Discussion Locked

You don't have the right to not be offended

0 helpful
282 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Not in the US, nor any country I know of, do you have legal protections from getting your feelings hurt or being offended.

In the US, we have adopted the policy of the "Pursuit of happYness". This does not give you the RIGHT TO HAPPYNESS. It gives you only the right to do what you can to achieve happyness.

People have Freedom of Speech as part of our Constitution. I know other countries belive in this, but not sure if they have it in writing or not.

This Free speech, provided it does not incite violence, is protected, not EVEN when it is unpopular, but ESPECIALLY when it is unpopular as THAT is when it NEEDS protecting.

If you do not like what the speech is about, then you do not have to listen, but you may NOT interfere with them. You may leave, or you may use your free speech to counter.

You do NOT have the right to not get offended by someone elses free speech.

The attacks on everything Religious in America over the last few years has been a violation of this free speech.

The most recent is the attempts to DE-Christmas Christmas. If you do not wish to celebrate Christmas, don't. There have been MANY steps taken to INCLUDE other religious holidays during this time, but they have not seen the same attacks on them. (go figure).

When someone tells you "Merry Christmas", it is a wish of peace and happyness for you and your family. How can you be offended by this?

If you give me a heart felt well wish, based on anything you believe in, I welcome it as the blessing it is intended.

And with the shape the world is in, couldn't we all use some blessing and well wishes right about now?

Merry Christmas.

282 replies

by bob in calgary

I am in no way religious, As long as the "religious" don't force there beliefs on me, I doesn't matter which god or religion you believe in, That is for each individual to be at peace with. Just think what a wonderful world it would be if all religions accepted each other without judgement.

However having said that

I wish each and everyone of you a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year. And may your god go with you in peace.

by jdclyde

Merry Christmas!

Hope things are going better? Haven't heard from you in a while.

Best wishes.

by bob in calgary

Kids are coming home for christmas so we will have a good time, Met a really cool lady so all in all life is going well.

by jdmercha

The real issue is that government funds cannot be used promote religion. It is fine for a postal worker to wish you a Merry Christmas when you drop off your packages, but they cannot use USPS funds to buy a sign that says Merry Christmas.

by tonythetiger

"The real issue is that government funds cannot be used promote religion."

Nor should they be used to discourage it!

by daytonajim

< "The real issue is that government funds cannot...
"The real issue is that government funds cannot be used promote religion."

Nor should they be used to discourage it! >

AMEN!!!

by barghesthowl

The government should remain strictly religion-neutral, neither promoting nor discouraging religion in general, or any religion in particular.

Posting the Ten Commandments or using government funds to put up a manger scene is a government endorsement of religion, which is and should be prohibited.

Similarly, if the government were to prohibit a person from putting up such things at their home or business, that is also an unlawful government intrusion into a private religious matter.

I agree with a different poster who said there's nothing wrong with a postal worker wishing someone a "Merry Christmas"-that's simply a personal expression of goodwill. Now, if the Post Office were to require that -all- employees do this, including the non-Christian ones, that would be unacceptable.

The government may not prohibit you from privately expressing your religious beliefs (even, within reason, upon public property), nor may they endorse or fund religious endeavors or displays. Exactly as it should be-they should KEEP OUT.

by jdclyde

It is funny how many people have taken the myth of Separation of Church and State to be gospel. How is it people that people in IT with so much information at their fingertips just take that at face value?

There is NOTHING in our Constitution prohibiting federal money going to religion.

[i] "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof..." [/i]

The ONLY thing this does is ensure people the freedom to openly practice what ever religion they wish. It was later DISCUSSED by Jefferson and he wrote to the Danbury Baptists the words that people quite regularly misrepresent to be part of the constitution and used the words "separation of church and state".

[i]I contemplate with solemn reverence that act of the whole American people which declared that their legislature should "make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof," thus building a wall of separation between Church and State.[/i]
http://www.loc.gov/loc/lcib/9806/danpre.html

His intent was to assure the Baptist that they will not have to worry about if the offical religion of the state would change and put them out. Look it up. There used to be official religions in states. This all from out founding fathers.

If you do not believe this, look it up yourself and you will see that there is NO legal right for the government to PROHIBIT religion and the practicing of such.

The courts have also agreed that the government CAN give money to religions organizations providing they do not endorse a single religion.

I know this will be hard to accept from people that WANT the lie to continue, but if you are honest AND look into it yourself (and read the constitution) you will come to the same conclusion about the lie of Separation of Church and State as a constitutional directive.

Note: see this link where I did a much better job of presenting this, using referenced sources.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=185288&messageID=1897758

by barghesthowl

...a 1797 treaty passed -unanimously- by the Senate, and happily endorsed by Pres. John Adams:

" Art. 11. As the Government of the United States of America is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion; as it has in itself no character of enmity against the laws, religion, or tranquillity, of Mussulmen; and, as the said States never entered into any war, or act of hostility against any Mahometan nation, it is declared by the parties, that no pretext arising from religious opinions, shall ever produce an interruption of the harmony existing between the two countries."

THAT, at the time, was a unanimous act of Congress, having force of law. The Constitution is the charter of the United States, and as such, holds the highest force of law in the land. The writings of Thomas Jefferson, while excellent and having a great amount of historical value, do NOT have the force of law.

Let's take your premise, that the Constitution applies -only- to the federal government, to its logical conclusion.

-The vast majority of police searches/seizures are not conducted by the federal government, but by state, county, or city police departments. Therefore, these departments would not be subject to Fourth Amendment guarantees, and don't bother with that idiotic warrant, just barge in wherever you'd like.

-Most criminal punishments are under state law, not federal. Therefore, states would be free of the cruel, unusual, and excessive punishment restrictions, and of the freedom of religion requirement. Therefore, states would be free to implement public floggings for failing to attend the "correct" church.

