Discussion Locked

Why all incumbents must go

0 helpful
34 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I've been following the Foley scandal, and this was just announced on CNN.com:

"House Speaker Dennis Hastert said Thursday he was "sorry" about the scandal surrounding ex-Florida congressman Mark Foley's contacts with teenage pages but said he would not resign over the matter. "I'm going to run and presumably win in his election," he said. He did not, though, name former FBI director Louis Freeh to head an independent investigation of the page system, as expected, due to objections from Democrats."

Ok, let me try to understand this. Hastert wants to do something to fix the problem (an FBI investigation), but Democrats don't want him to?

This is why all incumbents must go, and we must get new blood up there. This is starting to appear to be another instance of finger-pointing by one party at the other, but they are probably doing the exact same thing. (Why else would the Demos NOT want an investigation? What do they have to hide?)

BOTH the Democratic Party and the Republican party are corrupt. Both need to go. They only care about winning and protecting their own turfs. It really is time for a change.

::deep breath:: Ok, I'm done venting now :)

34 replies

by yobtaf

It actually makes sense, but the Republicans and Democrats
will never allow it to happen.

In most of the civilized world there are multiple political
parties that fit a person's political philosophy more closely.
But that will never happen here.

by stress junkie

... is that politicians rely on private funding of political campaigns. If the government funded political campaigns and private funding was outlawed then politicians wouldn't have to look to private interests like corporations for support. If politicians didn't have to raise the money for their policital campaigns then they would not be put in a position where they have to become endebted to special corporate interests just to run a campaign.

Another problem is implied in NickNeilsen's post. Most people think that we have a two party system. Hell, when I was in elementary school I was taught that we have a two party system. It's a lie. Unfortunately government creates a structure that appears to operate a two party system. When we register to vote we can choose to either claim allegiance to the Republicans or to the Democrats or to claim no allegiance at all. When the political primaries are run it only includes the Democratic and the Republican parties. It would be cathartic if a third party took a significant percentage of the seats in Congress. Power struggles would be less clear cut. All political parties would have to deal with the other parties in order to get anything done. Three or more parties in Congress would put an end to the tyranny of one political party.

Most Americans are too stupid to change their political habits and allegiances. They are loyal to the party of their fathers and their grand fathers for no particularly good reason. They aren't interested enough to learn the real political issues or to bring the issues that they care about into the political discussion. Instead they sit catatonic in front of the television while the tv news departments decide what the issues for this election will be. Then if they bother to vote at all they vote for the candidate that they think will win or the candidate of their father's political party. Most Americans are a bunch of freakin' idiots.

by nicknielsen

Freakin' idiots? I wouldn't go that far. This line said it best: [i]They aren't interested enough to learn the real political issues or to bring the issues that they care about into the political discussion.[/i]

Lazy idiots, maybe, but not freakin' idiots. ;)

by yobtaf

He is being a bit extreme with his language but I can
understand how he feels. I tend to foam at the mouth when
get started on this too.

I agree with him, I would just suggest that he could win over
more support if he was less emotional.

by maxwell edison

Government funding of elections? Outlawing private funding? What a terrible and oppressive idea!

Interest groups are a GOOD thing. What do you think gives an individual voice any hope of being heard? A single vote can, and does, mater, to be sure, but not as much as a collective voice. And to take private voice out of the funding would spell doom for our republic.

Interest groups are a way for collective individual voices to be heard as one -- and to make a difference. Special interest groups were the driving force behind the abolition of slavery, women's right to vote, the first minimum wage and child labor laws, and scores of other things.

You go and try to talk to your Senator, and you probably wouldn't be given the time of day -- even if you DID vote for that person. But speak to him/her through a special interest group, and they're all ears.

For the government to tell individuals or groups of individuals that they can't exercise their freedom of speech by contributing to a political party, person, or campaign, is the epitome of an oppressive government.

You said, [i]"If politicians didn't have to raise the money for their political campaigns then they would not be put in a position where they have to become indebted to special ______________ interests just to run a campaign."[/i] (I took out "corporate" because that is just one of many "interests".) Therefore, if they weren't indebted to "our" interests, they wouldn't be obliged to serve "our" interests. What a scary thought! And if they finance their own campaigns, with OUR money that they take from us in the form of taxes, and we can't do a thing about it, ......

