Why do IT people really bash Windows?
This is page 8 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Windows Forum
This is page 8 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by benoddo53
True you can't blame the O/S if you don't set it up properly and it crashes. The reason I bash Windows has more to do with Microsoft itself rather than its flagship product.
First, Microsoft has engineered Windows to be overly complex, integrating what are essentially applications such as a browser and a media player into the O/S. This has proven to be a bane to Microsoft as this has opened the door to hackers to gain control of systems owned by unsuspecting and often uninformed users.
Speaking of uninformed users, dumbing down Windows in order to sell more copies of the O/S and thereby more hardware has help to spawn millions of users out there that have not a clue about what is going on inside their desktops or laptops. Thus they are prime targets for worms, viruses, trojan horses and spammers.
Lastly, Microsoft has no business getting into the anti-spyware and anti-virus business. This can result in a conflict of interest. As the sole owner of the source code, Microsoft can engineer its own viruses and malware that can only be repaired by its own products. This can make Sony's attempt at DRM protection seem like small potatoes.
by bobhog
I've been in the IT world for 12 years, from a time when bashing Windows was the last bastion of die-hard UNIX heads who despised any opening for common users into what they saw as "their domain".
In hindsight, the first connotations of Windows were flawed but only because some notorious people pointed out the "human" flaws in the software, not necessarily the technical flaws. To this day, despite the greatest efforts of the largest wave of intellectual achievement and greatest advances in computer science, we cannot seem to rid ourselves of security vulnerabilities in our beloved computers.
Why is this? Well, many in the IT industry would simply point the finger at Microsoft. "They produce a flawed product." I say to you, the IT industry, "Prove that Windows is truly flawed." The fact that any company can produce a imaginary product, a product with no physical mass, no physical boundaries, that can allow an semi-educated child living in an undeveloped country to compose a technically complex electronic mail message and send it to a friend 6000 miles away with only a few simply key strokes is nothing short of a miracle. An operating system, a complex entity comprised of billions of dollars in intellectual capital and billions of lines of code, that can allow more than half the world to conduct business day-to-day and that has advanced our human potential well beyond that we experienced during the industrial revolution is nothing short of a miracle.
To say that Microsoft simply ignores the complaints of their millions and millions of users in pursuit of a haphazard, money-oriented goal is truly simplistic at its core. Any company that lacks the capacity to learn and grow is left in the dust. Why has Microsoft, with its "obviously flawed product" continued to lead their chosen industry? Simple. They do strive to create a product free of issues, a product simple for the everyday user, a product that will make businesses more profitable. This is no simple task and until some of the members of my illustrious industry can create an equally competitive product, then they should put their creative energies into working with what they have at hand.
Why do so many in the IT industry choose to bash Windows? Is it the never-ending pursuit of perfection? I say it boils down to a lack of creativity. My industry if full of pushing elbows and scratching to get to the top of the heap. Everybody wants to be the expert or wants to one-up the expert standing next to them. Well, what better way to get noticed than to deride the very product for which you get paid to support? If you can't get noticed on your own merits, then drag down others so you may shine a little more.
Wake up. Windows is not alone in it's security vulnerabilities. Macs, Linux, Unix, Palm, Visual Basic, C, machine code, Fortran, COBOL, hell, the computer that tells the high temperature light on your dashboard to come on. They are all at risk. Why, because of the ever-present "human" element. Everything we create will be vulnerable to exploitation by someone wanting the cookies we are paid to protect. No matter how much we want to believe the big bad Microsoft is the problem, we turn the white hot light off Linda, the office manager who tapes the yellow sticky note of the accounting system passwords onto her monitor. We forget about Ted, who doesn't log out every night giving Dat, the night janitor and grad student from the local tech school free reign to backdoor the network. We ignore Carl who took the phone call from the guy pretending to be with tech support in Idaho who talks Carl into resetting his password. We overlook "Goku09836" who created that neat JavaScript game that your user, Pete, had to download, installing that backdoor. Let's not forget George, the network administrator who doesn't read his security posts from Microsoft and doesn't patch his SQL server and doesn't turn off unneeded services and doesn't block unnecessary ports letting that worm cream the network during peak working time that Friday, forcing management to let everyone out early that day with deadlines looming, costing the company $1.6mil in lost revenues.