-The state's also free to implement executions of anyone who speaks against that church, because along with being free of those pesky cruel and unusual punishment restrictions, they've also been freed from those nasty freedom of speech/expression ones. But while you're waiting to be burned at the stake, you can take comfort in the fact it's not the federal government doing it.

Luckily, the Supreme Court took a bit wiser interpretation-that the Constitution, being the supreme law of the land, applies to EVERY governmental entity within that land. Think carefully about which one you'd wish to see.

by jeasterlingtech9

the problem is the government especially the courts selectively enforces the rule, Christianity, Judaism, bad-- Wicca, Islam, Gaia (earth worshiping paganism) atheism, those are ok and if 999 of 1000 are Christian, Jewish, or don't care and 1 is offended well we just have to keep the 1 happy, screw the 999's rights. What is right about that?

The only two groups you are free to discriminate against are Christians and fat people

by jdclyde

the people that don't fall in with the pretty people.

More "common" looking people than supermodels, yet the models run the world.

So much for all the hypocritical talk of equality we hear about ALL THE TIME.

by absolutely

In what way do Wicca, Islam, Gaia or atheism receive preferential treatment by US government?

by road-dog

My World Studies Teacher gave us the "ins and outs" of Hinduism, Buddhism, Islam, and to a lesser degree various pantheistic "earth worshipping" forms of religeon. I don't see it as indoctrination.

I suspect that he had some contempt for Christians, he really disliked the book banning types that wanted a school library to pull "Making it with Mademoiselle", sight unseen I presume. It turned out to be a sewing pattern book.

He might not have had the most balanced approach, but I don't equate teaching the "bullet points" of other religions with indoctrination.

He got me to like the composition and fullness of the Electric Light Orchestra, so I consider it a fair education.

I thing Christians are too ready to call offense as relates to the introduction to world religions curriculum.

by faradhi

I believe in the separation of state from church.

Leave your political beliefs at the door of the chapel. When I go to church, I go to learn about Job, Jesus, or other biblical stories. I do not want to discuss Supreme Court rulings, bills in congress, the death penalty, or abortion.

You cannot avoid Christian ideals from affecting the government since the overwhelming numbers of those in government are Christian. But many churches have gone as far as to advocate during services a political party. It is not just republicans. This IMHO is going too far.

I am intelligent enough to make the connection between the scripture and modern issues. Most people are. However, there are those issues that have scriptures that support both sides. Then an individual must make up their own mind and not have it made for them by the clergy.

There have been many atrocities made buy all religions in the name of religion. This is usually when the church has gotten involved in government. The Crusades, Middle East politics in general and Spanish inquisition are examples.

So when it comes to State issues, keep them out of my church.

by old guy

I think that is kind of hard to do (except in America). As a Christian, my life centers around my belief and faith in God (and as a Christian, in Jesus Christ)not the other way around. I know that a lot of Americans compartmentalize their lives with their spiritual (or religious) compartment not really interacting with the other compartments in their life. As a Christian, yes, the government does affect my beliefs and yes, I do need to be involved in government.

As an aside, I believe that the churches keeping quiet all this time is the primary reason that we have allowed the vocal miniority to bash Christianity. Now, that we have gotten involved in how things are run in this country those that want to quell us are attacking us at a greater rate. We have raised our ugly head against those that want to oppress Christianity and they can't stand it. Yes, we are more vocal and more involved in legislature because it affects our way of life.

It is not just the fact that the words Merry Christmas are noticeably absent that have us riled up. It is not the fact that if those words are not uttered that we believe our way of life will cease to exist. It is the cumulation of a lot of things that is in process here.

Yes, whether someone wants to acknowledge the fact that a small minority of people who wants to try to tear Christianity out of America or not, it is happening. Only those who just want to hear themselves rattle or who just wants to instigate trouble are the ones who can't recognize or acknowledge what is going on.

One can try to justify anything they want to by using a lot of words as smoke screens but the reality is still there whether someone accepts it or not.

by dmambo

Sorry, I'm just a little stressed out by the "joy" of the season. :)

You're right about the world needing all the positive energy and blessings it can get. If someone from another culture gives me a greeting filled with wishes for good health for me and my family based on their religion, I'll take it gladly. It sucks that a message filled with hopes for peace gets slapped down only because it's based on the religion of the majority.

Even when John Lennon sang Imagine there's no religion, I liked the point of his message - that there should be less violence in the world.

I seems patently ridiculous that in the name of poitical correctness, we give equal time to the celebeation of Kwanzaa. I don't mean to demean it, but it was invented in 1966 or something, and does anyone you know really celebrate it? Jews didn't really celebrate Chanukkah in a mega-commercial sense until mass media made Christmas the mess that it has become. When my Jewish next door neighbor wishes me Happy Chanukkah, I'm truly grateful. I know he wants me and my family to be happy.

Well, I have to go elbow some dick at Walmart just to brighten my holiday gloominess.

Wow - This turned into a rambling pointless discourse, didn't it?

by jdclyde

not rambling, nor pointless.

Very good points, very good ideas.

Oh yeah, even as full of the holiday spirit as I am, I like elbowing dickhead in walmart too! :\

by jdclyde

Mambo gets a lisence to thrill and say as he wants, yet I get censored just for saying the SAME word with "head" added on?

