Discussion Locked

Why do people pay taxes on their labor to the IRS?

0 helpful
249 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

249 replies

by nicknielsen

So the pie chart that displays the sources of government revenue is not the percentage of the $2,142 billion total under the chart, but the percentage of GDP on the previous slides?

http://piv.pivpiv.dk/

And that's my last word.

by johnbeaman

Maybe you need to find out, like Tom and I did.

"Ignorance of the law is no excuse..."

"Are you trying to say that American law only applies to an individual if that individual is part of a group that is explicitly identified?"

EXACTLY!

"Maybe I am limited,.."

Without the knowledge I recommend you seek, you will remain as limited as you realize you are now. That is exactly why I recommend you find out the truth too.

Here is an excellent place to begin:
http://www.devvy.com/notax.html

by johnbeaman

Do I have to explain to you how to read a report?

I never said it wasn't a percentage. In fact I said that it was.

But, you have to look for a percentage of what?

It is a percentage of all money collected as it relates to the GNP.

That is all it says!

There is no indication of where each individual piece collected

is spent by the government. Does it?

It only tells you how much the government sucked out of the Gross National Product.

It doesn't say that some sources have specific allocation, or laws that tell where that specific source of money has to be spent. You are assuming it is all goes into one huge general pot that all the government spends from. Don't be fooled. Not so.

Example, SSI cannot be spent on anything except SSI benefits for those that contributed. (and the overhead of that function).

Since it is a "stand-alone" package, and has nothing to do with "income taxes", why do people think that "income taxes" pay their government managed retirement (SSI)?

Because they read stuff like this and make too many incorrect assumptions.

by johnbeaman

I give it to you and you you still refuse to believe.

He didn't file a 1040 at all because the IRS couldn't prove that you have to file a 1040.

So you say but really where is the proof?

That is what the court said.

Well I say that he didn't get convicted because he's Pink with Purple Polka Dots

The court did not say that, so my discussion with you has ended because you are more interested in propagating your ignorance in a foolish attempt to prove me wrong.

Go tell the courts that they are wrong instead of harassing me when I relay the facts from the court to you.

by johnbeaman

Your reply has to be the biggest pile of horse crap I have ever heard from anyone.

Everything you state here is a total lie based on misconceptions and propaganda.

You have to be the most ignorant of the facts and the truth than I have ever come across in years.

Please take the American flag avitar off your posts because you are effectivly wiping your ass with it in what you have said. And many of us here don't appreciate it.

Forget the original constitution, because it's not 1776. The laws have changed so much over the past 200+ years since the constitution was written that the original document is no longer applicable to modern day law.

The Constitution hasn't changed, and many have died to uphold that documents statement.
It is the base-law of our country, has been and always will be until idiots like you convince more like-gullable people into believing your diatribe.

The constitution does not dictate federal and state fiscal policy, which is why the IRS and Treasure Departments were created.

The IRS is a private corporation, as is the Federal Reserve. Where does it say that they has the power to dictate fiscal policy over our Constitution? Your ignorance is amazing.


When the constitution was written, there was no treasury department and the founding fathers did not mention taxation because of the issues they had with paying taxes to the British monarchy.

I think you need to get a copy of our Constitution, Bill of Rights, and Ammendments, and read them, because that statement is proof positive you never have.

With that stated, how does a nation support its military, roads, infrastucture, etc. if it does not levy taxes from its citizens?

No one ever said there were not taxes. The US government ran fine for many years without the "income tax". It was well funded for all it's assigned purposes. The "income tax", one of many collected, does not go to our government, and pays for none of the services you indicate. That comes from other sources.

Where will the money come from? The gov't can't just print more money or pull it out of their behinds!

But they certainly CAN "just print" it.
That is the responsibility of the Treasury Department. Which is part of the Government, and guided by our Constitution.

I cannot believe you are really this misinformed and that ignorant.

Do us all a favor and STFU until you read those documents. You are a discrace to us all.

by johnbeaman

When someone states what a court decision was?

You can find the statement of results in many places.

Because you don't like one persons reporting it does not make the facts of the courts decision inaccurate or nonfactual. This is the point being made here. You seem to have lost all touch with that.

Just more of your distractions because you refuse to think that it might be true, and make you look like a fool for having paid that extortion money. Avoiding the truth because you don't like the person tellin it to you is quite childish.

You are more interested in trying to show me wrong than addressing what I am even talking about. Maybe you don't even know what that is.

Your extensive ignorance will continue as long as this is your only purpose here.

by johnbeaman

Do you have links for where the military funding comes from?

I said that the "income tax" was allocated elsewhere, just as the SSI money is also allocated elsewhere. It doesn't pay for our military, even though some SSI money is "borrowed" from the SSI trust fund while they manipulate money from one area to another to balance the budget. (or attempt to).

The Donald Duck reference was his message to pay "income taxes" as if it were a patriotic thing to do. It is not, in my opinion and my research, it is a fraud because we get zero services from it, and it is extortion because you are so fearfull in not paying a tax you don't owe, legally, and yet you still pay it.

Pension/Disability plans are not paid by the Income Tax, so where are they being paid from?

