Discussion Locked

Why are we, as a country, making our children fat?

0 helpful
139 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

139 replies

by apotheon

I rather suspect that if he said anything like that, he was talking about classical liberalism, not this namby-pamby pantywaist Clinton Democrat "liberalism".

by oz_media

Since I started posting here I have been adamantly opposed to people's notion that Canada is a socialist country. There are MANY threads where you can quote me on that one.

Please post a quote and link to where I have said Canada is a socialist country (unless obviously tongue in cheek, sarcasm), we have NEVER had a socialist government, why would I have said that?

by oz_media

I quoted a single sentence and commented on it...nothing else, just the one quoted sentence.

From that, you derive something with regards to the homeless (and obviously decdued that it is 100% due to Liberalisms failed laws), refer to a discussion I am not at all familiar with, then finally catch on that I was laughing at a single quote, then went on to say something you didn't say in your previous post at all.

Like I said, you're clever aren't you.

You sure you're not a woman? (Tip: look in pants, if little nose and jowels are not present, you are a woman).

You have an uncanny ability to create conversations that never occur and then argue points never made.

I honestly think you just make it up as you go, or perhaps you are having conversations with yourself. Do these voices in your head ever shut up and leave you alone?

by maxwell edison

....just as I claimed. If he denies it (which he won't), I'll find the message (because he knows I can).

He said it, by the way, not in a conversation with me, but with another person in the context of "social liberal" issues -- and hating Bush, of course.

by apotheon

He said "socially liberal". That just means stuff like "supports the first amendment, supports Roe v. Wade, doesn't discriminate against minorities" and the like. It doesn't mean "socialist, commie, social Democrat" and so on.

In fact, within the context of the rest of his post, I'm kind of inclined to agree with him. Considering my undying and vitriolic abhorrence of the encroachments of Democratic socialism into my life, and my absolute commitment to free markets, that should tell you something about what he meant.

A classical liberal is basically an old-school libertarian, by the way -- socially liberal, fiscally conservative. This pretty much boils down to "get government the fsck out of my life". If you think that attitude is destroying America, you're high, and I hope one of those "conservative" apoplectic fits of yours thins out the authoritarian herd soon. Every vote counts.

by oz_media

I said, "Well everyone here seems to constantly say Canada is a socialist country, which it isn't, especially now."

now if you think I meant CANADA when I said here, I can see where you got that idea (even though I was referring to TR when I said 'here')but even thn I said, "...which it isnt"

So how, out of THAT did you think that I said Canada was a socialist country???

by absolutely

It was very selfless of you to post that link, as it is completely contrary to the leftist image you're trying to paint of me!

by maxwell edison

I provided the link for all to make their own determination, which they will. And I posted it to show your irrationality and inconsistency, which it did.

I stand by my comments. It looks as though you're running from yours.

by jdclyde

after you were done, was clearly listed, "canada".

Oh, it is a burden always being right, but I am used to it! B-)

Have a grand weekend.

(and yes, I DID take it as tongue-in-cheek, but like I would ever let that ruin my fun?)

You will notice that I did not ever make the claim. SocialisTIC maybe, but not SocialIST.

by oz_media

I change and delete sentences as I go, that looks to be an orphaned word broken off of a sentence I was typing. I hadn't even noticed it said Canada.

BUT....even then, I have not said Canada was a socialist country, anyone here, including yourself, knows I DON'T consider Canada to be socialist. Yes we have many laws in place that are quite reflective of socialism, as do most countries, but we don't have a socialist government nor do we operate our government based on socialism. In almost ANY sense, if something is provided by the government, it can be said you practice socialism. A socialist state would be MUCH different though, as demonstrated in many other nations and as described by JamesRL.

by onbliss

But I will remember that "no one is suggesting that" the next time when I read someone writing about less/more of tax and governments.

Sorry for stating the obvious.

by apotheon

Someone should be saying it. Taxation is unethical. Period. Fees-based revenue systems are at least ethical justifiable -- taxation is just authoritarian theft.