Give your head a shake and think that one through again.

by nicknielsen

Limit the campaign. Give the candidates and their advocates 90 days to make their point. After all, most parliamentary democracies manage to vote reasonably intelligently with only 45-60 days of campaigning.

IMO, this is one of the reasons that many people tune out the political process; the campaigns have become so long, they are just so much more noise. It often seems that new campaigns start even before the polls are closed on election day. I don't think there is anything more stupid than some politically anal talking head telling me that what just happened really happened, then speculating on the effect on the next election.

That and driving to Grandma's at Thanksgiving and seeing campaign posters still up at the roadside...

by stress junkie

What I'm saying is that special interest groups should not have the structure to purchase consideration. Speaking through a collective voice is certainly one of the pillars of our populist government. The way things are today a collective voice isn't heard unless there are collective dollars to purchase attention from politicians. This is the opposite of government for the people.

I'm saying that if politicians didn't have to fund their elections then they wouldn't have to seek money from rich sponsors to whom they are then expected to pay special consideration. The government agenda should not be dictated by the people with the most dollars. Then special interests can organise and seek attention based on the number of people in the group or based on the moral imperative of a given issue. The current system negates those two dynamics.

Funding of political campaigns would be even for each candidate. There would have to be a qualification for this, just as there is currently a qualification to get on a ballot. It could be the same qualification; the number of people who sign a petition to put you on the ballot.

I think that publicly funded political campaigns would result in politicians having fewer conflicts of interest and the ability to pay more attention to the people. Then we could outlaw money changing hands in lobbying activities. That would also benefit the interest groups that don't have fat treasuries to pay for political attention.

No, I still think that if we can eliminate money from elections and lobbying then the political process would be fairer.

by tony hopkinson

Who pays for the funding they get now ?
We do.

A question, how do you speak through a special interest group, especially if you don't share that interest. Given the interest group has got his ear, that means in the current system they are funding him. So do you have to contribute to the group to get your cut of said politician's time?
The guy is meant to be representing us not them!

Don't throw the baby out with bathwater because it sounds like an interference in business, think of it as another check and balance on the politicians.

by yobtaf

The party with the most money always wins. Is that
Democracy?

Gore Vidal, when asked why didn't make a career in
politics answered: "Why be a Senator when you can just
buy one"

If you believe the country belongs to the people, then the
people should publicly fund the process.

If you believe that country belongs to the corporations,
then our present system is fine. But the door is opened to
influence peddling, that's what the Abramoff, DeLay and
Ney scandal is all about.

by absolutely

"For the government to tell individuals or groups of individuals that they can't exercise their freedom of speech by contributing to a political party, [b]person[/b], or campaign, is the epitome of an oppressive government."

We each have the right to give to the political party, or campaign, of our choice. But [b]individuals[/b] are different than collectives (party) and actions (campaigns). Once a person is elected or appointed to any government office, until he or she relinquishes political power, [b]any[/b] gift to that person should be prosecuted as a bribe. Yes, I know that gifts within a certain amount are considered "acceptable" by law today. I think those laws are wrong, and would be improved by being made more absolute.

by tonythetiger

does not obligate the government to PAY FOR your free speech! (which is what government funded campaigns would amount to)

... and since I am not loyal to the party of my father, I must be a freakin' genius! Thank you. I appreciate the compliment :)

by twhipkey

The thought of the feds deciding which candidates are worthy to receive my tax dollars to fund their campaigns terrifies me.

Currently I am free to contribute to the candidates and parties I choose. Would that change under your proposal?