They are paid for from SSI contributions.

by johnbeaman

I have read that, and in looking deeper to see who it applies to, which is not me, I find out it is irrelavant. So how does this apply to the average taxpayer? It doesn't. How did it apply to Tom, it didn't.

,br>
If it was that simple, why was that presentation not proof to the court in Toms case? Because it does not apply. It didn't prove that he owed "income tax" and it shouldn't to you either. (unless you are sufficiently gullable and ignorant to accept that small pice as the "whole" law on the subject.) BTW, that is IRS code,

by nicknielsen

http://devvyconklin.tripod.com/fakery.html

And a direct quote:

Devvy's idiot income tax arguments are so old that the courts will not even hear them anymore.

[Footnote 7] The opinion stated, 882 F.2d 1263, 1268-1269, n. 2 (CA7 1989), as follows:

"For the record, we note that the following beliefs, which are stock arguments of the tax protester movement, have not been, nor ever will be, considered `objectively reasonable' in this circuit:

"(1) the belief that the sixteenth amendment to the constitution was improperly ratified, and therefore never came into being;

"(2) the belief that the sixteenth amendment is unconstitutional generally;

"(3) the belief that the income tax violates the takings clause of the fifth amendment;

"(4) the belief that the tax laws are unconstitutional; [498 U.S. 192, 199]

"(5) the belief that wages are not income, and therefore are not subject to federal income tax laws;

"(6) the belief that filing a tax return violates the privilege against self-incrimination; and

"(7) the belief that Federal Reserve Notes do not constitute cash or income.
Miller v. United States, 868 F.2d 236, 239-41 (7th Cir. 1989); Buckner, 830 F.2d at 102; United States v. Dube, 820 F.2d 886, 891 (7th Cir. 1987); Coleman v. Comm., 791 F.2d 68, 70-71 (7th Cir. 1986); Moore, 627 F.2d at 833. We have no doubt that this list will increase with time."

by av .

I don't have a link to his transcripts, but here is an interesting discussion you might like that could lead you to what you're looking for. http://www.suijuris.net/forum/taxation/12035-tom-cryer-takes-irs-3.html

I've worked with many lawyers in an IT capacity. Lawyers, believe it or not, are very ethics oriented. They will not hesitate to send one of their own, however, to the big house if they violate ethics laws and I've seen it happen. Lawyers conduct peer reviews and rate each other. We should have something like this in the IT world.

Tommy Cryer is CV rated. This rating is a big deal to lawyers. A CV rating isn't bad, its mediocre if you've practiced law for many years. Here is an explanation of what that means.

http://www.martindale.com/ratings_explanation

If I do come across some other links, I will post them. I've yet to talk to the tax attorneys I work with about this case.

AV

by johnbeaman

"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary
safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."
--Benjamin Franklin

The threat of jail.

You can't seem to put two thoughts together, can you?

by the scummy one

Why should I risk Prison right now? The lower courts cannot even use these as a defense, so what would be my reason to just quit paying taxes and get away with it?

by johnbeaman

You seem to put more faith in rhumors than fact.

Where does it say: "The lower courts cannot even use these as a defense.."

OK, you mind is made up, I'll quit trying to confuse you with facts.

"If ye love wealth better than liberty, the tranquility
of servitude better than the animating contest of freedom,
go home from us in peace. We ask not your counsels or your
arms. Crouch down and lick the hands which feed you. May
your chains set lightly upon you, and may posterity forget
that ye were our countrymen."

-- Samuel Adams

by faradhi

The web based system called PACER, charges 8 cents a page. Your saying that the transcript is 20,000 pages. Just how long was that trial?

by johnbeaman

You are more interested in creating a tangential argument than persuing the issue.

That price was mentioned in a link/reference I provided above.

Now you insinuate I claimed it was 20,000 pages?

How long was the trial?
More trivial distraction.
If you are so interested in trivia, go find out for yourself.

by faradhi

This is another example. Someone posted on a message board that the transcripts are $1,600 and, with out even questioning it, you parroted that here.

You see, I question everything. I especially question anything posted on a message board. That seems to be the difference between you and I. That is why here at TR the one who makes the assertion has the burden of proving it. You have failed miserably in proving anything.

Your post that included the statement that the transcripts cost $1,600 did not in anyway state that you read it on a message board. It was stated as if you knew it was $1,600. So I questioned on how you came up to with that figure. So I decided to look up how much the transcripts would be. That is when I found PACER and discovered it charges 8 cents a page. That is how I came up with the 20,000 pages.

I was not in any way insinuating that you claimed it was 20,000 pages. I was insinuating that your information was incorrect. The question about the trial was sarcasm. Now, you blame the message board. Well, here is a lesson for you. Do not believe everything posted on a message board. I know it is shocking to you that someone would post something not true on the internet but it does happen.

My point in all of this is that it seems that you take what comes from a message board as fact. As such, I have to question your facts since you have prove to take so called facts from what I would consider questionable sources.

You seem to be hostile to questioning. This is often a sign of someone who's facts are not a substantial as one would like you to believe. In fact, the responses like look for yourself or it is not me to hand you the answers, sounds more like responses I would get from a cult leader.

