Discussion Locked

Would you meet with President Bush?

0 helpful
53 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

A recent news story revealed that Jessica Simpson refused to meet with President Bush. I won't go into details, as it doesn't really matter, and you can look them up if you want. I have an opinion about it, but will refrain from sharing it, at least for now.

However, would YOU meet with President Bush if you had the chance?

For argument's sake, let's assume you have fifteen minutes, no more, no less. Let's further assume that it's a totally private meeting with no advisors present, no wife, no secret service, no distractions, just you and him, and you have his undivided attention. If so, what would say? What would you do? How would you act? What would you ask?

Of course, those who like and admire President Bush would undoubtedly say yes. But what about you folks who don't like him, those who openly call him a moron, a liar, incompetent, and so on? Would you talk TO him the same way you talk ABOUT him? Or would you pull a "Jessica Simpson", and snub him as a matter of "principle"? (And assume that your "snub" would make the news and/or make such a statement.)

So there you go. Would you meet with him?

And those who like him, agree with him, etc., please reply as well. My answer will follow at a later time.

53 replies

by itgirli

I would meet with him. And let me also say that I would snub Jessica Simpson.

I'm not sure what I would say to him. I really don't care about his plans for Iraq. Since I am currently unemployed, I'd probably ask if he would give me a job or at least a letter of reference. He's just a normal person. Maybe I would talk about the weather.
I don't know. But I think he has enough stress, I wouldn't try to add to it.

by lhatcher

I guess I would at least meet with the guy. Not a big fan, but hell he is the president.

by maxwell edison

Her reasons, as I said, are not the point. The circumstances, as I said, are not the point. I didn't ask for comments on what Jessica Simpson did or why.

I only used that little anecdote as a set-up for a question about what you might do and/or say in a meeting with the president.

(Maxwell, you idiot. You should have known.)

by absolutely

I'd meet him face to face to discuss his proclamations in 2000 in opposition to "state building".

by onbliss

Anyway...I do not hate or admire him. He is a politician doing his job. And that puts things into perspective and makes me little indifferent; and agree and disagree with his policies.

I would certainly go and meet him, **ONLY** if the White House extended an invitation to me (why would even they do that :)], I do not have a personal desire to go and meet him (or any other politician) of my own accord.

He has enough advisors and people to talk about the world and the country, so I will not be talking about *** World peace **** or ***poverty***.

I will be just polite, exchange the usual plesantries. I wonder what sort of small talk can one do with a President. I am ***very*** bad in small talk. By the way, since the invitation was from the WH, I would ask him why he wanted to see me.

I would like to ask him how it feels to be the President of the ***most*** influential country in the World.

Is it bad to tell him "take care", when the meeting is done ? :-))

Max, you see I would rather meet you than him :-))) to see what makes you tick :-)) Honestly, you seem to be a more interesting person than him.

ps:
I am not a US citizen, so I might be biased towards meeting the world's most important man so that I could just go and brag about it :-))

by john.a.wills

I would tell him to dump AIPAC, accede to the ICC, try to repeal the amendment which prevents the US using the ICJ, order the Israelis to give the stolen private property back,... But has any US politician the courage to buck AIPAC? Well, he should have.

by cheesel

that there is no Israel. To be fair, then everyone else, including the US must give their 'stolen property' back, as well as the Canadians, Australians, and many other folks. While we're at it, since humans are native to Africa only (as far as we know), maybe all six billion of us should just move back there.

Oh, and as far as the ICC, when they do something wrong, who polices THEM? BTW, you can also forget about your Fifth Amendment rights.

by john.a.wills

1. I was talking about private property, not sovereignty;
2. Israel will live till the end of time, but whether the Israeli state will is another matter;
3. The ICC is a small light in a dark world, and started as a U.S. idea; we are better with it than without it, but the Israelis do not want it so the U.S. is going along with sabotaging it.

by cheesel

I consider what is happening on the Rio Grande an assault on the US. Close the $(*%$ borders, George! I voted for him twice because I believed (and still do) that when it comes to security, Republicans are better than Dems. However, I am no longer a member of the Republican party because they ain't conservatives anymore. They are more conservative than the Democrats but not by much....

by amcol

Not one on one, and not for fifteen minutes. In fact, in the interest of full disclosure, it wasn't precisely a meeting...I was attending a function in my capacity as CIO/CTO of a federal agency with numerous other colleages and he was there.

However, nit-picky details aside, he's actually quite an engaging man. Contrary to the picture painted in the media he's far from dumb, uniformed, and disengaged. He's deeply religious and makes that pretty obvious, and he's as much of a people person as Bill Clinton ever was.

I've spoken with people who have had private meetings with him and he's not much different in that situation than he is in public. Maybe a little more relaxed.

To answer your specific question...I would approach the meeting the same way I would any meeting with anyone in a position of power and authority. Respectfully, deferentially, and with a certain amount of curiosity as to the nature of the person with whom I'm meeting and the types of answers and reactions I'm going to get.

Regardless of your personal feeling about him, I quite frankly can't imagine anyone turning down a chance to meet with the President of the United States. What an opportunity, and what an honor. Why waste it?

by x-marcap

GWB I haven't met yet.

Eisenhower reminded me of my great grandpa. He seemed to be always laughing.

Family connections put this 4 year old, a deck of cards, and Dick Nixon in the same room. My 50 cent allowance left after 2 hours of him teaching me to play poker, (and to never try to draw to an inside straight. ) He walked out with my money, but he gave my dad a dollar for me. Ford plays golf, I caddied... Carter I met, he was an Annapolis man who was a submariner (Think of the attitude. and don't turn your back...)

Reagan may have been the nicest man I ever met. I was sitting down after a funeral, Marines and he discussed the fact he could get my commission back for me... George's dad was there but said nothing. He was sympthetic to a grieving family.

Clinton, Whoo Boy! I was given a question to ask him at a rally. He shook my hand. I then counted my fingers to see if they were there. Anyone who tries to hug me without my permission should know I'll be very careful around them. Anyone who is immediately that intimate has a problem... I asked him a question he wasn't prepared for and his bodyguards let me know their displeasure.

Would I meet with GWB? Yes, because he seems a lot more real than all of the others except for Reagan. I don't like many of the things he is doing, but the things he does are not to hide his latest personal scandal...
I learned a lot about poker since, especially to quit when the cards are running bad.

by maxwell edison

I agree with many of the things you say, but, quite frankly, I think you're full of crap.

You're a Marine pilot AND a doctor AND you've met every president sinc Eisenhower AND everything else you've claimed, AND you post messages on TechRepublic.

Ooooooookay. whatever you say.

It's just getting too friggin' deep. Give me my boots.

by oz_media

Sure I'd like to meet him, actually I think it would be pretty cool. I would probably refrain from knocking him out, only because he is 'protected' so. But I most certainly would tell him I thought he had little credibility and despite his recent training on mannerisms and his awareness of his giveaway lies, he was still unbelievable.

I'd thank him for making th eworld a more volatile place, I would thank him for pulling troops out of Afghanistan so that more Canadians could die in Kandahar, I would thank him for misleading his country's people and then would politely say FU Very much and leave.

Would I shake his hand? Not in my lifetime.

by mickster269

I'd first wonder why the President would want to talk to me. I don't have anything in common with him, except that we are both Male, and baby-boomers.

He's Texan, I grew up in Colorado and live in Kentucky. He's rich, I'm comfortable. He's Christian, I'm Buddhist. I don't think we share any of the same political beliefs.

So, there wouldn't be a lot to talk about. I could ask him how it felt to own a baseball team, and if he thinks the Cubs will EVER win the series again.

I'd be polite to him, though. Even if you don't agree with a man's beliefs, there's no need to be rude.

