Discussion Locked

Will the US ever bring Osama Bin Laden to Justice?

0 helpful
19 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Almost six years after 9/11, I can't believe that Osama and his #2 Al-Zawahiri are so elusive. If the recent $50 million dollar bounty offered by the US on Bin Laden doesn't produce better intelligence, than I have to think that someone with alot of money and power is hiding him.

Possibly he is in Pakistan in the mountainous regions or maybe he died of his health problems in the obscurity of a cave. The fact is though, that he has remained untouchable, dead or alive, for almost six years.

Then again, maybe he isn't in Pakistan at all. Maybe he is in Saudi Arabia. Even though he is the black sheep of the Bin Laden family, blood is still thicker than water or oil. Maybe the US knows where Bin Laden is but can't touch him because of politics.

If Bush ever wants to save his legacy and save face with America, he has to bring this criminal and his minions to justice.

What do you think? Why hasn't the US brought Osama Bin Laden to justice six years after 9/11?

AV

19 replies

by w2ktechman

Osama was caught, the Bush administration will still suffer plenty of ridicule for the rest of their actions.

A bounty of any size, would only be good to the living. If anyone knows where he is, they are either too scared, or faithful to Osama to turn him in.

by av .

I've always thought it was peculiar that Bush, a couple of years into the war on terror, suddenly decided that Osama was not all that important to catch. Did he do that because we didn't have good intelligence or because it wasn't politically correct with Saudi Arabia or maybe Pakistan?

Surely there has to be one turncoat out there that wants to be $50 million dollars richer.

How far does faith go if you have to live like they do everyday? Hell on Earth. Is Osama and his ideals, a rich man, worth it?

AV

by w2ktechman

Why else would we not have aken Osama in Afghanistan? Why did we pay warlords to get him when we knew where Osama was?
I think that they wanted Osama to be captured by locals, to downplay our involvement to the Muslum people.
Then he moved on, to Pakistan or elsewhere. To invade Pakistan at that point would have turned many against us, as we were already in Iraq

by charliespencer

I fully supported our military actions in Afghanistan and still do. The administration, for whatever good or bad reasons, decided Iraq was the bigger issue. Resources that could have been used in Afghanistan and Pakistan against the proven Al Qaeda threat were instead used against a possible threat in Iraq.

by dawgit

Plain answer to a complicated question.
Yes, He just might be caught some day, but Justice, unfortunatly has for a long time been distorted and perverted. -d

by av .

9/11 was a very painful and unforgettable experience for America. Maybe we can't get real justice, but Osama's capture or demise would bring closure to a very tragic event in our country's history.

AV

by dawgit

Closure for one group of people, is an open wound to another. And the cycle continues. -d

by tony hopkinson

but there are those who value things more than money.

50,000,000 is a lot of dollars, if that price was on my head, I'd be a bit careful about where I put it.

Maybe he'd dead as a nit and it's a clique making fake videos to keep him 'alive'. His continued existance is useful to a great many.

Catching Bin Laden won't rescue your president, how could it since his predecessors created him in the first place!

Is this Justice as in revenge, or justice as in fairness?
The former is usually rare and the latter non-existent in the judicial system.

by av .

I don't care about Bush or Clinton. I know we were attacked because of our foreign policies, but 9/11 was a huge wake up call for the American people. There have always been terrorist attacks, but never an attack of that magnitude. No one wants to die at their desk at work because of the government's policies.

Its not quite revenge, though revenge is part of it, its self-preservation. Osama and Zawahiri continue to unite Al-Qaeda against the US. Their demise would be a huge blow to Al-Qaeda. We don't want to see another 9/11.

Even though I think their capture or death would be a boost to Bush, that isn't the reason why we should pursue them. Perhaps their death or capture would be a major wound to Al-Qaeda.

I hope he is dead as a nit. Its a possibility as we haven't seen his face in a video for quite awhile.

I know most of his followers think they would burn in Muslim Hell if they turned him in, but there has to be someone out of that group that is disenchanted. At least, I hope so.

AV

by tony hopkinson

out would be a good move.

Just keep in mind the "The enemy of my enemy is my friend" is a short term strategy.

That's how we got Bin Laden, Hussein and such like in the place.

Personally I think your administrations are too boundd up in their own perceotions of themselves.