The day an operating system can protect us from ourselves would be the day we experience another ice age. I would like to think the "IT industry" would wise-up first and companies would stop putting up with piss poor techs and admins.
That's what I think.
by apotheon
"[i]Why has Microsoft, with its "obviously flawed product" continued to lead their chosen industry? Simple. They do strive to create a product free of issues, a product simple for the everyday user, a product that will make businesses more profitable.[/i]"
They don't lead it, they just dominate it in terms of market share. There's a distinct difference. In addition, the reason they dominate is not an honest ongoing attempt to produce the best possible software: it's an honest ongoing attempt to get people to pay them money. Software only has to be "good enough" in key areas to do that, if in addition efforts are made to restrict the availability of alternatives and engage in other shady business practices of the sort.
"[i]what better way to get noticed than to deride the very product for which you get paid to support?[/i]"
I don't get paid to support it any longer. I made a concerted effort to get good enough with alternative technologies so that I can be paid to support something that doesn't make me want to tear all my hair out on a daily basis. I'm now in the comfortable position of only being driven to distraction by the humans that use the technology, rather than by the humans [b]and[/b] the technology. Half the aggravation. Much better. Ultimately, it was expertise in Windows that drove me from it: the more I understood about how it worked, the less I liked what I learned. I'm finally reaching a point where I'm beginning to surpass my Windows knowledge with unix knowledge, and I still haven't the same bad taste in my mouth related to unices that I have with Windows.
"[i]Everything we create will be vulnerable to exploitation by someone wanting the cookies we are paid to protect. No matter how much we want to believe the big bad Microsoft is the problem, we turn the white hot light off Linda, the office manager who tapes the yellow sticky note of the accounting system passwords onto her monitor.[/i]"
Speak for yourself. I don't forget such things. In fact, now that I don't do work that requires me to spend all my time fighting fires with the technology issues, I have a lot more time to devote to tracking down human-element security concerns. In any case, the fact that anything is vulnerable under the right circumstances and with a determined and clever enough enemy in no way invalidates the assertion that one should not invite the dumb and lazy criminals in with all the silver neatly prepackaged for easy transport.
"[i]Let's not forget George, the network administrator who doesn't read his security posts from Microsoft and doesn't patch his SQL server[/i]"
Let's also not forget Microsoft, who released patches that reversed the effects of earlier patches, thus opening up (again) an old vulnerability so that SQL Slammer could take down significant portions of the Internet a few years ago. Let's furthermore not forget that Microsoft then [b]blamed their screw-up on network administrators not patching their systems properly[/b] for several weeks, probably getting a lot of people fired, before they finally admitted that they might have made a boo-boo in the equivalent of back-page retractions.
by damian
From what I have seen over the years in both Unix and MS OS systems, is everything works fine up to the moment someone decides that there 'is a need to update' something. This is all very normal and understandable, but over the past years it is expected that all of these changes can be done by the click of a button and insufficient funding, resource and time is made available to perform the actions correctly.
How many of you have watch a project completion in a rushed fashion, only to get out on the other side and realise there is no one to support the implementation after the contractors have left and no documentation to boot...
I personally feel the same budget restrictions apply both in our homes, our OS and SW vendors and in our work places.
We all want the best things, but how many corners do we have to cut to get them?
Happy New Year to everyone on the post.
It amazes me that so many people will go out and buy something new for their computer and then spend hrs reading all about it so that they get every aspect and nuance of the product so as not to have any problem.
Then they get mad at Outlook Express, because it isn't working the way it's supposed to.
I then ask "How is it supposed to act an you would not believe some of the answers I get.
Then I go on to discover that they never really took the time and trouble to learn about the thing in the first place and have only a marginal knowledge of how it works. It was put in by the salesman so they let it be.
Most of my clients don't even know that there is a program called Window Explore that let's you look inside your hard drive.
When it comes to Messenger, they're "Geniuses", IE Explorer, passing knowledge but the thing is FULL of useless toolbars from just about everybody you can think of and yet they know how all these tool bars work.