The United States existed just fine without income tax until the twentieth century. Once income tax was finally institutionalized, when the Supreme Court had been stocked with enough Justices that were politically friendly to income tax that government could get the interpretation of law that it wanted, it's just been downhill ever since. The floodgates were opened: the fiscal liberals were able to take over governmental economic controls. The ability to tax provided more money, the money was spent on ridiculous crap, and government got less efficient, so more taxes were levied. A vicious cycle was born.

PJ O'Rourke: "When buying and selling are controlled by legislation, the first things to be bought and sold are legislators."

Benjamin Franklin: "When the people find they can vote themselves money, that will herald the end of the republic."

The end days of the United States have been on us for close to 150 years. It's just a long, slow death, and most of us haven't noticed yet.

by apotheon

EDIT: [i]This post is in direct reply to maxwell edison's post. I have not, at the time of this writing, read any of the other posts following maxwell's post that bear the label "Max message level has been reached."[/i]

1. The term for what we have in the United States, which exhibits characteristics of both a capitalistic market economy and a socialistic managed economy, is known as a "mixed economy". Ours is a primarily capitalisitc mixed economy as a framework supporting significant socialistic structures. Interestingly enough, our economy here in the US also exhibits characteristics of another form of economic structure than capitalistic markets and socialistic managed economies: classical fascism, wherein the lines between government and private business are blurred, particularly in the realm of the corporation (which is, by strictest economic definition, the building block of fascist economies). So: there's no need to invent a new term. Call it a "mixed economy", and if you're pressed for details on what that means, you can relate it to capitalistic markets, socialistic managed economies, and fascism, at least in the case of the US.

2. I've (almost) always heard the metaphor with a lobster, rather than a frog, but regardless of whether it's a Frenchman or a sea-bug, it was dropped in the pot no later than the 1860s. The reason you pointed at about 100 years ago rather than around 150 is pretty obvious to me: you're identifying the encroachment of socialism as the problem. While it's part of the problem, it is also a symptom. The real problem is not socialism so much as it is authoritarianism. Socialism isn't bad in and of itself -- it's bad because by its nature it encourages, fosters, and even requires authoritarianism and tyranny. In case you're wondering, authoritarianism is essentially the basis of government's justification being its own existence, thus engaging the logical fallacy known as "affirming the consequent" whereby the point you're trying to prove is also the principle on which you base your argument: in other words, authoritarianism claims that government has authority over your life simply because it is government. Divine right of kings is another form of, or at least closely related to, unadorned authoritarianism. Tyranny, meanwhile, is simply put governance that violates individual rights, and authoritarianism cannot help but be tyrannical when it holds sway. So, you see, there's a distinct relationship here: authoritarianism implies tyranny, and socialism requires authoritarianism, and ultimately it's the authoritarianism that's the root problem (particularly in the US, where authoritarianism came before socialism).

3. You're absolutely right about property taxes. Anything you own that is taxable (I speak of taxation of possession, such as property taxes and vehicle registration taxes, not taxation of transactions, such as sales tax) is not in fact yours by law. There is a state of ownership whereby the law recognizes your full, unfettered ownership, effectively from the core of the earth to the edge of the atmosphere: this form of ownership is known as [b]allodial title[/b]. You can hold allodial title in real both estate and vehicles, but it's not easy to come by. Typically, when you purchase a vehicle, the true title to it is given to or already in possession of governmental authorities. What you receive is not the title itself, but something called a "certificate of title". In theory, you can "redeem" your certificate of title for the true title, but in practice that is effectively impossible. Your only hope of getting full allodial title ownership of a car is to do something like this:

Find a state where the dealership still holds the title until someone buys a car, and where it is then passed on to the government and you are given a certificate of title, rather than a state where the title is already held by the state before you ever go to the dealership. Make sure it's not a state where you live, or regulations in place will prevent you from getting your hands on the title: it is only the fact of an out-of-state purchase, and the fact that new ownership of the vehicle is not subject to the laws of the state in which it is purchased, that allows you to gain allodial title to your vehicle. Go to the dealership, ensure that you will be granted the actual title rather than merely a certificate of title, and carry out your purchase under those terms. That's it. At that point, you are not technically subject to laws regarding vehicle registration (which is also how they tend to enforce emissions testing, so that goes out the window as well), nor do you even need a driver's license to operate it (in most jurisdictions, at least, though I'm not sure of the widespread nature of this one). Of course, you're still subject to harassment by law enforcement and the IRS, both of which will A) probably not know anything about the realities of allodial title, and will thus make your life hell while you try to find a lawyer that is competent to defend your position in court, and B) not like your uppitiness anyway.