Oh, btw, I have seen your website and I must say that quoting yourself is a sign of quality and you should do more of that.

by naturatek

I love when someone simply point people to written hidden truths about something, and they get all fightish on it, ready to kill the obvious truth.

It doesn't take a Einstein intelligence person, or 10 college degrees for someone to see certain truths.

People, you are missing the point in what JBeaman is saying, he is directing you to hidden truth. Its your choice to educate yourself more in this area if you wanted to.

We all know there are hidden tips/tricks/rules in life that benefit is, but you don't see them being presented to us in commercials/advertisments/etc, we dig for them don't we?

Taxes do piss me off in a sense. I would understand if there was like one type of tax, but there are all kinds of taxing mulching at your hard earned income.

I always found it strange as a teenager, how someone works, gets paycheck and get taxed a good half their checks sometimes.

One thing I don't understand. If you get paid, you check is already taxed federal income tax, state tax, city tax, medicare, social security, and those BS welfare tax known as SDI in NJ...then after your check has been taxed, everything else you buy is also taxed. So if someone makes a 300$check, they will have the above taxes taking out, and out of the remainder, pretty much guaranteed they'll pay 7% taxes (in NJ) for anything else you buy.

Then comes your utility bills, Fcc tax, 911 fee, cable tax, tax this and tax that.

If you buy something nice like a good car or house then you pay luxury tax, land tax, house tax, rental income tax, and whatever else tax comes with that.

Then I see these very same ppl struggling to make ends meet get a second job somewhere like a department store or 7-11. But making more money technically means they will take more.

Haven't we all been there? We get that 5,000 dollar raise a year but only to see by federal tax guidelines they will actually take out more?

And I love those people that say "well my retirement taxes are gonna help me live". Hmm, I hope you get tons of taxes taking out for your retirement if you really are gonna 'depend' on that solely as your retirement income. By your 80s-90s inflation might have gone up, different rates, etc..so your little social security retirement is gonna be enough to live in some crappy nursing home (if that) eating ramen noodles and buying 2nd hand clothes to pull thru. Ahh.. I'm sure theres a nursing home tax too.

Don't believe me? Go speak to old folks in your community / local nursing home. See exactly how they living on their 'tax' retirement, especially those that are living off their 1950's retirement, that era payrates where cheap. Not much taking out.

You might make 25dollar per hour now, by the time you are retirement age, maybe the typical payrate then will be around 125$ per hour, so your retirement funds will be dealing with expenses of that new era.

Oh, and maybe, just maybe when you are old and your greatest accomplishement was buying that tiny house by a river, might just be taking away at your old age, because you are not making ends meet with the current tax, or after decades, they found a discrepancy in your returns of that tax you didn't pay somewhere. Don't we hear of cases like this often?

We should educate ourselves a little more, and not rely on some tax funded retirement.

by w2ktechman

taxes are way out of control. retirement funds will likely also not be enough. I would also like to say that we pay way too much (from tax money) to other countries for many different things that most people would likely disagree with.
I have spent quite a few hours trying to determine if I could get away with not paying taxes, or only paying for the parts that I agree with.
An example of that would be back in the 80's. I was on my own, making just above min. wage. I had to go to the hospital. But I didnt qualify for help from the state because of my race. I complained, the lady finally gave me a form to fill out. first 7 questions were to determine race without actually asking. When I turned it in, she looked at the first 3 questions and disqualified me. If it were up to me, I would not be paying that portion of state tax.
Personally, since I am not a lawyer, and I do know many lawyers who do pay their taxes, I am not inclined to risk prison.

by nicknielsen

[i]I would also like to say that we pay way too much (from tax money) to other countries for many different things that most people would likely disagree with.[/i]

Just how thin do you wish to shave that particular penny? Foreign aid traditionally amounts to less than 1% of the total budget ($15 billion in 2001, http://www.usatoday.com/news/sept11/2001/12/04/foreignaid-usat.htm) and over 60% traditionally goes to humanitarian aid such as innoculations, famine recovery, etc.

When you consider how much is wasted inside the US because of congressional earmarks, I don't miss that penny at all.

by johnbeaman

There are two problems here...

1. "if I could get away with not paying taxes"

You sound like it is cheating, when it is the IRS who is cheating you. How do you "get away " with something you arn't required to do?

2. "Personally, since I am not a lawyer, and I do know many lawyers who do pay their taxes, I am not inclined to risk prison."

You don't have to be a lawyer to know the truth. Our founding fathers expected people to be knowledgable about how our governments works, without having to be a lawyer. Lawers can make this same mistake. Where would our country be if not those willing to risk prison? It wouldn't, and all those that cower are riding the backs of those great men that chose to do whats right in your behalf.

"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary
safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."
--Benjamin Franklin

by johnbeaman

You are correct.
Thanks.

Seems people are more interested in bashing those that pull their pants down, than realizing that they have been provided a gift.

I don't have to tell anyone what I found out.
Everyone can continue to pay the extortion because they are too lazy to accept that there may be some truth to all this, and dig further.