In short they studied. It therefore seems to me that is they applied this kind of dedication to the learning of Windows, regardless of the version, they would be amazed at what windows can do.
As it is now, they barely know the windows system, but are completely knowledgeable about Winamp, or Kazaa or Google just to name a few.When I mention that they should try to study up on their Windows, they look at me like I just slapped them. Then they blame Windows.
So you see, I have come to the conclusion that at least half of the problems would go away, if only people would get into the learning of windows the way they do the useless and pointless add-ons and toolbars.
They don't understand it, it can't possibly be their fault, so they bash the heck out of Windows.
I would highly recommend that the person dedicate themselves to learning as much as possible about the inner workings of their windows, I'm willing to bet that half their "Windows" problems would vanish.
Regards
Aaron :^O
by damian
From what I have seen over the years in both Unix and MS OS systems, is everything works fine up to the moment someone decides that there 'is a need to update' something. This is all very normal and understandable, but over the past years it is expected that all of these changes can be done by the click of a button and insufficient funding, resource and time is made available to perform the actions correctly.
How many of you have watch a project completion in a rushed fashion, only to get out on the other side and realise there is no one to support the implementation after the contractors have left and no documentation to boot...
I personally feel the same budget restrictions apply both in our homes, our OS and SW vendors and in our work places.
We all want the best things, but how many corners do we have to cut to get them?
Happy New Year to everyone on the post.
by pkr9
I don't know why most people bash MS, but I can tell you why I do. I'm no newbie in IT, I started with punched cards in 1967, and hav ebeen through it all - mainframes, Unix, S/36, S/38, AS/400, Netware, Mac, Linux - and Windows from ver. 1.2
Windows is not a technically driven OS - if you want to call it an OS. Windows tries to do everything, and ends with accomplishing nothing. It is a mix of system services and applications, thrown togeter and intermingled in a way that even MS themselves can find head or tails in, as demonstarted my the rising number of security fixes that deconnect elements. When we install a new XP desktop in the office, we are greeted with "congratulations !!, You just bought the best OS for multimedia presentation", or other to the same effect. In this case we DON'T want a multimedia PC, we want a fast piece of office equipment, but alas Mr. Gates has decided that we need the MM stuff. And please... forget about the uninstall argument, because you can't.
Windows is market driven, thats why a new version, always much better and maybe even working, than the previous one is issued every 18 months. And always with big delays and major parts of the promised features stripped off. They go through beta, alfa and RC before getting sold to the public, but the real version to be used by any responsible IT manager has always been SR1.
I have been to many seminars, tradeshows and the like with IBM, Novell, Oracle and others, and NEVER seen a system crash during demonstration. In the MS world it happens frequently, and people take it as a normal thing, and even buy the stuff on their way out.
Would you buy a car where on wheel fell off during the test drive ? Maybe because it coud have been the one-in-a-million failure. But if you previous car of the same brand spent more time in the workshop with all kind of weird problems, tha it was actually on the road, would you then buy the one where the wheel came off? Probably not - why then with Windows.
Why is windows, as the only known product in the world, immunde to it long standing history of armbending, poor backward comability, lack of respect for customer investments, extremely bad security history, poor uptimes, heavy maintenance costs, curing bloated and buggy SW with extreme HW (now we all have a decent sized mainframe under our desks for writing a letter).
I bash MS because their OS is bad, their business methods have been deemed illegal in many courts all over the world, their applications are generally bloated and filled with unneeded and even unwanted features which I can't remove, their pricing reflect their market dominance, and they have shown that they are ready to buy out and kill any opposition that comes up with a better solution.
Microsoft didn't win because people selected MS. MS won due to some nasty agreements (armbending and legbreaking) with OEM's, and as a consequence the general public - and alas also the IT world that should have known better -, got Windows stuffed down their throats. Some companies 'upgraded' form multitasking OS/2 to teh DOS shell W/95. A lot 'upgraded' form Novell til Windows NT network, and today most use AD - which is just about where Novell NDS was 10 years ago.