Now, if I got a chance to meet his Dad, I'd go in heartbeat.

by mickster269

He had served as a U.S. congressman from Texas (1967?1971), ambassador to the United Nations (1971?1973), Republican National Committee chairman (1973?1974), Chief of the U.S. Liaison Office in the People's Republic of China (1974?1976), Director of the Central Intelligence Agency (1976?1977), Chairman of the First International Bank in Houston (1977?1980), and the 43rd Vice President of the United States under President Ronald Reagan (1981?1989).

Not to mention a WWII Fighter Pilot, and was shot down in the South Pacific.

by jdclyde

I did see him in 04' but not up close. Saw him speak at the Saginaw Dow Event Center. (it was that or Grand Rapids).

I would like to try to know more of what he is like.
I would tell him the things I admire.
I would tell him the things that really bother me.

I would hope he would take what I have to say to heart, or at least be able to explain off the record why things are like they are.

by jdclyde

previous one, sure.

for the same reasons he was a terrible president, he would be great at a party. A man that with no moral standards is bound to be the life of the party.

Funny, all the people that were his brainwashed followers trust him to protect the country but wouldn't trust him alone with their daughters. Tells you something about the honesty of his supporters, huh?

Hillary is a horrible person and it shows the mental illness that has taken over the state of NY. To put this "person" in place show they are deficient and deserve everything they don't get from her.

Funny, but what HAS she done since getting that position except scream that horrible scream of hers? While I am VERY apposed to adultery, in this case I at least understand it. don't condone it, but I understand it.

by maxwell edison

In 2008, the next presidential election year, Americans will have had twenty (20) years with either a Bush or a Clinton in the White House. The last thing we'll want is a Clinton bush.

(I didn't really say that, did I?)

by oz_media

And for once, your political comments have amused me. :)

I have to go now, I can't bite my tongue any longer, so....many.....comments....can't....stand..it....gonna implode!

by jaqui

the conditions stated.
I would want to have at least one live broacast of the meeting so when I nail his balls to the wall over his stupidity everyone sees it.

by absolutely

is not in question. It wouldn't matter how stupid you make him look, the AmericanVoter is stupider still.

by absolutely

Maybe reliability is the word to use, not trust, but I'm getting to an interesting point, so be patient. If Bill Clinton has the opportunity with a beautiful young woman, let's all assume he's going to bone her. George W. Bush, on the contrary, hasn't made that reputation for himself, but if he sees a vulnerable country, he'll fire his missiles at it. I prefer to elect somebody who enjoys sex with beautiful young women over somebody who wages war for fun.

by bfilmfan

Yes, I would meet with him.

Although I have great differences with him over his policies, I can differentiate between the man that holds the office and respecting the Office of the President, which we both know are highly different things. Thus, I would be respectful, but tell him that his advisors have sucked American military forces into the swamp of a civil war in Iraq, while back home the politicians are busy taking pot shots at each other rather than solve the problem by putting more soldiers on the ground or disengaging.

Frankly I hope that the next set of debates aren't the softball questions which have been asked in the recent past, but a chance for everyday people to stand up and ask the office seekers questions and give them a chance to answer. If they are evasive or wishy-washy in answers then we'll know a bit more about them, no matter their political party.

by jardinier

I would ask him what it felt like to be leader of the most powerful nation in the world.

I would ask him if he had any regrets about his policy decisions.

And I would definitely shake his hand.

I will tell you something I have observed about talking to politicians when they know there is no media present.

There have been two venues where I have had ample opportunity to listen to, and ask questions of, politicians.

The first was lunch-time talks at university, and the other Sunday night "Question Time" at the Wayside Chapel.

With no fear of their statements being made public, they came across for the most part as totally different people to how they appeared on television, or in statements they made to the media where they had to be "politically correct."

Almost everybody who was anybody of note was a guest speaker at a no-holds-barred public meeting at the Wayside Chapel over a period of 2 - 3 decades.

There is NO substitute for being able to ask questions of a prominent figure in a face-to-face situation without the media being present.

