Discussion Locked

Why are managers firefighting instead of riskfighting?

0 helpful
18 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have been a project manager for 15 years. I know, that a lot of colleagues suffer. A project manager simply does have so many duties!

One of the duties are to keep the project away from risks. I know that the majority of my colleagues doesn't. They are much too busy.

So - my company has developed just the right risk management tool - RiskFighter. Using this tool risk fighting and risk tracking are so easy, that everybody just should do it.

I do not claim that the tool is fancy. But I think that the tool is very useful and easy to use. And most of all - I think that the tool does fight the project risks.

However - in the sales process i have now participated in meetings with about 20 companies. All of them were outmost positive. But nobody are using the tool. It is my impression, that they are too busy.

How on earth is it possible to tell project mangagers, that riskfighting will reduce firefighting? Why don't they see, that rikfighting will provide at much better feeling in there stomack? And most of all - why don't they see, that risk fighting is the best thing they can do for their career??

Best regards
Ren? Jorgensen
www.riskfighter.com

18 replies

by kontakt

Sorry for that. I've got my license to this domain yesterday. I was never here before. So i think two posts are all right.

Right now my life is about risk management. And about selling our risk fighting tool. So that is what i write about. And i really think that it is a problem, when project managers does not conduct risk management.

Best regards
Ren? J?rgensen
www.riskfighter.com

by oneamazingwriter

Treated differently than other workers 08/18/04

That's what it says, and when I followed the link it was your name and the same kind of question.

So from where I sit it looks like you are trying to make sales.

Since members I respect have replied seriously to your post, I will apologize if I prove to be wrong.

by jaqui

most companies use a default allow security mindset.

controlling risks is based on a default deny mindset.

Firewalls are an excellent example of the mindsets, a solid firewall is configured to deny all traffic to all ports by default, then explicitly allow acceptable traffic on limited ports.

most windows based firewalls allow all traffic on all ports unless you explicitly deny it.
[ this has been changing of late, but it still has a ways to go before the default deny is in place ]

You have to sell your prospective clients a different security model for their entire operation to get them to be willing to implement the risk control tool you are trying to sell them.
A far harder sell than a new type of firefighting tool like they already use.

by jmgarvin

I know that sounds silly, but that is the crux of the issue, isn't it?

It means that managers have to think long term and outside the box. They also have to pay more into a system (initally) than just going with the "basics."

My thoughts on selling risk analysis:
1) Put it in dollar amounts. Explain everything from the best case to the worst case. Explain WHY it costs so damn much to lose data and why it takes so long to rebuild (if it is even possible).

2) Provide them with a full risk analysis. @Risk makes great plug-in for Excel.

3) Explain the reduction in firefighting costs over both the short term and long term.

4) Security aspects of risk...A great example is when Valve software lost the Half-Life 2 code.

Good luck!

by kontakt

Thank you for the input. In the matter fact those proposals are in line with what i am doing. And people does buy my arguments. After all risk management is a whole chapter in every book about project management.

So project managers know they should fight the project risks. But they don't do it before it's too late and then it is not risk fighting but firefighting.

Well maybe one should try to scare people a little more.

Best regards

Ren? J?rgensen

by cactus pete

Even if he's having an honest discussion about it, he's still selling his own product. It's questionable.

by oneamazingwriter

I wouldn't have said what I did, if I hadn't taken the time to check his profile and check his other post. According to his profile he's had membership for two years, and he said he just joined.

I don't mind ads on this site because they keep the site going, but I'm not fond of reading one when I enter a discussion.

I'll stick with firefighting my way. I'm a red head. We get firey! :D

by maxwell edison

You were right-on with this clown. His discussion message is tantamount to spam. Not only is his sales pitch disguised as a discussion, but it's a thinly veiled and poor example of one. Moreover, even though I usually refrain from commenting on people's grammar, in this case, I'll make an exception and give him a failing grade in that regard as well.

Just like a poorly written resume, this one is in the trash heap already.

Okay, I gotta' go. I have a tech-fire to put out.

by oneamazingwriter

I mean the little band of people who used to get drunk on weekends and bring their canoes off the island in Maine and torment the white folks! LOL

by oneamazingwriter

is connection to Great Spirit. But we WILL not start another "religious" thread here! ROFL. I have too much Badger Medicine for that!

by oneamazingwriter

doesn't it, that one of the writer's was from Maine. Penobscot is a neat name! A lot of people have never heard of the tribe, yet there's a river named after it.

by tony hopkinson

Corporate managers don't want risks, they certainly don't want to fight them.

RiskMinimiser would have been a better name.

I think you are scaring them off, say risk near a corporate manager is only useful if you can't find a vice, you can use the crack of their arse instead.

Risk is a loaded word, in admin and security risk is a threat. In development risk is the downside to an opportunity.

So who are you selling to, they look at risk in different ways.

Jaqui is principally an admin and immediately associated risk with his side of the job. I'm a developer and I associated it with mine. Ask a PM what risk means to them, I suspect it's context sensitive depending on the project itself.

Also I'm much more of a risk taker than an admin. I tend to concentrate more on the reward side from a development angle, whereas in a straight admin role there is no benefit to a risk.

Minimising risk is a benefit, but there is always a cost, in development and the corporate myopia that generally permeates our industry this means bodge and hope the issue goes away before the next version.

HTHs

P.S. If you'd have couched your question without plugging your product you could have expected a lot more responses like this one.
I've given you the benefit of the doubt this time.

by jamesrl

I really considered not replying to your thinly veiled spam.

But I thought it raised the larger issue.

Why do people think they can subsititute tools for reason? Why do people lean on IT for magic bullets.

Risk management is not rocket science. You decide to do it or you don't. Its the thought and the effort you put into it, not the tool you use to capture and track it.

I used to work at a large scale engineering company that had 4-5 year projects that cost billions of dollars and involved thousands of people. They didn't use a tool, they tracked it on a spreadsheet.

I got a contract at a major bank with billions of dollars in assets. I was asked to do a risk assessment on an IT project worth tens of millions. I had to have it approved by the bank's own risk assessment team. They thought it was great, and it was contained in a word document.

Project managers fight project risks, tools don't fight project risks. Tools can make it easier to do so, and make it easier to track risks but are not strictly necessary. What is more important than tools is diligence.

James

This discussion is closed to new replies.