Why I don't use something else ? I do. Professionally I manage a Windows shop, but ALL critical things runs UNIX. We did a thorough investigation this fall, and found out that we could remove 90% of our dependence on MS without suffering businesswise, and in some fields get big improvements - if management had the guts. I thnk they will in a year or two.
rgds
Peter
IT Manager
by pkr9
I don't know why most people bash MS, but I can tell you why I do. I'm no newbie in IT, I started with punched cards in 1967, and hav ebeen through it all - mainframes, Unix, S/36, S/38, AS/400, Netware, Mac, Linux - and Windows from ver. 1.2
Windows is not a technically driven OS - if you want to call it an OS. Windows tries to do everything, and ends with accomplishing nothing. It is a mix of system services and applications, thrown togeter and intermingled in a way that even MS themselves can find head or tails in, as demonstarted my the rising number of security fixes that deconnect elements. When we install a new XP desktop in the office, we are greeted with "congratulations !!, You just bought the best OS for multimedia presentation", or other to the same effect. In this case we DON'T want a multimedia PC, we want a fast piece of office equipment, but alas Mr. Gates has decided that we need the MM stuff. And please... forget about the uninstall argument, because you can't.
Windows is market driven, thats why a new version, always much better and maybe even working, than the previous one is issued every 18 months. And always with big delays and major parts of the promised features stripped off. They go through beta, alfa and RC before getting sold to the public, but the real version to be used by any responsible IT manager has always been SR1.
I have been to many seminars, tradeshows and the like with IBM, Novell, Oracle and others, and NEVER seen a system crash during demonstration. In the MS world it happens frequently, and people take it as a normal thing, and even buy the stuff on their way out.
Would you buy a car where on wheel fell off during the test drive ? Maybe because it coud have been the one-in-a-million failure. But if you previous car of the same brand spent more time in the workshop with all kind of weird problems, tha it was actually on the road, would you then buy the one where the wheel came off? Probably not - why then with Windows.
Why is windows, as the only known product in the world, immunde to it long standing history of armbending, poor backward comability, lack of respect for customer investments, extremely bad security history, poor uptimes, heavy maintenance costs, curing bloated and buggy SW with extreme HW (now we all have a decent sized mainframe under our desks for writing a letter).
I bash MS because their OS is bad, their business methods have been deemed illegal in many courts all over the world, their applications are generally bloated and filled with unneeded and even unwanted features which I can't remove, their pricing reflect their market dominance, and they have shown that they are ready to buy out and kill any opposition that comes up with a better solution.
Microsoft didn't win because people selected MS. MS won due to some nasty agreements (armbending and legbreaking) with OEM's, and as a consequence the general public - and alas also the IT world that should have known better -, got Windows stuffed down their throats. Some companies 'upgraded' form multitasking OS/2 to teh DOS shell W/95. A lot 'upgraded' form Novell til Windows NT network, and today most use AD - which is just about where Novell NDS was 10 years ago.
Why I don't use something else ? I do. Professionally I manage a Windows shop, but ALL critical things runs UNIX. We did a thorough investigation this fall, and found out that we could remove 90% of our dependence on MS without suffering businesswise, and in some fields get big improvements - if management had the guts. I thnk they will in a year or two.
rgds
Peter
IT Manager
by pkr9
by pkr9
Unless you have very special programs running you could install a new thin client in under 5 minutes. Enrolling a new user would set you back 10 minutes.
Thin clients works well for most users, but I would never even dream of giving a DP or CAD user a thin client. Just as I would be very carefull about giving them a windows PC - they deserve better.
by pkr9
"So are gas-powered SUVs fascism too, and electric cars represent liberty?"
Gas powered SVU's are dinosaurs, and the electric vehicle is the future. The electric vehicle is technology driven, the gas guggling SUV is market driven. A new electric vehicle is evolving around new technology, a new Ford pick-up is not. Just like a new Windows OS is sent to market when MS wants some more of your money, not because new technology is available.
So yes - an electric vehicle presents freedom as electricity can be produced anywhere, and soon by pollution free hydrogen produced by free solar power, which are the most common thing on earth. The gas guzzler runs on OIL, and we know where that comes from and what kind of government is present in most oil-producing countries. By buying their sole export product, which the europeans and americans found and developed for them, we support their fascist systems.
by apotheon
by pkr9
If you don't learn from history or mistakes, or want to listen to tjose who knows history (maybe they were even present) or have made the mistakes, your are bound to make the same errors over and over again.
Rgds
from another guy who was there when the punched card was used, and hate MS for precisely the same reasons as you.
by pkr9
I have firsthand knowledge of an IBM AS/400 which kept churning for 4 years. Yes - FOUR YEARS. In the meantime we changed most of the internals, including all disks with the exception of the one with the system on. And that was the reason for shutting it down - replacing the system disk.
Natrurally it was never infected with viruses, worms, spyware et. al., even though it was on the net for the same period.
On another box we changed it from 48 bits to 64 bits, reloaded all apps and DB's without rewriting a single line of code. We did later, but for other reasons.
I wouldn't dare running an NT box for 8 months without patching - flirting with death.
by han810p9
This is the point I try to make constantly - form follows function - all OS's have their purpose. In our IT department (which I run) we have deployed a mix of Windows, Windows Server, Red Hat, and soon Mac. Each performs a specific function - the function the user specifies drives the form of the OS.
As techs we are becoming more skilled, more marketable in a very competitive IT world - nothing to lose and everything to gain as far as I can see.
by noyoki
Is it logical to say: "The more people that have eyes on a program, the more flaws that will be found and fixed"? There was a study on Firefox, Opera, and IE. Opera was left vulnerable 16% of the year, Firefox (Windows version) was left vulnerable 7% of the year... IE was left vulnerable *98%* of the year.
(If anyone has a link to that study, as it was posted here weeks ago, please let it be known? I have it at work, just not here.)
It's really your choice.
by mwb
by pkr9
Contrary to common belief Windows is not easy or intuitive to use. I'll just mention the classic hit the 'start' buttin of you want to stop.
Windows is easy to use because we all learnt it, some learnt nothing else, and they are shocked tha things could be done in a different way, sometimes more logic, than concieved in Redmond.
If you take 2 'blank' users and place one in front of SuSe linux, and the other in front of Windows XW, the Suse user wil be productive before the XP user, both machines being set-up properly by a trained technician. Windows still after 25 years treat us all as idiots, with stupid "wizards" popping up out of nowhere when you least want it. It install things behind your back, and I have often seen modified settings set back to standard and unsafer settings - and I didn't do it on my _personal computer_.
The user interface changes with every new release, and what's worse the administrative tasks changes dramatically too. The MS crowd never talk about the learningcurve or costs involved in learning these completely new techniques every 2 or 3 years, and the same crowd ALWAYS point of that it will bancrupt your company to train users in the slight differences in using f.inst StarOffice or Linux. Users shouldn't be bothered about learning the OS anyway, it's a job for administrators. Users should be trained in applications, as this is what their job is about.
You know certainly how to uninstall a program in Windows. Run add/remove pgms, select and it disappears - almost or maybe. Ever tried measuring diskspace before installing Office and after uninstalling it, and wondering where the 100 MB or so missing diskspace went?. Tried unstalling in a MAC - dragging it to the trash or uninstalled folder?. And installing it by dragging from the uninstalled to system?
Windows is a mess. It has a major design flaw it will never recover from, demnostrated by this weeks critical fix - that affects ALL windows. So much for the 'completely new and better' we are shown every 2 years. MS has all the money needed to do it better, they just don't care. Why invest money in improving trash that sells as gold ?
by pkr9
"I haven't penciled out the cost of replacing those machines with newer gear, or some magic machine that doesn't need to be patched as much."
I did pencil out how much is cost to run a medium sized (100 pc's 10 servers) Windows shop. I focussed on the desktops, and for one year we meticously registrated every single 'incident', what it was, what we did, how much tiome was used - both supporter time AND user time. My supporter spent 75% of her time fixing desktop related problems (95% MS OS or MS apps) and 10% fixing server issues.
We decided to scrap all desktops execpt a few specialist machines, and replace them with thin clients and 2 Citrix servers. The payback was 6 months, and a much quieter environment both physically and mentally.
Many apps will work under a Citrix environment, and it is really worth the initial work.
Now we service 10 servers, we did a little consolidation in the server room, and 5 PC's. Windows is ailing, but the desktop PC died years ago.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending