Why is it?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Windows Forum
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by jdclyde
but it won't be staying. just playing along with a joke for a day or two. ;\
Will be back, as good as new, soon enough.
As for the noobs, they deserve whatever they get! :D
by tonythetiger
Social Security is not a form of savings, it is a tax. It is disengenuous of the government to even make it a seperate entry on your pay stub!
Here's an example to illustrate:
George worked at the plant for 45 years. He was married to Edna, who never worked a day in her life outside the home. They had a little savings. So George retires at 70 and starts getting $1900 a month in Social Security. Pretty soon Edna gets sick of him and divorces him.
They each get half the savings account, as you'd expect, and if Social Security were a savings plan, you'd expect they'd each get half of that too, but that's not what happens. They each get the full amount! (In fact, many older couples divorce (but continue to live together) for just this reason.)
Who is paying for the "extra" $1900 every month?
That is [b]very[/b] different to here. Both in overall/relative amounts and in manner of administration.
I'd be pissed off.
by tonythetiger
by oz_media
I don't quite get what you mean, Max. When you say people want mroe government, are you referring to people who blame the government for not taking action; thus they don't have to accept personal responsibility for things like tripping on a sidewalk that didn't have a beware sign, feeling descriminated against for allowing recognition of foreign language days in school etc.?
Is that the type of government interaction you are referring to people wanting more of?
Or are you referring to people who want the government to up funding for welfare, medical and other commonly known "social services" ?
I see and agree with the point that peop[le need to take more responsibility and not expect teh overnment to protect them from life but you know I support the government using tax dollars for social programs.
Just not sure exactly what you meant, prehaps as a result of missing a leading topic?
I think that just because I [i]'expect'[/i] more from my government, this doesn't mean I want MORE govrnment. I think they can do better with what they have, not neccessarily have more control over my income.
I object to the way they govern, I object to the way they spend MY tax money in some ways, but I don't want them to gain even more control. Is that what you mean?
Sorry, I was late to notice this one and don't want to go through all of it just to catch the focus of many opposing opinions.
by absolutely
by tonythetiger
by absolutely
by absolutely
[i]You're right, no doubt.
So that's another significant power base who aren't going to roll over easily. Because, to use your phrase, we all know the rich have never historically been in the mood to enable lots of other people to try to share that wealth. Because for lots of them, it's not the freedom or independence, it's the prestige. Can't be prestigious when everyone has their own private jet?? And I'm not being cute or facetious. It's (in my experience) very true.
So so far on the "other side" we've got most politicians, at least 187,000 public servants, an entire accounting and taxation industry, major slabs of the legal profession, and an arguably high proportion of the rich.
Not to mention major slabs of the transitional period that are yet to be described.
Like I said in a previous note, I think it is indeed brilliant. I've thought a simple indirect tax scheme that has some 'safe harbour' provisions for the lower paid echelons. Provisions in the form of rebates or in the form of exemptions is a detail, not a real argument as such - either manner will be open to abuse and "lobbying".
That's a formidable front against it. Not insurmountable but formidable.[/i]
Therefore, what? (Sorry, Maxwell, but this was crying out for it.) One man's 'formidable' is this man's 'no problem'.
by tonythetiger
by absolutely
In my (quite possibly naive) readings, the provision to only tax new goods is a potential and real problem.
It's also an unnecessary qualification on the process.
Include used goods and simply remove any potential loophole.
Just adjust the 'X' percent accordingly.
No change to the process, no burden on recalculation, no additional burden on collection or reporting.
Loophole gone.
And you realise, of course, that a consumption-based tax must be distributed inequitably.
It is a fundamental concept of consumption tax.
The "extent" of your future government is totally irrelevant to the argument. Whether the size of government in the future stays the same, gets less or grows.
The rich/big states and cities pay for the poor/small states and cities.
It works for me. As long as your comfortable with that ...
I am rich!!!!
and from that previous note, and on the other thread about selling your freedom and democracy to the highest bidder ...
"Absolutely": you're just dumb.
Um, not much to say but YES.
A couple of the points that I did not write clearly enough:
[i]For example, is your quality of life entirely beholden upon there tiers of government (fed, state and local) and all the inherent, pure, utter waste that this structure entails?[/i]
What I was referring to was that in the US, ... similarly in Canada, Australia, Germany and others ... There are three tiers of government - local, state/provincial/regional and federal.
Surely ONE of those tiers could basically just be dumped. Gone. Kaputski.
Constitutionally improbable and emotionally / historically extremely difficult to do, I am fully aware.
But the question I was asking was: does paying for three tiers of government, in and of itself, enhance your life, liberty and pursuit of happiness?
From you: [i]Also our represenatives should not be ALLOWED to have a separate benefits package than the rest of the real world. Same retirement package as anyone else would get. If they were forced to be in the same system, you can bet your a$$ they would fix it.[/i]
Amen. This is seemingly universal. How did it happen in the first instance? Is it quite possibly the most basic single point of inherent corruption in the mechanics of politics?