I am not selling anything, and all my time in replying to these posts is an attempt to help them, but they would rather sit on their superstitions and old-wives tales, and all the propagated propaganda than to act like an intelligent adult and discuss the matter in that light. I expected more from a forum of technical professionals. Where is the inquisitiveness? Where is the logic that you are all supposed to have? All you can do is attack the truth out of ashamed ignorance instead of inquiring into the possibilities presented.

Sorry people, you have been duped big time.

Laughing is a natural reaction when you have been caught.
Continue to laugh, but attacking someone like me is rude and childish.

"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary
safety deserve neither liberty nor safety." --Benjamin Franklin

"Nothing in all the world is more dangerous than sincere ignorance

and conscientious stupidity." --Martin Luther King, Jr.

"Great spirits have always encountered violent opposition from
mediocre minds." --Albert Einstein

"Arrogance and rudeness are training wheels on the bicycle of life -
for weak people who cannot keep their balance without them." --Laura Teresa Marquez

"Condemnation without investigation is the height of ignorance." ?? Albert Einstein

"First they ignore you. Then they laugh at you. Then they fight you. Then you win."
--Gandhi

by nicknielsen

[i]Where is the inquisitiveness? Where is the logic that you are all supposed to have?[/i]

My logic tells me that the laws of the United States apply to all residents of the US, not just those who might be specifically identified in those laws. The law states specifically that I must both pay taxes (26 USC 1) and file a return (26 USC 6011). Therefore, I follow those requirements.

And my inquisitiveness calls me to ask if what you are smoking is legal.

All of your arguments are debunked starting on this page: http://www.irs.gov/taxpros/article/0,,id=159932,00.html#_Toc153765503. They have the courtesy to provide actual references to applicable law.

edit: type, post, proofread

by johnbeaman

You are again ASSUMING that these apply to you.
Again: As mentioned in any code or law, "a person" is not necessarily you.
You have to look for the assignment clause.

The debunkers have a lot of fun with their limited research, as they jump to conclusions
when they quit looking further. As soon as they "think" they have the answer, they stop digging.

It comes from the usage of words, and the law is very strong on the fact that words matter. They also define most all words and phrases elsewhere. You are supposed to know what those words mean for legal application. When these definitions differ from the commonly used meaning, you are led astray by assuming their meaning to be what the public "thinks" it means.

I have been there many times, and if you stop short of tracking the application of these references, you would think it applies to you, but it does not. That is why the "debunkers" come to those conclusions.

1. The Feds cannot tax you on your income.

2. Your labor is not taxable.

The Feds can only tax on interstate and international activities.
It has not the jurisdiction to do otherwise. ref: THE Constitution.

3. No law can contradict the Constitution.

If you want to think that section 26 applies to you, then you are sucked into the fraud thru ignorance of the complete law (definitions?).

This is not easy to decypher, by design, to make you think "a person" is specifically you. The complete law says it is applicable to "whomever", and if you ain't one of them, it cannot possibly apply to you. If you keep looking for these definitons you will find that the Fed cannot tax you on an activity that you are not doing. (makes sense?) If this is true, then how can the "person" in all these references you read and share be about you?

They aren't.

Your reference/link is about "Payment of tax is voluntary" where they keep refering to the "taxpayer".

Look up the exact definition and application of the word "taxpayer". It is NOT someone that is required to pay this "activity tax" where that "person"'s income is used to calculate the amount, it is a person that IS ALREADY PAYING THIS TAX, for whatever reason they chose to.

Once you realize that all of this may be true about someone, but not you, you will see that you are off on an unrelated (to you) tangent.
You are arguing the details about something that doesn't apply to you, so why are you arguing about it?

Interesting questions:
1. When you get your car fixed, say $2,000 total bill, why do you not send them a 1099?
2. Why are the parts taxed and not the labor?

Then why would someone 1099 you on your labor?

Because they "assume" it is proper. Thay are not tax experts, so they go along with the crowd. Don't go along with the crowd. Find out the truth. Stop reading pieces of the law, and jumping to conclusions as they all have. You have to connect the dots backwards to see that all of this does not apply to you. That is what Tom did.

Parts are taxed because the price is marked up, and that is an activity. It is called "profit". Profit is taxable. Labor is not "profit" it is your "right". You own your labor and you trade it for money. There is no profit or "gain" involved. Therefore: not taxable. (the feds can only tax "federally controlled activities anyway, not "income".)
Also labor is property, not an activity.

Don't assume that "gross income" means "everything that comes in" as they would like you to believe. It means (defined) "Gross Taxable Income Amount". And, if it aint taxable, then the rest is not applicable.

Remember that the tax code is MEANT to make everyone think it is applicable to them, but it is not. If it did, then Tom Cryer would have been found guilty.

The "taxpayer" is someone that files a 1040.

You can become a "taxpayer" three ways:
1. The "taxable activity" required you to file, so you did.
2. You "volunteer" out of the kindness of your heart, so you filed.
3. You volunteered, and filed, because you ASSUME it applies to you when it doesn't.

It makes no difference why you do it, only that when you choose to, do you become a "taxpayer" and suddenly all those laws are now applicable. It is all based upon your assumption that it applies to you and you chose to pay whether you actually owe it or not.

If the IRS cannot show law that says you have to file a 1040, and you choose not to file, you are not a "taxpayer" and all those phrases like "from whatever source derived" do not apply to you.

So go ahead and reference and link and quote all you want, but if it is not applicable to you, why bother arguing about the details of the reference?
It only distracts you from finding out if any of this actually applies to you. (by design)

If someone sends you an invoice for something you didn't buy, why argue the amount? Or the color of the paper, or the size of the form, or whether it had enough postage?

Same thing here.

Remember:
We are NOT a "democracy. We are a republic.
A "democracy" is where the "majority rules". Like in a gang rape.
Don't be "raped" because the majority assumes what they "think" is the law.

Tom didn't, Vernice didn't, I didn't, and neither should you.

Tax Evasion is a crime. Tax Avoidance is not.
Tax Evasion is when you file a false 1040.
Tax Avoidance is when you do not file one, legally.

Not filing a 1040, when you are not required to, is not cheating. It isn't "getting away" with anything at all. And it makes no legal difference if the majority thinks/says that it is.

Remember that if the jury and/or the judge don't know tax law (they don't), or have preconcieved notions about it (they do), they CAN rule against you (and have).
If the "majority" believes a falshood, then this is expected. It still does not make it the law, or the truth. Tom and Vernice were successful in showing that all these rumors, and preconceved notions were wrong, and asked the IRS to show othewise. (and they could not.)

by nicknielsen

[i]Your reference/link is about "Payment of tax is voluntary" where they keep refering to the "taxpayer". [/i]

You are obviously not intellectually equipped for this discussion.

Bye!

by johnbeaman

You are too interested in bashing others and holding on to the non-threatining lies.

Bye?

Good riddance, some want to know the truth.

by johnbeaman

Why give Mexico aid when they promote illegal immagration to the US?

Why give North Korea aid when they threaten us?

Why do we do this? Where does it say that our tax money should go to helping anyone?

"I cannot undertake to lay my finger on that article of the Constitution which
granted a right to Congress of expending,
on objects of benevolence,
the money of their constituents...."
--James Madison--

"It is a precedent fraught with danger for the country, for when

Congress once begins to stretch its power beyond the limits of
the Constitution, there is no limit to it and no security for
the people...
... the Constitution, to be worth anything, must be held sacred
and rigidly observed in all its provisions."

--Colonel David Crockett-- A.K.A. Davy Crockett --

--Member of the U.S. Congress 1827-31 & 1832-35--

by big ole jack

who like a brainwashed cult member keeps repeating his same old schpiel no matter how many times we disprove his nonsense with actual laws and facts provided by the IRS and US Treasury. If he wants to avoid paying taxes and risk getting locked up in prison, then that's his choice, but I certainly will not be pressing my luck and engaging in what I know constitutes tax evasion/avoidance.

by johnbeaman

Seems this subject is too foreign to your assumed BS that you like to repeat over and over, as though it could become the truth if you did. That is what Hitlers Minister of Propaganda believed too.

If you don't even understand the difference between Tax Evasion and Tax Avoidance, then why are you bothering to write your BS here.

Do like NickNick and just leave the chess game, as you barely have a checkers mentality.


"If a Nation expects to be ignorant and free in a state of
civilization, it expects what never was and never will be...
if we are to guard against ignorance and remain free, it
is the responsibility of every American to be informed."

--Thomas Jefferson--

by johnbeaman

I read a lot of stuff, and I read (somewhere) that the cost was $1600 for the transcripts.
The point I was making was that it is expensive, and I am not going to buy it to refute some chicken s#it little detail. I am sure you my find a different source for the material and the cost may be different, but that was not the reply I got, what I got was another question asking me if it was 20,000 pages. Some act as if I make all this up, and prefer to criticize my spelling or that a trial quote is somehow suspect because of who reports that quote. It doesn't make the statement said at the trial questionable, and I provided multiple sources for the same information from other sources, and they are the same quoted information.

So why, on such a serious subject do people feel so compelled to have fun with trivia? I don't appreciate the ignorant claims by others that have obviously never studied this material, like we have a flexible constitution, that its laws can be rescinded, or that the 16th amendment gave new power so that we all owe this tax. They laugh when I quote supreme court statements that say differently, but they just want to laugh about it all.

I am sorry, but to makes such ridiculous claims against our constitution and laws just to rile me is not appreciated. I thought we could get serious here, but too many just want to have fun with it. This is not about fun, it is about most of the people in this country being hosed, and suggesting they go deeper than the surface to find out why.

It is obvious that there is something to this if Tom Cryer was found not guilty because the IRS and the feds could not prove that he was required to file at all. Those are facts, and yet people want to be sarcastic about one of the sources of those facts. They want to derail the conversation, not address the seriousness of it, and the implications. That is childish. Most of these people having fun at my expense also post this kind of crap all over TR for the same reason. They have nothing to offer the readers but their sarcasm. They derail serious subjects with tangential crap that makes it so the typical passersby leave in disgust, or jump on the fun and games to make it worse.

