Discussion Locked

Wrong delivery of messages in Exchange 5

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hello,

I am facing a rather strange situation with my exchange server 5.5 SP3.

I have a some users complaining that they sent email messages to other users and the mails are received from users that do not appear in the TO: section of the email message.

For examples:
I send a message TO: user1@somewhere.com and the message is reveived from user2@elsewhere.com. Note, that user1@somewhere.com received the message, too.

Do you know what is the problem?

How the mail message delivery is working?

What can cause the mail server to send the mail message to a user that is not appearing in the TO: section of the mail message?

PS: Except BCC...

Thanks in advance.

4 replies

by shmaltz

I assume:
1. You are using Outlook as the client (not Outlook Express).
2. All users (senders and recipients) are in the same Exchange Site.
3. You are only using the To field when sending a message and this problem happens.

There are 2 ways this could happen:
1. Rules.
2. Exchange mailbox properties.
1.
Rules you can check on the client side (check the rules for both the recipient and sender, there might exist a rule on the sent items or outbox folder). In outlook click on tules and then the rules wizard.
2.
If you think it's in exchange open up exchange administration highlite the real recipients mailbox and click file > properties. Click the Delivery Options tab. Make sure that alternate recipient is cleared.

by shmaltz

If it still doesn't help:
Make sure tracking is ebabled on the Exchange Server (It's in the server and each connecters properties).
Reproduce the problem (by sending to that recipient and make sure it arrives to the wrong recipient as well).
Open up Outlook, open up the message you just sent, from the sent items folder on the senders mailbox, or from the inbox in the recipients mailbox. Click File > Properties > Message ID. Write down the message ID or copy it to the clipboard or save it to a file (you need all the = and ;).
In Exchange 5.5 click on Tools Track Messages. Choose any server in your site (if this message travels over more then one server in your site, You will have to track it on each server using the same message ID). When the search box comes up click cancel. Click on advance search. Click on Message ID. Entere the message ID click Search. Click Track. In the results you should see if Exchange is redirecting it or not.
If Exchange is redirecting it. Then there is a rule that keeps sending it to the wrong recipient.
Make sure that you dont have any nested rules (where rule 1 redirects it to user2 and user2 has a rule to redirect it to user3). Disable all rules for now. Remove any alternate recipients and then try again.

by shmaltz

If it still happens:
Try disabling the receive option on the recipients mailbox (the wrong recipient that is). You can do that by clicking delivery restrictions In Exchange, and choosing to deny messages from everyone. And see who gets the NDR (NonDeliveryReport). You the sender or the real recipient.
If it's you then you have done something that makes it arrive to the wrong recipeint, or there is an Exchange rule active (not a mailbox rule but an exchange rule, like a mailbox property). Ifit's the real recipient that gets the NDR, then he has a mailbox rule active. If noone gets the NDR then it doesn't arrive to the wrong recipient by messaging. Make sure that the recipient that is not suppose to get it doesn't have any other mailboxopen besides his own.

This discussion is closed to new replies.