Question Locked

Why does Internet Explorer include a "run" option for downloads?

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a boss who screwed up his computer yet again because he chose "run" instead of "save" when I told him to download and install a program, and he insists on using IE instead of Firefox.

I can't explain to his satisfaction why he should save the file to his desktop and then run the installation, when, in his logic, if IE gives him the option to run the file instead of saving it, he doesn't undertstand why he can't just run the file instead of saving it.

No matter what I tell him and what the outcome is, he insists on running the file, because IE gives him this option. So basically I want to know Microsoft's reasoning for including this option for downloads in every version of IE back to the beginning, when it obviously creates problems.

8 replies

by seanferd

The Run option gives users a chance to create a proper file association for, or have a choice for say, mpeg files. Do you want to download it and watch it offline? (Yes, I have a low bandwidth connection. No, but I don't want Windows Media to play it in IE, I want VLC to play it in another Window), or perhaps there is just no current association at all for a filetype for some reason, as there is no app to run it, or multiple apps to choose from with no default.

Occasionally, there may be files you actually want to install over a network connection, but that is best for LANs.

And no, you don't want to choose Run for a lot of files, due to type or size, over the internet. It is too easy for something to fail and leave the system in a bind.

by jerie

He was downloading an executable, IE should not offer to run that filetype, only save it.

Thanks for the tips, but I had already given him those explanations and more, it just doesn't penetrate. He feels since the option to run the program is there he should be able to use it.

Bottom line, the option should not be there for *.exe files. This option may be the explanation for a lot of viruses and computer mishaps, so I still want to know why it's an option when it shouldn't be, and it's not an option in Firefox or Opera when downloading .exe in those browsers.

by seanferd

For one, they expect that their browser will be used in corporate LANs, where installation may occur over the network. I've gotten downloads from Microsoft itself that either suggest doing a network install, or even disallowing any other type of transaction. Other update software does network installs as well.

I believe it is a consequence of the content type application/x-msdownload.

While I have similar choices in SeaMonkey, there is no "Run from current location".

Which version of IE is it? Newer versions should give the boss an extremely hard time doing that, unless reconfigured.

I don't know what you can do with that type of user, aside from locking down his account so he can't do things like that. I mean, he has the option to delete almost everything on his hard drives. Would he do that?

I feel your pain.

edit:
Just to see how popular this is:
http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Run+this+program+from+its+current+location%22

by snuffy09

*Security and Viruses

If you download/save your files first you can scan them and make sure they are nice and clean before you run them.

*Faster Install/Run time

Saving the file first then installing/running it saves loading time by at least 50%

*Provides a quick go-to

If he just clicks run every time he has no way of going back to the file or Application without retyping the URL

by thumbsup2

Anti-Virus software can't scan the whole file until it has been completely received/downloaded. Since viruses often attach themselves to the end of an EXE file, there's no way to detect the virus tacked onto the end of it if the RUN command has been issued prior to reaching the last little bit of the file being downloaded. By then, it's too late. The EXE is already running.

by slayer_

EXE's are Binary files that can only be run when they are complete. IE does not just arbitrarily start running an EXE file after the first byte is downloaded. Choosing run causes the entire file to be downloaded to some random temp file and then be automatically run. The only real difference is that its a bitch to find the file you just downloaded.

Most the time, virus scanners scan files as they are created, if not, your virus scanner sucks. And most I've seen fail to notice the virus till after you run the file, even if you do a manual scan. And then your SOL.

Also 90% of the time I use run instead of save as I am usually installing some small app from online and saving it to the desktop is just an extra step.

This discussion is closed to new replies.