The ideal solution would have been assassination, but that wwould be 'unamerican'

by delbertpgh

Fighting Islamic terrorism means fighting Islamic terrorists, right? And doing what you can to minimize the recruitment of new terrorists. We had a chance to pick him up in the hills around Bora Bora, back in 2002. We chose instead to subcontract the job to our unreliable Afghan mercenary allies. Should have thought. Didn't think. Instead, we conserved our forces to launch an equally ill-managed, unnecessary war. Which now looks like something we'll have to retreat from, and let a strategic country descend into anarchy and mass murder.

I see no reason to doubt that Osama is hiding in Pakistan. It's got a completely ungovernable population, sort of a tribal libertarian survivalist culture, that hates central authority and idolizes lonely fighters. The Pashtun people take everything to extremes, including religion, revenge, and manly pride. Osama will do just fine there. You can't get a decent pizza anywhere in the tribal areas of Pakistan, but I don't think that figures for much in Bin Laden's game plan.

We can't invade an ally, Pakistan, whose hold on its own territory is so tenuous. That's why Bin Laden is safer there than in Afghanistan or Saudi Arabia. The Saudis have been taking Islamic terrorism pretty seriously lately, at least within their own borders. No blood thicker than water for them these days. They're worried about revolution.

by av .

Truly, the Bush Administration screwed up royally and America is paying dearly for it.

The best thing that could have happened is that Donald Rumsfield is no longer calling the shots. Hopefully his replacement, Robert Gates and General Petraeous can turn things around because it is a huge mess with dire consequences for the US. At least they are honest - there has to be a political solution, not just a military one.

Yeah, Pakistan is the perfect place for Bin Laden, but I still can't rule out the Saudi connection playing a part somehow.

AV

by av .

Bush definitely got sidetracked in Iraq while Osama and Al Qaeda, the people really responsible for 9/11, were allowed to exist in the mountains of Afghanistan.

We should step up our efforts now to find Osama and Zawahiri. Its never too late to bring them to justice and it would mean a great deal to this country.

AV

by delbertpgh

Striking back at Al Qaeda by attacking the country that willingly offered itself as a platform for their operations was a good thing. Al Qaeda is still an important foe, and it would save us some future trouble to take down their top figureheads. It would also make us feel good, which is important.

However, killing Al Qaeda (which will go on with or without its head guys) is not going to win the "war on terror." Our problem will be zealot crackpot Islamists who grow up in small towns and cities across the world thinking that their religion or their states are under threat from the modern West, and that their lives mean nothing unless they do something big, and attacking us is the key to life. Sooner or later history will shift and these people will lose this special fascination, but until they do, we have an ongoing problem.

Calling it a "war on terror" is a simplification. We've got to fight terrorists, but we've also got to not throw fertilizer on the garden that grows them. This is a complicated situation that needs careful management as well as war-fighting, for a generation or more.

by inachu

The only goal here is to further the Bankers goal to shove Coca cola and Pepsi down the throat of every muslim in the middle east and have them thank us for it.

All this and we still do not use Iraqi oil in USA which is done to keep prices high.

by av .

If the warloads in Afghanistan took care of him, Osama would be less likely to become the ultimate martyr because the US killed him.

We definitely can't invade Pakistan, but there has to be another way to get more cooperation from them. Everyone wants something. I'm certain that Pakistan jealously eyes our possible nuclear deal with India, for example, not that I would ever like to see a nuclear Pakistan.

AV

by dawgit

Pakistan is Nuclear.!. Has been for a while too. And, they the rockets to deliever the war-heads. That part of the world is a nasty little pot of sticky goo. -d

by w2ktechman

around '00 or '01 when they proved it.

As far as Pakistan goes though, I think it best to let them run their country unless they are seriously threatened. Then we should offer assistance to their current govt., or a better one. As is Pakistan is a tangled mess right now, and with the ability to create nukes, it is a very bad situation.
If the current govt. loses power, what should our immediate step be?
My opinion would be to move quickly and block off nuclear sites from terrorists while working with the 'new govt'. If not, we should quickly squash the new govt. if it is a terrorist regime, which it will most likely be.

by inachu

Osama and Rumsfeld had a love affair with weapons in the 1970's & 1980's

We helped him and made him rich.

So we go around the world giving weapons to local warlords then we turn our backs on them when we are done manipulating them for whatever neocon goals. So now we want to kill those who we groomed.

Waste of time and money.

This discussion is closed to new replies.