Discussion Locked

Yank Tank at root of Oil Crisis!

0 helpful
60 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

As I can no longer locate the relevant thread in "WHY," I am starting a new discussion.
My first car was a 1938 Ford V8 of which I was of course extremely proud.
Moderate sized American built cars were quite popular in Australia for several decades (say 1930 - 1960) possibly because they were cheaper/easier to acquire than English and European cars. However we lost interest by the time the genuine Yank Tank became the norm for Americans: those ugly, unweildy monstrosities which were as thirsty as they were long. By Australian standards (most of what we pay for petrol goes to the Government) petrol was absurdly cheap in America.
But while the trend to ever larger cars continued in the USA, Australia (backed by General Motors) produced the first Holden, which became the standard family car in Australia: a position it held for decades.

First produced more than half a century ago, the Holden was built with unitary contruction: no separate chassis, hence less weight. It had a modest but adequate 6 cylinder engine, room for 6 average sized adults, and because of its extremely light overall weight and modest engine capacity, was extremely economical.

Gradually more and more English, European and Japanese cars were introduced toAustralia, but the choice of the buyer was predominantly economy over size. Thus the Morris Minor and Mini Minor, and Volkswagen became enormously popular.

As the Yank Tank grew large and thirster, the choice of most Australians was towards the smaller, more economical car.

The point is that, compared with all other countries in the world, Americans consumed far more petrol per capita than any other country. And as far as the argument introduced somewhere in the original discussion about isolation of population leading to a dependaence on private transport, that argument applies equally, if not more so, to Australia.

60 replies

by maxwell edison

Yank Tanks - You gotta' love 'em:

http://tinyurl.com/6d5b

Okay, conceding the point that, "compared with all other countries in the world, Americans consumed far more petrol per capita than any other country", I have to ask, therefore what?(My first Yank tank, by the way, was a 1956 Ford Thunderbird (it was 13 years old at the time) that I drove in High School.

by jardinier

"Bless me Father for I have sinned. I have withheld important information on the grounds that it might incriminate me."
"And what is this information, my son?"
"Not only was my first car a 1938 Ford V8, but in the recklessness of my youth I also owned a 1935 Studebaker, and lusted after a semi-derelict Buick straight-eight convertible which the owner declined to sell. What must I do to absolve myself of these sins?"
"Repeat 10 times: 'Hail America, land of the free. Blessed art thou among nations, and blessed is the cornerstone of thy economy, the gas-guzzling mega-vehicle.'"

Yes, Max. They were great in their hey-day, but personally I think they became excessively large and unwieldy.
After 4 decades of mostly small, 4 cylinder cars, I now drive a Volvo: generally agreed to be the safest and one of the highest quality cars ever made.

by seven_sr

Oh god.... not a volvo *cringes*. I'm sure you're different from the mass majority of people that I see on the road, but around here volvo = slow and annoying.
~Scott

by oldefar

I am jealous. Closest I ever came was a 36 Dodge gangster mobile. Unable to convince my father to sign for me, I finally worked up the courage to pull out my life savings and attempted to work a deal on my own. As I drove up, some guy was gettingin it and drove off. Turns out he had just bought it, for $95!

Had to stay with my 63 Dart. A compact car in its day. Bored out slant 6 and 3 speed torque flight push button automatic. I could get rubber in all 3 gears, and scared a lot of Mustang 289's who figured I had to have at least a 340 under the hood. Little did they know that when I got rubber in third I was done - never broke 100mph even downhill with a tailwind.

Parked next to a restored one in my current Buick. That compact Dodge Dart was bigger! As for the Buick - I buy used, drive them to they die. Cheaper that way. Of course, finding someone willing to part with a quality car like a Volvo at a price I am willing to pay is tough.

by thechas

While I am an American, I do not own nor want an SUV.

That said, the US economy DEPENDS on cheap energy!

The US auto industry is the driving force of the US economy. Try as they may, they have yet to find a way to make a profit on vehicles that get over 20 miles per gallon.

In my opinion, a large part of the problem, is that the decision makers in the auto industry are "car nuts". They cannot envision why anyone would want a quality economical vehicle. In their minds, the only marketfor economical cars is the working poor. Combine this with their desire to have engines with 5 times the power needed to perform the required task, and you can see why the US is sold on the fuel hog vehicles we have.

Now, all of the blame cannotgo to the auto industry.
The average worker in the US:
Chooses to live 20 or more miles from where they work.
Refuses to support public transportation.
Refuses to car-pool.
"Needs" a 2500 square foot energy in-efficient home.
Has motorized recreational 'toys' for each season. (that they need to tow for a 6 hour drive to use)
Has numerous motorized lawn 'tools'.

I am likely the only person in my neighborhood that has no gas powered lawn tools.

My point, if there is one, is that the US is not willing to give up it's toys or squanderous energy use until there is no more energy to use.
Somehow, it is perceived to be our God given right to command all the energy on the planet.

Chas

by road-dog

I'm in any way "entitled" to the world's energy. The US economy is based on getting goods and people where they need to be. Oil just happens to be the most economical way to do that right now.

We're not stealing oil, we're BUYING it.

When somebody figures out cold fusion and we have small reactors under the hoods of our SUVs, the middle east will be bitching all the way back to the stone age.

We'll still be the bad guys because our celebration of the individual and free markets will cause our standard of living to outstrip the world.

The sad thing is that many of us will continue to find reasons to blame ourselves for the world's problems.

The middle east is the hell hole that it is because whenever somebody suggests away to make life better that doesn't agree with some fanatic's interpretation of the Koran, that individual is stoned to death.