Now I am offended! :D

Does that mean TR is ENCOURAGING the corruption of the innocent one? :^O

by janth45873

To complain that because someone does not wish you a "Merry Christmas" is akin to taking Christ out of the holiday is both asinine and uninformed. Its no wonder that people think that Christians are a non thinking group of individuals. When someone says "Happy Holidays" what are they actually saying? Has anyone done the leg work does anyone know the etymology of the word "holiday" has anyone bothered? Most certainly not, or if they have, they are hoping that most have not and will be offended and thereby making an issue out of a non issue. "Holiday" is a shortening of the word, Holy day, as a result anyone saying Happy Holidays, is wishing the recipient of the greeting to be wished peace and happiness during this Holy season. As a result of this how can one naming the name of Jesus Christ be offended? They cannot be it is a non issue. We were instructed by the apostles of old to not give into vain discussions that lead to no where, it would seem that the church has ignored this advice and rather has been taken over by men who seek to control it by using foolish arguments which take away from its primary mission. But hey, if getting into vain arguments is your thing go right ahead. Somehow I think the Jerrys and the Pats are off somewhere laughing thier tails off at the foolishness they can get the church worked up over.

by tonythetiger

He said you didn't have the right to NOT be offended, so you can rest easy :)

Hmmm. I suppose that you can be offended or not offended as you choose. I guess jd should have said:

"You do not have the right to be shielded from an attempt to offend you."

by maxwell edison

.
....in case you didn't know, my message was intended to be a joke.

I'm offended that you didn't realize that.

And if you did realize that, I'm offended that you didn't acknowledge it.

by tink!

What a world we live in today, full of hypocrites and bitter souls that have nothing better to do than gripe about hype, or fight for nonsense.

I agree that people should not take offense when wished Merry Christmas or Happy Hanukah or what not. These greetings are meant to pass on the joy of the season, nothing more.

People read way too far into things these days. And often not for the better.

Merry Christmas!

by jdclyde

That there are still people out there that can accept a greeting and blessing of goodwill still.

I ask the question for the people that will ask what the big deal is, if it is no big deal, quit attacking and leave things be if it isn't a big deal.

And yes, it WILL be a Merry Christmas.

by old guy

JD, thanks for putting it so adamantly. This whole pc thing has gotten way out of hand. The people who "get offended" by Chistmas are just a bunch of greedy, selfish, hateful, inciteful, people (and I use that term loosely) who are mainly out for their 15 minutes of fame and just want to see how many people they can tick off.

It's almost like it's ok to be anything you want to be except a Christian. Part of this may be our fault for sitting back and not saying anything for too long. They are awakening another sleeping giant. I for one, though I won't push it down anyone's throat, will not hide nor temper my faith and beliefs for anyone else. I will say Merry Christmas and I appreciate other's spiritual beliefs when it too wishes peace and happiness for the world.

Merry Christmas and may God bless us all!

by jdclyde

people standing up saying enough is enough.

I will continue to say Merry Christmas to everyone. If I KNOW someone is Jewish, I will add in Happy Chanukkah as well. But I don't take the Christmas away.

But yes, the party that promote tolerance does it for everything BUT Christianity. It is "fashionable" to be a Christian basher it seems. Try that with a minority, woman, gays and you are some kind of monster (and you are) but the rules change when it comes to Christianity somehow.

Glad you liked the post OldGuy. Been mulling it over for a few days now on how to word it.

I do expect more of the bashers to come around in a few days though. That and much more about the myth of Separation of Church and State drivel will come out of the wood work.

by cactus pete

I don't recall anyone being offended by having Merry Christmas being thrust at them from every marketing angle there is... I haven't heard it.

But I have heard people being pleasantly pleased (tm) when their own holiday of choice was noted to them, rather than just the normal Merry Christmas.

By the way, who's offended by Happy Holidays?

I remember once wishing a Merry Christmas (or some other holiday) to a new coworker who I knew to be from the Middle East. I caught myself and said, "Oh, do you celebrate that one?" To which he replied, "Yes... I'm Christian, just like you."

I smiled, waved, and walked out without mentioning to him that I'm not a Christian.

I wasn't offended, but I did smirk to myself. Funny world.

by jdclyde

the people that are insisting on "happy holiday" instead of Merry Christmas.

The people that are calling Christmas trees "Holiday trees".

The people that fight tooth and nail to remove nativity settings.

The people that insist on calling it the "winter break" instead of Christmas Break.

The people that complain that federal money might go directly to a homeless shelter run by a religions organization instead of going through the government channels that get very little of that money to the people it is meant to help.

The people that will try to tell you our constitution prohibits all of this because of "Separation of Church and State", showing how uninformed they are and how blindly they have fallen lockstep in with the Anti-Christians.

Do you have to be a Christian to believe in the Christmas spirit of good will to man and peace on earth? I don't think so.

I have been hearing it, and hearing it a lot.

Merry Christmas dpetrak.

by cactus pete

I've been hearing ABOUT it a lot. But I haven't heard it myself. So I'm left here thinking, What's all this fuss about?

I see no groups demanding that stores say Happy Holidays instead of Merry Christmas. And if the stores chose that, so what? I've never been offended either way.

I see no evidence that anyone calling a Christmas Tree a Holiday Tree were offended by the old ways. I do see them trying to be more inclusive...

I've never heard of anyone fighting tooth and nail to remove nativity scenes.

You'd think that I'd hear something, living in Chicago... It's not like I live in a bubble.

by jdclyde

A member for two years, and it took this discussion to pull you in?

What kept you out so long?

I didn't post anything the first few years I was a member either. :D

by daytonajim

This particular discussion really hit a nerve. I was tired of feeling like the Lone Ranger when I wasn't talking to someone I know from church. All the anti-Christmas crap had been getting me down.

I hope you have a FANTASTIC, Merry Chris5tmas!!

by jdclyde

and I am hopeful. Life has been a lot of ups and downs, but it seems to be on a definate up swing now and I have custody of my boys the week leading up to Christmas.

And just remember, even though many don't want to speak up and bring unpopular attention on themselves, there are MANY that feel exactly the way we do. The good thing is, more and more are saying NOW is the time to stand up and say no more stripping away who and what we are just to please others.

Merry Christmas.

by mjd420nova

That right not to be offended is based on my
SECOND RIGHT to bear arms and then I don't think you want to piss me off.

by jdclyde

that sometimes it is very unwise to offend intentionally or other wise!

And your arguement doesn't stop people from offending you, although I doubt their would be a repeat performance? :\

Merry Christmas, if it is alright with you that is! :p

by old guy

I really want to thank all of you for your comments on this discussion. I think, for the most part, we are all in agreement, even though some may not be of a Christian background you are still supporting all the differences and seeing through the facade. I think someone here stated that they felt alone in this and it is encouraging to realize that there are a lot of us who feel the same way and are not afraid to put it to voice (or in this instance, text).

JD, again I really thank you for starting this thread and for all the other comments I have been keeping up with from you.

by road-dog

As a culture we have allowed the angriest and most extreme among us to define what is "offensive". It used to be that when you opened a door for a lady, you were exhibiting some amount of deference and class. The uber angry, non armpit shaving, bra burning, psycho feminists destroyed a small part of our social graces with this ridiculous notion that a man opening a door somehow was an assertion that she couldn't do it for herself. In other words, they chose to superimpose their values over yours and take offense.

Now we have gotten to the point where we cannot extend warm greetings to someone for fear you will not hit upon the particular celebration that suits their liking.

This acts to the detriment of us all.

Me, I think we should just say "happy" whatever WE celebrate as a greeting. If they choose to take offense, that is their issue. After all, we don't go around with badges denoting our faith. If the recipient cannot say "I'm not of that belief, but thanks for the sentiment", then maybe they have the problem and not us.

Just as opening doors is more of a statement about ourselves than those we open the door for, (after all, are you SURE she's a lady?) then perhaps our greetings should be the same way.

I'm a Christian, but I treasure the Spider-man T-shirt my friend's son gave me for a Hannukah present last year; not because he got my faith right, but because of the sentiment with which it was given.

Maybe we just need to greet people in our own way and let them take offense if they so choose. At any rate, this fear of offense will eventually balkanize us to the point where we are unable to celebrate what unites us because of the racket created by those who want to divide us.

That is the crux of the issue, offense is taken not given.

by old guy

and amen! That is the best and most succint statement I have heard in a long time--without it being derogatory. Very good and very well spoken!!!

Especially: "If the recipient cannot say "I'm not of that belief, but thanks for the sentiment", then maybe they have the problem and not us."

by jdclyde

thats my wife! (ex wife that is!) Sorry, I know. VERY old joke, but it just seemed to fit.

But yes Road-dog, that is a very valid point. Look at secular France, and they are more racist than we are!
(someones worst than us! someones worst than us!)
Maybe if they hadn't done everything to chase all religions out, the people would not be in such sad states? When they take it to the extreme of not allowing anyone to even WEAR something that is concidered a religions icon, you know they have gotten out of control.

Thank goodness out constitution protects US from the loud and angry, provided we stand up for ourselves.

by old guy

Could you explain a little more about what you were saying about France. I'm not sure I've heard much about that.

by richn

I dont remember the whole thing but it goes something like this
I said nothing when the crazy old man across town was taken... after all nobody talked to him
i said nothing when they took the family from down
the street after all i was scared and i didnt want to stand out.
when they came for me there was nobody left to say
anything.
I beleive this was part of a story of jewish deportation alluding to the gradual erosion of rights and freedoms. these are the same things
happening around us every day gradual erosion of rights and freedom

by road-dog

You need another reason to hate the French????

My God, man.....They're French!

but Merry Christmas to them anyway....;)

by jdclyde

the ten commandments HAVING to be removed from court rooms or other places where they were on display?

Please tell me you have heard about this?

You have never heard of a city that has had problems because they have a nativity scene?

Don't you watch the new? Never read a paper?

by old guy

How about the courts keep trying to take God out of the Pledge of Allegiance? Target, Walmart, and Home Depot are just three that have made it a point to take Christmas out of their adds and store window. They received enough emails from us that they are recanting and are now, all of a sudden, including Merry Christmas with their Holiday ads.

by jdclyde

that more people are out CHRISTMAS shopping, than HOLIDAY shopping.

I would not be offended at all if they had a MLK jr shopping day to honor him. Or SincoDeMio (sp?) or any other celebration people would like to have. Just call it what it is.

by old guy

That's true. Too many of us have stood by for too long and said nothing. Welllll, look out now, anti-Christian rights, there's an awful lot of us speaking up here. And, there's an awful lot of teens speaking up too. The group of teens I work with are getting more vocal about this and I know there are other groups just like the one I work with.

by jeasterlingtech9

First they came for the Communists,
and I didn?t speak up,
because I wasn?t a Communist.
Then they came for the Jews,
and I didn?t speak up,
because I wasn?t a Jew.
Then they came for the Catholics,
and I didn?t speak up,
because I was a Protestant.
Then they came for me,
and by that time there was no one
left to speak up for me.

by Rev. Martin Niemoller, 1945

by Member 25348569

Well, I could be if I wanted.

Christians have no right to claim Christmas as their own as they nicked it from the Roman Festival of Mithras which, anyway, was syncretically adopted from the pagan Turn of the Year celebration that every culture has (except Muslims whose "year" is too short). Just because you're in the majority doesn't make you right.

So, on Mithras Day I will be celebrating with a traditional Mithras ham washed down with copious draughts of wine and throw in a few pagan touches such as a Yule Log. Who knows? I might get a snog under my Druidic mistletoe.

I won't be having the Christian Christmas Tree but will go back to the original pagan ritual of hanging animals and a few enemies from the branches of the Sacred Tree if I can do it without being caught. Some of those ba5tard 8th Floor users are in line as I have to add yet more diskspace to their storage area...

