Discussion Locked

Wisconsin passes download tax

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Wisconsin passed a measure that will tax certain downloaded items from the net. Mainly geared towards music but it also reaches out to software, ringtones, e-books, etc... My first thought when New York did this is won't that encourage illegal downloads?

I can see three types of reactions to this:
1. Pay for it and dont care
2. Pay for it but grumble about it
3. Download through an alternate method (ie illegally)

What are your thoughts?

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/02/19/wisconsin_passes_download_tax/

10 replies

by Tammy.Cavadias

when NY passed theirs how exactly do they make it work?

If you live in NY/WI you get taxed on downloads where the store is home based in that state? or any state? What if you download from a company based in another country? What if you live out of state and the company is based in NY/WI - what if you live in WI and download from a company based in NY - Do you get double taxed?

Who's going to tell all the Internet stores they must start charging tax? How do they force them to do so? How do they collect and pass go? Who's going to regulate it all? The Governments? The ISP's? The credit card companies? The in-state/out-of-state or different country company?

-Tammy

by w2ktechman

to report it to the state if it was downloaded in whatever location. Then the State sends out forms to pay.

by Tammy.Cavadias

then how do they know for sure it was a payable item and not a freebie? How do they know how much that item was if it was payable?

Something tells me I need to start looking for a soon tax increase across the board on top of the last tax increase a few months back - at least where I am.

-Tammy

by thechas

Much like the states attempting to find ways to collect their sales and use taxes on mail order and on-line hard goods purchases, states are trying to extend their tax collection to any form or commerce.

The net result of this will be to drive more commerce outside the US borders.

At the start, the only firms that will collect the tax are those with a physical presence in the state, or who already collect sales tax for hard goods ordered online.

At first, sellers who do not wish to deal with collecting taxes on behalf of the state will simply locate their operations in states that do not enforce out of state sales tax collection. If and when the states ever get national enforcement of state sales tax collection, the low cost sellers of downloadable content will simply move off-shore.

Or, Wisconsin could handle this the same way Michigan attempts to collect sales tax for mail order and online purchases. On the Michigan State income tax form, there are a series of questions where you help the State determine how much use tax you owe for your out of state purchases.

Just another way to make the little guy fund the government.

Chas

by magic8ball

They have a self reporting tax that in theory when you buy something you have to pay a tax unless charged by where you buy it. CDW for example charges tax when I buy something from them. Other places don't.

However on the NM tax and rev website they say that you're supposed to pay this tax but there is no official method in place to collect. So its on the honor system. I wonder how many people don't pay this tax either because they don't want to or don't even know about it so they don't pay it.

by w2ktechman

I buy cigarettes online and the state sends me tax forms because they are reported to the state. However, the way it is written and what information the state actually knows is different. The forms are sent, written like it's supposed to scare you into submission. However, if they knew how much I paid and everything, the state would surely itemize everything rather than ask how much I purchased and how much it costed, and where I purchased.

by dr dij

MJ was made illegal initially by a 'stamp tax'.

So you may be right,
when they make downloads 'illegal' (e.g. heavily taxed), only outlaws will download!

Hopefully the taxes won't be hundreds of dollars a song, e.g. to make 'death rap' or other stuff that people with too much time on their hands worry about illegal..

substitute your favorite 'thing' in this phrase that 'only outlaws will have.. :)

I guess Wisconsin doesn't mind doing this because you can't 'download' Wisconsin cheese, at least until we have "plasma ducts" routed all over the planet, from massive fusion reactors, and your food synthesizer materializes the cheese!

by w2ktechman

scare tactics. If you are uncertain of what they know, you may just be 'honest' or over guess?

Either that or there is a certain tax for each download, regardless of what you paid for it.

by magic8ball

The NM website says that they have 'no mechanism' in place to enforce the tax. I believe thats the wording they use. So they say we have this tax but you can't pay it because we can't enforce it. I wish all taxes were like that.

Reminds me of another article I read about a restaurant that one day a week the owner doesn't charge anyone for the food but instead they pay what they think its worth. Gutsy move but if I remember correctly it was paying off pretty good.

This discussion is closed to new replies.