I'd rather pay fair market value (and I am sure we each have an idea of what that may be!!!) as long as they played by the same rules they force me to play in.
From you: [i]I assume you mean during that time frame because rights were not quite so equal back then?[/i]
Yes, but I wasn't referring to slavery for exactly the points you make.
Just simply that in excess of 50% of the population did not have access to l/l/&tpoh.
I appreciate your response.
by absolutely
by absolutely
[i]and from that previous note, and on the other thread about selling your freedom and democracy to the highest bidder ...
"Absolutely": you're just dumb.[/i]
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=207626&messageID=2146742
From your mindlessly emotive responses and your eagerness to sell [b]my[/b] freedom and democracy to the [b]lowest[/b] bidder, "caniberichnowplease": you're just bitter.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=207626&messageID=2147319
[i]It's called a cost-benefit analysis
I'm sure you've heard of the process, if (obviously?) not participated in one.
I do it daily for my job. Have done for 23 years.
I could tell you specifically how it would be acheived and where the direct costs would be taken out of the government machinery.
Sorry, but I think your apparent unwillingness to even consider spending money now to reduce expenses later will get in the way of any reasonable discussion.[/i]
When you grow up and want to have an adult conversation, include in your "cost/benefit analysis" the costs, to whom, and the benefits, to whom. Only [b]after[/b] you have honestly done so will you be sufficiently worthy of my respect to continue this conversation.
by tonythetiger
Didn't know if you've seen this.
[i]The argument that the ability of money to "buy influence" becomes less credible as the price of communication media drop. With hard drive storage around $1 per gigabyte (that's 1 Billion * 8 bits, 8 thousand million for the newbies), the argument that $ undermines free speech is already ludicrous. If your ideas aren't convincing people, it can only be because you haven't been trying, or your ideas are just stupid.[/i]
And there, in a puff of blinding logic, goes pretty much the entire global marketing, advertising and lobbying industries (not to mention of course major slabs of the media industry), to name a few.
You genuinely have no idea how the real world works, do you?
The chances of your plans or dreams taking off are zero.
Stop voting, you're actually wasting someone else's tax money.
by absolutely
by absolutely
.. the tools do exist, access is (practically) free. You are right, and a smart or enthusiastic or dedicated person can acheive wonders that even 20 years ago were unheard of.
I need to ask about two points though, because they seem more important to you than simply throw-away lines:
[i]Those with better ideas will tend to support freedom of speech[/i].
With extraordinarily few exceptions, few "thinkers" in the world would ever question that. You "righties" and we "lefties" scream for it, albeit/agreed for sometimes opposing objectives.
Would 'freedom of speach', in itself, enable anyone to decide if an idea was good or not?
Personally I think not.
[i]"may the best ideas win"[/i]. Is that a somewhat innocent take on the overall communications / 'getting them to vote for me' proposition?
If that is all it took, every single politician, by definition, would never lose! Because I have never heard a politician commence their discourse with "I have an idea but it might not be the best you've heard ...."
If that is all it took, you and I would also be extremely satisfied that the fairtax approach would win the day.
The "idea" is, in and of itself, quite often the least of it all.
....
If they are throw-away lines fair enough.
edit spealing
by sleepin'dawg
Most people are incapable of understanding the nuances of cause and effect but expect the government to provide a safety net for every aspect of their sad little lives. However, they will bitch like hell if taxes are increased when the same service is extended pandemically to all, not just themselves. Individual selfishness is the operative here not intelligence; that and the failure or lack of capability to be self reliant.
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
by tonythetiger
by absolutely
normally attributed to Voltaire, although in checking up a few sites there seems to be some doubt that it was actually ever said at all.
http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/authors/v/voltaire.html
In checking up I did find a quote that has infinite applicability:
[b]An ideal form of government is democracy tempered with assassination./[b]
by absolutely
[i]Would 'freedom of speach', in itself, enable anyone to decide if an idea was good or not?
Personally I think not.[/i]
No, the person would also need to think.
[i]"may the best ideas win". Is that a somewhat innocent take on the overall communications / 'getting them to vote for me' proposition?
If that is all it took, every single politician, by definition, would never lose! Because I have never heard a politician commence their discourse with "I have an idea but it might not be the best you've heard ...."
If that is all it took, you and I would also be extremely satisfied that the fairtax approach would win the day.
The "idea" is, in and of itself, quite often the least of it all.[/i]
They all present their proposals as the best, packaged amongst carefully-selected words, picked for their potential to [i]counter[/i] rational examination. Too many lofty adjectives, high-mided idealism, etc. Listen, no politician will ever usher in anybody's "utopia" except a brutal dictator, who will introduce utopia according to the minds of psychopaths. But, promising a Christian utopia works for a lot of Republicans and promising an atheist welfare state with voting rights works for a lot of Democrats. Neither can ever deliver because of the existence of the other. If they were to rationally, maturely concede the right of the other to exist, both would have to stop promising their utopia, and present ideas that truly are possible.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending