Discussion Locked

Your colleague will be fired & you know

0 helpful
16 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I heard that two of my fellow IT workers will be terminated soon. "They fell short of mgmt's expectations." I saw other people being interviewed for the positions and these new possible hires were introduced to us as temporary help (but I knew better). The thing is: what do I do? Shall I tell my friends and start something ugly? Or shall I keep it to myself and let it run its course? What would be the advantage to tell them, anyhow? But what about friendship and loyalty? It's a dilemma. In the meantime, we're all working hard on a new project and they are excited about it, but I can't tell them that they won't see this project to its conclusion. Any thoughts?

16 replies

by epepke

Been there; done that. Say nothing. If you tell your friends, and they do get fired, then they'll get angry at YOU. No, this doesn't make any sense, but people are monkeys who don't think much, especially when they get bad news.

by zale

Personally, I would start making plans to leave myself. A company that would misrepresent itself to its employees by having you train "temps" that will soon replace you is no place to stake your future. Then I would let my friends know that the temps are not temps and we all need to skedaddle. Hope this helps.

by admin-stuart

First, I'm a Net Admin, and manage no one but myself. Any IT worker deserves to receive feedback from and the chance to respond to performance evaluations, however, it's a sad reality today that too great a potential for mischief and vandalism to critical systems exists to always allow an IT worker to have advance knowledge of a dismissal. Management there may have been burned badly in the past.

by bertustech

Thanks to all of you who responded so far. I think there is a history of mischief, prior to an announced dismissal (or maybe it's just rumours to justify a certain conduct by management), the truth I'll never know. It is unnerving, though. I think I'll stay put and mum is the word. It's the best route to take, for now.

by trademan

What if it were you in that situation? I would want the truth straight in my face and at the earliest possible time.

THE TRUTH WILL ALWAYS SET YOU FREE!

by ahevans

I agree with Admin-Stuart, friends are friends, but you must watch out for yourself 1st. They must be slacking otherwise it wouldn't come to this. Management has to be carefull, the 2 employees in their position can cause alot of problems if pushed that far, and guess who gets to rebuild the servers..YOU!!. Leave it alone, its not your problem. Also, if your name comes out in this as giving them the heads up, guess who's next....YOU !!!!!

by greggen

I don't know where you you get the idea that Management is somehow forced to treat the employees like crap. It is a choice. This is not effect and cause. Because some idiot manager thinks there will be trouble, the soon-to-be dismissed employees are to be let go without warning?
It 'came to this' because Management has no respect for its employees, not because they are 'slacking'...
If I knew, I would warn my friends, and get the hell out of there asap!

by bigbadwolf

Business is business!!! You are abviously being trusted with very critical information that if leaked to these individuals could cause you much work and headache as has been described by other members here. Our team operates as a whole but we eachhave our individual duties to perform to keep the team whole. Working side be side we may not see all that happens but management has a way of finding out the not so obvious to suit there terms. So we each tell one another on the job to CYA--- Cover Your Ass... if info has been given to you maybe you are the one being tested by management. I use a policy of what is heard never leaves my lips except to the person that told me in the begining and that is only if we are on the subject at their descretion. Rock the boat and you may fall off as well.

by rzan

Although as a friend, you may be tempted to spill the beans and let your friend know of his/her upcoming surprise termination, it is best to keep your mouth shut on this matter. What you can do is hint to your friend that there are many better jobsout there, and the opportunities are endless. Try to find a technical recuiter and have him/her contact your friend with an appealing offer. If your friend can't read between the lines behind what you are saying, then they are on their own. Personally, if I were you, I too would be looking to get out of that craphole of a company who must lie to its employees.

by langmyr

What I have noticed in a personal circumstance is that the the truth will not always set you free but sometimes also put you into a whole lot of shit that you don't need.
In that situation, no offence but I would rather be quiet because you never know when a good thing you did could become a bad thing that could give you alot of problems and headache.
I talk from experience.

by marshallkeithusa

Run don't walk to your next job. A company
like that can't expect loyalty from any
employee. Loyalty goes both ways. .
.Companies like that usually do it to keep
cost down. . .look at the turnover rate for
the entire company and you will probably see
a pattern. They are probably keeping you to
help train the Newbies but eventually they
will get around to you.

by bertustech

Thanks for the responses. Same story all around. It's a real stumper. Shall I say something, or not? Shall I warn them, or not? If I say something, then something else, even worse, may happen. If I don't, it hurts. But it'd hurt any way I turn. I like the suggestion about urging them to look around for better positions. In the meantime, I think I'll do the same (even though I love my job here). And I hope they'll never get around to me next...

by pmercer

Did you happen to overhear a private conversation? Or, was it a rumor passed on to you from someone close to where these decisions are made? Or, did someone who is a part of that decision making process take you into their confidence?

One thingto keep in mind is where the information comes from.

An approach may be to mention to the folks you work with that you heard they are planning on letting some folks go, without naming names . . . assuming you heard this info second hand.

However if it was told to you in confidence then passing that on may be detrimental to your career . . .

I have been in situations where I knew things that no one else knew, because the manager confided information to me. I did not like being in that position, but did not betray those confidences.

by epepke

Trouble is, when you try to walk a mile in another's shoes, they think you're stealing them.

by bertustech

The law of the jungle. Basically everyone out there thinks alike. To answer one of you guys: how did I find out? I'm good friends with the Implementation Asst. Mgr. He wouldn't lie (would he?).
Thanks!

by epepke

as to say "the law of the jungle." But there are only so many times that you can do a good turn for a friend and have him turn on you like an attack dog before you realize it isn't a very good idea.

This discussion is closed to new replies.