Discussion Locked

Why WXP in place of W2K on a network?

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
My question is why do people insist on using Windows XP in a network enviroment? My take on WXP is that it replaces WME for home users. Hense the need to "log on and activate" XP by sending your system configuration to Microsoft and they in turn monitor where that copy goes (re you upgrade your machine hardware and ooops, things don't work cuz esentially Microsoft sees that copy being installed on a different machine it wasn't licensed to be on). XP doesn't offer any better operating system [really worse] than W2k for network environments. XP is really better suited for home users who surf the web, play music, watch movies or streaming media videos and to provide Microsoft a way to control illegal pirating of their O/S. W2K, which you can install remotely on client computers either attended or unattended is far better way to go. SO WHY XP?

3 replies

by thechas

Think of XP Home as the Me replacement.

XP Pro is the replacement for W2K.

While you can still get some system manufactures to install W2K instead of XP for corporate accounts, I suspect in a year or so, that that option will no longer be available.

Then, within the next couple years, (likely just after the next version of Windows comes out) Microsoft will drop ALL support for W2K.

So, yes you can stick with W2K for a couple more years. But eventually, you will be forced to either reuse old licenses, or switch to a newer version of Windows.
(at some point, newer software and hardware won't work with the unsupported OS)
(I have read where you cannot install W95 on some P4 systems)

As to the licensing / product activation issue, that is just a continuation of what was introduced with Office XP.

As the PC market tightens, and shrinks, you can expect more software companies to require some similar form of product activation.

By the way, when Microsoft first announced XP, I concluded that it must stand for eXtra Profits, not eXPeriance.

I myself, am installing XP Pro on most of the new PC that I setup for people.
The factors driving this are cost, and support life for the operating system.
XP Pro costs just slightly more than W98, and is less than a copy of W2K from my supplier.

Chas

by cg it

I understand XP Pro is to replace W2k, yet Microsoft has come out with the .net frameworks (which can be used in a W2k environment) in support of .net software programs development, and a .net beta server software[which we here at The Corporate Groups are testing out]. All of which is poised to introduce the .net family of operating systems for network environments. These . net networking environments are supposed to support W2K clients just as W2K supports non W2000 systems. I've watched the different tech boards on XP and have found most XP users have untold problems with it including trying to have a XP computer as part of a NT W2K server environment with more headaches than it seems worth it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.