Question Locked

Why do some CD-R's and CD-RW's not work in all drives

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Why can i not burn certain CD-R's in my CD burner? Some brands work and some brands do not?

4 replies

by older mycroft

They ALL look like apples.

Due to economic constraints and more importantly the avarice and greed of Users, some folk prefer to pay less for their optical media than others. They end up buying badly made (inferior coatings on the data side of the disc) media.

Also, technology never stands still. But the optical drive in your PC is static (apart from being able to spin a disc, that is).

Some new coatings may be too advanced for the firmware in your drive.

[i]I prefer the apples comparison myself!![/i] ;)

by boxfiddler Hot topic

re: different coatings and such. My Plextor drives do not like cheap media. Probably a good thing as you do 'get what you pay for' - at least for the most part - in life.

by oh smeg

We used to buy CD Media at $25.00 a Disc. Back in those days some of the cheaper CD Burners like the ones with a Kodak Brand on them would only use Kodak Banded Media.

You couldn't buy any other that would work in these burners.

Skip forward quite a few years and you will find that some of the really cheap media doesn't conform the what is called the Standard and these are a problem with some of the cheaper Drives. They have the wrong Dye on the Data Side of the Disc to work with all Burners or they have other manufacturing limits placed on them by the need to sell them for less that they cost to make so shortcuts are made.

When you mix these cheap Blanks with a Cheap Drive/Burner they just fail to be recognized by the burner and are unusable in that particular drive though they may appear to work perfectly in another.

But with these cheap disc's I've seen one explode and destroy a drive as well as other less drastic things happen. If the disc's are of the correct Format they will still not always work in all available burners just as some Oils used in cars work differently but in the case of a CD Blank instead of causing damage or accelerate the wear of the burner they just fail to work. This is because of Manufacturing Tolerances so if you have a Batch of Blanks at one extreme of the Manufacturing Tolerances and the Burner at the other end of the same tolerances something has to give and in the case of CD Burners it's the Burner fails to reckons the Disc placed in it.

Similarly bad storage of Blank Media can also impact on the way that the media works in extreme cases the media is useless to anyone because it's been stored in direct sunlight and the Ultraviolet in the light has destroyed the Dye Layer.

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.