If you're wanting to whine about "entitlement" to energy, send a letter to the Al-Sabah family in Saudia Arabia. Tellthe how wrong they are for flying their 747s to London so they can shop for suits on seville row and play with the hookers in the nightclubs while swilling Dom Perrignon.

All the while, the Mullahs back home are killing people for dancing or drinking when caught by the morality police.

by maxwell edison

When you said, "We'll still be the bad guys because our celebration of the individual and free markets will cause our standard of living to outstrip the world."

Sure, I suppose it could be argued that Americans want more for themselves (and call it whatever you want), but it's because we expect more out of ourselves. People usually live up to the expectations placed upon them (by others and/or themselves), and our expectations (as a whole) are set rather high.

When will the rest of the world either "get it" or not begrudge us for it?

And why is it that America can buy and refine oil and market it at only a third of the price as the rest of the world? Is this our problem or theirs?

Oil and Automobiles, just like anything else, is driven by supply, want, and demand. We all know that if you build a better mousetrap - or automobile - people will beat a path to your door to buy it. If there's a better way, build it and we will come. The explosion of Japanese cars in the U.S.A.proved that we're not partial to just American cars.

And put in my order for one of those SUVs with the cold fusion reactor under the hood.

by thechas

Sorry for any confusion.

I do not blame the US for the worlds problems.
Although, we help cause a lot of them by our choices of 'friendly' governments, and business partners.

As a country, we can and should do more to bring balance to the world and our lives.

While there is no doubt that we could all make do with smaller more efficient vehicles. We could save nearly as much energy by a slight modification of our driving habits.
Every trip, I see the majority of drivers racing from stop light ot stop light. The gas they use to accelerate above the speed limit, and then sit for nearly the full length of the red light idling is wasted.

If we simply reduced our energy waste by 1/2, there would be no need to talk of the waste of the SUV and other ostentatious trappings of Americanism.

By entitlement, I was not suggesting that we are stealing oil, only that we want ours first, and cheap, the rest of the world is allowed to share what we leave behind.

And that movement of goods, when the big 3 automakers are in a slowdown, the movement of goods drops to a trickle.
It is still true, that when GM gets a cold, the US economy catches pneumonia!

I believe, that George W.'s SUV tax write-off proposal is his plan for economic stimulus to assure re-election.
SUVs are a high profit item not just for the big 3, but for their suppliers as well.
Increasing the sales of SUVs is likely the simplest way to give the US economy a boost.

To assure that people are willing to buy the SUVs, he needs to secure the middle-east oil fields to keep the cost of gas low.

Chas

by generalist

Hmmmmm. I guess that I'm a semi-average worker.

While I live more than twenty miles from work, I ride the bus and take advantage of the longer commute time to read, write, daydream or nap. If I really wanted to, I could also do some computing on a laptop.

While the house I live in is large for the neighborhood, it is smaller than 2500 square feet. Furthermore, we tend to shorten our heating season by living cooler than many and reduce the impact of our cooling season by using the basement and fans instead of airconditioning.

Our motorized recreation 'toy' will consist of a crewcab pickup truck or passenger van we hope to purchase in the next year or so. It would be used for camping and vacation travel as opposed to commuting.And there are a few times when it might haul cargo. (It might be cheaper to rent...)

Our motorized lawn tools consist of a heavy duty gas powered shredder we use for composting.

Of course, there is the electric lawn mower and edger. Powered but not gas powered.

by omie

Let me explain my point...
To be honest I have a SUV.. and you know why ? I live here in NorthEast portion of the US and during the snow storm I don't have problem in going around(Australia don't experience snow). I used the SUV for my job as an ITconsultant in bringing boxes of printers and monitors that won't fit in even the biggest car trunk.

Why in america uses bigger engines ? Well we have a good infrasture so the cars a running at 65MPH in highways. In case of accident you have better chances.

For the gas powered toys... well time is money here. If you spent days to mow your lawn it is up to you... you might have earn more money if you worked. Again the minimum wage here in America is $5.00/hr while in the 3rd world is $5.00/day.I would rather spend in a worthwhile manner. For me they are not toys they are my tools to make my life easier.

For the enviromental aspect .. I think USA have cleaner air to breath compared to other countries.

by thechas

I admit that I think the SUV should be outlawed.
There are numerous other more economical ways to perform the same tasks.
Station wagons, mini-vans, small pick-up trucks, can all transport items more economically than a SUV.

Realistically, the SUV is nothing more than a mini-van on steroids.
The US male resented being forced to drive the feminine mini-van as the family vehicle. The SUV performs the same task, only in a manly fashion.

As to the safety factor. It is starting to come to light, that the SUV may actually be a less safe vehicle than a mid-size sedan. When you factor in roll-overs, damage to smaller vehicles, accidents caused by over-confidence of the SUV driver, the safety advantage of the SUV dwindles.

Yes, in any given accident, you are better off in a SUV than a sub-compact. But shouldn't the goal be to avoid accidents?
Simple physics shows that it is easier to avoid an accident in a small car than in a large SUV.

As to lawn tools, I don't expect everyoneto use hand tools. But, how many 100' by 200' lots require a riding lawn mower?

I only ask that as a nation, we start to consider the global consequences of our choices and forget the almighty dollar.

Chas

by tomsal

You bring some good points TheChas,

however did you know...

Right now the technology exists (and has for at least a decade now) to run cars FAR more fuel efficient than they are made to be now.

There was a study done and published in one of the science magazines about 6 or so years ago in fact (I think it might of been Popular Mechanics?) I remember reading where an experiment was done at a university. The student built an engine that had a fuel economy on the order of like 150 MPG.
Also, there is no argument (I'm an american too) that we are the resource pigs of the world. That isn't news, if any american is shocked by that they must live under a rock or something.