How would this work in local politics?

by stress junkie

The process that we currently use to qualify people to be included on the official ballot works pretty well. We could use the same sort of qualifications for government funding of a candidate's campaign.

by absolutely

There just continue to be millions more bits still voting D & R, but gradually, they're coming around.

by stress junkie

I disagree with your first statement. We, as individuals, do not pay a significant percentage of political campaign funding. Millions of dollars are donated by special interest groups such as large corporations to political action commitees, known as soft contributions, and to individual campaigns. These large organizations aren't trying to promote the electoral process. They are trying to purchase special consideration from the politicians. For example, of a large military contractor like Newport News ship yard contributes to a political party and political action committees and to individual campaigns they expect to be given favored status when they are looking for military contracts. When a large industrial corporation like DuPont makes similar contributions they expect to be given assistance when the EPA doesn't like the way that they are disposing of toxic waste. When a national land developer gives political contributions they expect the politicians to help them out when they want to develop land that is in a national wildlife sanctuary. Those are the kinds of sources of political funding at the moment. This is why the government is not acting in the best interest of the American people much of the time. Politicians have to give these kinds of organizations special consideration if they want more contributions when they decide to run again. And let's not forget that politicians find ways of moving unspent political funds into their own private bank accounts. One of the most egregious incidents occurred during Bill Clinton's re-election campaign when a "donation" from the Chinese government was personally accepted by Al Gore. That created the appearance that our government is for sale to foreign powers.

The same kinds of things happen while politicians are in office. Lobbyists like Jack Abramoth deliver huge sums of money to politicians with the expectation that the politician will look favorably on the lobbyist's client when certain legislation comes before the Congress. America is one of the few nations that allows foreign powers to lobby the members of Congress. That is outrageous.

So when you say that we, meaning individual citizens, fund political campaigns I have to disagree. Contributions from individuals in aggregate could never come close to the amount of money that is donated by large special interests. If we could remove that source of funding and fund political campaigns from government dollars then politicians would have fewer contenders for their loyalty. If we could also get rid of money changing hands in lobbying then maybe the politicians would serve the people and the best interest of the country for a change.

by stress junkie

Well of course the money just goes round and round in the comsumer cycle. That doesn't mean that when Proctor and Gamble make a political contribution it represents a grassroots movement. I think you're just being silly with your last comment.

by nicknielsen

The money comes from the government, which determines what is legal tender and issues appropriate bills/coins.

Political donations, whether personal or corporate are an expression of self-interest. We make such donations to individuals or causes that we feel will further our own interests. Corporate donations are made to further corporate interests. If those interests also happen to be consumer interests, it's a positive side effect, nothing more.

by absolutely

Democrat Byron Dorgan frequently advocates -[b] alone [/b]or with only a few, less articulate allies - to hold Cheney's corrupt friends accountable for wasting the military budget. Democrat Patrick Leahy & Republican Arlen Specter are consistently alone, on the right side of individual rights and a faithful interpretation of the Constitution. Republican Tom Coburn of Oklahoma is the cream of the crop for identifying, and speaking out against, the root cause of all corruption: earmarks. There are probably a couple others with a principle or two, but most of the rest of them can go to Lebanon & be exploded for all I care.

If you aren't outraged, you're either not paying attention, or are profitting off the corruption.

by ts.atomic

If we switch to sole federal funding of campaigns, would that serve to prevent private entities from garnering political influence?

Presume all private monetary campaign donations/funding are outlawed. Consider that interest groups will still have a desire/need for political influence to support their interests.

If they can't "buy" that influence with campaign dollars, what would prevent them from lobbying with a different form of currency, like votes? As in, "we will guarantee you "x" number of votes from our special-interest members and/or endorsements, campaign volunteers, door-to-door efforts, etc..."

Among the top desires/needs of a politico is to be re-elected and supported by their constituency. As long as that is true, then there are myriad ways to "buy" influence from them. I happen to believe that the only thing that would change is the type of currency used.

At the risk of shifting the topic, perhaps what we really need are some form of term-limits.

That and an added proviso that campaign funds can not be used for anything other than *direct* campaign efforts and when the politico leaves public office, all (and I mean *all*) unused campaign funds must be fully accounted for and then deposited in the U.S treasury general fund for public use.

-JD-

by yobtaf

If you want to get a full view of what's going on in
Washington, I implore you to watch Bill Moyers on
America: "Capitol Crimes"

http://www.pbs.org/moyers/moyersonamerica/capitol/
index.html

I just want to warn you that it runs two hours long, and
the discussion at the end is crucial. If you start to watch it,
please don't bail out half way or you will miss the point.

by absolutely

They set up an operation in a separate building, because the calls they were making would have been illegal to place using government phones. But, they were still peddling government power, using funds of the Republican party, which were only available to them for the political power of that party. So, why allow any private group to contribute any money to any elected official, in any context? I don't know any reasons that eclipse the importance of keeping bribery out of politics.

by hlhowell9

We threw out King George over 200 years ago because his fuedal policies and excess taxation were unsupportable. We have now replaced him with a new feudal empire of professional politicians, mostly from the legal field (what about the separation of powers?).