It is not a fear of being misreported, but just the fact that they can "be themselves" without having to fit neatly into the persona which has been carefully moulded to present to the general public a certain, desired image.

by old guy

that Tjsanko was using conjecture not speaking for God. Gee, still trying to instigate instead of understand.

by onbliss

...Hillary if she became the President and you had a chance to meet her? A similar scenario to what you had initially quizzed us about, just that the person is different.

by antuck

I wouldn't meet with President Bush. 15 minutes is not a lot of time. It would be difficult to say what you need and hear his responce. To me it wouldn't be worth it.

by absolutely

I'd ask him for all the documents, recordings, and all data in any other format, that he had about Iraq's Weapons of Mass Deception. Then I'd ask him for all the information presented to Congress, to the UN, and to the US public through the various press channels he used to publicize the Iraq sector of the Axis of Evil. Then I'd interrogate him about the glaring differences among those data sets.

I guess 15 minutes would not be enough.

by absolutely

All gods were invented, by people, to serve the authors' desires. I am a real person, not invented as a fictional device and with purposes of my own, which do not include playing a part in your story or anybody else's but my own. I do not serve you, Old Guy, and I do not serve any of the authors of any story, including the Old Testament and the New Testament.

by sleepin'dawg

Piled Higher and Deeper??? :p Never mind the boots; just get me a shovel so I can get the hell out of here. The stench is making my eyes water. You don't have to go all the way to Denmark to find someting rotten.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

most powerful man in the world would have to be a real experience, especially if it was in a small group; it wouldn't have to be one on one but I would like more than fifteen minutes. I'd like to meet his dad and Dick Cheney as well. Agree with him or disagree with him, it would be an opportunity not to be missed. From everything I've been hearing lately, GWB may not be too good under pressure in front of groups but one on one in an informal situation he is supposed to be an excellent conversationalist and raconteur. You don't graduate from Yale or Harvard with only mush between your ears.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jardinier

that a politician may appear quite different in an informal situation to what he/she may appear under pressure such as at a press conference or public speech.

by thechas

I would absolutely not meet with GWB.

I also don't think I would jump at a chance to meet with Bill Clinton either.

Now, if I had a chance to meet with George H. W. Bush, I would jump at the opportunity.

Heck Max, despite our political differences, I would jump at the opportunity to meet you in person. In fact, if given the choice to meet with you or GWB, I would choose to meet with you.

The primary reason reason I would not meet with GWB is that the meeting would be a waste of time for both of us. Nothing I would say would have any impact on GWB or the remainder of his Presidency. I would fully expect GWB to respond to my concerns with some whimsical folksy comment, and believe that he had addressed my concerns.

Meeting with a President you have no respect for, would only show the limitations of ones personal convictions. If one is strongly at odds with the actions and policies of any leader, showing up for what amounts to a photo-op with them would show a lack of commitment to their own beliefs and causes.

What is a true "snub" to the President is the growing number of Republican candidates who do not want to be scene with GWB lest it loose them votes this fall.

Fair weather political allies like fair weather sports fans are the ones who do the real snubbing.

Chas

by thechas

After thinking some more about this, if I were offered the opportunity to meet with GWB, I would do my best to get the invitation changed from me to my father.

My dad would enjoy and get a lot of benefit from a visit with GWB.

I would make my dad happy in a number of ways, and get a lot of points with him.

Chas

by zlitocook

Yes I would love to meet him! But I would be shot in the first few seconds after that. I would bring all the people who have lost jobs, homes, land, and family to the president and his staff. We have lost jobs, land to imamate domain, family because it gives more to a family with no father and it gives a great deal to people with money.
Ask a republican how to get ahead and they say will invest in oil. And ask how if you only make $20.000 a year and they say invest what you can.
We need to get back to our country and invest in it.
Look at what is spent on the war in what ever and look at what our country needs. I think we need to spend all of our money here first and the help others.

by faradhi

and the position is more than the man. So regardless of my personal feeling of his policies, I would feel honored to meet with him.