It gets frustrating, and I apologize for being curt, but you have to make claims from your research over the course of 30 years of study that you may not remember exactly where you got the information. Many times it is from multiple sources, other professional opinions that quoted court documents. The volume of information required to generate the positions I take is way too much for this board. I also never intended to give a course in tax law. I intended to say that it is not as every one thinks, and recommend they find out why Tom Cryer and many others have made their case and won in court.

Example of this is the 20,000 pages question.
How bout we say that I accept the courts ruling, and I know why/how Tom did it. I don't need to buy the transcripts, but others may want to. They are expensive, and I am not going to buy them just to shove some more facts down someone throat that doesn't care to learn, but only wants to find fault until this thread has 1 million pages with his name all over it.

The problem with message boards is there is only typed text, and many times it is difficult to tell if someone is funning with you.

Sorry, but if it is really that important to you for me to spend my time looking for where I read that the transcripts were $1600, I will. If you are doing it just to slam me for your own enjoyment, then F U.

If you accept the notion that basically what I claim might be true, then lets address it intelligently. Just remember that picking at details, or making outrageous claims, unsubstantiated, while at the same time asking me to substantiate every little detail that you want to pick on will take years, and seems the purpose of may posters here. Sorry, but I try to accomplish something of value, not play chase the white rabbit for fun and games.

Again, I go back to the original purpose of this thread....

If Tom got off, why are so many still paying?

All I got was in incredible amount of disinformation, old wives tales, BS and unsubstantiated claims by foolish and ignorant people. Being ignorant is only that, not knowing much about a subject. I am ignorant about brain surgery, so I don't try and argue from a knowledgeable position on that subject.

I can give you more links for study on this subject if you are interested, as my time permits, but if all you want to do is find fault, I don't care to indulge you, I have to work for a living.

I have answered the few posts with specific directions so they can find out more, and steered a few back on track. I will do the same for you, but I cant give you all the answers of 30 years of study, not every reference I have read, only my conclusions based on the facts I have read.

This is a huge fraud, extortion and conspiracy that the people are doing to themselves by propagating all this crap like BigOleJack(ass) and his disinformation. I tried to address his misunderstandings, but all I get is tin-foil remarks to which I really don't have the patience for.

Peace, my friend, and I hope I can help.

If not, please don't harass me for the sake of your amusement. This is too serious a subject for me to play games here.

People ask me to substantiate the cost of trial transcripts, but woudn't bother to find out WHO is liable for this tax. Tom proved it ain't us. Some are so ignorant they still think it is a "tax on your income" which it is not. How do they know differently from what I claim? I have done 30 years research on the subject, I see Tom win on what I have learned, and yet people here claim their ignorant, misled BS should carry more weight?

They don't even get the title of this thread. It is a play on words. There is no tax on your income. No such thing, the constitution prohibits it. The 16th ammendment clarified that, and yet everyone thinks it says something else. Guess what, They are supposed to so the IRS can extort money from you.

Or, where is my retirement money going to come from if we all don't pay this tax? Uh, how about a retirement program you joined, like Social Security, or private plans. The misinformation and propaganda and extortion tactics have beat you into believing this crap. I say, like me, Tom and many others, You have been duped. Learn why, research it, dig. It ain't what you think it all is.

Sorry bout that.

Sorry bout that.

by nicknielsen

You criticized many here for only quoting "parts" of the law and ignoring the whole. You were provided a link that debunked your claims using multiple instances of current case law. You chose instead to quibble over definitions.

by johnbeaman

You may have misunderstood Nick.

What you are seeing is that people quote parts out of the context of this extreemly large and complex issue. It is not easy to see the whole picture when you view it thru a soda straw. If it was as easy as they think, then the solution would be easy too. It's not. That is also why many fail in court, and only a few properly prepared people win.

All I was saying is that you have to dig thru a lot to see it. They make it complex and confusing on purpose.

If it was easy, more would be not paying it.

I am not criticizing the responders here near as much as I am trying to tell them it is a lot of work to find out why Tom Cryer was found not guilty.

If he was, then there must be a reason, and the short sound bite phrases and single documents are not going to show you the answer.

If you are only trying to prove me wrong, then you don't get it.

If you think there may be something to this, as Tom and many others have shown, then you have a lot to learn, as I did. It ain't easy.

If you are really interested, do you want to read a 65 page PDF document that explains it all? It means studying every page of it, and trying to understand. If you only want to find fault, of laugh at it all, then forget it.

Read this:
http://www.w3f.com/taxableincome2007.pdf

Just remember that many people like Tom has failed, and there is a reason for that too. Not because they wernt' right, but because judges and juries have the same attitude as those here.

Like I said, it aint easy....
It's complex, so the simple statements cannot tell the whole truth.

by johnbeaman

Where did does it say he was convicted of Tax Evasion? Show me the citation, please.

I do not agree with everything that Larken says, but 98% of his research is the same as I found. He also explains it well.

Remember you are looking for "Where does it say I have to file" and the IRS could not answer that question, so Tom was acquitted. The trial covered a lot more than just that just to point the entire trial to the final issue, "Show Me the Law!" Most never get that good of a focus on that point.

