Discussion Locked

Why America is going to the dogs...

0 helpful
42 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Study shows American teenagers indifferent to freedoms.

http://msnbc.msn.com/id/6888837

[i]"The original amendment to the Constitution is the cornerstone of the way of life in the United States, promising citizens the freedoms of religion, speech, press and assembly.

Yet, when told of the exact text of the First Amendment, more than one in three high school students said it goes ?too far? in the rights it guarantees. Only half of the students said newspapers should be allowed to publish freely without government approval of stories."

"When asked whether people should be allowed to express unpopular views, 97 percent of teachers and 99 percent of school principals said yes. Only 83 percent of students did."[/i]

I find this concept TERRIFYING!!! When I'm in my 50s and 60s the current teen population will be running our government. One day, I'm going to walk outside to talk to my neighbor, make an off the cuff comment the likes of "Someone needs to do something about the streets being full of potholes," and be thrown in jail for defaming the city government, without a trial, and without my one phone call. My family will not know where I've gone. A missing persons report will be filed. My body will never be found.

When that day comes, I hope Canada, the UK. and my free-er global neighbors, perhaps Iraq will by then be free... will come to the aid of this country which I can only hope, will be torn apart by civil war, fighting to protect freedoms we once held so dear.

42 replies

by dwiebles

But, there is still somethings that need be considered, in high school, do you remember what expressing unpopular views meant? Being outed socially, picked on, maybe beat up at the monkey bars. So, is there any question as to why a greater number of students vs. adults who hold this view? It is unfortunate, most definetly, but I would like to see a poll of people aged 20-25 as well, to see the change assosiated with moving out of high school and into the "real world" (excluding College). I sincerly hope that this doesn't lead to a civil war in the US, the arsenal available there, nevermind in the whole country, but just in texas, is enough to make me cringe.
I am staying at home in Canada. I am sure there would be only slight deviation in our high school populations if asked the same questions, but I am not afraid of Paul Martin (he's our leader, kinda...)

-DW

by jessie

[i]"The study suggests that students embrace First Amendment freedoms if they are taught about them and given a chance to practice them, but schools don?t make the matter a priority."[/i]

The study suggests, though the article doesn't substantiate the suggestion, that it's a problem of education, not of mere high school peer pressure. I tend to wonder myself though, if the students who CARE about the first amendment protections, feel that way because they were educated via their after school activities, or if they care about journalism (almost always an after school activity) and therefore are more informed about the first amendment.

by dwiebles

Yes, it is entirely possible that lack of education into the importance and application of the amendment is causing a relativey "uninformed" response from students. Having been educated in Canada, and the fact that the U.S. Constitution and it's amendments (I apologize if I am mis-naming or incorrect in anything) don't apply to me in any direct and daily way, I am a little misinformed myself. I am however only a few years senior to high school students, and am basing much on my own changes in the past few years in my personal opinions, world views and political leanings. There is no way I am 100% right in any of my assertions (or even 5%), just wanted to give my viewpoint.

Cheers,

-DW

by awfernald

We have Law & Order and NYPD Blues and CSI on TV to teach kids how to value their rights (I think). And best of all, M-TV is such a great day care assistant.

by admin

"A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed"

If asked: "Should the Federal Government not infringe on the right of people to freely keep and bear arms for the security of their state?"

How many kids would think it's a bad idea for their neighbors to posses certain arms?

Is this because the schools are not making a priority of teaching their students about arms and giving them a chance to practice with them?

Just curious about how this holds up for TR members over time broadly across amendments- even the original ones known as the Bill of Rights.

by dc_guy

During the late 1960s and early 1970s the older generation was petrified by the "fact" that by the end of the century the Flower Children would be running the country. We had exactly one President who represented that subgroup within our generation: Clinton, a free-lovin', pot-smokin', color-blind, pacifist, rockin'-and-rollin' Rhodes Scholar. And that was it. Now we've got the people in power who threw rocks at us while we were demonstrating for civil rights and against the war. Don't make long-term predictions. People are unpredictable.

by jessie

than a warmonger as president... I'd have been a hippie, or at least a hippie sympathizer ;) Hippies don't scare me... but people who don't care about my first amendment rights do.

by protiusx

I would take a serious look at the results of this test. I have been around a few teenagers and I think that time of life is anchored in rebellion and anti-establishment. I was conservative even as a yoot but I still believed in the basic freedoms provided by the constitution. Perhaps that comes from growing up in California. Dude, says it all. Totally. Perhaps given that teenagers are prone to rebellion and anti-establishment and given that today's teenagers grew up threw the 90's they are rebelling against the very flower power tie-dyed love fest, pot smokin' hippies that governed during that time?

by jamesrl

Something to the effect of;

"If you aren't a socialist in your 20s you have no heart. If you aren't a conservative in your 40s you have no brain."

I'll admit I was more conservative in university than I am today. So maybe I had no heart.

James

by maxwell edison

You're pigeon-holing absolutely everybody into one of two groups -- those who protested the war, or those who "threw rocks" at them. Nothing could be farther from the truth. You see, I have first hand knowledge and experience of that time. And generally speaking, there were no "counter-demonstrations" to the war protestors. There weren't any "pro-war" rock throwers, as you suggested. That's a blatant lie, and you should retract your comment. Moreover, the war protestors picked the wrong targets to protest -- at least most of the time.

Sure, they protested outside the White House and such, which is all fine and dandy. But they also assaulted young men who rode a motorcycle to the base while in uniform by running them off the road -- I know; it happened to me twice. They also assaulted or threatened to assault young men who happened to be having dinner in bar and grille while in uniform -- I know, as that also happened to me. They also ambushed weary soldiers at the airports in San Francisco and Los Angeles who were returning from Vietnam, spitting on them and calling them baby-killers. I know; my brother walked through one such mob.

But I didn't assault back, and my brother did not disgrace his country and his uniform be stooping to their level with similar tactics. I just went about my business, and he simply walked through without reply. So don't demean those who did not resort to such despicable tactics.

And the protestors who then called my brother and me baby-killers are the same folks who now protest for their rights to kill babies.

And by the way, lookup who the civil-rights supporters really were. You'll find that the Republicans generally voted in favor of the civil rights act of 1964, while the Democrats -- including Al Gore Sr. -- voted against it.

by dc_guy

We were subjected to more violent counterprotests and general harrassment at civil rights rallies than at anti-war rallies. Frankly I didn't participate in too much anti-war activity. Having a high regard for self preservation, I thought it would be really stupid to get into an emotionally charged argument with anyone who, by definition, actually believes that it's ever okay for people to resolve their disagreements by killing each other.

by jessie

I have no doubt that quite a number of the students are influenced by their peers. I know that I've made MANY MANY personal and character changes in the years since high school... I like myself far better as I am now, than as I used to be.

I would HOPE though that even high school students would be able to differentiate between what you can and cannot say in highschool, and what you can and cannot say in a free society. The fact that half of them think the government should be able to censor newspaper articles is just... harrowing!

by amcol

Same day, different newspaper:

"A National Institutes of Health study suggests that the region of the brain that inhibits risky behavior is not fully formed until age 25, a finding with implications for a host of policies, including the nation's driving laws." - The Washington Post

And with implications for a host of other things, including teenagers' ability to formulate truly informed judgements.

Today's kids are growing up more affluent than any previous generation. Mommy and Daddy provide every single thing little Janey and little Johnny could possibly desire. They don't need to work for anything, therefore they don't need to really think about anything.

Don't harbor the entirely unrealistic expectation that teenagers (as a group) will respond to any serious question posed to them in a thoughtful, educated manner.

Then, there's the little matter of statistical integrity...of which this story is in seriously short supply. It says this was "a study of high school attitudes". What high school(s)? Where? Was the respondent community heterogeneous in any way, and if so how?

The study was conducted by "the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation". Here's an excerpt from their Statement of Values: "It is dedicated to furthering their ideals of service to community, to the highest standards of journalistic excellence and to the defense of a free press." Service to community...OK, I like that. High standards of journalistic excellence...I like that too. Defense of a free press...oh oh, wait a minute. Think these folks have a bit of an agenda here?

Don't get me wrong, I'm violently opposed to any idea that smacks of censorship. A free press is essential to the democratic process. But this study focuses only on results that furthers the cause of the sponsors and as such lacks credibility.

So why was it published on MSNBC? Because it made a good story. It got you to access the website and read something. You saw a few ads while you were there, didn't you? It didn't really result in us learning anything noteworthy, but it did accomplish the goal its creators intended.

As I've said in other threads...the media is not in the business of reporting the news, they're in the news business. It's a business, with a profit motive. We should all be a little more choosy in terms of what we believe and allow ourselves to get exercised over.

by admin

"Yet, when told of the exact text of the First Amendment, more than one in three high school students said it goes ?too far? in the rights it guarantees. Only half of the students said newspapers should be allowed to publish freely without government approval of stories."

Wait a few more years for the kids even younger in their developmental stages during 911 and see what happens.

We are in a "War" that is perpetual now. It has no standards to judge a victory or defeat. We can claim "winning" or "losing" as descriptive of certain points, but not in the traditional "Win" that brings a time when our lives can ever change back to a Pre-Patriot Act America.

Now that we are in a "War" we are acting in the way all generals have known is essential for many many centuries. Sun-Tzu stated it very eloquently in the classic: "The Art of War" many many years ago. We just used to see this as an essential but temporary condition of war. What has changed is that it is now not a temporary response, but a way of life.

The following is an excerpt from Sun-Tzu's writing:

The Principle of Secrecy

On the day that you take up your command, block the frontier passes, destroy the official tallies, and stop the passage of all emissaries. [11:63]

It is the business of a general to be quiet and thus ensure secrecy; upright and just, and thus maintain order.
He must be able to mystify his officers and men by false reports and appearances, and thus keep them in total ignorance. By altering his arrangements and changing his plans, he keeps the enemy without definite knowledge. By shifting his camp and taking circuitous routes, he prevents the enemy from anticipating his purpose. [11:35-37]

by jessie

If there was such a thing... a responsible news organization wouldn't give out the position or plans of our military troops... thereby putting thousands of lives in danger. In times of war, the life of our military is sacrosanct. Their positions and movements should NEVER be given away.

But a law that would require this kind of secrecy from the media would have to be so specific as to be a 200 page treatise on what information can and cannot be made available to the public.

The ratings competition between the different "news" agencies is so fierce, they all seem to be competing as to who can give away the most vital information about our troops. All our enemies have to do is tune in via satellite and they know where all our troops are, and how easiest to defeat them. It makes me SICK!

by sleepin'dawg

Alzheimers or BSE??? Sorry James I just couldn't resist a straight line like that. I was a fiscal conservative back then and I'm still one now. Would that make me brainless or heartless or both?
I do believe in some liberal concepts such as old age pensions, free speech, free press and assistance for those too incapacitated to work but in general do not believe in welfare for those too lazy to work and feel the welfare rolls should be drastically trimmed to get rid of the parasites. ;)
Dawg

by dc_guy

Fiscally conservative but socially liberal. In other words, you believe in minimal government interference in human life. Because despite their best intentions they almost invariably screw it up, because power corrupts, and at their best they do the job for twenty times the cost and twenty times the bad second-order effects as it could have been done privately.

This is the philosophy that used to be called "liberal," until the leftists co-opted the word.

by maxwell edison

.
...in our young people.

Teenagers today are no different than teenagers of my teenage day (the 60s) or yours (whenever).

I see some outstanding young people every day.

More on this later when I have more time.

by g.brown

I mean you want an unbiased, fair and balanced picture where you hear both sides of the argument like wot fox duz.

You really crack me up.....

by maxwell edison

.
I worked with a group of about 100 teenagers last December who, for the previous couple of months, collected toy, clothes, and food donations from various sources, wrapped them up, and made Christmas possible for hundreds of less fortunate families in a major metropolitan area.

I've seen older teenagers who mentor younger teenagers who are experiencing, for the first time, a new school, a new environment, or a period of time away from their parents, making them feel comfortable and helping with their confidence.

I've seen scores of teenagers who have done so well in school that they literally have their choice of colleges to attend.

I've seen teenagers whose insight and wisdom is remarkable considering their limited experiences.

For every teenager MSNBC will show in a negative light, rest assured there are many more that could be shown in a positive light.

Moreover, let's take a close look at this so-called "study". Let's "follow the money", so to speak.

The survey that drew certain conclusions was sponsored by The John S. and James L. Knight Foundation. Who are they, you might ask? Well, they are a private foundation created by the Knight brothers' newspaper empires, and it is, as they describe themselves, "dedicated to furthering their ideals of service to community, to the highest standards of journalistic excellence and to the defense of a free press."

So let's see. At a time when the "free press" is under scrutiny for creating news, fabricating news, attempting to influence elections, and so on, as shown by the Dan Rathergate memogate scandal, The New York Times fabricated stories scandal, an so on, a "free press" foundation is attempting to show that their "free speech" rights might be under threat.

Color me skeptical. This study isn't worth the cyber-paper it isn't written on.

Hey, in my opinion, most parents want their kids to grow up as well-rounded people, and most parents do whatever they feel is necessary to make it happen. This is no different than what your parents or my parents had to face. And in my opinion, these kids will be just like those who came before them. Most of them will turn out just fine.

I'm confident that we're leaving our mess in good hands.

by maxwell edison

.
For all the "parents" who see all these negative things in today's kids (things I've read thus far in this discussion), they better take a look at themselves and how they are interacting with the kids they presume to criticize. Whether a person is willing ot admit it or not, a kid is a reflection of their parents.

by admin

Max,

It is not negative to think that your kids are reacting to the world around them when it is somewhat different than your own generation.

The teenagers today are a great bunch of people as are the younger ones I specified. In the WW2 generations I saw some different attitudes than in my generation and in my generation we didn't have exactly the same issues either- I grew up without AID's and pre 911 for instance- I am not saying the basic stuff of life is that much different, however these things that occur while one is growing up, and the attitudes that come out of those years definately "color" the different generations differently.

People need to be prepared to accept their golden years and realize that yes, things are, will and have changed.

One thing that I believe is quite likely is that our kids will want more protection from the government, and are smart enough to ask that they get certain kinds first. Could you really imagine Thomas Jefferson dealing with our present America? We want (and have) a lot more protection from the governemnt for all of our citizens than he may have had in his day, so this is a longstanding trend.

You know I am a fan of covert ops and winning in a conflict or war. By nature it is of the highest importance that the fewest people ar impacted or injured as possible on both sides. We call it covert ops, but it is a long rich history of an integral part of war that public news releases in wartime -on both the liberal and conservative sides- should be used to save lives and minimize losses. The Cold War was perhaps one of the best examples of this. I would say that the manipulation of information is far better than actually having a physical War with Russia was a positive thing. The same thing is happening now. The difference is, there won't be a lot of catching up and new releases of information until it is safe to do so- which may be a long time.

Personally, I would want more freedom and less government, but my son would like to know when we are in a tall building ( this often gets brought up in elevator rides ) that as we go farther and farther upwards that someone is trying to make sure an airplane doesn't crash into it. I don't think that's negative- just understandably different.

And yes, my child is a reflection of me. I always like that saying actually. It brings out the nuance that he is not exactly like me, but is in my "image". I can learn a lot from a good look into a mirror. :)

by maxwell edison

.
There were no "pro war" demonstrations to speak of - period.

There were no "pro war" demonstrators, supporters, or whatever, "throwing rocks" at war protestors - period.

And I challenge you to support your stupid assertions. Go ahead - prove it.

".....resolve their disagreements by killing each other...."??????

That's meaningless and stupid, and it only shows your inability to discuss things in a reasonable and thoughtful manner. Instead, you have to resort to shallow platitudes.

As far as the violence surrounding the civil rights movement, it came from two sources. One source was the police presence, especially in the south, when they used water cannons and dogs to disperse the crowds, or perhaps from the "Robert Byrd" type KKK idiots, again in the south -- either of whom, had STRONG ties to the southern Democrat movement that voted AGAINST the civil rights act of 1964, and tried to put it down.

The second source of violence came from the civil rights demonstrators themselves. It wasn't the "anti-civil rights" crowd, if there even was such a thing, that started burning the cars and buildings, and running amok in the streets causing the curfews of 1968. It was the demonstrators themselves - you know, the W.E.B. DuBois and Malcom-X crowd.

Your version of revisionist history is contrary to reality.

by jamesrl

And yes, though younger than Maxwell I lived through it too.

No there were no anti-war counter protests - are you asserting that the entire country treated the anti-war demonstrators with politeness and respect? Does Kent State represent Ghandi like restraint?

As for the riots and burnings, I would suggest that those weren't people in the mainstream of the movement, the followers of Martin Luther King Jr(or even Malcolm X after he became an anti-violence advocate and broke from the nation of islam). Those people sought to prove that the non-violence movement had failed to gain its objectives and that their own way - the way of violence - was the only way to succeed.

As for Southern Democrats, I hope you aren't asserting that Southern Republicans were angels either. That would also be revisionist history.

It is unfortunate that you and your family were subject to violence because you wore a uniform. But you pigeon holed democrats and anti-war protestors the same way you objected to the pigeonholing or stereotyping of Republicans as anti Civil Rights movement. One doesn't justify the other.

James

by maxwell edison

.
There were not "pro war" activists at Kent State.

Just like the events in the South where police used water cannons and dogs to break-up the crowd, the Kent State event was broken up by National Guard soldiers who were called in to help control the unruly crowd. And not to excuse those soldiers, but the rowdy crowd would not disperse, and when it got too out-of-hand to keep under control, the National Guard tried to use tear-gas, at which time the protestors threw rocks and bottles at the national guard, and some nervous and scared national guardsmen started shooting into the crowd. So it WAS NOT pro-war counter-demonstrators. That notion is absolutely untrue.

And there were very few, if any, "southern Republicans" in the 1950s and 1960s. The Democrat Party pretty much had a strangle-hold on the southern political scene at the time. (Go ahead, look it up.)

Riots and burning - I was challenging the notion that they were anti-civil rights people. They weren't. I don't care who they were or whom they followed. The message I replied to was wrong, and I simply corrected it.

by g.brown

Sounds like you're the one "revising history"

The media was going all gung ho for the war, so I suppose the pro war people were just happy enough watching it on their telly.

Until of course their telly tells them to do something else:

"But many of the rallies, it turns out, have been organised and paid for by Clear Channel Inc - the country's largest radio conglomerate, owning 1,200 stations - which is not only reporting on the war at the same time, but whose close links with President Bush stretch back to his earliest, much-criticised financial dealings as governor of Texas. The company has paid advertising costs and for the hire of musicians for the rallies."

"Media giant's rally sponsorship raises questions

By Tim Jones
Tribune national correspondent
Published March 19, 2003

Some of the biggest rallies this month have endorsed President Bush's strategy against Saddam Hussein, and the common thread linking most of them is Clear Channel Worldwide Inc., the nation's largest owner of radio stations."

"In a serious violation of media ethics, Clear Channel Worldwide Inc., the nation's largest owner of radio stations is sponsoring massive pro-war rallies in cities across the nation, including Atlanta, Cleveland, San Antonio, and Cincinnati. But that shouldn't be surprising given the company's intensive lobbying effort to undo media ownership rules ? a wish the Bush administration is only too happy to fulfill."

http://www.guardian.co.uk/Iraq/Story/0,2763,922040,00.html

http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/showcase/chi-0303190157mar19.story

http://www.alternet.org/waroniraq/2003/03/000418.html

by jessie

"Laws that forbid the carrying of arms . . . disarm only those who are neither inclined nor determined to commit crimes . . . Such laws make things worse for the assaulted and better for the assailants; they serve rather to encourage than to prevent homicides, for an unarmed man may be attacked with greater confidence than an armed man."
--Thomas Jefferson, quoting Cesare Beccaria in On Crimes and Punishment (1764).

"The constitutions of most of our States assert that all power is inherent in the people; that... it is their right and [b]duty[/b] to be at all times armed."
--Thomas Jefferson to John Cartwright, 1824.

Of course, times change, and our forefathers KNEW this, and provided for it in setting up our system of government... Those of you who think the Constitution of the United States of America is an inviolate and perfect document that need never be changed, should ask yourselves why there are so many amendments to it.

by admin

My point exactly. The interpretation in today's world by the Judiciary should reflect 2005, not 1965. If it gets to be a wide enough gap, then the second amendment will need to be modified accordingly.

Again, to quote The Who, the kids are alright.

P.S. Max, she beat me to it! Well done Jessie :)

by maxwell edison

.
"The constitutions of most of our states (and of the United States) assert that all power is inherent in the people; that they may exercise it by themselves; that it is their right and duty to be at all times armed; that they are entitled to freedom of person, freedom of religion, freedom of property and freedom of the press."

- Thomas Jefferson

"The beauty of the second amendment is that it will not be needed until they try to take it."

-Thomas Jefferson

"The strongest reason for the people to retain the right to keep and bear arms is, as a last resort, to protect themselves against tyranny in government.

-Thomas Jefferson

"I am not a friend to a very energetic government. It is always oppressive.

-Thomas Jefferson

"Most bad government has grown out of too much government.

-Thomas Jefferson

by jessie

The Southern Democratic party was formed before the American civil war. They were the group that believed each state should have the right to make it's own laws regarding slavery and other issues, and that the federal government should butt out.

Today's democratic party (at least in the Northern US) still believes in States Rights, in the value of the working man, and that the government should butt out. We are NOT racists (in general) though we did indeed evolve from a group of people who believed it was alright to own a fellow human being. How many of us are children of grandparents and great grandparents who believed that non-white races were not as intelligent as whites? I am evolved from just that type of parentage... and I am head over heals in love with my husband who happens to be black, and my children are all mixed... Change... it does a nation good.

by admin

Perhaps I just can't find where in The Constitution of The United States of America that it addresses either information on free speech or the bearing of arms.

Anyone interested in our process should really check out the 21rst amendment. It's history shows the process our amendments can through, whether or not you agree or disagree with the 18th and 21rst- it gives a window into the process.

The basics are, you are correct, just as valid today as ever. The time is gone for protection under the 2cd amendment for citizen soldiers to really own and use modern day weapons that would be capable of defending against an attack to a state. The "I'm gonna defend my place with a gun" are living in lala land and a few hard core people owning Tanks and Rocket Launchers are still not going to hold out very long. This has to date, been handled largely in the Judicial branch.

To say that the basics of this amendment are the same as in the 1700 and even 1800's are the same however, cannot be seriously handled anymore. There is no way they meant to limit this originally to "Sporting or Hunting Firearms" and this is exactly what it is today.

Free Speech in the First Amendment is also becoming Technologically different. We have instant worldwide communication for the masses. This is simply too dangerous to allow and if the information networks continue to push this to the extreme it will increasingly have to be reigned in.

My point is that worrying that an amendment is being re-interpreted or even changing- even in the Bill of Rights- is not perhaps the best course. Amendments can and do change over time. That is a fundamental part of why our country works. In fact, if views were not changing generationally.... well, then everyone should be worried.

by jamesrl

I didn't state that there were pro-war protesters at Kent State, or at the White House. But I would challenge you that the Anti-war movement was violent whereas the rest of the country was not.

I didn't say the Democrats didn't have a stranglehold on the south during the 60s and for much time before. But just because they weren't elected to office doesn't mean that there were not Republicans running for office. Strom Thurmond switched from Democrat to Republican in 1964. George Wallace left the Democrats in 1968 to run as an independent. Barry Goldwater opposed the Civil Rights act in 1964 and won 5 Southern States.

The civil rights laws and other issues by LBJ split the Democratic party in two. More than 100 years earlier the Democratic party split the same way (North and South) over slavery, and that brought in Lincoln.

My point is that you suggested that it was Democrats who voted against the civil rights act and republicans for it - I suggest if you either amend that to Southern Congressmen voted against it and others voted for it, you'd be closer to the truth.

James

by maxwell edison

.
This whole tangent started when someone made the suggestion that the "pro war" protestors "threw rocks" at the "anti-war" protestors.

That's untrue. There is absolutely no basis in truth. There were no "pro war" protestors. That assertion came out of la-la land. The only people "throwing rocks" were the anti-war protestors.

Geesh!

by g.brown

Maybe they're more gullible today than they were in those days then.

I mean with all the scares about the non-existent WMD and stuff, this just stinks.

This discussion is closed to new replies.