I'm posting this because I have a [b]huge[/b] hangover after our Team Christmas Lunch (which ended at 10:30pm) and I'm blaming you bloody Christians! :(

Now bugger off and keep the noise of those damn carols down.

by jdclyde

Hangovers are a big part of the SECULAR celebration after all!

We claim the RIGHT to claim anything we want, anytime we want, anywhere we want! So there! :p

Mithras day? Is the like mothers day, just MOTHRAS mother instead of the general population? ;\

Oh, I have a few people to send for your tree. They don't fit on mine!

Merry Mithras Day my friend! Or is it "Happy"? or is it "Druidic"? (sigh, I tried!)
And a Merry Christmas as well!

Buggering off now.....

by Member 25348569

Had to go Googling that one. Godzilla never was that big over here so the reference shot over my head...

Which hurts...

I don't know what the Romans did but I'll accept a "Merry Mithras" from you. :D

by jdclyde

Wow, how did you miss all that?

Here are a few discussions the were pretty good in going over what was happening, and Neilb does a LOT of "filling in the blanks" for us, living over in the UK.

What is going on in Paris? by Garion11
http://tinyurl.com/apxce

What should the UK do next? by neilb
http://tinyurl.com/awa36

Both are fairly long so I would recommend going into print mode so you can read one after another without having to deal with that infernal "next" button and then the load times to completely reload the pages. Both are well worth reading from beginning to end.

by maxwell edison

.
Good question. My guess is that about .01 percent of the population (or less) "might" have some problem with it, one way or the other. And I know for sure that media outlets create the issue just to make a news story and/or to advance their own silly agenda. Kinda' like the polls they decide to take (and phrase how they want) just so they can report on the results.

I've heard about it on the news, but I've never met a person in my entire life who had any real issues, one way or the other.

Much ado about nothing, if you ask me. (The power of the press indeed!)

by road-dog

The PC crowd has been able to run roughshod over the sensibilities of the vast majority for some time. The difference this year is that the vast majority has finally had enough and is making it's presence felt in ways that have not been tried previously. It takes a lot to move the majority to action because their feelings on the issue are not so strong as to prompt action on a large scale until some 'critical mass' is reached.

The pendulum swung a long way in one direction and is now swinging back under pressure from a majority that has finally been pushed to the point of action.

http://tinyurl.com/e3vfu

I think it is just a case of the retail industry taking the path of least resistance. They were able to appease the "easily offended" by removing the "C" word for a long time. This voiciferous minority was the loudest opinion on the matter for some time. Now the majority has been stirred to action and they are responding by moving back in the other direction.

**** DISCLAIMER ****

By majority, I mean those who are NOT offended by the word Christmas, not core practicing Christians. I'm dividing along the 'offended by Christmas / not offended by Christmas' line, not Christians vs non-Christians line. I'm not implying a Christian majority as a whole in the US, but as being a larger voice at this time as relates to this particular issue.

by jdclyde

The pressure has been building for a long time, but without focus or aim.

It took a few to get the ball rolling, and droves of people were more than happy to jump on the bandwagon and go for a ride.

Now that the ball is rolling (or the pendulum swing if you prefer) things are going to start going in the opposite direction.

More people will see that it is perfectly acceptable for them to have their beliefs and not have to hide anymore.

Sure, we will start hearing the shrill screams from the hateful on the left about the "evangelical right". Next time they say it, listen to HOW they say it. It is always said as a BAD thing.

Pay attention to the words they CHOOSE to use when discussion religious people, and it is almost never in a good light in the media. Why is that?

And why do you have to be a religious nutcast to wish someone a Merry Christmas?

by road-dog

And I demand satisfaction. Your mention of several other holidays in addition to mine has placed them as equal to my own. They are not equal and clearly your inclusiveness was intended as a specific insult to my delicate sensibilities. My particular belief system is the only one that is correct for this season and all others are an insult to mine by your callous inclusion! An apology is clearly in order and I demand forthwith that you post this apology publicly and provide photographic evidence of your celebration being exactly as my own!

Therefore, please post a picture of your Christmas tree and photos of you decking a fellow shopper at a Wal-mart near you to secure posession of the latest X-box. Nothing less will be satisfactory. (BTW, please send me the X-box as fair compensation for damages)

by Member 25348569

The Christian Church's blatant theft of the Celtic Midwinter Festival and their rebranding of same as "Christmas" neans that all of the X-boxes are [b]mine[/b]. Send them to my mailing address c/o Neo-Pagan HQ, Stonehenge, Dorset, UK marked "Yule Prezzy".

As for decking a Wal-Mart shopper, they own Asda over here. I like the sound of your quaint American custom so I'll try it at Asda tomorrow and get back to you.

by faradhi

That you are in need of satisfaction. I would suggest your spouse, significant other, or person of convenience for that.

You take my comments to personally. I did not mean to offend your religious sensibilities. I intended to offend all sensibilities.

Therefore if I mentioned your holiday and you were not offended, please let me know. State your preferred holiday and I will offend you at my earliest possible convenience.

by old guy

...are seriously unbalanced, or crackers for you UK blokes! Did your mommas drop you on your head when you were born??? :) :)

by old guy

...are seriously unbalanced, or crackers for you UK blokes! Did your mommas drop you on your head when you were born??? :) :)

by road-dog

Apparently, I didn't make myself as clear as I might have. My faith and mine alone has any claim to this holiday. Any other historic claims are null and void. Henceforth and herewith I demand that you cease and desist any and all measures to co-opt this day for any other purposes than those implicitly endorsed by myself in perpetuity.

Please feel free to clothesline a fellow shopper tomorrow though, nothing demonstrates the good will of the season more than swift and blinding violence! To truly show Christmas spirit one need only level a few people to display greater love for the season. After all, the goal is bigger, better, faster, more.

Enjoy!

by sleepin'dawg

When they mention the cold winds coming from Canada understand we will be doing our level best to include a foot or two of snow, sleet and ice with that. Don't want you to miss having a white Christmas now, do we??? Trust us; a foot or two of snow will level all those wussy Floridians, and would drive up the value of the options on orange juice futures.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by road-dog

Then we can save a step! We'll have frozen concentrated OJ right on the tree!

Personally, I haven't laid eyes on snow since 1986. I doubt I'll like it, but I've seen frost on the ground at sunrise and been outside in a T shirt at lunchtime. If you don't like the weather in Florida, wait a few minutes, it'll change!

I laugh at your puny efforts to demoralize me! I've got the jumbo pack of teryaki beef jerkey from Wal-Mart and 2 Pounds of coffee. I can hold out for weeks! MUAHAHAHAHA!

by road-dog

Now, that game close to crushing my mood! 28-0. Wow..... If you have any "wrath of God" type weather, send it to Tampa. They deserve to have their stadium taken away for the Saints to use for the rest of the season! Barring that, fill Raymond James Stadium even with the nosebleed seats with snow. Hell, they can't find the damn endzone anyway!

by old guy

I wrote the post and hit submit. It said the page couldn't be found or something. I hit the back button and clicked Submit and then it posted twice. I think it goes back to still having trouble on TR web site.

by jeasterlingtech9

The winter solstice falls around December 25 and the Romans celebrated with a bacchanalian that consisted of drinking far too much, eating far too much and having an orgy. While the non Christian Romans were doing this, the Christians (who didn't really hold to the whole drunken orgy thing) decided that since no one really knew for sure what Jesus? birthday was, and the Christians didn't want to stand out by not at least feasting and partying a little, decided that the rebirth celebration was as good as any. this also gave converts and missionaries a little common celebrations

by tony hopkinson

work's xmas party was renamed to the annual party, for fear of offending any of my islamic colleagues. The one's I've talked to were very offended by the idea that someone thought they would be very offended by an invite to the knees up. PC gone mad. I don't think of xmas as a religious festival anyway, it's crap tv, an excuse for rampant commercialism and big smiles on many children's faces. The latter makes all the other stuff tolerable, even better would a small smile on every child's face every day of every year.

So yuletide greetings and new year felicitations to one and all, thank whoever you choose for what you have and don't beg anyone for more than you need.

by absolutely

It looks to me like the fast food industry caters to people who are uglier and fatter than normal. Those of us who want to be healthy have to search much harder for nutritious sustenance than fatties who will eat anything as long as it has high cholesterol content.

"In the US, we have adopted the policy of the "Pursuit of happYness". This does not give you the RIGHT TO HAPPYNESS. It gives you only the right to do what you can to achieve happyness."

by road-dog

As demonstrated, someone can provide you with precedent, definition, backing documentation, and anecdotal exidence, and you choose to ignore it and reiterate your own opinion ad nauseum as if contrary opinion and fact are nonexistent.

Quite simply, why provide documentation to someone who doesn't care to listen? Perhaps you like to hear yourself blather on and on, but it gets tiresome for those with cogent and reasoned opinions that are borne out by considerable amounts of reinforcing data.

I'm not afraid to question my own inerpretations of the world around me, to reevaluate my worldview in light of more complete understanding.

You on the other hand, cling to your own flawed notions as if they were a life raft. No amount of contrary information will convince you otherwise, as you selectively ignore anything that might persuade you otherwise.

Your definition of double jeopardy is right; and legal scholars, case law, best practices, and accepted legal definition are dismissed by you in order to protect your opinion.

Frankly, why give you any documentation at all? Better to engage in a reasoned discussion of abstract concepts with a wall. At least the wall will keep the wind off you at the end of the day. It won't be any more educated, but still be of use...

by absolutely

provide supporting [b]facts[/b] to support their conclusions. The decision of a court is only factual in the sense that it is documented and legally enforceable, but in an abstract conversation about ethics, that ruling is nothing more than an opinion shared by a few people who happen to be appointed to interpret the law. That appointment means that I may be bound to obey, but I also have the legal right to describe why they are wrong. I exercised my right to dissent from the court's opinion, and I have not contradicted or ignored reality. I haven't ignore the fact that a court ruled as you cited, I've said that they are wrong.

Legal jargon aside, the simple facts are that if a 5-year term for crime B is increased to 7-years because of the existence of a previous crime A, whose term was already fully served, is nothing less than a second punishment for crime A.

by jeasterlingtech9

Many schools have mandatory classes on Islam (try that with Judaism or Christianity)
The class in California was "the 5 pillars of Islam" what would they do if asked for a class in "what Jesus taught"
Harry potter is welcome in schools (a gateway into witchcraft, spell casting, and potions), Narnia is not (recent Florida case)
Earth day and radical environmentalism sure my kids had all sorts of lessons in this including vegetarianism and how horrible the government was for not signing the Kyoto accords
Try a google search
and look at it this way 1 atheist got prayer out of school over the rights of the hundreds of thousands who would have kept it one guy wanted "under god" out of the pledge "Christmas" is winter holiday and if some child dare mention god in a paper they are libel to be told to rewrite or get a failing grade or a graduation address they may not get their diploma
by the by evolution is a major tenant of atheism you can?t believe in a creator God if you believe in accidental evolution you don?t have to say atheism is right if you block all other paths

proof is obvious

by barghesthowl

- Many schools have mandatory classes on Islam (try that with Judaism or Christianity)
The class in California was "the 5 pillars of Islam" what would they do if asked for a class in "what Jesus taught"-

I took a comparative religion class in school, and it included an overview of ALL major world religion's histories and beliefs. That certainly included Christianity. They're still very widely offered. The only rule is, the teacher may only teach the religion in terms of "Christians believe", "Hindus believe", etc.