Larkin's documents traces all possibilities, including the 861 issue, not as it is proof, but because it too fails to show thet YOU have to file/pay. That is the point. Larkens material is great in it helps you follow the trail back to the definitions which is the key process to see why none of this crap applies to us. That is it's best value.

Larken was found guilty for the OTHER reason people have trouble winning in court, and no amount of facts and research can help you when the judge does not also follow the law.

You can be 100% right and still lose. Larken was made an example by the judge because the he had the same attitude as many here, they refuse to believe, and are too lazy to research it to the last letter of the law. So they take stuff out of context like many do that believe it applies to us. Taken that way, they are kinda right. Judges do not want to become tax experts, they rely on the lawyers to point this crap out to them, and go on that. If they don't let you address an issue that is vital to your case, then you are screwed, unless you can tell the judge that he must allow the subject. Larken was not able to get this done. (He is not a lawyer.... no respect...) Tom got respect because he WAS a lawyer, and the judge listened to hem because he knew how to ask the questions.

The key piece is that you have to have the Constitution in mind when you read all laws, as none can go against it. That is all the 16th amendment did, and yet taken by itself, and with the "assumed" meanings of words, most everyone "thinks" it says something different that what it is.

Tom Cryer was a lawyer, and Larkin is not, so Tom had a better chance of getting the judge to play by the rules. If you read the quotations and summaries from knowledgable people, they all say that Tom's biggest reason for winning was his sumation to the jury, and that the judge did not interfere with that. Larken was prohibited to quote law by the judge on key issues, Tom was allowed.

I have seen perfect cases foiled because of the judge instructing the jury improperly. They do it all the time, and unless the lawyer can fix that, you are screwed even though you are right.

Larken did not get a lawyer, so the judge was able to say and do many improper things that made Larkens case impossible to win. Tom was able to thwart them, that is why he won and Larkin did not. It's really that simple.

If this was easy, and guaranteed, then everyone would be doing it. Yes, it has risks, just ask Larken. But it is CORRECT like Tom showed, that we are all being hosed seriously, mostly by the complexity, the judges impropriarities, and life long propaganda.


"An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile,
hoping it will eat him last."

-- Winston Churchill--

That quote sounds like it was written for many of the people responding here.


"What good fortune for governments that the people do not think."
--Adolf Hitler


"Nature gave man two ends -
one to sit on and one to think with.
Ever since then,
man's success or failure
has been dependent on the one he used most."

--George R. Kirkpatrick--

by johnbeaman

Ever wonder why Tom Cryer was found not guilty, and Larken Rose was?

Read previous my post on Larken Rose.

If this was easy, everyone would be doing it.

They make it "not easy" for that exact reason.

Your reference is interesting, but most parts never states the fact that what is quoted does not apply to us. Therefore the whole argument is a waste of time.

"It is ridiculous because it would mean that the 16th Amendment does not mean what it says. The amendment plainly states that ?The Congress shall have the power to tax incomes? and tax protesters nevertheless try to claim that Congress does not have the power to tax incomes." http://evans-legal.com/dan/tpfaq.html#section861

What he says is true, but he failes to point out is only for "those they are allowed to tax", which is not us. That is part of the 16th Amendment because it must comply with the Constitution which disallows what is commonly known as "the income tax".

When you see the phrase "except that excluded by law", they are talking about the Constitution and Bill of Rights.

He also fails to clarify that the Federal "income tax" is not a "tax on income". It is
a tax on "certain activities" that the Federal Government has the power to control and regulate, which is interstate, and foreign activities. The "Taxable Income" is only used to figure out how much to pay for the tax on these activities. The Fed cannot "tax our income".

"The income tax is, therefore, not a tax on income as such. It is an excise tax with respect to certain activities and privileges which is measured by reference to the income which they produce. The income is not the subject of the tax: it is the basis for determining the amount of the tax."
Congressional Record of 3/27/1943, page 2580.

But, all if this is moot when Tom Cryer could not get the IRS to show the law that required us to file a 1040 at all, in a court of law.
That is because we are not involved in those "taxable" activities and therefore all the rest of the discussion is a waste of time. A designed-in distraction.

The 16th did not grant new power, but clarified previous laws to show that all of this, because of the Constitution, must be considered in it's intrepretation of any law or any Amendment.

by faradhi

with a vicious pack of facts.

That can't be true. John has put 30 years of research in this. You found that web site within three weeks of this conversation. That would mean that John wasted 29 years 49 weeks of time. It simply cannot be true

He has written websites on the subject. It is on that internet thingy. Only smart people put things on that internet thingy. It MUST BE TRUE. He quotes himself because he is smart enough to put stuff on the internet thingy. He has countless links that all use each other as proof of their 30 years of research.

You however actually read both the code and the case law that contradicts his 30 years of research. You dare contradict him with facts. You just do not understand the plain English in which your links are actually written. You do not understand the law. You do not understand that the courts are part of the conspiracy and enforce the non-existent law. If you had done the 30 years of research, you would know what he knows. You would have same mental condition he has. You would know that they are after you and your money.

