I'd like to appologize for the rambling and tangent jumping in this post. But hopefully, some comment can be gathered from my words:
You know...being an black/african american'afro american/whatever, I never had to be lured into, dragged into IT, or for that matter science in general. back in the 80s, I don't even remember there being a call for luring minorities and women into the science and tech fields. For me, I didn't need to be enticed by dreams of making lots of money or just the need to replace numbers. I was a naturally curious person that had a gift for using a computer. I had a decent educational career growing up. For half of my life (public school education), I went to to school in a very flourishing , basically rich public school district; Good schools, good teachers, culturally diversed. The second half, I went to a very small, underachieving public school district that was all african american. Poor economy, not enough teachers...you name it. But, I remained interested in science. Back then..I say "back then" like it was 30-40-50 years ago, but it was just over 10 years since I graduated high school and the push to encourage minorities to the science field wasn't in existant. And if it was, not to the extent that is is today.
Maybe what people should be doing is talking to people like me (minorities and non-minorities) to to how and why we are so able to be naturally attracted to the sciences without encouragement. How is it that some of us who aren't honor roll students, Honor Society members can still go into a field and do well. There's only so much encouraging can do. I've had classmates who were encouraged in some way to go into IT/IS/Computer Science because of the money and all that jazz. But once they started doing the coursework, they got bored...didn't like all of the work. This was male and female students. So what's the use of encouraging minorities and women when if you have 10 men and women to go into a program and then 9 drop classes or change majors completely? And this is just in college.
This paragraph is the last section of one of those articles that was posted by this topic's originator:
"The Loneliest Number
Meszaros and Chase focused on that word: "isolation."
The perception that a computer career means working alone is a turn-off to middle- and high-school girls who prefer to work in groups. More so than men, girls and women appreciate the social aspects of their jobs. They prefer to work together.
That doesn't surprise Meszaros. "We know that women are more relational in their working careers than are men," she said.
According to "Tech-Savvy," a report from the American Association of University Women, "Girls are concerned about the passivity of their interactions with the computer as a 'tool.'" When it comes to choosing a career, girls "assert a 'we can, but I don't want to' attitude toward computer technology."
Girls don't want to end up working alone. And that's what geeks do.
"They don't see the I.T. field as being a field where they can help people," said Meszaros.
The AAUW backs her up: "Girls tend to imagine that computer professionals live in a solitary, antisocial and sedentary world," it said in its report. "This is an alienating -- and incorrect -- perception of careers that will rely heavily on computer technology."
Hollins and Seckinger agreed wholeheartedly. "I don't want to sit in front of a computer all day," they said, disturbingly, in unison. "
I've seen that in the eyes of those same example of students that I mentioned that would drop out. Even with talking to women friends of mine who aren't in IT, they have the perspection that I spent all of my time in front of the monitor, that I don't interact with anyone. I try to explain to them, like many of my fellow IT workers, because of the position that I have and the lack of other IT professional, I'm a jack-of-all trades. No everyone is willing to work by themselves, even though it's not an ordinary part of working in IT. But like in the paragraph says, "Sitting in front of a computer equates to isolation".
Are tech fields that much more than any other field? Is a DBA position greater than a neuro biophysiologist??? Both require knowledge and experience and both are needed. The goal of encouraging is a noble goal. But how it's done is key. I don't know many times when I've told people what I do or what I'm going to school for, the automatically say "Computers? That's where the money is" and comments like that. And I get encouragement from them to keep on going. But they are coming from the context of "he's going to make money in the future". I get really offended by that. I'm starting to think that's a cultural image that's held because you don't hear that being said if a person is a doctor or a lawyer.
There are so many different reason why the encouragement isn't working. But there are equally as many reasons to why the system of IT is more the reason why there is an IT shortage. Is this the solution???