I'm not really sure how Imminent Domain and Kelo v. New London relate to allodial title in real estate. If anyone has any information on that, I'd love to learn something new. I do know, however, that one technically should be able to secede from the United States if one holds land in allodial title, but we know how well that went in the mid to late 1800s.

disclaimer: I am not a lawyer.

By the way . . .

The Social Democrats basically run the Democratic Party. If you hunt up some academic treatments of the term "social democrat", you'll quickly notice that a social democracy is exactly the form of government Karl Marx endorsed. So, yeah. The Democratic Party is run by neo-Marxist socialists.

by aldanatech

That's right Oz. Here I thought I was engaging in a fine conversation about why he believes that Liberalism is the source of many of today's problems. We both agreed that Conservatives can also have such preposterous ideas as those expressed in the articles, but he then he digresses the discussion towards political parties; as if either the title of the discussion or the article would read "Why are liberals from any party making our children fat". My first impression was the we wasn't thinking right at that point, but I just had to read from himself. It would seem that was apparently the case. Let me tell you, I found it quite comical.

by absolutely

The size of the community is being analyzed incorrectly here as cause for a different type of rule, when in fact populations is the aftereffect. The progression from small community to large is made possible only by the previous introduction of better rules that work so well that they continue to function for a larger population than the one in which they were introduced.

by absolutely

In order to fight lefty communism, the government intruded even into private schools with its fitness programs. Yes, the concept of state as nanny is evil, whether you mean the nanny's role as caretaker or custodian. The state is not my custodian. The state has no right to deal with me as long as I mind my own pursuit of happiness, intruding on nobody else's.

by sleepin'dawg

One of the reasons for lard butts. Maybe once in awhile but more than once a month and you're adding to the problem.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

Nowaday some kids are sucking in more calories or carbohydrates in one "snack" than is required to sustain a construction worker all day. This says nothing about the cholesterol, trans fats and nitrates being consumed. Ten and twelve year old children are now suffering from heart disease, strokes, and having heart attacks.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

Back when I was in high school, there was no driver's education in the schools and yet the day you turned 16, if you could pass the test, it was legal to drive. I passed my drivers test precisely on my my 16th birthday but there was no way Iwas going to be allowed behind the wheel of the family vehicle until I coughed up the money to pay to have me endorsed as a driver on my dads policy. Add to that, I was required to pay for my own gas.

How I ever got through my teens without wrecking a car or having any kind of accidents is still a mystery but the answer, I think, is because I was car crazy by the time I was twelve and by the age of fourteen I could hotwire my parent's vehicles if they were away somewhere and left the cars at home. Driving illegally, under those circumstances, actually served to make me a more careful driver than all the drivers-ed courses could have possibly made me.

When I finally did get my own car, it was a 1950 Ford two door coupe which I paid for myself as well as the insurance on it. I paid $35 for it and had to almost rebuild it completely. Even registering in my dad's name to keep the insurance costs down, insurance cost more than the car was worth. I did quite a bit of work on that car and would take it to the drags or out on a quiet road for some pink-slip racing, doing so well, that I was able to purchase a 58 Chev Impalla SS, which I did a number on. I sold that to purchase my first "foreign" car a Triumph TR2.

Because I rebuilt or worked on my own cars, it made me respect the vehicles and the work required to obtain them and maintain them. It was excellent exercise as well.

When my kids wanted to learn to drive, I let them take drivers-ed but I wouldn't let them behind the wheel of any of my vehicles until I was satisfyed they were fully capable drivers. I also made them pay their portion of the insurance but had to subsidize that a bit, because the cost of insurance is insane these days. One other thing, before my kids could pull away from the curb, they had to know how to check the oil, change a tire and/or put air in it. By the end of six months they also knew how to change the oil and brakes on their vehicles as well as the plugs and all the filters. Knowing all that doesn't make them safer drivers but does make them appreciate what is involved in maitaining a vehicle and the costs involved so that they are more likely to be a bit easier on it and thus safer. Wih the increasing costs of operation they are just as likely to walk as to ride and that is no bad thing.