As for the questions I would ask, I am not sure. I would have to think long and hard. It would be an appropriate and respectful question, again remebering the position he is filling.

Jessica Simpson is a bimbo and an idiot.

by ontheropes

I?ve given this a little thought.

I?m hardly in support of many of the current Administrations policies but I would meet with him under the conditions you outlined. I find it odd to somehow believe that a meeting like that would be possible. The President may be one of the most powerful and influential people on the planet but he is still a man. As a human he is subject to all of the human frailties just like me, and you, I might add. Perhaps grandiose thinking is one of those frailties.

I believe I would be as respectful towards him as I try to be when meeting anyone for the first time. I feel that deep-down inside we are all created as equals. I?d meet with him on even ground, so to speak, and look him in the eye. I could go on about that but I won?t trouble you or anyone else to follow my thinking processes. There it is anybody, the easy shot. Ouch?

Would I be nervous? If he were to come here and met me on my turf I?ll say no. If we met in the Oval Office or his other official trappings of power, yes. Being out of my element is uncomfortable but I do know how to deal with discomfort successfully.

I would ask George questions about the events of 9/11/2001 and after. It may only take one question to start a dialogue. I?d listen carefully to his answers and study him closely to decide whether or not I believed him. If I had any problems with his answers I like to believe that I?d be able to form adequate follow-up questions and comments to explain my viewpoint clearly. Fifteen minutes is not a lot of time for me depending upon the circumstances I?m in. Sometimes fifteen minutes feels like eternity.

I?d hope to be able to confidently shake his hand when we were through talking. If I believed his answers to my questions I would shake his hand and invite him to go fishing and have a few beers sometime. If I didn?t believe him, I wouldn?t shake his hand and I?d tell him why not if he was puzzled.

For what it?s worth here?s my opinion regarding Jessica Simpson?s snub. I don?t care what she does or doesn?t do. That only reflects on her. I don?t know her and don?t particularly care to know her. I haven?t seen too much of anything to cause me to be impressed by anyone with the last name of Simpson. Nick might be a decent bloke, as the Aussies say, but that?s it.

by aldanatech

I would ask him why he decided to meet with me and not someone like, say Cindy Sheehan. I'm sure she would be far more pleased with the honor. After all, she had a son that gave his life for his president's noble cause. Neither myself nor my children are anywhere near of such an exceptional accomplishment. If he had fifteen minutes to meet with me, would he consider setting another fifteen minutes for the mother of such a heroic soldier and other like her?

by maxwell edison

Well, that's a good question. But actually I've already met with Cindy, Mrs. Sheehan, and I have expressed my personal sorrow, and I offered the thanks of our nation for her great sacrifice. It was a very good meeting. But since that meeting, she's gone on to a life of political activism, mostly aimed against me, and that's fine, she's certainly entitled. There wouldn't be much of a point, though, to meet her again, especially since it would be more of a media circus than a real heart-felt meeting. I was sincere the first time I spoke with her, and I assume that she was sincere as well. It was a good meeting, and we can just leave it at that.

by deadly ernest

It's about the only way I'll get to see the USA.

The first thing I'd ask him is why didn't he abuse all the previous administrations for NOT taking action against Sadam earlier when he first violated the Cease Fire Agreement.

Second things is why doesn't he improve the welfare legislation and funding.

Third is why does he put up with rogue organisations like the CIA - it does little that other organisations don't duplicate now anyway, mainly because the CIA would NOT share data with the other intel organisations. Prune the bugger back and get it back under control.

Fourth ask him to recind the Digital Media act and reef in organisations like RIAA etc, pass legislation making the inclusion of aggressive copyright protection legislation an offence with an automatic 10 years prison for the corporate executives.

Regardless of if you think he's a fool or not he is in a position of power that can be used beneficially if you can get him to so act.

This discussion is closed to new replies.