We need to do a few things to make this magnificient experiment work right, impose greater government, madness lies that way.

I suggest:
1. Ban lawyers from political office as part of the separation of powers, their path to power is the judiciary, and perhaps a new path to some post higher in adminstrative rank, but still limited by elected officials.
2. NO one holds office more than say 10 years ANYWHERE. This means that once you have done your 10 years you go back to the real world.
3. A. End the states actions of controlling the electoral college. The electorial college was supposed to chose the president based upon their experiences in interviewing the candidates, so that they knew each candidate and would cast their vote as representative of the people that elected them.
3. B. create a new means of selecting the electorial college, such that each member represents 1/30000 of the population in the state. This gives everyone a chance to meet and know their electorial college people. Their election would occur in the middle of the term of president so that they would have 6 months to meet the candidates personally, and to interview the candidate with that interview on the internet so that their electorate could see the process, and know that they were getting fair representation. Technology makes that possible today.

4. No retirement from any public office. This would force the public officials to find and do work in the private sector to provide for their own security.

5. Everyone stop the personal attacks and focus on the benefit of the country.

6. a numerical limit on laws, and no unrelated information in a bill. If more than 10% of the senate or house contests the inclusion of an article in a legislative bill it is stricken from the bill and must be introduced on its own.

7. Any bill addressing science must be brought before the appropriate professional body and debated publically, and must pass the normal criteria for acceptance by that body. No bodies may be created just for a bill to be heard by it unless it is a new branch of science, determined by the first scientific body to hear the bill and only after public debate for 3 years.

8. Taxes must be paid by everyone who claims citizenship. The criteria for proving citizenship is a current tax bill. Welfare recipients are non-citizens in voting, because most normal people given the opportunity to vote themselves a pay raise will at least be tempted to do so. Wellfare is a necessary institution, but should not be a free ride in any country. While on welfare you are a dependent and as such are incapable of chosing correctly until your personal situation is improved by yourself.

9. Tax witholding should not exceed 50% of the collectable tax bill. Everyone signing a check at the end of the year will change our attitude about government more than any other course.

10. At the end of the tax year, the government entities should provide a summary to every individual of the total taxes paid by that individual, or in some cases the average of the taxes per capita to aid people in knowing just how much they are taxed. Again this will impact dearly how government is viewed.

Regards,
OldETC

by absolutely

I think that eliminating the monetary incentives of representatives to obey special interest groups [b]before[/b] the interests of their contituencies is so important as to make election finance issues all but irrelevant. Suppose that a candidate will be banned from accepting [b]any[/b] money, from any entity save the government jurisdiction to which he seeks election, from the moment he declares intent to pursue office. Then, the election finance issues will take care of themselves, because all incentive to corruption will have already been removed: there will be no possiblity of politicians for purchase, regardless of the outcome of the elections!

by stress junkie

Finally a kindred spirit!

Yes. If election funding and lobbying did not allow money from various interest groups to change hands then we would be closer to government that is of the people rather than government that is representative of the rich.

by yobtaf

that in the late 19th century the Supreme Court, I believe,
recognized corporations as an individual. I forget the details,
but by law there is no distinction between a person and a
corporation.

Is there someone out there that knows the specifics of the
law? I'm asking because I don't known how that jive with the
fact that if you incorporate, you get certain tax benefits that
normal individuals don't.

by stress junkie

If interest groups "paid" politicians with the promise of votes then that would be much closer to the ideal. The people who get out and vote should be the only interest group that politicians pay attention to. If the Teamsters can deliver a million votes then that's okay because if the politician favors the Teamsters he is following the will of the electorate.

by justinsvalois

Not that this is supposed to be a political board, and this is way off topic, but this moderate independent is voting republican this year. Tired of the cheap dirty powerhungry tricks the blue are playing to gain power.
(my 2 cents, if its even worth that much...)

This discussion is closed to new replies.