Now if we could only get rid of all the MP3 players and game consoles and limit online computer gaming there might be some hope, but I doubt it. Obesity and fat are like cancers metastasizing throughout the body of our society. Unless people get off their own butts and make their kids get up off theirs, we are only going to see more of this.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

Ernest if you need a Great Dane you might be able to borrow one from Col.

Jd, I keep telling you duct tape for just about anything but this. What you want is concrete blocks and heavy stainless steel chain. You could use a bit of tape across her mouth for the drive to the shores of Lake Michigan. Give her a sporting chance. Only go a quarter mile of shore. If she can swim that distance with half a dozen concrete blocks and twenty-five pounds of chain wrapped around her, then she might deserve to live. Note I only said might.

BTW rowing is good exercize.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jdclyde

is the first person they suspect is the one that is giggling...... ;\

It is funnier than hell. with not working for the last seven months, I really noticed at the boys soccer game today that her a$$ is definately getting bigger! laying on your back for a few months would do that, I suppose! :D Didn't get a chance to say anything about it.....

by jdclyde

STOP BUYING ALL THE "SIT ON OUR ASS" ACTIVITIES!

MP3 players are good, because they can be used on-the-go.

I have for the last two years had a rule for Christmas and birthdays. No video anything.

My boys are very athletic and healthy. I plan on keeping them that way.

I cook much better now too.

We drink water/moo juice/ and gatorade instead of soda. (for the most part)

When I DO buy soda, it is in smaller containers. when you open a container, you drink a container. It is STUPID to buy ANYONE a 20oz bottle of pop and then complain that your ass is five feet wide.

by absolutely

both of the major parties create big government in practice, and only occasionally promise small government before breaking these promises, manufacturing scandal to deflect attention from their dishonesty if necessary. More importantly, the classic dictionary definition of "liberal" is in direct conflict with all forms of authoritarianism, including communism. The fact that the more capitalist of the two major parties also defines itself as opposed to "liberal" ideals is much worse news for the United States than any band of ragheaded terrorists.

by absolutely

I continue to be unable to understand why you believe that the Republican Party is friendlier to your belief in individualism than the Democrat Party. I may not be as old as you yet, but I'm wise enough to admit when I don't understand a contradiction between my observations and my premises. Sometimes, at least.

by absolutely

Just because they [b]can[/b] be taken "on the go" doesn't change the fact that they [b]are[/b] basically a SIT ON A55 device, in practice. Even when I use my Nomad Micro, I lose a couple minutes of my workout picking the "right" album. If I didn't treat musical distraction as a necessity, I'd spend that much more time exercising. They may permit movement, but they also exist for passive entertainment, making them inherently sedentary.

by jdclyde

AB, you may see music as a distraction, but the few seconds I take to put on music is more than made up by the added productivity I get from having toons jamm'en.

Some people turn on a TV, I turn on music. I have music playing in my office all day (currently Marty Friedman). When I am out doing anything that does not require interaction with other people, the ipod is on. (got it free as a door prize at a VOIP seminar that I wasn't even going to go to! :D )

It is also great to get work done when you don't want to be interupted. People are less likely to come up and "chat" if they see you have headphones on. Going back to school, this is a life saver. When I only have so much "free" time to get lab work done, I can't spend it chit-chatting (unless it is with someone real cute).

Like anything, it can be used to sit on your a$$ or to get you going.

Did I mention I can't even fall asleep if I don't have something relaxing playing at night? Maybe some Metallica or Pantera. B-) That used to drive the EX nuts, so I had gotten a "pillow speaker".

I also have nerve damage from years of working in metal shops, and if it is perfectly quiet, my ears start ringing so loud it is deafining. Silence is my enemy.

----------------------

[b]cross link note,[/b] I agree about the rules of society post. It is the improved rules that allow the society to grow, not the growing of society that makes the rules.

by absolutely

I meant my criticism of MP3 players to apply only to the image of working out while jamming. I work much better with tunes myself, but try to work without headphones when I can, just to be sure that I can!

This discussion is closed to new replies.