As to your "mandatory class on Islam", sure would like to see a link to that one, I can't imagine it -didn't- make the news. Comparative religion classes always are and should be an elective, and if a school's forcing students to attend a class exclusively on Islam, they're as far out of bounds as they would be with Christianity. But let's see some backup on that one.

-Harry potter is welcome in schools (a gateway into witchcraft, spell casting, and potions), Narnia is not (recent Florida case)-

My daughter, after being fascinated with the Narnia movie, checked out the book from her elementary school library. She's reading it now as a matter of fact. Harry Potter's there too. (Oh, by the way, both are works of FICTION, not "gateways" to anything.)

-Earth day and radical environmentalism sure my kids had all sorts of lessons in this including vegetarianism and how horrible the government was for not signing the Kyoto accords-

For Earth Day at my daughter's school, they went and picked up trash around the school grounds, learned about various types of pollution and what causes them, and how to reduce waste and consumption in their everyday lives. Terrible, radical stuff.

-and look at it this way 1 atheist got prayer out of school over the rights of the hundreds of thousands who would have kept it one guy wanted "under god" out of the pledge-

That's not preferential treatment, that's known as "the court upholding the law". It's kind of their job.

-"Christmas" is winter holiday and if some child dare mention god in a paper they are libel to be told to rewrite or get a failing grade or a graduation address they may not get their diploma-

To the first part-who the hell cares? It's in winter. Seems like a fine name to me. I've actually generally seen them referring to "winter holidays", and while you may not know this, there are a lot more winter holidays then Christmas. Really!

However, most of the decorations from the kids say "Merry Christmas". Some say "Happy Hanukkah", others something else entirely. That's fine-the kids SHOULD be allowed to express themselves. But the school itself stays neutral. Exactly as it should be.

As to the "God in a paper" bit? Some teachers are hostile to various types of content in a paper, if they disagree with them. That happens on far more subjects then religion. That's the teacher being an ass, not any kind of official policy.

-by the by evolution is a major tenant of atheism you can?t believe in a creator God if you believe in accidental evolution you don?t have to say atheism is right if you block all other paths-

The "major tenet" of atheism is that no God exists. Even intelligent design acknowledges evolution, it simply states that it was "made to happen" by some sort of all-powerful being.

Here's the problem. Intelligent design is not science. That's why it doesn't get taught in a SCIENCE class. That's not anyone's "opinion"-by the definition of a scientific theory, it isn't one. Science class is to teach science, not to misinform about what it is. We don't teach kids in English that Chaucer wrote A Midsummer Night's Dream, we don't teach them that the Battle of Gettysburg took place in France, and we don't teach them that "cat" is spelled with 2 t's. Why? Because those things are provably, factually incorrect.

That is not to say that ID -itself- is provably wrong. But the idea that it is a scientific theory is. So keep it out of science class.

So, given that most of what you're posting doesn't really happen or isn't school policy, I can only come to the conclusion you are not posting from this planet. I didn't realize they'd extended net access that far!

But in all seriousness. Do you -HAVE- a kid in school, do you observe this firsthand? Or is that just what you heard on Fox News? Because guess what-it isn't really like that.

by tonythetiger

"But in all seriousness. Do you -HAVE- a kid in school, do you observe this firsthand? Or is that just what you heard on Fox News? Because guess what-it isn't really like that."

Can we asume the same about Columbine then? It's not really like that because we didn't observe it firsthand? How about the Holocaust? Gee, how can we trust anything the press says?

by tonythetiger

"Here's the problem. Intelligent design is not science. That's why it doesn't get taught in a SCIENCE class."

The only difference between science and religion is who makes up the rules. Therefore rightfully, neither should be taught in school. Belief is belief, and nonbelief is belief too.

by barghesthowl

None of them receive preferential treatment. That's why the perception is there-when the Christians are told they must abide the same rules as anyone else, they scream bloody murder.

It would never be allowable to post the Wiccan Creed, a passage of the Satanic Bible, or a "Praise Allah" plaque in a courthouse. I've heard very few oppose this regulation. But tell 'em "Oh, and by the way, that means no Bible passages either" and they're screaming all over the place.

Christian parents would not be happy if the Pledge of Allegiance contained the words "under Satan". Their being upset would be understandable, it holds no place there. But tell 'em "Well, that means no Under God, either", and you're trying to tear down America.

It's all perception. There IS no discrimination, or if it is, it's against those OUTSIDE the religious mainstream. But we'll continue hearing about the poor persecuted majority regardless.

by jdclyde

"None of them receive preferential treatment".

Then there are attacks against one group, while support for others, there is preferential treatment.

When is the last time an issue came up in the US, and they refered to a voting party as "fundamentalist muslums"? In Michigan, down by Detroit (Dearborn) there is one of the largest muslum communities in the Country and they have their concerns just like everyone else does. When people disagree with them, it doesn't get thrown as just a bunch of religious nuts, but that is EXACTLY what happens to the Christians.

And "GOD" is a generic term, kind of a "fill in the blank". It does not sanction a single god over others, and thus IS legal and DOES deserve to stay there. If the only god you worship is money or the stripper up the road, that is fine too. Just think of whatever floats your boat when you say "god".

Look at all the documents from the beginning of this country, right down to the state constitutions. All of them reference GOD, showing our founding fathers DID recognise we are a religious people and saw that not as a bad thing.

Go look up "unalienable rights" and see if you find any religious references.

"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men." by Thomas Jefferson.

Our founding fathers did not intend this to be a godless nation, and there is nothing in anything they put in the constitution that would turn the US into this godless nation you so desparetly want.

by nighthawk808

A merry Penguin season to you, Mr. Gates.

