Discussion Locked

Win XP Home -vs- Win XP Pro in NT Domain

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a slight confusion about XP Home and XP PRO with joining an NT domain.

My confusion lies in the fact that while trying to find out how to join an XP Home client to an NT 4.0 network (domain) I searched through every networking options on XP home and only found out how to join it to a WORKGROUP. So I join a little MSN moderated "tech support" chat group and I can't seem to convince the supposed "Tech Support Gurus" there that connecting to NT via a workgroup is DIFFERENT from connecting to NT by joing a DOMAIN.

So I did one of those "yeah ok..well thanks." deals and left.

Meanwhile I search Microsoft's knowledge base and found how-to directions for joining an NT domain with Windows XP PROFESSIONAL. So then am I too assume that only XP professional (and not home edition) can participate in joining NT DOMAINS (not merely workgroups)?

Thanks for your assistance in advance.

4 replies

by tomsal

Sorry for the wasting of space for my post, I jumped the gun. I should of researched more before I posted...I found this info at the Microsoft Windows XP page :

"Windows XP Professional is required to access a domain-based network. If you're not sure whether the network you will access is domain-based, talk to the person in charge of the network to make sure you choose the proper version of Windows XP."

Solves that one.

(God MS is getting lamer and lamer)

by lordinfidel

For now at least...

Jees' tom.... Why would you want to punish yourself for.

Stick with 2kPro.

Oh, and the answer to your question, even though you found it out on your own,

The marketeers at M$ in their infinite wisdom, since WinMe was such a huge success in it's lack of networking support. Decided to make XP in 2 flavors. Home and Pro. Taking away that domain network support from the Home user.

Thanx Bill.

by jellimonsta

I have not had any exposure to XP Home or Pro but from what I have seen you supposedly cannot join an XP Home computer to a domain (server oriented) environment.
You could either upgrade to XP Pro or try entering your domain name in the workgroup box of the local system. You will need to log on as a local administrator and change the settings of the system. You can right click on 'My Computer' and go into the properties to do this.

by mrjay67

As you have found XP home will not join a NT domain. However, if its not necessary to join but just have access to resources, that should be possible. You would just create a local account on the home machine and give rights to that user on the server for accessing data/apps/folders or whatever. They should be able to see computers in my network places and get to desired resources or be able to map to them. You could use a local login script that would automaticly give them their mapings or whatever other rights/restrictions you need them to have. Just a suggestion and work around if home is what you really want to use. Personally i like XP pro for the better networking options.(for home use or office)

Jason

This discussion is closed to new replies.