Discussion Locked

Who's jr_IT_guy and what's his problem?

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

On the Q&A section of TechRepublic, many of us come together to help each other through difficult times. Some questions do not have answer, nor ever will. I posted a question in the Q&A section to address not just "jr_IT_guy" but those people that just go around telling you to close out your question, if you don't have an answer or a suggestion , you should shut up and stay away. Telling someone to close out a question that they haven't solved yet is just pouring salt on the wound. If you have something to suggest, that is what Q&A is about, not telling someone to close out their question. those people need to stay away from Q&A.
---the following was posted in Q&A-----
there's someone on TechRepublic that believe's everyone has a local super hero. I know we all have our peers we look to for suggestions, but I don't have a local super hero, most question come to me, not from me.
So who is jr_IT_guy, and why does he keep answering every question with 'go ask your local super hero?' is he the guy that thinks he knows everything, yet knows nothing, and can barely spell computer?
------------------------------------
any comments on this matter would be greatly appreciated.

3 replies

by mckaytech

Interestingly, I've seen his entries several times on stale questions and it looks like his intent is to exploit a bug in the TechRepublic software that auto-closes questions. The answers I've read from him have never been useful or relevant.

It seems that if a question gets very old, it still will not auto-close from inactivity until there is a new response (or maybe it requires a second response)and then it auto-closes that night. jr_IT_guy apparently has figured this out and several times has posted a response on a question I have answered - his response is usually something like "yeah, like HE said" but when it auto-closes that night, he ends up with half the points (or a pro-rata share if there are more than two non-rejected answers to the question).

It's just one more case in a long line of points manipulation events here on TechRepublic. This past weekend, I verified that his method generally works although in two cases, I received rejections on test answers I posted toquestions that had been open since last November or before (my apologies to those two participants, to whom my answers must have sounded strangely unlike an actual answer).

So I don't think his answers have anything to do with what he does or doesn't believe or know - he's simply found a way to accumulate points by converting stale questions to a situation where they auto-close and award him a share of the points.

paul

by shanghai sam

I've never seen an IT department or any IT function that could allow a problem to linger on for a year or more.

If there is a question posted on Tech Republic that hasn't been adequately answered in one year, and the problem still persists for the "user" for that long, there's really no hope of getting it solved on this thread. In addition, how effective is an IT professional who takes a year to NOT SOLVE a problem? Not very. And most likely, he/she wouldn't be around for very long.

TechRepublic is all but one resource we can all use to help us solve our problems. If anyone relies totally on information gained ONLY from this one source, they don't have very much on the ball, and they're not very resourceful. I certainly wouldn't want someone like that working for me.

There's no reason whatsoever a person shouldn't gently remind someone to close a question that's a year old. And if that person somehow gets "rewarded" (with Tech Points) in the process, so be it and more power to him. At least I did it with the intent of interjecting a little humor. Some people just don't see humor in anything, I suppose. And besides, if it's suggested that you close a question, it doesn't mean you have to, does it?

Just because one person gets all bent out of shape over a harmless little message doesn't mean everyone will. Most people, at least those who said anything at all, were not upset or put out in the least. If you get this worked up over something this trivial, it's no wonder you need more than a year to solve your problems.

Regards,

jr

by mckaytech

jr -
I appreciate the explanation of where you're coming from. As a rationalization for your actions, it's not all bad, although I would note for the record that many of the questions on which you intervened were substantially less than a year old.

However, even though the points earned on TechRepublic have no discernable economic value, I do recognize a distinction between points earned by sharing hard-won technical knowledge and those earned by 'reminding' people to close their questions or offering 'me too' seconds to existing questions that are clearly intended only to gain a share of the points when the question auto-closes.

If you have offered genuine technical answers to questions, I apologize for my blanket characterization of your answers as being of no substance. I only had what I have seen to go on.

regards,

paul

This discussion is closed to new replies.