I hate the simplify it down to being money, but I really think that is why there is no fast progression to more fuel/energy efficiency in this country.

The oil and the car industry (auto parts / mechanics, etc.) is ENORMOUS.

If car makers really honesty used all possibly technology today - there's nodoubt we can't have 150 MPG (at least) cars right now. They don't because the Oil industry is too big/powerful. Electric cars are slow to come for likely similar reasons -- what happens to the auto parts industry? what happens to gas stations? Mechanic shops? Electric vehicles don't require half the the parts combustion engine vehicles do.

Finally, our oil (gas) is cheap in this country because its subsidized by taxes. That is the only reason, if it was subsidized we'd be paying just like Europe for it at the pump.

by jardinier

Now you've really got my ears pricked up. Did I hear you correctly? Does the government subsidise gas (oil, petrol) in the USA?

Somewhere in this discussion I mentioned that the greater portion of the cost of petrol in Australia is taxes taken BYthe government.

by admin

unitary contruction: no separate chassis, hence less weight. 6 cyl.... hmmmm.... sounds like my first (and a present) automobile... a 1965 Ford Mustang.... :)

I don't drive it much though... just 4 fun.

The ultimate in light weight gas efficient commuter vehicles for me are 2 wheeled :)

by jardinier

I was under the impression that the Australian Holden, first produced in the late 1940s, was the first car in the world to use unitary contruction. However I did not like to venture this statement as I was not certain. Perhaps you can enlighten me.

by admin

circa early 1930's was unitary construction. I do not know of any preceding that. There very well could be.

The Mustang was of course quite later, I was not saying it was first, just that despite the mythology of all Mustangs being outfitted withhuge motors, originally they came out with a quite small 260 v8 or a small 170 6 cyl in a unitized body. By the end of 1966 production year, they still were an economical 289 v-8 and a 200 straight six. The extreme lightweight unitary cars sold veryvery well in the states at the time and continue to be amoung the most popular cars ever produced in America today.

I was just saying that the American auotomotive industry, despite the current myths, has not always had the burden of affluenza.
And then there was the Nash Metropolitan. :)

by road-dog

See, there ya go! Who decides what's frivolous?

It's too wasteful in this society to have a second computer on your home. We all know that a family of four COULD share a single computer. What if some eco-whiner group decided that something that each of us enjoyed was frivolous and unnecessary?

All of our lives would be managed by the most extreme among us.

Needless to say, other than 2000 calories worth of food, a temperature range between 55 and 100 degrees, and a couple of liters of water per day are all we need. The rest of the things that make up our standard of living make life worth living.

I drive a 1990 Ford Aerostar minivan. I gave up being cool back when it was new. I see SUVs all day on the road, and the only thing that pisses me off about them is when their drivers cannot drive them well enough to make them fit in a single parking space.

Let these guys waste their money at the gas pump, I'm saving up for a H&K PSG-1 rifle! HOOAH!

by oldefar

That was my posting you were refering to.

You are absolutely right that my comment about the evolution of auto versus mass transit applies equally well to Australia. It does.

A seperate issue is style and how that has been shaped. The pump price for gasoline is about the same around the world until the taxes are added. It is the huge tax that creates higher prices elsewhere. This has had the dual effect in many countries of driving popular preference in vehicles to smaller and more efficient models, and providing additional funding for mass transit.

A third benefit was to improve the market demand for local manufacturers over American manufacturers back in the late 1960's. Some countries added other incentives, like Australiawhere the vehicles had to be converted to right hand drive. This doubled the consumer cost for an American import. The US has taken similar steps with its restrictions, beginning in the 1970's when efficient foreign cars grabbed market share domestically.

by jkaras

Yank tank, that cracks me up. Yeah so we indulge a little from now and then. My first tank was a 68 Camero with deluxe interior (only 608 were made!), 327 small block which got stolen from me after only 6 months at high school. I of course replaced it with another 68 Camero, only this was my hot rod that broke down frequently where I put a small block 400 sporting 350hp and 560 ft pounds of torque!!! What a monsta! It cost me a bundle to maintain and still have it rotting in my garage. Now I have a Honda Accord that was my first new car and it is the best car I ever owned. Believe me when I tell you that I was the diehard Chevy fan and everything else was a joke in my opinion. After growing up a bit I realized that I needed a practicle carto make me money, my Honda has only broken down 3 times (2 batteries and a clutch) since I bought it in 97. I have seen the light!!
As for comments about SUVs, well if you can afford it so be it, it's your choice and I dont believe that the war on oil is due to families carting around in their SUVs. Some families require a large vehicle due to divorced families merging kinda like the Brady bunch. Some just have status symbol infatuation and believe that they will be liked or envied, they just bought into the marketing strategies. I'm not a fan of them due to their inability to properly drive them, but thats the chance we all take when we climb into our various death traps. Rather then bicker about how much comsumption why not complain why the industry puts out unsafe vehicles to ensure return business vs. race cars that can with stand 100+ mph crash with little damage to the driver. Lets face it the only thing that gives cancer a run for the money in deaths are car accidents, how bout that for the cost of costs?

by dcosgrove

Energy is a very complex issue. The fact that SUVs make headlines doesn't make them the main culprits here. The US uses crude oil for many things, electricity, tranportation you name it. Lokk at it this way, say personal vehicals account for 50% of the consumption (which they don't). Reduce there consumtion by 25%, a nice drop. Now how much energy did we save, 12.5%. Even with such drastic numbers you can see my point. SUVs are not evil, The US does have sad mass transit, yes we do pass on viable options. I guess I'm just saying that improvements can be made, but focusing on trivial aspect only hurts the entire process. Have you ever heard of soy diesel fuel? You should have.

by maxwell edison

I couldn't disagree more vehemently on a couple of points.