FOR SHAME I tell you.... for shame.

edited to change your to you're

by johnbeaman

The FACT is that Tom Cryer was found Not guilty in court. The rest is crap, fact or not.

The IRS could not show the law that we have to report our income. FACT.

All the "other facts" - No, they are only opinions on small parts of the law taken out of context of the above stated FACT and the tax code,which is not law until you file a 1040, and then it becomes a contract.

Even this:

"The income tax is, therefore, not a tax on income as such. It is an excise tax with respect to certain activities and privileges which is measured by reference to the income which they produce. The income is not the subject of the tax: it is the basis for determining the amount of the tax."
Congressional Record of 3/27/1943, page 2580.

Is a waste of time as the IRS could not show we had to file a 1040 or even state our income as taxable. FACT.

All the rest of it (The facts as you call them) just do not apply to us. Period.

Arguing about laws that don't apply to us is a waste.... Don't you get it yet?

by faradhi

Case law is what counts. You see, it is the courts responsibility to interpret the law. You may remember that from Civics (No John that is not a type of car).

The site quoted by nick provided the Case law that states the tax applies to US citizens. That would be you and me.

[i]The determination of where income is derived or ?sourced? is generally of no moment to either [b]United States citizens[/b] or United States corporations, for such persons are subject to tax under section 1 and section 11, respectively, [b]on their worldwide income[/b][/i]Great-West Life Assur. Co. v. United States, 230 Ct. Cl. 477, 678 F.2d 180, 183 (1982)

I know your going to say that the law does not define income. But the courts do in Habersham-Bey v. Commissioner, 78 T.C. 304, 309 (1982).

[b]Don't you get it.[/b] If the politicians say it is true, the police say it is true, the prosecutors say it is true, and the courts say it is true, I am inclined to believe them. Just because you have found one criminal case in which the 12 stupidest people that could be found in that county found one moron not guilty does not change the fact that I must pay income tax. I wish it did. But criminal cases are not used as precedents in law unless it is at the appeals level. Usually even then it must be at the Circuit level or higher.

by nicknielsen

If I had the same mental condition he has, I wouldn't be me, I'd be him!
.
.
.
I laughed when I read your post, but I'm scared now!

by 1969mtilley

you say
"1. The IRS is a private Deleware Corporation paid by the Treasury Department as a collections agency."

but then explain why Internal Revenue Service employees are Federal employees of the Treasury Department, get paychecks and W-2's from the US Treasury Department, have Federal health benefits, are on the Federal pay scale, etc.

I am not saying that there may not be a company in Delaware with the name IRS, but the Internal Revenue Service is a Federal Agency in the US Treasury Department.

from http://www.irs.gov/irs/article/0,,id=149200,00.html
Brief History of IRS

Origin
The roots of IRS go back to the Civil War when President Lincoln and Congress, in 1862, created the position of commissioner of Internal Revenue and enacted an income tax to pay war expenses. The income tax was repealed 10 years later. Congress revived the income tax in 1894, but the Supreme Court ruled it unconstitutional the following year.

16th Amendment
In 1913, Wyoming ratified the 16th Amendment, providing the three-quarter majority of states necessary to amend the Constitution. The 16th Amendment gave Congress the authority to enact an income tax. That same year, the first Form 1040 appeared after Congress levied a 1 percent tax on net personal incomes above $3,000 with a 6 percent surtax on incomes of more than $500,000.

In 1918, during World War I, the top rate of the income tax rose to 77 percent to help finance the war effort. It dropped sharply in the post-war years, down to 24 percent in 1929, and rose again during the Depression. During World War II, Congress introduced payroll withholding and quarterly tax payments.

* 1913 Form 1040 (PDF 126KB, 4 pages, including instructions)

A New Name
In the 50s, the agency was reorganized to replace a patronage system with career, professional employees. The Bureau of Internal Revenue name was changed to the Internal Revenue Service. Only the IRS commissioner and chief counsel are selected by the president and confirmed by the Senate.

Today?s IRS Organization
The IRS Restructuring and Reform Act of 1998 prompted the most comprehensive reorganization and modernization of IRS in nearly half a century. The IRS reorganized itself to closely resemble the private sector model of organizing around customers with similar needs.

*
Today's IRS Organization

also, at the foot the of the IRS.gov website, "?2009. IRS.gov | Internal Revenue Service | United States Department of the Treasury"

by nicknielsen

This thread was dead for over 2 years until you resurrected it.

Let's just let this zombie subside quietly back into its grave...

by brokeneagle

We pay income taxes to the IRS because the early 20th Century "Progressives" got the 16th Amendment passed.

They had to pass an Amendment, because the Supreme Court through out all their previous attempts. They passed it by promising only the rich would pay income taxes and our great-grandparents and grandparents believed the lie.

Well, congratulations! We are all rich!

Now, the "Progressives" are telling us more lies about "heathcare reform" and "climate change".

by j_black60

Income Tax Myths

"There's just no law requiring you to pay federal income taxes."

The most basic myth of tax protestors is that there is simply no law mandating the payment of income taxes. Frequently one can observe tax protestors to say something like,

This discussion is closed to new replies.