I'm sure it's been a really nice Christmas season for all of you standing in line for non-existent X-Box 360's for your kids. Especially those in sun-drenched winter states like Ohio, Minnesota, North Dakota, etc.

by scottincalgary

Is this not written on every coin and note issued by the FEDERAL Treasury department? Have we evolved so far that we have forgotten where we come from and that our society (state) was founded in religious (church) principles? Removing the christian moral values from the government is equivalent to removing the foundation from a building. I would definately not want to live in the building. As much as this may get me flamed... The GOD that is spoken of in Jewish, Muslim and Christian religions is all based on the same God of Creation that is respected and revered by these faiths. In its best, Christmas is a time to express our love for fellow men/women and to show others that we care and love them. Not through the presents that we give but through the presence that we give. God Bless to all and a Merry Christmas.

by barghesthowl

"In God we Trust" and "Under God" in the Pledge of Allegiance were added during the McCarthy hysteria.

by jdclyde

I have heard of the first three celebrations, but that fourth one has thrown me for a loop.

Where do they celebrate "Steve M"? ;\

by absolutely

The right to free speech does not include the right to an audience. I have every right to not listen to you, and to not hear you when I'm in my home, and I choose to exercise those rights. I also have the right to not subsidize the expression of your opinions, and nobody's [b]free[/b] speech right includes the privilege of billing the rest of the populace for a means of expressing our opinions.

When somebody says "Merry Christmas", good will may be implied in most cases, and good will does not offend anybody. What does offend me is the assumption that I hold with the xian faith. I do not. If the [b]primary[/b] purpose of the phrase were to wish peace and happiness for me and my family, the phrase would be "peace and happiness to you and your family!" And if that wish were sincere, it would be offered in other seasons as well as around winter solstice.

With the present shape of the world, sincerity is far more important than vapid greetings describing superstitions nobody believes, and most imitate because they don't care enough to learn why their faith is evil.

by jdclyde

My right to freedom of speech does not trump your right to not stand there and listen, or in this case come into a discussion and continue to read the postings. That was your free choice to decide to continue reading in here or to hide in your home.

And yes, free speech can and will be paid for by federal funds. Look at affirmative action. Not religious, but it's form of reverse-discriminiation is paid for by us. Insult to injury, now we have Sharpton calling anyone who opposes this reverse-discrimination a racist. Hmm, if I don't discriminate against white males I am a racist?

As for sincerity. Some mean it, some don't. With your agressive outlook on all religions, of course you will only see the bad around you because that is all you are looking for. Sounds like a sad way to spend the day, but again, that is your choice.

Until then, I do wish you and everyone in here, a VERY Merry Christmas. Peace and goodwill towards all men/women/children. Hopefully the Christmas season will not be too trying on you as you tolerate the rest of us.

by tonythetiger

When you say "within reason", you are opening up an unresolvable can of worms. Who determines what is reasonable?

It should be very simple: If a school allows a chess club to meet there after hours, it should allow a religious based club to meet there as well.

If a school has a bulletin-board that allows non-school related posts, it cannot disallow a religion based post.

If a school allows advertisers to post signs around their stadiums in exchange for donations, they cannot discriminate against any donor putting up any sign they want (as long as it doesn't break any other laws).

The courts have held repeatedly that communities can set standards, and many do: Whether or not to allow alcohol to be sold within their community, or what constitutes public obscenity, or more recently, whether or not to allow smoking in public. In these instances, outsiders can't come in and impose their different view on that community.

I look for some bright legal eagle to eventually make the connection.

by tonythetiger

sexual predator registration:

Has the guy paid his debt to society or not? If he has, he shouldn't be any more restricted than any other ex-criminal. If he hasn't, keep him in prison!

by eferris

With the way Christmas Has become so commercialized the true meaning has been lost. Christmas now means money and gifts nothing else! The offensive part is; the loss of the true meaning!!!

by jck

But in the same right that Christians have the right to worship and celebrate as they wish, they do not have the right to impose their religious observations upon establishment or individual.

The threatening of Christian organizations to boycott stores who did not change the name of the trees they were selling from "Holiday trees" to "Christmas trees" because it did not meet their requirements for celebrating their religious holiday is putting into the face of people with other/no religious affiliation through devisive coercion.

To be honest, I laugh at the whole thing because it's silly (being a Christian myself) to put so much effort into naming trees for 5 weeks of the year. I'd rather worry more about my family, friends, work, travel and observe Christmas for what it's about...not for what I want it to be.

I whole-heartedly hope that everyone who isn't a Christian boycotts those stores who gave into the demands of a secular movement.

And Merry Christmas...

by tonythetiger

When some people use the phrase, is is THEIR speech they want protected... they could give a rat's ass about yours.

I ma involved in an interesting little "free speech" quandry here at work. If involves signature lines in email. Some people put little quotes after their contact information. A couple of people put Ohio's motto "With God, all things are possible".

I had some humorous quotes on mine that changed on occasion: Examples:

"A day without sunshine is like... night!"
"What if the hokey-pokey really IS what it's all about?

Various little quotes that nobody said anything about for YEARS. Then, after I got involved with Fairtax.org I changed it to:

"(The following is my personal opinion, and is not intended to reflect the views of my employer.)
When you go home tonight, check out www.fairtax.org and keep more of the money you earned!"

Less than a week later, someone complained and I was told to remove it.

When I mentioned the Ohio motto quoted on others' email I was told that since we are a state agency that the motto was allowed. Since both of these people are the "shove religion down your throat" types I said that and that if the Ohio motto was "Mares eat oats and does eat oats and little lambs eat Ivy" that they wouldn't be posting it but to no avail. My boss then made a snide remark in email "Just curious, have you contacted anyone about the US dollar bill?" (he is one of the people with the quote. The funny thing is, he removed it as soon as I voiced my displeasure but a couple of months later he put it back, and the other employee said "I have free speech rights, and I'm NOT removing it", and never has).

I've located the text of the Ohio Constitution and am adding it to the signature line of all my internal emails (all quarter meg of it) :)