The suggestion that President Bush is proposing –any- kind of tax relief simply to, as you suggested, “assure re-election” has no basis in fact. Contrary to the previous administration where every little move was weighed for its political implications, President Bush’s actions are based on underlying principles. Sure, there are political considerations to keep in mind; after all, if he’s not in office he can’t implement his ideas. But I don’t think he compromises his principles for the sake of advancing his political future. He builds his policies on a set of core principles, he acts accordingly, and just lets the political chips fall where they may.

In the case of tax relief, for example, he believes that it’s a viable method to stimulate a faltering economy. He believes that more dollars belong in the hands of those who earned them. And he believes that if you tax something (namely production) you get less of it, and if you subsidize something (namely government hand-out programs) you get more of it.

(continued...)

by maxwell edison

In the case of wanting to get his hands on Iraq’s oil, I think that this is very flawed thinking. President Bush has no desire to “acquire” or otherwise “secure” Iraq’s oil. Sure, Iraq’s position as a major supplier of the world’s oil is a political factor – a political factor, I might add, that is considered by everyone involved (or not involved) regardless of which side they’re on – because ensuring the free flow of oil on the open and free market is to everyone’s benefit. President Bush believes in free markets – plain and simple.

Consider this scenario for being determined to unseat Saddam Hussein: Saddam Hussein hates the United States, considers us the“Great Satin”, and he has amassed weapons of mass destruction. If Saddam could arrange it, he would supply one or more of those weapons to others (terrorists) who would smuggle them into the United States, detonate it (or them) in a major U.S. city (or cities), thereby killing tens of thousands of Americans. I think that President Bush truly believes that this is a very likely scenario – more likely if gone un-checked - and I agree with him. His underlying principle is this: He will do everything in his power to prevent this scenario from becoming reality. The present and future conflict with Iraq is not about oil. It’s about providing security for the American people.

by jkaras

Max, I know that you are a Bush fan, but couldnt it be a possibility that Bush could save face by war with Saddam due to his failure to catch Osama? How come we dont hear any news of attempts to find him? That the USA economy could rebound because war is known to be great for economies, ensuring a relection? Like it or not they are possibilities and I hope that it's not the case. I'll admit I'm not a fan of Bush (well at least a different bush..hehehe)he's my president and hope he makes the right choice and will still support him if what he claims is true, to me patriotic duty is questioning the actions of our leaders vs. blind faith. I know you are very politically informed, I'm not, but I'm trying. You said Saddam sees us as the "Great Satin", did you mean satan or what does Satin mean in this context? And if your wondering whether I think Saddam and that Kim whats his name is nuttier than a squirrel turd, the answer is yeah, it's not spin doctoring, they need to go. I believe that they want destruction or the illusion to ensure power and clout in the world, but if we dont handle the situation properly then we open up more cans of worms that will plaque future generations or play into their twisted schemes. Please respond so Ican get a better understanding. cya

by dcosgrove

If the US has one inherant weeaknes in the way it deals with the rest of the world, it's the fact that we get a new boss every 4 years. Not to look down on the rest of the world, but think of it this way. If you son want's candy for dinner, how doyou deal with it? Say yes and he's very happy and loves you, say no, he screams and hates you. So is it right to feed him candy? For the past 12 years, Iraq has been allowed to scoff at the UN and play games, it's his choice to divert money from food and medicine to the military and to break his treaty with the UN. And N. Korea was given all the stuff it wanted. World opinion goes up, we are the benevolent big brother of the world, right. Wrong, we're the bad parent, and yes, we do have to act as a parent sometimes. It is simply more obvious and painful when one administration takes the easy way out and the next won't or in this case can't. It's kinda like "wait till your father gets home", Mom looks nice, Dad is a bully. As far as Saddams view of the world, yes, we are Satan, the devil. We treat women as equals and allow personal freedoms forbidden in the Koran. Even if we lifted all sanctions and left him alone he would not say, "hey, thery're not so bad after all" He'd say "see, the great Satan has looked in my eyes and run like a coward". I've spent time in Egypt with the Army, and I lived with two Iraqi refugees. I was really kind of like you during the first Gulf war, I went to anti war protests etc. Those two getlemen changed my mind. They told me first hand what it was like hiding under a mattress to listen to the BBC, knowing that there family would be killed if they were caught. Not them, there family. That way they would suffer with the knowlege that they were responsible. Nice huh?

by maxwell edison

I hate it when that happens - These stupid spell checkers should be improved to be "context" checkers as well. (But I take the blame myself.)

Saddam thinks we are the Great "Satan" (With an a).

Thanks for pointing out my error.

by maxwell edison

Sure, I suppose it's obvious that I hold President Bush in high esteem. And I do so because I see him as such an honest and principled man. (The fact that we agree on most, but not all, political issues doesn't hurt either.) I’ve always liked him, and have always maintained that he’s not the “idiot” that many made him out to be. He rose to the occasion in the days after 9-11; he’s done everything to earn the trust of the American people, while he’s done nothing to violate that trust. So I can't agree with your assertion about him simply trying to "save face". I just don't buy it; that's not who he is. He’s acting on principle, no one can show any evidence to the contrary (just baseless speculation), and he’s doing what he believes to be the right thing.

And besides, who ever said the chase for Osama is over? I'm certain that there are efforts going on right now to find bin Laden. I'm also certain that if those efforts were made public, they would be compromised. Quite frankly, I would hate to see a "play-by-play" on the nightly news about that effort. (Besides, he may be buried in a cave.)

Another point is this. The war in which we are engaged is against "terrorism". Osama bin Laden is not the supreme commander of all terrorists. He's only one spoke in a larger wheel. Saddam is another spoke, and there are others. We have to look at this threat in the wider context that it deserves, and refrain from getting tunnel vision.

Osama bin Laden led the group that crashed planes into the world Trade Center. But let’s not forget the first attempt to bring the twin towers down. The 1993 bombing at the WTC, which killed 6 and injured hundreds, was planned and carried out by Ramzi Yousef, an Iraqi intelligence agent. Was he following Saddam’s orders? (Rhetorical question)

by thechas

Perhaps, I have become too cynical.

I see every policy proposed by the Bush administration as a handout to his political donor base.

A tax cut plan that primarily aids the upper 5% of tax payers.

Exploiting our natural resources.

By-passing existing labor unions.

The proposed tax write-off for buying a SUV was my last straw.

When he was campaigning, every speech I heard was revised to 'pander' to the local audience.

While the 'goal' of the Iraq struggle is NOT to take theiroil. A 'MAJOR' side benefit of toppling the Husein government is the opening of Iraq's oil reserves.

The resultant 'cheap' oil, and the SUV tax incentive WILL provide a sudden rebound to the US economy just in time to assure President Bush's re-election.

Chas

by road-dog

To give a different speech to different audiences is common during campaigns. A group of machinists in an auto parts plant is not interested in hearing about farm subsidies, get it? This is a good thing, really. A really big liar like Al Gore who has to inflate his accomplishments can really generate t.v. footage and show inconsistancies.

Although I'm not in that top 5% tax bracket, I'm happy that tax cuts are coming. Considering those 5 % pay over 20% of total tax revenues, it's beyond insane. The bottom 50 % pay 4% of taxes. The rest is shouldered by us workers who got trained and left the minimum wage behind.

What has he done that exploits natural resources? This issue is so big that I need to know what your specific problem is. Is it possible that you hear so much in the mainstream media about Bush destroying the environment that you feel like he is but don't really know why?

I don't know of anything he's done to unions, other than attempting to keep the federal baggage screeners from being in the federal employees union. I've worked in union shops, and found that the worst employees, who make your job unsafe or that never carry their weight are the biggest union proponents. I've known guys who walk around with the union contract in their pockets all day (really). They were the biggest "no-loads" in the shop and constantly had the shop stewards trying to get them paid overtime for an Engineer tightening a screw. If Bush made every federal job non-union, I wouldfeel a little better on April 15th.

I'll addess the "war for oil" thing in another post, I'd appreciate you clarifying you being suspicious about timing. After all, George (41) won his gulf war and still lost the election.

by jkaras

Thanks both Max and Dcosgrove for your excellent points, you both answered your opinions well as expected. Yes I do feel we need to be in there insuring compliance and I have a friend stationed in an undisclosed base ready to fight. I appreciate hissacrifice for the greater good, merley playing "devil's advocate" ( no pun intended...really) and would hate to lose a friend for a political platform. My opinions of polititicans tend to swing towards self serving elitists, rather than altruistic leaders desiring change/evolution of the human race rather than a certain ethnicity. Just the switch from the hunt of Osama to war with Saddam changed direction a little fast to me that raised an eyebrow coupled with the reluctancy of the UN to back the investigation. It's nice to know that the UN doesnt act swiftly to ensure the peace as expected and prefers to not have the balls to find out vs. debate with half a$$ inspections. I desire them to be the heavy handed parent ready to punish vs. utilizing military might to get proof. This situation merley proves my disdain for the people responsible for the evolution of mankind.
P.S. excuse my typos on my big words LOL

by thechas

Yes, I know that you need to tailer a speech to the audience.
The things I heard were statements that conflicted his 'core' policies, or something he had said just the day before, because yesterdays promises would not play with today's group.

Onthe environment, the administrations plans are so bad the their own EPA boss is near the point of quiting because she can't support the policies.
From weakening pollution regulations, to the Alaska oil fields, there are just too many instances where the wants of big business are over-riding saving the planet for the future.

On the union issue, it goes beyond the new security screeners. All of the workers who's agencies were moved into the Homeland Security Department LOST there collective bargaining agreements.
That is why the Democrat's would not act on the package.

Now, I'm not a big proponent of Unions, but I disagree with simply summarily voiding a collective bargaining agreement by making it part of critical legislation.

As to the timing issue:
Say the action starts mid March.
Give it 3 months of major action, followed by 6 months of photo-ops of the US troops helping Iraqi villagers.

Barring any major destruction of the oil fields, the oil will begin to flow to the world markets before Christmas 2003.

Gee, 2004 is a Presidential election year.
Fuel prices will be down, SUV sales will be up, the US economy will be booming.

The problem that George H. Bush had, was a year of a stagnant economy between the Gulf War, and the election year.

Remember, the US funded a lot of the technology that Iraq has when Iraq was fighting our enemy Iran in the 80's.

Chas

by maxwell edison

The SUV business tax write-off to which TheChas is referring was (and is) part of an economic stimulus package first passed by Congress and signed by President Clinton in 1996. The amount of the write-off has been on an automatic (emphasis on automatic) accelerated schedule, increasing the amount of allowable write-off each year since 1996. That's when Congress changed the tax laws to encourage business investment. Tax experts say the light-truck tax loophole was originally targeted for farmersso their working pickup trucks would not be treated, for tax purposes, like luxury cars.

But to be totally honest about it, this provision is part of a HUGE (and I do mean HUGE) budget bill that the President (whoever he is, regardless of political party) must sign every year in order to keep the financial functions of the government running. (We’ve all heard past rhetoric about “shutting down the government” by not signing, not submitting, etc. – each political sideblaming the other. But we all know – don’t we? – that this is nothing more than political posturing.)

As I said, President Bush signed this “overall” package most recently, but President Clinton (with whom it all started) also signed it in 1996, 1997, 1998, 1999 and 2000. President Bush signed it in 2001 and 2002. Moreover, the real provision is full of (intended?) loopholes, which makes this SUV write-off possible in the first place.

(continued...)

by maxwell edison

Gee, this gives credence to the line-item veto argument, doesn’t it? (Generally opposed by Democrats and favored by Republicans – but to be totally honest, both parties play the game equally well.) However, The Supreme Court ruled in 1998 the line item veto unconstitutional. The pro-spending lobby in Washington had quite the celebration, but Democrats and Republicans alike, now that pork projects all over the country will be spared presidential cancellation, are happy. In fact, justbefore the High Court ruled on the issue, Sen. Robert C. Byrd (D-W.Va.), long the prince of pork on Capitol Hill, declared that if the court strikes down the line item veto, it would be "my Christmas wish come true."
See this link:
http://tinyurl.com/6gxx
A most recent “provision” (pork) included in this HUGE bill is one submitted by House Minority Leader, Nancy Pelosi (Democrat, California) which will give 1 million dollars to a California based, Democrat Party supported “think tank”. Now how did that get approved? (Yea, President Bush signed the overall bill in which this was buried.)
These kinds of things also give credence to the argument for a simpler tax code. Personally, I’d be in favor of scrappingthe whole 17,000 page, 2.8 million word code, and starting all over from scratch. (Okay Congress, we’re starting with nothing, and nobody gets to leave this room until it’s finished. Well, I can dream, can’t I?)
Again, this is an item that awakened my pet peeve, which is stating a false premise, thereby building a faulty argument, and drawing a conclusion based on a false premise and a faulty argument. What does that say about the conclusion?
A side note for all you IT Consultants out there – buy a light truck (of which an SUV is a subset) for your business vehicle. You’ll get a nice – and well deserved – tax break.

by maxwell edison

Gee, this gives credence to the line-item veto argument, doesn’t it? (Generally opposed by Democrats and favored by Republicans – but to be totally honest, both parties play the game equally well.) However, The Supreme Court ruled in 1998 the line item veto unconstitutional. The pro-spending lobby in Washington had quite the celebration, but Democrats and Republicans alike, now that pork projects all over the country will be spared presidential cancellation, are happy. In fact, justbefore the High Court ruled on the issue, Sen. Robert C. Byrd (D-W.Va.), long the prince of pork on Capitol Hill, declared that if the court strikes down the line item veto, it would be "my Christmas wish come true."

See this link:

http://tinyurl.com/6gxx

A most recent “provision” (pork) included in this HUGE bill is one submitted by House Minority Leader, Nancy Pelosi (Democrat, California) which will give 1 million dollars to a California based, Democrat Party supported “think tank”. Now how did that get approved? (Yea, President Bush signed the overall bill in which this was buried.)

These kinds of things also give credence to the argument for a simpler tax code. Personally, I’d be in favor of scrapping the whole 17,000 page, 2.8 million word code, and starting all over from scratch. (Okay Congress, we’re starting with nothing, and nobody gets to leave this room until it’s finished. Well, I can dream, can’t I?)

Again, this is an item that awakened my pet peeve, which is stating a false premise, thereby building a faulty argument, and drawing a conclusion based on a false premise and a faulty argument. What does that say about the conclusion?

A side note for all you IT Consultants out there – buy a light truck (of which an SUV is a subset) for your business vehicle. You’ll get a nice – and well deserved – tax break.

by admin

"Again, this is an item that awakened my pet peeve, which is stating a false premise, thereby building a faulty argument, and drawing a conclusion based on a false premise and a faulty argument. What does that say about the conclusion? "

The conclusion could very well be true. A deductively valid argument can go from:
true premises to a true conclusion, false premises to a true conclusion or false premises to a false conclusion. Interestingly enough a
deductively valid argument cannot go from true premises to a false conclusion however.

even if "a" is a false premise, then if a=b and b=c therefore a=c is both a valid argument AND a true conclusion. "stating a false premise, thereby building a faulty argument" would then be incorrect with the conclusion that a false premise necessitates a faulty argument. Furthermore we can demonstrate that if a=b and b=c therefore a=e but later realize that c=e that although our original conclusion was derived from an invalid argument, it is neverless true. Therefore "drawing a conclusion based on a false premise and a faulty argument" can indeed lead to a true conclusion.

by maxwell edison

Before I comment on your other points will you please provide some detail to the assertions you’ve made?

For example, what exactly is President Bush doing that is, as you put it, “exploiting our natural resources”? And will you please provide a link to a story that shows Christy Todd Whitman is near quitting because of a policy conflict? This is a new one on me. I’ve not heart that before.

While President Bush was campaigning, how did he “pander” to local audiences in a way that “conflicted” with his “core policies”? What exactly did he say, and what exactly did he say that was contrary to his previously stated policies?

On the union issue, and we may disagree on this, but I think that, generally speaking, unions have crossed the line from protecting the workers to exploiting the employers. Unions have grown from something that truly did help transform the working environment for the good, into what unions are today - an uncontrollable monster. They just don’t know when to stop wanting more. Moreover, I resent the fact that a union represents ANY government worker because the potential conflicts abound. How can one serve two masters, so to speak? Is the government worker there for my benefit or the union’s? It can’t be both. This is especially true with the Homeland Security Department where incompetent workers must be dealt with without any interference from their union. (Not to mention the fact the unions are VERY partisan.)

