independent, financially or otherwise. Money is only the means of keeping score.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by lansche

I heard mention that the best job for anyone is something you would do as a hobby, anything else will have it's share of problems. Don't choose you next job because it pays more, has less hours, or even travling. All that will work its self out in time in your favor, most times. If your young this will be one of the most important decision in your life. Remember one very important lesson: Stress Kills!

by sleepin'dawg

That bit about stress is just so much bullsh|t. There are those who thrive on stress and go around the bend without it. And yes others get ulcers and heart attacks via stress. You can't categorize everyone by your standard. The quotation you were looking for is, "Work at what you love and you'll never work another day in your life." I know lots who work at what they 'love', myself amongst them but that doesn't eliminate 18 hour days if they are going to be successful. Once you're a success you can cut back on the 18 hour days but they'll be there occasionally.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

This discussion is closed to new replies.