As far as the “war for oil” argument, please see my rebuttals in other messages and/or threads. I’ll find them and repost them if anyone makes that request. Feel free to comment on thosemessages.

(The SUV tax write-off issue is covered in another message. Sorry about the double post.)

by cactus pete

You mention that unions, in your opinion, have gone from protecting workers to exploiting employers.

I would go so far as to say that, in general, unions have begun protecting themselves [their leaders] by exploiting employees as well as employers.

I am truly sorry if I offend anyone with that, but I have had first hand knowledge of high level annual meetings that just had to be held in Vegas... where no one met another for the purpose of discussing anything pertinent to the good of the workers or furthering the industry.

I lost my world-view/humanity innocence that day.

by thechas

The story about Cristy Todd Whitman was on NPR weeks ago.
As I recall, it was in the form of a 'leak', and was soundly denied by the Bush administration.

As to the environment in general, one of the first things that Bush's team did as soon as he entered office, was to place on hold as many environmental initiatives as they could.
These dealt with drinking water quality, air pollution issues in some national parks, logging and a few other items that slip my mind.
Further, the Bush budget significantly reduces funding for the EPA making it virtually impossible for the EPA to enforce the laws already on the books.

As to 'pandering', I remember 2 back to back speeches where he told one group that we would not enact a specific policy.
The next day, in a different state, he told another group that he fully supported the policy.
I don't recall the specific issue. I only recall the event because that was the point in the campaign that I decided that I personally could not supportor vote for Mr Bush.

For the record, I voted for Ralph Nader in 2000. My vote was a naive hope that the major parties would begin to see that the polarization of the present candidate selection process leaves moderate voters with no choice.

I agree that most unions are no longer helping the US workforce.
My issue was not that the new Homeland Security workers would not have collective bargaining.
My issue is that the existing staff of departments shuffled into the Homeland Security Department lost their agreements with no do process, or compensation.

YES, the war is about a valid security issue.
However, IF the oil fields are opened up, and the oil is flowing, the resultant lower cost for oil in the world WILL fuel a significant recovery of the US economy. Just in time for the 2004 elections.

Chas

by maxwell edison

Alaskans on ANWR:

http://tinyurl.com/6jiz

http://tinyurl.com/6jj9

http://tinyurl.com/6jjb

http://tinyurl.com/6jjc

Government workers and collective bargaining:

“The National Labor Relations Act (NLRA), enacted by congress in 1935, is the law that gives the private sector workers legal rights to join unions and bargain collectively with their employer. Federal employees are not covered by the NLRA, with the exception of the U.S. Postal Service.”

Link:

http://tinyurl.com/6jjm

by maxwell edison

I think it’s time I put an end to my off-topic, political, foreign policy, etc. discussion comments. (However, I reserve the right to change my mind. After all, I didn’t say I wouldn’t continue reading them.) Not that I’m frustrated, PO'ed, or anything like that, but I think I’ve said all that I can. (And I’ve got work to do.)

I want to thank Thamer, Duck and Guru for opening these threads, which gave me (and others) the chance to voice opinion and engage in honest debate. It’s been a fun experience. To those with whom I’ve disagreed, I hope we can end the discussion respectfully agreeing to disagree. To those with whom I agree, I’m glad to see that you see things in the correct light (yuk yuk). If anyone wants to continue discussing any of these (or any other) issues with me (for whatever reason), feel free to email me. I’ll gladly reply. (But be warned, I do have a tendency to ramble.)

See ya' at the next discussion and/or at the Q&A.

maxwell_t_edison@yahoo.com

by guruofdos

Been fun, hasn't it?!! Ah well, I suppose we should show willing and go and mend a few computers...

by guruofdos

In Germany, around many of the US military bases, you will see piles and piles of rusting American cars. When US service personnel are 'posted' to Europe, they are allowed to ship out their own car. Of course, the first TUV or MOT test they try and pass, they fail miserably!! It is cheaper to buy a 'new' car in Europe than it is to get a 'Yank Tank' converted to European emissions and safety standards. When said soldiers and airmen (or women) go home to the US, they can ship a vehicle back. An incredibly large proportion ship back their European purchases!! This gives the USA a chance to aquire cheap BMW's and Volvos, helps them dump their old jalopys in Europe and provides a thriving spares market for those Europeans who somehow still think it's cool to drive a gas guzzler! Everybody happy yet?!!

by jkaras

Dont be bitter cause our cars are cooler than yours, ours have style! There is always a demand for cars from other countries, it makes the driver stand out as different. Everyone spluges on excess whether it's cars, collectibles etc.. who cares whatanybody else thinks, it's personal preference to spoil oneself over the hard work that we all do everyday. If it puts a smile on your face, good, it's not killing anybody (and non of that emissions killing the environment and people yadda yadda we all injest far more toxins on a daily basis than smog will reduce your life). Both sides of the pond have the demand as well as the supply so everyone's happy. Hoooray for toys, who says there only for kids?!!!!!!

by jardinier

On the contrary because of its excellent handling ... you can throw it into any corner at any speed and there is NO body roll (in obvious contrast to earlier Yank tanks)... I am inclined to drive more vigorously than I normally would.
Often ignoring the speed limit of 60 KPH (37 MPH) in built-up areas, I usually drive faster than most other drivers.
It has been explained to me that the Volvo myth originated with elderly drivers, with the necessary finance, choosing a Volvo for its safety features, but driving slowly merely because there were elderly people.
I live in an area of Sydney (the Upper North Shore) where the Volvo is the preferred means of transport.

At no time have I observed Volvo drivers driving in any manner differentthan other drivers, except perhaps for the fact that they are likely to be more polite (no road-rage, honking or finger signals).

I suspect that there is a jealousy factor involved, because they are a relatively expensive car (around $AU 55,000).They are of course extremely well built and will give you 250,000 miles if properly serviced.

by omie

Well, running 37 mph here in the continental US highway is a crime. Police will pull you over for traffic obstruction. In the highways say I-95 in the East Coast has a minimum speed of 50MPH.

There are even times that you will be involved in an accident because you are running slow in the highway for a lot of vehicle will be passing left and right.

by jardinier

I stongly recommend that you READ a posting before commenting on it. The 37 MPH limit applies to built-up areas, as in suburbs, cities, side-streets, little children running out from behind parked cars etc.
I have certainly pressed a sensitive button by mentioning the word Volvo. What is the particular hang-up you have about high quality European cars? Could it have anything to do with the fact that they are better made, better designed and more durable than US rust-buckets?

Boy I am REALLYGETTING PISSED OFF with you arrogant yanks.
Perhaps these discussions should be confined to IT matters, for which they are intended. Perhaps techrepublic could find a way of blocking discussions that stray way off the area for which they are intended.

by jardinier

Thanks Duck for your typical cool, reasoned, non-judgmental comments. This gives me the opportunity I wanted to thank you for the humility, courteousness and commonsense that is a feature of your postings.
You will certainly hear more from "down under."

by jardinier

Hi Max. Thanks for your informative posting. And yes, my website is intended to provoke discussion, not present absolute opinions. And whilst I take great effort to research certain articles to ensure accuracy, others are just ideas off the top of my head. All contributions welcome.

by thechas

Fair enough.

I do have a tendency to lump things together.

In my mind, (what little there is) the protections afforded to most Federal Workers are akin to Union benefits.

The fact remains, that a large number of workers were transfered fromother agencies to the Homeland Security Department, and LOST many protections that they had.

As to the EPA, I can only hope that the story about Ms. Whitman's potential resignation lead to some changes in policy.

Chas

by thechas

As far as I am aware, there are no direct gasoline price subsidies from the US government.

There are some VERY generous tax write-offs for oil exploration, equipment depreciation, and other COSTS of drilling for oil.

The US is also very liberal on allowing the use of public lands for drilling.

So, while not direct subsidies, the cost of exploration and drilling for oil are at a minimum, tax free.

The majority of taxes on motor fuel, are used to fund highway construction and repair.
Chas

by jkaras

Groovy, hip, fresh, fly, smokin, hellabad, sweet, bitch'in, mad, bling bling, roll'in, righteous, any work for ya? hehehehe

by guruofdos

Any of the above! Actually, I had a 1972 8.2 litre V8 Caddy Eldorado in metallic maroon with a white vinyl roof and matching white leather interior for a while (try getting spare for THEM in the UK!!!), but then fell in love with a 1967 Rover P5B 3.5 litre. Drove that through the last Gulf Oil Crisis then got married, so the thirsty motors had to go. Now I won't drive anything that does less than 65 miles to a gallon!!!

by maxwell edison

jul646,

I had to chuckle at your post.

You said, "Boy I am REALLY GETTING PISSED OFF with you arrogant yanks". Well, in all honesty there are arrogant "others" getting the "yanks" PO'ed as well. Moreover, there are arroogant yanks getting other yanks PO'ed. (I may be one of them, or both of them, or whatever.) That's one of the reasons I posted my message saying farewell. It's really getting out of hand.

As far as European cars, those high quality vehicles, they're everywhere. Audi, Mercedes, Those new VW Beetles, and so on. And especially those Ferraris - I have THREE of them (Dream on....)

And don't forget, Secretary of State Colin Powell collects vintige Volvos. I think he has a dozen or more.

By the way, I owe you an email and/or posting to your Web site, don't I?

by mallardtooxx

Woah there pardner, I think your Volvo is gonna hit a curb. I don't see any reason to get Pissed here I really do not. I think these last few threads have been kinda theraputic in a way. I understand the reasoning behind your angst here, but I think it is boiling for the wrong reason. I don't think it is a matter of arrogance, I think of it more as ribbing. There are very few people here who are malicious. Just take a step back cool off and consider the sources. Max for instance is not intending to piss you off, he is just playing with you. None of us are trying to get your goat, we are just having fun. My advice in this is; if people are getting to you then just don't post around them, otherwise you will have to expect people to mess with you, it goes along with the community we have formed here. As for off IT subjects, well I think it is necessary from time to time to come out of our little worlds and see what is happening outside our cubicles/offices. I for one hope you remain, it is nice to have a down-under perspective on matters.

-duck

by jardinier

My 1935 Studebaker did 12 miles per imperial gallon, and had a top speed of 70 mph. However it also featured an automatic choke and a freewheel feature.
A fading pale blue when I acquired it, I decided to repaint it tangerine and black: a popular combination for clothing in the early sixties. Everyone was of course horrified.

But as the two-toning was complemented by the lines of the car, even the fuddy-duddies had to admit that it looked real cool.

One of the greater regrets of my life: I didn't take a colour photo of it before its untimely demise (another story).

by maddiuex

Face it, If it wasn't for America. You would not have all the items you have, and the reason you have cheap gas, is america keeps giving you our tax dollars, so you will whine...So the rest of the world wants to be the best, Like us americans... dream

by guruofdos

An American comedian once said...and I quote:

'The American people won't call the US President a pussy behind his back...so they elected a man called 'Bush' so they can tell it to his face!'

Funny how Bush is listening to Blair at last over the Middle East?!

This discussion is closed to new replies.